Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit | peritpatrio's comments login

Matthew Walker's "Why We Sleep" Is Riddled with Scientific and Factual Errors — https://guzey.com/books/why-we-sleep/


Thanks for the link, will check it out. I note however that Walker has responded to the criticism (https://sleepdiplomat.wordpress.com/2019/12/19/why-we-sleep-...).


From a quick skim of that response, it reads to me like Walker admits to and agrees with at least some of the criticism.

But it also looks like he ignores some of the more damning accusations, like cutting out parts of graphs that don't support his theories, being incorrect that the WHO has declared that we have a "sleep loss epidemic", and questions about where he actually earned his PhD (which he seems to continually misrepresent).

So yes, he seems to have responded to the criticism, but IMO not really addressed it to a satisfying degree.


All of what you said might be true and it could still be the best book on why sleep is important.


It's also possible that someone who lies 99% of the time has something really important to say with the other 1% (if you can even separate it from the 99%), but I wouldn't consider that person trustworthy or even worth dealing with.

Not saying that perfectly describes Walker, but the evidence does seem to point in that direction.

If you still want to trust someone like that, I guess that's your prerogative, but... well, that sort of thing doesn't seem like a winning strategy in life.


If I'm allowed to just make shit up I could easily write an even better one!


IMO he has mostly satisfying answers. He agrees with some minor points and he doesn't address important stuff like cutting out parts of graphs, but I don't think the criticism is strong enough to conclude that the book is "riddled with scientific and factual errors".


Here’s pretty good starting point for building overall strength: https://stronglifts.com/5x5/


You beat me by 1 minute! 5x5 is an excellent starter program. I've lifted for about 10 years and while I'm more in the advanced and intermediate lifting programs, 5x5 is my goto when I have a long hiatus in lifting. I'm definitely doing it once the COVID lockdowns are over.


Seems like this requires both physical space and equipment. Being stuck at home right now, what would be good enough alternatives for the exercises other than squats (perhaps with smaller dumbbells or with body weight)?


https://old.reddit.com/r/bodyweightfitness/wiki/kb/recommend... - maybe check out this program. I haven't run it myself, but I've heard a lot of people speak well of it.



Can you spot the three magic words?

"One contributing factor might be Orange's offer to give anyone upgrading to the Lumia a free Xbox 360."

Gaining market share is one thing, making a decent profit is another.


As I haven't contributed anything for the HN community, take these invite codes as a token of my appreciation:

		fBtbsnyhR7Sw3k3B
		a9LXkhTx4YdTkP4a
		czSVXhFkLgwRx6zS
		e7wuTAMVtVck8BMC
		cYAAdNPCpBgCtyyu
		fG7GsqbFsBaE2knG
		eCECZNnkaRy4VJ8q
		duJy7W9EAR2KyYBd
		exmWgPwsfsVbgBKy
		eScdc6ctgdNsRSGF
		e5K5nXfmswZfV8Mk
		fBBnJNgd4Ur49XZZ
		aUTDk63STysENRhM
		dHgs5mwfTpwFuHzE
		dyrJCYY74WKd3fnS
		fkqWs4B2A4rV6bpu
		dHuPEYSSLCHNgGS6
		bkUkZy5bsw9c4u3U
		fdVPkN4Fd65r33De
		aKEwzC3yTBRNbLE9
		eEp6Lq23VwW98wTu
		cP2LJhfd7sbNXYMY
		dDJzy2qmHCHKVRsW
		ddDzbdD2d6MhA9Ur
		edtLcZqrnZY2bXWm
		eeENV5uFfnfUVayA


eEp6Lq23VwW98wTu used. Thanks!

Since I didn't see an obvious way from the front page, the place to sign up for a free account if you have an invite code is: https://www.spotify.com/us/get-spotify/overview/


That helped me a lot. I kept trying to sign up on the wrong page and kept saying every code I was using was invalid. I was getting incredibly irritated!


Thanks, I used fG7GsqbFsBaE2knG


dHuPEYSSLCHNgGS6 used. Thanks so much!


a9LXkhTx4YdTkP4a used. Thanks!


fBtbsnyhR7Sw3k3B used. Thanks!


On another note regarding Finnish language:

The word-forms of the Finnish noun kauppa 'shop' (N=2,253), generated automatically by Fred Karlsson

http://www.ling.helsinki.fi/~fkarlsso/genkau2.html


The word with the most forms, also the longest word in the world is the English 'strawberry'.

   strawberry
   strawberry-less
   strawberry-less-ness
   strawberry-less-ness-less
   strawberry-less-ness-less-ness
   .
   .
   .
   ∞


Except that all the forms listed there actually mean something and could be used in everyday conversations (some of them are pretty rare, of course). In English those would be communicated by a lot of prepositions. Take "kauppoinennekaan" [1], that would roughly mean "not even with your (plural) shops".

[1] Dashes are on the page for clarity, they're not part of Finnish language


Used YWWXYTRXNAA7, thanks!


I'd like to recommend Alfred App [http://www.alfredapp.com/] as an alternative for Quicksilver.


I've seen it before, but haven't tried it. What do you like better about it than QS?


I found the general user experience more pleasant and Alfred easier to configure for my needs. QS did (and probably still does) a good job, but I wouldn't switch back anymore.


Consider applying for YC's Summer 2025 batch! Applications are open till May 13

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: