Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit | oblio's comments login

I wonder how Aurora fares on this?

I wondered how Microsoft SQL Server fares, but not it's tested in the long list of databases:

https://jepsen.io/analyses


It may violate the SQL Server license? Microsoft have not apparently paid for a Jepsen analysis (or perhaps don't want it public :))

> Microsoft have not apparently paid for a Jepsen analysis (or perhaps don't want it public :))

If I was some database vendor that sometimes plays fast and loose (not saying Microsoft is, just an example) and my product is good for 99.95% of use cases and the remainder is exceedingly hard to fix, I'd probably be more likely to pay for Jepsen not to do an analysis, because hiring them would result in people being more likely to leave an otherwise sufficient product due to those faults being brought to light.


And yet, this one was done without compensation, so it seems the value of the report and the backing investigation is not only for money

If I'm understanding the issue correctly, it probably doesn't.

From what I understand, multi-az has some setup with multiple semi synchronous replicas where only 1 replica needs to acknowledge the transaction.

Aurora doesn't use semi synchronous replication but uses clustered/shared storage with a different replication setup for cache invalidation


Aurora doesn't offer Postgresql 17 for now I think


"They occurred in every PostgreSQL version we tested, from 13.15 (the oldest version which AWS supported) to 17.4 (the newest)."

So unlikely v17 will make a difference.


When I want to make old devs cry I send them this link[1]:

https://forum.dlang.org/

I know it's very simple, I know there isn't a lot of media (and definitely no tracking or ads), but it shows what could be possible on the internet. It's just that nobody cares.

[1] Yes, Hacker News is also quite good in terms of loading speed.


Private torrent trackers are generally fast too. My pet peeves is when news websites are slow, because the only content you have is 90% text.

That 10% left of adware is heavy stuff

I just use hibernate instead. Marginally longer start up time and no more worries. For shorter periods I just leave it on (like when taking the laptop to a meeting room).

Hibernate is a lot harder to make work correctly, and can lead to problems in more niche cases, so it's not a guarantee

Huh? I have enabled that on hundreds of installations in the past and have yet to see an issue. It's neither hard nor does it lead to issues more than standby does. (Even less, from my XP)

Google Keep is a note taking app.

However when you're inside a note (which BTW, can also be converted into checkboxes, aka very simple TODOs), Google Keep, the note taking app from search giant Google, doesn't have search functionality for that specific note.

Besides the many small bugs, sometimes the missing functionality in Google apps is mind boggling.


On a asimialr vein, Microsoft's OneNote, which is of course part of the famed and expensive Office suite, still doesn't support Find and Replace. But, they do have a meticulously written official support article that suggests you can copy the text you want to replace with, and then do Find, double click the text it finds, ctrl+V, and repeat...

https://support.microsoft.com/en-us/office/find-and-replace-...


Wow that is ridiculous. But really, OneNote is the most crusty part of the whole office suite. It's completely unfit for purpose. They don't even bother to make a web version that properly works (you get signed out every day and you can only search in one folder, not even a whole notebook)

I moved to obsidian with self hosted livesync and it's such a breath of fresh air. It actually does what it says. There's tons of plugins. The sync never drops a beat.

It's a typical example of Microsoft's solutions to be B-quality at best. An AAA level solution is always better.. Microsoft's goal is only to be not bad enough for people to drop the "included with your subscription" product and go for something actually fit for purpose.

Unfortunately I'm stuck with OneNote at work. I guess they want me to be ineffective and inefficient.

It's just annoying because I don't have any use for "office" applications but a personal knowledgebase is something that's super important to me.


When I last reinstalled the apps on my phone, the one Google app that ironically I didn’t keep was Keep.

I really want a simple and easy to use shopping/TODO/checklist app that I can use with my family, from a vendor that has been around for a long time. Ideally free, but I'm fine with paying a small price for it. It should be available on Windows/Android/iOS.

The problem is, I don't really trust most small vendors...



Maybe rememberthemilk.com. I don't use it or any other fancy stuff like it now, but it was pretty good a decade ago.

At least as much mission critical software runs on C++, Java, and of course, plain old C.

I wouldn't portray Cobol to be some sort of magic "hardcore" pixie dust for anything.


End jus solis. Allow all current parents to stay.

There ya go, the humane solution to this.


Birthright citizenship is explicitly included in the 14’th amendment of the US constitution. Technically the constitution could be amended again. But if we include wildly controversial constitutional amendments that one of our parties would be completely opposed in the list of possibilities, the conversation will quickly get silly.

> But if we include wildly controversial constitutional amendments that one of our parties would be completely opposed in the list of possibilities, the conversation will quickly get silly.

You're this <> close from becoming a dictatorship, things could become very silly regardless.

If anything, I'd say Trump is just a silly Sulla. Sulla was somewhat benevolent, he retired. But he paved the way for Caesar and Augustus (people who really meant business, especially Augustus).


I mean, I’m worried about the trajectory of the country generally. But, we need to be able to talk about the actual laws and process (this assumes we still have laws and processes).

If the country turns into a dictatorship, then it is just rule by dictatorial fiat. But in that case this whole conversation is sort of pointless because we wouldn’t have democracy and our opinions about how things should be run wouldn’t matter anymore.


Foreign citizenship is being subject to a foreign power.

I don’t see any connection here.

Birthright citizenship doesn't apply to children born to parents subject to a foreign power. That's what the text of the ammendment says.

No. What the law says is that birthright citizenship does not apply to those *not* subject to US law. Foreign diplomats with diplomatic immunity. It's not the foreign power that matters, it's the lack of the US power.

That isn’t what it says.

> All persons born or naturalized in the United States, and subject to the jurisdiction thereof, are citizens of the United States and of the State wherein they reside.

All people in the US are subject to the jurisdiction of the US (other than some very unusual situation like diplomats and, in the past, some Native American tribes).


Can someone who down voted this comment please explain why? Is this because you do not agree with his general stance or because it simplifies and doesn't contribute to the debate?

I would not consider a radical change to how US citizenship has worked for at least a century and a half to be “non-extreme.”

“End Jus Soli” would require a constitutional amendment and would be universally opposed by at least one party. So, it is bringing the conversation in the direction of ridiculous out-there topics.

And it can cause headaches with people being stateless because neither the country of their parents nor the country of their birth recognizes them. And that's something that's normally prohibited by treaty: you can't take an action that will render someone stateless.

Is that really so? It seems odd because not every country has soil-based birthright citizenship. So, there must be some combinations that will result in a stateless person (although I would expect that this is an exceptional case that is just handled as an exception).

And it causes problems.

Where? I haven't really heard of many cases like this. Usually the most abuse that happens is someone "forgetting" their citizenship and trying to gain asylum, because they know they can't get citizenship otherwise, anyway.

Because it recommends the government should just ignore the constitution.

No, I'm saying that the US government should be able to change the constitution, if its citizens want it. Apparently about 50% of the US population is rabidly anti-immigration.

All this status quo is doing is creating all sort of gray area cruelty. Just be open about it, become anti-immigration, but make it fair. The US is basically the only developed Western country that I know of where you don't even have fixed time frame to become a citizen. In the EU + CANZUK if you live lawfully in a country you become a citizen in N years. The N is well known ahead of time.


I think birthright citizenship is one of the few examples of America doing something strictly better than most other countries.

Why? Why should someone be a citizen because they were born in a specific country? With jus sanguinis things are much clearer: one of your parents is a citizen, you're a citizen. Your kids are citizens. In perpetuity.

Jus solis is a bit like right of way at American intersections: the person that's been there the longest goes first. Whaaaaaa? What if two cars arrive at the same time? What if 4 arrive at roughly at the same time? What is people can't agree who arrived first? A lot of the rest of the world gives way to the car coming from the right. Which is obvious and basically non-negotiable.

Similar idea here.


Not sure who downvoted, but simply ending jus solis because authoritarians want to make people's lives miserable is an extreme position with an awful BATNA.

Americans are extremely cruel.

The real solution to this is to end jus solis.

Separating children from parents is incredibly cruel, inhumane, even.


> The real solution to this is to end jus solis.

No, that's a step down a terrible return to pre-Civil War policy. We should be actively fighting against enslavement and for due process, not throwing our hands up and saying "well, guess we can't [bring them back from El Salvador, have a sane policy with respect to families, have people's rights to citizenship and legal residence respected]".


Well, I wish you luck with that, you're currently losing.

I have nothing to gain from the US devolving from a democracy, but you're headed that way.


That thing only has an estimated 3 million people, and that's including a lot of Oregon.

Surprisingly, those Coastal cities have a lot of people (common theme in the US).


Those Coastal cities have lot of people, yes, but not a lot of land.

It also isn't just north California, but also the east.

Here, check out this map. https://www.politico.com/2024-election/results/california/

It seems reasonable to expect all of the Trump-voting areas to stick with the United States.

This would end up being more of a Hong Kong type situation, and less of a Taiwan-type situation.

Without having any of it's own agriculture, and without being able to act as the middle-man for all of the trade between Asia and America, California would find itself in an extremely precarious situation.


As soon as California left, it would be a very small, weak territory with almost no military capacity.

And it would be home to some of the most important natural resources around, deep water ports in particular.

Imagine that California was a separate country today. Military conquest by America would be an obvious course of action.

The real outcome of this would be the transformation of the coastal cities into non-state US territories under military control, without no voting rights or citizenship.

And that actually might be a pretty good outcome?


China isn't annexing Germany any time soon, for example. California could afford a solid defensive military.

That's transitioning to streaming services which still have studios.

Join us for AI Startup School this June 16-17 in San Francisco!

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: