Yesterday’s Gems, Today’s Insights
A Roundup of the Web’s Finest Blog Posts!
4-18-25
Texas: Republican Legislators Endorse Vouchers https://dianeravitch.net/2025/04/17/texas-republican-legislators-endorse-vouchers/ via @dianeravitch
Governor Greg Abbott of Texas successfully pushed through voucher legislation after years of resistance from a coalition of Democrats and rural Republicans. This legislation was backed by out-of-state billionaires and conservative figures, including Donald Trump. The move to establish taxpayer-funded school vouchers has been controversial, with critics arguing it will divert funds from public schools and primarily benefit those already attending private religious schools. The legislation, seen as a victory for private school choice advocates, faces criticism for being anti-democratic and potentially discriminatory, as voucher schools can exclude students based on various criteria.### Key Points
- Governor Abbott achieved voucher legislation after defeating rural Republicans who opposed it.
- Out-of-state billionaires and Trump supported Abbott's efforts to pass vouchers, bypassing public referenda which historically reject them.
- Voucher schools can choose their students and are not bound by anti-discrimination laws, often benefiting private religious schools.
- The Texas House voted to create a large taxpayer-funded voucher program, a significant win for private school choice advocates.
- Critics argue vouchers will strain public school budgets and primarily benefit wealthy families already using private schools.
IRS Considering Revoking Harvard's Tax-Exempt Status, New York Times Reports https://dianeravitch.net/2025/04/17/irs-considering-revoking-harvards-tax-exempt-status-new-york-times-reports/ via @dianeravitch
Harvard University is under threat from the Trump administration, which is considering revoking its tax-exempt status. This move comes after Harvard's President, Alan Garber, refused the administration's demands to control the university's curriculum, admissions, and hiring practices. Such interference is seen as a significant attack on academic freedom and university independence. The IRS, reportedly under pressure from the administration, is investigating Harvard, although any attempt to revoke its tax-exempt status would likely face legal challenges. Harvard argues that losing this status would severely impact its educational mission and financial aid programs. The situation highlights concerns about political influence over independent institutions.### Key Points
- Harvard is threatened with losing its tax-exempt status after refusing Trump administration demands.
- The IRS is reportedly investigating Harvard, a move seen as politically motivated.
- Harvard argues that losing tax-exempt status would harm its educational mission.
- Legal experts believe any attempt to revoke Harvard's status would face legal challenges.
- The situation is viewed as a significant attack on academic freedom and university independence.
Department of Homeland Security Demands Harvard Turn Over International Student Disciplinary Records https://dianeravitch.net/2025/04/17/department-of-homeland-security-demands-harvard-turn-over-international-student-disciplinary-records/ via @dianeravitch
The article discusses the conflict between Harvard University and the Trump administration, particularly focusing on demands made by the Department of Homeland Security (DHS) for disciplinary records of international students. Harvard has refused to comply, citing its independence and constitutional rights. The article criticizes the administration's approach as an overreach of governmental power and likens it to authoritarian control. It also touches on the broader implications of such government actions on academic freedom and democracy.### Key Points
- CNN reports that Kristi Noem sent a letter to Harvard demanding international students' disciplinary records or risk losing the ability to enroll them.
- Harvard stands firm against the government's demands, emphasizing its independence and constitutional rights.
- The article criticizes Trump’s administration for its authoritarian tendencies and interference in private institutions.
- The discussion includes comments on the importance of immigrants and the dangers of government overreach in education.
- The article draws parallels between Trump's actions and authoritarian regimes, highlighting concerns about democracy and freedom.
The Freedom Flip: When the Right Became the Left (But Not Really) https://cloakinginequity.com/2025/04/17/the-freedom-flip-when-the-right-became-the-left-but-not-really/
The article by Dr. Julian Vasquez Heilig discusses the shifting dynamics in American politics, particularly in the context of education and ideological narratives. It highlights how the political right has adopted rhetoric traditionally associated with the left, such as anti-discrimination, while simultaneously undermining true equity and freedom. The piece argues that this is a strategic move to control public education and reshape democratic discourse. Meanwhile, the left is reclaiming patriotism and democratic ideals to defend academic freedom and resist authoritarian influences.
### Key Points
- The political right claims to champion anti-discrimination while using it to suppress dissent and consolidate power.
- The left is now invoking the First Amendment and patriotism to protect academic freedom and democratic values.
- The right's tactics are seen as a strategic costume change rather than a true reversal of roles, aiming for control over public education.
- The article calls for building coalitions to protect public institutions and reclaim the language of liberty and equity.

The article discusses the ongoing hype surrounding artificial intelligence (AI) and emphasizes the importance of accountability and pushback against this trend. It highlights several instances where individuals and organizations have resisted the unchecked adoption of AI technologies, providing examples of critique and analysis from various sources. The article also touches on the role of regulatory bodies and alternative platforms like Bookshop.org in challenging the dominance of big tech companies.
### Key Points
- Emily M. Bender discusses the persistent AI hype amid political chaos and stresses the need for accountability.
- Denise Utochkin critiques the University of Copenhagen's rush into AI, questioning the reality it invites students to consider.
- Ann Leckie comments on the excitement around ChatGPT, offering a critical perspective.
- Cadbury provides insightful analysis of AI in an ad campaign.
- Researchers find that AI literacy inversely correlates with AI receptivity, suggesting that demystifying AI may reduce its appeal.
- Ada Ada Ada's performance art questions Instagram's nudity filter, highlighting the arbitrariness of AI algorithms.
- Lina Khan's FTC work exemplifies effective regulation of tech companies.
- Bookshop.org expands into ebooks, challenging Amazon's dominance and supporting local booksellers.

The article discusses the ongoing debate between traditional and progressive education methods, emphasizing that both types of schools can be considered "good" despite their differences. Traditional schools focus on order, authority, and academic standards, while progressive schools prioritize freedom, personal growth, and social development. Despite their differences, both share a common goal of promoting democratic values and civic participation. The article argues against the notion of a single "best" school system, suggesting that diverse approaches can coexist and fulfill the fundamental purpose of public education.
### Key Points
- The debate between traditional and progressive teaching methods has persisted for over a century, with both types of schools being considered "good."
- Traditional schools emphasize order, authority, academic standards, and regular assessments.
- Progressive schools focus on freedom, personal growth, multiage classrooms, and narrative assessments.
- Both schools aim to instill democratic values and civic participation, a core duty of public education.
- The article argues against the idea of a single "best" school system, advocating for diverse approaches.
The article discusses the Trump administration's lawsuit against Maine for allowing transgender athletes to compete in women's sports, challenging the state's adherence to its human rights law that protects transgender students. The Trump administration claims Maine's policies violate federal Title IX regulations, threatening to cut federal education funding. Maine has resisted compliance, leading to a legal battle. The administration's actions have raised questions about civil rights interpretations and the potential impact on educational funding for vulnerable communities.
### Key Points
- Trump administration sues Maine over transgender athletes in women's sports, claiming violation of federal law.
- Maine's human rights law protects transgender students, conflicting with Trump's executive order.
- Trump threatens to cut federal funding for Maine, including education and school meals programs.
- Legal experts question the administration's interpretation of Title IX and civil rights laws.
- Maine challenges the administration in court, winning preliminary rulings to restore some funding.
- The administration's approach to civil rights enforcement and investigation processes is criticized.
Trump's trade war with China, characterized by the "madman theory," is causing significant economic strain. His ban on Nvidia products to China has led to major financial losses for the company, impacting its growth and the global tech supply chain. The trade tensions have also resulted in China halting rare earth shipments to the U.S., further disrupting technological manufacturing. This strategy is risky, potentially leading to broader economic and geopolitical conflicts.
### Key Points
- Trump's trade war with China is based on the "madman theory," aiming to create economic chaos for political gain.
- The ban on Nvidia products to China has caused a $5.5 billion loss for the company and affected its stock.
- China has stopped shipping rare earth elements to the U.S., impacting the tech industry and supply chains.
- The trade war risks escalating into broader conflicts, with some Trump advisors pushing for aggressive actions.
The article discusses the controversial hiring of Fred Piccolo by Richard Corcoran at New College of Florida, despite Piccolo's history of inappropriate behavior and legal issues. It outlines a timeline of events leading to Piccolo's eventual termination after multiple arrests related to indecent exposure. The piece questions the decisions made by Corcoran and the lack of immediate action against Piccolo, highlighting the potential dangers of such behavior being overlooked.
### Key Points
- Fred Piccolo, known for his inappropriate behavior, was hired by Richard Corcoran as New College's director of marketing, despite a history of legal issues.
- Piccolo faced backlash for a controversial COVID-19 tweet in December 2020 and resigned shortly after.
- A lawsuit was filed against Piccolo in October 2022 for sending inappropriate messages, which was later dropped in April 2023.
- Piccolo continued to face legal troubles, including multiple arrests in 2024 for indecent exposure incidents at retail stores.
- Despite these issues, Piccolo was not immediately fired, raising questions about Corcoran's decision-making and the lack of transparency regarding Piccolo's arrests.
- Piccolo was finally removed from his position at New College in April 2025 after his fourth arrest.
The article discusses the rise of authoritarianism and fascism in the United States under the Trump administration, highlighting the erosion of democratic principles and the complicity of institutions such as universities. It emphasizes the need for organized resistance and collective action to combat these threats and preserve democracy.
### Key Points
- The rhetoric of erasure under Trump has become policy, targeting immigrants, dissidents, and institutions, branding dissent as terrorism.
- Trump's regime has normalized cruelty and exclusion, with language echoing racial purity ideologies reminiscent of fascism.
- Citizenship is weaponized, creating a brutal politics of disposability and enforced invisibility for marginalized groups.
- Education and media are repurposed to glorify war and normalize cruelty, contributing to social homelessness.
- Universities have capitulated to neoliberalism and political pressure, failing to defend academic freedom and human rights.
- Historical parallels are drawn with Nazi Germany, warning against the erosion of moral courage in educational institutions.
- The Trump administration's attacks on Palestine activists, immigrants, and universities are part of a broader fascist politics.
- Resistance is growing, with protests signaling opposition to authoritarian measures, but it requires sustained and organized action.
- The necessity of collective nonviolent direct action and solidarity among various groups to disrupt authoritarian rule is emphasized.
- The article calls for a revival of radical imagination and collective power to resist fascism and uphold democratic ideals.
Teacher Tom reflects on the importance of being comfortable alone with one's thoughts and reveries, drawing from his childhood experiences. He reminisces about spending time outdoors and engaging in imaginative play alone, which fostered his ability to enjoy solitude and creativity. He contrasts this with the current era dominated by screens and structured environments that may hinder children's ability to be alone with their thoughts. He suggests that learning this skill could be an antidote to loneliness. Teacher Tom also offers resources and insights from his years of experience advocating for play-based learning.
### Key Points
- Teacher Tom shares childhood experiences of outdoor play and solitary imaginative activities, emphasizing their role in developing comfort with solitude.
- Reflects on how modern distractions, particularly screens, prevent people from being alone with their thoughts, potentially contributing to loneliness.
- Discusses the importance of learning to embrace one's thoughts and reveries, suggesting it might help combat loneliness.
- Offers resources and insights from his extensive experience in play-based learning, encouraging support for his blog.
Episode #123: Big Data/ Predatory Data with Anita Say Chan
To be ruled is to be spied upon and inspected, quantified, measured, and ranked, and then registered and regulated with all the inherent structural violence packed into those arrangements. To be free is to abolish all of it, to reject that system’s hold over our minds as well as to defeat its power in the world. … Continue reading
RFK Jr. has made controversial statements about autism, suggesting it is a condition that needs curing and making inaccurate claims about the capabilities of those on the autism spectrum. The author, Fred Klonsky, a former teacher with decades of experience working with autistic students, strongly refutes these claims, emphasizing that autism is not a disease and criticizing Kennedy's views as eugenic.
### Key Points
- RFK Jr. claims autism is a condition that needs curing and makes derogatory statements about the abilities of autistic individuals.
- The author, with extensive experience teaching autistic students, argues against Kennedy's views, stating that autism is not a disease.
Jesse Hagopian has launched a new Substack newsletter, "Teach Truth & Sing the Blues," which combines his work on education justice with his creative pursuits. The newsletter addresses "truthcrime" laws that aim to suppress honest discussions about history and systemic racism. It also features Hagopian's creative work, such as poems, blues songs, and films, emphasizing healing and memory. He collaborates with The Blue Tide and is working on a personal documentary, "Where I Got My Name," exploring his family's history. The newsletter is a platform for those interested in education justice and the cultural impact of the blues.
### Key Points
- Jesse Hagopian launched a Substack newsletter, "Teach Truth & Sing the Blues," combining education justice with creative work.
- The newsletter addresses "truthcrime" laws and includes creative content like poems and blues songs.
- Hagopian collaborates with The Blue Tide and is working on a documentary about his family's history.
- The newsletter is for those interested in education justice and the cultural impact of the blues.
The article discusses the challenges of teaching middle school students, addressing the misconception that they are inherently lazy. It critiques the simplistic view of disengagement in teens and explores how their developmental changes impact learning. The author argues that students are not lazy but are making choices based on a cost-benefit analysis of their education. The piece suggests that teachers should help students evaluate the benefits of learning and make lessons genuinely relevant. It also highlights the importance of reducing the perceived cost of learning to prevent students from adopting a "Passenger Mode" mindset.
### Key Points
- Middle school students often lose interest in learning due to developmental changes, not laziness.
- Adolescents experience emotional and physical changes that affect their learning engagement.
- Students are not lazy; they make choices based on a cost-benefit analysis of learning.
- Teachers should guide students in understanding the benefits of learning and make lessons genuinely relevant.
- The educational system should avoid labeling students as lazy and instead focus on reducing the perceived cost of learning.
Grumpy Old Teacher's blog post discusses the recent developments in Florida regarding immigration enforcement on college campuses. The state has enacted laws requiring local law enforcement, including campus police, to assist with ICE efforts, which involves screening individuals for immigration status. This has led to agreements between universities and federal authorities, allowing campus police to act as ICE agents. The move has raised concerns among students about safety and racial profiling, as they feel targeted and unsafe on campus.
### Key Points
- Florida has enacted laws requiring local law enforcement, including campus police, to assist with ICE efforts by screening individuals for immigration status.
- Florida universities, such as Florida Atlantic University and the University of Florida, are entering agreements with federal authorities to deputize campus police for immigration enforcement.
- Students express concerns about feeling unsafe and targeted due to the new enforcement measures, fearing racial profiling and unwarranted detentions.
In the grand theater of American politics, Bernie Sanders and Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez (AOC) have emerged as a dynamic duo, leading a "Fighting Oligarchy Tour" across the United States. This tour is akin to a political rock concert, aiming to dismantle the oligarchy and restore power to the people. Their rallies attract massive crowds, even in conservative areas, highlighting their message of economic justice and corporate accountability. AOC is seen as a potential frontrunner for the 2028 Democratic presidential nomination, while Sanders continues to champion grassroots mobilization and collective action. Despite criticism, their tour seeks to ignite a movement transcending party lines, offering hope and action in a politically divided landscape.
### Key Points
- Bernie Sanders and AOC lead a "Fighting Oligarchy Tour" to challenge economic inequality and corporate power.
- Their rallies draw huge crowds, even in conservative areas, emphasizing a message of economic justice and grassroots mobilization.
- AOC is considered a potential 2028 Democratic presidential contender, while Sanders focuses on rejecting billionaire influence.
- The tour aims to inspire a movement beyond party lines, despite criticism of populist tactics.
The story of OldMan_Advocate, a digital warrior who faced a 'breakup' with Facebook/Meta. Despite setbacks from algorithmic misinterpretations, he continues to advocate for public education and seeks new platforms for his humor-infused activism.
### Key Points
- OldMan_Advocate's humorous yet tumultuous relationship with Meta and his advocacy for public education.
- The impact of algorithms on digital expression and community building.
- OldMan_Advocate's continued efforts to engage with the public through various platforms.