Latest News and Comment from Education

Tuesday, March 5, 2013

Why Sending Your Child to a Charter School Hurts Other Children | Alternet

Why Sending Your Child to a Charter School Hurts Other Children | Alternet:


Why Sending Your Child to a Charter School Hurts Other Children

Parents should fight for quality education for all, not just their own kids.

Photo Credit: Shutterstock.com/iofoto
On a blog post challenging the role of charter schools in education reform, a parent named Dienne left a comment about choosing to remove a child from “a test-prep, drill-to-kill, twelve times a year testing factory” public school, and then posed a powerful question: “I’d ask you what exactly am I supposed to do?”
Dienne’s question highlights one of the biggest dilemmas charter school critics, many of whom are civil rights and social justice advocates, face: how to speakwith, and not for, marginalized parents struggling against poverty, racism and sexism, while many of these parents believe charter schools are in the best interests of their own children.
This predicament can be likened to feminist scholar

UPDATE: Protesters sit in outside the mayor's office | Philadelphia Public School Notebook

Protesters sit in outside the mayor's office | Philadelphia Public School Notebook:



Protesters imply SRC is bulldozing schools

Inside City Hall right now, a small group of protesters are staging a sit-in, a criticism of the mayor's support for the District's mass school-closings plan. Outside City Hall, the rally to Occupy Nutter is also in full swing. Here's a great photo from the protest, tweeted by the PFT.
read more


Protesters sit in outside the mayor's office

by Paul Socolar on Mar 05 2013 Posted in Latest news



A crowd of about 20 opponents of the School District's closings plan is staging a sit-in outside the mayor's office on the second floor of City Hall this afternoon, following a meeting with Mayor Nutter.
The protest includes members of Action United, the NAACP, Parents United for Public Education, and PCAPS (Philadelphia Coalition Advocating for Public Schools). The groups are criticizing the mayor's support for the District's plan to close 29 schools. Action United has set up a livestream of the sit-in.
City police have blocked off the corridor where the protest is taking place. Craig Robbins, director of Action United, who is part of the sit-in, was reached by phone. He reported that a group met with the mayor at 2:15 p.m, including these groups and two members of a clergy coalition, and laid out the argument for a one-year moratorium on school closings. "We also asked him to be more aggressive in fighting for more funding for the schools," Robbins said.
According to Robbins, "We didn't get very far. ... The mayor said parents are voting with their feet and leaving schools, and this is what we have to do." Robbins said that after the 45-minute meeting, the group left the office, met with supporters, and the sit-in began.
Robbins added, "We're going to stay a while."

Big Education Ape - SPECIAL Mid Day Banana Break 3-5-13 #soschat #edreform



Big Education Ape - Mid Day Banana Break



The History of the Term “Failing Schools”

Kevin Kosar, who earned his Ph.D. at NYU in a study of federal education policy, researched the use of the term “failing schools.” It was seldom used until 1990. Since then, as you can see when you open the link, it has become a commonplace term.
This is clearly political, since test scores for every group are higher today than they were in 1990, graduation rates are higher, and dropout rates are lower.
“Failing schools” is a term that enables privatizers to take over more public property and to enroll more students when their neighborhood school was closed.


Special episode of At the Chalk Face coming up at 5PM EST with Carol Burris

You can listen via this link. Live tweet or join us in the chat room. 


Evaluating teachers -- A snapshot


Race to the Top and No Child Left Behind waiver requirements have prompted states to make major changes to teacher evaluation policies.

This report offers state-by-state data that shows how often states evaluate teachers, how many levels states use to rate teachers, and how much of a teacher's evaluation is based on student data:


Pi Day

March 14 is National Pi Day.
Nothing better than a good pi...right?
If you are interested in this day with potential endless mathematical learning opportunities you might
want to gather some information at the following sites.

http://www.eveandersson.com/pi/
http://www.joyofpi.com/pilinks.html
Happy Pi Day

Arne Duncan: The newest rhetoric vs. the reality

Education Secretary Arne Duncan appeared at a Washington Post-sponsored conference on families today, and he sounded (mostly) highly reasonable: Early childhood education is the absolute “best long-term investment” that the country can make for kids, families and the economy, he … Continue reading →

What Happens When Kids Craft Their Own BYOD Policy?

pencils.001
It started out with a standardized writing prompt and was never intended to move outside of the small testing window. However, when students finished writing a persuasive text on whether students should  be allowed to have cell phones and MP3 players (a student aptly pointed out that banning MP3 players would still allow him to have an iPod, because they don’t use the MP3 format), they wanted to create their own BYOD (Bring Your Own Device) policies.
The Process
I began by asking students to create a series of questions. After tweaking the language, the guiding questions 

BEWARE THE LIES OF MARCH

A Note from Steve Zimmer Friends, In less than 12 hours the polls will close on this historic school board race. This race is so close that we know every single vote will count. So I am asking you to send one last email blast, post one last facebook message, make one last phone call, talk to one more voter. Our message is very simple. Don't believe the lies of March. Never in the

Hmmmmmm….PTA & Amazon Kindle Launch Partnership

The National PTA has just announced a partnership with Amazon Kindle:
The National PTA® today announced Amazon Kindle will be the exclusive sponsor of a new Family Reading Experience program to be hosted by local PTAs in cities across the United States. Throughout 2013, the National PTA and Kindle will work together to encourage family involvement with their children’s reading.
It seems to me that this next sentence is the most important part of the press release:

As the “Official E-reader of the National PTA,” Amazon Kindle will donate Kindles for the National PTA to 

State Senate takes field trip to Long Beach - Los Angeles Times


State Senate takes field trip to Long Beach
Los Angeles Times
... the world of work and careers," said Senate President Pro Tem Darrell Steinberg (D-Sacramento). He said the Long Beach Unified School District is on the "cutting edge of linked learning in California," and is one of the top performing districts in ...

Judge Blocks AL Gov from Tax Credit Bill



Gov. Bentley announces Alabama Accountability Act
Gov. Bentley announces Alabama Accountability Act"Local school systems will have the flexibility to make more decisions on behalf of their students. Families will have new options if their children are stuck in failing schools. All children, regardless of their family's income or where they live, will have the opportunity to receive a quality education," said Bentley.Watch video
MONTGOMERY, Alabama -- Montgomery Circuit Judge Charles Price issued an order this morning blocking a controversial school choice bill from being sent to Gov. Robert Bentley for his signature today.
Legislative staff would have sent the bill to Bentley shortly after lawmakers convened at 1 p.m. Bentley planned to sign the bill this afternoon.  Price issued his order shortly before 11 a.m.
The Alabama Education Association filed a lawsuit Monday night seeking to stop the legislation that would give parents zoned for "failing" schools an estimated 

Multiple Union Endorsements Give Runoff Options

Website for UTLA’s Political Action Committee
The teachers union’s entire strategy for defeating District 2 incumbent Monica Garcia is predicated on the race going to a runoff.  They’ve spent much of their money attacking her record, and if — as most insiders are predicting — Garcia fails to reach the 50 percent threshold required to avoid a runoff, UTLA has already endorsed all of Garcia’s possible opponents (except Isabel Vazquez) and can begin its general election campaign without any delay.
The union’s decision will be harder in District 6, where UTLA has endorsed multiple candidates but hasn’t yet spent any money supporting them. If front-runner Antonio Sanchez doesn’t reach 50 percent, then UTLA will have to decide whether to concede the race to a candidate who’s been endorsed by and received gobs of money from the Coalition for School Reform — and keep focus on defeating Garcia in District 2 — or go through the awkward process of un-endorsing Sanchez and throwing its weight behind Sanchez’s likely opponent, Monica Ratliff, who is, after all, a teacher and member of UTLA’s House of Representatives and has also already been 

Morning Read: Voters Head to Polls for School Board, Mayor

With Reform Fervor in the Air, Local School Board Elections See Record Outside Spending
This year, huge amounts of money and passion are flowing down the ballot into the school board elections — part of an all-out war over public school reform. KCET
See also: LA School Report

Epic fail: Kids school ‘Fox & Friends’ hosts on basic math

The hosts of Fox News’ morning show on Tuesday proved that many adults have poor math skills by failing a simple quiz from their own children in an epic way. Fox & Friends hosts Steve Doocy, Gretchen Carlson and Brian Kilmeade noted that a recent study found that only about 5 percent of...

Garfield Library Needs Votes!

Garfield's library has entered the Follett Challenge.

"The Follett Challenge was designed to reward school libraries for their work applying technology, content and creativity in ways that engage students, foster literacy and promote critical thinking. "

The video is called "One Book, One School; Community Wide Reading for Plugged-In Teenagers" and was made one of our contributors, Johnny Calcagno and Garfield librarian, Janet Woodward.  The entire freshman class did a field trip to the International District, met with internment survivors, and did papers and projects on the book, Hotel on the Corner of Bitter and Sweet

If you have the time, please check out their video in support of their submission and give them a vote.  It's money 


Tuesday Open Thread

From a reader:

White mothers of biracial daughters and sons are invited to participate in a study. I will be in Seattle April 10 - 14th to interview mothers for this critical study. Please let families know about the study and interested families can contact me.

[email protected]


Great story out of South Glens Falls, NY.  It seems that this high school has had a dance marathon since 1978 and this year donated the proceeds, nearly $500,000, to help people tackling huge life challenges.  From the AP:


District Statement on The Center School Race and Social Justice Class

 Statement from Superintendent Banda on The Center School race and social justice curriculum class (partial):

On Dec. 21, 2012, we received a complaint from a family at Center School alleging that the instructional activities used in the Citizenship and Social Justice: Advanced Placement Language and Compositions and Social Studies class included intimidating and discriminating actions, attitudes and classroom environment.

Our Human Resources Department then launched an investigation of this complaint, as is our process. At the 


As UFT elections get underway, dissenters face an uphill climb

As UFT elections get underway, dissenters face an uphill climb
It’s been nearly three years since Michael Mulgrew was elected to his first full term at the helm of the United Federation of Teachers, which means election season has arrived for the city’s teachers union. As would-be candidates work to meet Wednesday’s deadline to collect the signatures they need to get on the ballots in April, we’ll be keeping you up to date on Mulgrew’s re-election bid and about what to expect from the changing union landscape. What is clear is that there won’t be much suspense in the race for UFT president, as Mulgrew will almost certainly coast to a second full term. He’s backed by the union’s longtime dominant party, Unity, whose presidential candidate typically wins by a landslide. Three years ago, Mulgrew received 91 percent of the vote. The unified support that the union’s leadership typically receives is one of many ways that the union has remained powerful in the face of threats. In other ways, too, the elections are about more than Mulgrew. There will be hundreds of positions on the ballot, including 90 executive board positions and delegates to the national and state unions, many with significant ability to impact decision-making. 


The Teacher “Bar” Exam is no solution to teacher quality

The Sad truth about Education programs in the US (Photo credit: brewbooks)
American Education is in the DumpsterWhen a cat and a dog start howling at the moon together, something is terribly wrong.
With Randi Weingarten and Arne Duncan howling in unison over the need to overhaul teacher training, I get immediately suspicious.  These two never seem to howl together for anything, and when they do…it is usually more self-serving than selfless.
Recently, Weingarten, president of the American Federation of Teachers (AFT) has been touting the need for a streamlining of teacher certification, so that all teachers are held to the same standard.  This new system is meant to replace the multiple certification systems in place in all fifty states, geared toward making sure that “an 


Education Department Releases New School-Level Graduation Rate Data to Better Inform Parents, District Leaders

Today the U.S. Department of Education released provisional school-level graduation rates for 2010-11 – the first school year for which all states used a common, rigorous measure for reporting high school graduates. The data release furthers the Department's efforts to provide transparent information to parents and students about their schools and ensure all schools are preparing students for college and careers.
Previously, the variety of methods states used to report high school graduation rates made comparisons among states unreliable. While the new measure is not comparable to previously reported rates, it provides a more accurate snapshot of high school graduation and can inform schools' efforts to improve going forward. States, districts and schools can use the new, common metric to promote greater accountability and to develop strategies that will reduce dropout rates and increase graduation rates in schools nationwide.
"Having good information is critical to making good decisions, and these high school graduation rates are a vital tool to help parents and school leaders make useful comparisons of student growth and success," said U.S. Secretary of Education Arne Duncan. "These data will also help state, district and school leaders better gauge progress and support their work to help more students graduate on time, ready for college and .


Watch: What’s At Stake in Today’s School Board Election

KCET explores what’s at stake in today’s Los Angeles School Board election, including snippets from the District 4 candidates, UTLA President Warren Fletcher, education advocate Diane Ravitch, and local parents. You can skim the transcript here.
Popout


Westside Teachers Dial for Zimmer

Grand View Elementary teacher Irene Perez making calls at Carrow’s
About 20 teachers sat down in the back room of a Carrow’s restaurant in Santa Monica last night making phone calls reminding registered voters to vote for UTLA-backed District 4 incumbent Steve Zimmer.
Volunteers were given cell phones, a list of phone numbers and were allowed to order a meal for up to $10 plus a drink (no alcohol though). The goal: call voters to remind them to vote.
“I wanted to see if you’ll join us in helping to elect Steve Zimmer tomorrow,” a tentative Grand View Elementary teacher Irene Perez said into the phone, as her son Kingston ate from a bowl of vanilla ice cream.


Listen: District 4 Candidates Answer Parent Questions



Still undecided about how to vote in District 4?  One helpful blogger put together some parent-focused questions for District 4 candidates Steve Zimmer and Kate Anderson. The questions – on parent fundraising, curriculum narrowing, teacher evaluatoin, and charter school co-___location and expansion  – are categorized by topic, with answers from each candidate conveniently lined up one next to the other. You can listen to them here.


Arne Duncan: The newest rhetoric vs. the reality

Arne Duncan: The newest rhetoric vs. the reality:


Arne Duncan: The newest rhetoric vs. the reality

Arne Duncan                                                        (Bill O’Leary/The Washington Post)
Arne Duncan (Bill O’Leary/The Washington Post)
Education Secretary Arne Duncan appeared at a Washington Post-sponsored conference on families today, and he sounded (mostly) highly reasonable:
Early childhood education is the absolute “best long-term investment” that the country can make for kids, families and the economy, he said. (Not, apparently, the billions of dollars he spent in the first term of the Obama administration pushing states to enact school reforms that linked standardized test scores to the evaluation of teachers and made these tests more high stakes than ever).
He said further that, of course, kids can’t focus in class if they are hungry or can’t see the blackboard. “Social and emotional needs have to be met  for students to do well in school,” he said.  In fact, there isn’t “one simple answer” to improving schools. You need “great principals” and “fantastic teachers,” and “all the wrap-around services” and food to feed hungry children and after-school activities and transformative school cultures. (Not, 

A school brings brain research to the center of its curriculum

Most teachers would tell a panicked student simply to calm down, but that’s not what teacher Glenn Whitman did when a junior came to him in knots about a major oral history project. “Maddy,” he said, “I care about your amygdala.”
Read full article >>


Diane in the Evening 3-5-13 Diane Ravitch's blog | A site to discuss better education for all

Diane Ravitch's blog | A site to discuss better education for all:






Teachers in Grand Rapids Say They Qualify for Food Stamps

Want to know why teachers are demoralized? Read this story from Grand Rapids, Michigan.
Michigan has been a national leader in attacking public education, increasing charters, and diminishing teachers’ pay and benefits. Governor Rick Snyder must take pride in crushing his state’s public school teachers.
Oh, did you know that more than 80% of the charters in Michigan are for-profit?


Breaking News! Public School Supporters Sitting In Philly Mayor’s Office

Public school activists are conducting a sit-in in the office of the mayor of Philadelphia to protest school closings.
This is the announcement I just received:
BREAKING NEWS – March 5, 2013 – Philadelphia, Pennsylvania
Hello PCAPS (Philadelphia Coalition Advocating for Public Schools & Moratorium Endorsers,
The fight for education has just reached new levels! Parents, community activists, retired teachers and allies are sitting in the Mayor’s office as we speak and they are refusing to leave until we win a one year moratorium on 

Viva Eastside Memorial High School!

On other posts, I have told the story of Eastside Memorial High School in Austin, Texas.
The school board and superintendent (Broad-trained) decided to give the school to a charter chain called IDEA. This was not popular with the community. Many families in the neighborhood pulled their children out of the IDEA charter in protest and sent them elsewhere. In the November election, the community elected a school board member opposed to the charter takeover, and the board severed the contract. Now the state is considering shutting down the school, and the parents and students are trying to block the school’s closure. At the Save Our School Rally last weekend in Austin, a large contingent of parents and students from Eastside Memorial High School marched and chanted in unison, raising their “bear paws” to show their support for their school.
Here is a letter from a parent:

Dear Diane, Thank you so much for sharing our story! ~~
There are many misconceptions about our school. Some created by self-serving “

Why the Bloomberg Reforms Failed

Mayor Bloomberg plans to start four charter high schools that will open after his term of office ends.
This constitutes an admission that his own efforts to reform the public schools have failed.
The mayor has had 11 years of total control of the public school system. Every year, he closes more schools. Some of the schools he closes are schools that his own administration opened..
Less than 5% of the city’s 1.1 million students attend charters.
The other 95% have been forgotten, adrift in a system that has been reorganized four times, with all regional and 

The History of the Term “Failing Schools”

Kevin Kosar, who earned his Ph.D. at NYU in a study of federal education policy, researched the use of the term “failing schools.” It was seldom used until 1990. Since then, as you can see when you open the link, it has become a commonplace term.
This is clearly political, since test scores for every group are higher today than they were in 1990, graduation rates are higher, and dropout rates are lower.
“Failing schools” is a term that enables privatizers to take over more public property and to enroll more students when their neighborhood school was closed.


Research on School Closings

Before the passage of No Child Left Behind, public schools were seldom closed for low test scores. School officials and the public understood that low test scores reflected the social and economic conditions in which students live. It made no sense to punish the school because its students were living in poverty. After NCLB and Race to the Top, more and more urban schools are being closed to punish them for their low test scores.
A reader suggested that we read the following research brief:
“Here is a recent Issue Brief from Research for Action that 

Florida Newspaper: What Miracle?

Former Governor Jeb Bush traverses the nation, especially the red states, bringing news of the Florida miracle. After the debacle of the “Texas miracle,” which thrust NCLB on the nation, Mr. Bush would be well-advised to pick another issue.
The Palm Beach Post wrote a scathing editorial taking down the myth of the Florida miracle (which Bush’s former deputy Hannah Skandera is now selling in New Mexico).
The editorial says:
“Former Gov. Jeb Bush has an undeserved reputation as an education reformer. Florida’s recent education 

LISTEN TO DIANE RAVITCH 3-5-13 Diane Ravitch's blog | A site to discuss better education for all

coopmike48 at Big Education Ape - 2 hours ago
Diane Ravitch's blog | A site to discuss better education for all: [image: Click on picture to Listen to Diane Ravitch] Occupy DOE Calls on States to Drop Common Core Testing by dianerav This just in from organizers of protest demonstration in D.C. From April 4-7: Campaign to Withdraw from Assessment Consortia The Common Core was a clever plan hatched by the corporate sponsors of ACHIEVE to ensure that national standards based tests, now being completed by the federally financed PARCC and SBAC consortia, would be cemented in place for years to come. States were pressured to sig... more »