Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login
The giant world Halla should have been swallowed by its star long ago (nytimes.com)
32 points by Hooke on July 1, 2023 | hide | past | favorite | 21 comments




Based on the headline, it almost sounds like the NYT is advocating for mundicide

"Hella delenda est"


[flagged]


Yes. Paywalls surviving is such a disappointing development in the evolution of the internet.

I'd really like to have a browser extension that could remove links to paywalled sites from search engine result pages and popular news aggregators. I don't really need to see that part of the internet or be reminded of its existence.


Do you prefer ad-supported internet over paywalls?


Over the nytimes "please sign up online but phone retention during business hours to cancel unless your jurisdiction makes that illegal" paywall at least.


They really need to change the cancel process. It makes them seem like amateurs. I feel like Sirius radio and the nytimes are run by the same people, and if you’re the nytimes that’s a problem.


There are, of course, more than two options.


> Do you prefer ad-supported internet over paywalls?

Does it matter? OP just wants a search results-set to not have content that he cannot access.

This is perfectly reasonable: when I search for something it's pointless showing me a result that I cannot access.


Yes, I can block the ads.


How do you propose the research for these articles is funded?


Its a common naivete of older technical folk who are used to being in a "special category" of people who know what X tool is and how to use it. They view other people consuming adverts as the answer while they know how to get around them. Except that, now, Brave and similar poducts mean everyday users utilise these tools too, so no adverts get viewed.

I think paywalling something but with a much lower on the spot cost, as an instant microtransaction without an account.


what is the alternative, in your mind?


I find the anthropomorphisms of "swallowed" and "ate" and "cheated death" so annoying that it's hard to read the article. I really wish science writers would tone this nonsense down. It gets in the way.


What would you prefer? The astrophysical process you’re referring to is called accretion [1]. It is a single word that covers many different situations that are all the result of the same underlying phenomenon: gravity.

[1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Accretion_(astrophysics)


'Halla is “a forbidden planet of sorts,” said Marc Hon'

This guy obviously knows how to talk to big media. But maybe NYT is not the right place for you to read science news?


NYT isn't the right place to read much these days. Just a bunch of old racist/transphobic neo-liberal trust fund babies writing nonsense. There are many more higher quality leftist oriented websites.


Like where?


You could paste the text into GPT3.5 and ask it to do just that.

I imagine it won't be long before that's an add-on, so you don't even have to leave the page. "Hemingway this up for me", and boobs your uncle.


Amusing autocorrect ;-)


Metaphor is the basis of language, with the human body being the most accessible reference.


I wonder if the title is making a pun about eating a Jewish variety of leavened bread.




Consider applying for YC's Summer 2025 batch! Applications are open till May 13

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: