Mayor and State Reach Deal to Pave Way for Schools Chief

Cathleen P. BlackMs. Black

The state’s education commissioner, David M. Steiner, and the Bloomberg administration have reached a deal that will allow Cathleen P. Black, a media executive, to become the next schools chief.

Shael Polakow-SuranskyMr. Polakow-Suransky

A top education official in the city’s schools system, Shael Polakow-Suransky, the deputy chancellor for performance and accountability, will be named the chief academic officer to serve as the No. 2 to Ms. Black, according to a person with knowledge of the agreement between the state and the city.

In return, Dr. Steiner on Monday will grant Ms. Black a waiver from the state law requiring the chancellor to have certain education credentials that Ms. Black, the chairwoman of Hearst Magazines, lacks.

Dr. Steiner had expressed reservations about granting Ms. Black an exemption and had made the appointment of a chief academic officer a condition for considering her nomination.

The move is a major concession from Mayor Michael R. Bloomberg, who typically resists any intrusion into his management of city agencies.

The Bloomberg administration did not dispute the details of the agreement, but refused to comment.

But in a letter from Mr. Bloomberg to Mr. Steiner released by the city’s Education Department, the mayor said Ms. Black’s decision to make Polakow-Suransky her top deputy reflected her strong leadership skills.

Ms. Black, Mr. Bloomberg said, understands that a leader’s role is to “hire the best people, give them the room to innovate and hold them accountable for success.”

Ms. Black and Mr. Polakow-Suransky have had extensive conversations in recent days about management of the system and leadership approaches, people on both sides of the negotiations said.

The city, in its letter to the state, emphasized that Mr. Polakow-Suransky was Ms. Black’s selection, though the negotiations suggest the idea of installing him was reached more broadly.

It is clear from the city’s letter proposing the compromise that Mr. Polakow-Suransky will be given broad duties, including some that might be expected to fall to the chancellor.

They include “serving as educational leader of the school system,” and “communicating the educational vision and priorities effectively to staff, students, and community,” along with “developing, implementing, and monitoring the change process to improve the educational program,” according to the letter.

Not everyone applauded the deal. City Councilman Jumaane Williams said he had hoped the mayor would scrap Ms. Black’s nomination altogether.

“I understand the mayor is used to getting his way and will do anything to prevent egg on his face,” Mr. Williams said Friday evening. “Still this is about the 1.1 million kids, who are not just numberss to be managed. I was hoping that Commissioner Steiner would be brave enough to listen to the people.”

Mayor Bloomberg’s letter to Mr. Steiner.

Comments are no longer being accepted.

Ridiculous!!!

I thing we live in a crazy world. I am so disappointed. I was hoping for a completelly different person with a new perspective.

Major concession? Looks like the State caved in to the emperor of NYC.

I think we live in a crazy world. I am so disappointed. I was hoping for a completelly different person with a new perspective.

There is an old African proverb which is quite apropos here. “When elephants fight, the grass gets trampled.” In this instance, the children, i.e. the grass of the New York City public school system will be trampled. What a shame.

Does this mean we now have to pay for two of them–an unqualified fom (friend of Mike) and someone competent to actually do the work?

If she had a shred of honor she would withdraw. But these people are beyond shame.

Unacceptable.

Dictator agrees to compromise, a bit, with democracy.

Gee, thanks, Mike. Your trickle down is so ingratiating.

I don’t get it. Which one is the ventriloquist?

Dr Bob in the Bronx November 26, 2010 · 5:05 pm

The education assistant should have been from outside the NYC DOE system, not a title shift from within. This is little more than window dressing. Hizzoner The Billionnaire always gets what he wants. Dr. Steiner obviously ignored the committee that failed to approve Ms. Black.

So, who did Bloomberg buy off to obtain this concession? That’s the way the man does business, and surely how Cathleen Black will as well. Perhaps Bloomberg will next lobby for a 4th term.

Isn’t this an admission that Black is not the best, most qualified person for the job? I must admit, though, that I am relieved that Bloomberg didn’t name Rhee out of spite when he couldn’t get his way the first time.

What’s the Bloomberg long term view on public education?

Long story short– he wants to privatize it. To him privatized schools, will be cheaper,better and the unions and their pensions will fade away.

Cathleen Black, with her ability to raise corporate money, is the key to privatization. Her #2 is irrelevant.

What wrong with privatization/charterization? Neither one will cure the so-called “minoritypoverty student syndrome. As in the Harlem children’s Zone, the charter school par excellence that has attracted so much hedge fund and Goldman-Sachs funding, , much is promised, much money is delivered but little is changed.

The question comes down to who would you rather educate children? for profit corporations or union teachers.? (take a minute to consider)

This is a major concession by Bloomberg? He still gets his crony in the Department Of Education. King Bloomberg gives a token concession and his subjects are supposed to accept it. Meh!

Perley J. Thibodeau November 26, 2010 · 5:08 pm

Carl McCall got the same deal for his wife at Fashion Institute of Technology.
It’s not who you know but, who’ll do something for you that counts!

The Mayor’s lack of judgement in appointing Ms Black is compounded by naming a chief academic officer to serve as No.2. Who will be responsible for what? It’s unsettling to think
about the conflicts that will arise when when things go wrong.
And rise they must! Instead of clarity, the order of command will be muddled and the school system, which should be the major concern, trails last.

Shocking display of power misused.

And how much extra is that costing the taxpayers?

Mayor Gloomberg is a thug who does not deserve to serve a third term let alone appoint a novice to this post. Parents should rip him a new one. Maybe the Mayor should go back to school and learn about the voice of the voter? BUT Mike can do what he wants because he is the richest New Yorker – what a great lesson for the young.

As an academic I totally disagree with the appointment. The NYC is in desperate need of someone who can speak to assessment, evaluation and measurement not to management finance. In lieu of the drop in student scores across the city I believe her appointment will not do much in Student achievement nor managing many city employees who already out educate and have a broader experience in the field. I now wonder why have license requirements for teachers and administrators when the top person in the system is allowed to work without them. I believe we in NYC all DOE employees should request waivers when applying for jobs.

“Sometimes it takes an outsider to come into a field and see what is being missed, or taken for granted.”
//www.nytimes.com/2005/11/01/science/01prof.html?_r=1&pagewanted=all

So maybe Cathie Black can be such an outsider.

Note that the quoted comment concerned theoretical physics and a graduate of Stuyvesant. The problems of the NYC school system do not concern Stuyvesant students and physics.

Here’s hoping Ms. Black has enough vision, smarts and courage to figure out that her challenge concerns neither management nor academic standards and certainly not testing. There’s a more complex set of objectives involved. It requires grasping the vast gulf between the lives of most NYC students and the lives of the yuppies who occupy Mike Bloomberg’s City Hall, thinking they have all the answers and trying to tell the rest of the city what’s best for us. If Ms. Black gets enough support in her efforts to figure it all out, perhaps she will succeed in doing so and educate first of all the mayor.

In other words they just rolled over. There is no guidelines for what this Chief Academic Officer will do and how much he will truly be in charge of academic affairs. And as he reports to her, it’s clear who’s in charge.

Look, my youngest has a year and a half left in the schools. So this really won’t affect me too much. But it really angers me that after Bloomberg bullied the city council into giving himself a third term, he gets away with this nonsense.

I am very very disappointed with Steiner. This is a education maven, a classics major, of all things. Going along with this appointment is like letting Derek Jeter take over the Morgan Library, Hey he’s a great leader, but a little out of place, don’t you think?

If I see a USA Today in a public school, I will set fire to it.

So, the deal is done? The over-rated saleswoman, Cathie Black, will become the figurehead “schools chief,” while a “top education official” will run her errands. Well done, Dr. Steiner your integrity illumines the heavens like a brown dwarf star. Well, does it matter? The monied classes send their children to their bunker schools, while the City struggles with what will constitute a 21st Century education for the lower-middle and poor children.

Perhaps Ms. Black can persuade her friend Oprah to open a number of charter schools in East New York and other deserving neighborhoods.

Aww, fudge cookies. So who then will be the sock puppet? Probably both.

From the minute Dr. Steiner made his silly announcement regarding changing the state requirement to apply only to whomever is in the number two position, it was clear what was going on. But no one is fooled by this. The waiver is for Ms. Black, who remains patently unqualified. The huge concern regarding her utter lack of qualifications for this hugely important post still applies, all of the criticism of this absurd appointment still applies. Nothing has changed.

This is on you Dr. Steiner. The responsibility for this terrible decision is on now you.