Convergence and Syntactic Reanalysis:  The case of &#39;so&#39;  in Dakkhini

Karumuri V.  Subbarao

Convergence and Syntactic Reanalysis: The case of 'so' in Dakkhini

Abstract

The following evidence can be cited for treating so as an adjectlvallzer in Dakkhini. 2.2.1. Notice that so precedes the head NP (a pronoun in this case) usku and uno In sentences ( ) and ( ) respectively. Further, when such sentences as ( ) and (6) are uttered, there is no pause between the marker so and the following head NP. A potential pause can occur only after the head NP, viz. usku or uno in ( ) and ( ). (It is a pan-Indian pattern, that a pause cannot occur between a phrasal modifier and its head NP.) This point establishes that so cannot be treated separately from the head NP and that so and the head NP together form a single unit. Note further that in Dakkhini an expression of the type ( ) below is perfectly grammatical. In (other) modern South Asian languages, however, a correlative pronoun and a head NP containing its own demonstrative pronoun do not occur in sequence, one immediately following the other. If we treated so as a correlative prounoun, we would be forced to claim that Dakkhini exhibits radically different behavior.

Figures (74)

lf we consider the distribution of prevocaiic y, it is clear that there are no cooccurrence restrictions between initials and following glides; all combinations are possible, as illustrated in (16). As for prevocalic w, the case is more complex, because it can be preceded only by the velars k, k’, and h, as shown in (17) below. This raises the question whether w should be regarded as part of the onset. Now, considering w to be part of the onset would make it impossible t¢ State the restriction against rhyming wa with ya in the manner that it should be namely as conditioned by the nature of the nucleus. Secondly, the argument: to be presented in the next section show that prevocalic wis subject to the same dissimilatory constraint wihin the nucleus as is prevocalic y, suggesting that it i: indeed part of the nucleus.

This distribution can be accounted for by the Branching Rime Constraint in 29), next page.

It turns out that in the most straightforward adaptation of Earley’s algorithm, an analog of the left recursion problem reemerges. Shieber (1985) illustrates this with problem with a ‘counting grammar’ but the same point can be made using a type of grammar that is somewhat more familiar in recent linguistic theory. Specifically, infinite cycles can arise in grammars that handle subcategorization with list valued features such as Head Driven Phrase Structure Grammar (Pollard and Sag 1987) or PATR style grammars (Shieber 1986). To illustrate the problem, suppose that we are parsing a sentence using a grammar with the PATR style rules in (1) and (2). The problem of non-termination can arise with this grammar since rule (2) allows for lexical items with indefinitely long subcategorization lists.

Andrews, Dasgupta, Lehmann, and Srivastav provide special motivatior for this analysis by pointing to 'multiple-headed’ RCs of the type (7a-c) which because their RPs refer to more than one constituent of the CC, cannot possibly be accounted for as embedded. For which NP would they be embeddec under? As Kiparsky (1989) has noted, similar difficulties are encountered ir structures of the type (7d) in which there is no coreferentiality between the relativized NP and any NP of the CC. (Cf. further Hettrich 1988 with references and Hock 1989d.) Passages like these tend to be difficult to translate. In many multiple-headed RCs, such as (7a), it is possible to render one of the two RPS as an indefinite pronoun; and this has been claimed to be the general inter pretation for Sanskrit structures of this type; cf. e.g. Andrews. But in other cases e.g. (7b) and (7c), such a translation is not appropriate. It is therefore unlikely

Dasgupta (1980) objects to a conjoined analysis of relative-correlatives with the following arguments: (i) RCs that precede CCs cannot be followed by

The third question concerns the user and uses. Research on the prag- matics of English — that is, on the variables of pragmatic success and failure in world Englishes — is basically determined in terms of (a) the formal charac- teristics of the code or its varieties; (b) the participants in an interaction; and (c) the 'effective results’ of verbal communication. Linguistic encounters in the Outer Circle are primarily viewed with reference to variables of the Inner Circle.

In other words, the question of the whole semiotic system is involved here. And, more important, in answering questions about Englishes across cultures, we get only glimpses of truth. True, these glimpses are tantalizing, but they do not present the whole truth about the users and uses of English. And here, once more, | must go back to Dwight Bolinger’s inspiring Presidential Address io the Linguistic Society of America (1973), in which, with reference to a different context, he says ‘Truth is a linguistic question because communication is impossible without it.’ (1973:549) We, as applied linguistics, cannot justifiably be just ‘social sideliners’. And if | may continue with Bolinger’s quote, the issue becomes more complex, since as he aptly warns us, ‘a taste of truth is like 2 facto of blond’

THE CONTRIBUTION OF AFRICAN LINGUISTICS TO LINGUISTIC THEORY DEPARTMENT OF LINGUISTICS, UNIVERSITY OF ILLINOIS URBANA, ILLINOIS 61801

n.'a tall, very straight palm tree with a smooth trunk and sometimes no fronds

These facts can be rearranged into what can be presumed to represent a diachronic process. A verb is reduplicated for emphasis (cf. the morphological reduplication used to convey plurality). For greater emphasis the second part may be formally altered, either prosodically, with extra-high tones, or segmentally, e.g., by changing a vowel. This step is not absolutely necessary as shown by the ideophones that are segmentally identical to the verbs from which they arise. This item is then reanalyzed as a separate element. A schematic representation of the different possibilities, all attested in Kisi, appears below. In all cases there are formal and semantic similarities between the forms at each stage. The stages are arranged in the order in which they may have occurred. Stage one thus represents the earliest stage and the fifth stage a possible final stage. An actual example from Kisi follows.

there is a process by which onomatopoeic forms become ideophones and even verbs, as has been noticed by others, e.g., Alexandre (1966:24). Some examples of onomatopoeic ideophones and cognate forms are given below.

In (19), the final syllable of the utterance is marked extrametrical by rule (16) and the grid-building rules in (14) apply. The Right End Rule (14c), interpretec according to Convention (17b), adds a third level beat to the penult and the Well-Formedness Condition (18) fills in a second level beat. The derivatio: continues as in (15), with the intonational high tone associating first to the initia tone of the utterance and then spreading to the accented position, deriving the correct tone pattern.

The application of tone shift (20a, b) is illustrated by the derivation of (1a), given in (21):

In (27a), the high tone of okui:ga may spread since that word is in phrase- medial position, but the high tone of jind6Bo may not spread to the extratonal phrase-final syllable. In (27b), too, only the high tone of okui:ga may spread since that word is in phrase-medial position, but the high tone of jind6Bo may not spread, because it is blocked by the phrase-final low tone.

The argument is that this H links to the penultimate vowel because penultimate position is accented, i.e., metrically strong. Other Bantu languages show attraction to a metrically strong position. The nature of this attraction can be LINKING, SHIFTING, or SPREADING of a tone (usually H, but also potentially L, as in Haya (Byarushengo, Hyman and Tenenbaum 1976)). While it is possible to formalize a rule referring to a position relative to a right (or left) bracket or word boundary, rather than referring to a metrical accent, there are several reasons listed in (9) to think that metrical structure is the proper descriptive device.

However, in their survey of Dahl's Law in a number of Kenyan languages, Dav and Nurse (1982) found multiple applications such as in (30b) and no evidenc [quote] ‘of any...convergence on an obligatory rule giving only alternatin outputs’ (p.174) as in (28c). In other words, there have been no segmente correlates to the alternating H tones reported in Bantu.15 While this is not. requirement, the crucial absence of a supporting segmental evidence of the so produced by Paulian for Kukuya, for instance, leads me to think that direc assignment of H tone is just as good as systems with metrical heads. There is much more to be said about Kirundi and Kinyarwanda—in fact monographs can and have been written on the subject. | want only to say two things. First, we have seen that the metrical approach deals clumsily wit! Kikuria and Makua, and in fact, with most of what Odden (1988) call: ‘predictable tone’ in Bantu. It is easy to imagine how metrical theory could be elaborated to count up to the 5th position (initial syllable extrametrical - construction of cola), or, in mirror-image fashion, the 5th position from the end Other equally odd calculations are possible from the overly powerful metrica model. The second point is that the accents that are built for alternating H ton systems have no other purpose: like the penultimate accent, these accent: exist for the sole purpose of placing H tones—there is nothing segmental tha corresponds to a strong vowel position vs. a weak one. For example, a simila stem and prestem environment is involved in the dissimilatory process know: as Dahl's Law, schematized in (30a).

Le kpokolo posséde un systéme vocalique de surface qui comprend 13 voyelles :7 voyelles rétractées ( [ - ATR ] )? et 6 voyelles avancées ({ + ATR] ). En outre, la présence de voyelles centrales est a signaler. || s'agit, en effet, d'un fait assez peu courant dans les langues kru, et qui présente un certain intérét dans l'analyse de la sélection des classes que nous suggérons dans la section 4. Pour situer le lecteur, la voyelle transcrite par le signe [ 4 ] représente une voyelle haute rétractée d’arriére non arrondie. La voyelle correspondante [+ ATR ] est représentée par le [ 4 ]. La voyelle représentée par le chiffre 3 est un schwa[- ATR]. La version [ + ATR ] de cette voyelle est transcrite par [ 6 ]. Par convention, nous représentons les voyelles [ - ATR ] par des capitales et les voyelles [ + ATR ] par des minuscules. Par exemple, le [ I ] représente le iota, cest-a-dire, le [i] relaché. Le [ E ] représente le [ € ], c’est-a-dire le son que l'on retrouve par exemple dans le mot frangais p[é]re, etc. En (1), nous présentons le systéme vocalique du kpokolo.

Timmons & Dunn: Sélection morphophonologique des classes en kpokolo

Enfin, les noms appartenant a la classe / O/ acceptent n'importe quelle voyelle périphérique en finale. Par ailleurs, il est A noter qu’aucun nom en kpokolo ne se termine par une voyelle centrale. Etant donné que I’on veut préter ici a la voyelle finale du nom une fonction morphologique de classement, il serait intéressant de faire découler ces contraintes de notre définition formelle des classes phonologiques et de leur mode de sélection. Le tableau (7) récapitule les facteurs sémantique et phonologique qui priment dans le classement des nominaux en kpokolo.

(10) Représentation phonologique du kpokolo En (10a et b), I’élément souligné agit comme téte de l’expressior phonologique.2 La notion de téte d'une expression est utilisée dans le calcu matriciel et permet de dériver la forme phonétique des expressions phonologiques. Une expression consiste en une téte et un opérateur. Pa convention, la téte est soulignée et placée a la droite de l'opérateur.1° Le caicu d'une expression consiste 4 assigner la valeur du trait chaud de l'opérateur at méme trait de la téte, ainsi, l'expression ( A + U) dont la téte est U se calcule

Nous sommes maintenant en mesure de définir formellement la ‘ressemblance phonologique’ qui détermine |’appartenance a une classe, de méme que les classes elles-mémes en kpokolo. Sur la base de ce que |’on vient de présenter, on peut affirmer qu’il existe trois classes phonologiques qui correspondent aux primitifs de la théorie des éléments de KLV, c’est-a-dire, I, U, A. Un nom se terminant par une voyelle dont la téte est un de ces trois éléments appartiendra a la classe correspondante. Ainsi, la sélection de la classe en kpokolo est fonction de lidentité de la téte de la derniére voyelle du nom avec celle du marqueur de classe (de la classe elle-méme) (cf. 12 a fa page suivante).

En (14), on constate que le marqueur d’accord du pluriel est bel et bien [I pour l'ensemble des classes nominales.

St92 V.19 1989 cop. 2 CENTRAL CIRCULATION AND BOOKSTACKS The person borrowing this material is responsible for its renewal or return before the Latest Date stamped below. You may be charged a minimum fee of $75.00 for each non-returned or lost item. Theft, mutilation, or defacement of library materials causes for student disciplinary action. All materials can be owned by th* University of Illinois Library are the property of the State and are protected by of Illinois Law and Article 16B of Illinois Criminal Protedur«. TO RENEW, CALL (217) University of Illinois Library at DEC When 333-8400. Urbana-Champaign 1 1 200) renewing by phone, write new below previous due date. clue date L162 PAPERS IN GENERAL LIN^^mrrCS Preface rt Harbir arora and K. reanalysis: The V. " O Ql^^' Subbarao: Con\W|ence and case of so in Dakhini "" " ^ ^. uj: Camille Bundrick: An interference-baSfe^j^ft&tmt of relative which and that syntagtk»=' J^p^\Gr. 1 restrictive 19 Farida Cassimjee and Charles W. Kisserberth: Shingazidja nominal accent 33 the representation of Kejia diphthongs 63 Raung-ftj Chung: On Dale Gerdemann: Restriction as a means of optimizing 81 unification parsing Hans Henrich Hock: Conjoined we stand: Theoretical implications of Sanskrit relative structures Braj B. Kachru: World Yamuna Kachru: Englishes and applied linguistics Corpus planning for modernization: and Englishization of Hindi Sanskritization 93 127 153 SQUIB Rakesh Mohan Bhatt: Good mixes and odd mixes: Implications for the bilingual's grammar 165 REVIEWS Agnihotri (1987). Crisis of identity: Sikhs in England. (Jean Aitchison) Tej K. Bhatia (1987). A history of the Hindi grammatical tradition. (Rajeshwari Pandharipande) Dick Chambedain and Robert Baumgardner, eds. (1988). ESP in the classroom: Practice and evaluation. Rama Kant ELT Documents 28. (Numa Markee) Sumitra Katre (1987). Astadhyayl of Panini. (Texas Linguistic Series.) (Ladislav Zgusla) 1 1 69 173 181 187 Department of Linguistics University of Illinois . STUDIES IN THE LINGUISTIC SCIENCES PUBLICATION OF THE DEPARTMENT OF LINGUISTICS COLLEGE OF LIBERAL ARTS AND SCIENCES UNIVERSITY OF ILLINOIS AT URBANA-CHAMPAIGN EDITOR: Hans Henrich Hock EDITORIAL BOARD: Eyamba M. Green, Erhard W. Kachru, Michael Howard J. G. Bokamba, Chin-chuan Cheng, Georgia Hans Henrich Hock, Braj B. Kachru, Yamuna Kenstowicz, Chin-W. Kim, Charies W. Kisseberth, Hinrichs, Maclay, Jerry L. Morgan, Rajeshwari Pandharipande, and Ladislav Zgusta. AIM: SLS is intended as a forum for the presentation of the latest original research by the faculty and especially students of the Department of Linguistics, University of Illinois, Urbana-Champaign. Invited papers by scholars not associated with the University of Illinois will also be included. SPECIAL ISSUES: Since its inception to restricted, specialized topics. on the back A SLS has devoted one complete list issue each year of such special issues is given cover. BOOKS FOR REVIEW: Review copies of books may be sent to the Editor, Studies in the Linguistic Sciences, Department of Linguistics, University of lUinios, 707 S. Mathews, Urbana, IlUnois 61801. SUBSCRIPTION: There will be two issues during the academic year. for subscriptions should be addressed to SLS Linguistics, 4088 Foreign Languages Building, 707 of lUinois, Urbana, Illinois 6 1 80 1 UPCOMING "African ISSUES: Vol. Linguistics, 11"; Vol. S. — "African 20:2 — "Special Anniversary 19:2 Price: Requests Department of Mathews, University Subscriptions, Linguistics, I"; Vol. 20:1 $7.50 (per issue) Issue." — STUDIES IN THE LINGUISTIC SCIENCES Papers In General Linguistics EDITOR Hans Henrich Hock VOLUME 19, SPRING DEPARTMENT OF NUMBER 1 1989 LINGUISTICS, UNIVERSITY URBANA, ILLINOIS 61801 OF ILLINOIS 9 CONTENTS Preface v Harbir Arora and K.V. Subbarao (University of Delhi): and syntactic Camille Bundrick: reanalysis: The case so of An inference-based account in Convergence Dal<khini of restrictive relative which and that 1 Farida Cassimjee and Charles W. Kisseberth: Shingazidja nominal 33 accent Raung-fu Chung: On the representation of Kejia diphthongs Dale Gerdemann: Restriction as a means parsing Hans Henrich Hock: Conjoined we 81 stand: Theoretical implications of 93 World Englishes and applied Yamuna Kachru: Corpus planning and Englishization of Hindi 63 of optimizing unification Sanskrit relative structures Braj B. Kachru: 1 for 127 linguistics modernization: Sanskritization 153 Squib Rakesh Mohan bilingual's Good mixes and odd grammar Bhatt: mixes: Implications for the 165 Reviews Rama Kant Agnihotri (1987). Crisis of (Jean Aitchison, London School Tej K. Bhatia (1987). A identity: of Sikhs in England. Economics) history of the Hindi 169 grammatical tradition (Rajeshwari Pandharipande) Dick Chamberlain and Robert Baumgardner, eds. (1988). ESP in the classroom: Practice and evaluation. ELT Documents 128. 173 (Numa Markee, Division of English as an International Language) Sumitra M. Katre (1987). AstadhyayFof Panini. (Texas Linguistic Series.) (Ladislav Zgusta) 181 187 Preface With the present issue of Studies in the Linguistic Sciences, the change in format and production announced in the last issue (Vol. 18, No. 2) has nearly been completed: All contributions have been produced on the computer, and except for one paper, all of them have been printed on the Apple LaserWriter, from documents composed in Microsoft Word and using Apple's 'Helvetica' as base font. the present issue breaks with past tradition by featuring several The editors intend to continue including reviews, review articles, and squibs in future general issues, in addition to regular articles, as well as short book notices. In addition, reviews, as well as a 'squib'. Regrettably, for various reasons which include the changes just mentioned, the present issue appears with almost one year's delay. We hope to be back to our regular publication schedule with Volume 20. Volume 19:2 and 20:1 will be special issues, featuring papers presented at the Twentieth Annual Conference on African Linguistics, held at the University of Illinois in April 1989. Volume 20:2 will likewise be a special issue, celebrating the twenty-fifth anniversary of the Department of Linguistics. would thank the following Department of Linguistics submitted papers: Chin-Chuan Cheng, Georgia Green, Yamuna Kachru, Michael Kenstowicz, and Charles W. Kisseberth. The editors also appreciate support from the College of Liberal Arts and Sciences toward publishing this issue, and technical support from the Language Learning Before concluding, faculty members I like to for refereeing Laboratory. Last, but not least, have the pleasant duty of thanking Beth Creek, Corinne Saldeen, Eileen Sutton, and Lieve van de Walle of our Department for I their support in preparing this issue. January 1990 Hans Henrich Hock (Editor) the Linguistic Sciences Studies in Volume 19, Number 1, Spring 1989 CONVERGENCE AND SYNTACTIC REANALYSIS: SO IN DAKKHINI* THE CASE OF Harbir Arora and K.V. Subbarao (University of Delhi) This paper argues that the archaic Hindi-Urdu correlative marker so has been reanalyzed in Dakkhini Hindi-Urdu to perform an entirely new set of syntactic functions, such as adjectivalizer in prenominal and predicate position, as well as with conjunctive participles and negative relative participles (whether prenominal or predicative), linker in negative verbal participles and reason adverbial clauses, and complementizer. As a consequence, the functions that so performs in Dakkhini are entirely distinct from those of so in Hindi-Urdu, and this difference in most cases is due to convergence with Telugu, a Dravidian language. We shall finally provide a historical account of the syntactic development of so, based on Dakkhini texts from the fourteenth century to the present. 1. Dakkhini Hindi-Urdu (hereafter Dakkhini) Hindi-Urdu'' (an Indo-Aryan language) used in is a transplanted variety of the southern parts of India where Dravidian languages are spoken. Dakkhini has been in intimate contact with Dravidian languages for about five centuries. As a result of this prolonged contact Dakkhini has acquired a number of Dravidian syntactic traits. This paper aims to study the syntactic nature of so in Dakkhini. so, which a correlative marker in Hindi-Urdu and Punjabi, has been reanalysed in Dakkhini to perform an entirely new set of syntactic functions, such as prenominal adjectivalizer, adjectivalizer in predicate position, adjectivalizer with conjunctive participles and negative relative participles (prenominal as well as predicative), linker in negative verbal participles, linker in reason adverbial clauses, and complementizer. is We show paper that the functions that so performs in Dakkhini Hindi-Urdu and that this difference in most cases is due to syntactic convergence with Telugu, a Dravidian language. We shall argue that the use of so to perform so many varied functions repre- shall in this are entirely distinct from those of so in Studies in the Linguistic Sciences 19:1 (Spring 1989) sents the optimal utilization of a grammatical category. The reassignment of functions of so in Dakkhini, we claim, shows that in syntactic reanalysis there need not necessarily be any functional commonality between particular lexical items of the source and borrowing languages. We shall further show that the occurrence of so with predicative adjectives is due to analogical extension from the prenominal position to the predicate position. We shall finally provide a historical account of the development of the functions of so, taking into consideration data from Dakkhini texts from the fourteenth century onwards. Indo-Aryan languages such as Hindi-Urdu and Punjabi have a typconstruction, in which the clause containing the relative pronoun precedes the 'correlative in the main clause' (Masica, 1976:25), the correlative being the pronominal form of the coreferential noun phrase. HindiUrdu has two correlative markers, vah/ve and so, and Punjabi has o and so. The forms vah 'he, she, it' and ve 'they' are productively used in present-day Hindi-Urdu (cf. (1) below), whereas so 'he, she, it; they' occurs in idioms and proverbs (as in (2) below). It thus is no longer productive in present-day HindiUrdu. The following sentences from Hindi-Urdu (H-U) and Punjabi (P) are 2.1. ical relative-correlative illustrative. (1) Correlative pronouns are H-U: (2) H-U: (3) P: (4) P: in boldface. mehnat kartaa jo hai vah tarakkii kartaa hai he progress does whoever works hard 'Whoever works hard, prospers.' khotaa hai sotaa hai so jo whoever sleeps he loses 'Whoever sleeps, loses.' tarakkii kardaa menat kardaa ai o jo he progress does whoever works hard 'Whoever works hard, prospers.' karegaa so paregaa jo he will pay whoever will do 'Whoever will do, will pay.' (literal) ai 'As you sow, so shall you reap.' 2.2. Kachru (1973, 1978, 1986) claims that so in Dakkhini is a correlative marker, whereas Mohiddin (1980) treats it as a participial marker. We will argue that Dakkhini (D) so functions as an adjectivalizer in modifying constructions. Let us consider sentences (5) alizer in (5) D: kal (6) in which so occurs as an adjectiv- usku puucho so him ask ADJR person who came yesterday.' uno mereku bhaaii aaye so aaye yesterday 'Ask the (6) and prenominal position. D: kal yesterday come+PERF come+PERF ADJR he to me honaa be 'The one who came yesterday is my brother.' brother Arora The & Subbarao: Convergence and syntactic reanalysis following evidence can be cited for treating so as an 3 adjectlvallzer in Dakkhini. 2.2.1. Notice that so precedes the head NP (a pronoun in this case) usku and uno In sentences (5) and (6) respectively. Further, when such sentences as (5) and (6) are uttered, there is no pause between the marker so and the following head NP. A potential pause can occur only after the head NP, viz. usku or uno in (5) and (6). (It is a pan-Indian pattern, that a pause cannot occur between a phrasal modifier and its head NP.) This point establishes that so cannot be treated separately from the head NP and that so and the head NP together form a single unit. Dakkhini an expression of the type (7) below is permodern South Asian languages, however, a correlative pronoun and a head NP containing its own demonstrative pronoun do not occur in sequence, one immediately following the other. If we treated so as a correlative prounoun, we would be forced to claim that Dakkhini exhibits radically different behavior. Note further that fectly grammatical. (7) D: In in (other) aaye so Studies in the Linguistic Sciences 19:1 (Spring 1989) Now, is the if same so were a correlative two questions would arise: First, both singular and plural? Second, correlative marker, marker used in why why does the so-called verb form not exhibit agreement with its subject as it usually does in Dakkhini, and why does the form of the verb instead always remain in the (masculine singular) oblique? One plausible explanation would lie in assuming influence from Telugu. For in Telugu, neither the participle nor the adjective exhibits any agreement with the noun it modifies. The invariant Dakkhini participle might thus be claimed to have adopted the Telugu pattern of non-agreement. A second possible explanation is that the oblique form of the verbal adjective in sentences of the type (8) is formed on the analogy of Dakkhini participial adverbials, which are always in the oblique (marked by the suffix -e.). Given the strong evidence for Telugu influence in other areas of the syntax of so, the former explanation appears to be the more likely one. 2.2.3. The next argument for treating so as an adjectivalizer derives from A noun phrase containing a correlative pronoun can in HindiUrdu be followed by any postposition, marking accusative, dative, or any other oblique case, whereas the so of Dakkhini cannot if it occurs alone. This means the following fact: so cannot directly bear any grammatical relation with another constituent in a sentence. The following examples are illustrative. (Example (10c) illustrates that the combination correlative pronoun + postposition is grammatical in HindiUrdu. Note however that in Hindi-Urdu a full relative clause has to precede the that correlative pronoun.) (10) Arora (b) & Subbarao: Convergence and syntactic reanalysis *tarkaarii kaatte vegetable cut+IMPF haat gayaa kat hand got 5 so se ADJR with cut 'My hand got cut by the knife with which the vegetables are cut." (13) D: (a) vaa se there from so aaye come+PERF ADJR admii kaa man of GEN naam name (b) kyaa what ai ? is 'What is the name of that person who *vaa se aaye so there from come+PERF ADJR ai ? naam kyaa name what came from there?' kaa of is 2.2.4, Further, if so were a correlative pronoun, then there should be an antecedent relative clause containing a relative pronoun (RP), with or without nominal head. The ungrammaticality of the (b) versions in the following examples demonstrates that, unlike in Hindi-Urdu (for which see for instance (14c)), there cannot be an antecedent relative clause. Therefore, so cannot be treated as a correlative pronoun. (14a) so Arora & Subbarao: 7 Convergence and syntactic reanalysis Dakkhini speakers could then analogically extend the use of so to the predicate position, as in sentences (17) and (18) above, where as a consequence the combination of participle plus so comes to parallel the combination of participle plus huaa of the earlier type (19) and (20) which, again, survives in present-day Hindi-Urdu. participial however, this analogical extension was limited to perfect Dakkhini does not allow so to be used with imperfect relative constructions in the predicate position.3 The following ungrammatical sentence is illustrative. Interestingly, participles: so *baccaa jaate go+IMPF ADJR boy The boy is going.' (23) D: We how are not quite sure ai is Our guess to explain this limitation. limitation is linked to the fact that Hindi-Urdu, too, does as is shown by the ungrammaticality have retained a constraint of Hindi-Urdu. ticiples in the predicate position, That is, Dakkhini (24) H-U: 2.2.7. seems to *baccaa boy jaataa it huaa go+IMPF PPLE is that the of (24). hai is provides strong arguments against a correlative marker and for the hypothesis The evidence presented so the assumption that Dakkhini so that is not permit imperfect par- far functions as an adjectivalizer. 3. In this section, we will discuss some of the other functions performed by so in Dakkhini. In 3.1 we show how the adjectivalizer so can be used to convert a conjunctive participle into a modifier. The subsequent sections discuss the role of so in reason clauses (3.2), negative relative participles (3.3), negative verbal adverbials (3.4), and complemention (3.5). Such a variety of functions indicates that a lexical item indigenous to the source language may be exploited to perform a number of new syntactic functions not found in the source language. Such an optimal utilization is a result of syntactic reanalysis. 3.1. A Dakkhini conjunctive participle of the type V-Zce can be made into a nominal modifier by the addition of the adjectivalizer so; of. the examples below. (In It should be emphasized that the presence of a tense marker is obligatory. the following examples, the conjunctive participle, the tense marker, and so are in boldface.) me aa-ke hai so (25) D: ghar (26) D: ADJR come is The people who have come home de-ke usku raam house in Ram he+Dat paisaa abbii talaak money until 'Ram (vo) having having given naiT now did not yet get the not money which he gave to him.' Studies in the Linguistic Sciences 19:1 (Spring 1989) Dakkhini, just as in Telugu, an adverbial of reason, time, manner, can be modified by a participle. Examples of so occurring as an adjectivalizer in reason clauses are given in (27) and (28). (The reason adverb and so are in boldface.) 3.2. In or quantity usku tum bulaaye so it+DAT (reason) you call+PERF ADJR came because you called me.' usku so aap jaldii aaye it+DAT you soon come+PERF ADJR (27) D: uu have come aayii 'I (28) D: puuchrii am uij asking (reason) 'I am asking you because you came early.' Note that a pause occurs after usku and not after so, just as we observed in section 2.2.1 above regarding sentences of the type (5) and (6). The corresponding Telugu (T) sentences are worth noticing, in which the adjectivalizer -a occurs. anduwalla/anduku cepp-in-a say+PERF+ADJR because of that miiru (29) T: you occinaa came (reason) 'I (30) T: came because you miiru tondaragaa you quickly waadiki koopam called me.' anduku come+PERF+ADJR because wacc-in-a came he+DAT anger 'He got angry because you Examples time, (31) - manner, or quantity (31) D: is came quickly.' Dakkhini sentences (33) illustrate (reason) occindi in which an adverbial of modified by an expression marked by so. aap bulaaye so jab you call+PERF ADJR ADV uu aatii (time) will come when you call me.' vaisaa aap bole so ADV (manner) ADJR you say+PERF will come 'I (32) D: 'I (33) D: will do as you aap bole you say+PERF uu do say.' (so) uttaa ADJR ADV that tnat 'I kartii will have given as much as you asked uu have given dii (quantity) much mucn me to give.' reason clauses (as in (27) and (28)) modifies a third person pronominal followed by a reason marker in the same way as it modifies the adverb of time in (31), adverb of manner in (32), or adverb of quantity in (33). This modification of adverbials we attribute to Telugu influence, whose corresponding structures are exemplified in (34) - (36). Notice that so in Arora & Subbarao: miiru (34) T: you 'I (35) T: will jeppin-a-tia say+PERF+ADJR+ADV will do as you (time) ostaa come jeestaa miiru miiru (36) T: appu^u pilicin-a call+PERF+ADJR ADV come when you call me.' you 'I 9 Convergence and syntactic reanalysis (manner) will do say.' iccinaa jeppin-a-anta say+PERF+ADJR ADV (quantity) have given you have given as much as you asked me to give.' 'I 3.3. so functions as an adjectivaiizer also with negative relative participles, both in prenominal and in predicate position. The following examples are illustrative. (The negative relative is in boldface). maf kar detii uu kaam so tum naiT kare will do work you NEG do+PERF ADJR will do the work which you did not do.' (Prenominal) ai so nalT aaye uno yaa paile be NEG come+PERF ADJR he here before maalum paraa? kaise aapku boike came to know COMP you DAT how 'How did you come to know that he had never come here (37) D: I 'I (38) D: before?' (Predicative) Another function of so is that as a linker with the main clause; cf. the following examples. 3.4. (39) D: (a) (b) (40) D: (b) maf naiT aaye of negative adverbial clauses ^ Studies in the Linguistic Sciences 19:1 (Spring 1989) 10 neenu (41) T: raakun^laa nuvvu yetlaa how you come NEG ADV PPLE not having I 'How would you go unless come?' raamudu naaku jeppakun^iaa Ram l+DAT without telling pootaau? go will I (42) T: poyyindu has gone welJJ NEG ADV PPLE 'Ram went away without telling miiru jeyyani pani (43) T: you me." work not doing neenu jeesinaa I did NEG RELPPLE did the 'I work which you did not do.' The above sentences indicate (i) that in Telugu, the form of negative verbal from that of negative relative participles, and (ii) that no adjectivalizer occurs in such constructions, whereas in Dakkhini, the same verb form is used in negative relative participles (cf. (37)) and in negative adverbial participles (cf. (39) and (40)), and the adjectivalizer so occurs in both participles of is different these constructions. 3.5. Dakkhini so is also used as a complementizer. This use as complementizer is found with verbs such as maalum honaa 'to come to be known', bataana 'to tell', dikhnaa 'to appear', if and only if the matrix sentence is either a question or a negative statement. (44) D: baalamma gaye so Balamma go+PERF COMP do not know that Balamma has gone.' tumku janaanaa ai so ye mereku l+DAT naiTmaalum NEG known 'I (45) D: you DAT dikhraa is this ladies' place is COMP naiT NEG kyaa ? Q marker seen you know 'Don't that this is a place exclusively meant for ladies?' 3.6. To sum up we have shown that so in Dakkhini so has been reanalysed so as to be new functions. This reanalysis has resulted in the the discussion so functions as an adjectivalizer. able to perform a variety of maximal In far, addition, utilization of this lexical item. relative participles and as reason clauses, this reanalyis results from Telugu influence. The use of negative participles, too, can be attributed to Telugu influence, though formally, the formation of such participles is more similar to the pattern of HindiUrdu. In a most cases, such as the use with prenominal linker in We have argued that the use of so with participles in predicate position is an example of analogical extension. Finally, the assignment of many new functions to this single lexical item clearly shows that there need not be any 1 Arora identity & Subbarao: between the functions Convergence and syntactic reanalysis we in the source contact variety. performed by the item originally language and the functions performed by 1 in it the new account of the development from Dakkhini texts from the fourteenth century onwards. We observe that only some of the present-day functions of so were found in the older stages of Dakkhini (from the fourteenth to eighteenth century). 4. In this section, shall provide a historical of the functions of so, taking into consideration data The 4.1. Old Dakkhini (OD) attestation of a relative-correlative conone of present-day Hindi-Urdu is found in the works of (1388-1423 A.D.) (The relative (RP) and correlative pronouns first struction similar to the Banda Nawaz (CP) are (46) in boldface.) OD: jo kahyaa hai so uno karnaa RP said is CP he do-i-INF 'He should do whatever is said.' Note that as in standard Hindi-Urdu, the relative marker jo and the correlative marker so both occur in sentence (46), and the relative clause jo kahyaa hai precedes the correlative clause so uno karnaa. The modern standard Hindi-Urdu equivalent of (46) is given below. (47) H-U kahaa gayaa hai has been said jo RP vah usko CP he DAT karnaa hai do+lNF is Structures of this sort suggest that Dakkhini started out with relative clause same type as found in modern Hindi-Urdu as well as in the structures of the majority of other Indo-Aryan languages. 4.2. Interestingly, the works of Banda Nawaz additionally contain relative constructions with relative clauses (introduced by relative pronouns) followed by correlative clauses with a sequence of two correlative pronouns {so followed by are (v)o). in Sentences (48), (49), (50) are illustrative. (The correlative pronouns boldface). (48) OD: koii gujaryaa so CP whoever passed maraa kar baaje je some after dying vo marne ke aage CP before death muhakikkaa bolte hai philosophers say. 'Whoever has passed (these stages) and dies before death, he (49) OD: jis ke is called a philosopher.' aastin whose me paike calaa sleeve in hor gussaa left and anger vahaa caar the there four were who had a patch in the sleeve went and who were not angry were four." "The one others the the his Studies in the Linguistic Sciences 19:1 (Spring 1989) 12 (50) OD. bakaa so vo haq taala kaa jo vajuud RP The existence left is CP CP God's only existence that remains is that of God.' hai hai is appears that the occurence of two correlative pronouns following a clause reflects a transitional stage. Such sequences of two correlative pronouns are not permitted in modern Dakkhini or in Hindi-Urdu. The reason for claiming that sentences such as (48), (49), and (50) reflect a transitional stage is that there are sentences such as (51), also from Banda Nawaz, in which the relative pronoun is absent and only the two correlatives occur. It relative (51) OD: beje ketak so many vaajib ai essential is hai so are CP CP 'There are so 4.3. in The the works of (52) OD: first clear examples many of things which samjhnaa to need understand to be understood.' so as an adjectivalizer are likewise found Banda Nawaz, such as bhaaii vo ciij things (52) below. Arora & Subbarao: Convergence and syntactic reanalysis The one who reminds you of himself shows 13 his own existence.' 4.5. Another usage of so appears to be limited to Old Dakkhini. This is its combination with a following negative which imparts the meaning 'no sooner than' to a preceding participial expression. We have found this use only in the texts of Aminuddin Ala (1570); cf. Iqbal Ahmed 1986, Mohammad 1988. (55) OD: apnii one's umr own age malbub me Malbub in laahuut kate Lahut is me hii mulk naasut EMPH country Nasut yaa jabrut me or Jabrut in said in yaa or c gujar kar EMPH having spent so mukaam me ADJR place in poce gayaa so naiT uske tafsaalik reached + no sooonerthan his/him true believer kahaajaayegaa be said will 'In one's own life he will pass through the stages of No sooner than reaching he will be called a true believer.' 'Nasut', 'Malbub', or 'Jabrut'. the stage called 'Lahut', the above sentence, so occurs twice, in two different functions: In the phrase kate so mukaam 'the place which is called ...', it has its ordinary use as an adjectivalizer. However, in poce gayaa so na/T it is used in the sense of 'no sooner than'. As noted earlier, this use is not found in later Dakkhini, including In the present-day language. 4.6. In modern Dakkhini, the participle modifying a noun invariably precedes it, whereas when used as a complementizer, the combination of so plus verb follows the noun (cf. section 3.5 for the latter pattern). For convenience we provide the following illustrative examples from modern Dakkhini. (56) D: (57) D: hue SO be+PERF 'Tell me the ADJR baat matter 'Inform thing that you baat matter so be+PERF COMP of me bataao tell have discussed.' hue me mere ku to mere ku tome bataao tell what you have discussed.' combination of participle plus so, even that noun; cf. (58) which comes from Kadri (1750-1820); cf. Iqbal Ahmed 1986. Interestingly, in old Dakkhini the when used as a noun modifier, the writings of Sayyad Examples (58) of this type, OD: may follow Mohammed however, are quite totaa rare. tumaam ahvaal whole incident khajastaa kaa kahaa parrot Khajasta to told havaa so happened+PERF ADJR 14 Studies in the Linguistic Sciences 19:1 (Spring 1989) The parrot narrated the whole incident that had happened to Khajasta.' 4.7. In the works of Wajhi (1635), so followed by an otherwise unmarked is used as the object of verbs of saying, such as kahnaa; cf. complement clause (59). This use of so (59) OD: is not found amaa isk in present-day Dakkhini. Arora & Subbarao: 15 Convergence and syntactic reanalysis In addition, Old Dakkhini has the following functions which modern Dakkhini does not have: (i) The use of so as a correlative pronoun and its ability to be directly followed by another correlative; (ii) the employment of so as an agentive marker; (iii) the use of so plus complement clause as the object of verbs of saying; and (iv) the ability of so to be used as a full-fledged resumptive pronoun. Moreover, so as an adjectivalizer can precede as well as follow the head in Old Dakkhini. In present-day Dakkhini, on the other hand, so must precede the head noun when used as an lows if functions as a complementizer. adjectivalizer, while it obligatorily fol- it As in section 3 has shown, there Is an almost one-to-one the functions of present-day Dakkhini so and its Telugu Interestingly, however, the functions of so that are found in Old the discussion correspondence counterpart(s). in Dakkhini but are absent in the modern language have no such parallels Telugu. This, we think, deserves an explanation. in appears that after so had been reanalysed as an adjectivalizer in Old its use was extended to a variety of new structures, such as agentive constructions and complements of verb of saying. However, being in intensive bilingual contact with Telugu and converging with it in its overall structure, Dakkhini sooner or later eliminated those innovations which had no counterIt Dakkhini, parts in that language. in Dakkhini not only provides a case of extreme conmore specifically, shows how innovations specific to the converging variety of a language (and not shared by other varieties of that language) can come to be abandoned under the influence of the contact language. Thus, the study of so vergence but, NOTES *Earlier versions of this paper were presented at the 1986 South Asian Languages Analysis Roundtable, University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign, and at the Department of Linguistics, University of Wisconsin at Madison (1986). We are grateful to Yamuna Kachru, M. K. Verma, and especially Hans Henrich Hock for valuable suggestions and comments. Thanks are also due to Ramakant Agnihotri for helpful suggestions. The abbreviations used ADJR ADV - in this adjectivalizer adverb COMP - complementizer OP - correlative pronoun - D Dakkhini DAT dative - - paper are as follows: EMPH EXPL GEN - - - emphatic. expletive genitive H-U - Hindi-Urdu IMPF - imperfect INST - instrumental 16 Studies in the Linguistic Sciences 19:1 (Spring 1989) LOG NEG OD P - - locative PPLE negative PROG - RP Old Dakkhini PERF - - progressive relative pronoun T - Telugu Punjabi - - participle - perlect "From the originate from written records available, it appears that Dakkhini did not a single source language. According to Chatterji (1963:142), and associates speakwent to Central and South India, and carved out Muslim Kingdoms for themselves settling down among Marathas (Indo-Aryan), Kannadigas and Telugus (Dravidian). The dialects they took with them supplied the basis of a literary speech they developed from the fifteenth century. It was known as Dakkhini or the southern speech.' 'North Indian Muslims with Hindu allies ing dialects of western Hindi (Indo-Aryan), Punjabi (Indo-Aryan) 2|t should be mentioned here that simple adjectives For example in Dakkhini agree with the noun that they modify. acchaa acche baccaa bacce acchii baccii/bacciyaa 'good boy' 'good boys' 'good girl/girls' ^Notice that the imperfect verbal participle followed by the verb 'be' in its imperfect form is permitted in the predicate position in Dakkhini on the pattern of Telugu. The following sentences are (i) illustrative. ai karte ue kaam morning since work do IMPF PPLE is 'Ramayya has been working since the morning.' ceestuu unnaadu raamayyaa poddutanunci pani has been doing morning since work Ramayya 'Ramayya has been working since the morning.' raamayyaa D: subbo se Ramayya (ii) T: But note that an imperfect relative participle cannot occur in the predicate 'be', as illustrated by the ungrammaticality of example (23), repeated below for convenience. position without the verb (iii) so *baccaa jaate go+IMPF ADJR boy 'The boy is going.' D: '*The various negative participles (i) D: naiT NEG (ii) D: aaye in ai is Dakkhini are as follows: so admii ADJR man come PERF 'The man who did did not come ..." admii naiT aate so man come IMPERF ADJR NEG The man who does not come ...' admii Studies in the Linguistic Sciences 19:1 (Spring 1989) 18 1635. Sabras, ed. Shree Ram Sharma. Hyderabad: Dakkhini Hindi Prakashan Samiti. ZORE, S. M. Quadari. Depot. 1960. Hindustani lisaniyat. Lucknow: Naseem Book ) the Linguistic Sciences Studies in Volume 19, Number 1, Spring 1989 AN INFERENCE-BASED ACCOUNT OF RESTRICTIVE RELATIVE WHICH AND THAT Camille Bundrick Although the restrictive relative pronouns which and that are sometimes considered interchangeable, argue here that whichconstructions and frtaf-constructions have systematically different use conditions and consequent implicatures. These differences are I shown correspond to Donnellan's referential/attributive distincsubsequently argue that w/7/c/)-constructions are used referentially and f/7af-constructions attributively. This difference in use is explained via Horn's division of pragmatic labor. Using Horn's theory, provide an account of both the different implications arising from the use of each expression as well as an explanation for the continuing coexistence of two words used for the same purpose, i.e. tions. to I I to introduce restrictive relative clauses. 0. INTRODUCTION This paper addresses the question of why there should be two distinct pronouns, which and that, in the English language to serve a single purpose in the sentences in which they are used. Stahike (1976: 584) restrictive relative mirrors the general (1) and (1 (2) (2) as consensus among grammarians and 'virtually linguists when he cites synonymous': The cow which kicked over the lantern belongs to Ms. O'Leary. The cow that kicked over the lantern belongs to Ms. O'Leary. In what follows argue that restrictive relative clauses introduced by which have systematically different use conditions from those introduced by that. The difference between the two types of restrictive relative clauses is not truth conditional, nor is it always possible for readers to discern the difference between the two types of clauses. But, where there are differences, the differences in use are systematic. In fact, in using one over the other a speaker can give different implications about how he is using the N modified by the For that-conrestrictive relative clause to refer to his intended referent. I Studies in the Linguistic Sciences 19:1 (Spring 1989) 20 structions'' the implication is that the speaker is using the N for_arbitrary or N cannot be the restrictive clause is essential to inferby itself ring the denotation of the intended referent. Without the restriction or definition the restrictive clause provides, Ns modified by relatives introduced by that may not be used successfully to refer to the speaker/writer's intended referent. When an addressee encounters lV/7/cA7-relatives give different implications. wrt/c/7-constructions, the implication is that the N modified by the restrictive clause is being used to refer to a particular referent in that context. In the attributive reference in that context. used successfully to refer — What this means is that the argue that, unlike f^af-constructions, clause is sufficientjor but not essential to the denotation of the intended referent. Two types of Ns illustrate this difference in reference dependent upon whether which or that is used to examples of w/7/c/7-constructions to follow I for iv/7/c/7-constructions the restrictive relative introduce the restrictive relative clause. The first type is definite descriptions, loaned you, which use the definite article the to imply referDonnellan (1966) was the first to propose that individual. definite descriptions can be used in two distinct ways. The distinction is one between reference to a particular individual (referential use) and reference to whatever individual fits the attribute given (attributive use). In section 1, first briefly discuss the referential/attributive distinction and then show its relevance to the distinction between which and that by claiming that wrt/crt-constructions are used referentially and f/7a^constructions attributively. such as the book ence to a unique I I Donnellan's distinction can be extended to include descriptions other than those introduced by the definite article. Although these descriptions may not be strictly referential or attributive in Donnellan's sense, still a distinction can be made between descriptions that are used to refer to particular individuals and those that refer to arbitrary individuals, i.e., whoever or whatever fits the desargue that which is used in constructions cription, if anyone at all. In section 2, not introduced by the definite article which imply that the N modified by the I restrictive relative clause has a definite, particular referent, a generic, //laf-constructions implies reference to A whereas the use of arbitrary individual. theory which provides the framework for a unified account of the between that- and w/7/c/7-constructions is Horn's (1984) theory of Q- distinctions based and R-based inference. In it, Horn reduces Ghee's (1975) maxims of conversation to two principles: the Q-Principle (similar to Grice's maxim of Quantityi) and the R-Principle (based on Grice's maxim of Relevance). These principles are in opposition to one another, as a speaker following the QPrinciple says as much as she can (given R), whereas a speaker abiding by the R-Principle says no more than she must (given Q). The interaction between the two creates what Horn calls the 'division of pragmatic labor,' a notion which accounts for, among other things, the distinction between marked and unmarked expressions. In section 3, argue that Horn's theory of Q-based and R-based inference provides a unified account of the different contributions which and that make to the restrictive relative constructions they are part of, as well as an explanation for why the two relative pronouns continue to coexist. I Bundrick: 1. An inference-based account 21 REFERENTIAL/ATTRIBUTIVE DISTINCTION The referential/attributive distinction was first proposed by Donnellan (1966) as a distinction in the way definite descriptions are used. Since this diswill tinction consists of contrasts that are relevant to the rest of the discussion, first briefly describe Donnellan's distinction before going on to give examples I using which and that. A speaker could use (3) for example, either referentially or attributively: The lady who (3) lives on Main Street On the referential use the speaker would be referring to a particular person, say, her hairdresser Marie, who she just happened to describe in the way that she did. It is possible that there were any number of other ways the speak- same referent with an equal probability of success enabling her addressee to pick out her referent. Thus, the speaker could refer to her hairdresser Marie with (4) - (6) and still possibly succeed in denoting er could have described the in her intended referent: The lady with the pointed toenails The lady with the beehive hairdo The lady who just drove by (4) (5) (6) the atthbutive use, the speaker uttering (3) refers to whoever happens the description. It could be that there is no other way to describe the person that the speaker is referring to. For example, imagine a camp for boys where the only females on the whole compound consisted of one housemother per street. If a camp contest based prize giveaway on the ___location of one's res- On to fit would be appropriate to announce The next prize goes to the lady on Main Street, without it being necessary or even possible for the speaker to be referring to a particular person as long as it was assumed that only one lady lived on Main Street. Clearly, though, the prize could not be given to a woman with pointed toenails or a beehive hairdo unless it was also true of her that she lived on Main Street. idence, who it lives Even if his description of description referentially and still a referent is may use mistaken, a speaker successfully refer to his intended referent. the If I you The lady who lives on Main Street is on my bowling team and you know that have trouble with names and always get Main and Market Streets confused, then still may have successfully referred to the person intended on my bowling team. But if a speaker uses a mistaken description attributively, the description either won't refer to anyone or will be taken to refer to someone that instruct a florist to deliver some the speaker didn't intend to refer to. So, if flowers to the lady who lives on Main Street and three women live on Main Street or else no woman lives on Main Street, then the florist won't know who want the flowers delivered to. say to I I I I I To sum may either denote a particular referent whatever fits the description (atthbutive use). On use, reference may be made almost in spite of the attribute, since up, definite descriptions (referential use) or the referential whoever or Studies in the Linguistic Sciences 19:1 (Spring 1989) 22 may be more than one way to referentially pick out a referent (including a proper name), and mistaken or wrong descriptions may still be used referentially and serve to pick out a referent. But on the attributive use, reference is impossible without the correct attribute. Because the attribute is essential to there correct reference, there speaker uses an attribute, the description either someone that the one way to refer attributively. Also, if a and turns out to be mistaken about the won't refer to anyone or will be taken to refer to may be only attributive description speaker didn't intend to refer to. distinction is illustrated in (7), where the construction with that implies reference to a generic, arbitrary individual, The referential/attributive whereas with who^ a (7) The a. is referent of the is is NP implied. be understood as the individual that will the referent of the subject, The b. definite referent referent of the NP will be understood as the individual who the referent of the subject. is that the author is referring attributively to any indithe description of 'being the referent of the subject'. As long as it is true of any individual X that X has the property Y of being the referent of the subject, then X is being referred to. Any other property of X is not In (7a) vidual the implication who happens to fit in this example. In (7b) a different implication is example an addressee may infer that there exists some particular, but unknown individual of whom it happens to be true that this individual is the referent of the subject. It is possible that the author could have described this individual in some other way with equal success in enabling her reader to relevant to successful reference made. From this pick out the intended referent. which and that involved in referential and attributive With that used to introduce the restrictive relative clause, the implication is that, regardless of the nature or form of the semantic rules which guarantee John to be the object of please, whatever they are, they might have been different: Another example constructions is (8) of below. is no logical reason why English adjectives go before the nouns they modify (e.g., united states) rather than after, as Likewise, the semantic rules that unis). in French {etats guarantee that John is understood as the object of please (8a) For example, there in John is easy to please (i.e., that make it equivalent to It is easy people] to please John), might have been otherwise, allowing John to be understood as the subject (making the sentence equivalent to It is easy for John to please [people]). (Green p. 6) [for When which implication is is used to introduce the restrictive relative clause, the that particular semantic rules are being referred to: (8b) For example, there is no logical reason why English adjectives go after, as before the nouns they modify (e.g., united states) rather than Likewise, the semantic rules in French (etats unis). which Bundrick: An inference-based account 23 guarantee that John is understood as the object of please equivalent to It is in John is easy to please (i.e., which make easy [for people] to please John), might have been otherwise, allowing John to be understood as the subject (making the sentence equivalent to It is easy for John to please [peoplej). (Green p. 6, it which substituted for that) example, the writer indicates that there exist particular semantic say Rule A, Rule B, and Rule C. That is, she believes they exist in some form or other and they can do a particular job (i.e., guarantee that John is understood as the object of please). In this rules, Because the use of a definite description implies a particular use implies a more arbitrary referent, it makes sense for a definite description used referentially to actually refer to a previous mention in a text (or context). A definite description used attributively, on the other hand, need not be used to make reference to something encountered previously in the text, since it implies an arbitrary rather than particular referreferential referent while the attributive ence. This is the situation in (9). In (9), the referent of the situation can be either taken to be part of the previous text, i.e. what the speaker has said in the previous clause, or it could be taken to be simply whatever situation the speaker might be indicating exists, including what he/she has said, (i.e., the speaker might be implying an insult by saying Your mother wears combat boots.) (9a) of the discourse-interpreter is a) to understand what the speaker has said, that is, to construct a mental model of the situation WHICH the speaker is indicating exists; and b) to evaluate that model and use it to update his own model of the world. The task (Green, p. 5) With which used to introduce the restrictive relative clause, the situation implies a particular referent. In the context of this text, a logical referent for the situation is what the speaker has said, since what a speaker says can be taken to represent a situation. Thus, when which is used to introduce the restrictive relative clause, the implication is that the situation refers directly to speaker has what the said. With thatXo introduce the restrictive relative clause the implication no particular interpreter, discourse, or speaker is being referred to: (9b) is that of the discourse-interpreter is a) to understand what the speaker has said, that is, to construct a mental model of the situation THAT the speaker is indicating exists; and b) to to update his own model of the world. evaluate that model and use The task it (Green, Rather, it p. 5, f/7af substituted for which) Whenever they implies a universal claim: interpreter's job to construct a mental model of whatever exist, it is the situation the speaker's Studies in the Linguistic Sciences 19:1 (Spring 1989) 24 words indicate. the situation that the speaker is indicating exists need what the speaker has said. The speaker might have said a delightful woman, but implied that he was being insulting. In fact, not refer directly to Your mother 2. is PARTICULAR/ARBITRARY DISTINCTION refer Ns other than those modified by the definite article can also be used to two ways. On one view they can be used to refer to particular individuals, they can be used to refer to_whoever fits the description. This distinction can be seen in (lO).^ When the N sincere questions is modified by a restrictive relative clause introduced by which, the implication is that particular questions had been under discussion at some earlier point in the text. One may infer that or, the questions also happen to indicate When implication the restrictive relative is that, of some clause a set consisting of speaker's desire for information. is all introduced by that, however, the sincere questions, only those that could be used to indicate the speaker's desires were under discussion. (10) a. b. We discussed sincere questions which indicate that the speaker wants some information he believes the addressee has. We discussed sincere questions that indicate that the speaker wants some information he believes the addressee has. is that the sincere questions under discussion just be described as indicating that the speaker wants some information he believes the addressee has. It's possible these questions could have been described in some other way, with an equal chance of successful reference. That situation does not hold true of (10b). In (10b), the relative clause serves to remind the reader of the definition of the term sincere questions. Any other description of the questions may not have resulted in ref- In (10a) the implication happened erence to to the same intended referent. Example (11) also illustrates the arbitrary reference of f/7af-constructions compared to the particular reference of w/7/c/7-constructions. This example is one gave to eight informants as part of an informal test which involved inserting which or that in sentences taken out of context where the relative pronoun slot was left blank. All eight participants, including the original author of the sentence, wrote that for this example. The original sentence"* was written I with which. (11) a. The remark also threatens the addressee's face referring to the in implicitly addressee's wanting something that the speaker has. b. The remark also threatens the addressee's face referring the addressee's wanting something which the to in implicitly speaker has. In (11a), with that, the implication is that it is face-threatening for reference be made to the addressee's wanting anything at all the speaker might have, whether it be her husband, her jewelry, her dining room table, or even a glass of to .. Bundrick: An inference-based account 25 water from her kitchen sink. Whatever it is, as long as it is something the speaker has, the addressee's face will be threatened if implicit reference is made to the addressee's wanting it. And, out of context, this seems the most In the original text, a much likely way to view the implication of this example. different scenario was created. The sentence was located in the middle of a discussion of using may, should, and mustXo show deference to an addressee. The examples used to illustrate this deference involved a hostess offering fruitcake to a guest. The something that the speaker has in (11b) is clearly the would be face-threatening to the fruitcake, and the discussion points out that addressee/guest for the hostess to imply (by uttering You may have some of this fruitcake, for example) that the addressee wants some of it. it In (11a) with the f/jaf-construction, the restrictive relative clause contains information essential to inferring the denotation of the intended referent. Without any given context, something only implies arbitrary reference. The restric- clause supplies the information necessary for the hearer to infer a In (lib), though, something clearly has a particular referent. This point will be discussed more fully in the next section. tive relative possible referent for something. 3. HORN'S THEORY OF Q-BASED AND R-BASED INFERENCE Horn proposes a schema for pragmatic inference derived from Grice's conversational maxims. He reduces Grice's (1975:45-46) maxims (given in example (12) below) to the two principles (13) and (14): (12) Grice: Quality: Try to Do Do 1 2. make your contribution one that is true. not say what you believe to be false. not say that for which you lack evidence. Quantity: contribution as informative as required (for 1. Make your 2. the current purposes of the exchange). Do not make your contribution more informative than is is required. Relation: Be relevant. Manner: 3. Avoid obscurity of expression. Avoid ambiguity. Be brief. (Avoid unnecessary prolixity.) 4. Be 1 2. Horn (p. 13): (13) The Q orderly. Principle (Hearer-based): Make your contribution sufficient. (Cf. Say as much as you can (given R). (Lower-bounding principle, inducing Quantityi) upper-bounding implicata.) 26 Studies in the Linguistic Sciences 19:1 (Spring 1989) (14) The R Principle (Speaker-based): Make your contribution necessary. Relation, Quantity2. (cf. Say no more than you must (Upper-bounding The Q Manner) (given Q). principle, inducing lower-bounding implicata.) hearer-based in the sense that a speaker must overcome an inclination toward least effort and become as informative as the conversational exchange requires. Instead of saying as little as possible, a speaker operating on the Q Principle must say as much as is relevant to ensure his contribution is sufficient for the exchange. This principle is a lower-bounding principle which may be exploited to generate upper-bounding implicata. In other words, by saying ... p ... a speaker may license the hearer to infer... atmostp... A alized; Principle is conversational implication can be made so often that it becomes generi.e., some expressions consistently license the hearer to infer that is meant than was said. The main examples of generalized Qbased implicata are those from scalar predications. For example, some (lower bound) can license the inference not all (upper bound). If tell you that some of my dishes were broken license you to infer that not all of them were. If knew that all of the dishes were broken and felt that this was relevant knowledge for you, would have been bound by the Q Principle to say so. Assuming that was something more I I I I I obeying the Q stronger claim Principle licenses the inference that — All of the dishes were broken I — was was not certain that the true. Principle is just the opposite of the Q Principle. Where the Q Prinhearer-based, forcing the speaker to overcome an inclination toward least effort, the speaker-based R Principle encourages minimal effort. A speaker operating on this principle would say only what he must (as long as it is enough) to make his contribution necessary to the exchange. Just the opposite of Q, the R Principle is an upper-bounding principle which may be exploited to induce lower-bounding implicata. That means that a speaker uttering ... p ... The R ciple is licenses the inference The speech ... more than p ... example of a generalized R-based As Horn aptly puts it: classic act. implication is the indirect ask you whether you can pass me the salt, in a context where your do so are not in doubt, license you to infer that am doing something more than asking you whether you can pass the salt am in fact asking you to do it. (If know for a fact that you can pass me the salt, the yes-no question is pointless; the assumption that am obeying the Relation maxim allows you to infer that mean something more than what If I abilities to I I — I I I I I say.) (p. 14) Although the R Principle and the Q Principle may operate independently to generate implicata, their simultaneous operation also licenses various inferences. These two opposing forces in inference strategies create a conflict whose most common explicit derivation Bundrick: An inference-based account resolution is summarized by Horn given The use (15) sion 27 with his in (15), more in (16a-f): of a marked (relatively complex and/or when a corresponding unmarked prolix) expres- (simpler, less 'effortful') alternate expression is available tends to be interpreted as conveying a marked message (one which the unmarked alternative would not or could not have conveyed). The speaker used marked expression E' containing 'extra' matotherwise less basic in form or distribution) when a corresponding unmarked expression E, essentially coextensive (16a) erial with (or it, Either (16b) (ii) it was (i) available. was irrelevant and unnecessary, or E could not have been appropriately the 'extra' material was necessary (i.e., used). (16c) (16b(i)) is in R conflict with the Principle and is thus (ceteris paribus) to be rejected. Therefore, (16d) (16b(ii)), from (16b), (16c) by modus tollendo pon- ens. The unmarked (16e) use or alternative E tends to become associated — through conventionalization — by marked (by meaning) with un- situation s, representing stereotype or salient member (R-based inference ...) The marked alternative E' tends to become associated with the of extension of E/E'. (16f) complement of s with respect to the original (Q-based inference ...) (p. extension of E/E'. 22) Marked and unmarked expressions may coexist when a productive process creates an expression synonymous to a lexical expression already in existence. One such example is the productive pale red in contrast to the already existing lexical item pink first discussed by McCawley (1978). By using the marked expression pale red a speaker implies that the unmarked alternative pink does not hold. For those speakers for whom pale red is meaningful (some find it impossible according to Horn), it could only be used to describe a range of colors not already preempted by pink. The use of pink licenses the R-inference that the stereotypic or salient color is being referred to. Use of the marked alternative pale red Q-implicates that unmarked pink does not or may not hold of the color being described. A similar situation obtains with the distribution of lexical causatives. ited in their causative use to stereotypic causation, kill in i.e., result. (17a) (1 Lexical causatives, such as 7b) Jack killed Susan. Jack caused Susan to die. and productive (17a) have a tendency to be lim- where physical action has a direct 28 Studies in the Linguistic Sciences 19:1 (Spring 1989) Such limitation of lexical causatives to stereotypic situations sidered to be straightforward R-based conversational implicature. may be conA Q-implic- ature would obtain through the use of the relatively marked productive causative cause to die in example (17b) that the unmarked situation does not Use could not have been used appropriately, amounts of poison in her tea every day or loosened the screws on a balcony she is known to lean on. hold. of (17b) implies that (17a) possibly because Jack put small The alternative to an unmarked single lexical item need not be a producexpression made up of two or more words. Although neither which nor that is a productive expression, still which is marked in a way that is not. The relative pronoun that is used exclusively in restrictive relative clauses, whereas which may be used in either restrictive or non-restrictive relative clauses. tive The desk which was being repainted got damaged. The desk, which was being repainted, got damaged. The desk that was being repainted got damaged. *The desk, that was being repainted, got damaged. (18) (19) (20) (21) tions The differences between which- and ^A)a^constructions pointed out in sec1 and 2 can be given a unified account if we assume thatXo be unmarked and which marked. First, according to Horn's division of pragmatic labor, unmarked that\N'\\\ represent the stereotypic use of a restrictive relative pronoun. As an unmarked lexical item, that will have a tendency to be limited in use to stereotypic restriction, i.e., it will be used to restrict the reference of the N to those possible referents of which the condition given by the believed to be true. Such clause is conBecause the restrictive limitation of that to stereotypic situations may be sidered to be straightforward R-based conversational implicature. R Principle is one of minimal effort (say only what you must), unmarked relative that licenses the inference that the restrictive clause it introduces is essential to the reference of the N in the relative construction. A speaker saying the minim- um the relative clause if he felt the N alone could intended referent. Since the minimum possible included the restrictive clause, the implication is that it is the attribute or property stated of the N in the restrictive clause that crucially enables reference to the possible would have have been used to refer left off to his N could serve as referent, as long as it by the restrictive clause. It is this implicatum that gives rise to the arbitrary reading for f/7af-constructions discussed in intended referent. That implies that any was a member sections 1 and of the set defined 2. Assuming which to be marked also explains its role in licensing the inferences it does. As the relatively marked expression, its use Q-implies that something different was meant from the straightforward restriction that that provides. Otherwise the speaker/writer would have used that to introduce the A speaker saying as much as he could might use a he felt the N alone could have been used to refer to Since the speaker is understood to be saying as much as restrictive relative clause. w/7/'crt-construction his even intended referent. if he can given R, the implication is that the attribute stated of the N in the Bundrick: restrictive clause to reference. is 29 enable reference, but not necessarily essential words, the use of a w/7/'c/7-construction may license the has a particular referent. sufficient to In ot^her inference that the N Examples (22a-b) used An inference-based account illustrate these differences. In (22a) with unmarked to introduce the restrictive clause, the implication is that the that speaker is operating under the R Principle and saying only as much as is absolutely necessary. Since the R Principle is a law of minimal effort, a speaker operating under it would have only said the lamp without the restrictive clause if he felt that that would have provided the hearer with enough information to enable him to pick out the intended referent. Since the speaker didn't only say the lamp but a hearer making an R-inference would necessary to denote the intended lamp, other lamps that this particular lamp is in went on to include the restrictive clause, assume that the restrictive relative that there may is possibly exist a set of contrast with. (22a) The lamp that we bought at Carson's short-circuited. marked which used to introduce the restrictive that the unmarked situation represented by that In (22b) with the relatively clause, the Q-implication is does not obtain. In other words, the stereotypic restriction that that generates, with its implication that the N by itself is insufficient to establish reference to the intended referent, does not hold. With strict restriction preempted, along with its subsequent implication of modifying an arbitrary or indefinite N (as in a member of a set), the marked situation represented by the iv/7/c^-construction is that the N has some particular referent. The Q condition on sufficiency licenses the inference that the restrictive clause is sufficient for but not essential to reference. Thus, with (22b) the implication is that some particular lamp is being referred to, which the speaker happened to describe as being from Carson's. The property of being bought at Carson's still serves to distinguish this lamp from other lamps, although (22b) 4. it need not be the sole distinguishing The lamp which we bought at quality. Carson's short-circuited. SUMMARY I have tried to show that ivrt/c/7-constructions and //7af-constructions have That systematically different use conditions and consequent impiicatures. means they can be used to produce distinct differences in the nature of the reference of the N modified by the restrictive clause. By assuming that\o be the relative pronoun and which the marked one, use of Horn's division of pragmatic labor generated by his Q and R Principles makes possible an account of both the different implications arising from the use of each expression, as well as an explanation for the continuing coexistence of two words used for the same purpose, i.e., to introduce restrictive relative clauses. unmarked 30 Studies in the Linguistic Sciences 19:1 (Spring 1989) NOTES *l am grateful to Georgia Green for her many helpful comments on earlier drafts of this paper. ^By 7/jaf-construction' I mean a construction represented by a structure of the sort where the restrictive relative clause, represented by S, is introduced by the relative pronoun that. Likewise, use 'w/i/c/j-construction' to indicate the whole NP, only with which used to introduce the relative clause. When refer to the noun modified by the restrictive relative clause, use N. By this refer only to I I I I N the circled 2| have in the structure given above. tried wherever possible to use examples from to I will be applicable to who, although I do not apply it in this (This real texts. me by Georgia Green from a manuscript she is example uses who instead of which, but am assuming my was given one working on.) The analysis of which paper. 3The examples in (10) only make sense if the set of sincere questions can be taken to include questions that don't indicate that a speaker wants to know something he thinks the addressee knows. These include questions which indicate a speaker is being polite, such as Would you care for some of this fruitcake? or even sincere rhetorical questions, such as Who knows the mind of Chomsky? ''Example (1 1 ) is an altered version of a sentence from Green p. 1 50. REFERENCES DONNELLAN, Keith. 1966. Reference and definite descriptions. Philosophical Review 75.281-304. Repr., Readings in the philosophy of language, ed. Englewood Cliffs, NJ: by J. F. Rosenberg and C. Travis, 195-211. Prentice-Hall. GREEN, Georgia 1989. Pragmatics and natural language understanding. Lawrence Eribaum Associates, Inc. GRICE, H.P. 1975. Logic and conversation. Syntax and semantics, 3: Speech acts, ed. by P. Cole & J. Morgan, 41-58. New York: Academic Press. M. Hillsdale, NJ: Bundrick: HORN, Laurence An inference-based account 31 Toward a new taxonomy for pragmatic inference: Meaning, form, and use in context: Washington, DC: Linguistic applications, ed. by D. Schiffrin, 11-42. R. 1984. Q-based and R-based Georgetown implicature. University Press. McCAWLEY, James D. 1978. Syntax and semantics, 9: Conversational implicature and the lexicon. Pragmatics, ed. by P. Cole, 245-259. New York: Academic Press. Herbert F. W. 1976. Which that. Language 52.584-610. STAHLKE, Studies in Volume 19, t he Linguistic Sciences Number 1, Spring 1989 SHINGAZIDJA NOMINAL ACCENT Farida Cassimjee and Charles W. Kisseberth In this paper we explore the accentual system of Shingazidja, a Bantu language spoken on the Grand Comoros island, belonging to the Sabaki group, and closely related to Kiswahili. This system is interesting both in terms of general linguistic theory and in terms of the history of Proto-Bantu tone in East Africa. We argue that Shingazidja (at least in the nominal system) has essentially retained the Proto-Bantu distribution of High (H) tones, it superimposes a metrical structure over these tones, and the metrical structure that determines the surface ___location of but that is One tones. H, tone is critically rule, Meeussens' Rule, which deletes an H involved in after obtaining the correct surface ___location of it H an H tones. — We review two earlier accounts of Shingazidja a descriptive study by Tucker and Bryan (1970) and a metrical analysis by Philippson (1988). We attempt to clarify what the facts are with respect to Shingazidja nominal accent and to show why our analysis is superior. 1. Introduction In this paper we present an analysis of some of the fundamental aspects of the accentual system of the nominal in Shingazidja, a Bantu language spoken on the Grand Comoros island. This system is of considerable interest both from the theoretical point of view and from the point of view of the student of the We demonstrate that Shingazidja has system in the noun, but that it regards High tones as rendering a mora metrically heavy, and builds an unbounded, left-dominant, quantity-sensitive foot over each High tone in a history of Bantu tone. will attempt to essentially preserved the Proto-Bantu tonal phonological phrase. We will show that, prior to the construction of metrical ^ Studies in the Linguistic Sciences 19:1 (Spring 1989) 34 underlying distribution of High tones may be altered. Further, we will subsequent to the construction of metrical feet, a well-known Bantu applies to delete the High tone in one foot if Meeussen's Rule tonal rule the immediately preceding foot has a High tone. This rule must apply iteratively feet, the show that from left — — to right, since given the underlying distribution of High tones, it es- beginning at the left edge of an expression, the first foot and every other one after it has a surface High tone. The actual phonetic realization of the High tones that remain after Meeussen's Rule is controlled by two principles: The H in a foot is realized on the last mora of the foot, and the Highs in a phonological expression exhibit 'downstep'. There are further matters of phonetic implementation that merit detailed phonetic exploration, and it is our intention to ultimately provide such a study. But the present paper is largely confined to the major structural aspects of the Shingazidja pitch/accent system, rather than the phonetic implementation of these structablishes an alternating pattern; i.e., tures. literature on Shingazidja accent is not extensive. The first system is found in a paper by Tucker and Bryan (1970), henceforth T&B. T&B offer no analysis of the system, actually. Their focus is mainly classificatory, based on what they perceive to be the pitch patterns displayed by nominals in isolation and phrases containing nominals. Because their paper is well-known to students of the Sabaki language group (which includes Kiswahili and its various dialects, the Comorian languages [= Shimasiwa], the Mijikenda languages, Pokomo, and Elwana), we have taken some pains to clarify T&B's account of the Shingazidja data and to explain why their attempt at classi- The published account of the fication is ultimately unsuccessful. Philippson (1988) explores the accentual system of three Comorian Shin[d]zuani, Shimwali, and Shingazi[d]ja, but his discussion of Shingazidja is based (apparently) largely on T&B, and he refers to these data languages — as 'tres fragmentaires et assez peu sures, mais neanmoins revelatrices' (35). Despite the limitations of the data, Philippson (unlike T&B), does offer an analysis of the system underlying the surface pitch patterns in Shingazidja. As Philippson presents them, the accentual systems of the other two Comorian languages discussed seem closely related to Shingazidja (although from the published literature we cannot gauge whether the phonetic implementation of the systems are parallel, and we have not as yet had a first hand opportunity to study the other languages). We will not here attempt a detailed review of the material in Philippson, but rather concentrate on his analysis of Shingazidja and the main outlines of his analysis of Comorian accent in general. 2. Tucker and Bryan's description T&B distinguish three tonal (pitch) patterns of nouns in their isolation form. type they refer to as a 'Level Tone Pattern' (I); a second type they refer to as a 'Mid + Low Tone Pattern' (II); and the third type they refer to as a 'High + One & Kisseberth: Cassimjee Shingazidjia nominal accent 35 (III). However, with respect to Type III, T&B note: 'Memberonly tentative, dependent in the first instance on our ability to Low Tone Pattern' ship here is distinguish a 'High' from a 'Mid' tone in words spoken isolation by in one informant who, from time to time, varied his intervals' (354). We will ultimately argue that Tone Pattern (= TP) II and III are phonetically distinguishable, and that the structural basis for this phonetic difference look at the morphophonemic becomes very clear when we variation exhibited by these nominals. As turns out, T&B's analysis of Shingazidja does not stop at classifying nouns on the basis of their isolation forms: '... there is another allocation of nouns according to their Tone Patterns in certain contexts. For the present exercise the deictic form of the noun in conjunction with the pronominal possessive has been selected as most representative, and three main Tone Patterns have been found, called here A, B, and C. These Patterns in many respects fall in with the Tone Patterns already discussed [i.e. II, and III; FC and CWK], but in other respects cut across them' (360). should be noted that the three Tone Patterns A, B, and C do not refer just to the shape of the nominal word itself, but also to the shape of what follows. (In the case that T&B discuss in detail, this is the pronominal possessive.) In other words, these Tone Patterns it I, It refer to the tonal influence a nominal has as well as to its own surface shape. The picture that emerges from the T&B account of Shingazidja is a confusing as well as a confused one. In the end, the intersection of Tonal Patterns I, II, and III with Tone Patterns A, B, and C tonal classes (out of the logically possible nine). count, bisyllabic nominal stems show yields for six different T&B other words, In six different in T&B's ac- (unpredictable) patterns of Since the Proto-Bantu tonal system, from which Shingazidja and Low, and since a bisyllabic noun stem in Proto-Bantu could have one of four possible tonal shapes (LL, LH, HL, and HH), it would be somewhat surprising if in Shingazidja there are in fact six different underlying tonal types. We shall argue that in Shingazidja, there are in fact four distinct accentual types for a bisyllabic stem (just as in Proto-Bantu). There are good reasons for the confusions in T&B. The data are subtle and not at all straightforward; in many instances there are alternative forms available that confuse the classification. tonal behavior. surely derives, exhibited a contrast between two tones. High 3. T&B's Tone Pattern I Let us begin our discussion of Shingazdija with nouns. The first point about these tinguishable from the nouns that way T&B nouns label is T&B's Tone Pattern I that they are in fact readily dis- Tone Pattern II and III. T&B provide TPI nouns, simply describing them as (mid) 'level' (although at one point indicating a possible raising of the final syllable above this mid level). In our experience, items of this type (in isolation) consistently exhibit a level pitch up until the last syllable, at which point the pitch rises. It is not simply that the last syllable has a higher pitch level, little in the of discussion of the pitch patterns of 36 Studies in the Linguistic Sciences 19:1 (Spring 1989) For the time being, we will transfinal vowel, with all the preceding syllables being unmarked. In addition, we will underline the final vowel. (Underlining indicates the syllable which we will ultimately analyze as having an H tone associated with it.) but the pitch seems to rise on that syllable. mark over the cribe items of this type with an acute Some examples of this type of kapwa (1) 'armpit', godorQ 'river', 'face', noun follow below. nyumba 'mattress', parg 'house', sutru 'spoon', meza m-dri 'road', hi-ri 'chair', 'tree', 'table', m-drfi m-levi 'drunkard', (r])koha 'dove', u-bu 'porridge', u-sq. gada 'hole', ter£ 'drop', i-tsawazi 'a kind of plate', m-ber£ m-tsuzl 'a kind of tree', nanga 'anchor', m-tsana 'day', mfuri(y)apa 'a kind of tree', birci 'office, closet', bawa 'wing', furaha 'happiness', m-nazi 'coconut tree', kasha 'suit 'finger ring', case' [Note: m indicates a syllabic nasal.] if we were to attempt a purely tonal might propose that there is a High tone associated with the ultimate vowel of these words. Indeed, if we look at bisyllabic ProtoBantu noun stems that have a LH pattern, we find that when they have cognates in Shingazidja, they do indeed appear as TP nouns with regularity. (Problematic correspondences are not discussed here.) Below we list some relevant reconstructions along with their Shingazidja cognates. (In these materials, 'G' refers to Guthrie 1971, and the number refers to the numbering of his re- Given just this isolation pronunciation, we analysis of Shingazidja, I constructions.) *-baba 'wing' (G. 6) *-cana 'day, daylight' (G. 273) *-c\6 'face' (G. 346) •-dor^go 'clay' (G. 667) •-nyCimba 'house' (G. 2168a) (2) *-nyur]gu *-tf 'tree' From the data so 'pot' (G. far presented, Shingazidja nominals. In in it is 'wing' rti-cana u-sa ' day' 'face' donga 'clay' nyumba nyungii m-drf (G. 1729) between where Highs appeared of 2173a) bawa 'house' 'pot' 'tree' clear that there is some correlation Proto-Bantu nominals and the pitch pattern our opinion, however, it will quickly become evident that Shingazidja did not simply retain the Proto-Bantu tone system, and that it is not best regarded from a synchronic point of view as simply a tone language. That the correlation between Proto-Bantu High tones and the surface of raised pitches in Shingazidja is indeed not direct becomes immediately appparent from an examination of phrasal phonology. Consider appearance & Kisseberth: Cassimjee Shingazidjia nominal accent 37 example what happens when a word that in isolation has the same pitch Tone Pattern nouns is combined with a Tone Pattern noun. The example we will use here is the element djuu 'on' (cf. *-judu 'top', G. 959). for pattern as (3) I I meza djuu 'on a table' djuu 'on a chair' pare djuu 'on a road' nyumba djuu 'on a house' hiri We have transcribed the above expressions with an acute accent over the second vowel from the end of the expression. should be noted that the It phonetic implementation of this syllable in these expressions is not the same as the phonetic implementation of the final syllable in (1). We shall return to this matter of phonetic implementation below. Given that the two words involved both have a final raised pitch in we might have expected phrases with shapes like *mezi, djuu. and 'hiri djuu. We do not find such pronunciations. There is a single raised syllable and it is the one in between the underlyingly raised syllables (assuming that the isolation forms represent the underlying pattern). Consideration of some additional data will help us to establish more precisely where the raised syllable isolation, will occur. Let us consider the situation where an adjective which has an isolation form with a final raised syllable follows a noun with a final raised syllable. We will use -(bjili'Xv^o' (cf. *-bidi'\vjo', G. 113). (4) ma-soha ma-ili birQ mbili mi-rj mi-ili 'two axes' 'two offices, closets' 'two trees' mi-furi(y)apa mi-iH 'two (kinds of) trees' zi-tsawazi zi-ili 'two plates' is that in expressions consisting of two words which end, in their isolation form, in a final raised syllable (we will refer to these as underlined syllables in what follows), there will be a single raised syllable immediately to the left of the final underlined syllable. In an example like birQ mbili there is just one syllable between the two underlined syllables; in zitsawazi zi-ili, there are two syllables in between. Regardless of how many What these data demonstrate syllables intervene, the raised syllable is one to the left of the final underlined syllable. While a tonal treatment of this material is not impossible, it is not at all obvious how we can start with two High tones (located on the final vowels of two successive words) and reduce them to a single H tone located to the immediate We would have to propose left of the ___location of the second of these Highs. Studies in the Linguistic Sciences 19:1 (Spring 1989) 38 something like Given two H tones, the first spreads rightward up second H; then the second deletes; and finally all a multiply-linked H structure delink. This would result in the following: to the syllable before the syllables but the last in an H on the appropriate syllable. Given that there is no particular evidence for the spreading and delinking operations required by the tonal analysis, and given that there will be additional evidence later, suggesting that Shingazidja is not simply a tone language, let us explore how we might make sense out of these data. We will follow the suggestion of Philippson (1988) that Shingazidja represents a language where metrical structure plays a pervasive role in terms of determining the surface pitch pattern. Our analysis will, however, differ radically from Philippson's in terms of the metrical structures involved. We feel that in the interests of clarity it best to examine Philippson's analysis later, after the data motivating our analysis have been introduced and analyzed. is We suggest that one part of the tonal analysis is correct; namely, a High tone must be deleted after a High tone. This is a well-known rule of Bantu tonology and in recent years has come to be known as Meeussen's Rule. 2 But we propose that the apparent shift of the High tone from the final syllable of the first word to the syllable immediately in front of where the High tone in the second word is (underlyingly) located is due to a very simple principle: The High tone associated with the head of a foot is realized phonetically as a raising of the pitch of the last syllable of that foot. Let us spell out our proposal a little more carefully. We suggest that ProtoBantu High tones have been retained in Shingazidja. Furthermore, we suggest that Shingazidja has developed a system of metrical prominence that involves and that the constnjction of unbounded, left-dominant, quantity-sensitive feet syllables associated with High tones count as 'heavy' in this system. It could be maintained that the feet are constructed starting at the left edge of the phrase (whether the syllable at the edge is heavy or not), or that they are constructed subject to the proviso that the head of the foot must be heavy. If the feet are constructed starting at the left edge, then in some phrases there will be an initial foot that contains no High tone. For the sake of simplicity, we will assume that feet are built only over heavy syllables, but we know of no evidence at the — moment In bearing on this particular issue. our presentation, we will adopt the metrical grid approach to the reprewe will not attempt to motivate sentation of 'accent' ('prominence', 'stress'), but this approach in general nor explicate it beyond the level of detail required for approach, the cooccurexample) and accent Is represented as the linkage of that unit to a prominent position in a grid. A grid is an array of asterisks (which can be equated with a positive value for prominence at a given level) in columns and lines. A grid consists of as many columns as there are the presentation of our analysis of Shingazidja. rence of some unit (a syllable, for In this Cassimjee & Kisseberth: Shingazidjia nominal accent 39 the representation. For present purposes, we may as many lines as there are levels of prominence. Line consists of as many asterisks as there are accentable syllables in the representation. Line 1 consists of an asterisk for every position on Line that is in fact accented. The syllables with a Line 1 asterisk are the heads of metrical feet. The syllables that are joined together with a head to form a foot are shown by enclosing them with the head inside brackets on Line 0. Finally, syllables that are extrametrical are shown by enclosing them and their asterisk on Line in parentheses. accentable syllables suppose in that there are Consider first how we account for Tonal Pattern nouns in isolation. we propose that syllables with an H tone are metrically heavy and that left-dominant, unbounded, quantity-sensitive feet are constructed over heavy syllables in Shingazidja. In TP nouns, the last syllable is associated with an H tone. Thus a foot will be constructed with that syllable as the head of the foot. Since there are no syllables to the right, this foot will not contain any other syllables. The H tone will be realized on the last (which is the only) syllable of I Recall, I the foot. Next consider how we account for the pronunciations in (3) - (4). The phrase will have two H syllables (the underlined syllables in our transcriptions). Unbounded, left-dominant, quantity-sensitive feet are built over the heavy syllables. Thus we will have representations such as the following: * (5) * * Line **][*] * [* ma-so ha, ma-i li H H 1 Line extend from the last syllable of the first word through the penult second word. The last syllable of the second word will be itself a foot. Meeussen's Rule will delete the H from the second foot. The H of the first which is the syllable foot will be realized on the last syllable of the foot immediately preceding the second foot. In other words, we account for what is special about the syllable immediately preceding the second of two High tones by saying that this syllable represents the end of a foot, and the raising of pitch in Shingazidja coocurs with the end of a foot. The first foot will syllable of the — of is Let us now turn to another source of evidence about the proper treatment Tone Pattern nominals. In particular, we will examine what in the literature sometimes referred to as a 'stabilized' noun phrase. The general structure of I such noun phrases in Shingazidja is: a 'stabilizer' (/ndV/) plus an element proto the noun that serves as a definite marker, plus the noun. There is some morphological complexity that is beyond the concerns of this paper; e.g., the stabilizer sometimes merges with the definite marker into a single syllable. Some examples of stabilized Tone Pattern nominals appear in (6). (The clitic I 40 Studies in the Linguistic Sciences 19:1 (Spring 1989) phonetic implementation of the syllable marked here with an acute symbol is same as the phonetic implementation of the syllables in (3) - (4) marked with the See below the acute. for discussion.) nd£ meza '(it is) the table' ndfi le godorQ '(it is) the mattress' ndQ usQ '(it is) the face' (6) The where a raised appears immediately to suggests that in the underlying structure of the complex 'stabilizer + definite proclitic' there must be an H tone. It is not possible to argue here whether it is the stabilizing element or the definite marker that contributes this H tone. (In some cases the two are fused in any case into a single syllable.) Somewhat arbitrarily, we will assume that it is the proclitic element that bears the H tone underlyingly. the tonal pattern in (6), syllable of the underlined syllable of the noun, left Given the assumption that the stabilizer has an H, then the above data Feet will be constructed with follow directly from the analysis presented above. the heavy syllables structure that results in the phrase as the heads of the feet. The metrical is illustrated in (7): (7) r * ndfi. * * * r ] le godo * 1 ro. H H The first foot spreads from the stabilizer up to the penult syllable of the noun. The second foot consists just of the last syllable of the noun, fvleeussen's Rule deletes the H from the second foot. The H associated with the first foot is realized on the last vowel of the Tone Pattern I first foot — on the penult syllable i.e. of the nominal. To summarize, nouns are, in our analysis, then, T&B's Tone Pattern have an H tone associated with their final syllable. In general, this syllable will be the head of a foot. The H tone associated with this syllable will is not subject to as long as be realized on the final syllable of the foot Meeussen's Rule. nouns I that — At this point the examples let in this us discuss section. mez^, godoro^ and so foot has a on), the rising quality to it. briefly When it the matter of phonetic implementation of there is H associated a single foot in the word (cf. sohg, with the final (only) syllable of the Furthermore, the extent of the rising is not sharp (witness T&B's deschption of this TPI nouns as 'mid level'), though certainly detectable. The raised syllable that appears on the last syllable of a foot, before a second foot (in our transcriptions, on a vowel before an underlined vowel) does not have such a clear rising quality, and indeed seems to have some Cassimjee falling & Kisseberth: Shingazidjia nominal accent 41 character to it. We assume that these phonetic distinctions are to be in the phonetic implementation component of the grammar. specified 4. T&B's Tone Pattern nouns II T&B's Tone Pattern II nouns turn out to represent for us two (partially although their pronunciation in isolation is identical. Let us consider one subset of T&B's TP II nouns. Call them TPII-A for now. TPII-A distinct) types, nouns have the following isolation pronunciation: They have a relatively level on the syllables prior to the penult, and the pitch rises on the penult, and then is low on the final syllable. Some examples are: pitch (8) paha (ma-pvaha) keng^le buku (ma-) 'cat', falasika 'bell', 'bottle', 'book', i-tranda (zi-) 'bed', shon^nde 'knife', almasi 'diamond', sabuni 'soap', djunjya 'sack', i-fuba 'chest', 'knee', shishiyo 'ear', tiho 'roof, m-sihiri 'mosque', gunguno dziwa 'lake', fumu kalamu 'pen', masikini 'poor person', siriwali 'pants', 'fare', shano 'plate', sh-iba 'bone*, sindanu 'needle', katfli rti-draya 'quarter (of a city)', sufuri(y)a 'pan', kofl(y)a 'hat', 'spear', nawili 'murderer', shati 'shirt', mw-ana 'child', bunduki 'gun' We have transcribed these nouns with an acute mark over their penult syllable and we have underlined this syllable (or at least its vocalic nucleus) as well. It should be stressed that this syllable does not have the same phonetic implementation as the expressions given in (3), (4), and (6). In fact, the implementation involves the nouns same sort of rising quality (and not sharply rising) as the in (1). A look at the historical sources of the nouns in (8) shows immediately that they reflect the case where Proto-Bantu bisyllabic stems had an HL pattern. Some relevant data establishing this point are as follows. (9) *-bQda 'rain' mvu(w)a (G. 225) 'rain' *-c[ku 'day' (G. 352) u-siku *-c(_mba slmba 'lion' nyQha 'snake' paha 'cat' 'lion' (G. 357) *-j6ka 'snake' (G. 952) *-paka 'cat' (G. 142) *-tanda 'bedstead' (G. 166) *-tQmu 'spear' (G. 1868) 'day' i-tranda fiimu 'bed' 'spear' If we assume that these nouns continue in Shingazidja to have an H tone associated with their penult syllable, then according to our analysis we would expect a foot to be constructed over this syllable. If the final syllable of the noun were permitted to be incorporated into this foot, we would expect the H tone of the penult syllable to surface as a rise on the last syllable of the noun. This does not happen (at least when the noun appears phrase-final). What we 42 Studies in the Linguistic Sciences 19:1 (Spring 1989) would like to suggest here is that phrase-final syllables, if not associated with a High tone, are extrametrical. Thus in the case of the nouns in (8), the foot will consist just of the penult syllable of the word, since the ultimate syllable will be The extrametrical. structure is shown below: (10) * [*] The H tone *) ( sho no H (nde) be realized on the last (in fact, the only) syllable of like shonQnde and sohQ share the property that they have a single foot and that foot consists of a single syllable. The realization of the H tone in these cases is similar: There is a rising quality to the syllable. Phrases like nds. le sohQ, where there are two feet, realize the H tone of the first foot differently: It has more a falling character than a rising character. that foot. of the foot will Notice that nouns Our treatment of the nouns in (8) as having an H on their penult syllable Consider first the case where the finds confirmation in various context forms. element djuu is (11) located after a TP ll-A noun. i-tranda djuji 'on a bed' beramu djuu 'on a flag' a roof dzjwa djuu 'on a lake' m-sihiri djuu 'on a mosque' sufuriya djuu 'on a pan' kofjya djuu 'on a hat' tiho djuu 'on nouns in that they find here is that TP ll-A nouns are just like TP induce the appearance of a raised pitch on the syllable in front of the (underlyingly High) final syllable of djui2. In our analysis, this follows from the assumption that there is an H tone on the penult of these nouns. We predict the What we I following metrical structure: (12) dju ko fi ya H The presence of the the noun means that a foot will be constructed noun and continuing to the penult of djuu.. (Notice of the noun is not phrase-final, it is not extrametrical H tone on starting at the penult of the that since the last syllable and therefore will in the first foot of the phrase. Note also that since associated with an H, it is heavy and thus cannot be foot. Instead it will form the second foot of the phrase.) be included the last syllable of djuu incorporated into the is first Cassimjee The H of djuu. now is be realized on the in phrases 43 Shingazidjia nominal accent subject to Meeussen's Rule. last syllable of the first foot (Incidentally, this syllable of djuu. observed & Kisseberth: H tone has The H — which the same of the is, TP ll-A noun will of course, the first phonetic realization as mezg^ djuu) like Up to this point, when discussing combinations of TP ll-A Noun plus Word, we have limited ourselves to structures with djuu as second member, i.e. with a word in final H. Suppose, however, that we combine a TP ll-A noun with another word that can be argued to be TP ll-A underlyingly. Examples include -rstru 'three' (13) and -f/'f/ We 'small'. find the following tonal patterns: 'three bones' z-iba zi-raru sindanu n-dr^ru 'three needles' ma-katili ma-r^ru 'three murderers' ma-djuniya ma-raru 'three sacks' shati i-titi i-tranda w-ana small 'a 'small children' wa-titi bunduki shirt' small bed' 'a i-titi 'a n-tinti small gun' Before proceeding to demonstrate that these surface forms follow let us make a few comments about the phonetic implementation of these structures. The pitch rises on the syllable that we have marked with an accent, and then descends sharply on the following syllable. automatically from our analysis, Under our analysis, the metrical structure of these phrases will be as in (14): * * (14) * * * [* ma-dju ni ya *] [*] ma- ra H H Meeussen's Rule plus the of its (*) (ru) an H tone is realized on the which syllable will be raised in pitch. principle that foot correctly predicts last syllable TP ll-A nouns have an H tone in They do not necessarily require that this H tone be on the penult of the noun. The H could have been on some earlier syllable than the penult. The next data that we will consider establishe more clearly that this H must be on the penult syllable. The preceding data help to establish that their underlying representation. (15) nd£ nd£ nd£ 16 le paha fuma 'the cat' 'the spear' zi-tranda 'the beds' 44 Studies in the Linguistic Sciences 19:1 (Spring 1989) nd£ nyfiha 'the snake' nd£ ze nyfiha 'the snakes' ndfi. 'the chicken' r]kuhu ndg m-pundra 'the donkey' nd£ le sungurwa 'the hare' ndfi she i-fuba nd£ nd£ nd£ le 'the chest' gunguno masikini siriwali 'the 'the knee' poor person' 'the pants' Notice that In every case the H tone contributed by the stabilizer appears on the syllable immediately preceding the penult of these nouns. In some cases this syllable is the definite particle (which may be coalesced with the stabilizer, as in ndQ nyoha), in other cases this may be the first stem syllable or even the second stem syllable. This pattern falls out from our analysis, provided that the noun has a High tone associated with the penult syllable. The metrical structure of ncfg masikini, for example, will be: (16) [* nde * *] masi H [* ki H ] (*) (ni) Again, Meeussen's Rule and the principle that realizes an H on the last syllable of the foot will correctly locate the position of the H tone in the expression. As mentioned earlier, the nouns in (8) represent only one subset of T&B's nouns. A second subset is contained in (17). We will refer to Tone Pattern these nouns as TP ll-B. II (17) pera 'guava', trunda (ma-runda) 'orange', m-dji 'town', mw-ango 'door', 'cow', ndzi(y)a 'road', fti-lfmi 'farmer', 'wall', djando 'wall', domo 'lip', ndovu 'elephant', m-be u-pando ndevu 'beard' These nouns are implemented with a raised (in fact, a rising) pitch on their penult syllable. (We do not underline this raised syllable here for reasons that will become clear below.) historical perspective, the nouns in (17) are characterized by the they derive from Proto-Bantu stems which did not contain an H tone. data illustrating this point are as follows: From a fact that Some (18) *-gen(^ 'stranger* (G. 805) m-djeni *-g6b|, 'skin' (G. 837) n-gozi *-g6ma 'drum' (G. 844) r)-g6ma *-gubd 'cloth' (G. 873) 'stranger* 'skin' r]-gu(w)o 'drum' 'clothes' Cassimjee & "path" (G. *-jicia *-yama 'meat' n-dzi(y)a 940) nyama (G. 1910) (G. 2170) *-yun|^ 'bird' When pronounced 45 Kisseberth: Shingazidjia nominal accent isolation, in we have tinguishable from the nouns nuni the TP 'bird' nouns ll-B referred to as 'road' 'meat' TP ll-A in (17) are indis- and which, we have seen, derive from noun stems with a (single) H associated to their penult Despite this overt lack of distinction between TP ll-A and TP ll-B syllable. nouns, they demonstrate contrastive patterns of behavior in context (although, as we will see below, there are forces at work in the language that may merge these two types in certain situations). in which TP ll-B nouns differ from TP ll-A nouns is illustrated in where these nouns are followed by words that are either Tone Type or Tone Type ll-A (i.e., words that either end in an H or have an H on their One way (19) below, I penult syllable). (19) u-pando djuu 'on the wall' djando djuii 'on the wall' r)-goma m-bili 'two drums' wa-ndru wa-i 'bad people' r)-goma n-tinti 'a small drum' 'big clothes' r)-guo n-kiiu wa-ndru wa-huu wa-ndru wa-raru Notice that the phrases foot in 'big people' 'three people' (19) are pronounced as though there — namely, the foot constructed over the is just one last syllable of djuu, -(b)ilL or -(b)f, If there were a syllable in the noun -kjiu, or -r^ru. an H tone, we would expect a foot to be constructed from that syllable to the penult syllable of djuu, and we would expect the last syllable of that foot to bear the only raised pitch in the phrase. Compare the data in (13) above for examples of Tone Pattern ll-A nouns which behave or the penult syllable of that was associated exactly In in this -titi, with fashion. other words, TP nouns ll-B not have any underlying H considering the pronunciation of nd£ le from trunda nd£ r)-guo nd£ le pera TP "the ll-B nouns orange' 'the clothes' guava' drum' ze r)-g6ma 'the drums' 'the ndg. r]-g6ma 'the nd£ ndQ u-pando 'the wall' ndfi m-limi TP ll-A nouns in that the former H associated do underlyingly Further evidence for this position derives from with their penult syllable. (20) differ while the latter have an 'the farmer' in the stabilized construction. 46 It Studies in the Linguistic Sciences 19:1 (Spring 1989) is important to make a comment about the phonetic implementation of the This syllable has the rising quality that is characteristic of TP II nouns in isolation. In other words, these phrases have the character of an H tone realized on the last syllable of a foot that is the only foot in the phrase. penult syllable in (20). If the nouns in (17) are regarded as having no underlying High tone, then a foot will be formed starting from the heavy (= H) stabilizer and extending as far as the penult syllable of the phrase (the last syllable is of course extrametrical). The H tone associated with the stabilizer will be realized on the last syllable of i.e. on the penult syllable of the phrase. TP ll-B nouns (cf. (15) will the foot have an entirely different pattern since there will be two feet one starting at the stabilizer and one on the penult syllable of the noun. — — We have now seen how the assumption that TP ll-B nouns are underan H tone will explain the differences in behavior between these nouns and TP ll-A nouns. What we have not yet said is why TP ll-B nouns surface, in isolation, with a shape identical to TP ll-A nouns. We turn to that lyingly without issue now. One notable fact about Shingazidja is that there are no independent words/expressions that are appropriately analyzed at the surface level as seems fair to assume that this lacking a High tone. Given this observation, surface lack of phrases without High tones must be attributed to the application of a rule. Given the analysis that we have developed, we have to assume a mle that assigns an H tone to any phrase lacking an H tone. It is not immediately clear where this H tone would be assigned. It could be assigned directly to the penult syllable (actually, given the extrametricality of the final syllable, the penult syllable is the same as 'the last (visible) syllable'). But it could also be assigned to some pre-penult syllable since under our analysis an H located on some pre-penult syllable would still surface on the penult. We turn below to an examination of where toneless words are assigned an H tone.^ it In order to provide some evidence about where the H tone is assigned to a toneless word, we must consider the case where the toneless word is itself followed by a modifier and this entire expression is placed after a stabilizer. Two pronunciations are available. (21) One wa-ndru wa-huu nd£ ze r)-goma n-tjnti ndfl pronunciation is illustrated in (21): 'the big people' 'the small drums' nd£ ze r)-goma m-bili 'the two drums' ndQ wa-ndru wa-ili 'the two people' In these pronunciations the toneless noun behaves just as we would expect a It has no H tone and therefore is incorporated into the toneless noun to behave. Cassimjee & Kisseberth: The foot that begins with the stabilizer. 47 Shingazidjia nominal accent stabilizer H will surface at the end of this foot. The second possible pronunciation of these phrases is given in (22): nda wa-ndru wa-hliiu ndg ze n-g^ma n-tlmti (22) wa-ndru wa-il!( ndfize n-gama m-bil!i ndfl clear that there are three feet Is It in these phrases, and the head of the located on the penult syllable of the noun. This is reflected by the fact that the H of the foot containing the stabilizer appears on the syllable immediately preceding the penult syllable of the noun. The H of the foot that second foot is begins with the penult syllable of the noun does not surface, of course, due to the application of Meeussen's Rule. Notice that the third foot is built over the H syllable of the modifier, and that the H of this foot does in fact surface (although We attribute the appearance of the H on the third foot to the it is downstepped). fact that Meeussen's Rule applies See below feet. for further iteratively from left to right, affecting alternate discussion of this point. can be explained as follows: A toneless noun may be an H in a phrase of the form stabilizer + noun + modifier. clear from (22) is that when a toneless noun is assigned an H, the The data (22) in optionally assigned What is H ___location of that Actually, nouns is is one the penult syllable. of the sources confusion between TP ll-A and TP pronounced the same in isolation, but of the not just the fact that they are ll-B that in certain contexts as a result of (a) the possibility of assigning toneless items and (b) the possibility of deleting underiying H In (23) we tones. The data in (22) above illustrated the former situation. illustrate the possibility of deleting the H tone of a TP ll-A noun. they fall together an H tone to ndfi (23) Or: she i-tranda nd£ she 'the bed' i-tranda nd£ sh-iba 'the Or: ndfi shfba Or: nd£ ze trunguu nd£ ze trunguu bone' zi-illi 'the ndfl wa-pisi wa-illi 'the Or: In nda two onions' zi-ili two cooks' wa-pisi wa-fli the alternative pronunciation, the noun has lost its H and thus has no heavy and is simply gathered together into the same foot as the stabilizer. syllable, 48 Studies in the Linguistic Sciences 19:1 (Spring 1989) What we have seen above is that there are situations where TP ll-A nouns High tone and situations where TP ll-B nouns can acquire a High tone. And the ___location of the H tone is always the same (i.e. penult). Because of these possibilities, the correct identification of nominals as TP ll-A and TP ll-B underlyingly is difficult. At the present time, we do not know for sure whether there are any morphological or syntactic (or semantic/pragmatic) environments can lose their between TP and TP between penult H and where the distinction toneless) invariably maintained. (In our data, the locative noun, formed with -nf, seems to maintain the contrast with consistency.) is the enclitic We ll-A ll-B (i.e. should observe that Philippson (1988), on the basis of T&B, suggests that Shingazidja consistently maintains the contrast (TP and ij-guo (TP ll-B). H, and 'non-marque' (In ll-A) lexical Philippson states: CWK] nous is between nouns like i-tr^nda the following quote, 'marque' is equivalent to a equivalent to lack of a lexical High tone.) de ces exempies nga. [= Shingazidja; FC & done une introduction simplifiiee aux mecanismes de 'La discussion fournit Simplifiee, car les autres dialectes de notre corpus ne nous fournissent pas d'exemples aussi clairs d'opposition entre themes marques et non-marques. En effet, tant en nzu. [= Shin(d)zuani; FC & CWK], que'en mwa. [= Shimwali; FC & CWK], dans le contexte syntaxique cite cidessus (nom. + adj.), I'ecrasante majorite des themes qui nous sont apparus non-marques en nga. ne se distinguent pas de ceux qui nous sont apparus I'accentuation comorienne. marques.' (49) To (24) illustrate this point, Philippson cites the following phrases: wa-ndru wa-i 'bad people' wa-ndru wa-titi 'small people' w-ana w-ana 'bad children' wa-i wa-titi 'small children' regard w-a_na as a TP ll-A noun and wa-ndru as a TP ll-B noun in The data in (24) from Shindzwani and Shimwali illustrate them being both treated as TP ll-A nouns. But as we have seen, they may be treated this way in Shingazidja as well. At this juncture it is not really dear that there is a difference between the dialects, and Shingazidja should not be viewed in any We Shingazidja. way as 5. 'simpler' in this respect. T&B's Tone Pattern III nouns We have now identified three distinct accentual structures for bisyllabic = toneless, H = High). In Philippson's account stems: OH, HO, and 00 (where of Shingazidja, these are in fact the only three types that he recognizes. However, T&B do have yet another tonal pattern in their account, and this tonal pattern indeed seems to have considerable validity to it, despite the fact that T&B often are mistaken in their identification of membership in this class. Cassimjee T&B characterize & TP Kissebenh: Shingazidjia nominal accent III 49 nouns as 'High+Low' (in contrast to the 'Mid+Low' Some examples of the nouns that we would pitch pattern of TPII nouns). as classify TP III are as follows. (25) bisvllabic stem u-shashi 'scarcity' u-nkab£ 'spoon' m-hiinga 'eel' 'tamarind tree' fti-hadju i-kflmb£ 'cup' (n)-kud£ n-dravi trisyllabic 'beans' 'banana' stem kuv£ti 'wash basin' kapiika 'can' fulfishi piichah kiidjime dfidflke 'spear' 'knife' 'rooster' 'a kind of vegetable' budume 'male goat' m-fiimatso 'blind person' dukut£ra 'doctor' ma-dukut£ra 'doctors' We do not believe that there is in fact any clear the syllables marked with an acute symbol marked syllables there a phonetic contrast. is in TP 'high' vs. 'mid' pitch contrast for (25) as TP particular, we the isolation form of In in II compared nouns. But with the acute- we do believe that believe that the syllable that is nouns in fact is equivalent to the raised syllable in an example such as ndg nyumba. 'the house' or sind^nu n-drg,ru 'three needles'. To be more precise, the phonetic implementation of the acute-marked syllables in (25) is parallel to ndg nyumba. in all cases except for the type puchari, where the phonetic implementation is parallel to sind^nu n-dr^ru. raised If in pitch in we are right in III our phonetic identification of the acute-marked syllables in nde nyumba and sind^nu n-drgru, then the analysis of the items in (25) is fairly easy to work out. Assuming that prefixes are without an H tone, then in the case of bisyllabic stems, there must be an H on each of the two syllables. In the case of thsyllabic nouns of the type kuveti, there are two possible sources, OHH or HOH; but below we will see that all of the examples so far available indicate OHH. In the case of trisyllabic nouns like puchari, there is only one possible source: HHO. (25) with the acute marked syllable in 50 Studies in the Linguistic Sciences 19:1 (Spring 1989) nouns and TP nouns is an audible it with any degree of reliability, as can be seen from the fact that in our opinion they misclassify a number of words as being TP III which should not be so classified. In a future study, we will provide an extensive lexicon of Shingazidja with the accentual structure The phonetic one, but T&B TP contrast between clearly were not able systematically marked. to III II recognize For that reason we will not attempt here to review all of Examples of nouns that T&B incorrectly pera 'guava' (actually 00), n-devu 'beard' (actually 00), gisi the examples misclassified by T&B. label TP III are: 'goose' (actually HO), pfho 'wing' (actually 00). If we are right in our analysis of the nouns in (25), it would be reasonable expect that these nouns might have their source in Proto-Bantu HH noun stems. Unfortunately most of the nouns that we have identified as TP III do not have Proto-Bantu sources known to us. One of those that does m-hiingo, 'eel' does have a PB source, and it is HH; cf. '-kurjga 'eel', G. 1228 And the examples kudume and bijdume can quite plausibly be argued to have such a double H source since the -dume part of these words is clearly derived from PB *-dume 'male' (G. 697) and the other part is a contraction of PB HL nouns, namely *-kuku 'chicken (G. 1203) and *-iJud('goat' (G. 185). But other examples of TP III are HL in PB, at least according to Guthrie's reconstructions: (n)kude. 'beans' (cf. *-kunde 'beans', G. 1222), u-nkQbs. 'spoon' (cf. *-k6mbe 'spoon', G. 1140), i-kQ.mbs, 'cup' (cf. *-k6mbe 'cup', G. 1139). Clearly, the historical development here is not entirely clear-cut. to — — The synchronic evidence for TP III nouns and their proper analysis derives not just from the isolation pronunciation of these nouns, but from the behavior of these items type is in Consider, for instance, the case where a noun of this context followed by djuu: biidiime djulu 'on a male goat' (26) washing bowl' a floor' on a tamarind tree' kuv£ti djulii 'on a large ikfimbfi djulii 'on m-hadju We djulii ' element djuii continues to have a raised final symbol is employed to indicate that this raised syllable is not raised to the same pitch level as the first raised syllable in the expression. We refer to this as 'downstepping'. have indicated that the syllable in these expressions, but the 'I' were understood as having just one H tone in their where the H on djuu. would be deleted by virtue of Meeussen's Rule and the H of the noun would be realized on the penult syllable of djuu. We would not predict in any way the pronunciations cited in (26). However, we accept the analysis suggested, where these nouns have two High tones, then an account of why the H remains on djuii is readily available. We hypothesize that Meeussen's Rule operates from If the nouns structure, then in (25) we would predict pronunciations if 1 Cassimjee an H & Kisseberth: Shingazidjia nominal accent one foot if the immediately preceding Meeussen's Rule guarantees that of three or more feet, alternating Highs will be deleted. Thus in second H of the noun will be deleted, the H of djulu will remain. left to right, deleting The in left-to-right application of 5 has an H. a sequence foot in (26), while the To complete our account of the phonetics of these phrases, we need only have downstep occur between each pair of H tones in the representation. This can doubtless be accomplished in terms of how the feet in a representation to are organized into larger, phrase-level metrical structures. But demonstration of this point in the interests of conserving space. Even more (27) evidence of the correctness of our account a stabilized form. striking placing these nouns in ndflm-hadjlu 'the nd£ mi'-hadjlii ndQ u-nkab!£ ndflm-hungla nd£ ndg we 'the 'the omit a comes from tamarind tree' tamarind trees' spoon' 'the eel' le kuv£t!i 'the le kapukia nd£puch!ari will washing bowl' 'the can' 'the knife' nd£ le kudlume nd£ le djidlfike nd£ madQdifike 'the rooster' 'the kinds of vegetable' 'the kinds of vegetables' ndj£ dukut£r!a 'the doctor' nd£ ma-dukut£r!s 'the doctors' these phrases were regarded as having a single H tone, this H tone to undergo Meeussen's Rule after the But in fact stabilizer and thus there would be just one H tone in the phrase. there are two High tones. And where these High tones are located is interesting. We will now proceed to go through all the data and show how the analysis we have suggested will account for the behavior of the nouns in these phrases. If then the nouns in we would expect Consider first the nouns with a bisyllabic stem. We have claimed that these must have an H on each syllable. Therefore, when placed after the stabilizer, which has an H, we find that these nouns will have their first H deleted by Meeussen's Rule but not their second H (in accordance with the alternating pattern observed earlier). Next take nouns like kuveti. We suggested that there are two possible underlying sources: HOH or OHH. The data cited demonstrate that for the nouns given, the representation must be OHH. In (28) we show the incorrect representation. Studies in the Linguistic Sciences 19:1 (Spring 1989) 52 * (28) [ * *] * [* * *] [*] kuve ti nde le H H H This representation would incorrectly predict that the H of the first foot would be realized on le. The representation in (29) correctly predicts that the H of the first foot will be realized on ku. * (29) [ * * * * *] [*] [*] nde le ku ve ti H H H Next take nouns representation: HHO. like puch^ri. The data in We claim that this has only one possible If the noun (27) support this representation. has an initial HH sequence, the foot built over the stabilizer will be able to extend only as far as the syllable in front of pu.chs,ri. The initial H of puchQhwW delete by Meeussen's Rule, but the second H will surface. This is exactly what happens. A noun like dukuts^ra. could have any of the following representations: OOHH, HOOH, or OHOH. All of these representations would have an initial foot whose last syllable is the penult vowel of the word. The data given in (27) suggest that OOHH is the correct representation, since the foot built over the stabilizer extends as far as the second syllable of dukutQrQ. (Recall that how far the foot extends is shown by where the H of the first foot is manifested.) We should mention that there seems to be a certain amount of variability in these 'double-H' nouns, and that at the present time we do not have a clear grasp of all that is involved in this variability. Nevertheless, the existence of this class of nouns is well-established. The tonal representations that we have motivated for TP III nominals involves a violation of the OCR, which claims that HH is not a permitted representation. While we do not believe that the OCR is an absolute principle of phonology at the underlying level of representation, it is a constraint that undoubtedly influences phonological representations and processes. The variability in TR III nouns may in the final analysis be a product of the tension created We have shown by the HH shape for bisyllabic they manifest. noun stems and HH. four possible tonal types: OH, HO, 00, in Shingazidja that there are have not yet done a suf- We ficiently extensive study of the lexicon to determine exactly how many tonal types are possible in trisyllabic noun stems. We suspect that there may be some significant gaps (e.g. HOO and 000 are so far suspiciously absent, sug- Cassimjee & Kisseberth: 53 Shingazidjia nominal accent gesting a constraint on representations that does not permit nominals to end two toneless syllables), but a full study of this must await another occasion. 6. T&B's Tone Patterns A, in and C B, Why do T&B not simply stop in their classification scheme with the three and III? One reason should be obvious: Since T&B's TP Tone Patterns actually lumps together HO and 00 nouns, and since these nouns show distinct II II, I, patterns of behavior some contexts, nothing in T&B's classification would HO and 00 nouns into separate categories. What T&B in permit segregating our do to solve this problem is to establish three 'context patterns' and to say that nouns are classified both for their isolation shape and the context pattern that they are involved in. They refer to the three context patterns as A, B, and C. The context that they use as their test case is one they refer to as a 'genitive' construction. In this construction, a noun is followed by a particle AG-a (where AG = an agreement element determined by the noun class membership of the head noun) plus a possessive root. The examples cited mostly involve the possessive root -ghe, but occasionally T&B cite -Qngu, first person. T&B actually are not always correct in their transcriptions of the first person cases, and since they do not recognize that the two possessive roots have different accentual properties, they run into problems in making accurate general descriptions of their A, B, and C tone patterns. T&B characterize occasionally with the High. The Tone of the Some examples (30) TP A la is kapwa hahe le soha ye le la High. are as follows: 'his ye nyumba ya hahe le 'The tone of the noun is Mid level, or The tone of the Genitive Particle is Mid + Low or Low + Low' (361 ). as follows: Possessor of soha le TP A final syllable h^he axe' 'his house' 'his armpit' hanglu 'my a^e' 'my house' kapwa la hanglu 'my armpit' la nyumbaya h^nglu ye m-buzi ya hahe 'his goat' wo m-hfino wa hahe 'his arm' wo u-lime wa hahe 'his tongue' ye m-buzi ya hanfliu 'my goat' wo m-h^no wa hanglii 'my arm' wo u-lime wa hanglji 'my tongue' Some comments about T&B's description of the noun occasionally having a final syllable of final TP A H seems are in order. The reference to where the to refer to situations the noun and the genitive particle AG+a contract. We will not 54 Studies in the Linguistic Sciences 19:1 (Spring 1989) on There indeed considerable contraction in Shingait to the extent of determining whether it interacts in any cmcial way with the matters dealt with in the present paper. With reference to T&B's claim that there are two possible shapes for the possessive root, viz. Mid + Low or Low + Low, we find only one pattern for the third person possessive and only one pattern for the first person possessive. But they are different. The syllables that T&B described as 'Mid + Low' (cf. the possessive in ye nyumba. ya h^he, for example) have the following phonetic implementation in our experience: The first syllable of the possessive shows a clearly audible descent from the high of the -a particle, while the second syllable is low in pitch. The syllables that T&B describe as 'Low + Low' (cf. the possessive in ye nyumba. ya ha.ng!ii) have the following phonetic implementation in our experience: The H of the -a particle descends during the initial syllable of the possessive, while the second syllable exhibits a rise that is downstepped relative to previous Highs. dwell at all this matter. zidja speech, but we have is not investigated T&B recognize that all of their TP nouns (OH nouns in our analysis) also TP A. Some of T&B's TP nouns are also in TP A. Those TP nouns that are in TP A are simply those that have the structure HO. Our 00 nouns and our HH nouns are never in TP A. I exhibit II II Tone Pattern B is characterized by T&B as follows: 'The Tone of the noun and the Genitive Particle are Mid level. The Tone of the Possessive is Mid falling (occasionally High falling) + Low' (362). Some examples (31) Or: Or: T&B's TP B are as follows: ye r)-guo ya hahe 'his clothes' ye r]-giio ya hahe ye ngoma ya hahe 'his drum' ye rj-g^ma ya hahe ye ^-Qii.0 ya hanglu 'my clothes' hanglii 'my orange' ye r]-gama ya hanglu 'my drum' ye r]-goma ya hangu le Or: of trunda la The alternatives cited involve the possible assignment of an H to the penult of toneless nouns even when these nouns appear in conjunction with other elements bearing an H tone (i.e., even when the phrase is not toneless in its entirety). we should comment first of all on T&B's description of the pattern. + Low' is not clear to us. It seems clearly to be referring to the third person possessive root, but we are not certain whether it is referring to the pronunciation in ye ij-goma ya hQhe or ye rj-go^ma ya h^he. Again The reference to 'Mid falling In & Kisseberth: Cassimjee 55 Shinga2ddjia nominal accent syllable of the possessive in the former example has a the second example that same syllable shows a descent from the previous High syllable. Thus it would seem that T&B are referring to the second pronunciation when they speak of 'Mid falling'. However, they do our experience, the first rising quality, while in not their description in make reference to the appearance of a raised pitch on the genitive particle. the other hand, T&B's 'High falling + Low' cases can, from T&B's actual be seen to refer to the first person possessive root in the pronun- On transcriptions, where the noun q-goma ya hi,ngu. ciation In TP B, T&B treated as toneless, is place some TP II They also place some nouns analysis. nouns in this i.e. — the in pronunciations ones that are like ye in our 00 pattern that they identify as TP III. these instances, they are simply mistaken in their identification of these nouns as TP III. The nouns they have misclassified here are: mw-ili 'body', i-levu 'chin', rv-limi 'farmer', pera 'guava', w-embe 'razor'. All of these nouns In are in fact T&B wholly or examples — 00 nouns i.e. TP ll-B. describe Tone Pattern C as follows: 'The tone of the noun stem is part higher than that of the genitive, which is as in B' (363). Some in are: wo u-nkab£wa (32) le wo le hiahe kuv^ti la hlahe 'his spoon' 'his basin' wa hlgngu 'my spoon' hiangu 'my basin' u-nk(ib£ kuv£ti la noun consists of two feet. The third person possessive has one foot, person possessive has two feet. In all cases, the H of the first foot of the noun will be realized. And, since Meeussen's Rule applied iteratively from left to right, the H of the third foot (which is the first foot in the possessive root) will A Type the III first also manifest these cases is itself, but it will be downstepped. Clearly, T&B's description of roughly accurate. nouns and some of their TP III place some of their TP nouns they place here are in fact the ones that they have correctly identified (i.e., ones that have two H tones in our analysis). The TP nouns placed in this pattern are ones that T&B have misclassified. In other (of the HO variety) but TP III (HH). The misclassified words, they are not TP nouns are: i-kQmbQ 'cup', n-dz^a 'child-bearing', and n-drjcw 'banana'. In nouns. TP C, T&B The TP II III II II What we have seen, then, is that TP A is characteristic of HO and OH nouns, while TP B is characterstic of 00 nouns, and TP C is characteristic of HH nouns. In other words, the context patterns cited do bring out the distinction between HO and 00 nouns (which T&B treated together as TP II), but they have Studies in the Linguistic Sciences 19:1 (Spring 1989) 56 no other bearing on the classification some nouns and forms that led [= HO], MB the fact that T&B of nouns. It HO and 00 nouns to claim six different classes of [= 00], IIIA [erroneous classification], is T&B's misclassification are identical — in their of isolation i.e. lA [= OH], IIA nominals [erroneous classification], IIIB andlllC[=HH]. 8. Philipsson's analysis We have so far (a) motivated our classification of Shingazidja nominals and compared it to T&B's classification, and (b) presented an analysis based on the four-way distinction of bisyllabic stems into OH, 00, HO, and HH. We have demonstrated that this analysis will predict a wide range of data involving nouns in isolation and in context (although we have certainly not surveyed the full range of tonal contexts). In the remainder of this paper, we will summarize Philippson's (1988) analysis of Comorian accent, which includes an account of Shingazidja (based on T&B's data). In terms of the general character of the system, Shingazidja (= Ng.) does not seem to differ radically from the two dialects that Philippson primarily concentrates on: Shin(d)zuani (= Nz.) Shimwali (= and fvlw.) Philippson proposes that in the underlying structure of Shingazidja, vowels are either 'accented' or not. For the sake of clarity, however, we will refer to such syllables as 'marked' versus 'unmarked' (since the notion of 'accent' will also be invoked by Philippson in the sense of metrical prominence, and for him metrical prominence and a 'marked' syllable do not necessarily coincide). There are no tonal specifications. To this extent, Philippson's proposal is essentially the variant of our analysis presented unmarked in phrase-final syllables are extrametrical, just as 3. Furthermore, our analysis. note in But his analysis diverges radically from ours when it comes to the process on the basis of accented syllables. He proposes that feet are right-dominant in Shingazidja (not left-dominant, as we maintain). He does not, however, attempt to give a single definition of how to build feet; for of building metrical structure example, he does not say: Build right-dominant, unbounded, quantity-sensitive feet starting at the right edge of a phrase (where 'marked' syllables would be metrically heavy). Rather, he goes through the following separate procedures. (We will see below why a general foot-building strategy will not work, under his assumption that feet are right-dominant.) When in a phrase is marked, he proposes that a over that syllable. In the case where there are no other marked syllables, Philippson assumes that nothing more will happen, except for the earlier syllables being gathered together into that single foot (although this step plays no critical role in his account of the data as we understand it). the last (visible) syllable 'degenerate' foot is built Cassimjee & Kisseberth: 57 Shingazidjia nominal accent Thus for Philippson, nouns such as soha_ and i-trstnda will have the following metrical structure (once the syllables in front of the accented vowel are gathered together into the foot): * (33) [* * *] [* *] i-tra soha ( *) (nda) He then assumes that an LH tonal melody is inserted, with the H linked to the accented syllable. Since we are not actually going to be concerned here with any aspect of the pronunciation other than the syllable that is the locus of the High tone, in our discussion we will just discuss the H and omit any reference to the Low part of the melody. Why does Philippson want to say that 'degenerate' feet are built over the a phrase if it is marked? In the above examples, where last (visible) syllable in there is just one marked syllable, he turns around and allows the earlier sylsame foot as that final marked syllable. lables to be gathered together into the Why does he not want just to build right-dominant, quantity-sensitive feet startedge of a phrase? The answer comes from how he proposes to deal with phrases where there are two marked syllables. ing at the right Before discussing these phrases, we should note that Philippson proposes is the initial is a single metrical prominence in a phrase, and that foot in the phrase that has this prominence. He proposes to achieve this result by assigning prominence to the left-most foot in a phrase. He then proposes that the LH tonal melody is inserted only on the accented syllable in the phrase. We will have more to say about this aspect of Philippson's analysis below. that there it meza, djuu, where an H is manifested on the Given that the last syllable of mezg and djuii are marked, if in this phrase we built right dominant, unbounded, quantity-sensitive feet starting at the right edge of the phrase, we would have a metrical structure such as: Recall, now, phrases like syllable in front of the final syllable of djuu- * (34) [* *] me za If we [* dju *] u then accented the left-most foot the head of this foot, this result, we would in the phrase, and assigned an H tone incorrecty derive 'mezQ, djuu. 'n to order to avoid Philippson proposes an entirely different strategy for building feet. After having built degenerate feet over the last (visible) syllable if it is marked, Philippson proposes a second foot construction pattern that will be triggered just in the event the phrase has more than one marked syl- 58 Studies in the Linguistic Sciences 19:1 (Spring 1989) lable. This second foot construction procedure to building right-dominant, left, unbounded will apply iteratively from right feet that will extend as tar as, but not pass, a marked syllable. mez^ djuu, the procedures work as a degenerate foot is built over the last syllable of the phrase, since it is marked. Second, since there is another marked syllable, the second foot constnjction procedure will come into play. It will build a right-dominant foot starting at the right-most unfooted syllable (which is the first vowel of djuu). This i.e. as far as the foot will extend as far to the left as the next marked syllable final vowel of mez^. No further feet will be constructed, since there are no more marked syllables in the expression (though the initial syllable of mezs, will be gathered together into the following foot). Next the left-most foot will be accented, and an H tone will be associated with the head of that accented foot. And this is the crucial point: For Philippson, the head of the first foot in the expression is the syllable immediately to the left of the final (degenerate) foot! Thus Philippson proposes to account for the appearance of the H immediately In the case of an expression such as follows. First, — to the left of the final We marked syllable. can now see why a degenerate built on a final marked a foot starting at the marked final syllable, and if this foot extended as far as the preceding marked syllable, then there would be no way to get the first syllable of djuu to be the head of a foot and thus no way, in Philippson's analysis, to get an H tone associated with that vowel. For Philippson, High tones only occur on the heads of feet. syllable. If in the expression mezQ djuu To complete Philippson's account has no mark, a foot will be constructed syllable is extrametrical) of foot we must be built Shingazidja accentuation, if a phrase starting at the penult (since the ultimate and continuing in unbounded fashion leftward. The usual rule assigning an H to the metrically prominent syllable will again come into play. Thus Philippson accounts for the raising of the penult syllable in unmarked words (00 words One in our analysis). feature of Philippson's account needs to be expanded on. The claim a single accented syllable in a 'phrase' is a bit misleading, since Philippson in fact uses the foot structure to define the 'phrase'. In particular, the account that he gives of Shimwali seems to coincide with the observations that we have made for Shingazidja: 'Pour le mwa., la situation est, en principe, plus simple, puisque les groupes accentuels ne peuvent comporter plus de deux pieds. Si une syntagma comporte trois pieds ou plus, le decoupage se fait normalement par groupe de deux pieds, de gauche a droite' (76). What Philippson is describing here is presumably what we have expressed earlier in terms of claiming that (a) Meeussen's Rule applies to High tones iteratively, in an alternating pattern, from left to right, and (b) there is downstep between each pair of High tones. that there is just Cassimjee & Kisseberth: 59 Shingazidjia nominal accent Having summarized Philippson's account of Comorian, let us briefly why we prefer the analysis presented above to his. The major objection Philippson's account is the diversity of foot-building procedures and the lack universality of these procedures. Why should there be a degenerate foot built review to of over final (visible) syllables that are marked? And why should the syllables preceding these marked syllables be gathered into a foot just in case there is a preceding marked syllable? And why should the foot being constructed to the left of the marked cedures seem phonology. to final syllable go up to and include the mark? be entirely arbitrary and unmotivated in terms These pro- of universal the advantage that there is just one type of unbounded, quantity-sensitive, a type of foot that is certainly predicted by universal phonology. The fact that the H tone is realized on the is realized on the head of a foot) last syllable of a foot (whereas in Philippson does not seem to us objectionable on any universal grounds. There seems to us to be considerable evidence that metrical structure may determine the surface realization of High tone, but no evidence that the ___location of a High tone necessarily correlates with the head of a metrical foot.^ The analysis we propose has foot: left-dominant, it H tone realized on the last and by invoking Meeussen's Rule, we explain the tonal shape of phrases containing no H tone, one H tone, two H tones, three H tones, four H tones, and so on. By making feet left-dominant, but having the syllable of a foot, 9. Conclusion We have presented here what we believe represents a classification of Shingazidja nominals which can serve as the basis for predicting the shape of a nominal both in isolation and in context. Furthermore, we have developed an analysis that involves 'foot' construction that is familiar from universal grammar: left-dominant, unbounded, quantity-sensitive feet. We believe that the analysis presented has validity beyond the nominal, and in fact operates in the verbal conjugation and the phrasal tonology as well. We leave it to another occasion, however, to demonstrate the validity of our analysis in this wider ___domain. We hope to have demonstrated that Shingazidja largely preserves the Proto-Bantu tonal system, but integrates it with a metrical system that explains why there is no very direct correlation between the ___location of Proto-Bantu tones and the surface realization of High tones in the language. We also hope to have demonstrated the fruitfulness of exploring Bantu tone in terms of metrical structure. We do not claim that all Bantu tone systems display the effects of metrical structure, but we do suggest that the history of Proto-Bantu tone in the Sabaki languages of East Africa is the story of the ways in which tone and metrical structure may become interlinked. Studies in the Linguistic Sciences 19:1 (Spring 1989) 60 NOTES Of course, no one can guarantee that we have not mistakenly attributed Sonne phonetic phenomena to the realm of 'implementation' when they should be considered to have an account in terms of the very structures that we are dealmg with In the present paper. We have systematically attempted throughout the paper to offer some comments on implementation, but we feel that detailed phonetic exploration is needed in order to validate these comments in detail. 2For discussion of Meeussen's Rule see Goldsmith 1984. 3|t might be objected that the insertion of an H on the last visible syllable of a phrase lacking any H tones is rather arbitrary from a purely tonal point of view. And indeed it is. However, in a system where H tone has become equated with metrical prominence, the insertion of a High tone is equivalent to the insertion of prominence. In the event that the reader is unwilling to accept the notion of a rule assigning H (= metrical prominence) to the last (visible) syllable of words lacking H (= metrical prominence), we can reshape our analysis as follows. Suppose that we were to assume that Shingazidja has reinterpreted ProtoBantu High tones as being 'accents'; in other words, lexical items do not have High tones, but rather have some syllables marked as the (obligatory) heads of Given these heads, left-dominant unbounded feet are constructed. let us assume that an H tone is associated by rule with the last syllable of each foot, and that f\/leeussen's Rule applies to delete the second of two successive High tones. Under this analysis, TP ll-B nouns lead us to assume that when an unaccented word is the only word in the phrase, will be assigned an accent on the last (visible) syllable. We have now produced the same results as under the analysis in the text. The only difference is that in this analysis, High tones are assigned on the basis of foot structure and are not lexical; in the other analysis, foot structure is based on H tones, and H tones may be lexical or inserted by rule. We will not seek to choose between these two approaches, since at present it is not clear what sort of evidence could choose between them. feet. Furthermore, it To Appear for a discussion of metrical structure in Chishown that heads do attract H tones, but where is also the "^See Kisseberth zigula, where it is case that some High tones cannot to H tones. it link to heads and some heads are not linked Cassimjee & Kisseberth: 61 Shingazidjia nominal accent REFERENCES Goldsmith, Aronoff J. & rule. Language sound structure, ed. by M. Cambridge, MA: MIT Press. Comparative Bantu, v. 2. Farnborough, Hants., England: 1984. Meeussen's R. T. Oehrle. Guthrie, M. 1971. Gregg International Publishers, Ltd. Kisseberth, C. To Appear. Metrical structure in Chizigula tonology. A festchrift honor of E. O. J. Westphal. University of Capetown. Philippson, G. 1988. L'accentuation du comorien, essai d'analyse metrique. Etudes d'ocean indien 9.35-79. Paris. Tucker, A. N., and M. A. Bryan. 1970. Tonal classification of nouns in Ngain zidja. African Language Studies 11.351-382. the Linguistic Sciences Number 1, Spring 1989 Studies in Volume 19, ON THE REPRESENTATION OF KEJIA DIPHTHONGS* Raung-fu Chung most other Chinese dialects, Kejia has at most four sega syllable, which form a sequence of consonant-glidevowel-consonant (or glide). This paper argues that a rising diphthong GV occupies one single skeletal slot, whereas a falling diphthong VG occupies two slots in the skeletal tier. This proposal is based on the postulate that there theory advanced in Schane 1987. In addition, are at most three skeletal slots for a Kejia syllable. This assumption accounts for the generalization that no falling diphthong can be followed by a consonant. Furthermore, it is shown that a branching nucleus, i.e. a falling diphthong, behaves differently from a branching rime, which is composed of a nucleus vowel and a coda consonant. Like ments within I 1. Introduction This paper discusses the diphthong representations in Kejia, one of the Chinese dialects spoken in southern China and part of Taiwan. Like most other Chinese dialects, Kejia allows at most four segments in a syllable, with the eventual form appearing as CGVC (or G), where G is a glide. Another generalization is that no consonant can follow a falling diphthong, whereas a hsing diphthong can precede a coda consonant. This is illustrated as follows. (1) a. yam/p ex. Studies in the Linguistic Sciences 19:1 (Spring 1989) 64 The generalization that no consonant can follow a falling diphthong cannot accept the syllable structure posited in traditional Chinese linguistics given in (2), because if there are four slots in a syllable, there is no reason to prevent a consonant from occupying the coda position. In particular, syllables like *tuin or *tiun cannot be ruled out by (2), for both u and / can be a glide or a vowel, and there are no more than four segments. be captured (2) if The we traditional representation $ \ / F I / R N I F: final rime nucleus E: ending N: E I I initial R: \ / I syllable I: M: medial \ M $: I XXX X propose, following Kaye (1985) and Schane (1987), that Kejia has two diphthong representations. The first one is for falling diphthongs, in which there are two slots in the skeletal tier, as given in (3a). The other is for rising diphthongs, which are linked to a single slot in the skeletal tier, as shown I distinct in (3b). N a. (3) / X I I a y RD (4) \ X X / FD b. BR c. $ $ $ / \ \ \ / \ / R R R / I I I 1 I I N I N I N I I I I I X X I p y / / XX \ I I pa \ X I y XX i I pa \ C I X 1 n To account for the generalization that no falling diphthong can precede a consonant, postulate that there are at most two skeletal slots in a rime. On this background, a rime containing more than two segments has three possible structures as in (4) above, to take ^^pya 'to run', ^^pay 'cripple', and ^^pan 'to I On Chung: move' as examples. (FD BR a branching rime.) the representation of Kejia diphthongs for is a falling diphthong, RD a rising 65 diphthong, and Since a rising It follows from (4) that either N or R branches, but not both. diphthong occupies a single skeletal slot within a non-branching N in (4a), it is possible for a rising diphthong to occur in a branching N, as shown in (5a), or to occur in a branching R, as in (5b). Examples can be seen in ^^tyaw 'bird' and sspyan 'to avoid'. N a. (5) R b. \ / / / \ \ XX XX / yaw I y \ I a n However, as shown in (4b), a rime having a falling diphthong occupies two There is therefore no possibility of having another skeletal slot in N. This why forms such as 'ayn and those in (lb) are ungrammatical. slots. is a prevocalic glide should be be explored in Section 2. In addition, if a falling diphthong is represented as in (4b) while a branching rime is as in (4c), there must be some phonological differences between a branching rime and a non-branching rime. Those differences will be discussed Section 5 provides further evidence of distinguishing a in Sections 3 and 4. branching N from a branching R. Section 6 presents a summary and conIf a rising diphthong is represented as part of the rime instead of part of the onset. in (4a), This will clusion. The data are transcribed in the IPA system with tone marked by a The phonetic inventories superscript Arabic numeral preceding each syllable. of Kejia are (6) a. as follows ([ ] is ' consonants for aspiration).'' Studies in the Linguistic Sciences 19:1 (Spring 1989) 66 c. 1. tone MM Chung: (9) On the representation of Kejia diphthongs a. pray for bread b. pay for 67 ^ bray for pread bay for preeze breeze ^ The salient difference between Kejia and English is that English allows consonant clusters in the onset as well as in the coda position, as in tree and palm, though they are subject to some constraints (Clements & Keyser 1983, Sohn 1987). However, save the CG sequence in the beginning part of a syllable, no GC, CG, or even CC occurs in any other position within a Kejia syllable. Thus in terms of syllabic pattern, if G in Kejia is assumed to be part of an onset, then there is an asymmetry between the consonant clusters in that they occur only in the onset but not in the coda (cf. Clements and Keyser 1983). The argument based on English is therefore not relevant for the analysis of Kejia. 2.2. Colloquial and literary differences In the phonological relationship between the literary and colloquial levels speech, there are certain cases in which the onset is different while the rime remains the same, as shown in (10a) and (10b). 2 in other cases, only the rime is different and the onset is the same, as shown in (10c) and (lOd). of (10) Studies in the Linguistic Sciences 19:1 (Spring 1989) 68 initial consonants remain the same in the colloquial except for the palatalization of dentals before y. What differs in (10c) the literary form has GV, is the (glide plus) vowel that follows the initial, while the colloquial one has a plain vowel; in (lOd) the relationship is reversed. However, in both cases the change is limited to the combination glide plus vowel, suggesting that both are members of the rime. In and (10c) and (10d), the literary levels, To sum between the up, the difference affects only the rime or only the onset.3 with the rime, suggesting that Tone and the 2.3. A i.e. syllable with [11] tone. initial it is In literary and the colloquial levels either case, the prevocalic glide stays part of the rime. consonant a voiceless unaspirated consonant cannot have yangping, The condition is given voiceless, unaspirated consonants in in (12), where L Kejia are: p, t, is ts, tc, yangping tone. and k. The *L (12) I $ I I -voice -spread This condition applies without regard to the presence of a prevocalic glide, suggesting that the prevocalic glide is not part of the onset. In (13), Arabic numerals like 44, 31, and 55 show that a voiceless unaspirated consonant can occur in syllables with other tones. 11 (13) a. b. tone 33 kyang tyam c. pyen d. tcyang The condition in (12) has a historical motivation. Words with yangping in Kejia (among other Chinese dialects) came from words with a voiced Specifically, the voiced onset initial consonant in Middle Chinese (Tung 1968). consonant of MC underwent a rule of devoicing if it occurred in a yangping syllable regardless of the presence of a prevocalic glide or not. The historical change thus provides further evidence for the suggestion that a prevocalic glide is part of the rime. Chung: 2.4. Rhymes in folk On the representation of Kejia diphthongs 69 songs Kejia has folk songs, usually referred to as shangge 'mountain songs', of which more than 300 have been studied. The general rule for rhyming is that the nucleus vowels must be identical, while following consonants may differ, as shown in the examples below. (14) a. 33tc'im Hfin 33cim 70 Studies in the Linguistic Sciences 19:1 (Spring 1989) If we consider the distribution of prevocalic y, it is clear that there are no cooccurrence restrictions between initials and following glides; all combinations are possible, as illustrated in (16). As for prevocalic w, the case is more complex, because it can be preceded only by the velars k, k', and h, as shown in (17) below. This raises the question whether w should be regarded as part of the onset. (16) 1 On Chung: 2.6. the representation of Kejia diphthongs 7 Summary The overall evidence examined in this section is in favor of the claim that prevocalic glides are not part of the onset but occupy a position within the nucleus. 3. The construction of diphthongs no constraint on the combination of the initial consonant and is a dissimilatory constraint on the formation of diphthongs, whether combinations of a prevocalic or a postvocalic glide plus a vowel. The dissimilatory constraint, which is given in (18), states that glides and vowels cannot agree in their specification for the feature [back]. The constraint works under the assumption that the feature specification for vowels is as in (19), where the low vowel [a] is underspecified for the feature [back] (cf. Steriade 1987). While there is the prevocalic glide, there (1 Dissimilatory Constraint 8) (first version) *N / / [aback] Back feature (19) \ \ [aback] specification back + u, i, e a The constraint (20) a. in *ye (18) precludes the following b. *ey On diphthongs *wo *ow the other hand, the following diphthongs are allowed. (21) a. falling diphthongs 55tyy 'team' ^^loy 'to ay iw ssppay 'to sell' 55kjw 'long' ew aw 33t'ew 'to steal' 33paw 'to uy oy ex. come' wrap' in Kejia. Studies in the Linguistic Sciences 19:1 (Spring 1989) 72 b. is rising diphtfiongs ya yo 55pya -to 33k'yo 'cripple' wa we 33kwa 'melon' 55kvve 'very' run' Given below are the [back] feature specifications for (20) and (21), where A Only C is ungrammatical, being in for (21a), B for (21b) and C for (20). violation of the Dissimilatory Constraint. (22) A. uy [ + ] [-] B. ya yo wa we [-] [ ] [-] [+] [ + ] [ [ + ] [-] ] C. *ye *ey *wo *ow [-] [-] [-] [-] [ + ] [ + ] [ + ] [ + ] By connparing (23) with (22A) and (22B), we further realize that the first segment of a rising diphthong and the second of a falling diphthong must be [+high]. (23) a Chung: The evidence On of the behavior of the triphthongs requires the following modification of the Dissimilatory Constraint (26) 73 the representation of Kejia diphthongs Dissimilatory Constraint (final in (18). version) *N / \ \ / / [aback] \ (X) [aback] where X is a segment In other words, no two segments with the same value for the feature [back] can occur within a nucleus position, no matter if another segment intervenes. The fact that the Dissimilatory Constraint affects not only also GV and GVG combinations provides strong — and I VG combinations, but believe, conclusive — evidence that prevocalic glides are part of the same structure as vowels and postvocalic glides, namely, part of the nucleus. "* 4. The construction of branching rimes If the combination of the nucleus vowel and the following consonant is not a diphthong but a branching rime (henceforth, BR), then we would expect constraints on a BR to be different. This is indeed true, as will be demonstrated in the following discussion. First of all, as shown in (27) and (28), a labial or velar consonant and a vowel forming a BR must agree in their values for the feature [back]; otherwise, ungrammatical forms result. Contrast the (a) and (b) versions in (27) and (28). (27) labials or [-back] JMBBSBC !^ % Wl 1^ "= I'iS T.'f are- Tcr ae --£ :2r T5 3racE£2rc 2SI—sSCT STOWS, trec S X ——-35=:- — 2S — -- s- -' - i -- --' — 1 - ------ — —-- 'T' 5*^23«g- r^.~-'~- - "t-: i-r :>«. 1 -~z~T ~ri_n: (36) i-z --,,;-; -fi*" r 55 76 Studies in the Linguistic Sciences 19:1 (Spring 1989) (38) a. *om/p *um/p Following Yip (1987) and Steriade (1987), the distributions of labial segments are attributed to the Labial Constraint in (39). Labial Constraint (39) *[+lab The +lab]j To begin round vowel are specified for other words, the specification for the [labial] feature in UR is as Labial Constraint applies under the following assumptions. with, only the labial [+lab] in ... UR. In consonants and the front follows. (40) Lab The application of the coda rule in the sense of Steriade 1984 triggers the a syllable does not have a coda, back vowels will not have the [lab] feature. The Labial Constraint thus succeeds Examples are in accounting for the labial distributions in (35) through (38). given in (41), in which [+] stands for [+labial]. [+lab] feature specification for (41) a. *pam back vowels. b. If *pu c. *tom d. 55p >po 'newspaper' UR [ CV [+] +] + ] [ [+] [ [ p a m p a m I ] [ I P + ] u + [ +] [+] o m t [ ] u I 1/ R P o +] I I O R +] torn 1/ O R + I O R [ [ ] P o I I + I torn I ] [ + 1 torn Labial [ t I R p a m lab specify [ [+] [+] I + I I R Coda ] P 1 I + ] Chung: In On the representation of Kejia diphthongs 77 (41a) and (41b), the [+lab] feature for the consonants and u is underThey are thus clear violations of the Labial Constraint. The lyingly specified. back vowel o leads the o becomes However, the coda rule and hence "torn finds no chance to apply, so the underspecified for the feature is in [lab]. (41c) to be specified for the [lab] feature, ill-formed. In (41 d), the coda back vowel o remains underspecified rule for the [lab] feature. This accounts for why (41 d) is grammatical. However, this analysis runs into great difficulties, in that a cooccur with the labial glide w in the coda position, as shown in 55pay^ 'leopard' b. 55p'aw 'firecracker' c. 55maw 'to (42) a. The asymmetry labial onset can (42). buy' that a labial onset not with a labial consonant has long can cooccur with a final labial glide but been a problem both in the traditional analysis (Light 1977) and in non-linear analyses (Yip 1987, Steriade 1987). One of the contributions of our proposal here is to help make the Labial Constraint work more successfully: If falling diphthongs are [+syll] units, as suggested in Chung 1989, then the glide in (42) is dominated by the nucleus and is therefore the vowel [u] in UR. And since [u] is not specified for the feature [lab], is immune to the Labial Constraint, and paw is grammatical. it 6. Conclusion I have argued nucleus. In that the prevocalic glide within addition, I have argued that, with the a Kejia syllable is part of the representation of diphthongs the generalization is captured that a falling diphthong cannot be followed by another consonant, because there is no other skeletal slot left. Moreover, the difference between a falling diphthong and a rime, both of which look the same in that they occupy the last two positions in a syllable, cannot be accounted for without appealing to the representations given in (3). (See also below.) Finally, the diphthong representations suggested here also account for the asymmetry of the labial coda consonant and the labial offglide with respect to the Labial in (3), Constraint. me conclude with a brief summary of the arguments in favor of the between diphthongs/triphthongs and branching rimes, and with a summary of the rules and representations that account for the distinction. Let structural distinction We have seen that diphthongs and triphthongs are subject to DC and thus must be considered dominated by N. Further, nucleus vowels and the final consonants of branching rimes are subject to the BRC, suggesting that these structures are dominated by a different node, R. Now, what needs to be accounted for is that combinations of the type yam/p are possible, while 78 Studies in the Linguistic Sciences 19:1 (Spring 1989) We Structures of the type *aym/p are not. and can account if we accept the assumptions in (44) for this of rime stnjcture in (43) together with the additional account (45). R N (43) * N(+C) -* X (+ X) Rising diphthongs are analyzed as light diphthongs (44) (cf. Kaye 1985): N I X / y A (45) \ a may rime more than two not contain As a consequence, the rime the following combinations and structure rules skeletal slots. will be permitted to generate to generate the starred structures fail and (c') (d-): R (a) R (b) N N (C) X / a (m) y a *R / N / II I ay / (b) / I X \ way I C \ / \ w a I I I y m structures dominated by by definition X C \ XXX I N while complex structures dominated by Note that / I \ N y m Complex N C \ X X (m) / It I /\ *R (d*) \ XXX a / (X) \ C \ N (C) (X) R (d) /\ II II X II (C") R (c) /\ /\ is and (d)) are subject to DC, and (b)) are subject to BRC. (in (b), (c), R (in (a) subject to both constraints. NOTES *l am Kenstowicz indebted to Chin-chuan Cheng, Hans Henrich Hock, and f^ichael for their comments and suggestions. All errors are of course mine. On Chung: 79 the representation of Kejia diphthongs and n are palatalized from ts, ts', s, and ng or n, they are followed by / or y. Note that tc, tc', and c are traditionally transcribed as tg, tg', and g, respectively. ^The palatals respectively, tc, tc', c, when 2There are two levels books while the of speech in is used colloquial level The Kejia. in daily used to read For further discussion, see literary level is life. Chung 1989. 3Tone might be also involved, as shown in (15c). However, here we are concerned with the position of the prevocalic glide, hence tone is ignored. "^Underthe DC, the structure a triphthong might be as for N a. / N b. / \ XX \ / I I III I G V G there are three skeletal slots within a nucleus, there is no to prevent a nucleus "ayn from occurring, which is absolutely prohibited in favor way \ XXX V G G follows. (a), because if Kejia. REFERENCES CHEN, Matthew. The primacy 1980. of rhythm in verse: A linguistic per- spective. Journal of Chinese Linguistics 8.15-41. CHUNG, Raung-fu. 1989. Urbana-Champaign CLEMENTS, G. N., and Aspects of Kejia dissertation J. Keyser. in phonology. University of Illinois at Linguistics. 1983. CV phonology. Cambridge: MIT Press. HASHIMOTO, Phonology of Cantonese. Yu. 1972. Studies in Yue dialects 1 Cambridge: University Press. KAYE, Jonathan. 1985. On the syllable structure of certain West African languages. African linguistics: Essays in memory of M. W. K. Semikenke, Amsterdam & Philadelphia: John ed. by D. L. Goyvaerts, 285-308. Benjamins. LAI, Bixia. 1983. Kejia folk Ssongs. Taipei: Beike Press. LIGHT, Timothy. 1977. The Cantonese final: An exercise in indigenous analysis. Journal of Chinese Linguistics 5.75-102. SCHANE, A. Sanford. 1987. The resolution of hiatus. Papers from the 23rd Regional Meeting of the Chicago Linguistic Society, 278-290. : Studies in the Linguistic Sciences 19:1 (Spring 1989) 80 SHAW, Patricia. 1987. Non-conservation of melodic structure in reduplication. Papers from the 23rd Regional Meeting of the Chicago Linguistic Society, 291-306. SOHN, Hyang-Sook. 1987. Underspecification in Korean phonology. University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign dissertation in Linguistics. STERIADE, Donca. 1984. Glides and vowels in Rumanian. Proceedings of the Berkeley Linguistic Society, 10. 1987. Redundant values. Papers from the 23rd Regional Meeting of the Chicago Linguistic Society, 339-362. TENG, Xunzi. 1982. The source of the Kejia people. Taipei: Wunhua Press. TUNG, Tong-ho. 1968. Hanyu yinyunxue (Chinese phonology). Taipei: Stu- dent Book Store. Li. 1957. Hanyu shilu xue (Chinese versification). Shanghai: Yanzhi Press. (Reprinted 1973, Hong Kong.) YIP, Moira. 1982. Reduplication and skeleton in Chinese secret language. WANG, — Linguistic Inquiry . 1987. identity. 13.637-661 The Obligatory Contour Principle Linguistic Inquiry 19.65-100. and phonological rules: A loss of Studies in Volume 19. the Linguistics Sciences Number Spring 1989 1, RESTRICTION AS A MEANS OF OPTIMIZING UNIFICATION PARSING* Dale Gerdemann Restriction in was originally parsing unification employed as grammars without 1985). Other uses of restriction cussed in previous literature. be used optimize several steps backbone (Shieber unification parsing have not been dis- in In this in a device to avoid infinite cycles a context free paper, I argue that restriction can parsing with Earley's algorithm. These steps include the subsumption test, the completer step, and lookahead. general, restriction information in a the parser to 1 is a useful operation whenever only a subset of all In the possibly large feature structure needs to be considered for make next step. its Introduction Since Shieber (1985). restriction has been recognized as an important operation unification parsing.^ As Shieber points in most straightforward adaptation of grammars fails because the infinite number out, the Earley's algorithm for use with unification grammars can cause the predictor step in the algorithm to go more and more new predictions (i.e.. the problem The basic idea is that new predictions are not subsumed by previous predictions). of restriction is to avoid making predictions on the basis of all of the information in a DAG,^ but rather to take some subset of that information (i.e.. a restricted DAGhenceforth RD) and use just that information to make new predictions. Since there are only a finite number of possible RDs. the predictor step will no longer go into the infinite loop described above. The price you pay for this move is that some spurious of categories in these into an infinite loop, creating ever predictions will be made, but as Shieber points out. the algorithm any spurious predictions will Shiebers use of restriction other hand, there has been of parsing. In this paper. I is still correct since be weeded out by the completer step. in little will the predictor step is by now well established. discussion of the uses of restriction in On the other stages argue that restriction can be used to advantage in at 82 Studies in the Linguistic Sciences 19:1 (Spring 1989) least three additional ways. First, restriction can be used to significantly speed up the subsumption check on new predictions. Second, in can be used it the completer step in order to speed up the process of finding the correct states in the state sets to be completed. And parser. third, it can be used to add a lookahead component to the unification begin by briefly reviewing Shieber's use of restriction and then will I discuss will the three additional uses for restriction mentioned above. 2 Restriction in the predictor step To understand the the original purpose of restriction recursion problem. left gorithm was to solve the algorithm One left recursion problem, but generalized to handle attribute- value is cursion problem emerges. Restriction new this A it help to will review first is when Eariey's new analog of the left re- turns out that it grammars a the device used by Shieber (1985) to eliminate recursion problem. left The 2.1 parsing, in of Eariey's prime motivations for developing his al- recursion problem left simple recursive descent parser must contain at least the two operations: expand and scan. These operations are used pretty much as in a left derivation. That is. the The start symbol is expanded by replacing it with the right hand side of some rule whose left hand side matches the start symbol. Then, the left-most non-terminal in the new string is expanded and the process operation begins with the start symbol. continues terminal are manner in this until the left-most matched against the is "popped" off. first word The process continues element in this At a terminal. is the input sentence. in manner If until all of this point the they match, both the input has been matched against the top-down expansion and no elements remain to be expanded or scanned. All that the problem remains, then, is that is to add a control regime some way must be found terminal gets expanded over and over again. happen is the arrow when is non-terminal there is some rule in is next non-terminal expanded using the in line to be expanded eliminate mainly because the loop It the goes beyond the scope of left The simplest case this which in this which the category immediately to the rule may A will —^ A . . . , then, is more than paper to give a full can right of For example, when A if the expanded, the again be A. This kind of loop involve But. which the same non- in identical to the category to the left of the arrow. A and backup. for failure to avoid loops is hard to a single rule. exposition of Eariey's solution to recursion problem. Nevertheless, the basic idea is fairly simple. Left recursion loops are avoided by dividing the expansion step into two steps called prediction and ^ Gerdemami: Restriction as a completion. Prediction works just only once. once, the new can only apply It left turns out that analog of the infinitely is a finite A new left if it turns out that a left needed to be used more than once, the completer step many times as needed. a parse has been found for portion of the input 2.2 expansion except that a prediction can be made predictions are thrown away. Then, to complete the prediction as when like 83 unification parsing the parser starts to go into a loop by making a prediction more than If rule (or set of rules) applies means of optimizing in some ambiguous number of recursive will portion of the input. So. unless or the input apply Now, the completer step only is infinitely some long, the completer times. recursion problem the most straightforward adaptation of recursion problem reemerges. Earley's algorithm, an Shieber (1985) illustrates this with grammar' but the same point can be made using a type of somewhat more familiar in recent linguistic theory. Specifically, infinite cycles can arise in grammars that handle subcategorization with list valued features such as Head Driven Phrase Structure Grammar (Pollard and Sag 1987) or PAIR style grammars (Shieber 1986). To illustrate the problem, suppose that we are parsing a sentence using a grammar with the PATR style rules in (1) and (2). The problem of non-termination can arise with this grammar since rule (2) allows for lexical items with problem with a "counting grammar is that indefinitely long subcategorization lists. (1) (2) xO -^ xl x2 84 Studies in the Linguistic Sciences 19:1 (Spring 1989) DAG). Since the start rule in (1) satisfies this requirement, the next step xl daughter. a prediction for the In Earley's algorithm as was it il would simply be its category label grammar, however, category labels are just features (Eariey 1970). the prediction for this unification style DAGs Since the feature. is make to originally formulated np). (i.e. In any other like associated with each of the non-terminals (iO,il,. . . ,in) may express just partial information about that non-terminal, it is possible that some non-terminals (such as x2 in the second rule) will not be associated with any category label at all. The natural solution, then, would be to make a prediction using the entire DAG associated with a given non-terminal. Suppose, now. that we have parsed the np in rule (1) and were ready to parse x2. The DAG associated with in a rule x2 would be (3) (3). vp cat first np cat subcat rest When rule this shown unifies with the category on the left hand side of (2) we get the in (4). xO (4) DAG end xl x2 cat vp subcat [2] cat vp xO first il subcat cat first np rest rest end x2 Now. following the same procedure, the predictor would next make can easily be seen that when the the non-terminal xl in (4). unifies with the left hand side of It rule (2) the predicted rule is DAG a prediction for associated with xl almost the same as (4) becomes the value for {subcat rest rest) in the new prediction. In fact, the predictor step can continue making such predictions ad infinitum and. crucially, the new predictions will not be subsumed by previous except that the value for {subcat rest) in (4) predictions. To solve this problem Shieber proposes that the predictor step should not use of the information in the DAG associated with use some limited subset of that information. DAG non-terminal, but rather all it should Of course, when some nodes of the a are eliminated the predictor step can overpredict. but this does not affect the correctness of the algorithm since these spurious predictions Shiebers proposal is basically that before the predictor step will is not be completable. applied, an RD should Gerdemann: Restriction as a means of optimizing unification parsing be created which contains just the information associated with a finite set of 85 paths (i.e.. number of categories Since the number of possible a restrictor).^ In this way. Shieber's algorithm allows an infinite number of equivalence classes. becomes impossible to make the kind of to be divided into a finite RDs is finite, it infinite cycle of predictions illustrated above. Primarily for notational reasons. I define restriction will DAG the least specific of P if in D is D" D in is from Shieber's definition not really a for the list DAG for every in D' is path P the same complex then the value of P in in in is a tree and hence it the restrictor is in (5) (from Shieber 1985) will manner DAG D D' of D. and in This a variable. to be the value if as the value of P D' differs Thus the RD is can be represented more easily by a that reentrancies are eliminated but rather RD in the RD. structure. For example, given the restrictor [(a b). (d e DAG in (6). in such that atomic then the value of P the value of P simple C D different in a slightly from Shieber (1985). For our purpose here we can define the f). (d i j be represented by the indented the f)]. list RD shown which variables are indicated by []} (5) \j k [1] I [[a,[[^c]]], (6) K[[e,l[/,11]] 3 The Restriction first dictions. in the subsumption test use of restriction In I will new premade on each been made in the discuss involves the subsumption check on the original Earley's algorithm (Earley 1970). a check was new prediction to see that an identical prediction had not already same state set. Of course, if duplicate predictions are retained the parser can the left recursion trap. In Shieber's adaptation, however, this identity check is fall into changed more general notion of a subsumption check. If a new DAG is predicted that is subsumed by a previous (more general) DAG. the new DAG is not retained since any DAGs that could be predicted on the basis of the new DAG could already have been predicted on the basis of the more general DAG. Clearly, the move from an identity check to a subsumption check is the right sort of move to make, but a subsumption to the Studies in the Linguistic Sciences 19:1 (Spring 1989) 36 check on arbitrarily large ideal area in DAGs can be an expensive operation. This seems to be an which restriction could be used to optimize the algorithm. The move propose is the following. Initially, new predictions are made in the manner suggested by Shieber; i.e.. make an RD for the category 'to the right of the Dot' and then collect all the rules from the grammar whose left hand side category unifies with this RD - these rules then constitute the new predictions. At this point I I RD suggest that the new predictions: that used to find these predictions should be retained along with the is. kept for each state set. RDs a list of I that have been used to enters the predictor step and creates a a subsumption check can be made make predictions should be the RD_List. Then, the next time the parser will call this list new RD from which directly between this to RD make new predictions, and the RD.List. If the new RD is subsumed by any member of the RD.List then we can immediately give up trying to make any new predictions from this RD. Any predictions made from this RD would necessarily already have been made when the predictor encountered the more general RD in the RD_List. Thus we avoid both the expense of making new predictions and the expense of applying the subsumption test to weed these new predictions out. Moreover, since in RDs are typically very small (at least given the sample restrictors given Shieber 1985, 1986). the subsumption test that is performed on them can be applied very quickly. As an example, suppose that some made set of predictions has already been using making predictions using [cat. np].[num. sing]] since any such predictions would necessarily fail the subsumption check: i.e.. rules expanding singular noun phrases are more specific than (or subsumed by) rules the RD. [cat. np] [ then there |. is no point expanding noun phrases unspecified for in [ number. This particular case probably does not arise often in actual parsing, but cases of left recursion optimization can make a very significant difference in do arise for processing speed. which this In fact our (Gerdemann and experience with the UNICORN Hinrichs 1988). has shown that for grammars with a large amount of left recursion. make the difference between taking several minutes of natural language processing system this simple optimization can processing time and several seconds of processing time. There that two is one problem that can arise as RDs nevertheless result in a result of this optimization.^ It may happen any subsumption relationship with each other may the same prediction. For example, the RDs [f.a] and [g.b] may that don't stand in result in the same prediction some spurious ambiguity since each of the identical predictions could be completed in the same manner. This problem can be avoided, however, by linking predictions back to the RDs responsible for making both unify with the being left made more than hand side the prediction. This linking back described in of some rule, which could once. This could result the next section. is in an independently motivated optimization which The two is predictions, then, can be viewed as different . Gerdemann: Restriction as a means of optimizing unification parsing predictions since they are linked back to different RDs. Thus, only a finite predictions can be 4 made and Restriction The next use there is no possibility of 87 number of a left recursion loop reemerging. the completer step in of restriction I The completer propose involves the completer step. applies, in Earleys algorithm, at the point where of the right hand side of a rule all some state has been consumed, i.e.. the point at which the Dot' has been moved the way to the right in some rule. At this point the completer goes back to the state set in which the state to be completed was originally predicted and searches for in all which has a category a prediction in this state set unify with the mother node of the 'to the right of the Dot" which can rule in the state to be completed. This search can be quite time consuming since the completer must attempt to perform a unification for each state In in this state set. each state, there is which indicates a variable F in which state set that state was predicted so the completer can immediately go back to the Fth state set in order to make the completion. But there is no variable which indicates which state in the Fth state set could have been responsible for making that prediction. And. in fact, it would be quite difficult to particular state is it implement such a really only indirectly would have been responsible check. For example, suppose Each state BP is will for the prediction we a some had not been its Shieber's adaptation of Barley's algorithm: the rule represented by Dag, and F in problem with i in this which state set the (7) . . [Labi, Now suppose [(cat, np], is [num. sing]]. Dot is F, was and Dag are used, as a pointer to in the current position was made. To partial state set in (7), in illustrate the which the subscripted the tth state set. RD for When Dagl is [[cat.np]] in (8). it will . .] RD for Dag2 is make some number and suppose that the the predictor looks at state Labi . (For ex; [Lab3,Labl.0.i.Dag3] is a state with an arbitrary label. Lab3. a backpointer to state Labi, the Dot set at indicating the beginning of the was made (8) label. the more general kind of backpointer which of predictions with backpointers to Labi as new an arbitrary is BPl, Dotl, Fl, Dagl\,[Lab2, BP2, Dot2, F2, Dag2\, the subsumption for the value the label of the state that original prediction scheme, consider the indicates that this .[. is i.e.. a the sense that in system of backpointers as follows. responsible for predicting the current state, and Dot. only indicates prediction, be a quintuple (Lab.BP.Dot.F.Dag) where Lab kind of backpointer which takes as a if it implement try to many cases direct backpointer since in responsible for in state set i. left hand side. F set to i and DagS representing the new indicating that the prediction rule.) i[...[Labl,BPl,Dotl,Fl,Dagl],[Lab2,BP2,Dot2,F2,Dag2l [Lab3, Labl,Dot3, Dag3], \Lab4, Labi, Dot4, F4, Dagi], . .] 88 Studies in the Linguistic Sciences 19:1 (Spring 1989) But when the predictor looks at Lab2 no predictions will be made, since its RD is subsumed by the RD of Labi. Thus even though (without the subsumption check) Lab2 could have been responsible for the predictions Lab3 and Lab4. no backpointers are created for Lab2. is it RDs at this point that predictor attempts to to that state and to make can again help us out. predictions on the basis of predictions all made from The idea is some state that if will be either: no predictions were made because unification only on states that have many attempted RD is unifications that RD Now before. (9) ,[. In . FP is an RD Now the completion to the Fth state set and attempt this move eliminates To implement this idea, RD-markers. Clearly would be doomed to failure. BP states will be defined as quintuples (BP.FP.Dot.F.Dag) where a backpointer. is acting as Dag are as the analog of (7) will be (9). BPl and BP2 (9) RD an acting as a forward pointer and F, Dot. and [BP1,FPI, Dotl, Fl, Dagl], [BP2, FP2, Dot2, F2, Dag2],. . (ii) had already been used to make used as the marker. identical The RD used to make the predictions, or The completer can go back greatly simplified. is the more general more general RD predictions, then this step a (i) RD that state as a kind of marker (or coindexing between a state and the predictions resulting from that state). used for this coindexing when the adds an it for the prediction will each be instantiated to the value of the which created their respective state. . .] RD responsible FPl and FP2. however, will be uninstantiated variables since these two states have not yet been responsible for new creating any in (7) the state set (10) predictions. Now assuming then when the predictor applies to the .[. . shown . [BPl, in that the first state RDs for shown Dagl and Dag2 in (9). the result are as will be (10). [cat, np] [ ], Dotl, Fl,Dagl], [BP2, FP2, Dot2, F2, Dag2], [cat, [ np] ],FP3, Dot?,, F3, DagZ], [ [cat, np] [ [ ],FPA, Dot4, F'i,Dag4], . . .] Then when the predictor looks at the second state in (10). no predictions will be made as before, however the predictor will register the attempt to make a prediction by instantiating the variable FP2 as in (11). (11) ,[... [BPl, [BP2, [[cat, [cat, np] np]],Dotl,Fl, Dagl], ],Dot2, F2, Dag2], [ [cat, np] [ [ [cat, [ [ ],FP3, DotZ, F2, DagZ], np]],FPA, DotA, FA, DagA],. . .] Gerdemann: Now whenever Restriction as a means of optimizing 89 unification parsing the descendants of states 3 and 4 are ready to be completed, will it be easy to go back to this state set and find the states whose forward pointers are Thus many candidates identical to the backpointers of the states to be completed. for completion are immediately ruled out. 5 Restriction used The in use for restriction that final I lookahead propose involves lookahead. Lookahead one aspect is of Earley's algorithm which clearly needs modification in order to be used efficiently with unification grammars or natural language grammars algorithm, a calculation of lookahead was performed as in general. the original In part of the prediction step. simple example can show the problem with Earley's version of this procedure. S — NP VP > rule, when the predictor makes a prediction for a state for each possible lookahead string that can be derived number the large of verbs or adverbs that can start a would require adding to simply to find list all a VP huge number of states to the state in NP, it is In A the required to add from the VP. But given language this a natural set. Clearly we don't want the possible lookahead strings: rather the correct approach would be what features these strings have in common and then, to add a smaller number of states with feature based lookaheads. Aside from the question of what kind of lookahead to calculate, there are two other questions that need to be considered: and second how to calculate it. first the question of when to calculate lookahead Beginning with the when question, grammars require lookahead to be calculated at approach. The reason for this is illustrated by rules it unification a later point Earley's like (2). here as (12) (12) lO xO xl xl is clear that than which is it is in repeated 90 Studies in the Linguistic Sciences 19:1 (Spring 1989) immediately before the predictor applies to that category: for a category can be considered made immediately quick check to be a Unlike Eariey's original algorithm, then, is it lookahead i.e.. before applying prediction. not necessary to put a lookahead string into a state to be checked at a later point. The question, then, gorithm, there how is to calculate lookahead. Hk which when a function. is k-symbol strings of terminals which could begin to unification a We can begin each category. certainly cannot is It of implementing this idea C, the first thing does it infinite some form is When as follows. make an RD is When applied number of cat- of restriction implement any kind of lookahead. One. to be necessary in order to again going the predictor applies to a category Then for C. is relatively simple, lookup a table performed to is determine what preterminal categories could begin C. Since there are potentially nite preterminal categories, restriction the table lookup finds a set of RDs must be applied here that the next item of the preterminal the input in RDs. If make is So more too. call RDs the preterminal RDs. Then check must be performed to verify these a prediction a an instance of a category that can unify with one the check how the lookup then the prediction fails, is abandoned. One way such table is constructed. be constructed would be to run the parser in reverse for generation as remains Thus, is for to specify each possible RD determine what preterminal 6 1 in might Shieber 1988. (given a particular restrictor). the generator RDs can All that a table is used to begin a phrase of this category. Conclusion have argued here that restriction can be used optimizations. First, it the completer step, and finally The first in unification it it can be used to speed up the searching used can be used to implement two of these uses have been fully In is still general, the fact that unification in some way these categories. is UNICORN The use natural of restriction It grammars may have categories of indefinite of focusing on limited portions of the information seems quite likely, useful even in other parsing algorithms for unification that remains form of lookahead. under development. complexity necessitates contained a implemented within the language processing system (Gerdemann and Hinrichs 1988). with lookahead parsing to effect three can be used to greatly speed up the subsumption test for adding predictions to the state set. second new in infi- precisely, that could unify with whatever actual preterminal could begin a phrase of category C. Let us before the predictor can actually al- returns a set of possible strings of preterminals that list clear, then, that version of the C phrase of category C. grammars, however, the problem of having an egories again appears. way In Eariey's applied to a category what portion of the information in then, that restriction would be grammars. The primary question complex DAGs should be used in Gerdemann: Restriction as a these algorithms: that means of optimizing the question is. how is 91 unification parsing to choose a restrictor. Up to now, no general principles have been given for choosing a restrictor for greatest efficiency. Given the proposals in this paper, it becomes even more critical to find since restriction can affect the efficiency of several steps such general principles the parsing algorithm. in NOTES •| would like to thank Alan Frisch. Erhard Hinrichs. iucja Iwaiiska. Jerry Morgan. Mike Mendelson, and Tsuneko Nakazawa must comments. Any for their useful deficiencies me. Thanks also to the UIUC Cognitive Science/ Artificial Intelligence rest with fellowship committee for the support that version of this paper appeared in made An earlier Workshop on this research possible. the Proceedings of the International Parsing Technologies. Carnegie Mellon University. 1989. *By unification parsing. I mean parsing of unification grammars. See Seifert (1988) for a precise definition of a unification ^As tion is in grammar. Shieber (1986) the basic data structure for expressing grammatical informa- the directed acyclic graph or DAG. ^For a fuller treatment of the algorithm, the reader an introduction to Barley's algorithm and its is referred to Early (1970). For relationship to chart parsing in general, see Winograd (1983). ''The question of remain a how to select an appropriate restrictor for greatest efficiency See the conclusion of this paper question for further research. must for further discussion. RDs may ^Eliminating reentrancies from computational point of view. 1985. 1986. it would appear that reentrancies may be also be a reasonable thing to do from a Judging from the particular restrictors used occur rarely in desirable to include more information in would be the use of parsing algorithms for generation, in which purposes to use as it much top down in RDs. However, RDs. it A Shieber for some possible example would be desirable information as possible. ^This potential problem was pointed out to me by Henry Thompson. REFERENCES EARLEY. the J. ACM 1970. An efficient context-free parsing algorithm. Communications of 13:2.94-102. GERDEMANN. D. and attribute-value HINRICHS. E. 1988. grammars. Studies in UNICORN: a unification parser for the Linguistic Sciences. Vol. 18:2.41-86. Studies in the Linguistic Sciences 19:1 (Spring 1989) 92 POLLARD, and SAG. C. \. and semantics: Volume 1987. \: An information-based approach to syntax Fundamentals. CSLI Lecture Notes No. 13, Chicago: University Press. SEIFFERT. rules. R. 1987. Chart-parsing of unification-based E. Klein fication. and J. 335-54. Centre for Cognitive Science/Institute for Language, Logic and Information. Edinburgh. SHIEBER, grammars with ID/LP- van Benthem (Eds.), Categories, Polymorphism and Uni- S. Amsterdam. 1985. Using restriction to extend parsing algorithms for complex- feature based formalisms. Association for Computational Linguistics Proceedings. 23rd . 1986. Annual Meeting, 145-52. An introduction to unification-based approaches to grammar. CSLI Lecture Notes No. A WINOGRAD. . 1988. 4, Chicago: University Press. uniform architecture for parsing and generation. COLING-88, 614-9. T. 1983. Language as a cognitive process: syntax. Norwood: Ablex. the Linguistic Sciences Studies in Volume 19, Number Spring 1989 1, CONJOINED WE STAND: THEORETICAL IMPLICATIONS OF SANSKRIT RELATIVE STRUCTURES* Hans Henrich Hock Relative-correlative structures are wide spread in South Asian languages and are commonly analysed as derived from embedded structures in which the relative clause is base-generated under NP, as in English. An alternative view considers the relative clause of such structures to be base-generated in situ, as a subordinate clause adjoined to the correlative clause. A rarer third view, that the relative clause is conjoined to the correlative clause, has most recently been considered in Dasgupta 1980. and rejected — — paper argue that relative-correlatives are typologically in a subset of SOV languages that includes Sanskrit. provide language-specific evidence that a conjoined analysis is the most appropriate for Sanskrit relative-correlatives. conclude with an examination of relative pronoun (RP) placement: In addition to occurring initially and near-initially, RPs may be placed into a preverbal 'focus' position. This suggests that in this I well motivated as conjoined structures I I the 'landing but either 1. site* for TOPIC RPs in Sanskrit relative-correlatives or preverbal is not COMP, FOCUS. The problem The predominant relative clause strategy of Sanskrit, with counterparts in most other South Asian and many non-South Asian languages, is what is aptly called relative-correlative: A relative clause (RC) containing a relative pronoun (RP) is followed by a correlative (main) clause (CO) introduced by an (optional) 'correlative' pronoun (CP). Compare example (1). Note that in this archetypical example, the RC precedes the CC, the RP and CP are initial in their respective clauses (often separated from the remainder of their NPs^), and the coreferential NP (1) or 'head' is present [yami u ha _ ' RP [tamj u CP ha ^ " in both clauses. pasavo manusyesu kamamj arohamsjpc head eva pasiisu kamanhj rohatijcc (SB 2.1.2.7) eva tat head 'What very desire the cattle then obtained among men, that very desire he (now) obtains among cattle.' = 'The very desire the cattle then obtained among men he now obtains among cattle.' (2) Hock: Conjoined we stand 95 S Tree Diagram I S Tree Diagram II Andrews, Dasgupta, Lehmann, and Srivastav provide special motivation for this analysis by pointing to 'multiple-headed* RCs of the type (7a-c) which, because their RPs refer to more than one constituent of the CC, cannot possibly be accounted for as embedded. For which NP would they be embedded under? As Kiparsky (1989) has noted, similar difficulties are encountered in structures of the type (7d) in which there is no coreferentiality between the relativized NP and any NP of the CC. (Cf. further Hettrich 1988 with references, and Hock 1989d.) Passages like these tend to be difficult to translate. In many is possible to render one of the two RPs multiple-headed RCs, such as (7a), as an indefinite pronoun; and this has been claimed to be the general interpretation for Sanskrit structures of this type; cf. e.g. Andrews. But in other cases, e.g. (7b) and (7c), such a translation is not appropriate. It is therefore unlikely it 96 Studies in the Linguistic Sciences 19:1 (Spring 1989) that the the RP second RP of such structures structures exemplified in (7), simply a morphological peculiarity, with In fact, for most of the (a) is by means of conditionals; (See also note 12 below.) the best translation the alternative glosses of (7a,b,d). (7) is functioning as a suppietive indefinite pronoun. yahj svabhavo hi RP yasyaj syat tasyaj ^ asauj duratikramah RP CP ^ that (Hit. cf. 3.8) (b) "Whatever nature; whoj might have, thatj is difficult to overcome of/by himj." = *What(ever) nature someone might have ..." Or: 'If someone has a particular nature ..." yatarei no yataranj yajayisyanti tei hasyante (JB 3.187) (c) "WhOj of us will be sacrificers for whomj (= the others), theyi will be left behind." Or: 'If some of us will be sacrificers for the others ...' bhajamy aham tathaj yathaj marh prapadyante tarriSj yei (d) share "WhOj howj turn to me, in thatj way share themi." = those who turn to me in the way they turn to me.' tasmanj nah pahy yoj no agne dureva a martOj vadhaya dasati RP CP RP RP CP CP RP (Bh.G.4.12) ~' "I I | CP RP amhasahj (RV 6.16.31) 'Which mortalj, O Agni, with evil intention exposes us to the blow, from that distressj rescue us.' Or: A third 'If a mortal ...' approach, which ficulties with structures of like the type the preceding 'adjoined' one has no dif(7), considers the RCs of (some) relative- be conjoined with their corresponding CCs, as in Tree Diagram III. This analysis appears to underly Bach & Cooper 1978 and has been argued for on typological grounds in Hock 1988b, 1989a,b,d.s correlative structures to Tree Diagram Dasgupta (1980) objects with the following arguments: to (i) III a conjoined analysis of relative-correlatives that precede CCs cannot be followed by RCs Hock: Conjoined we stand 97 sentence-final intonation breaks, while the members of conjoined sentences can; (ii) RCs may be embedded into their matrix clauses, something which a conjoined analysis cannot account for; (iii) excepting exclamatory structures with unusual semantics, syntax, and phonology, RCs cannot occur by themselves, while the members of conjoined sentences can. An additional argument, (iv), underlying Hettrich's (1988) approach, is that RCs are subordinate and thus should not be considered Not all of these syntactically conjoined. counterarguments are of equal cogency. seems Argument (i) is a role in Intonation. But what is more important are pragmatic considerations. Consider e.g. the English sentences in (8). Syntactically, (8a) and (8b) exhibit subordinNevertheless, to insert a sentence-final ation, while (8c) has coordination. intonation break after back is as infelicitous in (8c) as it is in (8a/b). The reason no doubt is the pragmatic 'special connectedness' that holds between the component clauses, rather than syntactic notions such as subordination and coordination. The situation is the same in other syntactically coordinate structures with similar 'special connectedness', such as (9). True, syntactic information phonological, not syntactic. (8) (a) Whoever scratches my (b) If (c) You('ll) back, scratch his/hers. I my back, scratch scratch my back, and you scratch to play I yours. i('ll) scratch yours. (On one hand) they had everything money could buy, but (on the other hand) they felt depressed all the time. (9) Argument (iii), appealed to also by Hettrich (1988),9 runs into similar diftaken seriously, it would force us to consider sentences linked by means of coordinating conjunctions not to be conjoined, since their component at clauses cannot occur by themselves if they contain these conjunctions least not as well-formed structures; cf. (10). True, some structures with coordinating conjunctions, such as (10b), are possible as 'elliptical' sentences; but so are RCs unaccompanied by CCs, as in (11). Moreover, structures of the (English) type (12), even though non-subordinate, are altogether unacceptable. ficulties: If — (10) (a) srnvanta johavFmi vrdhe ca no bhavatam vajasatau •& (RV 1.34.1 2c/d) support you two (who are) hearing, and (may you) us for growth in the winning of booty.' */?vrdhe ca no bhavatam vajasatau 'I call for appear (b) vam avase to •&' */?'And appear to us for growth (1 1 ) (ta u haptya ucuh kam abhi _ | aty in the battle for booty.' eva vayam idam asmat para nayama ^ iti) 'whom' ya evadaksinena havisa yajata iti RP '(Now, these Aptyas said: "Let us lead this away from us." "Onto whom?") "[Onto him] Who shall sacrifice an offering without a daksina."' I'ti 98 Studies in the Linguistic Sciences 19:1 (Spring 1989) */???0n one hand, they had everything money could buy. (12) As for argument Hettrich correctly observes that semantic (iv), and Consider the German expressions in (13) - (15), in all of which the second clause gives the reason for the first one and thus is semantically subordinate to it. But only (13) has syntactic subordination, as indicated by verb-final order; the others have conjoined or juxtaposed main clauses, with the finite verb in 'second' position. Further evidence that (13) and (14/15) differ syntactically comes from topicaiization, which is freely possible in the second clauses of the conjoined/juxtaposed (14) and (15), but not in (13); cf. (13') - (15'), where the topicalized NP, diese Stadt syntactic subordination are not necessarily coterminous.^ 'this town', (13) is set off in boldface. Er kennt sich hier nicht aus, well er diese Stadt noch nie 'because' besucht hat. [V, 'He doesn't visited this (14) + fin.] know town way around here because he his denn Er kennt sich hier nicht aus, er hat diese Stadt nie besucht. 'He doesn't know his (15) way around noch [V,+fin] 'for' town hasn't before.' here, for he hasn't visited this before.' Er hat diese Stadt noch nie Er kennt sich hier nicht aus. [V,+fin.] besucht. 'He doesn't town know his way around here. He hasn't visited this before.' (13') */??Er kennt sich hier nicht aus, well diese Stadt er noch nie (14') besucht hat. Er kennt sich hier nicht aus, denn diese Stadt hat er noch nie besucht. (15') Diese Stadt hat er noch nie Er kennt sich hier nicht aus. besucht. This leaves just one argument, namely (ii) concerning surface-embedded RCs. will try to show that for Sanskrit, this one In the remainder of this paper argument must be weighed against several others which, on balance, favor the will try to demonstrate that surfaceconjoined analysis of relative-correlatives. embedded RCs are only apparent exceptions to the proposed analysis. Finally, will examine the evidence of RP placement and suggest that the 'landing site' I I I for RPs in Sanskrit is not COMP, — but either TOPIC or preverbal — FOCUS. While the arguments and supporting evidence presented in this paper have obvious implications for syntactic theory, the argumentation itself will be kept 'pretheoretical', i.e. independent of specific current theories, on the Hock: Conjoined we stand 99 assumption that the arguments and evidence should be relevant independent any theory of, to, and of syntax. Note that throughout the paper, will assume that structures of the type forms of the RP stem ya- and of the CP stem (e)sa/(e)ta(from now on referred to as tad/etacf), are relative-correlatives, just like structures of the type (1 ) and (7), which contain inflected forms of the same stems. In so doing deviate from traditional approaches, including the most recent treatment in Hettrich 1988, which distinguish the type (16) from (1) - (7) as 'dependent' vs. 'relative'. Both kinds of structures are relative-correlative, are ordinarily not embedded, and generally use the same pronominal stems.i° They are thus syntactically and even morphologically entirely parallel. And as Hettrich's detailed discussion shows, even in their functions, they are not clearly differentiated; cf. also Hock In Press and see note 12 below for the close pragmatic I (16), with adverbial I relationship between generalizing (16) (a) akararh yat ki'm RP Interr. relative structures and conditionals. tasmad idam apad(i) (SB 4.1.5.4) CP 'Because have done what ?, therefore this has happened.' = 'What have done to have gotten into this?' aloka u tarhi yajamanah yadi va ftvijo 'loka bhavanty CP (SB 9.5.2.16) RP 'If the priests are dispossessed of the worlds, then also the sacrificer (is) dispossessed of the worlds.' evam agnir ahito jFryati yatha vai puruso 'svo gaur jfryati CP (TS 1.5.7.3) RP 'Just as a man, horse, cow ages, so the fire, (when) lit, ages.' I I (b) (c) 2. SOV 'Strict There is typology and relative-correlatives^ ^ a well-known crosslinguistic tendency for SOV languages to use such as participles, absolutives, infinitives, and verbal non-finite verbal devices, nouns to embed (Tamil) data that this is in propositions into 'matrix' propositions; (17) and the Turkish ones the normal pattern in 'strict' (17) (a) In fact, finite — (Relative participle) nan pokira vrttukku nlvaravendam come to the house (to which) am going.' (Absolutive) nan atai-c ceytu mutittu-p ponen did that, 'Having done that, having finished, went away.' = finished, and went away.' Or; 'After had done that and finished went away.' (Infinitive) mm pitikka arampinarkal 'They began to catch fish.' avan ivanai atittu nintittatu cari alia (Verbal noun) 'It is not proper that he has beaten and cursed him out.' I 'I I I I (c) (d) e.g. the Dravidian is predicate. 'You must not (b) it SOV have a constraint on the distribution of simple or complex can contain only one — cf. generally believed languages, which are considered to finite verbs such that each sentence (18). in Studies in the Linguistic Sciences 19:1 (Spring 1989) 100 adam gikarildi ([Relative] man (who was) laughing was thrown out." gijlem (18) (a) 'The kalkip gittik 'Having risen (b) gali^mak (c) participle) (Absolutive) we went.' = 'We rose and went.' (Infinitive) istiyor 'He wants to go.' (Verbal noun) kapiyi kilitlediginizi unutmayiniz (d) = 'Don't forget that 'Don't forget your having locked the door.' you have locked the However, as pointed out I in door.* Hock 1988b, even for 'strict' SOV languages simply inaccurate. In many such languages, coordinated or 'conjoined' propositions are permitted to each contain a finite verb. This appears to have been the case for early Dravidian; cf. the Modern Tamil relics in (19). Turkish likewise permits conjoined structures with finite verbs in each clause; cf. (20). Conjoined structures of this sort are optionally marked by coordinating conjunctions, and these conjunctions may like Dravidian, the preceding characterization appear in each (19) (a) of the itu conjoined clauses; mey neg.V 'this' cf. e.g. (19b) atu-v-um alia that mey is and (20b). alia & 'that' and 'This is not true, is neg.V not true.' = 'Neither this nor that is true.' manitar(-um) (b) (&) '(Both) men kutiraikal(-um) arintana arintarkal masc. (&) pi. 3 neut. perished and horses perished.' = 'Men and horses pi.3 perished.' (20) (a) kalktik gittik pl.1 pl.1 'We rose (and) (b) went.' Ahmet(-te) baligi Mehmet-te pi^irdi, 'Ahmet cooked the fish, istakozu & sg.3 (&) pi^irdi sg.3 and Mehmet cooked the lobster.' SOV languages, permit cited discourse to connot to do so would make direct discourse, cross-linguistically preferred to indirect discourse, unavailable for 'strict' SOV languages, since the finite verbs of quoted discourse, embedded under a 'matrix' clause with its own finite verb, would increase the number of finite verbs per sentence beyond the limit of one. It is probably in order to signal that cited direct discourse is not subject to these restrictions, that SOV languages tend to use quotative markers to mark cited discourse as being syntactically independent from the 'matrix' sentence and thus entitled to its own finite verbs; cf. e.g. the Dravidian (Tamil) and Turkish examples in (21) and (22). (For the syntactic motivation of quotative mariners, see also Steever 1988.) Further, many, perhaps (21) all, As Steever (1987) has argued, tain finite verbs. [nan avan ihke 'I think (that) [he vantan] en-ru ninaikkiren sg.3 Quot. sg.1 has come here].' 3 Hock: Conjoined we stand [kim (22) bunu yapti] diye du^unuyordum sg.3 Quot. sg.1 was wondering [who had done 'I 101 this?]' SOV languages exhibit a variety of These prominently include non-finite, participle-like structures of the type (17a) and (18a) which agree well with the tendency of SOV languages to As for relative-clause formation, strategies. use non-finite structures for embedding. But beside (or instead of) these nondevices, a number of SOV languages offer relative-correlative structures; cf. Andrews 1975(1985), Downing 1978, K. Hale 1975, Keenan 1985, Chr. finite Lehmann 1984. As noted Hock 1988b, Dravidian belongs to this type of SOV language cf. the Old Tamil example (23). As turns out, Turkish such constructions, although these structures are used only as in with relative-correlatives; likewise offers generalizing RCs; (24). ''^ cf. [minnitai (23) it natunkuh kataippeyal vatai enrijRc [akkal sg.2 CP varuvar ekkal varuvat(u) RP sg.3 neut. en-k katalor-e]cG sg.3 honorific 'My lover will come at the time that you say the cold wind will come.' [ne kadar yukandan inerse]Rc [o kadar derine girer]cc (24) (a) RP CP sg.3cond. sg.3 "From whatever extent high (= the pile driver) descends, to that extent low it enters.' = 'The greater the height it falls from, the deeper it goes down.' it [ne (b) [softalar yikilmi^-sa]Rc yikmi^tir]cc RP pi. sg.3cond. 'What(ever) has been demolished, the bigots have demolished.' Note moreover that SVO or VSO languages do not commonly have relative-clause strategies that are exclusively of the relative-correlative type. Like non-finite subordinating devices, relative-correlative structures thus significantly linked with basic In Hock 1988b follows: finite In I like as well as from the postnominal clausal type of English, by the fact that the correlative or 'main' clause. seem On to involve conjoining, not that this behavior significant. seem order. argued that this correlation can be accounted for as surface structure, relative-correlative constructions differ from non- relative strategies, languages SOV In that is embedding not just a surface case we can argue correlatives are construed as RC is not embedded into the the surface, therefore, relative-correlatives Let us or subordination. phenomenon that in but such languages, conjoined sentences and are conjoined structures of the type (19) clauses. - (20), permitted to have assume syntactically is relative- therefore, like finite verbs in both 3 Studies in the Linguistic Sciences 19:1 (Spring 1989) 102 This permits us to formulate the following rule concerning the distribution verbs in languages like Dravidian and Turkish: of finite Rule A: One finite verb is permitted per sentence. However, in conjoined structures, each of the conjoined clauses is treated as a sentence in its own right and is therefore permitted to have its own finite verb. Relative-correlatives syntactically are conjoined struceach tures, permitting verb. two sub-clauses of the addition, cited discourse In dependent and thus own is to have its own finite treated as syntactically in- Elsewhere, i.e. in structures with syntactic embedding, only one finite verb is permitted per sentence, occurring in the 'matrix' clause; other verbs have to appear entitled to shape non-finite in its finite verb(s). (participles, absolutives, or infinitives, verbal nouns). 3. Evidence for Rule A There is a in amount fair of Sanskrit evidence that Sanskrit had a constraint against differed markedly from the modern it multiple finite verbs, or at least, that European languages in using non-finite expressions, especially participles and where the latter would prefer embedded dependent clauses with finite verbs; cf. the examples in (25) - (28). absolutives, (25) Participles: (a) samiddhasya srayamanah purastad brahma vanvano ajaram pple. pple. pple. suvfram | are asmad amatim bhadamana uc chrayasva sg.2 pple. mahate saiibhagaya (RV 3.8.2) 'Being installed the in front of lit (fire), winning the never-aging, heroic devotion, banning lack of thought far from us, rise for great fortune.' = 'You, who are being installed in front of the lit and who are winning the never-aging, heroic devotion, ban (fire) lack of thought far from us, rise for great fortune.' (b) yunjanti bradhnam arusarh carantam pari pple. pi. tastusah (RV 1.6.1) pple. 'They yoke the njddy stallion, moving around the standing ones.' = 'They yoke the ruddy stallion that moves around those who (c) stand/stay in place.' marhsai nivacanani samsan (RV 10.113.10) pple. 'I may think making speeches.' = 'I may think that I am speeches.' (26) Absolutives: (a) pusi tveto nayatu hastagrhya sg.3 'Let (RV 10.85.26) abs. Pusan lead you from here, taking you by the hand." making 3 ' Hock: Conjoined we stand (b) 103 punardaya brahmajayam krtvrdevafr nikilbisam | urjam prthivya abs. abs. bhaktvaya ^ urugayam upasate (RV 10.109.7) abs. pi. 'Having given back the brahmin's wife, having accomplished expiation through the Gods, having partaken of the earth's vigor, they pay their respects to the far-striding one.' = 'After they have given back the brahmin's wife and accomplished expiation through the Gods, after they have partaken of the earth's vigor, they pay their respects to the far-striding one.' (27) Infinitives: havamahetva^ upagantava " pi. 1 'We invoke you u (RV 10.160.5) inf. to come/so that you will come.' (28) Verbal n9uns; pura sambadhad abhy a vavrtsva no ... (RV 2.16.8) Verbal Noun sg.2 impve. 'Before (our) oppression turn to us ...' = 'Before we get oppressed, turn to us ...' While thus, compared to the modern European languages, Sanskrit has a marked tendency for employing non-finite subordinating devices, like Dravidian and other 'strict' SOV languages, permits multiple finite verbs in complex synit tactic structures First, and under the conditions Rule A. least surprisingly, finite verbs are permitted to occur apparently multiple 1989a,b,d.) finite in each of (The issue of problem structures with verbs within a single clause is addressed in Hock several conjoined sentences; (29) (a) of cf. e.g. (29). vedad avidvan chrnavac cavidvan (RV 5.30.3c) sg.3 sg.3 & one not knowing know, and let the one knowing hear.' me varuna srudhfhavam adya ca mrlaya sg.2 & sg.2 (RV 1.25.19) O Varuna, this my invocation, and be gracious today.' 'Let the (b) imarri 'Hear, Secondly, cited direct discourse, containing its own finite verbs, normally is not embedded into the 'matrix clause' and is not marked by any putatively subordinating elements. Moreover, we can observe the same tendency as in Dravidian, Turkish, and other 'strict' SOV languages, namely to mark direct discourse by a quotative particle which indicates that the discourse is 'outside' the sentence to which it is logically subordinate. Compare for instance (30) and (31), with and without quotative marker respectively. (30) [fravatr... bhutam] du.2 'You, Visnu, ... stemmed ["You shall be full vi astabhna rodasFvisno ete (RV 7.99.3) sg.2 apart these two worlds (with the words): of sustenance."! 104 Studies in the Linguistic Sciences 19:1 (Spring 1989) stosama [tvarh (31) ... ] tvagne I'ti || ... 'vocan pi. 3 (RV 10.115.8-9) rsayo Quot. pl.i '["We shall praise you ...,"] the rsis said to you, Agni.' course, Sanskrit has relative-correlative structures, with finite verbs in each of the component clauses. And as the discussion in §1 has shown, there is good evidence that the RCs of these structures are not underlyingly embedded into the corresponding CCs. Given the typological Finally, of in section §2, we may want to argue that the RCs and CCs of these structures are syntactically conjoined and that it is this conjunction which per- arguments mits each clause to contain its own show finite verb. such a 'conjoined' analysis is supported not only by general typological considerations, but also by the specific evidence of In the following will I that Sanskrit. 4. The conjoined nature of Sanskrit relative-correlative structures Topicalization: Evidence that the component clauses of Sanskrit relative-correlatives are conjoined main-clause propositions is provided first of all by the fact that each clause may contain 'sentence-initial' emphasizing particles such as eva or topic markers such as ha; cf. (32). Structures of this type are attested freely in Sanskrit, in marked contrast to English, where sentences of the type He obtains that very desire among the cattle which very desire the cattle attained at that time among men are so unusual or marked as to border on the ungrammatical. (Compare (13') vs. (14'/15') for similar restrictions on 4.1. topicalization in (32) German dependent yam u ha RP tam u ha ~ ev^ clauses.) tat pasavo manusyesu eva pasusu kamam rohati kamam arohams (SB 2.1.2.7) CP 'What very desire the cattle at that time obtained among men, he (now) obtains among cattle.' = 'He now obtains that very desire among cattle which the cattle obtained that very desire at that time among men.' and correlative pronouns While in (and indirectly, the constituents to which they belong), examples like (33) illustrate that other elements (set off in boldface) may be topicalized in each of the two clauses and be placed in front of the relative or correlative pronoun. (32), topicalization affects the relative (33) tv^rh tarn deva jihvaya badhasva duskrtam m^rto 'you' CP yo no 'mortal' (RV 6.16.32) God, tie down with your tongue RP ji'ghamsati 'You, O mortal, tries to slay that evil-doer who, a us.' 4.2. Question formation: As noted for instance by Hettrich (1988), only main clauses can be expected to express the illocutionary force of com- mands, questions, etc. But as illustrated by example (16a), repeated below as Hock: Conjoined (34), it ever, is is we 105 stand possible to question constituents of Sanskrit RCs. how- (This pattern, quite rare.) (33) tasmad idam akaram yat kirn RP Interr. apad(i) (SB 4.1.5.4) CP 'Because have done what ?, therefore this has happened.' = 'What have done to have gotten into this?' I I phenomena: Deletion 4.3. Sanskrit relative-correlatives preferentially from RCs were left to right, is As observed no matter whether the §1, head deletion in phenomenon, applying RC or the subordinate, the hierarchical difference between be expected to favor head deletion in in CC precedes. If might RCs and CCs the RC. Conjunction phenomena: conjoined, the interesting question must 4.4. tures are in essentially a linear If relative arise as to and correlative clauses are how these conjoined struc- turn conjoined with other structures. In conjoined phrases or semantically non-subordinate 'main' clauses (MCs), the conjunction usually attaches to the first element of the conjoined structure; and commonly, especially if the conjunction is a clitic, it follows the first element. Compare (34) for clitic ca 'and', (35) for non-clitic, second-position hf 'for (causal)', and (35) for the non-clitic quasi-conjunction tasmad 'therefore'. ''^ (34) (a) yo me dadati sata ca (RV virrisatirri ca gonarh [harfca yukta sudhuraJNP (NP conjunction) 5.2.7a/b) 'Who gives me 120 cows and (two) yoked, easily joined horses.' (b) srnvanta vam avase johavFmi [vrdhe ca no bhavatam vajasatau]MC (MC conjunction) (RV1.34.12c/d) call for support you two (who are) hearing, and (may you) appear to us for growth in the winning of booty.' tad indro 'mucyata [devo hi sahJMc (MC conjunction) 'I (35) (SB (36) 1.2.3.2) 'Then Indra freed himself; for he is a God.' upeva va enenaitad vevesti [tasmad upaveso namaJMC (SB 1.2.1.3) (MC conjunction) 'He attends {upa ...vevesti) on it with it; therefore its name is upavesa.' When a group of conjoined MCs is conjoined with another proposition, the commonly is attached only to the first clause of the group, as in (37). A rarer alternative, however, is to attach the conjunction to each clause in the group; cf. (38). conjunction (37) ... "... [ [vaca hi dFyateJMG [vaca pradlyate] mc]mc+mc (MS 1.11.5) by means of speech one gives (and) by means of speech for one hands out.' Studies in the Linguistic Sciences 19:1 (Spring 1989) 106 tasmad etah ... uttisthanti ... [sattrabhijitam hi ^ asam]Mc [avaruddham hi ^ asam]Mc ]mc+mc (JB 2.374) Therefore these set out ...; for there had been victory for them through sacrifice, for there had been obtainment for them.' (38) [ Now, when we tions, comes cf. comes it to conjoining RC+CC structures with other construc- attaches to whichever clause conjoined structures of the type (37); find that generally the conjunction first (whether RC or CC), just as in e.g. (39) -(41). na tvad dhota purvo agne yajFyan na karyaih paro asti svadhavah [visas ca yasya atithir bhavasijpc (39) | [ RP & [sa yajnena vanavad deva martan]cc ]rc+cc (RV 5.3.5) CP 'No hotr worshiped better before you, Agni; no (one) exceeds you through poetry, O independent one; and of whose clan you will be guest, he will defeat the mortals (40) (a) through sacrifice, O God.' [na hi tad avakalpatejcc [yad bruyad [ . . . CP . . . .]cc ]cc+rc (SB 1.1.1.6) for it is not proper that he should say ...' [yad (d)hi manasa dhyayatijpc [tad vaca vadatijcc ]rc+cc CP (TS 2.5.1 1.5) RP for what one thinks through one's mind, that one speaks with "... (b) . RP . [ *... one's voice.' (41) [tasmad [yaeva 'therefore' RP nrtyati ...]rc [tasminn evaita nfmislatama ivaJccJRc+cc (SB 3.1.4.6) CP 'Therefore, who dances ..., to him they are most attached, as it were.' However, just as in conjoined MCs, RC+CC native of placing the conjunction into both clauses; structures offer the rarer altercf. e.g. (42) and (43). In (42), the repeated conjunction uN, which here can be translated (roughly) as 'on the other hand', contrasts both components of the second RC+CC structure with both components of the first RC+CC structure. In (43), we find hi distributed members of the RC+CC construction, but without any special con- over both trastive connotations. (42) [ [yad asya purvamJRc [ asya]cc ]rc+cc [apararfi tad RP RP apararhJRc [tad v asya purvamjcc ]rc+cc CP (JB 1.258) beginning that is its end; on the other hand, what [yad V asya ^ RP 'What its is its end, that (on the other hand) (Similarly elsewhere; cf. e.g. JB is its beginning.' 2.269. 3.183) is Hock: Conjoined we stand (43) ... [yad 107 asyai kruram abhutjpc (d)hi' RP asya etad ahars[t]cc ]rc+cc (SB [tad (d)hi 1 .2.5.23) CP for "... what blood there has been taken from (Similarly of her, (for) that he has now her.* SB 1.1.4.4, SB (K) 2.2.4.16) placement, then, provides further evidence suggesting that relative-correlatives are syntactically conjoined structures. The evidence 4.5. of conjunction Multiple RC+CC combinations: relative-correlatives are syn- If should be possible to combine RCs and CCs recursively and quite freely, limited only by pragmatics, restrictions on memory, or processing difficulties. At least one linguist (Srivastav 1988) has claimed that in Hindi, recursive relativization is not possible in preposed RCs, which she considers have argued to be conjoined adjoined RCs and whose Sanskrit counterparts tactically conjoined, it I structures. (Cf. note 4 for further details.) preposed RCs is possible. RC CC having more than one two such RCs surround the possibility of In (44), is show therefore useful to RCs and CCs indeed, the combination of Sanskrit ive relativization of It is quite free Examples refer to different (44) - heads and that, that recurs- (45) illustrate the in the same CC. two such RCs The increasingly complex ex- that they refer to; in (45), both precede their CC; and in (46), both follow. amples under (47) further illustrate the possibility of recursive preposed relativization, where each of the RCs refers to the next clause following Srivastav's claim that preposed recursive RCs are not possible thus does not seem to hold for Sanskrit. (In fact, does not apply to Hindi either; cf. note 4.) it. it (44) yathai ha girau jyotir bhayad RP evami tasyarhj janatayarhj bhati CP CP yasyarhj bhavati ... (JB 1.240) RP a light might shine on a mountain, he shines among that peoplej among whom, he is.' yadyi ahainarh prancarh acaislr 'Just asj soj (45) RP yatha, paraca asmaya prsthato 'nnadyam upaharet RP tadr'kjtatj CP (SB 10.5.5.2) CP one were to as back to someone sitting (and looking) away, so, (would) that, (be).' = 'If you piled the fire altar forward, that would be as one were to bring food from the back to someone 'Ifj you have piled it (the fire altar) forward, just bring food from the if sitting (and looking) away." if, ) Studies in the Linguistic Sciences 19:1 (Spring 1989) 108 osati (46) ha vai saj tarrij CP CP purvo bubhusati yoj 'smat RP veda (BAU yai evarh 1 .4.1 RP 'He burns him who wishes to be before him, who knows thus.' = 'He who knows thus burns him who wishes to be before him.' (47) (a) yaj eva esa purusa RP tasyai yej pranas CP RP tanyj uttarany ahani (JB 3.379) CP "Who (is) man, of him what breaths (there are), they (are) the = "The breaths which belong to this man are the this later days." later days.' (b) yOj vai sreyasahj parivesanam avavadati RP yayak vai saj tami artya RP CP enarrij ninayati tayak kamayate (JB 3.303) CP of his betterj, with whatk affliction hej wants (to afflict) him,, with that (afflication) (hej) afflicts him;.' = 'Who deprecates the food of his better, he is afflicted by him with whatever affliction he wants to afflict him with.' [kascidj] eti tad yatraj vai ksatrenaranyena 'WhOj deprecates the food (c) RP yok vai tatrai tarhj RP CP yad dasyur janati yati [tasyak] syalvarri va madhu va bhavati RP tenai [sak] asmij avir bhavati (JB 2.423) CP 'Now, wherei [someonej] goes through the jungle with a ksatriya, whatk non-Aryan notices himj therei, whateven and sweetness there is (of himk), with that) hek = 'Now if someone goes through the a non-Aryan notices him there, he jungle with a ksatriya, shows himself to him with all the friendliness and sweetness at friendliness become visible for himj.' if his disposal.' Multiply 'attached' RCs: While patterns of the type (44) - (47) would probably be compatible with either the adjoined or the conjoined analysis of Sanskrit relative-correlatives, structures of the type (48), with an RC 4.6. simultaneously 'attached' to two different CCs, would cause great difficulties for Hock: Conjoined we stand 109 For simultaneous adjunction of a subordinate clause to in Tree Diagram IV) would be without precedent. Under a conjoined analysis, however, (48) is not substantially different from (44) - (47) and thus causes no difficulties whatsoever.'''* the adjoined analysis. two distinct main clauses (as sai vai (48) daivFvag CP yayai yad yadj eva vadati RP RP (BAU tad tadj bhavati 1 .3.27) CP 'Divine speech means of whichj, thatj faculty such that comes about.' (is) that; if (faculty) comes whatever) one speaks by about.' = 'Divine speech is a you speak something by means of it, that Tree Diagram IV 4.7. Syntactic parallelism of RPs and CPs: Further evidence that RCs and CCs of Sanskrit relative-correlatives have equal syntactic rank comes from the parallel word order behavior of the RP and the pronoun tad/ etad, both as CP and in other functions. In the Vedic language, both RP and the tad/etad have a strong tendency to be placed into clause-initial position, frequently separated from their heads. In addition to the examples cited earlier, compare for instance (49) below. (Here and in the following examples, the RP (in the (a) examples) and tad/etad (49) (a) (b) (in the (b) examples) are set sakhibhya a varam (RV 1.4.4c) '... who (is) dearer to you than (all) friends.' t^rh tva vajesu vajinam vajayamah ... (RV ... y^s off in boldface.) te 'We make victorious you, the victorious, in 1 .4.9a/b) the victories ...' is fronted, too, that element precedes, and any) inten/ene between that fronted element and the RP or tad/etad. (Fronted elements (X), which in this manner take precedence over RP and tad/etad, include verbs (50a), 'adverbials' (50b, 51b), and nouns (51a).) If any clitic pronouns (set off in small caps) are placed into the resulting 'initial If, however, another element sentential particles (if 1 Studies in the Linguistic Sciences 19:1 (Spring 1989) 10 Strings', the Rig-Veda prefers to place them after the but occasionally places language, the (50) (a) them before latter pattern is (as in RP or tad/etad (as In (51)). in (50)), the later Vedic-Prose the norm. taksady^tTE usanasahasasaho ... (RV 1.51.1 Oa/b) X (b) 'When Usanas made force for you by force ...' anu tan no jaspatir marhsFsta (|) ratnam devasya savitur iyanah X (RV 7.38.6a/b) 'May the Lord going (51) (a) (for of the Family assign this jewel of deva NO yatha sadam ... God Savitr to us, it).' id vrdhe asann (RV 1.89.1c) X so that the Gods may always be for our growth.' pra VAH sa dhftaye nasat (RV 1 .41 .5c) "... (b) X that reaches your (favorable) thinking." '... Beside such structures we 'near-initial' position, position; cf. e.g. (52). find (For details on this pattern, including (b) 4.8. continuation in (RV 3.1.12c) janita 'cows' 'creator' "... who as creator created forth the cows.' jajana Verb vavram anantam ava X CCs have yo ud usriya X sa 'down' 'May she its Hock 1989c.) the classical language, see (52) (a) in which the RP or tad/etad appear in initial or a pattern in which they are placed into preverbal fall down padfst.a (RV 7.104.17c) Verb into limitless depths.' Summary: There is thus a large amount of evidence that RCs and the same syntactic rank, that both clauses exhibit features typical of main-clause propositions, and that syntactically, they are conjoined, rather than to the other. Sanskrit RCs, then, although semantically subordinate, syntactically seem to be comparable to the German conjoined denn-clause type in (14), not to the subordinate ive/'/-clause type of (13). one being subordinate 5. Apparent problems There is, however, some evidence which appears to argue against a conjoined analysis of Sanskrit relative-correlatives. In the present section try to address this issue and to argue that, initial appearances notwithstanding, the evidence does not require an adjoined (or embedded) analysis. I Accentuation: An argument against a conjoined analysis, most employed by Hettrich (1988), is that in terms of Vedic verb accentuRCs systematically differ from CCs. While RC verbs are accented, (non- 5.1. recently ation, fronted) CC verbs are not; cf. e.g. (1), reproduced here as (53), with the verbs and others before him have claimed that this accentual difference reflects different syntactic status: Accented verbs occur in subordinate clauses, unaccented verbs, in main clauses. set off in boldface. Hettrich Hock: Conjoined we stand (53) yam 111 eva tat pasayo manusyesu kamam arohams eva pasusu kamam rohati (SB 2.1.2.7) 'What desire the cattle at that time obtained among men, that desire he (now) obtains among cattle.' u ha tarn u ha ^ ^ However, accented (non-fronted) verbs can also be found that are conjoined by means in of coordinating conjunctions like main clauses ca 'and', or juxtaposed without any overt marker of coordination; cf. (54) and (55). While in structures like (54), containing doubled ca ... ca, roughly translatable as 'both ... and", accentuation of the verb in the left clause is (nearly) obligatory, in other structures it is not; cf. e.g. (56) beside (55). As especially Delbrijck (1888:37-43) and Oldenberg (1906) have pointed out, in structures of the type (55) and (56), no syntactic or other formal criteria make it possible to predict whether the verb of the first clause will be accented or not. Presumably, the difference in verb accentuation is explainable, but only by pragmatic factors, similar to the 'special connnectness' invoked in §1 for examples (8) and (9). (Cf. Woodbury 1987 for a discussion of how phonological processes may be governed by general semantic or pragmatic factors without mediation by the syntax. And see Hock 1989a,b,d and In Press for further discussion of the Sanskrit facts.) (54) (55) (56) punar a ca yanti (RV 1.132.12) ca yanti & Verb & Verb 'They both go away and they come back.' a ^ anyah krosati pra ^ anyah sarhsati (TS 7.5.9.3) " Verb Verb 'One scolds, (and, but) the other one praises.' somarh anya upa ^ asadat ... karambham anya ichati " Verb Verb para (RV 6.57.2) 'One has sat down to the soma .... (and. but) the other wants porridge.' A more serious argument against a conjoined Dasgupta (1984) for Bangia (cf. §1 above), is based on the existence of structures in which RCs appear to be embedded into 'matrix clauses'; cf. e.g. (57) - (60). (The RCs of these examples are set off in boldface.) 5.7. 'Embedded' RCs: analysis, raised by (57) asmabhyarh tad dhattana yad va fmahe ridho visvayu CP saubhagam (RV RP 'favor* 5.53.13) we request, life-long favor, luck.' vayam y^d vavana tad vivisma I'ndraya 'for him' 'we' RP CP pl.1 'for Indra' 'For him, for Indra, we get that which he deserves.' a gha gamad y^di sr^vat sahsrinlbhir utibhih ... (RV RP 'Give to us that which (58) (59) asmai 'Let him come, if he hears, with thousandfold support 1.30.8) ...' 1 Studies in the Linguistic Sciences 19:1 (Spring 1989) 12 ye CA ^ im6 brahmanah RP & & susruvamso 'nucanas (SB 1.3.3.8) 'Around here sit both the Gods and who (are) these learned well-taught brahmins.' = '... and those here who are learned ...' tam etad dev§s ca paryasate (60) ^ it Now, as and precedes or the one that follows Gonda 1959] of the remainder of the Hettrich notes (1988:608), in constructions of the type (57) (58), either the part of the 'matrix clause' that the RC is an amplification [in the sense of Thus, in (57), radho visvayu saubhagam matrix clause. an appositive amplification 'life-long favor, luck' is tad 'that' occurring in the structure preceding the RC; and the passage preceding this amplification is a syntactically and Similarly, in (58), tad vivisma pragmatically complete CC+RC proposition. indraya 'that we get for Indra' is essential for the understanding of the whole structure, while what precedes the RC contains redundant information: vayam 'we' is expressed on the verb, and asmai 'for him' is duplicated by indraya 'for Indra'. The apparent embedding in structures like (57) and (58) may therefore be considered to result from stylistic movement processes such as extraposition (57) or left of the extraction (58). processes appear to be able to move However, note that the movement takes place vis-a-vis conjoined structures, not across clauses of different syntactic rank. Moreover, the view that structures of the type (58) result from As (61) shows, the extraction is supported by good empirical evidence. elements of the 'matrix clause' that precede apparently embedded RCs may contain 'initial strings' with sentence-initial particles like /7a and sma, and these What may be unusual is that these constituents accross intervening clauses. same strings may recur in the part of the 'matrix clause' that follows the RC. (Hock 1987b), 'same clause' are possible only in structures with extraction. Since in the present case, a 'reduced-clause' analysis is not possible, the only explanation for the double occurrence of ha across the RC from sma is that what precedes the RC has been extracted Now, with the possible exception such multiple occurrences of of 'reduced-clause' structures initial strings within the — the CC — that follows. (61) (a)thoHASMA ^ etenaiva samna cyavano bhargavo particles yad yad asanarh cakame RP tad tad (d)HA CP sma sarasvatyal saisavad udacati (JB 3.128) particles 'Now, by means of that very saman, Cyavana Bhargava, whatever food he desired, that he used to draw up from the (fountain of) youth of SarasvatF.' Examples of the type (59) are not amenable to explanations of this type, seems to be essential for a proper interpretation of the purport of a gha gamad '\q\ him come'. However, it is reasonable to assume that structures of this type are part of a more general since satisrinibhir utibfiih 'with thousandfold support' Hock: Conjoined we stand phenomenon, namely the parentheticals may insertion of parentheticals. 113 And as (62) illustrates, consist of any syntactic structures, including unambiguously independent, main-clause propositions. Presumably the intonational features generally associated with parentheticals mark these structures as inserted, rather than as syntactically embedded. vayam (62) te 'we' 'We The only vaya indra viddhi $0 nah pra bharamahe ... pl.1 (RV 2.20.1) 'strength' sg.2 'us' bring forth for you, O Indra ! .' . . structures that cause genuine difficulties are patterns of the type (60), containing 'replacive' or 'headless' head — know us well — strength RCs which have no corresponding the 'matrix clause' and which appear to function as constituents of that clause. Note that the relative clause ye ca ^ ime brahmanih susruvamso 'nucan§s 'and who (are) these learned well-taught brahmins' is conjoined, by in means of the particle devas ca ca 'and', with the subject constituent of And '(both) the Gods'. syntactic status recall that is of the same — sentences with sentences, or constituents with constituents, but not clauses with constituents. syntactically the 'matrix' clause, ca conjoins elements a constituent It appears therefore that the RC of (60) and thus embedded into that of the 'matrix clause' clause. But note that as Hettrich (1988:601, 608, 788, etc.) points out, replacive RCs usually appear at the margin of the clause to which they appear to belong. may suggest that they are not fully embedded into the 'matrix' clause. Moreover, as (63) illustrates, the internal syntax of replacive RCs is independent of the syntax of the 'matrix' clause: Here, the RC appears to function as one of several conjoint subjects of the 'matrix' clause and should therefore, like vidyut Instead, yam 'lightening' and tanyatuh 'thunder', be in the nominative case. miham 'what rain' is in the accusative case, as required by the internal syntax of the RC. This (63) na na „ asmai vidyun na tanyatuh sisedha yam mi'ham akirad ... (RV1.32.13) RP 'Lightning did not help him, nor thunder, nor poured what rain he out...' Most important, however, Hettrich (1988:694) suggests that these struc- tures have undergone ellipsis, the 'missing' head of the 'matrix clause' being easily supplied from the context. That this analysis is on the right track is suggested by the parallelism of (64) and (65). Here the Kanvfya (K) recension of the text (64) appears to offer a headless, replacive RC, while the Madhyandina (M) recension in (65) furnishes the 'missing head', in the form of the CP tarn. (Similar examples occur elsewhere; cf. e.g. SB (M) 2.6.4.1 SB (K) 1.6.4.1.) Interestingly, however, (65) does not have the head within the 'matrix clause'. Rather, the head appears to be extraposed after the RC. Alternatively, the configuration RC + head may be considered elliptical for the more complete structure in (65'). Either analysis would account for the fact that 'replacive' RCs : 1 14 Studies in the Linguistic Sciences 19:1 (Spring 1989) occur typically at the margin of the 'matrix clause". Moreover, under the second ca within the RC of (60) can be explained along the lines of § 4.4 above, as an instance of ca linking the entire elliptical RC+CC combination to the preceding clause; cf. (60') below.^^ analysis, the occurrence of the conjunction eteno eva vyajayata ya iyam asya vi'jitis (SB (K) 1.3.4.9) 'Through this he won what victory (there is) of him now.' = 'Through this he won the victory that now is his.' eteno eva vyajayata iyarh vfjitis tarn ya ^ asya (64) ^ RP (65) ~ RP (SB (M) 2.4.4.15) 'Through this he won what victory (there CP is) of him now, that one.' (eteno eva vyajayata) (65') [ [ya ^ asya ^ [tarn iyarri vfjitisjRc eva vyajayatajcc ]rc+cg CP RP '(Through this he won;) what victory (there one he won.' (tam etad devas (60') [ [ye CA is) of him now, that ca paryasate) ime brahmanah susruvimso 'nucanas]Rc RP [t6 paryasatejoG ]rc+cc CP '(Around it here sit the Gods,) and those here well-taught brahmins, they 5.2. Conclusion: As who are learned, around.' hope to have shown in this section, two possible the conjoined analysis of Sanskrit relative-correlatives the verb accentuation between RCs and CCs and the apparent difficulties for difference sit in I — — existence of embedded RCs are amenable to alternative explanations and thus do not invalidate the proposed analysis. 6. COMP In this Sanskrit defined or TOPIC? section I consider the question as to whether the 'landing — site' for RPs should be considered TOPIC or COMP however these may be in a formal grammar of Sanskrit. The former ('TOPIC') analysis has been suggested by Hock 1989c, Schaufele In Press (cf. also Hock 1982, Klein In Press); the latter ('COMP') account has been proposed by M. Hale 1987. The difference between these two accounts is of considerable interest for the analysis of Sanskrit RCs, since COMP is generally assumed to be the landing RPs (whether in 'logical form' or in the syntax), not only RCs, but also in relative-correlatives of languages like Sanskrit; cf. 1975 (1985), Dasgupta 1980. site for The TOPIC in embedded e.g. Andrews analysis: According to the TOPIC analysis, 'stressed RPs, tad/etad (both as CP and in other functions), and interrogative pronouns, behave alike and tend to be placed into 'initial strings' of the 6.1. pronominals', i.e. Hock: Conjoined we stand type (66). NPs The initial NPs position of these strings ('position 115 1') attracts 'topicalized' elements which are emphasized, under focus, etc.), or if nothing else has been fronted, stressed pronominals. Note that the initial position can accommodate at most one constituent or part of a constituent. or parts of (66) Vedic (i.e., initial strings 'NEXUS' (Hock 1989c): 116 Studies in the Linguistic Sciences 19:1 (Spring 1989) English w/7-words), while the former is the landing site for other fronted elements, presumably including tad/etad. Clitic pronouns follow COMP, while particles attach to the first element of the clause, whether that be TOPIC or COMP. Compare the summary in (67), where (a) and (b) illustrate what hap- pens TOPIC. Hale's analysis, then, disand predicts non-parallel behavior for RPs and to particles in structures with or without COMP tinguishes TOPIC from tad/etad. Moreover, of the different 'stressed pronominal' positions predicts only positions (67) Vedic initial TOPIC 1 and 3. strings (M. Hale 1987): in (66), it Hock: Conjoined we stand As noted §4.7, in in and namely the preverbal one string positions 1, 3, addition to 5, initial and 1 near-initial placement, Sanskrit offers another position for 17 i.e. initial- RPs and CPs, above. of (52) has been noted as a focus position for a number of (mainly SOV) languages, including Turkish (Kornfilt 1987), as well as Hungarian (cf. most recently Farkas & Sadock 1989). For modern South Asian languages have argued for a preverbal focus position for interrogative pronouns since Hock 1987a; cf. also Hock 1989a. Further arguments for preverbal FOCUS in modern South Asian languages, not limited to pronominals, have been advanced in Jayaseelan 1989 and Nagarajan 1989. (What has not been settled up to this point is the question of how preverbal FOCUS is to be characterized in a formal grammar; cf. the different accounts in Farkas & Sadock 1989 and the literature cited there, Jayaseelan 1989, and Nagarajan 1989, as well as work in progress at the University of Illinois by Steven Schaufele (on Sanskrit) and Rakesh Bhatt (on Kashmiri). But this is a question of analysis, not Now, preverbal position I of evidence.) have shown that a special preverbal position must be In Hock 1989c recognized also for Sanskrit. Note that this position is not limited to stressed pronominals, but also accommodates 'content words', such as the bold-face elements in the double-focus construction of (68). Here, one of the contrasted elements, the head of the subject NP {vSg, pranah) is 'postposed' into preverbal position in each of the contrasted passages. And as often happens in topicalization, in the process, the head is separated from its modifier (asya piirusasya mrtasya 'of this dead person'). (See also Schaufele 1989.) I yatrasya purusasya mrtasyagnim vag apyeti vatam prana(h) (68) 'fire' 'voice' 'air* (SB 14.6.3.13 = BAU 3.2.13) 'When of this dead person the voice enters the 'breath' ... (enters) the air Now, examples position is like (68) a (secondary) fire, the breath ...' leave no doubt that for 'content words', preverbal position and thus, in its discourse functions, FOCUS most closely related to the TOPIC position. Whatever its specific form, a semmust therefore be able to attach similar discourse functions to 'content words' placed either in FOCUS or in TOPIC. antic interpretation initial This conclusion can serve as the basis for a circumstantial argument that or near-initial RPs, CPs, etc. have been moved into TOPIC, not COfvlP: In the absence of contrary evidence, it is reasonable to assume that preverbal stressed pronominals are placed into the same preverbal FOCUS position as the 'content words' of structures like (68). To do otherwise would seem to be a violation of Occam's Razor. Once we do so, assign to preverbal however, RPs and FOCUS to permit the semantic interpretation to same scope and coreference approaches assign to them in COtVlP. That is, premust be able to perform functions traditionally assigned to relationships that 'orthodox' verbal we have interrogatives the 8 Studies in the Linguistic Sciences 19:1 (Spring 1 1 1 989) COMP. (An alternative would be to have RPs and interrogatives move into the syntax, and then into COMP in 'logical form". However, unless supported by independent evidence, the double movement required under this analysis must be considered special pleading and therefore highly suspect.) FOCUS in we are faced with a situation where the semantic scope and coreference relationships to RPs and interrogatives in preverbal FOCUS, (ii) to attach discourse functions to 'content words' placed in FOCUS, and (iii) to attach similar discourse functions to 'content words' placed in TOPIC. Under the circumstances, the most efficient Given this analysis, interpretation way for must be able (i) to assign semantic interpretation to operate would be to assign discourse func- and scope and coreference relationships in both positions, i.e. both in and TOPIC, rather than assigning discourse functions in FOCUS and TOPIC, but scope and coreference relations in FOCUS and COMP.^^ This, then, suggests that the formal mechanism for assigning scope and coreference relationships must look more like the one in Bach & Cooper 1978 than the ones proposed in Andrews 1975 (1985) and Dasgupta 1980. tions FOCUS 7. Summary and conclusions In this paper I have provided evidence, both typological and language- specific, that Sanskrit relative-correlatives syntactically are Moreover, I have attempted relative-correlatives correct, these is not to show COMP, arguments have conjoined structures. that the 'landing site' for but either TOPIC RPs or preverbal in Sanskrit FOCUS. If significant implications for syntactic theory. Thus, a Bach & Cooper-style account would be more appropriate for the semantic interpretation of Sanskrit relative-correlatives than the more 'traditional' analysis in terms of COMP. What needs to be further investigated is whether some or all of the arguments of this paper can be extended to relativecorrelatives in other SOV languages. (The typological arguments seem to hold for early Indo-European in general; cf. Hock 1989d. At this point, however, it is not clear whether the language-specific arguments are similarly applicable.) NOTES *An earlier version has been presented as a Linguistics Seminar talk, Illinois, 5 October 1989. Parts of the paper have been presented elsewhere in very different form; cf. Hock 1989 a,b,c,d. gratefully acknowledge helpful and challenging comments at the meetings at which these earlier papers were delivered, especially from George Cardona, Mark Hale, Stanley Insler, Yamuna Kachru, Paul Kiparsky, and Jared Klein. also thank Rajeshwari Pandharipande and my wife, Zarina M. Hock, for help with Hindi data, and Sarah Tsiang for help with Turkish. Some of the ideas presented in this paper converge with arguments in Kiparsky 1989. However, in its general argumentation, the present paper steers an independent course. As usual, the responsibility for any errors rests with me. University of I I — Hock: Conjoined we stand 1 19 ^For a formal account of discontinuous constituency resulting from the of RPs and other individual words, see Schaufele 1988, 1989, and In movement Press. keeping with the pretheoretical tenor of this paper, am not taking a in structures of the type (2) - (4) the head is simply unspecified or actually deleted. For brevity's sake will use the terms 'delete' and 'deletion' or 'ellipsis' throughout the paper. 2|n I position on whether I 3|n addition to the publications referred to in the discussion below, the relative-correlative nature of relative-clause formation in Sanskrit, other early Indo-European languages, and non-Indo-European SOV languages has been noted e.g. by Downing 1978, Held 1957, Hock 1985, 1988a, Lakshmi Bai 1985, Masica 1972, Ramasamy 1981, Watkins 1976. These accounts, however, do not meaningfully address the question of whether such RCs should be considered underlyingly embedded, adjoined, or conjoined. ^Srivastav (1988) proposes to account for preposed Hindi RCs as adjoined subordinate clauses, but for surface-embedded or postposed RCs (= 'postposed RCs') as underlyingly embedded. She supports her analysis by a number of arguments and finds further support in child language acquisition. Her analysis and arguments require closer examination than is possible in the (Dasgupta 1980 has raised similar arguments for Bangia present paper. 'postposed' RCs, but without working out the details.) however, is possible to point to weaknesses in some unlike postarguments: In her view, preposed RCs cannot stack up, and this asymmetry is left unexplained if we posed ones assign the same underlying structure to preposed and postposed RCs. Srivastav formally motivates this distinction by claiming that a postposed RC modifies its head and therefore is its sister, while a preposed RC 'picks out a set in the ___domain of discourse and the main clause asserts something about this set. As such, it functions like a quantifier, having scope over the main clause.' (149) Postposed recursive relativization therefore 'should be easy, since NP -» Even at this point, it — of Srivastav's formal — N' S' allows for it ... The recursive quantification is left-adjoined structure represents quantification not known to be a standard feature of and natural languages.' (151) In fact, though (like however, stacking is grammatical in Hindi, as in (a) below, even stacked postposed RCs), such structures may be difficult to process. (a) jo ranFj hathfpar baith ke ja rahFthF RP uSi ka ratn CP vahfj aj jis cor ne, curaya RP yaham ghCim raha hai CP 'Which queen was riding on an elephant, by which thief her jewel was stolen, he is walking around here today.' = 'The thief who stole 120 Studies in the Linguistic Sciences 19:1 (Spring 1989) who was the jewel of the queen riding on an elephant is walking around here today." A second argument Srivastav adduces is what she believes to be an asymmetry between preposed and postposed RCs as far as quantification is concerned: In structures with postposed RCs, quantification of the shared head does not require any special adjustment in the main clause; cf. (b) and (c). (In these and the following examples, RCs are set off in square brackets.) After preposed RCs, however, the main clause cannot be introduced by a simple correlative (d), but requires a partitive construction (e). Note however that the constraint appears to be sensitive not to the nature of the clauses involved (whether RC or CC, preposed or postposed), but to whether the quantification (the numeral do same in (f) 'two') situation in vs. (g/h). If occurs sequences in of the first clause or in the second. Witness the independent, non-subordinate propositions, as anything, the parallelism between (b/c) vs. (d/e) could be taken as an argument for considering both structures to be sequences of conjoined clauses. (b) do larkiyam khan 'Two do (c) *|jo girls (e) (f) (g) (h) [jo who larkiyarh "Which hairh [jo lambF are standing there larkiyarh [jo 'Two (d) girls girls larkiyarh lambf are khan hairh] tall khan are tall.' are standing there.' hairri] ve do lambf hairh hairh] un tall." mem se do lambfhaim of those, two are tall." tall." '(Several) girls are standing there; of those, two are this motivation is implicit at best. to vs. (g/h) hairh "Which girls are standing there, do larkiyam khan haim; ve lambF hairh 'Two girls are standing there; they are tall.' *larkiyam khan hairh; ve do lambf hairh '(Several) girls are standing there; those two are larkiyam khan haim; un mem se do lambF haim 5|n many accounts, major motivation seems (f) hairh] who are standing there, those two are khan and RC+CC and CC+RC be that base-generating In relative tall.' early analyses, the clauses under NP possible to relate them transformationally to clearly embedded, prenominal participial structures. Even if such 'powerful' transformational accounts were still acceptable, the arguments presented in this paper show that basegenerating RCs under NP does not properly account for the RC syntax of makes it languages like Sanskrit. As for Srivastav's (1988) argument that Hindi has both adjoined and embedded base-generated RCs, see note 4 above. Note that Wali (1984) finds it impossible to decide between the embedded and 'adjoined' analyses for Marathi. ^Andrews and Dasgupta's accounts are formulated for an 'adjoined' RC+CC structures. Bach & Cooper's proposal seems to be intended a 'conjoined' analysis. See also §6.4 below, where will argue that Bach & analysis of for Cooper's analysis I is preferable for Sanskht. Hock: Conjoined we stand 121 ^See note 4 above. 8A conjoined analysis has been proposed much earlier by Berman (1972) and Donaldson (1971). But these proposals come from a time when even English RCs could be considered underlyingly conjoined; cf. e.g. Thompson 1971 (1979)). A conjoined analysis has repeatedly been adumbrated in IndoEuropanist circles, through claims that RC+CC structures take an intermediate position between subordination and coordination; cf. e.g. Haudry 1973 and Jeffers 1987. And Holland (1984) seems to vacillate between an adjoined and a conjoined analysis. However, these accounts do not go much beyond suggestive or programmatic statements. ^Hettrich one of supplements semantic/pragmatic arguments with the formal On this matter, see §5.1 below. his Vedic verb accentuation. 10A minor exception is the usual correlative evam 'thus, so' of yatha 'how, what manner', as in (16c). (Though not derivable from the CP stem tad/etad, evam functions as a suppletive variant of the rarer CP tatha 'thus, so', which in contains the normal CP The stem.) only significant exception is the conditional which Klein (1985) derives through reinterpretation of coordinate structures with ca 'and'. Although historically and morphologically different, this marker has been integrated into the system of relative-correlatives, by acquiring (optional) correlative markers as in the following example. marker ca/ced 'if ced ittharri vai na bhavisyavo vai tarhi 'If we two will be saksyavah praja bhartum CP ' •if in this condition, then we will not (JB 1.294) to maintain be able the creatures.' For the general arguments in this section and the Dravidian data see also Hock 1988b. Turkish data have been adapted from Kornfilt 1987 and especially Lewis 1967. 11 i2What all the Turkish restriction of relative-corSecondly, note that the finite verb of Turkish generalizing relatives is in the conditional mood. This brings to mind the existence in Dravidian of generalizing relative-correlatives with conditional verbs; cf. Hock 1988b with references. Moreover, Sanskrit generalizing relative-correlatives frequently mark the verb of the relative clause in the optative, as in the is interesting is first of relatives to generalizing functions. examples below. Finally, note that pragmatically, generalizing relative struc- tures are closely affiliated with conditionals, (Compare also the data in (7) alizing relative-correlatives are (a) suryam yo brahmi RP 'What (b) priest/if (8) sa sg.3opt. CP id vadhuyam arhati (RV1 0.85.34) sg.3ind. a priest should know the surya, he deserves the bride's sa hanyate RP CP sg.3ind. 'Who/if the alternative glosses below. above.) vidyat garment.' yo na hanyat sg.3opt. cf. These peculiarities of generphenomena which deserve fuller investigation. and someone should (Pane. 1.271) not (decide) to kill, he is killed.' 122 Studies in the Linguistic Sciences 19:1 (Spring 1989) i3For rarer alternative orderings, see e.g. Klein 1985:53-55. same construction is grammatical in Hindi; might therefore be appropriate to examine to what degree a conjoined analysis might be justified also for Hindi relative-correlatives. I'^lnterestingly, essentially the cf. the example below. It bhasa vah sakyatai hai CP ke dvara jiSj vahfj jOj bhfkahte hairfi RP RP ban jaega CP 'Language (is) thatj comes whichj, thatj whateverj one speaks by means of = 'Language is a faculty such that if (faculty) about.' you speak something by means of that it, comes about.' i5The same ordering patterns seem to obtain for interrogative pronouns; on the other hand, locational deictics such as idam 'this (here)', adah 'that (over there)' behave quite differently. For further details, discussion, and references, see Hock 1989c. ^^The present account supersedes the one in Hock 1989d, where specRCs may result from a process of 'intraposition' or 'incorporation' that may be considered independently required to mediate between Bambara RC+CC and headless RC structures of the type (a) and (b) below. (Note that the related f^andingo only has the relative-correlative type; cf. I ulated that 'replacive' Sanskrit Bokamba & Drame 1978.) Ne ye tye min ye, o ye fini fere (a) CP RP 'What man saw, he sold the cloth.' = I (Relative-correlative) 'I saw the man who sold the cloth.' (b) Ne ye [tye ye fini min fere] (Replacive) ye RP 'I saw what man sold the cloth.' = 'I saw the man who sold the cloth.' arguments may be applicable to other languages. For instance, according to Kornfilt (1987:639), Turkish interrogatives are placed either in preverbal focus position or into sentence-initial (presumably TOPIC) position. i^Similar ABBREVIATIONS OF TEXTUAL REFERENCES BAU = Brhad-Aranyaka-Upanisad, Bh.G. = Bhagavad-GRa, Hit. = Hitopadesa, JB = JaiminFya-Brahmana, MS = MaitrayanF-Samhita, Pane. = Pahcatantra, RV = Rig-Veda, SB = Satapatha-Brahmana (Madhyandina-recension), SB (K) = Satapatha-Brahmana, KanvFya-recension, TS = TaittirFya-Sarhhita. Hock: Conjoined we stand 123 REFERENCES D., III. 1975 (1985). Studies in the syntax of relative and comparative clauses. Cambridge: MIT dissertation. (Repr. in "lightly retouched version", 1985, New York & London: Garland.) Bach, Emmond, and Robin H. Cooper. 1978. The NP-S analysis of relative clauses and compositional semantics. Linguistics and Philosophy 2.145- Andrews, Avety 50. Berman, Howard. 1972. Relative clauses Papers from the Relative Clause in Hittite. The Chicago which hunt: Linguistic So- Chicago: Festival, 1-8. ciety. BOKAMBA, Eyamba, and Mallafe Drame. 1978. Where do relative clauses come from in Mandingo? Papers from the 14th Regional Meeting of the Chicago Linguistic Society, 28-43. 1980. Questions and relative and complement clauses in a York University dissertation. Delbruck, Bertold. 1888. Altindische Syntax. Halle: Waisenhaus. Donaldson, Susan K. 1971. Movement in restrictive relative clauses in Hindi. Studies in the Linguistic Sciences 1 :2.1-74. Downing, Bruce T. 1978. Some universals of relative clause structure. Universals of human language, ed. by J. H. Greenberg, 4.375-418. Stanford, Dasgupta, Probal. New Bangia grammar. CA: University Press. Farkas, Donka F., and Jerrold M. Sadock. garian. Language 65.318-38. GONDA, Jan. 1959. Mouton. Hale, Kenneth. pology: In Four studies Gaps 1975. in in 1989. Preverb climbing grammar and culture. Linguistics Kinkade et Hun- The Hague: the language of the Veda. of C. F. Voegelin, ed. M. D. honor in and anthro- al., 295-315. de Ridder. Lisse: Hale, Mark Robert. 1987. Studies in the comparative syntax of the oldest IndoCambridge, MA: Harvard University Ph.D. disserIranian languages. tation. et correlation dans la phrase latine. de la Societe de Linguistique de Paris 68:1.147-86. Held, Warren H., Jr. 1957. The Hittite relative sentence. (Language Disser- Haudry, Jean. 1973. Parataxe, hypotaxe Bulletin tation, 55.) Hettrich, Berlin: Baltimore: Linguistic Society of America. 1988. Heinrich. Untersuchungen zur Hypotaxe im Vedischen. de Gmyter. Hock, Hans Henrich. PIE or discourse-based verb frontin Avestan and Homeric Greek. Studies in the Linguistic Sciences 12:1.1 -38. 1985. Review of Lehmann & Malkiel (1982): Perspectives on historical linguistics. Language 61.187-93. 1987 (a). Pre-Rig-Vedic convergence of Indo-Aryan and Dravidian? Paper presented at Osmania University, October 1987. (Other versions at ing? 1982. Clitic verbs in Sanskrit sa hovaca gargyah and congeners 124 Studies in the Linguistic Sciences 19:1 (Spring 1989) Kamaraj — — University, Madurai; Jawaharlal Neinru University, New Delhi; and Delhi University.) . . 1987 (b). Reduced-clause and clause-union absolutives and participles in Vedic Prose. Select Papers from SALA-7, ed. by E. Bashir et al., 182-98. Bloomington: Indiana University Linguistics Club. 1988 (a). Rebracketing and relative clauses in Old English. Germanic linguistics II: Papers from the Second Symposium on Germanic Linguistics, University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign, 3-4 October 1986, ed. by E. Antonsen and H. H. Hock, 35-54. Bloomington: Indiana University Linguistics Club. 1988 (b). Review article: Finiteness in Dravidian. (Sanford B. Steever Studies in (1988): The serial verb formation in the Dravidian languages.) the Linguistic Sciences 18:2.211-31. 1989 (a). On early Indo-Aryan and Dravidian syntax. International Seminar on Theoretical Approaches to Language Variation, 23-25 March 1989, Delhi University. To appear in the Proceedings. 1989 (b). Coordination, subordination, and the question of finiteness in early Sanskrit. 1989 South Asian Languages Analysis Roundtable, 2-4 June 1989, Madison, Wl. 1989(c). Chronology or genre? Problems in Vedic syntax. International Vedic Workshop, 11-14 June 1989, Harvard University. To appear in the Proceedings. 1989 (d). Early Indo-European syntactic typology: A different approach. Eighth East Coast Indo-European Conference, 15-17 June 1989, Harvard — — University. . In To appear in Indo-European Studies. 1 988. Language. Press. Review of Hettrich Delhi: Motilal Banarsidass. Subordination and relativization in early IndoEuropean. Proceedings of the 10th Annual Meeting of the Berkeley Linguistics Society, 609-22. Jayaseelan, K. a. 1989. Wh-movement in Malayalam. Paper read at the International Seminar on Theoretical Approaches to Language Variation, 23-25 March 1989, Delhi University. To appear in the Proceedings. Jeffers, Robert J. 1987. On methodology in syntactic reconstruction: Reconstructing inter-clause syntax in prehistoric Indo-European. Papers from , ed. In Press. Studies HOLLAND, Gary B. in Sanskrit syntax. 1984. the 7th International Conference on Historical Linguistics, ed. by A. G. Ramat et al., 305-23. Amsterdam: Benjamins. JUNGHARE, Indira. 1973. Restrictive relative clauses in Marathi. Indian Lin- guistics 34.251-62. Kachru, Yamuna. 1973 clause construction in Some aspects of pronominalization and relative Studies in the Linguistic Sciences Hindi-Urdu. 3:2.87-103. 1978. On relative clause formation in Hindi-Urdu. Linguistics 207.5-26. 1980. Aspects of Hindi grammar. New Delhi: Manohar. Keenan, Edward L. 1985. description, ed. by T. Relative clauses. Language typology and syntactic Shopen, 2.141-70. Cambridge: University Press. . Hock: Conjoined we stand 1 25 KiPARSKY, Paul. 1989. The rise of Germanic word order. Eighth East Coast Indo-European Conference, 15-17 June 1989, Harvard University. To appear in Indo-European Studies. Klein, Jared S. 1985. Toward a discourse grammar of the Rigveda, 1 Coord: inate conjunction, in 1 Introduction, ca, : L/fa. Heidelberg: Winter. Syntactic and discourse correlates of verb-initial sentences Hock (ed.) In Press:1 23-43. Press. in the Rigveda. KORNFILT, Jaklin. 1987. Turkish and the Turkic languages. The world's major languages, ed. by B. Comrie, 619-44. New York: Oxford University Press. Lakshmi Bai, B. 1985. Some notes on correlative constructions in Dravidian. For Gordon H. Fairbanks, ed. by V. Z. Acson and R. L Leed, 181-90. Honolulu: University of Hawaii Press. Lehmann, Christian. 1984. Der Relativsatz: Typologie seiner Strukturen, Theorie seiner Funktionen, Kompendium seiner Grammatik. Tubingen: Narr. Lewis, G. L 1967. Turkish grammar. Oxford: University Press. Masica, Colin. 1972. Relative clauses in South Asia. The Chicago which hunt: Papers from the Relative Clause Festival, 198-204. Chicago: Linguistic Society. Nagarajan, Hemlatha. 1989. A note on focus placement and focus movement rules in English, Hungarian, Aghem, and Tamil. Paper read at the International Seminar on Theoretical Approaches to Language Variation, 23-25 March 1989, Delhi University. To appear in the Proceedings. Oldenberg, 1906. H. Rgveda. 707-41 Patnaik, B. N. Vedische Untersuchungen, 16: Die Verbalenklise im der Deutschen Morgenlandischen Gesellschaft 60. Zeitschrift 1987. On the restrictive relative constructions in Oriya. inter- national Journal of Dravidian Linguistics 16.251-74. Ramasamy, K. 1981. Correlative relative clauses ed. by S. Agesthialingom and N. in Rajasekharan Tamil. Dravidian syntax, Nair, 363-80. Annamalai- nagar: Annamalai University Publications in Linguistics, 73. Schaufele, Steven. 1988. Where's my NP: Non-transformational analyses of Vedic pronominal fronting. Studies in the Linguistic Sciences 18:2.129- — 62. . 1989. The syntax of verb phrases in Vedic. 1 1th South Asian Languages Analysis Roundtable, 4 June 1989, Madison, Wl. Single-word topicalization in Vedic Prose: A challenge to (ed.) In Press:151-73. Srivastav, Veneeta. 1988. Relative clauses in Hindi and learnability. Cornell In Press. Government & Binding? Hock Working Papers in Linguistics 8.133-60. Steever, Sanford B.. 1987. Remarks on Dravidian complementation. Studies the Linguistic Sciences 17:1.103-19. 1988. The serial verb formation in the Dravidian languages. (MLBD Series in Linguistics, IV.) Delhi: Motilal Banarsidass. Subbarao, K. V. 1984. Complementation in Hindi syntax. Delhi: Academic in Publications. 126 Studies in the Linguistic Sciences 19:1 (Spring 1989) A. 1971. The deep structure of relative clauses. Studies in semantics, ed. by C. Fillmore and D. T. Langendoen, 78-95. New York: Holt, Rinehart & Winston. Repr. 1979. Syntactic argumentation, ed. by D. J. Napoli and E. N. Rando, 109-26. Washington, DC: Georgetown University Press. Verma, Manindra K. 1966. The noun phrase in Hindi and English. Delhi: Motilal Banarsidass. Wali, Kashi. 1982. Marathi correlatives: A conspectus. South Asian Review, Thompson, Sandra linguistic 6.78-88 Watkins, Calvert. 1976. Towards Proto-Indo-European syntax: Problems and pseudo-problems. Papers from the Parasession on Diachronic Syntax, 305-26. Chicago: Linguistic Society. C. 1987. Meaningful phonological processes. Language 63.685-740. WOODBURY, Anthony the Linguistic Sciences Studies in Volume 19, Number 1, Spring 1989 WORLD ENGLISHES AND APPLIED Braj B. LINGUISTICS Kachru This paper addresses the issue of the relationship between world Englishes (WE) and applied linguistics. The diffusion of English is seen in terms of three concentric circles: the Inner Circle (11 varieties, e.g., the USA, UK), the Outer Circle (ESL varieties), and the Expanding Circle (EFL varieties). The discussion is essentially resOuter Circle in which the institutionalized non-native varieties of English are used in multilingual and multicultural contexts. tricted to the The discussion is about four major al, and ideological, and focuses issues: theoretical, applied, societ- specifically on (a) altitudes concerning the ontological status of the varieties of English; (b) generalizations about the creative strategies used for learning English in multilingual/multicultural contexts; (c) descriptions of the pragmatic and interactional contexts of WEs and their implications; (d) assumptions concerning multi-cultural identities of WEs; (e) assumptions about the role of English in initiating ideological and social change; and (f) assumptions about communicative competence in English, The paper does not view applied linguistics as divorced from social concerns: the concerns of relevance to the society in which we live. This view, then, entails social responsibility and accountability for research in applied linguistics. 1. introduction^ The choice of world Englishes as the starting point of this paper calls for One, that of terminology: why 'world Englishes', and not just world 'English'? Second, that of justification of relationship: why choose world Englishes to address the issues related to applied linguistics? There is no simple or short answer to the first question. An answer to this question, as we know, entails more than pure linguistic issues: the issues of attitude, and additionally several extralinguistic factors. During the last two decades a reasonable body of research has been done to provide answers to this question. two types of explanations. Studies in the Linguistic Sciences 19:1 (Spring 1989) 128 (For bibliographic references see Kachru 1985 and 1986a.) to attempt in this paper, therefore, is What I would like second to provide a perspective for the question, that of the justification of the relationship between world Englishes and applied linguistics. A perspective which is essentially that of the user of who belongs Outer Circle of English out of the three concentric Note that South Afnca (pop. 29,628,000) and Jamaica (pop. 2,407,000) are not listed. The reason is the sociolinguistic complexity of English to the circles outlined below. — The ,.'' "Expanding B. Kachru: World Englishes and applied linguistics 129 these two countries in terms of their English-using populations and the functions of English. (See Kachru 1985: 12-14.) It seems to me that this perspective not only defines my approach to our understanding of the global spread of English, but to some extent it also defines the goals which set for the field of applied linguistics. I The relationship between world Englishes and applied linguistics as a research and inquiry is motivated by several types of issues: theoretical and applied, as well as societal and ideological. field of will start with what consider the theoretical issues. Since the 1950s there has been intense activity in the linguistic sciences for analysis and description of two main varieties of the English language, American and British. I I Extensive data banks have been established on English at the centers of research at the universities of Birmingham, Brown, London, and Lund, to name And such data banks are also being developed in Asia and Africa just four. (see e.g. Greenbaum 1989 and Shastri 1985). The largest number of applied linguists in various parts of the world are working in ESLVEFL related contexts. And, at some places, the term 'applied linguistics' is often wrongly equated with the teaching of ESLVEFL. The research on second language and first language acquisition, has primarily focused on English. acquisition, different aspects of sociolinguistics and have also concentrated on English. Additionally the interdisciplinary fields of stylistics, lingual lexicography gained in and monoThe major insights bilingual the theory of translation are derived from the translation of texts of English into other languages of the world, and of those languages into English. Generalizations about natural languages, their structural characteristics, and the possible categories of language universals usually begin with analyses of and examples from English. In short, what we see, linguistically and socio- and its applications are our time, English. And almost the total spectrum of applied linguistic research, its strengths and limitations, can be demonstrated with reference to this language. One might, then, say that the last linguistically speaking, closely linked to four is that the field of linguistics one major language decades have been the decades of of English. Moreover, English has acquired unprecedented sociological and ideodimensions. It is now well-recognized that in linguistic history no language has touched the lives of so many people, in so many cultures and continents, in so many functional roles, and with so much prestige, as has the English language since the 1930s. And, equally important, across cultures, English has been successful in creating a class of people who have greater intellectual power in multiple spheres of language use not surpassed by any single language before; not by Sanskrit during its heyday, not by Latin duhng its grip on Europe, and not by French during the peak of the colonial period. logical 130 Studies in the Linguistic Sciences 19:1 (Spring 1989) The reasons for the diffusion and penetration of English are complex, and these have been extensively discussed in earlier literature. ^ However, one dimension of the diffusion of English is especially important to us, particularly those of us who represent the developing world, who are directly influenced by the research in applied linguistics, and who are considered the main beneficiaries of the insights gained by such research. Again, it is the developing world in which the English language has become one of the most vital tools of ideological and social change, and at the same time an object of intense controversy. It this is developing world which forms an important component of the three Concentric Circles of English: the Inner Circle, the Outer Circle, and the Expanding Circle. These three circles, as has repeatedly been mentioned the literature, bring to the English language (and, of course, to a unique cultural pluralism, and a variety of its literature, in too) speech fellowships. These three and let us not underestimate circles certainly bring to English linguistic diversity; — as some scholars tend ed as does to say, Tom to do — the resultant f^yicArthur (1987), that cultural diversity. One is tempt- the three Circles of English have in several English 'languages'. True, the purist pundits find this posiunacceptable, but that actually is now the linguistic reality of the English language. resulted tion The world Englishes are the result of these diverse sociocultural contexts and diverse uses of the language in culturally distinct international contexts. As a result, numerous questions and concerns come to the forefront. Applied linguists, primarily of the Inner Circle, have articulated their positions about these concerns; they have interpreted various contexts of the uses of English; and they have provided research paradigms and methodologies. The range of paradigms is aspects of applied linguistics such scholars have covered in stylistics, language teaching, the acquisition of English as an additional language, and so on. The impact of such research has been significant; it has raised daunting questions which have never been raised before, particularly concerning the standards, models, and diversification in English, concerning the functions of English in the Outer Circle, concerning the functional power of English, and concerning the social issues and if may add the responsibility of applied linguists (see e.g. Quirk & Widdowson (eds.) 1985, Kachru & Smith 1986, and Lowenberg (ed.) 1988). their — — I And wide, e.g., sociolinguistics, need stressing: the terms 'applied linguistics' and The dichotomy between 'theoretical' and 'applied' linguistics is here, two things 'social concern'. one of difference in focus rather than of distinct identities. Charles Ferguson and Michael Halliday have repeatedly warned us that the separation However, applied linof the two (pure vs. applied) is not very meaningful. guistics, in whatever manifestation, is essentially an area which reveals certain essentially B.Kachru: World Englishes and applied concerns and certain responsibilities. And the term another dimension, though an extralinguistic one. I 131 linguistics 'social concern' brings in believe that 'social concern' refers to the responsibility of a discipline toward relevant social issues, and application of an appropriate body of knowledge to seek answers to such issues. The term 'social issues' naturally opens a Pandora's box: What is a social issue? And, how can a profession be evaluated on its response to such issues? These are, of course, controversial questions, and as Bolinger (1973:539) rightly says, the answers to these questions have to be rediscovered by each generation. However, now and then, a profession must address these questions as an exercise in evaluation of the field and its direction. It is true that in the USA during the 1940s and 1950s we passed through a long phase 'across the semantic desert'. There was a feeling that 'life had lost all meaning, except perhaps differential meaning' (Bolinger 1973:540). We had stopped asking questions concerning 'meaning' and responsibility. But, thankfully, even in the USA, that phase is over now. During the last two decades, serious questions have been asked: questions about the evaluation of the field, about the applied linguist's responsibilities, and about the goals and areas of applied linguistics (see e.g. Labov, particularly 1982 cited in Trudgill 1984; Lakoff 1975). However, a caveat is in order here: Whenever such questions are asked they are naturally concerned with issues related to the USA or the UK. Very rarely have questions of concern, of responsibility, and of linguistic pragmatism been raised with reference to world Englishes. In other words, to quote Bolinger (1973: 540) again, 'the linguist up to very recently has been a more or less useful sideliner, but not a social critic'. And, so far as world Englishes in the Outer Circle are concerned, that role of the linguist still persists. 2.0 Major issues of concern Now, do not propose to take up the role of a social critic here. What propose to do is to select some of the issues related to world Englishes and applied research, and share with you my concerns about such research. will, of course, not go into all the issues and their ramifications. will merely present a commentary on the following issues which consider vital for our underI I I I I standing of English in its world context: status of the varieties of English; (a) attitudes (b) concerning the ontological generalizations about the creative strategies used for learning English as an additional language and multicultural contexts; (c) in multilingual descriptions of the pragmatic and interactional contexts of world Englishes, and their relevance to pragmatic success and failure; (d) assumptions about the cultural content of the varieties of English and the role of such varieties as the vehicles of the Judeo-Christian (or, broadly, western) traditions; (e) assumptions about the role of English in initiating ideological and social changes; and (f) assumptions about communicative com- 132 Studies in the Linguistic Sciences 19:1 (Spring 1989) petence in English and the relevant interlocutors in such communicative contexts. discuss these points one by one in the following sections. But do that, must briefly discuss the current dominant and less dominant approaches to world Englishes to provide a theoretical perspective for the discussion. In recent years the following approaches have been used to study I before shall I I world Englishes: (1) the deficit approach; contextualizational approach; tional (4) (2) the deviational approach; the variational approach; and (5) (3) the the interac- approach. However, out of these five approaches it is the deviational approaches) that have dominated the first field. two (the deficit and the And, it is these two approaches which, believe, are the least insightful. The following comments are thus a critique primarily of these two approaches, and the attitudes that such approaches reflect. I 2.1 Ontological issues: The Conflict between idealization and reality question takes us to the core of the problem, the issues of The attitudes toward a variety of English are only partially determined by linguistic considerations. The other considerations are of assigning a place and a status to the user of the other variety, or marking the distance of a person in the social network. We see two major positions concerning the varieties of English in the Outer Circle: one, the nativist monomodel position; and second, the functional polymodel position. attitudes initial and identity. The first position, perhaps in an extreme form, is well-articulated in two paradigm papers, one by Clifford Prator (1968) and the other by Randolph Quirk (1988). These two studies were presented almost a generation apart. The Prator study was originally presented in 1966. Quirk presented his views first at the 1987 Georgetown University Round Table devoted to language spread (see also Quirk 1988 and 1989). The functional polymodel position entails the use of theoretical and methodological frameworks which relate the formal and functional characteristics of English in the Outer Circle to appropriate sociolinguistic and interactional contexts. have presented this position since the 1960s, and over a period of time, many studies have been written following this approach, at various centers. (For bibliographical references see Kachru 1986a.) I The Quirk papers, representing the first position, deserve special attention reasons: These papers are written by one of the most venerable and intellectually influential scholars of the English language during our time, and for several his papers take us back to some of the fundamental questions which concern all B. Kachru: World Englishes and applied linguistics 133 who are working in the areas of applied linguistics. Furthermore, the papers reopen some questions which some of us believed had been put to rest during the past rather productive years of research on world Englishes. The main points of what have called 'the Quirk concerns' may be summarized as follows. Quirk sees language spread primarily with reference to three models: the demographic, the econo-cultural, and the imperial. The demographic model implies language spread with accompanying population spread. The econo-cultural model suggests language spread without a serious population spread, essentially for scientific, technological, and cultural information. The imperial model applies to language spread as the result of political I (colonial) domination. The demographic model has resulted in several varieties of English in the (e.g., Amehcan, Australian, Canadian, New Zealand). The econocultural and imperial models have, over a period of time, resulted in the endocentric varieties of English in Africa, Asia, and the Philippines (see e.g. Bailey & Gorlach 1982, Kachru 1982 and 1986a, Piatt et al. 1984, and Pride Inner Circle 1982). However, Quirk's concerns are about the endocentric models in the Outer and their implications for pedagogy, the international currency of English, Circle language. These conquestions relevant to serious practitioners of applied for example, the following: (a) Do the Outer Circle varieties of English, primarily second language varieties, have an ontological status that is, sociolinguistically speaking? (b) What are the needs-analyses for the uses of English in the Outer Circle: econo-cultural or intranational? (c) What is the relevance of various types of ontological labels used for the varieties of English in the Outer Circle? (d) What is the relationship between the socio- and generally, the good cerns raise a number linguistics. Consider, linguistic health of the English of — linguistic identity of a variety of English, relevance of distinctions and the available descriptions of the is the formal and functional And (e). What such as ESL and EFL? variety at various linguistic levels? Quirk, in his usual elegant way, has not only raised these questions for the profession to ponder, but he has also brought into the open a concern which is shared by several scholars. In brief, his position on the above five as follows. Quirk rejects in the Outer Circle and the false extrapolation of Eng- questions is the sociolinguistic identity of the varieties of English considers the recognition lish "varieties" by some of such linguists' identity as (1988:232). "... He sees the international needs as econo-cultural. ('The econo-cultural model of language spread applied in our times more to English than to any other language', 1988:231.) He rejects the use of identificational terms such as 'Nigerian English', 'West African English', 'South Asian English', 'Singapore English", and of English essentially 134 Studies in the Linguistic Sciences 19:1 (Spring 1989) characterizes them as '... misleading, if not entirely false ...' (1988: 234); he does not believe that the varieties of English are adequately described at various linguistic levels and, therefore, these cannot be used as pedagogically acceptable (or ontologically recognizable) models. And finally, he rejects the generally recognized dichotomy between ESL and EFL. ('I ignore it partly because doubt its validity and frequently fail to understand its meaning', 1988: I 236.) In other words, for Quirk, among the English users of the world there is another kind of dichotomy: one between us (the Inner Circle) and them (the Outer Circle and the Expanding Circle). This dichotomy has serious sociolinguistic and attitudinal implications, one being that the power to define the other group is with us and not with them. This is an interesting way of making a distinction between 'inclusive' and 'exclusive' members of English-using far speech fellowships. am not saying that that is what Quirk has in mind from that. However, we should not forget that labels have a value, they provide a definition. And, Bolinger (1973:541) is right when he says that 'a loaded word is like a loaded gun, sometimes fired deliberately, but almost as often by ac- — I cident.' will not digress here to discuss why Quirk's major points cannot be accepted in terms of the sociolinguistic reality of world Englishes, and how they cannot be supported by the linguistic history of the spread of other major languages of the world. This has already been done in a number of studies (for references see Kachru 1986a and Smith, ed. 1987). However, do not want to give the impression that Quirk's concerns are not shared by other scholars. Indeed, there are several scholars of that persuasion in the U.K., in the U.S.A. will save the discussion of these concerns, 'the as well as in Asia and Africa. Quirk concerns', for another occasion (see Kachru 1989). I I I 2.2 Acquisition and creativity: The 'leal(ing' paradigms The second question relates to acquisition and creativity. The dominant paradigms of second language acquisition are 'leaking' for more than one reason. The question of 'bridging the paradigm gap' between the theory and functions of the institutionalized varieties of English has been discussed in am several recent studies (see specifically Lowenberg & Sridhar (eds.) 1986). addressing here another aspect of the 'leaking' paradigms: the misinterI pretation or neglect of the creative aspects of uses of English in the Outer Circle. This misinterpretation is essentially the result of undue emphasis on concepts such as 'interlanguage' and 'fossilization'. However, it is gratifying to note that, after dominating the scene for over a decade, the error in institutionalizing 'error analysis' as an insightful paradigm has finally been B. Kachru: World Englishes and applied linguistics realized (see relevant studies go back to the in Robinett & Schachter concepts 'interlanguage' and 135 (eds.) 1983). But let me 'fossilization'. 'Interlanguage' is 'the type of language produced by second-and foreignlanguage learners who are in the process of learning a language.' (Richards et al. 1985:145) and 'fossilization' refers to '... linguistic items, rules, and subsystems which speakers of a particular NL [native language] will tend to keep in their IL [interlanguage] relative to a particular TL [target language], no matter what the age of the learner or amount of explanation and instruction he receives in the TL' (Selinker 1972 in Robinett & Schachter 1983:177). is a developmental process, and fossilization is a developmental in the sense that it is mode! (or target) oriented, and suggests directionality in terms of attaining stages toward a goal. Interlanguage, then, static condition. The other is One static There are is and indicates at least three 'freezing' with respect to creativity. problems with these two concepts with particular reference to world Englishes. These are: a. Acceptance of a unimodel approach to creativity: The creative language is seen with reference to the model provided by the target language, and the goal of acquisition if determined by the acquisition of an exo-normative model; use b. c. of Rejection of the contact features as undesirable interference: This has even resulted in a failure to recognize subtle creative processes due to the influence of the contexts of contact. The effects of contact have only been viewed in a negative sense; and Emphasis on a 'unidimensional' view of functions: The 'unidimensional view' provides a misleading picture about the functions of English, and about the innovations in English. This view is misleading in results in a serious corpus constraint. more than one sense. First, Variety-specific generalizations are made on one type of data (e.g., scripts provided by students), ignoring the implications of the dine of bilingualism. Second, the 'interference' is not related to function: The result is that external discoursal and interactional norms are imposed on a variety. The 'interference' in, for example, Singaporean English or Pakistani English, is not always the result of acquisitional deficiency; there is sometimes a clear motivation for it. Often, in newspaper registers, for example, the aim is to establish, contextually speaking, an identity with readers (see e.g. Kachru 1982 for references). it The dimensions of creativity in English, such as non-native and intranational registers ('mixed' or 'unmixed'), seem to have escaped the attention of second language acquisition researchers in insightful literatures in English 136 Studies in the Linguistic Sciences 19:1 (Spring 1989) have said elsewhere (Kachru 1987), David Crystal Is not who believe that "... it is quite unclear what to make of cases like Nabokov and others' (see Paikeday 1985:67). It so happens that in bilingual societies, most literary creativity is done in a language or a variety which is not one's first language variety. The constraints of 'interlanguage' and 'fossilization' on such creativity are simply not applicable. If a text is not viewed in this broader context, the result is misleading generalizations of the type which we find in Bell 1976 and Selinker 1972. Bell considers 'Indianized English' or 'Anglicized Hindi' 'xized' varieties, because '... the motivation for or possibility of further learning is removed from a group of learners' (155). How misleading! English. It make In fact, among alone is as I linguists essential to consider the multiple dimensions of creativity, generalizations. appropriate to different By multiple dimension mean creativity contexts, genres, and so on. Consider, I and then of various types, for example, the following: 2.3 Pragmatic contexts: Success vs. failure The third question concerns the user and uses. Research on the pragmatics of English that is, on the variables of pragmatic success and failure in world Englishes is basically determined in terms of (a) the formal charac- — — teristics of the code or its varieties; (b) the participants in the 'effective results' of verbal communication. Outer Circle are primarily viewed with reference an interaction; and (c) Linguistic encounters in the to variables of the Inner Circle. because the underiying sociopresuppositions are mistaken. One basically wrong assumption is that non-native varieties of English are primarily used for international purposes. That actually is not true. In the Outer Circle, the interaction with native speakers of English is minimal. In India, Nigeria, Singapore, and the Philippines, to give just four examples, the localized (domesticated) roles are more extensive, and more important, than are the international roles. This, of course, raises several questions, linguistic B. Kachru: World Englishes and applied 137 linguistics Another mistaken assumption is that when English is used internationally, a native speaker is usually involved. This emphasis on the native speaker of English in ail interactional contexts is of doubtful sociolinguistic validity. The real-world situation is that, in the Outer Circle, the predominant functions of English involve interlocutors who use English as an additional language Indians with Indians, Singaporeans with Singaporeans, Indians with Singaporeans, Filipinos with Chinese or Japanese, Nigerians with Kenyans, and so — This point has been clearly brought out from several parts of the world. on. In in Smith 1987, with empirical data such intranational and Outer Circle encounters, the users of institu- tionalized varieties of English are certainly not using just one type of English; they expect an Indian to sound like an Indian and to use the discoursal strategies of an Indian, and they expect a Nigerian to come up to their notion a Nigerian user of English. The interlocutors in such interactions expect a functional range of varieties, and they certainly adopt the strategies of 'mixing' and 'switching' depending on the participants. It is thus the contexts of encounters which determine the international strategies used in (however stereotypical) a of linguistic interaction. am we should not expect linguistically (and what have been claimed to be the 'survival' registers. My claim is that, for determining the pragmatic success of the largest range of functional domains for English, the local (domesticated) pragmatic contexts are important, because it is these contexts that matter the most to the largest number of English users in the Outer Circle. The interaction with native speakers is only marginal. In an earlier paper (Kachru 1986b), e.g. legal or have suggested that this claim applies to several subregisters in India and Nigeria, to give just two examples. medical I certainly not advocating that contextually) maximal pragmatic success in — — In the Outer Circle, the members of English-using I speech fellowships a verbal repertoire consisting of several codes, and the use of each code has a 'social meaning'. We seem to have underestimated the linguistic manipulation of the multilingual contexts in which English is used. We see this manipulation when we watch a Singaporean doctor talk to a Singaporean patient, or an Indian or a Pakistani doctor interact with a patient from his or her region. The manipulation takes place in lectal switch, code mixing, and so on. interact with And, while discussing the pragmatics of a code, let me bring in an aspect Englishes generally ignored by applied linguists: the use of subvarieties of English in, for example, literary creativity. This aspect has been ignored particularly by those linguists who work in the areas of applied or contrastive stylistics. What immediately comes to mind is the nativized styles and discourse in the Englishes used in the Outer Circle (see e.g. Smith 1987). Consideration of this aspect of English is important, since the writer of English in the Outer Circle is faced with a rather difficult situation: He/she is a bilingual or of world 138 Studies in the Linguistic Sciences 19:1 (Spring 1989) And he/she Is using English a context which gives the language a new linguistic and cultural identity (see e.g. Dissanayake & Nichter 1987, Gonzalez 1987, Kachru 1983 and 1986c, multilingual, but not necessarily bi-or-multicultural. in Thumboo 1988). Now, the pragmatic success of such codes is not determined by the speaker toward the code, but by the effectiveness of such codes within the contexts of use, such as stylistic effectiveness, emotional effectiveness, and effectiveness in terms of identity. Let us consider for example, the creative writing of three contemporary Singaporean writers of English: Kripal Singh, Arthur Yap, and Catherine Lim. attitude of the native Singh's Voices and Yap's 2 mothers in a hbd playground, both poetic compositions, and Lim's stories A taxi driver and A mother-in-law's curse exploit distinctly different stylistic devices to achieve what believe is maximum pragmatic success in textual terms. Voices essentially uses mixed codes. Yap contextually, as it were, 'legitimizes' the use of an attitudinally low variety and I shows the effectiveness of various types of mixing. For instance, the poem contains jamban ('toilet bowl' in Malay), toa-soh ('drive in a car' in Hokkien), ah pah ('father' in Hokkien), and constructions such as What boy is he in the exam?, I scold like mad but what for?. Sit like don't And Lim provides convincing examples want to get up, and so on. code alteration true to of appropriate the sociolinguistic contexts of Singapore. such linguistic devices of diglossic switch and mixing (as in It is through Yap's poem) that various local stylistic resources for creativity are exploited. True, there is a linguistic dilemma in this: If such creativity is evaluated within reference points provided by the Inner Circle, or taking the native speaker as the primary reader of such texts, one might say that there are 'inappropriate' uses of varieties of English. However, if the creativity is viewed from the perspective of the code repertoire of a Singaporean creative writer and a Singaporean reader, the codes are appropriate in terms of use. And, for those who are familiar with the Singaporean sociolinguistic contexts, the language has been used with maximum pragmatic success. Another example Asia Week (May playwrights attempt to is from the state bordering on Singapore. 24, 1987:64) tells us that 'English-medium In Malaysia, drama by local a recent trend.' In the play Caught in the middle, there is an 'go completely Malaysian.' The strategies used are the following: is The bulk of the dialogue is in English, but there is switching and mixing between Bahasa Malaysia, Cantonese, and Tamil. We are told that '... "Malaysian English" spoken, especially marks a progression toward more realistic language in more realistic settings the home, the pub.' Consider the following — excerpt: 139 B. Kachru: World Englishes and applied linguistics Mrs. Chandran: Aiee-yah, mow fatt chee ka la (can't do anything about it). Clean it up, Ah Lan. The rubbish-man will be coming soon, and you know he doesn't take rubbish that isn't nicely packed and tied up. Ah Lan what. And (the amah): Rubbish is rubbish-lah. Supposed to be dirty, Real fussy mbbish-man, must have neat rubbish to take away. Llyod Fernando's observation is that Malaysian English provides realism to the play, exploits that with good humor. Malaysian English is now a dialect, recognized as such. In some situations, if you don't speak like that, you are regarded as a foreigner. By using it [Malaysian English] the playwright draws us into the magic circle (ibid.). it The point here is that the parameters for determining pragmatic success cannot always be, and should not always be, determined by the Inner Circle. Achebe (1976:1 1), therefore, has a point when he says that should like to see the word universal banned altogether from discussions of African literature until such a time as people cease to use it as a synonym for the narrow, self-serving parochialism of Europe. I Let me give another example here, from the register of advertising in Japan. Of course, Japan is not a part of the Outer Circle, and from my point of view that fact makes this example even more significant. The example throws a believe supports different light on our use of the term 'pragmatic success', and what have suggested above. I I The pragmatic success of English in advertising in Japan, as illustrated by the following example, must be seen with reference to the attitude of the Japanese toward English, and their 'consuming passion for English vocabulary' (Asia Week, October 5. 1984:49). 2. Kanebo cosmetics: for Tokyo Utility Company: 3. Shinjuku Station Concourse: 1. fair; planning Asia Week these examples; and makes an to the English or annoying. beautiful human life my life, my gas guy making; communicate nice creative; let's multiple days autumn apt observation about contextual justification of speaker they [vocabulary items] may be silly, childish, Sometimes a double meaning makes them unin- 140 Studies in the Linguistic Sciences 19:1 (Spring 1989) But the ubiquitous English of Japanese ads con- tentionally funny. veys a feeling The use of to Japanese these phrases — have a deep psychological — deviant from the native speakers' perspective effect a commercial perspective, that This point is clearly (ibid.). from the Japanese point of view; and, from what an advertisement should achieve. is just in the following extended excerpt: emphasized To produce one such phrase requires the expensive services of an ad agency as sophisticated as anywhere. A creative director gathers the team and concepts are tossed about, a first-rate copywriter works on the theme, a lengthy rationalization is prepared for the client, a decision eventually made to launch. Cost: maybe millions of yen. Everyone understands that it is substandard English. Explains a copywriter at Dentsu: 'Yes, of course we know it sounds corny to an American, even objectionable to some. But what the foreigner thinks of it is immaterial. The ad is purely domestic, a lot of market research has gone into it. It evokes the right images. It sells.' For product names, English words that seem dismayingly inappropriate to the foreign listener are sometimes chosen. The most frequently quoted example is a very popular soft-drink called Sweat. The idea of using a body secretion as an enticing name for a fluid to drink out of a can is just as unpleasant to a Japanese as to an Englishman, but sweat conjures a different image: hot and thirsty after vigorous activity on the sporting field. The drink's Pocari in Hongkong. Some English words enjoy a fad season. Currently very much in are life, my, be, and city, the lastnamed suffering from the phonetic necessity to render the s before My / a multi-storeyed shopping complex in Shinjuku where you can shop for my-sports things to take to your my-tiouse in your my-car. New remains popular. If no suitable English word exas sh. ists, nothing City is is lost, catchy: magineer. coin one. Others Some, indeed, are accidentally rather only sighs. Creap is a big selling elicit for coffee. Facom was perhaps not such a felicitous choice considering the open back vowel for Japanese. Currently in season are words ending in -topia, presumable from Utopia. There was a Portopia, a Computopia, and a Sportopia. The brand-new Hilton Hotel boasts a splendid shopping annex called the Hiltopia. (Emphasis added; Asiaweek, Octot»er 5, 1984). cream-powder 2.4 Cultural content of English of The fourth question is rather controversial: English? There are two views on this point. essentially an What is the culture-specificity One view holds that English is exponent of the Western Judeo-Chhstian tradition. It is believed B. Kachru: World Englishes and applied linguistics 141 more than Asia and Africa. Therefore, the second, non-culture-specific view takes the position that '... the English language is different from other languages in that it "extends" the meaning of particular words beyond the culture-specific connotations because of the interthat it is this association one sense national demands made on The is lutes that cultural load of English that interferes in it' (Lyons, quoted in Street 1984:78). in seems to be used in more than one sense. and the USA feel that the culture-specificity of its essential characteristic, and that the non-culture-specific view diposition of the language. In the Outer Circle, those who oppose first A number English and with the native socio-cultural traditions view, culture-specific, of scholars in Britain English, use the culture-specificity of English as a basis for arguing that the use Thus, according to this is an intrusion into their native cultures. group, English is an 'alien' language not only in the sense that it does not belong to the linguistic stock of the region, but also in that it represents a culture alien to the local socio-cultural traditions. of English It seems to me that the strength of English is not its culture-specificity with reference to Britain or America, or non-culture-specificity in the sense Lyons presents it, and which Street rightly rejects (for details see Street 1984:66-94). The strength of English lies in its multi-cultural specificity, which the language reveals in its formal and functional characteristics, as in, for example. West Africa, South Asia, and the Philippines. These characteristics have given the English language distinct cultural identities in these regions, and recognition of this fact is essential for any insightful research on the world varieties of English. A good parallel example is that of Christianity and Islam in Asia: These two religions have become so much a part of the local cultural traditions that very insightful to consider these now as 'foreign'. The fifth is not change 2.5 Ideological question culture-specificity it and is closely related to the preceding discussion since believe change seem to go hand in hand. ideological I change, undue emphasis has been laid on the positive or negative aspects of Westernone type of ideological change ization. The reality seems to lie in between the two extreme positions (see Kachru 1986d). A process of rethinking and reevaluation is needed to see what English has contributed in the past and continues to contribute in the present in toward self-identification the Outer Circle as indeed do other languages that in discussions of ideological — — — and self-knowledge. A good example is again provided by Japan. Consider JAAL Bulletin (December 986:7). obsen/ation from the 1 "» the following 142 Studies in the Linguistic Sciences 19:1 (Spring 1989) Prof. Takao Suzuku of Keio university lectured English and Native English — on 'International English really an International language?' Dividing English into International English and Native English, he criticized Japanese teachers of English for teaching Native English, dealing only with the literature, history, and lifestyles He urged us to recognize the fact that of England and America. English is no longer the sole property of native English speaker. Is Japan's relations with Europe and America have changed from advanced technology and culture) to 'horizontal' (economical and cultural exchange on equal terms). Accordingly, he argued, English teaching in Japan should also change from emphasizing the conventional 'receiver' type to emphasizing the 'sender' type in order to express ourselves and our culture. While using English as the 'form', he suggested, we should use as the 'content' Japan and other non-English cultural phenomena such as Korean history, Arabic religion, or German literature. 'vertical' (unidirectional inflow of question is about communicative competence and it has many preceding discussion of pragmatic success, culture-specificity, and ideological change naturally leads us to the area which is vaguely represented In in 'communicative competence' (for further discussion see Savignon 1987). recent years, communicative competence has become one major area to which applied linguists have paid serious attention. A partial bibliography on communicative language teaching includes over 1180 items (see Ramaiah & Prabhu 1985, also Berns 1985). Again, considerable research on this topic has been done with specific reference to the teaching of English in the Outer and Expanding Circles of English, and this research comes in various vintages. The most popular and, at the same time, rewarding for the publishing industry is research on ESP (English for Specific Purposes). The faces. last My Research on ESP, manuals for its use, lexical lists, and other aids are guided by the assumption of the culture-specificity of English, in which 'appropriateness' is determined by the interlocutors from the Inner Circle. have shown in an earlier paper on this topic that this assumption is only partially correct (see Kachru 1 986b). I However as an aside, would like to mention a recent paper by Frances Singh (1987) which insightfully discusses the role of power and politics in the examples chosen to illustrate various grammatical points in three grammar books used in the Indian subcontinent: Nesfield 1895, Tipping 1933, and Wren & Martin 1954. She, then, contrasts the examples used by these three grammarians with that of Sidhu (1976), an Indian teacher of English. The conclusions Singh arrives at are very illuminating. These four grammar books provide paradigm examples of power and politics as these reflect in the genre I of school textbooks. B. Kachru: World Englishes and applied linguistics What we need now is a study of the same that the results concerning the underlying say the type for assumptions ESP of 143 texts. My guess such texts will is be, to least, provocative. 3.0 Where does applied linguistics fail the Outer Circle of English? to me is the heart of the problem. And it naturally applied linguistics fail the Outer Circle of English? It is true that the last three decades have been the decades of significant strides for the development of applied linguistics. True, we must recognize the fact that And now is come to what Where does I controversial. applied theory has been used And in areas which were almost unresearched before. the result of this extension and application of the linguistic sciences has been insightful. 336) tells us, that now realized, though belatedly in the USA, as Lakoff (1975: the theoretical linguist must deal with problems of the intellect and morality, with reality and sanity ..." And, turning to applied linguists, Lakoff continues "... the applied linguist must concern himself with decisions among It is "... possible theories, universals of grammar, relations But, then, that is only one side of the coin. There systems.' side to this coin — a side which has traditionally side which touches millions of users of English It is this side of applied linguistics planners, parents, children and, above all, in been left among grammatical is, naturally, another without comment. A the Outer Circle. which concerns educators, policy a multitude of developing nations across the proverbial Seven Seas. The implications of applied linguistic research raise questions, and result in various types of concerns. As said at the outset, these are questions of theory, empirical validity, social responsibility, and of ideology. Let me briefly present some of these here. I First, the question of ethnocentricism in conceptualization of the field of world Englishes. The world Englishes in the Outer Circle are perceived from the vantage point of the Inner Circle. The perception of the users and uses of English in that circle English, but is is not only in conflict with the real sociolinguistic profiles of also conditioned by an attitude which has divided the English- using world into two large groups. One group, defined in most unrealistic terms, comprises those who seem to be expected to learn English for communication with another particular group. And, the other group comprises those who continue to look at the diffusion of English essentially in pedagogical terms. This ethnocentric perception has created a situation which is obviously incorrect on many counts. The second question relates to what has been termed in the literature 'the Observer's Paradox'. The 'Observer's Paradox" applies in several ways to observations on English in the Outer Circle. First, there is an idealization of contexts of use; second, the focus is on static categories of the lectal range as s 144 Studies in the Linguistic Sciences 19:1 (Spring 1989) dynamic interactional nature of the functions; third, the observer use of English from the total repertoire of the user; and fourth, the researcher does not recognize the confusion between the performance and the model. Opposed to the isolates the The question Involves the 'paradigm third trap'. The paradigm trap seems to constrain not only description of the varieties, but also discussion of creativity in the use of the language, models for teaching, and teaching methodology. notices this constraint in several ways: in the theoretical and method- One ological approaches used to describe the sociolinguistic contexts, and in the data selected for analysis; in the description of the acquisitional strategies and the resultant description of such language, and the generalizations made from such data (e.g., interlanguage, fossilization); and in the evangelical zeal with which the pedagogical methods are propagated and presented to the developing Third World, often with weak theoretical foundations, and with doubtful relevance to the sociological, educational, and economic contexts of the Outer Circle. The fourth question relates to the frustrating signs of excessive com- and professional organizations. In professional circles, in ESL/EFL programs, there still is the syndrome that the English language is part of the baggage of transfer of technology to the Outer Circle. This one way transfer-of-technology-mentality is fortunately being abandoned social scientists working on the proband forward looking by pragmatic lems related to the developing world. But, unfortunately, in the ESL7EFL circles the old paradigm still continues. mercialization of professional minds — — The above concerns do tensions which one notices my view in not exhaust the list; fundamental, concerns for broader significance. would like to discuss these I they are only indicative of the However, there are some other, in applied linguistic research, which have the literature. briefly. These issues concern conceptualizations about the users of English frameworks adopted for the description of the English-using speech fellowships in the Outer Circle, and the question of the 'renewal of connection' between the theoretical frameworks and the uses and users of English. internationally, conceptualizations of the theoretical me discuss the conceptualization concerning the users of English the post-1 950s, the dominant paradigms of linguistic research have taken monolingualism as the norm for linguistic behavior in linguistic interactions. This is particularly true of the USA. This position, unFirst, let internationally. In a rather distorted view of bilingual societies, and As a consequence, the manifestations of language contact have been viewed from the wrong perspective. Muhlhausler (1985) is fortunately, bilingualism has resulted in general. in ^ B. Kachru: right in World Englishes and applied 145 linguistics drawing our attention to the fact that language contact has been and less attention in linguistic literature. receiving less The concept that seems to have survived in applied linguistics is And here Joshua Fishman's observation (1968:29) has, unfortunately, come to haunt us. He says that linguists tend to see language in two ways '... the first being that of two "pure" languages, and the second that of "interference" between them.' That observation may not apply to all linguists, 'interference'. but it is certainly true of most dominant research paradigms used for the study of world Englishes. The term 'interference' has acquired a negative connotation, attitudinally very loaded. What such statements convey, unfortunately, is that multilingualism is an and monolingualism is the norm. However, the reality is that monolingualism is the exception, and the largest number of users of English are bi- or multilinguals; such bi- or multilingual users of English bring to the English language a multicultural dimension, not only in the Outer Circle, but even in Scotland, Wales, Ireland, and so on (see e.g. Walker 1984). aberration, It is and the sociocultural context is example by Quirk (1986:19), when he says, not that the relationship of language not recognized. Indeed it is, as for ... even the simplest, shortest, least technical, least momentous texts have a structure involving profound interactions between language and the world, between individual and culture in which they operate: involving extensive assumptions about shared knowledge and shared attitudes, reasoned inferences about the degree to which participants in even such simple communications are willing to operate. [Emphasis added] it comes to recognizing the implications of the use of example, the Asian or African contexts, the results of such uses on the form and functions of English, and the reflections of such uses in the However, when English in, for literatures written in English, there is serious resistance to the interrelation between language and the world, as we portant process of cross-over own papers is missing. find in Quirk's observation: That is The im- unfortunately true of Quirk's (see e.g. Quirk 1988 and 1989). this is the conceptualization of theoretical frameworks used and analysis of English in the Outer Circle. It is unfortunate that the types of models used for such descriptions by applied linguists have been rather uninsightful. What is needed is to view the uses and the users of English within the theoretical frameworks which may be considered 'socially realistic'. What have in mind are, for example, the framework presented by J. R. Firth, M. A. K. Halliday, Dell Hymes, and William Labov. Halliday (1978:2) tells us: And, related to for description I 146 Studies in the Linguistic Sciences 19:1 (Spring 1989) A social reality (or semiotic construct. otic a an edifice 'culture') is itself In this perspective, language systems that constitutes a one culture; also serves as an encoding system for others ... that is — meanings a one of the semi- of is distinctive in that many (though not all) it of the And he adds: The contexts in which meanings are exchanged are not devoid of a context of speech is itself a semiotic construct, having a form (deriving from the culture) that enables the participants to predict features of the prevailing register ... and hence to understand one another as they go along. social value; The advantage such frameworks as that of Halliday is that they provide language to use, and, yet, they bring out the formal distinctiveness. They assign a 'meaning' to what has merely been termed 'interference' or 'fossilization'. They provide a dimension to the description which many structural and post-structural paradigms have failed to of a content for description, they relate provide. A socioculturally satisfactory description analysis must seek the 'renewal and theoretically insightful connection with experience', as would say (1957:xii). And here, the cmcial word is 'experience'. still of Firth It is not too much to ask that claims about the form and functions of English the Outer Circle be justified in terms of the renewal of connection. This implies that the observations about English in the Outer Circle should be valid in in terms contexts, of the following: (a) the sociolinguistic contexts, (c) What that all I the pragmatic contexts, and have said above is (d) (b) broad generalization: It gives the impression current approaches to world Englishes have ignored the That actually is above contexts. not correct. The above discussion may be summarized which show the functional the attitudinal contexts. in terms of a bundle of fallacies the dominant approaches to world Englishes. The fallacies are of the following types: theoretical, methodological, formal, functional, and attitudinal. in For further details, see the chart on the next page. But all the bees are not out of my bonnet yet. The issues raised in this paper, though restricted to applied linguistics and world Englishes, apply to other areas of applied linguistics too. Here, must go back to the position which presented at the beginning. do not see applied linguistics divorced from the I I I concerns of our times, nor from the concerns of relevance to the societies which we live. This view, of course, entails a responsibility. The question social in of responsibility brings several other issues to the forefront: the issues of social identity, of attitudes, of cultural values, and of culturally-determined interactional B. Kachru: World Englishes and applied patterns and their acceptance, and, above paradigms of research. all, of linguistics choosing the most 147 insightful 148 Studies in the Linguistic Sciences 19:1 (Spring 1989) reaching ways. A large segment of the human population is involved in using English across cultures, and across languages. In our task, we have to satisfy many gods, and most of all, we have to remind ourselves more often than we actually do, that the situation of English around the world is unprecedented in many have to be unprecedented too, formally, and approaches to and attitudinally. It seems to me that our present paradigms are simply not up to the challenge which our discipline is facing. respects, it sociolinguistically, and attitudes And the profession at large does not show that we are aware of the issues which confront the largest segment of users of English in the Outer Circle. We must be courageous and ask ourselves, like a Brahmin priest asked of Gautama Buddha some 2500 years ago, 'What are you then? Are you a god, a demigod, some spirit, or an ordinary man?' 'None of these', answered the Buddha, 'I am awake.' is that applied linguists have not been asked the question. have no accountability; therefore, we do not know whether we are 'awake' about the challenges, and the social implications of our research. Perhaps the time has come to ask ourselves some serious questions: questions In other words, questions conof social concern and of social responsibility. The problem We seem to cerning accountability. NOTES •This is a slightly revised version of the plenary paper presented at the 8th World Congress of Applied Linguistics (AILA) in Sidney, Australia, August 1621, 1987. 2David Crystal provides an optimistic estimated figure of 2 billion users of He says, '... if you are highly conscious of international standards, or wish to keep the figures for World English down, you will opt for a total of around 700 million, in the mid 1980s. If you go to the opposite extreme, and allow in any systematic awareness whether in speaking, listening, reading, or writing, you could easily persuade yourself of the reasonableness of 2 billion.' However, he hastens to add, am happy to settle for a billion... (see Crystal English. ' *l 1985:9). The population figures for the countries listed in the three circles are from Encyclopedia Britannica 1989, Book of the Year, Chicago: Encyclopedia Britannica, Inc. 3For further discussion and references see Kachru 1985 and Kachru & Smith eds. 1986. ^Japan Association of Applied Linguistics. 149 B. Kachru: World Englishes and applied linguistics 5See e.g. Kachru 1981, especially p. 77. 6As Mijhlhausler correctly suggests (1985:52), aspects related to language contact are treated somewhat peripherally in introductory text-books on linguistics. A random sun/ey of such textbooks clearly proves Muhlhausler's point. He says, "... We can observe a marked decrease in the number of pages devoted to language contact phenomena ...' (52). For a detailed discussion on language contact and for references see Hock 1986. REFERENCES ACHEBE, 1976. Chinua. Morning yet in creation day. Garden City: Double- day. BAILEY, and M. Gorlach. eds. 1982. English as world language. Ann Arbor, R., Ml: University of Michigan Press. BELL, Roger T. 1976. Sociolinguistics: goals, approaches, and problems. London: Betsford. BERNS, Margie S. 1985. Functional approaches and communicative comPh. D. English language teaching in non-native contexts. petence: dissertation. University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign. BOLINGER, Dwight L. 1973. Truth is a linguistic question. Language 49.539550. How many millions? The statistics of English today. Today 1.7-9. DISSANAYAKE, Wimal, and Mimi Nichter. 1987. Native sensibility and literary discourse in Sri Lankan English. Smith, ed., 1987. CRYSTAL, David. 1985. English 1985. 1957. Papers in linguistics. London: Oxford University Press. 1968. Sociolinguistic perspectives on the study of A. bilingualism. Linguistics 39.21-49. GONZALEZ, Andrew. 1987. Poetic imperialism or indigenous creativity? FIRTH, John. R. FISHMAN, Joshua Philippines literature GREENBAUM, Sidney. in English. 1989. Smith, ed. 1987. Standard English and the international corpus of English. A. K. 1978. Language as social semiotic: The social inlanguage and meaning. Baltimore: University Park Press. HOCK, Hans Henrich. 1986. Principles of historicallinguistics. Berlin/New York: Mouton de Gruyter. HALLIDAY, Michael terpretation of KACHRU, Braj B. 1981. Socially realistic linguistics: International Journal of the Sociology of 1982. The other tongue: English across versity of Illinois Press. 1983.) Language (Paperback The Firthian tradition. 31 .65-89. cultures. Urbana, edition, Illinois; Uni- Pergamon Press, Oxford, 150 Studies in the Linguistic Sciences 19:1 (Spring 1989) 1983. The Indianization of English: The English language in India. New Delhi: Oxford University Press. 1985. Standards, codification, and sociolinguistic realism: The English language in the outer circle. English in the world: Teaching and learning of language and literature, ed. by Randolph Quirk and Henry Widdowson, 11-30. Cambridge: University Press. 1986(a). The alchemy of English: The spread, functions and models of non-native Englishes. Oxford: 1986(b). digm. Studies 1986(c). 1986(d). Pergamon Press. ESP and in non-native varieties of English: Toward a the Linguistic Sciences 16:1.13-34. shift in para- The bilingual's creativity and contact literatures. Kachru 1986(a). The Power and politics of English. World Englishes 5:2-3.1 21- 140. 1987. The past and prejudice: Toward de-mythologizing the English canLanguage topics: Papers in honor of M. A. K. Hailiday, ed. by Ross Steele and Terry Threadgold. Amsterdam: John Benjamins. 1988. The spread of English and sacred linguistic cows. Lowenberg, ed. on. 1988:207-228. 1989. Liberation linguistics and the Ouirk concern. (MS) L. Smith, eds. 1986. The power of English: Cross-cultural dimensions in literature and media. World Englishes 5:2-3. LAKOFF, Robin. 1972. Language in context. Language 48.907-927. 1975. Linguistic theory and the real world. Language Learning 25:2.309, and 338. LOWENBERG, Peter H. 1986. acquisition: acculturation , and second-language Malaysian English. World Sociolinguistic context and creativity in Englishes 5:1.71-83. ed. 1988. Language spread and language policy: Issues, implications, and case studies. (= Georgetown University Round Table on Language and Linguistics 1987.) Washington D.C.: Georgetown University Press. and S. N. Sridhar, eds. 1986. World Englishes and second language acquisition research. World Englishes 5:1.3-4 McARTHUR, Tom. 1987. The English languages. English Today, July 1987. MUHLHAUSLER, Peter. 1985. Patterns of contact, mixture, creation, and na, Their contribution to a general theory of language. Developmental mechanism of language, ed. by C. N. Bailey and R. Harris. Oxford: tivization: Pergamon Press. NESFIELD, J. C. 1895. English grammar series. Book IV: synthesis for high schools. Calcutta: Macmillan. PAIKEDAY, T. M. 1985. The native speaker is dead! Publishing. PLATT, John, H. Weber, and M. Routledge and Kegan Paul. , L. Ho. 1984. Idiom, grammar, and Toronto: The new Englishes. and K. Singh. 1985. The use of localized English English World-Wide 5:1.43-54. in Paikeday London: Singapore poetry. World Englishes and applied B. Kachru: 151 linguistics PRATOR, Clifford. 1968. The British heresy in TESL. Language problems in developing nations, ed. by Joshua A. Fishman, C. A. Ferguson, and J. Das Gupta. New York: John Wiley. PRIDE, John B. 1981. Native competence and the bilingual/multilingual speaker. English World-Wide 2:2.141-153. 1982. New Englishes. Rowley, MA: Newbury House. QUIRK, Randolph. 1985. The English language in a global context. Quirk & Widdowson, eds., 1985. 1986. Words at work: Lectures on textual structure. [LKY Distinguished Visitor Series.] Singapore: University Press. 1988. The question of standards in the international use of English. Lowenberg, ed. 1988:229-241. 1989. Language varieties and standard language. JALT Journal 1 1 :1. 14- — . 25. and Henry Widdowson, eds. 1985. English in the world: Teaching and and literatures. London, Cambridge, and New York: Cambridge University Press. RAMAIAH, L. S., and Prabhu N. S. 1985. Communicative language teaching: , learning the language A bibliography. Gurgaon, Haryana: RICHARDS, Jack, J. Piatt, and H. Weber. Indian Documentation Service. 1985. Longman dictionary of applied London: Longman. ROBINETT, Betty Wallace, and Jacquelyn Schachter, eds. linguistics. guage learning: Contrastive analysis, error Ann Arbor, Ml: University of Michigan Press. SAVIGNON, Sandra. 1972. Larry. in 1983. and Second lan- related aspects. communicative language teaching. Forum 30:4.16-21. English Teaching SELINKER, What's what 1987. analysis, Interlanguage. Reprinted in Robinett & Schachter 1983:173-196. 1985. Towards a description of Indian English: A standard machine-readable form. English World-Wide 6:2.275-8. SIDHU, C. D. 1976. An intensive course in English. New Delhi: Qrient Longman. SINGH, Frances B. 1987. Power and politics in the context of grammar books: the example of India. World Englishes 6:3.195-199 SMITH, Larry E., ed. 1981. English for cross-cultural communication. London: SHASTRI, S. V. corpus in The English Association. , ed. 1983. Readings New York: Pergamon 1987. in English as an international language. Discourse across cultures: Strategies in Oxford and world Englishes. London: Prentice-Hall International. SRIDHAR, Kamal English. , and K. 1985. S. N. Sridhar. acquisition theory 5:1.3-14. Sociolinguistic theories and non-native varieties of Lingua 68.85-104. 1986. Bridging the paradigm gap: and indigenized varieties of English. Second language World Englishes 152 Studies in the Linguistic Sciences 19:1 (Spring 1989) STREET, sity Brian V. 1984. Literacy in theoty and practice. Cambridge: Univer- Press. THUMBOO, Edwin. 1988. The literary dimension of the spread of English: in a second tongue. Lowenberg, ed. 1988:361-401. TIPPING, Llewlyn. 1933. Matriculation English grammar of modern English Usage. London: Macmillan. TRUDGILL, Peter, ed. 1984. Applied sociolinguistics. New York: Academic Creativity Press. WALKER, A. G. H. 1984. Applied sociology of language: Vernacular language and education. Trudgill, ed. 1984:159-202. WREN, P. C, and H. Martin. 1954. High school English grammar and composition, revised edition. New Delhi: S. Chand. Studies in Volume 19, the Linguistic Sciences Number 1, Spring 1989 CORPUS PLANNING FOR MODERNIZATION: SANSKRITIZATION AND ENGLISHIZATION OF HINDI Yamuna Kachru This paper discusses the impact of the two processes of and modernization on the structure of Hindi. show that the spontaneous corpus planning by the users of the language is giving a direction to the modernization of the language which was not anticipated by the official language planners. Natural selection and use of lexical and grammatical devices are resulting in Sanskritization of the lexicon but Englishization of the syntax of Hindi. The data are drawn from official documents, the media, and recently compiled Sanskritization dictionaries of technical I terminology. Introduction According to the Indian Constitution, Hindi in Devanagari script is the language of the Indian Union. Article 351 of the constitution directs the government to develop the language by making sure that it is enriched 'by assimilating without interfering with its genius, the forms, style and expressions used in Hindustani and in the other languages of India specified in the Eighth Schedule, and by drawing, wherever necessary or desirable, for its vocabulary primarily on Sanskrit and secondarily on other languages' (Nayar 1969:100). In other words, Sanskritization is to be the primary means of modernizing Hindi for use in administration, law, higher education, etc.; it is to be the center of all corpus planning activities. official mean by modernnot be out of place here to briefly discuss what and corpus planning. The notion of language modernization discussed in studies such as Ferguson 1968, B. Kachru 1979, Gonzales 1984, D'souza 1986, 1987, among others, is of crucial relevance to the concept of corpus planning (Kloss 1969). The term modernization has been used in various senses by various researchers; will adopt the sense suggested in D'souza 1987: 'Modernization entails the processes by which a language is made It may I ization I 154 Studiesin the Linguistic Sciences 19:1 (Spring 1989) functionally suitable for use in new or extended domains' (64). made Corpus plan- equip a language with elaborated codes for use in domains such as modern administration, science, and technolwould like to discuss in this study both the results of corpus planning and ogy. the processes whereby the planned development of elaborated codes in Hindi is being made partially irrelevant by spontaneous selection and use by a majority of the users of the language. ning refers to the deliberate attempts to I new the context of Hindi, let me make one or extended domains of language use Although it is not essential that societal modernization precede language modernization, in the case of India, language modernization is motivated by sociocultural changes that are taking place in response to the contact with the West. These sociocultural changes are most visible in the domains of sociopolitical ideologies and scientific and technical education (see e.g. Singer 1972 on the modernization of Before explaining the relevant in brief digression. Indian society). To come back to the extended domains of use of Hindi. No language of the Indian subcontinent, literary or non-literary, including Hindi, has had a tradi- use in modern administrative, legislative, and judicial systems, or science and technology. In the pre-British period, the language of the royal court(s) in a large part of India was Persian, and following the consolidation of the British rule in India soon after 1857, English became the language of administrative and legal systems. In addition, became the language of science and technolwas the medium of higher education (Report of the Official Language ogy as Commission, Government of India, 1956). All efforts since 1947 that have been directed toward making Hindi functionally useful in domains such as administration, law courts, scientific, and technical education, are thus relevant for my purposes here. tion of it it briefly the official policies and efforts to plan will then focus on and implement the results. the spontaneous developments that have been going on since the 1950s and their effect on the lexical, syntactic, and discoursal components of the language. In this paper, I will describe the enrichment of the language Official planning and implementation Following the adoption of Hindi as the India, there (Halliday I official language of the Republic of was a & Hasan great deal of emphasis on developing various registers 1976) in the language. The official policy was to coin tech- utilizing indigeneous sources; international sources were to be utilized if and where indigeneous sources failed to provide the necessary and appropriate resources. Indigeneous sources include terminology available in Sanskrit and regional languages, and also the Persian terms adopted or adapted in Hindi as well as various regional languages. In addition, the official policy recognizes the fact that people 'in the field', though not very well educ- nical terminology Y. Kachru: Corpus planning for modernization ated in English or Sanskrit, ces, including 'adaptations may and 155 already have developed appropriate resour- vulgarizations' of English terms for talking about technical topics; these should be adopted for modernizing the Indian languages (Report of the Official Language Commission, Government of India, 1956). A number of official bodies were instituted to develop and extend the use between 1951-1967, the following among them: (1) The Board of Scientific and Technical Terminology, set up in 1951 to evolve technical terms and words for use in mathematics, physics, chemistry, medicine, zoology, social sciences, administrative subjects, and defence services; (2) The Central Hindi Directorate, set up in 1960 to execute jobs relating to the propagation of Hindi; The Central Hindi Institute, established in Agra in 1960 to provide up-to(3) date expert knowledge and professional guidance for teaching Hindi to nonHindi-speaking peoples and foreigners, and to attend to allied pedagogical problems; (4) The Indian Union of Hindi Organizations, established in 1964 to advise the central and state governments in matters relating to the development of Hindi; and (5) A Central Hindi Committee and several Hindi Advisory Committees, set up in 1967 to review from time to time the progress made by various government ministries in the use of Hindi in their domains. In addition, the Central Translation Bureau was set up in 1971 to translate all types of nonstatuatory literature and to monitor the translations done by various departments and ministries. of Hindi Selection of an official language always has a tremendous effect on the educational system. A language designated an official language immediately carves out a prominent place in the educational system regardless of a deliberate policy in favor or opposition to such a move. In the case of Hindi, various activities initiated by the state governments in the Hindi area as well as those by the Union government have had an impact on the use of Hindi in administration and education. First, the Conference of Education l\/Iinisters, Vice-Chancellors, and other representatives from Hindi-speaking states met in July 1979 and resolved that universities in Hindi-speaking states were to switch to Hindi as the medium of instruction in Commerce, Arts, and Science subjects immediately. In the case of Engineering and Medicine, the switch to Hindi medium was to be effective beginning 1980. Secondly, from 1979, the questions for the General Knowledge and Essay components in the All India and Higher Central Services Examinations were to be set in both English and Hindi, and candidates were to answer the questions in any language listed in the Eighth Schedule of the Thirdly, in order to i.e., in any of the 14 national languages. promote the knowledge of Hindi among public servants, the Union government instituted three levels of proficiency examinations, and Hindi shorthand and typing examinations. By 1975, 57.3 percent of government employees had passed one or the other level of the proficiency examinations, and 59.6 and 50.7 percent respectively had passed the typing and shorthand examinations.'' Fourthly, the Hindi-speaking states began pursuing vigorously the use of Hindi in legal and administrative domains. Constitution, 156 Studies in the Linguistic Sciences 19:1 (Spring 1989) Actual corpus planning and implementation Although the official policy has always been to gradually replace English government have not been unambiguous. First, in the ___domain of higher education, a string of proposals and deliberations by numerous education commissions and other bodies with Hindi, in actual practice, the intentions of the debating the question of medium of instruction at the high school, undergraduate, and graduate levels finally has boiled down to this: Hindi is to serve as link language for the masses, whereas English is to be link language of the university-educated elite (Nayar 1969:173). In the ___domain of administrative languages, the percentage of Union government employees who have become does not exceed 50 percent; the number who use Hindi is even smaller, if one were to judge by the quantum of correspondence carried out in Hindi between the Union and the state governments (Gandhi 1984:212, proficient in Hindi Table). Moving over to the issue of spontaneous corpus planning, in spite of the emphasis on Sanskrit and other indigeneous sources, in practice, Hindi seems to be utilizing all the sources available to it in order to modernize itself: the traditional source of Sanskrit lexicon and grammar, the indigeneous source of folk terms, the pan-Indian source of terms from other regional languages, and the international source(s) of scientific and technical terms. The strategy varies from strict utilization of only one of these options to an eclectic approach of finding the most appropriate and least exclusive alternative. Almost all Indian languages adopt such strategies for modernization (see D'souza 1986 for examples from Bengali, Hindi, Kannada, Marathi, Tamil, and Telugu). Note that in most Indian languages, modernization is crucially dependent upon Sanskritization; Sanskrit has been the traditional source that has enriched all languages for intellectual speculations and technical terminologies. official In the remainder of this paper, will discuss the interaction of two strategies equip Hindi for use in administrative, legal, business, commercial, scientific, technical, and other such domains: drawing from Sanskrit, and mixing with I to English . In spite of the efforts of the purists and nationalists, the language as used day-to-day administration, business, courts, and scientific and technical education, etc. is heavily mixed with English. This mixing results from the following lexicalization processes: borrowing ('loanwords' in D'souza 1987); hybridization; simultaneous use of indigeneous and English items ('doublets' in D'souza 1987); loanshifting, including semantic extension ('loan extensions' in D'souza 1987) and loan translation, and use of neologisms (new words formed from indigenous material but with meanings/concepts adopted from a foreign in source, i.e., English).^ 157 Y. Kachru: Corpus planning for modernization Examples (1) of these processes are as follows: Borrowing Administration and Law: kes 'case', 'secretary', afear 'officer*, yay 'judge', aaffs 'office', sekreTarii ejeNDaa 'agenda' Business and Industry: ba/nk 'bank', arye/vr 'urgent', manii aarDar 'money order', rejisTreshan 'registration', d/paay'/T 'deposit' Science and technology: tharmal paawar sTeshan 'thermal power station', kren 'crane', espirin 'aspirin', alTraa saauND 'ultra sound" (2) Hybridization Administration and Law: faail-paddhati kendra 'i\\\r\g system', pulis caukii 'poWce station', reDio 'radio station', pres sensari 'press censorship', raashan adhikaarii 'rationing officer' Business and Industry; kendriiya baink 'central bank', vaahak caik 'bearer cheque', mashiiniikaraN 'mechanization' Science and Technology takniikii shikshaa 'technical education', mashiin mistrii 'machinist', esiTic (3) amia 'acetic acid' 'Doublets' Administration and Law: panjiiyak, panjiikaar aashulekhak saamaan, maal sangarodh Businessand Industry: utpaadan shilghraliplk, rajisTraar 'registrar' sTeno sTaak kwaarenTaain 'stenographer' 'stock', 'quarantine' proDakT 'product' samveSTan paikejing 'packaging' vijnaapan aiDvarTaayzIng prays braiND cainals av DisTribyuushan 'advertising' DimaaND 'demand'. nyuuraan insomniyaa 'neuron' aarsenik 'arsenic' muulya cihna vitaraN ke maadhyam maag 'price' 'brand' 'channels of distribution' (Singh 1983:63) Science and Technology: snaayu koshikaa anidraa rog sankhiaa 'insomnia' 158 Studies in the Linguistic Sciences 19:1 (Spring 1989) (4) Loanshifts: a. Semantic Extensions Administration and Law: sac/Va 'secretary', man/r/V 'minister', anus/jaasan 'discipline', rakSaa 'defence' Businessand Technology: hunDii'bWy, vyaapaar 'commerce' vyaw-saay 'profession', abhikartaa 'agent' (from abhikr'lo do in behalf of or with , reference to') Science and Technology: aavesh urvaraa b. 'charge', uurjaa 'energy', urvarak 'fertilizer' (from 'fertile soil') Loan Translations Administration and Law: (5) jana gaNanaa 'census', raaSTriiyakaraN 'nationalization', bandii pratyakSiikaraN 'habeas corpus' Business and Industry: jiivan biimaa 'life insurance', shram kalyaaN 'labor welfare', shramlk sangha 'labor union', amsh patra 'share', vitta 'finance' Neologisms Administration and Law: aakaashvaaNii'AW India Radio' (original meaning: 'voice from the air or heaven'), nagar nigam 'municipal corporation', bikrii /car 'sales tax', shamsaa-patra 'testimonial' Business and Industry: biijak 'invoice', rokaRiyaa 'cashier', bandhak 'mortgage', vaarSik vrtti 'annuity' Science and Technology: sangaNak 'computer', shodh 'research', prayogshaalaa 'laboratory', pratiip The processes stabilized as yet. India (Kansal illustrated In fact, one gaman 'regression' above make it clear that the terminology has not of the official publications of the & Sharma 1978) contains examples such as Government of The the following: proposes the translation equivalent uuSma for the concept of 'heat' jn physics in the paragraph on suggesting equivalents for international scientific terminology, but uses the term taap while discussing the Sanskrit terms current all over India for the same concept in the next paragraph (p. 30)1 In the ___domain text it has been found necessary to compile dictionterms used for the same English ones in the same state or in various states. One such dictionary, Tiwari, Bhatia & Singh 1982, provides lists of the type illustrated in (6) [next page]. (See also Paliwal 1986.) of administrative terminology, aries that list parallel Hindi In the absence of the English terms, the equivalent Hindi terms, essentialy borrowed from Sanskrit, may not be understood, or may even be misunderstood across states or between states and the Center! Y. Kachru: Corpus planning for modernization (6) a. 159 Face value English term: Hindi term: Central government: Rajasthan: pratyakSa muulya muulya mukhya muulya ankit/ pratyakSa muulya, ankit arhaa ankit muulya ankit/ Uttar Pradesh: ankit Bihar: Madhya Pradesh: Hariyana: b. muulya ankit English term: Intelligence Bureau Hindi term: Central government: guptavaartaa vibhaag guptavaartaa vibhaag xufiyaa byuuro/ adhisuucnaa kendra Rajasthan: Uttar Pradesh: aasucnaa abhiSThaan/ Bihar: byuuro, aasuucnaa/xufiyaa byuuro guptavaartaa vibhaag/ guptacaryaa kaaryaalaya guptavaartaa vibhaag Madhya Pradesh: Hariyana: Interesting as the processes described above are, more interesting are the changes introduced into the syntax of Hindi and other languages due to the processes of code elaboration and use of the elaborated codes in new domains. Consider the following examples from Hindi: (7) Excerpt from the Lok Sabha (Indian Parliament: Lower House) II (General Information relating to parliamentary and Bulletin [Part other matters), Monday March ke kaary sarkaarii government business 'Allocation of time for liye for 24, 1908 (Saka), p.1)]: samay kaa niyatan time allocation of government business.' sabhaa aaj shhi gulaam nabii aazaad dvaaraa pesh kiye gaye moved Lok Sabha today Mr. Ghulam Nabi Azad by lok ek prastaav par sahmat a motion on agreed huii ki {antarraajyik that Inter-state jal vivaad Water Dispute (sanshodhan) vidheyak, 1986, raa jya sabhaa dvaaraa yathaapaarit Rajya Sabha by (amendment) Bill as passed par} vicaar athaa paarit karne hetu3 ghaNTe kaa samay for of time on consideration and passing 3 hours niyat kiyaa jaae. allocation be done . Studies in the Linguistic Sciences 19:1 (Spring 1989) 160 'On a motion moved by Mr. Ghulam Nabi Azad, the Lok Sabha today agreed to the allocation of 3 hours for the consideration and passing of the Inter-state Water Disputes (Amendment) Bill, 1986, as passed by the Rajya Sabha.' The separation of the postposition par 'on* from its object NP by the underlined phrase in (7) provides an instance of the effect of English syntax as a result of a literal translation. 3 The order of the phrases in the sentence and the coordination of items in italics point to the same factor. According to the rules of Hindi usage, the sentence should have had the following word order: lok sabhaa aaj shrii gulaam nabii aazaad dvaaraa pesh kiye gaye ek prastaav par sahmat huii ki (raajya sabhaa dvaaraa yathaa paarit antarraajyik jal vivaad (sanshodhan) vidheyak, 1986, par} vicaar karne tathaa use paarit karne hetu 3 ghaNTe kaa samay niyat kiyaa (7") jaae. What fact that is noticeable about the language of the parliamentary bulletins is the all content words are from Sanskrit, but the syntax is highly almost The same phenomenon is attested in the journalistic register, as is in (8). The tortuous syntax and the use of the passive dekhaa jaa rahaa thaa 'was being seen' in this passage are influenced by English. A more idiomatic Hindi sentence would read as in (8').'* Englishized. clear from the excerpt (8) cailenjar Challenger amriikii antarikSa kaarykram ko ke visphoT se program to explosion from American space of suffered ubaarne dhakke se shock from emerging taur par kal way on yesterday Delta lege kii kSamtaa ke pariikSaN of capacity DelTaa raakeT rocket kii uRaan ko of flight ke of of test DO dekhaa jaa rahaa seen being thaa. was 'The flight of the Delta rocket yesterday was being seen as a test of the American space program's capability to extricate itself from the setback suffered as a result of the explosion of Challenger. (Jansattaa, (8') kal May kii Yesterday of 5, DelTaa raakeT kii uRaan ek Delta of flight antarikS kaarykarm space 1986:2) program rocket kii of dhakke se ubaarne shock from emerging a tarah se amriikii way from American cailenjar ke visphoT se Challenger of explosion from kii kSamtaa ke pariikSaN ke of capability of test of lage suffered taur parthii. way on was Y. Kachru: Corpus planning for modernization Mixing with English and technical 161 not confined to administrative, legal, business, is The language of duurdarshan, 'Indian telepresents several examples of English idioms translated into Hindi, which may be unintelligible to viewers not familiar with English. The examples sceintific, registers. vision', in (9) illustrate (9) this claim: yah faarm par rahnaa tumhaare ko Thiik nahTT baiThtaa. farm on living right not sits you to 'This living on the farm does not sit well with you.' a. this phon lagaaiye. phone connect hon. 'Please connect the phone to my wife.' merii vaaif ko b. my DO wife (Episode 51: Khaandaan, March 19, 1986) The Hindi idioms in (9a) and (9b) should have been ... tumhe raas nahii aataa 'does not suit you' and phon milaaiye 'connect the phone'. Note also the use of the indianized English word vaa/Twife' in (9b) instead of the Hindi word patnii. The rapid expansion of register range of Hindi and other Indian languages and the increased use of the English-mixed style in several domains has resulted in an overall mixed educated variety of these languages. A sample of this mixed variety of Hindi is presented below: plaazaa lauTte hue kuch der se while plaza from returning a (10) kaalej college aaj xush kaafii tabiiyat today mind ammaa uTh kar ghar cale aaye. raising home came away eating ek tej a sharp patra likhaa thaa, posT kar diyaa. post do gave is this ghaNTe had mai ne hai and sat for a while this day, home. I (I) felt in us likhe. letters wrote but post it hai. 10 yah aadmii man nahii, vah vyakti he person not apnii siimaae hai. own limits are way back from When Mother. Gyan duusraa that this of light-hearted. for ki kii the plaza on our brought the medicine thaa thought had not Taaip kar gyaan ko not doing other kabhii nahii socaa that type happy and se from there dii. patra posT na ag. ever — aur is iaa par use kadar 'miiDiaakar' ho saktaa be can mediocre way ek Taaip type a '(I) after I ko davaaii two hours meal written was light mother 10 medicine bring gave khaanaa khaane ke baad do letter baiThe rahe. seated remained in man halkaathaa. vahaa aur thii happy was and heart very me (I) I left the college. there, wrote (I) On came letters for two 162 Studies in the Linguistic Sciences 19:1 (Spring 1989) hours after eating. (I) wrote a sharp lettter to Gyan, but did not mail it; (I) mailed another one instead. had never thought that he could be so mediocre ... He is not an individual, he is a type, and that type has I its own limitations." (Rakesh1985:46) The excerpt Hindi spoken all in (10) represents the ordinary idiom of colloquial standard over the Hindi area by educated speakers of the language. Conclusion obvious from the discussion above that mixing with English has resultterms for many objects and concepts, semantic extensions or redefinitions of words from indigeneous sources, especially Sanskrit, and neologisms that are opaque for most speakers of Hindi and that need the equivalent English terms for appropriate interpretation. In other words, even the Sanskritization of the lexicon is being mediated through English. In addition to these effects on the lexicon, English has influenced the syntax of the language by introducing uncharacteristic word order, and extension of conventions of use of constructions such as the passive. These changes have not occurred because of deliberate planning; they have resulted from the process of rapid translation of texts from English (in the context of journalism, parliamentary debates, court room proceedings, etc.). Another contributing factor has been the nature of the speakers and writers responsible for the use of the language in new domains. Most speakers and writers who use Hindi in, e.g., administrative, legal, or scientific discourse have been educated through the medium of English. It is natural for them to continue to use English terms and idioms to express the meanings they have in Hindi. This naturally leads to the EnglishWhatever the official policy, English ization of Hindi (see B. Kachru 1986). continues to play a major role in the unplanned 'corpus planning' of almost all Indian languages. The resulting enrichment is not confined to the new and extended domains; it has spilled over to the old and restricted domains as well and introduced changes in the structure of the language. It ed is in parallel NOTES ^For statistics on implementation of policies with regard to Hindi as of instruction and in central services examinations, and the number of government employees with proficiency in Hindi, see Gandhi 1984, Tables on pp. 204-207, 200-201, and 106, respectively. medium 2AII these categories are proposed in D'souza 1987. Y. Kachni: Corpus planning for modernization ^The entire postpositional phrase is enclosed examples have also been used in Y. Kachru 1987. ^The and 'ag.', direct, in { }. 163 This and the next few 'DO', '10' in the glosses are abbreviations for the agentive. marking postpositions, respectively. The ending on the verb. indirect object to the honorific 'hon.' refers REFERENCES 1986. Language modernization in a sociolingulstic area. Anthropological Linguistics 28:4.455-71 1987. English in India's language modernization. World Englishes 6:1. 63-70. D'SOUZA, Jean. A. 1968. Language development. Language problems of developing nations, ed by J.A.Fishman, C.A. Ferguson, and J. Das Gupta, Ferguson, Charles 27-35. New York: John Wiley. Gandhi, K.L. 1984. The problem of official language in India. Delhi: Arya Book Depot. Gonzales, Andrew. 1984. Language dilemma in Philippine academia: nation- alism of modernization. Language for the third world universities, ed. by Pride, 23-38. New Delhi: Bahri Publications. J. Braj B. 1979. The Englishization of Hindi: Language rivalry and language change. Linguistic method: Papers in honor of H. Penzl., ed. by Rauch and G.F. Carr, 199-211. The Hague: Mouton. 1986. The alchemy of English: The spread, functions, and models of non- Kachru, I. Oxford: Pergamon Press. 1987. Impact of expanding domains of use on a standard Contemporary Hindi in India. Studies in the Linguistic Scien- native Englishes. Kachru, Yamuna. language: ces 17:1.73-90. Kansal, Hah B., and R. K. Sharma (eds.). 1978. All India Official Language Conference Souvenir. New Delhi: Department of Official Language, Ministry of Home Affairs, Government of India. Kloss, Heinz. 1969. Research possibilities on group-bilingualism. Quebec: International Center for Research on Bilingualism. Nayar, Batdev R. 1969. National communication and language policy in India. Ney York: Praeger. Paliwal, Naryandatta. 1986. Prashaasnik angrezii-hindii koS [English-Hindi dictionary of Administrative Terminology]. New Delhi: Takshashila Praka- shan. Rakesh, Mohan. 1988. Mohan raakesh kii Dayrii. Delhi: Rajpal & Sons. Studies in the Linguistic Sciences 19:1 (Spring 1989) 164 REPORT OF THE OFFICIAL LANGUAGE COMMISSSION, GOVERNMENT OF New Delhi: Government INDIA. 1 956. of India Press. Singer, Milton. 1972. When a great tradition modernizes: An anthropological approach to Indian civilization. New York: Praeger. Singh, Dilip. 1983. Vyaavsaayik hindii [Business Hindi]. Madras: Dakshina Bharat Hindi Prachar Sabha. TiWARi, Bholanath, K.G. Bhatia, and J. Singh. 1982. Akhil bhaaratiiya prashaasnik koS [All India Administrative Terminology]. Delhi: Prabhat Prakashan. the Linguistic Sciences Studies in Volume 19, Number 1, Spring 1989 SQUIB Good mixes and odd mixes: Implications for the bilingual's grammar Rakesh Mohan Bhatt — Code-mixing (CM) the intrasentential mixing of various linguistic units is perhaps the most pervasive phenfrom two distinct grammatical systems omenon that characterizes multilingual speech communities. Contrary to earlier claims that CM is random, there have been some successful attempts in the recent past to structure code mixing, both in its form and and in its function (e.g. Kachru 1978, 1982, Bokamba 1988, Pandharipande 1986, Poplack 1982, Sridhar & Sridhar 1980, Timm 1975). These studies have attempted to discover syntactic constraints on CM in order to characterize the bilingual's linguistic competence and its — implication for linguistic theory. indeed there are structural constraints on CM, or at least languagewe may have to try to develop a theoretical apparatus that will account for the phenomenon of CM and reveal principles of its organization and functioning. Put differently, we have to engage ourselves, as Ferguson (1978) has already pointed out, in writing a bilingual's grammar. The purpose of this squib is to respond, very briefly, to Ferguson's concern and to see if If specific constraints, structural constraints in CM fall out from general linguistic principles. multilingual societies, where CM is generally the norm, accode-mixed varieties necessitates important modification of linguisIf code-mixers do indeed have intuitions about 'good tic theory as we know it. mixes' as opposed to 'odd mixes', we are obliged to assume a code-mixed competence: the ability of speakers to give judgements about the acceptability or unacceptability of a certain code-mixed utterance. In fact, theoretical studies have focussed on the structural characteristics of CM in order to describe the properties of such internalized systems (Pfaff 1979, Poplack 1980, Shdhar & Sridhar 1980, among others). These studies, however, suffer from one very serious defect. Their cross-linguistic generalizations are based on a very small corpus of data and are thus falsified in subsequent studies. For example, Poplack's Free Morpheme Constraint has exceptions in 'Korean-English (/ man-a chip 'This man's house'), Swahili-English {Tunakwende ku-enjoy mjini"We are going to town to enjoy'; Kishe 1989), and Chikongo-French {Samba, chauffa bidia 'Samba, chauffe bidia 'Warm up the food'; Dimbamio 1989). In traditional quisition of — 166 Studies in the Linguistic Sciences 19:1 (Spring 1989) Sridhar & Sridhar's Dual Structure Principle has had its share of problems Their analysis of the insertion of elements of too (see Pandharipande 1986). the guest language 'Into appropriate slots in the syntactic frame of the host language' has exceptions in cases where the phrase structure order of the guest language is different from the host language. Consider e.g. the following CM passages involving Hindi or Kashmiri with English. Ct^ Hindi-English (1) (a) gaaRii sTeshan par aayii train station on/at came 'The train arrived (b) CM *gaaRii [in in the station.' the station] aayii Kashmiri-English (2) (a) gaaR' aayii sTeshanas p'aTh train came station on 'The train arrived (3) (b) *gaaR' (a) ba I 'I (b) (c) in aayii osus had had gone [in the station] dostas siith' friend with with *ba osus ba osus the station.' a gomut gone friend.' [with friend] friend siith' gomut gomut (DSP) will probably hold if we modify to a guest language can be introduced into the host language that are licensed by the phrase structure rules of the host language. This constraint will therefore predict sentences like (lb), (2b) and (3b) to be (severe) cases of 'odd' mixing. The modified DSP also holds true in Farsi-English (Gadhari 1989), German-Swahili (Vavrus 1989), etc. The Dual Structure mean Principle it that only those linguistic units of There is yet another constraint that seems to have cross-linguistic appeal. it Lexical Category Constraint. This constraint will not allow any 'lexical category' (= "stuff" that does not have any referential meaning, such as determiners, inflectional suffixes, postpositions, complementizers, etc.) to be mixed into the host language. Examples of such a constraint in Hindi-English CM are given as examples (c) and (d) in Kachru 1983:203. Other evidence is cited in (4) and (5) below. Similar examples can be found in Korean-English CM, Chikongo-French CM, Swahili-English CM, and Hindi-English CM, to mention only a few cases. In the absence of any preexisting terminology, I shall call Spanish-English (4) (a) di un libro gave a book gave a book 'I (b) *di (c) di un un a I to the estudiante student to the student.' libro to libro a I estudiante student Bhatt: Squib on 'Good mixes and odd mixes' 167 Creole-English (5) The to pan di kata on the turban on di kata pan di turban book (a) Di (b) The book *Di book (c) Di book constraints on functional categories, on the other hand, are subject parametric variation. For instance, in Korean-English, the head of the funccategory is the one which cannot be mixed, cf. (6). tional Korean-English (a) (6) meu serpuda very sad (b) *meu (c) very sad serpuda On the other hand, in Spanish-English, Hindi-English, Farsi-English, and Creole-English it is the head that can be borrowed from the guest language, not its complement; cf. (7) - (9). Spanish-English (a) (7 (b) muy sad very sad *very triste bahut sad very sad dukhii Hindi-English (a) (8) (b) *very Creole-English (a) (9) John thinks Mary (b) *John thinks Mary (c) John thinks Mary chupit too 'John thinks (that) Mary (is) very stupid' very chupit stupid too CM is still very small. And the task at hand is stupenddevelop a system of rules that interact to determine the form and meaning of a potentially infinite number of CM sentences. But the interest in empirical study of CM continues with the same rigor as it has since the early 1970's, it may lead to the formulation of highly restrictive and quite plausible hypotheses that contribute to the attempt to develop a theory of acquisition of knowledge that gives due place to multilingualism. The goal of such an enterprise will be to spell out, in some detail, the elaborate and abstract computThe data base on ous: to if ations, the formal principles, that age use in makes possible the creative aspect of langu- multilingual societies, viz., code-mixing. 168 Studies in the Linguistic Sciences 19:1 (Spring 1989) REFERENCES BOKAMBA, E. 1988. Code-mixing, language variation, and linguistic theory: Evidence from Bantu languages. Lingua 76:1.21-62. DIMBAMIO, B. 1989. Is code-mixing rule governed ? Department of Linguistics, University of Illinois, FERGUSON, Linguistics 97-105. GADHARI, MS. 1978. Multilingualism as object of linguistic description. the seventies: Directions and prospects, ed. by B. B. Kachru, C. A. in Sciences 8:2.) Notes on Farsi-English code-mixing. (= Studies in the Linguistic Department of LinMS. KACHRU, Braj B. 1978. Code-mixing as a communicative strategy in India. International dimensions of bilingual education, ed. by J. Alatis, 107-124. Washington, DC: Georgetown University Press. 1982. The bilingual's linguistic repertoire. Issues in international bilingual education: The role of vernacular, ed. by B. Hartford & A. Valdman, 25-52. New York: Plenum Press. 1983. The Indianization of English: The English language in India. Delhi: J. 1989. guistics, University of Illinois, Oxford University Press. A. 1989. Constraints on Swahili-English code-mixing. KISHE, Department of MS. PANDHARIPANDE, R. 1986. Formal and functional constraints on code-mixing. 11th International Congress of Sociology, New Delhi, India. PFAFF, C. W. 1979. Constraints on language mixing. Language 55.291-318. POPLACK, S. 1980. Sometimes start a sentence in English y termino en Linguistics, University of Illinois, I — Espanol: toward a typology of code-switching. Linguistics 18.581-618. 1982. Bilingualism and the vernacular. Issues in international bilingual education: The role of vernacular, ed. by B. Hartford & A. Valdman, 1-23. New York: Plenum Press. SRIDHAR, S. N., and K. K. Sridhar. 1980. The syntax and psycholinguistics of bilingual code-mixing. Canadian Journal of Psychology 34.407-416. TIMM, L A. 1975. Spanish-English code-switching: El porque y how-not-to. Romance Philology 28.473-482. VAVRUS, F. 1989. Reflections on code-switching and code-mixing. Depart. ment of Linguistics, University of Illinois, MS. the Linguistic Sciences Number 1, Spring 1989 Studies in Volume 19, REVIEW New Sil<hs in England. Crisis of identity: Agnihotri: Rs. 140/--, US Bahri Publications, 1987; pp. xv, 162, map. Rama Kant Delhi: $28.00. Jean Aitcinison (London School of Economics) In the twentieth century, immigration has taken place around the world on a large scale. Yet remarkably little is known about the detailed sociolinguistic patterns which are associated with the inevitable conflicts of adaptation, as the newcomers encounter a different language and a strange culture. Our ignorance is due primarily to three factors: First, the immigrant group is usually struggling to establish itself financially, and its members are often forced into unskilled or semi-skilled jobs. They are therefore not in a position to conduct Second, few of the hosts have enough their own sociolinguistic surveys. knowledge of the language and customs of the newcomers to be able to ask useful questions. Third, the immigrant group is often suspicious of inquisitive strangers. The result is that the host country often ignores the situation, hoping that the new arrivals will simply melt away by fast assimilation into the local language and culture. If they do not, then educational and social problems are dealt with piecemeal, and not always successfully. is typical of the treatment of immigrants in Great Britain, which has become a multicultural nation in less than half a century. The widespread ignorance about them and their needs can only be amended if we have many more studies of the type found in this book. Agnihotri's study of the conflicts faced by Sikh children in England is a model of its kind, lucid, informative, and thorough. As a native speaker of Punjabi, a fluent speaker of English, and a trained sociolinguist, he was an ideal person to deal with the topic. The bulk of the work was carried out in the early 1970s as part of his Ph.D. dissertation, which was written while he was a postgraduate at the University of The above York. pattern He was thus England, and it is a able to investigate the first generation of Sikh children study has taken so long to get into print. in pity the According to the preface, the book is the first and more general of two volumes. (The second, containing detailed linguistic analyses, has not yet been published.) It contains 10 chapters, which move gradually from general matters at the beginning, to linguistic analysis at the end. Studies in the Linguistic Sciences 19:1 (Spring 1989) 170 The early chapters deal with background information on Sikh culture and the circumstances of Sikh arrival in Britain: A first wave from rural India in the early 1960s was supplemented by an influx of urbanized Sikhs from Kenya and Uganda in the late 1960s and early 1970s. Chapter 3 contains a demographic survey of the Sikh community in Leeds, with information about age, sex, occupation, residential area, and family structure, culled partly from official sources, and partly from a survey conducted by the author. (chapter 1), Chapter 4 outlines the sociolinguistic situation faced by the Sikh children. lived with predominantly Punjabi-speaking parents and relatives, who insisted on the maintenance of traditional Sikh culture; they went to schools where they were exposed to the Leeds English spoken by the English children; school and on radio and television they intermittently came across the at English accent known as RP (Received Pronunciation, the educated standard of Britain); and they conversed with their siblings in a 'mixed code', part English, They part Punjabi. Chapter 5 looks in more detail at a small sample of children, 36 Sikh and 6 English, with the Sikh children divided into three groups, depending on their length of stay in Leeds (Group A, 2-5 years; B, 6-9 years; C, 10+ years). The chapter provides a 'sociopsychological profile' of the children, in that it outlines their beliefs and hopes. For example, over half of the Sikh children claimed that English was their 'best language', irrespective of their length of stay, indicating perhaps their realization that it was likely to prove the most socially useful. To a linguist, esting, since they the last two chapters (6 and 7) are perhaps the most interthe sociolinguistic patterns of adaptation adopted by the show Sikh children. Chapter 6 shows that predictably, perhaps, and encouragingly, the longer in Leeds, the more they approximate to the Leeds English variants, suggesting a gradual integration into the local norms. However, the Leeds features are not all acquired at the same time: Frequently used features are acquired faster, and stigmatized ones are picked up more slowly. The author also argues that features which fit in with Punjabi speech behaviour are the children are acquired faster. worrying finding was the discovery that whereas the Leeds children diverged in their casual speaking and formal reading styles, with the more prestigious RP used in the more careful styles, the Sikh children tended to model their reading style on their casual style. This suggests that the Sikh children were likely to be discriminated against in finding employment, since an RP accent (at least in the 1970s) was a distinct advantage in getting a good job. As in other sociolinguistic studies, the girls in this sample showed a greater use of prestige, non-stigmatized features. A somewhat more 'native' This chapter contains some minor phonetic defects, perhaps because the author has attempted to oversimplify matters for a nonspecialist audience. For example, there is a somewhat odd statement that in Leeds English bus is 'pronounced exactly as it is written.' (93): An RP speaker would make exactly the same claim, while pronouncing the vowel quite differently! Representation of the Leeds pronunciation of [t] as [ts] without further discussion is somewhat misleading. And (perhaps a fault of the printer) the glottal stop is almost uni- Aitchison: Review of Agnihotri 171 formly transcribed as a question mark. But these are minor matters, and do not detract seriously from an interesting chapter. Chapter 7 on the mixed code discusses the intermingled Punjabi-English which is spoken by the children, usually with their siblings. Since this work was carried out in the early 1970s, it is ahead of its time in realizing that simple 'code-switching' is too simple a concept for the complex code-mix which the Quite often it is impossible to tell whether the underlying children use: language is English or Punjabi, and it is also impossible to predict when switches or mixing will occur. Some of the constructions which are frequently mixed are described, and one can only hope that this fascinating topic will be dealt with more fully in the second volume (as promised). a well-documented, informative, and in many one done as long ago as the early 1970s. Had it been done in the 1980s, one might have liked a deeper discussion of morphology and syntax, though perhaps this will materialize in the second volume. Certain statements also seem a little dated. For example, the author regrets that the Sikh children may be doubly-disadvantaged, partly because they are foreign, and partly because they do not seem to be acquiring the RP accent necessary to get a good job. In fact, in the last decade, regional accents have become considerably more acceptable, and in some instances they are considered to be desirable, as they stamp the speaker as being more 'genuine'. The tub-thumping final paragraph also seems somewhat dated, in which the author states that 'the British government needs to reconsider its educational, linguistic, and cultural policies' (p. 132) in order to take account of the needs of a multicultural society. In the late 1980s, Britain is fully aware of the need to cater to a wide variety of languages and cultures. The basic problem now is one of providing the right kind of information to those in positions of power so that they can make decisions based on useful knowledge, rather than ignorance and speculation. Perhaps the final paragraph should more fittingly have requested those in power to read this informative book! As already noted, ways model study. It is this is particularly impressive for One final quibble: The book is entitled 'Crisis of identity.' Yet to an outsider reading this book, the children seemed to be coping remarkably well with their mixed identities, in spite of the conflicting pressures to which they were subjected. The crisis seemed to be mainly in the minds of the parents, who seemed desparately worried that their children were getting infected by the and (to them) often deplorable British ways. The children themselves showed a praiseworthy, pragmatic acceptance of the fact that they had to speak Punjabi to their parents and at the temple, and that they needed to use English alien at school; and they felt They seemed to accept One it useful to fall back on a mixed code with their siblings. was necessary to have a foot in each culture: sensible way in which most of them seemed to be that it could only admire the coping with conflicts which were undoubtedly more severe than most to face when growing up. In of us have is an excellent book which deserves to be widely read, by sociolinguists and educators. Hopefully, the second volume will the relatively near future. Ideally also this first volume will become conclusion, this particularly appear in easily available outside of India, preferably after correction of the typographical errors which mar the pages. numerous the Linguistic Sciences Studies in Volume 19, Number 1, Spring 1989 REVIEW Tej K. Bhatia: A history of the Hindi grammatical tradition. Leiden: E. J. Brill, 1987, pp. 229. Rajeshwari Pandharipande monograph presents a much needed survey of the 300 years of 1698 to the present. It carefully traces the origin and development of the tradition through a meticulous analysis of the form, content, function, and tacit or avowed motivations behind grammars Bhatia's history of Hindi grammatical tradition from at different points during the history of the Hindi The study and analysis of language. more than 400 grammars makes the survey very broad-based and extremely insightful. Bhatia focuses primarily on grammatical works of the 17th through the 19th centuries, for the simple reason that no previous work has tried to systematically reconstruct the Hindi grammatical tradition of that period. Though the survey of this tradition has been a minor part of many grammars, dissertations, and research articles on Hindi, the book under review surpasses them all and establishes a new genre of scholarship. The text includes analysis and critical evaluation of native as well as non-native grammars written by Germany, Russia, The grammar grammarians from different parts of the world (England, etc.). 'discovery of the (1698))' reported in first the grammar text, is one of of Hindi its (i.e., Ketelaar's original most commendable features. made an immense contribution to the history of Hindi grammatical by proving beyond doubt the existence and legitimacy of Ketelaar's grammar, which he personally examined in the Netherlands. In so doing, Bhatia satisfactorily resolves the controversy about the first grammar of Hindi. Similarly, the study presents, for the first time, a detailed, authentic treatment of some rare, unpublished, and even 'lost' grammars. Ketelaar's (1698), Schultz's (1744), Re. Adams's (1827), and Raja Shivprasad Sitare Hind's (1875). Some of the forgotten grammars written in European languages other than English (e.g. Garcin de Tassy's Rudiments de la langue hindoustani (1829), in French) are also discussed in this study. This inclusion of rare texts has not only brought Bhatia has tradition 174 Studies in the Linguistic Sciences 19: 1 (Spring 1989) unknown facts about the structure and contents of early grammars, but also their sociolinguistic makeup. to light hitherto The book has a very cohesive organization which allows easy comhistorical facts, their interconnection, and explanation. The prehension of the book is divided into seven chapters, followed by two appendices, and three very Each chapter covers a segment of time, and the titles of the chapters highlight the most influential landmark of that era: a grammar (e.g. Kellogg's grammar of 1876), an issue (e.g., the Hindi-Urdu style controversy triggered by the British government's decision in 1837 to shift from Persian to Urdu as oficial language for tax and revenue offices), or an event (e.g. the world-wide rise of vernaculars in the late 18th and early 19th century). The chapters are further divided into sections which include description, and evaluation of particular grammatical texts, i.e., problems, significance, and accomplishments of the texts in the context of the development of the tradition, as well as general features of the tradition during that particular period. The major advantage of this organization is that it allows a clear identification of the characuseful indices. each of the periods, their influence on the following period, and their impact on and conthbution to the tradition as a whole. teristics of The book incorporates analysis and evaluation of three types of grammars grammars, (b) comparative and historical grammars, and (c) modern linguistic grammars. Thus it examines the tradition through diverse frameworks and approaches which have led to the emergence of different perspectives on and insights into the analysis of the Hindi language. Also, the text presents a comprehensive evaluation of grammars at various linguistic levels, such as phonetics, phonology, syntax, semantics, and pragmatics. on Khan bolf, \he standard variety of Hindi: (a) traditional The scope of the study extends far beyond a simple chronological documentation of the facts through the history of the Hindi grammatical tradition. It explains the nature and direction of the growth of the tradition in the context of the sociolinguistic factors (e.g. sociopolitical contexts, attitudes of the grammarians, etc.) which have been influential in shaping the form and determining the direction of the growth of the tradition. Hence the text is extremely useful for understanding the causes behind particular developments in the tradition at various points in time. The methodological framework adopted, blending historical and thematic approaches, is well suited for a survey of this depth and magnitude. The major advantage of this method is that it presents description, analysis, and interpretation of grammatical trends through different periods of time without neglecting the contributions of individual marians or without glossing over their shortcomings. grammars and gram- Bhatia rightly describes the beginning of the Hindi grammatical tradition as a tradition which ran parallel to the establishment of European/British colonial trade centers in India as well as to the influx of Christian an 'alien tradition' — Pandharipande: Review of Bhatia The earliest period (1698-1770) of this tradivacuum in the country, created by the lack of Mughal rulers. This situation was largely res- missionaries tion was a 175 in the 17th century. time of general political and strength of the last ponsible for the fact that traditional indigenous scholarship had reached a moribund state. Not surprisingly thus, the grammars written in this period were all will second-language grammars (written mostly by administrators and Christian missionaries) based on a religious-colonial model of language and designed to give their European readers a taste of the exotic languages (similar to the exotic spices) of India. The outcome of the attempts of this period to write a grammar of 'Hindustani' was crude and unsophisticated in terms of thematic content and linguistic analysis. Grammars understandably focussed on learning isolated words, sentences, and expressions so that the users would be able to survive in India without too grammarians much difficuty. Also, the motivation of early Christian mission- Benjamin Schultz for writing his Grammatica Hindostanica (1744) was that 'learning of the language and scripts of "uneducated or illiterate" people was essential for instructing them in their native way to impart knowledge' (50). This was definitely the predominant attitude of the grammarians of that period. These works 'exihibit notable deficiencies in the area of phonetics, phonology (except Beliagatti's), and syntax (except Schultz's), morphology receives only a minimal amount of attention ...' (60), and suffer from 'errors in the recording and analysis of data, especially the wrong analysis stemming from the wrong segmentation of linguistic units' (63-64). There might therefore be some truth to the judgement of the native traditional grammarians that 'It is a shame to call them grammars and an insult to call their creators grammarians' (64). But do agree with Bhatia that in spite of all their shortcomings, these early authors must be credited for having 'initiated a tradition' ary like I when there was none indigenously available. A grammar of HIndoostani language by John B. Gilchrist (1796) marks the Gilchrist was the first successful grammarian who succeeded in describing the basic form and function of the three vexatious and often-mentioned grammatical constructions the causative, the compound verb, and the passive. Bhatia correctly comments that 'Gilchrist did not set out to find the linguistic mirror image of Latin or English in the (Hindi) language' (87). John Shakespeare's A grammar of Hindustani marks the end of the middle period. early middle period of the tradition. — The grammars of this period, in general, were notable for having system- incorporated a description of the hitherto ignored Devanagari script in the phonetic component, and the inclusion of 'indeclinables' as one of the parts of speech in the syntactic component of the language. During this period and later on as well, morphology too became 'an imperative topic for a grammar text' (93). As Bhatia points out (94-95), the inadequacies of the grammars in this period were the result of the reliance of the grammarians on English which atically they used as a model for their description of Hindi. Moreover, their colonial prejudices colored their analysis of the data. Consider for instance '... the fol- 176 Studies in the Linguistic Sciences 19:1 (Spring 1989) lowing remarks by Gilchrist on the frequent use of cahiye (want or need): "the learners by this time will be able to account for the frequent introduction of cahiye the expression alluded to above, will also perceive how useful such must prove to the pompous and lazy Indians" (95). 'Further for in word as this ' used such labels as "beautiful" and "magnificient" and such terms as "defects", "deficiencies", and "wild".' (95) regularities they irregularities for the Bhatia presents a balanced view of the analysis of the grammarians by providing both positive as well as negative features of their treatment of the language. On the positive side, for example, Bhatia comments, 'they dismissed the popular misconception of their time that vernaculars do not have grammar and may even lack parts of speech such as verbs' (97). Bhatia sums up the achievement of this period by saying, 'Hindi grammar was able to attain descriptive and observational adequacy ...' (96). What Bhatia calls 'The eve of the Kellogg era' (1821-1875), can be labeled middle period of the tradition. This period saw the emergence of three distinct styles of Hindi, each modeled after the writing of particularly prominent Hindi literateurs the Perso-Arabic style used by Raja Shivprasad, the highly Sanskhtized one used by Raja Lakshman Singh, and the fheth as the late — (colloquial) titled used by Devakmandan Khatri. Another historical landmark of this the first grammar (1827) written in Hindi by a non-native speaker enHindi bhasa ka vyakarana. Pandit Shrilal's Bhasacandrodaya (1855) period is 'the begining of the participation of Indian scholars and introduced the indigenous (Sanskrit) paradigm into the study of Hindi grammar' (109). However, Raja Shivprasad's HindT vyakarana (1875) should be considered the most noteworthy attempt in that it tried to eliminate a widespread prejudice (in favor of writing separate grammars of Urdu and Hindi) by showing that 'it was possible to write a common grammar of both forms (i.e., Urdu and Hindi) ...' (120). Understandably enough, the first-language grammars during this period were marked whereas second-language grammars were more The major contribution of first-language grammars was speakers' intuitions, which made them recognize the largely theoretically oriented, pedogogically oriented. that they utilized native non-discreteness of linguistic categories and the differences in the judgements speakers regarding the acceptability and grammaticality of particular of native structures. In addition to English, a competing model of Sanskrit grammar was 'This led to new analytical, classificatory, and terminological innov- introduced. 'Grammarians such as Ethrington argued that Hindi does not innovations either on Arabic-Persian or on English has a rich lexical stock of its own and a prosperous inheritance from ations' (149). have to because rely for lexical it Sanskrit' (150). The period from 1876-1920, which Bhatia appropriately labels as 'The silThe Kellogg era', can be viewed as the pre-modern era since the ver age: . Pandharipande: Review of Bhatia 177 trends of the modern era (from 1920), began to be introduced during this period. The need for standardization of the language and the impact of the then dominant historical-comparative method placed several new demands on the grammars and the grammarians. They had to account for the 'actual colloquial and literary language of the Hindus of North India', 'as well as the nature and extent of dialect variation' (156). Although the Devanagari script regained its preferential status during this period, other scripts such as Kaithfwere accepted by the grammarians. It was in this period that all grammarians, both native and non-native, chose the term 'Hindi' to refer to the language under investigation. This era saw some new and significant insights in language analysis. The major insight was to recognize the interrelatedness of linguistic levels, i.e. the interaction of phonology and grammar (175). Similarly, a clear understanding In of the notion of complement {puraka), was developed during this era. general, the grammarians of this era treated language as a dynamic, not a static phenomenon. Therefore, the relevance of sociolinguistic factors, situational response, functional aspects, interaction among various levels of grammar, discourse-oriented facts, and dialectal differences for the grammar of the language was fully recognized (164-176). Several questions (which were to receive more attention in the modern period) were first raised in this era, such as the notion of primary and secondary subject, the accent system of Hindi, etc. The question of the necessity for assuming two levels of the language structure (i.e. surface and deep structures) was also hinted at in discussions related to the case markers 0, ne, and se The modern era (1920-), which Bhatia divides into two parts, traditional grammars, and linguistically oriented grammars, includes first- and secondlanguage grammars and shows a multifaceted development of the Hindi grammatical tradition. Among the first-language (traditional) grammars, the most prominent are Kamta Prasad Guru's HindFvyakarana (1920), Pandit Jangbahadur Mishra's Vakya vislesana (1930), Acarya Ram Chandra Varma's Acchf H/nc/r (1944), KishorFdas VajpeyPs Hindfsabdanusasana (1958), and Dimshitz's HindFvyakarana kfruparekha (1966). These grammars, mainly oriented towards describing and explaining the grammatical features of Hindi, focussed more on the analysis of the data than on worrying about their relevance for general linguistic theory. As a result, they provided a detailed account of the grammatical categories and constructions. Language-specific issues related to accent, relativization, sentence analysis, sentence transformation, postpositions, tense and aspect likewise received a great deal of attention in these grammars. Bhatia additionally provides an overview of second-language grammars in English (Scholberg 1940. Sharma 1958, McGregor 1972, etc.) and other languages. Modern linguistically oriented grammars in the last four decades have been most influential in shaping the Hindi grammatical tradition. These grammars, Bhatia notes, are primarily influenced by the structural and trans- 178 Studies in the Linguistic Sciences 19:1 (Spring 1989) formational-generative models. dependence on linguistic theory, for concepts The major feature of these grammars is their and there Is a predominant concern for Introspective data; how language and actully works, — competence and performance, for problematic linguistic linguistic universals, simplicity grammars and Naturally enough, evaluation, psychological reality, linguistic variation (119). have followed the lead provided by different theoretical Some of the prominent grammars of this period are by S. K. Verma (1961), who adopted the systemic model proposed by Halllday, Balachandran (1973) and Shapiro (1974), who modeled their studies on Fillmore's case grammar, and Srivastava (1969) and Sahai (1970) who used the structural model. Kachru's (1965 and 1966) work on Hindi grammar followed Chomsky's transformational-generative approach. Diverse models of analysis brought to light new insights: 'With modern linguistic studies the scope of Hindi grammar has been radically extended. In view of developments In every component of the language (phonetic, phonological, morphological, syntactic, and semantic), the tradition has experienced several turning points during the relatively short span of three decades. Because of the use of diverse models of analysis, Hindi grammar has become more sophisticated thoretically, more advanced methodologically, and deeper analytically* (203). However, Bhatia appropriately emphasizes 'that theoretical, methodological, and analytical developments in the West continue to dominate Hindi grammar studies' According to Bhatia, in spite of their commendable achievements, (203). modern linguistic studies on Hindi are largely 'in a highly scattered state' (208) of this period frameworks in linguistics. and need consolidation. He further points out 'duplication and imitation are on the increase. that in the present studies The psycholinguistic and semantic aspect of Hindi grammar is still neglected. ... the yearning for a Panini-type grammar continues to shatter the self-confidence of Hindi grammarians and linguists' (203). The text also traces the development Hindi through different periods of time, of a standardized writing system of and establishes a nature of the writing system and the purpose for which link between the was used. For as an 'Inventory of alphabets employed in five scripts identified as "devanagaram" (45). Mill's view of the script was that "... scripts such as "devanagaram" are employed by Brahmins as a secret code to gain social influence and intellectual supremacy over the masses. This correlation between written code and social power was so significant in Mill's view that he employed it further as a classificatory criterion to group Indian scripts example. Mill's grammar treated it it ' into the religious approach of using and secular alphabets' Roman (46). transcription for Hindi In contrast to this, Gilchrist's was guided by his conviction teach the language it was not necessary ... to teach its writing system.' Raja Shivprasad SItare Hind's use of Devanagari script for Hindi students and of Perso-Arabic script for Urdu students went a long way 'in alleviating the widespread misconception of the existence of separate grammars of Hindi and Urdu and in eliminating discrepancies between the language of the then current grammar texts and the actual language of the learners' (120). Kellogg's that 'to Pandharipande: Review of Bhatia 179 exclusive use of Devanagari script was prompted by his goal 'to present a complete account of the actual colloquial and literary language of the Hindus of North India' (156). The above brief summary of the contents of the text provides a glimpse of scope, nature, and treatment. The text is an impressively rich source of information on the contents of grammars in different periods and a critical analysis of the Hindi grammatical tradition during the last 300 years. its The major strength of the book is that it provides a much-needed model for presenting a survey of a grammatical tradition, tracing the major developments in the tradition without neglecting specific grammars and their contributions. Therefore, the book is extremely useful for scholars who intend to study the history of Hindi interested in grammars in general. the extent to which the treatment of issues the theoretical framework of the grammar. Another valuable feature grammars grammars and for those The book demonstrates clearly a grammar crucially depends on or to analyze particular the history of linguistics of the in book within their sociolinguistic context approach not ony provides an explanation is that and it examines and evaluates their specific orientation. for certain formal and This functional features of the grammars of a particular period, but also facilitates understanding of the overall changes and developments in the history of the grammatical tradtion. This makes the book extremely valuable for the study of the interaction/connection between linguistic form and its function in the society. in Finally, the book is useful for scholars of Hindi by making available to them usable form the insights of earlier research. Linguists at large, and scholars and students working on Hindi language and grammar in particular, are sure to find the book enormously informative and and delightfully easy to read. the Linguistic Sciences Studies in Volume 19, Number 1, Spring 1989 REVIEW ESP in the Dick Chamberlain and Robert Baumgardner (eds.)Practice and evaluation. ELT Documents: 128. Lonclassroom: Modern English Publications, in association with the British don: Council, 1988; pp. 1-165. Numa Markee (Division of English as an International Language) The book under review is a collection of selected papers originally presented at the International Conference on English for Specific Purposes (ESP) held in Colombo, Sri Lanka, April 1-5, 1985. It consists of fifteen articles arranged in five themes: Arthur C. Clarke, 'The role of English in the twenty-first 'ESP and non-native varieties of English: Towards a shift paradigm'; and AT. Dharmapriya, 'ESP in Sri Lanka: A perspective.' Viewpoints: century"; Braj Kachru, in Teacher and Learner: Peter Strevens, 'The learner and teacher of ESP'; Esther Ramani, 'Developing a course in research writing for advanced ESP learners'; and Dick Chamberlain, 'The teacher-centred learner.' Methodology: Thomas Huckin, 'Achieving professional communicative relevance in a "generalised" ESP classroom'; Tom Hutchinson, 'Making materials work in the ESP classroom'; and Alan Mountford, 'Factors influencing ESP materials production and use.' Evaluation and Administration: Charles Alderson, 'Testing and its adin ESP'; Ian Pearson, 'Tests as levers for change'; and Christine Tan, 'The organisation and administration of an ESP unit.' ministration Domestic aides in L. Cumaranatunge, 'An EOP case study: and Robert Baumgardner and Ray Tongue, 'The problems and the potential of exploiting the English language press as an aid to language Materials: West Asia'; teaching in South Asia." 182 Studies in the Linguistic Sciences 19:1 (Spring 1989) The volume is the sixth to be devoted to ESP-related concerns, which Some of the previous volumes have established themselves as landmark publications in the field. One of my personal favorites is Smythe 1980. The back cover of the present book hopefully proclaims that 'this will be an essential source book for the practice of ESP teaching.' Unfortunately, it is unlikely that this volume will follow in the footsteps of some of its predecessors, for at least three reasons. attests to the vitality of this sub-discipline of applied linguistics. First, the title is ambiguous if not actually misleading. When I first read it, I expected the collection to examine classroom practice and evaluation in ESP. But the Viewpoints and Evaluation and Administration themes include articles that discuss a variety of issues from perspectives that have little, and sometimes nothing, to do with classroom practice (see in particular the paper by Kachru). Second, the overall organization of the themes is haphazard. For example, what do evaluation and administration have to do with each other thematically? And third, some of the articles in the Methodology section (specifically, those by Hutchinson and Mountford) could fit equally happily in the Materials section, which would seem to imply that 'methodology' and 'materials' are in some way interchangeable terms. Clearly, this is not the case. This situation is unfortunate, because individually speaking, many of the here are genuinely interesting contributions to the field. For example, the Viewpoints theme contains a polemical piece by Kachru, the leading proponent of the post-imperial viability of English as an instrument of articles printed and intranational communication (see also Kachru 1983a, 1983b, 1985, and this volume). Writing essentially from the perspective of an ESP 'outsider', Kachru claims that '... the conceptual ... and applied research on ESP seems to have avoided addressing issues vital for understanding the uses of English across cultures' (10). Specifically, he points out two unwarranted presuppositions in Western-initiated ESP: First, that the producers of texts are inevitably Native Speakers (NS) and that the consumers are just as inevitably international Non-Native Speakers (NNS) typology of ESP contexts. of English, which results And second, he argues in a highly restricted assumption indic- that this NS attitudes toward institutionalized non-native varieties that are not only unacceptable to educated NNS of the language but which also signally fail to take into account the sociolinguistic realities that obtain as a result of the phenomenal spread and use of English world-wide. Kachru then argues for a change in paradigm which amounts to a call for greater NS cultural sensitivity in ates this regard. In the Teacher and Learner section, the paper by Ramani is a noteworthy example of the pedagogical application of the notion of a 'thick description' of language use (Geertz 1983). This work, which demonstrates the growing influence of genre analysis on specialist second language curriculum design and Implementation, is further developed in Ramani et al. 1989. The Methodology Markee: Review of Chamberlain & Baumgardner (eds.) 183 section also contains valuable contributions: Huckin's paper provides an ina 'wide-angle' approach to ESP and the concurrent use of team-teaching techniques. This paper therefore complements and develops the positions of writers such as Hutchinson and Waters (1980) and Dudley-Evans (1984) on these questions quite well. Moreover, the contribution by Mountford on the crucial role of constraints on syllabus design addresses an issue that has generated much controversy in the field (see Munby 1978, 1984; Swales 1980, 1989; Holliday & Cooke 1982; Crocker 1984; Hawkey 1984; Maley 1984; Markee 1986a, 1986b, 1989a, 1989b; and Kennedy 1988). Moving on to the Evaluation and Administration theme, the paper by Alderson is interesting not least because it contains the arresting claim that 'testing is far too important to be left to testers: it is the legitimate concern of all involved in language teaching' (87). The arguments offered in support of this claim are refreshing; but most important, they are credible because they are expressed by one of the leading lights in performance testing. Consequently, this paper can potentially do much to demystify an area of ESP and Communicative Language Teaching in general which all too often has been avoided by many practitioners because of its perceived arcane and difficult nature. And finally, the paper by Tan discusses in a straightforward fashion the rarelydiscussed subject of the importance of establishing a clearly defined professional identity for ESP units within the larger administrative ecology of academic institutions. In this regard, it is not generally recognized that the longterm maintenance of ESP programs (particularly aid-funded projects) often depends less on the technical qualities of teacher development or materials design programs than on the ESP unit having an administrative 'home'. Tan's teresting synthesis of contribution is arguments for therefore both appropriate and timely. To summarize, despite the undeniably high quality of individual papers, a lack of thematic focus. Judging from the introductory remarks, it seems that this problem afflicted the original conference also. We may guess that the organizers and sponsors of the event wished to attract as broad a spectrum of local practitioners as possible. However laudable the aim of ensuring access to a national conference by such participants might be, the end results indicate that the days of the blockbuster ESP conference that seeks to be all things to all people are numbered. After all, the field is now sufficiently established and diversified that conference organizers can afford to call for papers on relatively specialized sub-topics of ESP without running the risk of not receiving enough quality contributions. Moreover, more specialized conferences have the inherent advantage that it is comparatively easy to ensure strong thematic unity; and the desirability of selecting a strong, narrowly-focused theme becomes all the more important when selected papers from conference proceedings are to be published by a journal with an international readership such as ELT Documents. the main problem with this collection is 184 Studies in the Linguistic Sciences 19:1 (Spring 1989) REFERENCES Crocker, Anthony. 1984. Method as input and product of LSP course design. English for Specific Purposes in the Arab world, ed. by John Swales & Hassan Mustapha, 129-150. Birmingham: Language Studies Unit, Uni- Aston Birmingham. 1984. The team teaching of writing skills. Common ground: Shared interests in ESP and communication studies. ELT Documents 117, ed. by Ray Williams, John Swales, & John Kirkman, 127-134. versity of in Dudley-Evans, Tony. Oxford: Pergamon. Geertz, New York: 1983. Local knowledge. Clifford. Basic Books. Hawkey, Roger. 1984. From needs to materials via constraints: Some general considerations and Zimbabwean experience. Read 1984:79-87. HOLLIDAY, Adrian, and Terence Cooke. 1982. An ecological approach to ESP. Issues in ESP, Lancaster Practical Papers in English Language Education, ed. by Alan Waters, 124-143 Oxford: Pergamon. Hutchinson, Tom, and Alan Waters. 1980. Communication in the classroom: You just shove this little chappie in here like that. . technical Smythe 1980:1-12. Kachru, Braj. 1983(a). Models of new Englishes. Progress in language planJuan Cobarrubias & Joshua A. Fishman, 145-170. Berlin: ning, ed. by Mouton. Indianization of English: The English language in India. Oxford University Press. 1985. Standards, codification, and sociolinguistic realism: The English language in the outer circle. English in the world, ed. by Randolph Quirk & Henry Widdowson, 11-30. Cambridge: University Press. Kennedy, Chris. 1988. Evaluation of the management of change in ELT projects. Applied Linguistics 9:4.329-342. Maley, Alan. 1984. Constraints-based syllabuses. Read 1984:90-111. Markee, Numa. 1986 (a). The importance of sociopolitical factors to communicative course design. The ESP Journal 5:1.3-16. 1986 (b). Toward an appropriate technology model of communicative course design. English for Specific Purposes 5:2.161-172. 1989 (a). ESP within a new descriptive framework. World Englishes 8:2 1983 New (b). The Delhi: . (in press). 1989 (b). Aspects of the diffusion of communicative innovations: Toward an integrated perspective. 24th Annual Mid-America Linguistics Conference, October 7, 1989, University of Northern Iowa, Cedar Falls. MUNBY, John. 1978. Communicative syllabus design. Cambridge: University Press. 1984. Communicative syllabus design: 1984:55-67. Principles and problems. Read Markee: Review of Chamberlain & Baumgardner (eds.) 185 Ramani, Esther, T. Chacko, S.J. Singh, and Eric Glendinning. 1989. An ethnographic approach to syllabus design: A case study of the Indian Institute of Science, Bangalore. The ESP Journal 7:2.81-90. 1984. Trends in language syllabus design. Singapore: SEAMEO-RELC. Read, John. Smythe, Elisabeth. 1980. ELT Documents Special: Anthology series Projects London: The British Council. Swales, John. 1980. The educational environment and in 13. materials de- sign. its relevance to ESP programme design. 1989. Smythe 1980:61-70. Service English in program design and opportunity second language curriculum, ed. by Keith Johnson, 79-90. University Press. cost. The Cambridge: the Linguistic Sciences Studies in Volume 19, Number 1, Spring 1989 REVIEW A^tadhyayf of Paoini. (Texas University of Texas Press, 1987; pp. Sumitra M. Katre. Austin: ries.) Linguistic Se1330. (xlvi), Ladislav Zgusta was the first European scholar to provide an edition of Grammar: His 'Astakam Paninfyam' was published in two volumes in Bonn, 1839; 1840; the second volume has the title 'Panini's acht Bucher grammatischer Regeln.' The first volume contains the text of Panini's sutras, with an indigenous Indian commentary in Sanskrit. The second volume contains Bohtlingk's own German commentary to the single sutras, an index of Otto Bbhtlingk Panini's II I the grammatical terms, an alphabetical index of the sutras, and the Ganapatha, is, an index of words treated by the sutras. Apart from this, the second volume also contains Bohtlingk's Preface that is still of value, because surveys the problems connected with Panini's biography, with his predecessors, with what is called the 'Nebenuberlieferung' in German (= 'secondary tradition'), and many other topics. This edition was reprinted in 1983 in Osnabnjck (Germany). that it Bbhtlingk edited the 1887. seems (This finished the first to Grammar once more, have been first as 'Panini's Grammatik', Leipzig operandi; Thus, having modus version of his dictionary, he started at the and produced another dictionary of the his general Grammar has a in several volumes.) different preface (more restricted in edition, but largely dealing with different subjects). new letter a once more This one-volume edition scope than that of the The most innovative in the fact that for each sutra Bbhtlingk offers and his commentary, a different one from that of the first edition. Given the compact character of Panini's text, the translations necessarily are of an interpretive character. The commentary mostly offers examples of forms derived by the respective sutra and cross-references to other sutras. The indigenous Indian commentary is left out, but there is an alphabetic index of the sutras, the Dhatupatha (that is, the list of roots treated in the sutras). the Ganapatha (an explanatory index of the grammatical terms), and other indexes of all words occurring in Panini's text and in the Ganapatha. As in the first edition, not only the text, but also all the Sanskrit forms quoted in the comment- feature of the his German edition consists translation 188 Studies in the Linguistic Sciences 19:1 (Spring 1989) and elsewhere are printed in the NagarF script. This 1964 in Hildesheim (Germany). ary edition was reprinted in The next edition, the 'Ashtadhyayi of Panini' was prepared by an Indian Chandra Vasu. was published in 1891 and reprinted in 1962 in Delhi. The important feature of this edition consists in the fact that Panini's text is offered in its continuous form governed by the rules of sandhi, and in the Padapatha, that is, as a sequence of the sutra's single words given in their prepausal forms and with the compounds dissolved. Thus, sutra 1.1.3 reads in the scholar, It continuous text: iko gunavrddhr, in the Padapatha: ikah guna-vrddhf (vrddhih, gunah). There follows an indigenous Indian commentary (a different one from that offered in the first edition by Bohtlingk), the author's English translation, and The translation is again interpretative and in some points his commentary. seems to be inspired by that of Bohtlingk, which is only natural. However, sometimes Vasu achieves a much higher clarity than Bohtlingk, because he puts in more interpretation. Let us compare sutra 1 .1 .3: iko gunavrddhr. Wenn Guna und Vrddhi vorgeschrieben werden, so ist implidamit gesagt, dass sie an die Stelle von u, r oder/und deren Bohtlingk: cite /', Langen treten. [= 'When guna and vrddhi are prescribed, that they are inserted instead of /, u, it is implied ror /and their long counterparts.'] In the absence of any special rule, whenever guna or vrddhi is enjoined about any expression by using the term guna or vrddhi, it is to be understood to come in the room of the ik vowels only (/, u, r, and / long and short), of that expression. Vasu: On the other hand, Vasu's commentary is written in English, but in the indigenous scholarship and using the traditional terms. For tradition of the commentary to sutra 1.1.3 says: 'This is a paribhasha sutra ...', using a traditional term of Sanskrit linguistics for explanatory elements. Of course, all Sanskrit forms are written in the Nagarl script. There follow alphabetical indexes of the sutras, of the roots, and indexes of cross-references to other Sanskrit grammatical works, such as the SiddhantakaumudF. instance, the The then doyen of French Sanskritists, Louis Renou, published his transas 'La grammaire de Panini' in three fascicles, Paris 1948, 1951, 1954. There is only a translation (no original text), and Renou's commentary. The translation excels in indicating in parentheses the exegetical additions and lation cross-references to other sutras. Thus, sutra 1 .1 .3 is translated: Le guna (2) et la vrddhi (1) (lorsqu'ils sont enseignes nommement, mais sans qu'il soit specifie de quoi lis sont les substituts, doivent etre compris comme substituts) des phonemes '/ ... k (= u, r, / brefs et longs). [= 'The guna (2) and the vrddhi (1) (when they are explicitly prescribed, but without specification of what they are substitutes for, should be understood as substitutes) of the phonemes '/ ... k {= u, r, / short and ' /, ' long).'] i, Zgusta: Review of Katre No doubt this was in its time the clearest who are not Sanskritists: Everything is guists 189 translation, written also for given in Roman lin- transliteration, Paninian technicalities are interpreted (e.g., ik= i ... k= u, r, /), etc. However, is no Dhatupatha nor any other index. A new edition of Renou's work was published in two volumes in Paris, 1966, in which the text of the sutras was i, there inserted, It in transliteration.'' is, then, a major event in Paninian scholarship that a new edition of the M. Katre, Astadhyayrof Panini (Texas Lin- Grammar has appeared: Sumitra Texas Press, 1987 (xlvi + 1330 pages). The given in Roman transliteration only (there is no Nagarf in the whole book). This is a decision that must be welcomed, because it will allow linguists who are not Sanskritists to get some immediate experience with the original text. Also, the transliteration is in a one-to-one correlation to the NagarF, so there is no ambiguity about the original form. Only guistic Series), Austin, University of edition contains, first, the text. It is so to speak, 'semi-continuous' form of the text is given; there is no Padacall the form in which the text is given 'semi-continuous', because the greatest difficulties of the truly continuous text are removed: Where possible, space between words is added; the single members of compounds are divided by hyphens; and sandhi that makes understanding difficult is dissolved by double hyphens. For instance, sutra 1.1.3 reads: iKo guna-vrd-dht. (Compare the citations above of the uninterpreted continuous form and of the Padapatha.) Sutra 1.1.39 reads in the uninterpreted continuous text krnmejantah, the Padapatha reads krt, ma-ej-antah (whose compound could be resolved into ma, ec, antah). Katre's edition reads kri=m=eC=antah, in Katre's translation '[(The t[echnical] t[erm]) avyaya denotes 37] expressions derived with krt [3.1.93], affixes (ending in 1.1.72) -m or ^-eC (= e, o, ai, au).' This example further shows that Katre introduces yet another interpretative element into his text of the sutras: He prints the so-called 'sigia', i.e., the abstract, formulaic elements of a, patha. I ** in capitals: eC is to be and what stands in the Pratyaharasutras (that precede, in the Grammar, the main body of the rules) between e and C, that is, e, o, ai. au'. Similarly, iK\s what stands between /and K, that is, There is no doubt u, r, that is this use of capitals for the sigIa that gives Katre's text its clarity and 'analyzability' even for a non-Sanskhtist. Panini's metalanguage (or language of description), understood as 'e /, /. it — each sutra follows Katre's translation as we have seen, a laudably one and his commentary, undoubtedly the best in existence, with its rich examples, cross-references, and derivations completed. For instance, 1.1.45 reads in the continuous text igyanah samprasaranam, in the Padapatha ik, yanah, samprasaranam; Katre's edition gives the text, translation and commentary as follows: After interpretative — 1.1.45 iK=yaNah samprasaranam (The t[echnical] t[erm]) samprasarana 'vocalization' denotes the vowel (replacing the semithe siglum) iK (= i, u, r. vowels comprised by the siglum) yaN (= y, v, r, I) (respectively 1.3.10). phonemes (comprised by 190 Studies in the Linguistic Sciences 19:1 (Spring 1989) 1. yaj+Kta = iaj+Kta (6.1.15) = ij+Kta (6.1.108) = is+Kta = is-ta- 'spok[sic]. Similarly vac + Kta = uk-ta 'spoken, uttered'. en, uttered' There follows a highly useful enumeration technical term samprasarana occurs. of the other sutras in which the The preceding example shows yet another, highly efficient, interpretative convention introduced by Katre: the underlining of irrelevant, inapplicable vowels. Panini's siglum yan (there are no capitals in Nagari), refers to a sequence of phonemes starting with y and extending to n. The fact that instead of yn the form of the siglum is yan is caused by the syllabic character of Nagarf and by the attempt to make the form pronounceable. (The sutras traditionally were to be memorized and recited, or quoted, by heart.) When Katre, then, writes y^N, he successfully conveys to the reader that y is an element of the language under description, N an artificial but meaningful element of the language of description, whereas a is a merely formal element of the language of description. Another important feature of the edition consists in the fact that the text indicates the accents according to Panini's rules of accentuation. cents are omitted the Grammar.) in all earlier editions, as well as in (These ac- the traditional recitation of an enormous amount of work and of scholarship went into the As is natural in a human work, there are some minor blemishes. Firstly, the number of misprints is somewhat higher than one would expect in such a 'work for centuries to come', fvlost of them may be easy to perceive and correct. For instance, in 1.1.36, for upasamvyaayoh of the text, read "vyanayoh, and for upasamyana in the translation, read upasamvyana. Clearly, preparation of this edition. On the other hand, the non-Sanskritist commentary may not necessarily perceive that the above) should be 'worshipped, consecrated', or the like; the gloss 'spoken, uttered' is obviously a typist's slip, a transfer from the gloss of the following ukta. translation of ista in the Another source uncertainty in of to 1.1.45 (see uneasiness consists the dissolving of compounds: without hyphens, but it appears in In in 1 .1 the fact that there .45 samprasiranam 3.3.72 as sam-pra-siranam. I is is some printed prefer the first The dissolving of compounds has only the purpose of making Panini's should stop at the boundaries of accepted terms. text more intelligible, so Katre's thought on this issue seems to have evolved, because his Preface is even more radical, in this respect: Morphemic cuts are indicated not only in form: it Sanskrit contexts (e.g., tri-muni vy-a-kar-ana-m 'grammar according to the three in English sentences (e.g., 'full implication of each su-tra', p. sages'), but also However, there is no particular harm in this. In any case, if we consider, example, sutra 1 .1 .3 (cf. above): iKo guna-vrd-dhC it is obvious that the two hyphens have different values, the first dividing constituent lexemic parts of the compound {guna and vrddhi), the second, bound morphemes. For underxlvi). for standing the sutra, only the first cut is relevant. Review of Katre Zgusta: 191 Perhaps a greater difficulty obtains in a certain vacillation in the use of the symbols - and =. One sometimes suspects the possibility of a misprint. Consider for instance, 1.1.39 krt=m=eC=antah. The sutra deals with expressions that are derived with krt (as defined class of sounds designated by in -eC sutra 3.1 .93), with the affix "-m, or with the au). "-m is, then, clearly an (i.e., e, o, ai, language under description, of natural Sanskrit. The double suggests, however, that a sandhi-form was dissolved here: Therefore, should there not be krt=m-eC=antah for the reading krnmejantah of the continuous text, just as we read 1.1.47 M-IT=aCah=antyat parah for the reading midaco 'ntyatparah of the continuous text? it would be wrong to suppose a dissolution of a form with a merely formal element ma (as above, in yaN) because this would give a sandhi form krnmaljantah. The sandhi of the continuous text, "meC" shows that we are dealing with "m only. (Cf. the similar case on p. xlv, paragraph 3: pari-bhasa=s; probably for pari-bhasa-s?) element of the hyphen m= , Generally speaking, the non-Sanskritist will certainly experience some attempting to restore the continuous text from the semi-continuous one. A sandhi such as 1.1.46 ady-antau is perfectly clear, but compare 1.1.39 and 1.1.47 just quoted above or 1.1.48 eCa iK=hrasva=adese for the continuous eca igghrasvadese. However, why should non-Sanskritists indulge in such attempts? They will be overwhelmingly thankful for Katre's interpreted text, because while not giving all the sandhi-forms of the continuous text, nor all the pre-pausal forms as in the Padapatha, it is vastly superior to the former by its analyticity and to the latter in respect to the use of the capitals and the difficulty in underiined lower case letters may in the sigla. As a mirror image to this, the trad- continuous text with its Padapatha, the inclusion of which would transform the semi-continuous text into the first component of the exegesis. However, this edition is intended above all for the non-Sanskritist, who is better served this way. itional Sanskritist regret the absence of the real must be stressed, however, that the superiority of this edition consists and above all, in the translations and commentaries, in which all the elliptic material is filled in, all the cross-references are indicated, and all the It also, derivations performed, step by step. 3.2.83 atma-man-e [The krt For instance: KHaS=ca 1.1 Ninj 78] as well as (ca) KHaS are introduced the verbal stem 1.91 man- 82, co-occurring with a nominal pada the object of the verbal stem is oneself (atma-mane). 1.93 affixes [after 1.2 4] when darsaniyam atmanam man-ya-te = darsanrya+0Uman+Kha^/Nini = darsanfya-muM+man + SyaN+a- = darsanfya-m-man-ya (3.1.69; 6.3.67) / The commentary darsanfya-man-in- 'considering one's also indicates the scope of the rule the following example: self and as good-looking'. of the sigla. Compare 192 Studies in the Linguistic Sciences 19:1 (Spring 1989) 1.1.47 M-IT=aCah=antyat parah (An increment) marked with M as IT is inserted after the (aC) of the expression to which it is added. = ru-na-dh- = ru-na-dh 1. rudh+SnaM 2. Increments with marker yIT. yasiil, (3.1.78) T last (antya) vowel (8.4.2) 'obstruct, hinder*. iT. H". namuT. tuT. dhuJ, nuT, syaT; increments with marker K are: aT, aj. yij, yiiJ, ruJ, sfyiiT, suT. aduK, asuK, anuK, ithuK, kuK, juK.tuK tithuK, tuK, thuK, duK, puK, muK, yaK, yuK, riK, riK, ruK, luK, vuK, suK, saK; increments with marker M are: aM, iM, uM, nuM, puM, raM, 6naM. are: niK, nuK, The strength of the exegetical component of the commentary can be exemplified by: 1.4.103 sUpah 101] of the affixes denoted by the siglum sUP [ = sU au Jas, Sas, Ta bhyam bhis, Nie bhyam bhyas, Nasi bhyam bhyas, Nas OS am, Ni os suP 4.1.2 taken one by one have the t[echnical] t[erms] ekavacana, dvivacana and bahuvacana to denote them 102 respect- [The triplets am auT ively]. 1. 2. 3. 4. ekavacana: sU, am, Ja, Ne, Nasi, Nas, and Ni. dvivacana: au, auj, bhyam, bhyam, bhyam, os, and os. bahuvacana: Jas, ^as, bhis, bhyas, bhyas, am and suP. These seven triplets of sUP have respectively been given the t[echnical] t[erms] prathama 'first' (nominative), dvitfya 'second' (accusative), trtiya pancamt 'fifth' 'third' (ablative), 'seventh' (locative) cases (instrumental), caturtht 'fourth' (dative), sasthT 'sixth' (genitive) and saptamf 104 below]. [vibhakti In addition to the edition itself, there is a Preface which introduces the reader to the technicalities of Indian grammar and systematically develops the picture of Sanskrit morphology as given by Panini. The body of the sutras is followed by appendices: an 'alphabetic index of sutras', the Dhatupatha, an alphabetic index of verbal stems, the verbal stems listed by their meanings, the verbal stems with specific markers [such as, e.g., IT] indicated in the sutras and the Ganapatha. All of these increase the value of the edition and make it more usable. Professor Katre is a scholar of many merits and achievements, of which being the founder and intellectual engineer of the 'Sanskrit Dictionary on Historical Principles' a project that is developing into the Sanskrit counterpart of the Oxford English Dictionary is hardly the smallest; and what he had done for Indian lexicography in that dictionary he has now done for Indian indigenous linguistics in this edition of the Grammar. — — Zgusta: Review of Katre 193 NOTE i|t will be useful to mention at this juncture the following book, the first of a planned series of eight volumes: George Cardona, Panini: His work and its traditions, volume Background and introduction. Delhi/Varanasi/Patna/Bangalore/Madras: Motilal Banarsidass, 1988. The series is not planned to be an edition of the AstadhyayF, but all the sutras will be discussed, and the commentary will be indispensable to any student of Panini. I: Spring 1974 Papers in General Linguistics $3.00 Spring 1975 Papers in General Linguistics $3.00 Spring 1977 Papers in General Linguistics $3.50 Papers in General Linguistics $5.00 Papers in General Linguistics $5.00 Papers in General Linguistics $5.00 Papers in General Linguistics $5.00 Fall 1977 Spring 1978 Fall 1978 Spring 1979 Fall 1979 Relational Grammar and (Editor: Jerry L. Spring Fall 1 980 1980 Semantics $5.00 Morgan) Papers in General Linguistics $5.00 Studies in Arabic Linguistics $5.00 (Editor: Michael J. Kenstowicz) Vol. Studies in Tlie Lin II 410 s-rx St92 19:2 FALL 1990 COPY 2 TO UNGUJSTIC THEORY v Preface Introduction Part vii Keynote Address I: G. N. CLEMENTS: African linguistics and its contributions to linguistic theory Part II: Syntax EDMOND BELOa: G. & 3 Ideophones Tuki gaps: Null resumptive pronouns or variables? TUCKER CHILDS: Where do . 43 . ideophones come from? Harriet Ottenheimer & Heather Primrose: Current 55 research 77 on Shinzwani ideophones Part III: Phonology & Tonology Laura J. Downing: Tone in Jita questions Larry M. HYM AN: Accent Claude Timmons in Bantu: An & Christian Dunt^: 91 115 appraisal La selection morphophonologique des classes en kpokolo Part IV: Lexicography Mohammed all Robert BOTNT: in Trends in & 135 Historical Linguistics Oromo lexicon and lexicography Bantu 1 Cynthia ROBB ClamonS: in the Part V: 155 Reconstruction of a grammaticalized auxiliary Wollegan dialect of Appendices 69 Modification of the gender system Oromo to the 187 Proceedings A. History of the Annual Conference on African Linguistics B. Research and Publications in African Linguistics Alumni,andFaculty of the University of Illinois, by Students, 1980-1990 199 203 Department of Linguistics University of Illinois STUDIES IN THE LINGUISTIC SCIENCES PUBLICATION OF THE DEPARTMENT OF LINGUISTICS COLLEGE OF LIBERAL ARTS AND SCIENCES UNIVERSITY OF ILLINOIS AT URBANA-CHAMPAIBN EDITOR: Hans Henrich Hock EDITORIAL BOARD: Eyamba G. Bokamba, Chin-chuan Cheng, Georgia M. Green, Erhard W. Hinrichs, Hans Henrich Hock, Braj B. Kachru, Yamuna Kachru, Michael J. Kenstowicz, Chin-W. Kim, Charles W. Kisseberth, Howard Maclay, Jerry L. Morgan, Rajeshwari Pandharipande, and Ladislav Zgusta. AIM: SLS is intended as a forum for the presentation of the latest original research by the faculty and especially students of the Department of Linguistics, University of Illinois, Urbana-Champaign. Invited papers by scholars not associated with the University of Illinois will also be included. SPECIAL ISSUES: Since its restricted, specialized topics. inception SLS has devoted one issue each year to special issues is given on the A complete list of such back cover. BOOKS FOR REVIEW: Review copies of books may be Editor, Studies in the Linguistics Sciences, of Illinois, 707 S. Mathews, Urbana, SUBSCRIPTION: There sent to the General Department of Linguistics, University Illinois 60801. two issues during the academic year. Requests SLS Subscriptions, Department of Linguistics, 4088 Foreign Languages Building, 707 S. Mathews, University of will be for subscriptions should be addressed to Illinois, Urbana, UPCOMING Illinois ISSUES: 60801. Vol. 20:1 — "African Linguistics, 11"; "Special Anniversary Issue". Price: $7.50 (per issue) Vol. 20:2 — STUDIES IN THE LINGUISTIC SCIENCES The Contribution of African Linguistics TO Linguistic Theory Proceedings of the 20th Annual Conference on African Linguistics Vol. I EDITOR Eyamba G. Bokamba ASSOCIATE EDITORS Rick Treece Dorothy E. Evans VOLUME 19, FALL NUMBER 2 1989 LINGUISTICS, UNIVERSITY OF ILLINOIS URBANA, ILLINOIS 61801 DEPARTMENT OF 5 CONTENTS Preface v Introduction Part I: vii Keynote Address G. N. CLEMENTS: African linguistics and Part II: EDMOND G. its 3 contributions to linguistic theory Syntax & Ideophones 43 BiLOA: Juki gaps: Null resumptive pronouns or variables? Tucker Childs: Where do ideophones come from? 55 Harriet Ottenheimer & heather Primrose: Current research on ShiNzwani ideophones Part III: 77 Phonology & Tonology Laura J. downing: Tone in Jita Larry M. Hyman: Accent in 91 questions Bantu: An appraisal Claude Timmons & Christian Dunn: La selection 1 1 morphophonologique 135 des classes en kpokolo Part IV: Lexicography & Historical Linguistics Mohammed Ali: Trends Robert Botne: Reconstruction of a grammaticalized auxiliary in Oromo lexicon Cynthia Robb Clamons: Modification in the Wollegan dialect of Oromo Part V: Appendices to the and lexicography of the in Bantu 1 55 1 69 1 87 gender system Proceedings A. History of the Annual Conference on African Linguistics 199 B. Research and Publications in African Linguistics by Students, Alumni, and Faculty of the University of Illinois. 1980-1990 203 Preface It is with considerable pleasure that we publish these proceedings of the 20th Annual Conference on African Linguistics (hereafter 20th ACAL) held at the University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign, April 19-22, 1989. This conference marked not only the twentieth anniversary of ACAL meetings in North America, but also a major phase in the evolution of our field internationally. The conference was attended by over 250 registered participants and included some 200 presentations in several sub-fields of linguistics. The papers were various recent and current theoretical frameworks, reflecting the and increased level of theoretical sophistication of Africanist linguists. What was particularly heart-warming was the proportionately high number of graduate student presentations. presented in diversity of interests In order to expedite the publication of the proceedings of the 20th ACAL, it was decided at the conference business meeting that selected papers be published in two issues of the Studies in the Linguistic Sciences (SLS). Accordingly, SLS 19.2 and 20.1 were specifically earmarked for the proceedings. Following established SLS editorial policy, all the studies included in these two issues were vetted by at least two faculty members selected from a number of universities in the United States. Their anonymous comments were reviewed by the editors and passed on to the authors concerned. The editors relied heavily on the opinions of these reviewers in accepting or rejecting the papers submitted for consideration. While this review procedure offered needed quality control, it also delayed the publication by a few months. The results have justified the wait, however, and we are happy to offer our readers the first volume of these proceedings which contains an excellent and very stimulating selection of the studies presented at the 20th ACAL. We would like to take this opportunity to express our gratitude to the following scholars for reviewing the papers submitted for consideration for this volume: V. Bergvall, E.G. Bokamba, C.C. Cheng, G. T. Childs, D. Dwyer, A. FolarinSchecler, M. Goodman, G. Gragg, G. Green, H. H. Hock, J. Hualde, J. Hutchison, L.M. Hyman, A. Kimenyi, L. Moshi, Paul Newman, D. Nurse, D. Odden, W. Samarin, and L. Zgusta. The constructive criticisms of these scholars have improved tremendously the quality of the studies included in this issue. We also owe a debt of gratitude to the African Studies Center( Michigan State University, East Lansing), the Center for African Studies (University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign), the Department of Linguistics (UIUC), the Miller Endowment Fund (of the Center for Advanced Study, UIUC), the College of Studies in the Linguistic Sciences 19:2 (Fall 1989) vi Liberal Arts Office of the Vice-Chancellor for Academic Student Organization and the African and AfricaAssociation (UIUC) for their financial and material support of & Sciences (UIUC), the Affairs (UIUC), the African Related Women the conference. of the conference itself would have been less successful without the effort of a number of local staff and students who served on the organizing and planning committees. Our special thanks are extended to Issam Abu-Salim (then Visiting Scholar from the University of Jordan), B. Creek, A. Diop, L Downing, A. Dunn, E. Hsiao, B. Khoali, A. Kishe, S. Lilanda, P. Lindell, S. Lo, S. Mmusi, M. Ngame, M. Ourso. D. Roth, C. Saldeen, Y. Scheven, E. Sutton, and S. Swisher. The following linguists from this and other universities who were indirectly involved in the planning committee by serving The planning and operation as colloquia and workshops organizers or as special project reporters (e.g., the history of ACAL) also deserve our special thanks: M. L Bender (SIU), V. Carstens (Cornell), G. T. Childs (Temple), D. Dwyer (MSU), C. W. Kisseberth (UIUC), S. A. Mchombo (UC-Berkeley), M. Mishra (UIUC), S. S. Mufwene (U of Georgia), R. Schaefer (SIU), R. Schuh (UCLA), and C. Myers-Scotton (U. of South Carolina). Their contribution in these tasks enhanced tremendously the quality of the scholarly debates that occurred during the conference. am deeply indebted to As the conference chair and proceedings' editor, Dorothy E. Evans and Rick E. Treece who served, respectively, as my Secretary and Vice-Chair for the conference and as associate editors for these proceedings. Their hard work, efficiency, and willingness to work long hours beyond the call of duty, and to achieve the best results possible contributed to what many participants characterized as 'resounding success.' Without their assistance, the conference would have been less successful and would have I I had a nervous breakdown; and without their continued assistance in editing the proceedings, this publication would not have been possible. Naturally all three of us derived considerable pleasure in the success of the conference and were gratified by the unsolicited commendation letters that many of you wrote. We sincerely hope that each of you will find these proceedings equally stimulating and informative. Urbana, April Illinois 1990 Eyamba G. Bol<amba Editor INTRODUCTION Eyamba University of G. Illinois at Bokamba Urbana-Champaign The field of African linguistics has experienced tremendous growth and evolution world-wide since the introduction in the mid-1960s of 'classical generative grammar' as characterized by Chomsky's (1965) Aspects of the Theory of Syntax and Chomsky and Halle's (1968) The Sound Pattern of English. Since that time the field has gone through a number of developmental phases that may be placed on a continuum of 'largely descriptive' at one end to 'highly theoretical' on the other end. For instance, studies published in most of the African linguistic journals (e.g., African Language Studies, Africana Linguistica, African Language Review, Journal of African Languages, Journal of The English Language in West Linguistics in Sub-Saharan the mid-1970s were largely descriptive. West African Languages ) and anthologies Africa ^\97^, Current Trends in Linguistics, Africa 1971) from the mid-1960s until (e.g., vol. 7: The few theoretical studies that appeared during this period (1965-1975), mainly article-length works and doctoral dissertations, were largely applicative in the sense that they applied the classical generative grammar approach to the analysis of African languages. There was very little theory construction based on African languages. Two of the few exceptions to this observation were William Leben's M.I.T. dissertation, Suprasegmental Phonology {^973), and Larry M. Hyman and Russell Schuh's (1974) article on 'Universals of tone rules: Evidence from West Africa' (in Linguistic Inquiry), in which new and insightful of analyzing tone phenomena are suggested and their implications for general phonology are persuasively discussed. ways As moved on from the mid-1970s to the late 1970s, became increasingly theoretical and innovative in their Here again, the field of phonology led the way in terms of major African linguistics Africanist linguists research. break-throughs in analytical insights and theory-construction. By building on the insights provided in Leben (1973), for example, John Goldsmith (1976, MIT thesis) developed the theory of autosegmental phonology for the analysis of tonal phenomena based on African language data. George N. Clements, in a series of papers (1976, 1977, 1981) extended autosegmental theory to the analysis of vowel harmony in African languages. Michael Kenstowicz and Charles W. Kisseberth's books on phonology. Topics in Phonological Theory (1977) and Generative Phonology (1979), which are commonly used as textbooks in phonology courses in the United States, popularized further African language data. Studies in the Linguistic Sciences 19:2 (Fall 1989) Developments in syntax and sociolinguistics (including pidgin/creole studies) during this period have been less dramatic in terms of theoryconstruction, but nonetheless significant insofar as application and critical assessment of non-African based theories are concerned. For example, the study of logophoric pronouns, grammatical relations (especially 'terms' in Relational Grammar), grammatical agreement, and Wh-question formation in African languages contributed important insights to the debates that shaped RG (Relational Grammar) and EST (Extended Standard Theory) in the 1970s (cf. Bokamba 1976, R. Epee 1976, Givon 1976, Gary and Keenan 1977, Kisseberth The bulk of the studies in and Abasheikh 1977, Kimenyi 1980, etc.). sociolinguistics during this period was primarily descriptive and devoted primarily to practical aspects of multilingualism such as language policy/planning, language variation, and discussion of salient structural aspects of pidgin and Creole languages (see Bokamba's paper in vol. 20.1 for a detailed discussion). The contribution of African linguistics to general linguistic theory in the 1970s, enhanced particularly by the establishment of three additional major journals devoted entirely to the study of African languages i.e.. Studies in African Linguistics (1970, UCLA), Journal of African Languages and Linguistics (1979, University of Leiden, The Netherlands), and Sprache und Geschichte in Afril<a (1979, University of Cologne)— enabled the field to emerge from its The convening of the Annual 'exotic' status to that of semi-respectability. — Conference on African Linguistics (ACAL), which began in 1970 at this by steadily drawing nonAfricanist scholars into the meetings as the conference moved from one university to another in North America. university, further increased the visibility of the field is that by the mid-1980s African as a respectable field in which language data and theoretical development impacted strongly on the constnjction of various theories of linguistics. By the late 1980s African linguistics had become a mainstream sub-field as continued to influence theoretical developments in phonology (e.g., 'CV phonology, autosegmental phonology, metrical phonology), syntax (Government and Binding, Lexical-Functional Grammar, and Generalized Phrase Structure Grammar), and sociolinguistics (especially code-switching, language variation, and creolistics). The impact of African languages on general syntactic studies in the last six years is amply illustrated by the work of scholars such as Marantz (1984), Baker (1985), Bresnan and Mchombo (1987), Bresnan and Moshi (1988), Kidima (1987), and the steadily increasing number of dissertations on African languages that apply contemporary theories such as GB and LFG: e.g., Harford-Perez (1985), The linguistics net result of these developments began to establish itself it Bergvall (1987), Machobane (1989), Culy (1989). Introduction The studies included in these two volumes, representing a cross-section of the papers delivered at the 20th Annual Conference on African Linguistics held from 19-22 April, 1989, exemplify both the progress made in the study of African languages per se and the mainstreaming of the field. As the title of the proceedings indicates, African linguistics has evolved to an extent that we are able to assess its 'contribution to (general) linguistic theory' and attempt to ascertain the direction for future developments. Yes, African linguistics is today a field to be reckoned with: it can no longer be ignored as an 'exotic' area. The contribution of an Afrocentric perspective, to use Clements' (in this volume) terminology, on the construction of a general theory of language will counter-balance the long-held Eurocentric approach to linguistic theory and will eventually lead to the emergence of a broadly-based theory. If the growth in descriptive and theoretical research exemplified by the work undertaken in the last decade is sustained, the potential for future growth is even greater and its this University impact will be considerable. Unlike in our regular SLS issues where papers alphabetically according to author, the ten studies in this are arranged issue are grouped by African linguistics, is The keynote address, which reviews progress in presented in Part I, and is followed by papers on syntax and ideophones (Part II), phonology and tonology (Part III), and lexicography and historical linguistics (Part IV). Part V includes two important documents that were prepared for and distributed at the conference. The organization of the papers in the issue was The largely dictated by the revised studies we received by the deadline. second issue of the proceedings (SLS 20.1) will contain the plenary session papers and several other studies that were read in the colloquia and plenary sessions. We hope the readers will find the studies here both stimulating and topic. challenging. REFERENCES 1985. Incorporation: A theory of grammatical function C. changing. Ph.D dissertation, MIT, Cambridge. [Subsequently published by the University of Chicago Press under the same title, 1988.] BARRETT-KEACH, Camille N. 1980. The syntax and interpretation of the Ph.D. dissertation, University of relative clause construction in Swahili. Massachusetts, Amherst. BERGVALL, Victoria. 1987. Focus in Kikuyu and universal grammar. Ph.D. BAKER, Mark dissertation. Harvard University, Cambridge. 1976. Question formation in some Bantu languages. Ph.D. dissertation, Indiana University, Bloomington. BRESNAN, Joan, and Sam Mchombo. 1987. Topic, pronoun, and agreement in Chichewa. Language 63:741-82. BOKAMBA, Eyamba G. Studies in the Linguistic Sciences 19:2 (Fall 1989) BRESNAN, 1989. Locative inversion in Joan, and Jonni M. Kanerva. A case study in factorization in grammar. Linguistic Inquiry Cinichewa: 20:1.1-50. BRESNAN, Joan, and Lioba Moshi. 1990. Object asymmetries In comparative Bantu syntax. Linguistic Inquiry 21 :2. 147-86. CHOMSKY, Noam. 1965. Aspects of the theory of syntax. Cambridge: MIT Press. and Morris MIT Press. , CLEMENTS, G. N. Halle. 1976. 1968. The sound Vowel harmony in Cambridge: pattern of English. nonlinear generative phonology. Distributed by Indiana University Linguistics Clubs (1980). Bloomington, Indiana. 1977. The autosegmental treatment of vowel harmony. Phonologica 1976, ed. by W. U. Dressier and E. Pfeiffer. Harvard 1981. Akan vowel harmony: A nonlinear analysis. Studies in Phonology, vol. 2, ed. by G. N. Clements. CULY, Christopher D. 1990. Syntax and semantics of internally headed . I. . relative clauses. Ph.D. dissertation, Stanford University. syntactic studies in Duala. Ph.D. dissertation, EPEE, Roger. 1976. Generative Cornell University, Ithaca. GARY, Judith O. and Edward Keenan. 1977. On collapsing grammatical grammar. Syntax and Semantics 8: Grammatical by Peter Cole and Jerrold M. Sadock. New York: Academic relations in universal relations, ed. Press GIVON, Talmy. 1976. Topic, pronoun and grammatical agreement. Subject by Charles N. Li. New York: Academic Press. GOLDSMITH, John. 1976. Autosegmental phonology. Ph.D. dissertation, MIT. [Subsequently distributed by Indiana University Linguistics Club, 1979.] HARFORD-PEREZ, Carolyn. 1985. Aspects of complementation in three Bantu languages. Ph.D. dissertation. University of Wisconsin, Madison. HYMAN, Larry M. and Russell Schuh. 1974. Universals of tone rules: and topic, ed. Evidence from West Africa. Linguistic Inquiry 5:1 .81 -1 Michael and Charles W. Kisseberth. KENSTOWICZ, 1 6. 1977. phonological theory. New York: Academic Press. 1979. Generative phonology: Descripiton.and theory. . Topics New in York: Academic Press. KIDIMA, Lukowa. 1987. Object agreement and topicality hierarchies in Kiyaka. Studies in African Linguistics 18:2.175-209. KIMENYI, Alexandre. 1980. A relational grammar of Kinyanwanda. Berkeley: University of California Press. KISSEBERTH, Charles W. and Mohammed I. Abasheikh. 1977. The object relation in Chi-Mwi:ni, a Relational Grammar, ed. Bantu language. Syntax and Semantics 8: New York: by P. Cole and J. Saddock. Academic Press. LEBEN. William R. 1973. Suprasegmental phonology. Ph.D. Cambridge, MA. dissertation, MIT., Introduction MACHOBANE, 1989. 'Malillo. morphemes. Ph.D. MARANTZ, Alec P. Some on the SeSotho transitivizing Quebec. grammatical relations. Cambridge: restrictions dissertation, McGill University; Montreal, On 1984. the nature of MIT Press. SEBEOK, Thomas in A., ed. Sub-Saharan SPENCER, John, ed. Longmans. 1971. Current trends in linguistics, vol. 7: The Hague: Mouton. 1971. The English language Linguistics Africa. in West Africa. London: I Keynote Address G. N. African Linguistics & its Clements Contributions to Linguistic Theory Studies in Volume 19, the Linguistic Sciences Number AND ITS 2, Fall 1989 AFRICAN LINGUISTICS CONTRIBUTIONS TO LINGUISTIC THEORY G. N. Clements Comell University & Universite de Paris 7 This paper examines trends in the field of African linguistics in the U.S. from its beginnings in the 1930s to the present, with a special focus on its more recent contributions to linguistic theory. Section 1 reviews some of the special circumstances that have given African linguistics on this continent its special character. Section 2 provides some background on its origins and early development, and section 3 gives an overview of the political and institutional context underlying the growth period of the 1960s and 1970s. Section 4 examines some of the contributions of African linguistics to contemporary linguistic theory, focusing on developments in phonology and syntax over the past twenty years. Section 5 offers some concluding remarks. "African facts often constitute a challenge to theories elaborated by Western 1 . scientists in a Western setting" - J. H. Greenberg, 1962 African Linguistics in the U.S. This paper examines trends in the field of African linguistics in the U.S. from its beginnings in the 1930s to the present, with a special focus on its more recent contributions to linguistic theory. This introductory section considers some of the special circumstances that have given African linguistics on this The two following sections provide some continent its special character. background on its origins and early development, and give an overview of the political and institutional context underlying the growth period of the 1960s and 1970s. Following this, a major section examines some of the contributions of 4 Studies in the Linguistic Sciences 19:2 (Fall 1989) African linguistics to contemporary linguistic theory, focusing on developments in phonology and syntax over the past ten concluding remarks. to twenty years. A final section offers some The goals paper are limited. First of all, it concerns African the U.S., with only occasional reference to research elsewhere. This is not out of a failure to recognize the important contributions of African linguists working in Europe and Africa (and more recently in Canada), but rather in response to the need to document the development of African linguistics in this country, which has so far not been the subject of systematic study. 1 It attempts to show how African linguistic studies first developed out of the activity of a few pioneering scholars beginning in the 1930s and 1940s, and picked up momentum in the late 1950s and 1960s in the context of a national drive to establish programs of language instruction and scholarship in Africa and other non-Western cultural areas. A second limitation of this study is that it does not attempt to review recent developments in comparative and historical linguistics; it thus omits mention of much important work that has advanced our knowledge of particular linguistic units, such as Chadic and Bantu. This choice is due in part to the fact that an adequate synthesis of work in this area would go well beyond the scope of a study of this size, requiring the evaluation of an aggregate of work done not only by American scholars but also by the European and African scholars with whom they have closely collaborated in many instances.2 But it is also due to my desire to focus on what consider to be the most original aspect of the recent U.S. contribution to African linguistics, and the one that has received the greatest attention in conference papers, theses and journal articles over the past twenty years: namely, the discovery of the contribution that African languages have to make to our understanding of general linguistics and the theory of universal grammar. language study of this in I There is perhaps one feature, more than any other, that has marked African linguistics on this continent since its beginnings some fifty years ago. have not been just Africanists—they have been linguists, with a broad training in fields such as historical, anthropological and theoretical linguistics. This fact has contributed much to the particular force and originality of African linguistics in this country from its beginnings up to the present. Africanists have first absorbed the lessons of successful work in other fields of linguistics, and then gone on to develop methods appropriate to the particular nature of African language study. And today, just as ten, twenty or thirty years ago, most of the original and influential contributors to African linguistics in the U.S. have a broad-based training In anthropological or theoretical linguists, and include general linguists who have chosen to devote much or most of their time Africanists here to the study of African languages. What is most specific to these last twenty years, at least on this continent, has been the increasing interpenetration of African linguistics with general and theoretical linguistics. Indeed, much current research on African languages is Clements: African linguistics & its contributions to linguistic theory 5 being done by linguists who would not define themselves as primarily Africanist in orientation. Why should this be so? To answer this question, we must consider the place of African linguistics in the larger context of linguistics as a whole. In the earlier part of this century, most linguists were primarily concerned with the goals of grammatical description and historical reconstruction. Many Africanists today are carrying on these traditions, and are continuing to make substantial contributions to these areas. However, the most novel and original enterprise of the field of linguistics in the second half of this century, and the one which most characterizes work in the U.S. as opposed to elsewhere, has been the search for an empirically-based theory of universal grammar. While many linguists inspired by this program have been content to concentrate on the relatively well-studied languages of Western Europe, many others have been drawn to the study of less familiar languages, especially those of non- Western cultures and civilizations. ^ Not surprisingly, African languages have to receive a large share of attention, due both to the variety of their grammatical structures and to the relative feasibility of research on African languages as compared with the languages of many other parts of the world. The emergence of this new research enterprise, more than any other single reason, explains the great expansion of interest in African languages and linguistics in this country over the past thirty years, especially in the areas most closely related to the study of grammar. come In parallel to this increase of interest in more theoretical issues, there has been a shift in the profile of American-based Africanists with respect to their European- or African-based colleagues. In the earlier tradition of Africanist research, which arose out of the activities of explorers, missionaries, and colonial administrators, European Africanists travelled to Africa to carry out field research, stayed for extended periods of time, usually learned the languages they were studying, and often concerned themselves with aspects of African history, society and culture. In parallel to this, African-born Africanists have generally concerned themselves with the languages they know from long per- sonal experience. have this kind of a lower level of national commitment to African studies has meant that government support for field research has not been widely available, so that relatively few Americans have been able to afford to travel to Africa with any regularity. Second, and connected with this, the near-total lack of institutional support for full-time Africanists in American universities has discouraged many linguists from involving themselves with any single African language or language group in much depth; this contrasts with the situation in Europe, where highly specialized, full-time Third, theoretical Africanists have received a larger amount of support. linguistics has inherited the prestige once enjoyed by historical, comparative and descriptive linguistics in this country, and few linguists are immune to the special appeal of directing their research toward current theoretical questions to In contrast, not background today, many American-trained for at least four reasons. Africanists First, 6 Studies in the Linguistic Sciences 19:2 (Fall 1989) which African languages so often have a good deal to say. Fourth, African nations have been sending students to America and Europe for their higher education in larger and larger numbers, and many Africans have settled in Europe or the U.S. on a more or less permanent basis. As a result, it has become increasingly possible for U.S. -based linguists to work with African language consultants without leaving their home universities, often over long periods of time. This proximity has established a new relationship between linguists and their languages. Linguists working on their home campus have no opportunity to immerse themselves in the language and culture in the way that is only possible through an extended stay in the area where the language is spoken. But on the other hand, the convenience of working on campus has led to a closer dialogue with linguistic theory, since study of theory and particular languages can be conducted at the same time and in the same place. '^ The proximity of linguists and Africans on campuses and in the larger cities has favored new methods of research which are especially appropriate to the study of grammatical and phonological structure, as opposed to many other areas. These differences in background, motivation and geographical circumstance have contributed to the particular character of African linguistics in this country. 2. Origins American European counterparts, were slow American scholarship in the humanities and social sciences up to World War was predominantly concerned with American and Western European issues, and linguistics was no exception. Very little research on African languages was published until after the war.5 But there is an important exception to this statement. African linguistics got off to a promising start when an African-American scholar, Mark Hanna Watkins, defended his thesis A Grammar of Chichewa: a Bantu Lar)guage of Britist) Central Africa at the University of Chicago in 1933. This descriptive grammar, later published by the Linguistic Society of America in its Language Dissertations series, is written to a high standard which was not equalled in this country for many years to come. Carried out within the framework of the (at that time novel) model of structural linguistics, and inspired by Sapir's organic conception of grammar, it reveals familiarity with recent developments in comparative Bantu studies outside the U.S., and pays close attention to many specific aspects of Bantu structure including the morphophonemics of tone. linguists, in contrast to their to discover the linguistic interest of African languages. II grammar already shows many came to characterize the future, such as the adoption of a current theoretical framework, close attention to argumentation, and data collection by means of interactive work with a linguistic consultant.^ Watkins went on to a career as Professor of Anthropology at Fisk University and later Howard University, where he directed the African Language and Area Center from 1959 to 1965. He maintained an active interest in African languages and linguistics to the end of his life in the 1970s, when as one of his last works, he published a descriptive study of Yoruba phonology (Watkins 1972).^ Watkins' American scholarship in features which African linguistics in 8 Clements: African linguistics & its contributions to linguistic theory African linguistics received a new impetus in this country after the war in the work of Joseph H. Greenberg. Greenberg's approach and research goals reflect the broad concerns of the first-generation structural and anthropological linguists in this country, many of whom were his teachers: Greenberg attended the linguistic seminars of Boas as an undergraduate at Columbia, and studied with Sapir, Bloomfield, Bloch and others at Yale both before and after completing his doctoral thesis at Northwestern. Greenberg's work in African linguistics was principally inspired by the belief that language provides one of the fundamental bases for the reconstruction of human history. His major was his thoroughgoing new system of African language (Greenberg 1963), a work whose major outlines are accepted by the great majority of Africanists today, and which is notable for its method of mass comparison and its careful refutation of many long-standing dogmas. A later article (1972) offers persuasive linguistic arguments placing the original homeland of the Bantu people in what is now southeastern Nigeria, and remains a model of the use of linguistic evidence in the reconstruction of prehistory. Other major achievements include the reconstruction of Proto-Bantu tone (Greenberg 1948), and an influential theory of the historical origin of noun class and gender markers (Greenberg 1978). A vigorous proponent of the development of linguistic research in Africa through the collaboration of American, European and African scholars, Greenberg was a pioneer in developing the infrastructure for Africanist research in West Africa through his active roles in the Language Survey of West Africa and the Linguistic Society of contribution to this area classification West Africa. A further major postwar figure in African linguistics was William E. Welmers, who pioneered in the application of structural linguistics to a great variety of African languages. Like Greenberg, Welmers was well trained in general linguistic theory due to his studies with Zellig Harris at the University of Pennsylvania. An early publication on Fante vowel harmony, coauthored with Harris (Harris and Welmers 1942), was one of the first studies in this country or elsewhere to develop an explicit suprasegmental model for the treatment of prosodic phenomena. His research ranged over all areas of grammar, including studies of the phonology, morphology, and syntax of Kpelle, but he is perhaps best known for his pioneering work in the description of tonal schemata, downstep, tonal morphemes and floating tones (see, e.g., Welmers 1959). Welmers was actively concerned with African language teaching, and was instrumental in setting up the program of African language instruction at UCLA, which became a major center of African linguistics beginning in the late 1960s. Welmers' achievements are summarized in his African Linguistic Stnjctures of 1973, an encyclopedic introduction to the linguistic analysis of African languages. Although dominated by the work of Greenberg and Welmers, African linin the 1940s, 1950s and 1960s saw important contributions by a guistics 8 Studies in the Linguistic Sciences 19:2 (Fall 1989) number Carleton Hodge pioneered in the study of Hausa pedagogical materials and a Hausa Grammar Lorenzo Dow Turner initiated the study of African influences on (1947). English-based New World Creole languages, providing a convincing demonstration of African lexical retentions in his classic Africanisms in tfie Gullati Dialect (1949).9 Wolf Leslau, based at UCLA from 1955 onward, established modern Ethiopic comparative and lexicological studies with many major contributions continuing up to the present, including his comprehensive Etymological Dictionary of Garage (1979). The Ghanaian linguist Gilbert Ansre made a of other scholars. linguistics, contributing articles, significant contribution to phonological analysis with his Hartford Seminary Foundation M.A. thesis The Tonal Structure of Ewe (1961), one of the first insightful studies of tonal analysis produced in this country. In the area of phonetics, Peter Ladefoged's classic study of the phonetics of West African languages (1968) unveiled the articulatory mechanisms of a wide variety of speech sounds rarely found, or completely unknown outside Africa. Major syntactic studies of this period included several works on Hausa syntax and grammar by Charles Kraft, and Alfons Loogman's Swatiili Grammar and Syntax (1965), one of the most thorough descriptions of the syntax of an African language written in the U.S. (or elsewhere) up to that time. Kay Williamson's grammar of jjp (1965), based on her 1963 Yale doctoral dissertation, is one of the first full-scale applications of transformational grammar to a non-Western language. A full account of this period would go well beyond the scope of the present study, and would include the work of a great many other scholars in addition to those named. ""O 3. The Creation of an Institutional Base New fields of study do not emerge out of a vacuum, but respond to specific research needs and social conditions. While the work of individual scholars laid the basis for African linguistics in the U.S., the great increase of interest in this field beginning in the late 1950s and 1960s forms part of a more general awakening of American scholarship to the languages and cultures of nonWestern peoples. World War II brought a dramatic demonstration of the inadequacy of American scholarship in foreign languages and cultures outside the Americas and Western Europe. In response to the widely-perceived need for scholars with a command of the languages, culture and society of particular Western and non-Western countries, a number of crash training programs were set up on campuses to produce what were called 'language and area specialists.' One of these programs was organized by the American Council of Learned Societies under a grant from the Rockefeller Foundation. This program, the ILP (Intensive Language Program), conducted wartime language courses in 26 languages at 18 universities, published language guides and instructional material, and advised the government on language problems (Newmeyer 1 986). A militaryrun program, the ASTP (Army Specialized Training Program), taught modern Clements: African linguistics & its contributions to linguistic theory 9 languages on 55 American campuses; between June 1943 and December 1945, over 16,000 members of the armed forces had been trained in a language and area program under this program, with 60% of the training foreign consisting of intensive language instruction {Mijhler 1983). When was terminated Language Training took its place. The FSI's School of Languages became one of the major centers of language teaching and linguistic research in the U.S., generating instructional materials including some twenty complete courses with language tapes, which have been widely used in universities and governmental agencies. A number of Africanists, such as Program the ILP after the war, the of the Foreign Service Institute (FSI) James Redden, Earl Stevick, and Lloyd B. Swift, were involved in this effort, and produced oral-oriented teaching materials for languages in which adequate textbooks were lacking; many contemporary Africanists got their first taste of African languages through teaching materials of this sort. Although we can criticize the limitations of some of these materials, which were often produced under pressure of time and limited facilities, they filled the gap created by the virtual absence of adequate textbooks for the practical teaching of most African languages. '' The universities and the major private foundations (Carnegie, Ford, Rockefeller) provided further funding for the study of non-Western languages and cultures. In the case of the more widely spoken languages, programs set up during the war were simply continued, but with a research as well as pedagogical focus (Hall 1947). The first program in African studies was established in 1949 at Northwestern under a grant from the Carnegie Corporation. Boston University set up its African Studies Center in 1953, and Howard its African Studies and Research Program in 1954. For these reasons, viable prototypes of today's foreign language and area centers were already in place when Congress passed the National Defense Education Act (NDEA) in 1958, largely as a response to the launching of Sputnik the year before (McDonnell 1983, Lambert 1984). Its aim was 'to insure trained manpower of sufficient quality and quantity to meet the national defense needs of the United States' (McDonnell 1983:1), and its special target areas were science, mathematics, and modern foreign languages. This legislation, and the Higher Education Act (HEA) which later replaced it, provided the most durable, and almost the only federal support for adding an international component to the higher education system from that time up to the present. Title VI of the HEA set up National Resource Centers in foreign language and area studies on American campuses, supported the development of language teaching materials, and funded competitive graduate student fellowships (FLAS fellowships).'' 2 A specially-targeted section of the Fulbright-Hays Act supported some of the overseas activities of the faculty and students of the centers, and the NDEA Title IV program provided graduate fellowships until 1971. All of these programs included support for basic linguistic research. As Newmeyer 10 Studies in the Linguistic Sciences 19:2 (Fall 1989) book The Politics of Linguistics (1986), they made a major development of linguistics in this country in the postwar years; they were also the single major force in giving African language studies an institutional base In this country. New African studies programs, most of them funded under the NDEA or HEA, were set up at the University of Wisconsin in 1959, and at Michigan State, Indiana and UCLA in 1960, and many further programs were added in the course of the 1960s, 1970s and 1980s.i3 Even today, instruction in African languages other than Swahili and Hausa is almost entirely dependent on Title VI centers, and most U.S. research on African languages (as measured by Ph.D. theses and scholarly books and articles) has pointed out in his contribution to the comes out of Title VI centers."'^ A setback in institutional support for African studies came in 1967, when the Ford Foundation's International Training and Research Program came to an end. No federal funds were appropriated to take its place. In 1973, the Title VI program was cut back drastically, and the 107 centers (including 13 1972 were reduced to 46 the next year (Lambert 1984:136). Similarly, Title VI (FLAS) fellowships were reduced from a total of 214 for all areas of African studies in 1972 to just 85 in 1974 (McDonnell Nevertheless, even when federal support was withdrawn, most 1983:136). African studies programs continued to survive on the basis of internal university support. Government funding has recovered somewhat in recent years, and there were 93 Title VI centers overall in 1985, including 10 in African studies at itself African studies programs) funded about the same More in time. difficult to quantify, but nonetheless real as a factor in the growth of was the increased prominence of Africa in popular consciousness as a result of the emergence of the newly-independent African states, many of which were headed by outspoken advocates of an African studies in the U.S. in the 1960s, African perspective on world events and political organization. This trend coincided, in the United States, with the civil rights movement and the rise of black pride among African-Americans, accompanied by an increasing awareness of African history and African contributions to literature, the visual arts and music. In addition, many Peace Corps volunteers had the opportunity to experiat first hand during extended assignments in African countries. The study of African languages seemed to many to be an indispensable basis for achieving a deeper understanding of African culture and society. One sign of this is the fact that enrollment in Swahili language courses (the only African language offered for study at most American universities) swelled to unprecedented numbers toward the end of the 1960s and into the early 1970s. But enrollment in graduate programs in African linguistics also saw substantial ence Africa growth, as we shall now see. Perhaps the best quantitative Indicator linguistic research American universities.is is the of the long-term growth In African number of PhDs in African linguistics awarded by Table 1 shows all PhDs in African linguistics since the Clements: African linguistics & its contributions to linguistic theory 11 1930s, "IS grouped according to general topic area. Gross totals are given in the last column, and the mean number of theses per year (MPY) in the last column, for each period. (A complete listing of theses by year, author, language, topic, and awarding university is given in the Appendix.) next to Table 1 U.S. Ph.D. theses on African languages 1933-87, by general topic area (Source: Appendix). HI 1930s GR PH SY SO AP m TOTAL MPY 12 Studies in the Linguistic Sciences 19:2 (Fall 1989) and a corresponding general decline in descriptive grammars as opposed more detailed studies of phonology or syntax alone. "i^ A given further in Table measure of the 2, showing the institutional to development of African linguistics is American Ph.D. theses, classified distribution of by region. Table 2 U.S. Ph.D. theses on African languages 1933-1987, by geographical area of the awarding university. (Source: Appendix) East Coast 1930s Midwest West Coast South/Texas TOTAL Clements: African linguistics Finally, country and & its contributions to linguistic theory 13 a discussion of institutional support for African linguistics in this Africa cannot omit mention of the Summer Institute of Linguistics, in the linguistic arm the SIL and its of the Wycliffe Bible Translators. Since its beginnings in 1934, over 3000 members world-wide have published thousands of books, articles, and technical reports, including many on African languages since the initiation of SIL activities in Africa in 1962.20 its linguists (around 1400 strong) are active in over 20 countries, including 10 in Africa, although its major focus has been in Latin America, the Philippines, and Papua New Guinea. A staff of over 100 part- and full-time faculty members teaches courses at three summer schools in the U.S. and Canada, and during the academic year at the University of Texas at Ariington. As a teaching institute, its courses are "especially designed to give basic tools needed by those who are preparing to serve preliterate peoples through language tasks such as Bible translation or literacy work" (from the 1989-90 SIL Course Catalogue, p. 4). Viewed as a constituency in the field of African linguistics, it is clear that most SIL members have a different agenda from most university-centered linguists, and its political However, and social role in developing countries has been controversial.2i some SIL members have pursued advanced studies in linguistics outside SIL centers and published through normal scholarly channels, and have made a significant contribution to the descriptive, and at times theoretical literature. Table 3 African languages ranked according to teaching A. Number and research emphasis. of Ph.D. theses on particular African languages in U.S. univer1933-87. Only languages which have been the subject of five or more theses are shown. (Source: Appendix) sities, Swahili 14 Studies in the Linguistic Sciences 19:2 (Fall 1989) Zulu Lingala 5 5 C. Percent of a sample of 176 Africanists In all fields who have studied a given African language. Only languages studied by at least 5% of the sample are shown. (Source: McDonnell 1983) Swahili Clements: African linguistics & its contributions to linguistic theory 15 taken up the suggestion that logophoric structures may be found in languages outside Africa.23 The continuing study of African languages will not leave our models of universal grammar unchanged. Our way of viewing Western (and other non-African) languages will improve as African language structures become better understood and better integrated into our theories. This is not to say that we, as linguists, study African languages only in order to enrich our theories of language in general. Far from it - we also (and perhaps primarily) study African languages for their intrinsic interest, and as a tool for the understanding of African histor>', culture and literary expression. But in addition to this, the valid insights that African languages offer into the structure of universal grammar are also valid insights into African languages themselves, and thus genuine advances in linguistic theory also constitute advances in African linguistics. Newer models, developed in part through an attempt to handle African language phenomena, stimulate further research on African languages due to their greater explanatory power and closer fit to African language structures: witness, for example, the explosion of work on tonal systems since the mid-70s, and the more recent renewal of interest in African syntax, stimulated in part by the study of object relations and argument structure in Bantu languages. Reviewing the work of the past twenty years or so, one is impressed by the approach to African language study has led, overall, to a more expansive view of grammar. The overly simple and mechanical models of the early 1960s in which each component of the grammar was unrelated to others have been replaced by increasingly powerful models postulating richer systems of representation, a higher degree of interactivity among the various components of grammar, and (in some approaches) a greater interaction between grammar and discourse structure on the one hand, phonology and phonetics on the other - in short, to what we might call an open architecture, as opposed to the closed architecture of earlier models. We can see this most clearly if we examine the two areas in which African linguistic research has been most concentrated in recent years, and in which it has had the greatest impact on recent linguistic theory: phonology and syntax. fact that the Afrocentric Developments in Phonological Theory, The past twenty years have been witness to a radical restructuring of phonological theory, which is largely due to results coming from the study of African languages. Perhaps nowhere else have we so clearly seen a deliberate attempt to develop new, appropriate models for African phenomena. The successive frameworks of Williams (1976/1). Leben (1973) and Goldsmith (1976) show increasingly radical departures from the linear, phonemic view of phonological representation inherited from their immediate predecessors (Chomsky and Halle 1968), and have provided successively richer theories of phonological representation. In particular, autosegmental phonology as originally developed by John Goldsmith postulates that tones form a separate tier of phonological 4.1 16 Studies in the Linguistic Sciences 19:2 (Fall 1989) representation at all levels of representation, underlying and derived; thus tones are related to tone-bearing units not through inclusion in a common feature matrix, but through the looser relation of The success autosegmental association. these innovations can be measured in terms of the First, they have given us improved theories of tonal structure, in which tonal phenomena that had earlier required arbitrary descriptive devices are now seen to reflect general properties of autosegmental phonological representation. Second, they have proven to have a high predictive value when applied to previously unstudied (or poorly understood) tone languages, and for this very reason have stimulated an immense amount of new research, to such an extent that the tonal phonology of African languages may very possibly be better understood than their segmental phonology at the present time.^-* Third, the tonal model has been generalized and extended to a wide range of non-tonal phenomena in the languages of Africa and elsewhere. In one such development, models of vowel harmony In African languages have been integrated into more general theories of autosegmental representation, which are being redirected to African language phenomena in turn. 25 in a further development of the autosegmental model (sometimes called CV phonology), evidence in favor of an abstract level of segmental organization called the prosodic template or CV skeleton was first drawn from the study of Semitic word formation, and subsequently generalized to phonological phenomena in Chadic, Ethiopian Semitic, West African and Bantu languages, as well as many non-African languages. 26 As a result of such developments, the current, generalized model of nonlinear phonology now represents a new paradigm in phonological theory, differing more radically from the generative model of the 1960s than generative phonology did from its own predecessors.27 of considerations stated earlier. Perhaps less widely familiar, but equal in importance, is the revolution in phonological feature theory that is now taking place, inspired again by studies Beginning with Ladefoged's work on the of African phonological systems. speech sounds of gling to revise their West African languages (1964), linguists have been strugto account for such typically African speech sounds models as multiply articulated stops and clicks. Rather than considering these sounds as marginal and exotic, linguists have again applied the Afrocentric method, with surprising results. In an important paper of 1983, Halle points out that we can better understand the structure of multiply articulated stops (including clicks) if we consider the speech-producing mechanism as consisting of three independent articulators: the lips, the tip or blade of the tongue, and the back of the tongue, or dorsum. Each of these articulators is capable of acting alone to define a point of articulation, as in the sounds [p]. [t], and [k], but they can act in combination as well. Thus if we combine the lips and the tongue tip. we produce what are termed labiodental stops, such as have been supposed to exist in the Chadic language Margi.28 if we combine the lips and the dorsum, we get the labiovelar stops exemplified in the name of the Gbe language cluster Clements: African linguistics & its contributions to linguistic theory 17 we combine the tongue tip and the dorsum, we get the Khoisan languages, as well as neighboring Bantu languages such as Sotho, Xhosa and Zulu. This apparently simple observation has been extended to a wider range of African phenomena,29 and a fourth articulator, the tongue root, has been suggested to account for the pharyngealization characteristic of many North Caucasian, Semitic and Khoisan languages.30 The full consequences of these proposals cannot yet be fully assessed, but it is clear that they are leading to a profound reassessment of phonological feature theory, which promises to yield a feature system bearing little or no relation to those that were widely assumed in the 1960s and 1970s. of West Africa. And if clicks that are characteristic of the Other developments in phonology, though less dramatic or less crucially dependent on African data, deserve mention as well. Work on Chadic languages brought to light the importance of the distinction between heavy and light syllables in tonal phonology, and contributed to the renewal of interest in the syllable in the 1970S.3'' Theories of tonal downstep, first developed for African languages, have provided the basis for models of intonational structure in European languages, and are now being turned back onto African languages, for which studies of intonational structure are just beginning.32 These do not exhaust the areas in which African languages have had an active impact on current phonological theory, but they are enough to show that African languages continue to provide a rich field for research in phonological theory. 4.2 Developments in Syntactic Theory. The role of African languages in the development of syntax has been less dramatic, and seems only now to be starting to realize its vast potential. The first theoretically-oriented work tended to apply early models of transformational grammar in a mechanical fashion, was particularly An initial impulse for innovation came from the West Coast, where a number of linguists began applying "nonstandard" models of grammar to African data. The journal Studies in creating elaborate rule systems that rarely brought to light what characteristic of the languages under study. African Linguistics, created at UCLA in 1970 under the initial editorship of Talmy Givon, became a sounding board for many of these ideas. In his UCLA thesis Studies in Chibemba and Bantu Grammar of 1969,33 Givon first applied the model of generative semantics to Bantu morphology. Shortly afterward, however, he proposed a new research program which held that "in order to understand the current morphology and morphotactics of a language, one must construct highly specific hypotheses concerning the syntax of that language at some earlier historical stage of its development " (Givon 1971:145). This view proved influential, and resulted in a renewed interest in historical syntax and processes of morphologization, perhaps best exemplified in Greenberg's work on gender and noun class markers (cf. Greenberg 1976), as well as in many studies by Heine and his associates at the University of Cologne. Givon's evolving ideas eventually coalesced into a theory of functional syntax, which continued to draw on African language data (cf. Giv6n 1976, 1984), and stimulated much work by others. In particular, l_arry Hyman and his many students 18 Studies in the Linguistic Sciences 19:2 (Fall 1989) and collaborators developed the notion of thematic hierarchy (cf. Hyman & Duranti 1982), and brought to light the morphological importance of focus in Bantu languages (Hyman & Walters 1984). However, many linguists, especially on the East Coast, found this theoretical framework insufficiently well-defined and constrained in comparison to framework evolving from classical transformational-generative grammar taking place at that time, and its influence decreased as Chomsky's theory of Government and Binding (1981) began to attract the attention of an increasing number of syntacticians (see below). A further source of innovation in the African languages was 1970s that drew in large part on Grammar, initially developed by the theory of Relational Perlmutter and Postal. 3^* This theory, which holds that grammatical relations are primitive (undefined) concepts and seeks to develop universal laws stated in terms of them, immediately attracted the attention of Bantuists, who found it a framework for exploring the complex properties of objects in Bantu Representative works include Kisseberth and Abasheikh (1977) and many publications in the journal Studies in the Linguistic Sciences in the late 1970s and early 1980s, as well as Kimenyi's 1976 UCLA thesis, revised and published as A Relational Grammar of Kinyarwanda (1980). The results from Bantu ted to certain proposed modifications in the general theory, but their larger importance can be seen in the fact that the ability to handle Bantu object relations adequately is widely accepted as a condition of adequacy by most new theories of grammatical structure that have emerged in the last few years 35 useful languages. Inspired by the study of Bantu syntax and its interrelations with phonology, morphology and discourse structure, Bresnan, Mchombo and their collaborators have recently begun to develop an enriched version of Lexical Functional Grammar (LFG),36 which incorporates many earlier results from functional grammar and relational grammar and integrates them into a formal model designed to achieve a more highly integrated expression of the relations between syntax, phonology, morphology, and the lexicon. One of its goals is to achieve a more transparent account of syntactic variation across closely related lan- guages while correctly deriving crosslinguistic generalizations, recent work has been focused on the study of and much Bantu syntax.37 Finally, an increasing number of Africanists are working within the framework of Government and Binding (GB) syntax, an approach which reduces the emphasis on rules in favor of an enriched theory of representation and attempts to explain syntactic form in terms of general principles and parameters of universal grammar.38 Over the past few years a number of PhD theses have examined African syntax in this framework, and publications are starting to appear. In a particularly thorough study of the syntax of several Kru languages, for example, Koopman (1984) examines the striking patterns of verb movement in these languages and argues that they support an extension of general In spite of principles independently required to account for NP movement. Clements: African linguistics & its contributions to linguistic theory 19 recent increasing attention to African language data, however, it seems fair to GB theory, like most of the other theories mentioned above, has still not say that reflected the impact of results from the study of African languages to a significant degree. 33 Why should this be so? The answer sure to be complex, but two related is the long neglect of African languages in this country (combined with a neglect of other aspects of African culture, history and civilization), resulting in the presence of fewer well-trained linguists involved in the study and teaching of African syntax in American universities, fewer English-language descriptive materials, and consequently less opportunity for younger scholars to be trained in, or stimulated to carry out, syntactic research. While it is feasible for linguists to carry out phonological research on languages with which they are not acquainted at first hand provided that adequate descriptions are available, it is much more difficult to carry out syntactic research without at least a working knowledge of the language under study and ready access to native speakers.'^o The second is that phonology was able to seek an "African" model for a phenomenon that had no close counterpart in European languages: lexically significant tone. Existing models for tonal phonology, based on East Asian languages, were quickly found to be incapable of explaining many intricate properties of African tone systems such as tone spreading, contour tones, downstep, floating tones, tone melodies, tone stability, and so forth, and in order to achieve insightful descriptions of these complex phenomena, new concepts had to be developed. Since tonal phonology seemed to have no direct implications for the phonologies of the better-described European languages, phonologists were free to experiment with new models without having to defend their views against welldeveloped preexisting theories in this area.'^^ In contrast, adequate descriptions of African syntactic systems are much sparser at even the most unsophisticated level, valid crosslinguistic generalizations are harder to obtain, and it is more difficult to determine without prolonged first-hand study whether any given phenomenon can be accommodated within some version of existing theory. A cautious view, and one not completely unjustified, would be that the burden of proof falls upon the linguist to show that existing theory cannot be adjusted or modified in small ways to account for what at first appear to be factors deserve special mention. radically different The is first phenomena. One hopes, however, that these considerations will not discourage from developing new syntactic concepts on the basis of the study of African languages. If, as has often been claimed, the intensive study of English (or French) syntax is capable of revealing properties of universal grammar, the intensive study of Yoruba, Kanuri or Zulu can do the same. And only by taking the potential contribution of African languages seriously can we avoid the danger of skewing our theories of syntax toward languages which have a long It is literary tradition, and which for that reason, we happen to know best. sufficient to page through earlier volumes of African linguistics journals to find linguists 20 Studies in the Linguistic Sciences 19:2 (Fall 1989) any number which focus exclusively on African counterparts to English, while passing over interesting and potentially important syntactic phenomena which do not have obvious counterparts in Western literary languages. The better descriptive grammars (as well as surveys such as Welmers 1973)) already suggest that African languages offer a rich range of syntactic constructions which deserve closer study, and arguably provide an analogue to tonal phenomena in their potential interest for general syntactic theory. It seems quite possible that an effort to construct an Africaninspired model of such phenomena as serial verbs, predicate clefting, focus constructions, and relative tenses (to take just a few examples), taking into account both language-internal and crosslinguistic generalizations, will lead to similar advances in the study of phrase structure, anaphoric binding, discourserelated constraints, and models of tense and aspect, with beneficial consequences for syntactic theory as a whole.'*2 of articles syntactic constructions in We have so far considered phonology and syntax in isolation from the each other and from the rest of the grammar. African languages have contributed more than their share to the current development of "interface" models, that is, models of the way the various components of grammar interact For example, early generative theory had proposed that with each other. domains of phonological rule application are defined symmetrically, according to a hierarchy defined by the left and right edges of morphological and syntactic constituents (Chomsky and Halle 1968). Subsequent research on African languages, however, has shown that tone rules could apply asymmetrically in domains bounded by the left edges of phrasal constituents, but not by their right edges, and these results have been integrated into a generalized edge-based approach to syntactically-conditioned rules.^3 More recently, it has been suggested that phonological rules may have direct access to syntactic structure, without the mediacy of the boundary markers or prosodic structure provided by This hypothesis continues to be debated in the current earlier theories. literature, but newer evidence, coming once again from African languages, seems to argue in favor of some interpretation of this hypothesis.'*'* However this issue is eventually resolved, it is clear that African languages, with their rich systems of postlexical phonological rules, provide a particularly fertile testingground for theories of the syntax-phonology interface, and will continue to remain at the center of investigation New developments in in this area. theory, whether originally generated by the study of African languages or subsequently enhanced by them, have made contri- butions to areas outside the study of grammatical structure properly speaking. In the study of language acquisition, for example, we now have the tools to undertake the serious study of the acquisition of African syntax and phonology African languages have been brought to bear on the study (cf. Demuth 1989). of Creole languages, and a number of linguists have suggested that the African substratum has a larger bearing on the linguistic structure of African and New World pidgin and Creole languages than has been previously supposed.'*5 Clements: African linguistics & its contributions to linguistic theory 21 Theoretical advances have contributed to the development of African language teaching as well. If good theory lays the basis for good description, good description is the foundation for developing successful language teaching materials: it is no coincidence, for example, that Swahili is at present both the best described African language, and the one for which the most adequate pedagogical materials exist. '^ Africanists have also taken the lead in producing textbooks in phonological theory and African linguistics, which have made tne structure of African languages more widely known among linguists at large. 47 5. Further remarks The preceding discussion has argued that many aspects of the development of African linguistics in the U.S. reflect particular features of the geographFrom the time of Boas, ical and political context in which it has taken place. Sapir and Bloomfield onward, American linguistics has had a particular strength in descriptive and theoretical linguistics, and this emphasis is reflected in its more recent contributions to African linguistics. Independently of this, the relative predominance of descriptive and theoretical approaches over historical and anthropological ones has much to do with the relative difficulty which the American scholar finds in carrying out extensive research in Africa itself. Geographical distance and limited institutional support have made types of research that are dependent on sustained field work quite difficult for the American-based Africanist, but more practical for the European with easier access to Africa, and of course most practical for the Afhcan-based linguist. We may hope that with increasing consciousness in this country of the importance of basic research on and culture, the American contribution to African linguistics will grow in depth and broaden in scope, and researchers will develop increasing contacts with their colleagues abroad, in Europe and especially in Africa, as many have done on an individual basis already. African languages, history, The vast majority of African languages still do not have adequate descrip- here that work based on shorter periods of residence in Africa or work with language consultants in the U.S. will continue to be useful There is much need for basic descriptive work in phonology, at all levels. morphology, syntax and lexicon, which will be essential not only for theory but tions at any level, and it is also for our eventual understanding of the complex patterns of relations among African languages and to the eventual reconstruction of features of parent languages, and of aspects of African prehistory. should be emphasized that advances in theory require careful basic much as advances in historical and comparative work do. In tonal phonology, some of the major advances have been based on the study of published descriptions of such languages as Margi, Mende, Igbo, Kikuyu, Tonga, Zulu, and Luganda, all of which had already been extensively documented, and for which the descriptions are complete enough that one can test It description just as 22 Studies in the Linguistic Sciences 19:2 (Fall 1989) In other cases, linguists have based their work on extensive descriptive materials they have provided elsewhere.'*9 in the absence of a sufficient descriptive base of this sort, theoretical conclusions are necessarily highly tentative, since small samples of data can be used to support almost any novel theory, including many that are mutually incompatible. There Is no reason, however, why new theoretical insights cannot be based on full, adequate descriptions, especially in the case of languages that are still poorly documented. The investigator will have to take special care to provide enough data, organized in a structured way, that researchers working in any framework or tradition can make use of it, and if alternative theories against them.'^s theoretical necessary, reinterpret it in ways different from the way the original investigator Such descriptions will continue to be valuable sources even when the theoretical issues they address have been resolved (or forgotten). did. In sum, the field of African linguistics has seen a substantial growth over recent years, not only in terms of purely quantitative measures, but also in terms of its increasing contribution to the development of linguistic theory. One thing we have an Afrocentric approach to theory constructo a pluricentric approach, in which all linguistic zones play a proportionate role can prove fruitful, and may continue to lead to new and valid insights as our knowledge of the diversity of linguistic form becomes broader and deeper. tion learned, I believe, is that —which must eventually be generalized — Clements: African linguistics Appendix: & its 23 contributions to linguistic theory American Ph.D. Theses on African Languages and Linguistics (1933-1987) The following list includes Ph.D. theses on Niger-Kordofanian, NiloSaharan and Khoisan languages, and Afroasiatic languages and linguistics also except Egyptian, Coptic and Semitic (but including Ethiopian Semitic). includes theses on pidgins and Creoles spoken in Africa. It does not include theses on the topic of oral literature. Each thesis is assigned a major topic, e.g., syntax, descriptive grammar, orthography. In the case of theses with two or more topics, the 'major topic' is selected according to the principle by which the It general linguistic field outranks the grammatical subarea, e.g., histoncal phonology is classed as 'historical' rather than 'phonology', a sociolinguistic study of syntax is classified as 'sociolinguistics' rather than 'syntax', and so forth. AbbreviatI 24 AUTHOR Studies in the Linguistic Sciences 19:2 (Fall 1989) Clements: African linguistics BAUCOM & its contributions to linguistic theory 25 26 AUSTEN Studies in the Linguistic Sciences 19:2 (Fall 1989) Clements: African linguistics BOYS & its contributions to linguistic theory 27 28 BADER Studies in the Linguistic Sciences 19:2 (Fall 1989) Clements: African linguistics & its contributions to linguistic theory 29 ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS is a revised and expanded version of my keynote address 'Progress in the Study of African Languages: Research in the U.S. 1969-1988' read at the 20th Annual Conference of African Linguistics at the University of Illinois, UrbanaChampaign, April 19-22, 1989. In preparing this study have benefitted from correspondence with Eyamba Bokamba, Don Burquest, Katherine Demuth, Joseph Greenberg, Larry Hyman, Paul Newman, James Redden, Carol Rosen, Earl Stevick, and Laurie Tuller, and from discussion with Thilo Schadeberg. Needless to say, the opinions expressed in this paper as well as any errors of am indebted to fact or interpretation are entirely my own responsibility. Sylvestre Osagie for valuable research assistance, and to Russell Schuh for sending me portions of Schuh (1988) and the questionnaire responses on which that study is based. Presentation of this paper at the 20th ACAL was made possible by a grant from the George A. Miller Endowment Fund, Center would finally for Advanced Study, University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign. like to thank the Africana Studies and Research Center and the Department of This I I I Modern Languages and Linguistics, both of Cornell University, for providing research support. NOTES Greenberg (1965) and Cole (1971) give general overviews of the history have little to say about work carried out in the U.S. Schuh (1988) reviews the state of African language instruction over the past decade with an equal emphasis on the U.S. and Europe, and gives quantitative information on linguistic research as well. 1 of African linguistics to the mid-twentieth century, but general synthesis of comparative/historical work in African linscope, is provided by the many contributions to volume 7 of Current Trends in Linguistics (Sebeok 1971). A synthesis of recent research on the classification of Niger-Congo languages is provided in Bendor2 The last guistics, international in Samuel tics, (1989). See Bokamba (1989) another area which is for an overview of work in sociolinguis- not treated here. empirically-based theory of universal grammar, of course, is one that concerning the structure of individual languages, hence the importance of the study of a broad and diverse language use the term 'grammar' broadly to include phonology, morphology, base. 3 makes An verifiable or falsifiable predictions I syntax, semantics, and lexicon. Studies in the Linguistic Sciences 19:2 (Fall 1989) 30 4 Thus questions such as 'does language X have parasitic gaps?' can be answered at the next meeting with the consultant, or even by picking up the phone. The Linguistic Bibliography (Utrecht) lists a total of nine articles by area of 'Negro-African languages' during the period (The authors were 1 939-47, the first for which the bibliography was published. Joseph Greenberg, Zellig Harris, Carleton Hodge, and William Welmers.) 5 American 6 linguists in the Watklns' informant currently by his Christian was Kamuzu Banda, better known to the world surname Hastings, and as President of Malawi (southern Africa). 7 His last publication is Watklns (1978), published posthumously in 1976. Another pioneering figure of the 1930s was Ethel G. Aginsky, who wrote a Grammar of the Mende Language (1935) at Columbia University under the direction of Franz Boas. Aginsky's later career was devoted to the study of the Pomo Indian culture in Northern California, in collaboration with her husband; have been able to determine, she did not make any further as far as I contribution to African linguistics. 3 is to be hoped that a future edition of much-needed index of languages and topics, It allowing this work to realize its full potential this work listing will actual as a resource it with a page numbers, provide for Africanists. 9 Turner was later active in setting up the Peace Corps programs in Africa, and prepared pedagogical materials and texts for the study of Krio. See WadeLewis (1989) for a review of Turner's career. 0 See Schachter (1971) for a review of aspects of and elsewhere during the period 1945-1969. African linguistics in this country '' Beginning in the 1960s, the Peace Corps took an increasing role in course development and language training. The Peace Corps has reprinted some of the older FSI courses, and has funded the development and publication of new courses in recent years, the more recent of which have extensive cultural notes. According to the Rand survey mentioned in note 17, 26% of a sample of Africanists in all fields supported by Title VI FLAS fellowships during 1962-1979 received language instaiction during service with the Peace Corps. 12 FLAS fellowship support was one of the major sources of financial support for graduate students in African studies In the first two decades of the According to a 1983 Rand survey of 176 Africanists who Title VI program. received FLAS fellowships (or were nominated as alternates) between 1962 and 1979, and who went on to earn the PhD between 1967-1979, 14.8% (or about 26) were linguists (McDonnell 1983). These fellowships thus supported Clements: African linguistics about & its 20% linguistics 13 31 contributions to linguistic theory of the approximately 120 PhDs awarded by U.S.universities during these years. in tlie area of African See Duignan (1967) and Rana and Distefano (1987) for further information. ''* To my knowledge, only two programs in African linguistics currently have departmental status: the Department of African Languages and Literatures at the University of Wisconsin (Madison), established in 1964 with a strong specialty in the study of oral literatures, and the Department of African Languages and Literatures at the University of Florida (Gainesville), established in the 1970s. A number of further departments combine African Studies with Afro-American Studies, though few of them have special strength in the linguistic IS study of African languages. This is, of course, only one way of evaluating the of research in African linguistics in the U.S. growth and direction See Schuh (1988) for discussion of other measures, covering the period 1978-88. •6 Figures for some years, especially 1987, may be incomplete. Not all degrees to bibliographical sources such as universities report their higher have suppleDissertation Abstracts International. In preparing this table mented published sources from personal knowledge whenever possible. I •7 Students graduating in this year would correspond to those who entered Ph.D. programs when FLAS funding was at its peak, around 1970-2. •8 Not reflected in this table is the growth in production of African language teaching materials, which also increased substantially during this period. See Johnson (1976) for a bibliography of materials available in the mid-1970s. 9 An examination of Appendix A shows that this increase mostly involves universities with Title VI funding. 20 1979/85 21 See Brend and Pike 1977 for a bibliography See e.g. Pike and for an overview of publications of Fries (1985), SIL of the SIL, members through Newmeyer and Wares 1982. (1986) for differing views. 22 See especially Goldsmith (1976,1981), Leben Pierrehumbert (1980) for developments of this approach. (1976), and 23 See Clements (1975) and Hag6ge (1974) for descriptions of logophoric pronouns in West African languages, and Sells (1986) for a more recent theoretical treatment. 32 Studies in the Linguistic Sciences 19:2 (Fall 1989) 24 For recent studies of African tone systems see, among others, Clements and Goldsmith (1984), Pulleyblank (1986), Clark (1988), and Odden (1988). 25 For the phonetics of vowel harmony see Lindau (1979); for phonological analysis see Clements (1985), Archangeli and Pulleyblank (1989). . | I 26 For comprehensive presentations of the current paradigm, with emphasis on African contributions, see van der Hulst and Smith (1982) and Goldsmith (1989a). 27 More recently, Maddieson (1987) has shown that the labiodental stops Margi are more accurately characterized as clusters; however, he elsewhere shows that labiodental stops occur In other languages of the world (Maddieson of | , and Ladefoged 1988). | 28 See Sagey (1986) for discussion of Bantu and Khoisan phonology within this approach. 29 See Maddieson and Ladefoged (1988) for the feature [radical]. In a somewhat different proposal, McCarthy (1989) argues that pharyngeal and laryngeal articulations form a natural class for which the feature [pharyngeal] | i is , proposed. 30 term See Newman (1972). To the best was introduced in this 'syllable weight" 31 (1983), Inkelas of my knowledge, the now-standard paper. i For downstep in African languages see, among others, Clements Huang (1985); for intonational studies see Lindau (1986), Leben and (in press). 32 For Classical Arabic see McCarthy (1981); for other African languages, see Halle and Vergnaud (1980), Kenstowicz (1982), Hyman (1985), Clements (1986), and others. 33 This 34 work was later published as Giv6n (1972), SAL, supplement Grammar was 3. first presented In courses given by Perlmutter (Vincennes) In 1973 and by Perlmutter and Postal at the LSA Summer Institute held at the University of Massachusetts In 1974, and became widely known in subsequent years through many lectures and privately circulated papers by Perlmutter, Postal and their collaborators. For a Relational i " at the University of Paris VIII collection of early studies see Perlmutter (1983). ^ ^ I Clements: African linguistics 35 & its contributions to linguistic theory 33 See, for example, Marantz (1984), Baker (1988), and Bresnan and Kanerva (1989). 36 See Bresnan (1982) for a collection of studies 37 See especially Bresnan in this framework. and Mchombo (1987), Bresnan and Kanerva (1989). 38 For the basic presentation of 39 For a further approach Makua approach see Chomsky (1981). Generalized Phrase Stucky's analysis of the Bantu language to African syntax, that of Grammar (GSPG), see Structure this (1981). '*0 As Eyamba Bokamba points out (personal communication): 'Syntactic research in African languages demands considerable knowledge of the language(s) concerned, and can be done easily only by native speakers of such languages. This is a major obstacle for graduate students as well as faculty members who are often under pressure to produce results in a short time for one reason or another. The consequence is the paucity of syntactic studies in general, including article length work, and theoretical development in particular.* '^i all in It will be recalled that Chomsky and Halle (1968) do not discuss tone comprehensive work. at their otherwise "^^ That there may already be some movement in this direction is suggested by the contributions to the first meeting of the Niger-Congo Syntax Workshop in Boston in 1988 and to the conference on Bantu linguistics held at Stanford '*3 sandhi Mwiini in in in 1989. See Clements (1978) for discussion of left-edge constraints on tone Ewe, and Selkirk (1986) for an analysis of the Bantu language Chia generalized theory of edge-bounded phrasal phonology. '*'* See Odden (1987, 1988) for discussion of rules requiring direct reference to X-bar phrase structure in Kimatuumbi, and Hayes (1988) for a reanalysis of some types of syntax-sensitive rules as 'precompiled' lexical rules, drawing many examples from African languages. ^^ See Alleyne (1980) and Koopman (1986) for studies of New World Creoles, and Singler (1988) for examination of a West African pidgin. ^^ See Zawawi (1979) for an informative descriptive study of Swahili noun class morphology, and Zawawi (1971) for a popular first-year textbook. 34 Studies in the Linguistic Sciences 19:2 (Fall 1989) Nurse and Spear (1985) present a nontechnical overview the Swahili people 47 and of the early history of their language. Hyman (1975) and Kenstowicz and Kisseberth (1979) are two widelyphonological theory with much detailed exemplification from African languages. Gregersen (1977) is a readable introduction to African used textbooks languages and 48 in linguistics designed See Goldsmith (1989b) contribution linguistics to for the general reader. for insightful discussion of the important European, especially British, tradition the development of autosegmental phonology. the of of descriptive 49 See, for example, the descriptive study of the Haya tonal system in Byarushengo, Hyman and Tenenbaum (1976), later given a theoretical reinterpretation in Hyman and Byarushengo (1984). •1 REFERENCES A grammar of the Mende language. Ph.D. dissertation, Published as Language Dissertation no. 20 by the Linguistic Society of America, Philadelphia, 1935. Alleyne, M.C. 1980. Comparative Afro-American: an historical-comparative study of English-based Afro-American dialects of the New World. Ann Aginsky, E.G. Columbia 1935. University. Arbor: Karoma. Ansre, G. 1. 1961. Hartford: The tonal structure of Ewe. Hartford Studies in Linguistics no. Hartford Seminary Foundation. Archangeli, D. and D. Pulleyblank. Inquiry 20:2.141-72. 1989. Yoruba vowel harmony. Linguistic Baker, M. 1988. Incorporation: a theory of grammatical function changing. Chicago: University of Chicago Press. Bendor-Samuel J., ed. 1989. The Niger-Congo languages: a classification and Lanham & New York: description of Africa's largest language family. University Press of America. Bokamba, E. 1989. African languages and sociolinguistic theories. Paper read To to the 20th ACAL, University of Illinois, Urbana, April 20-22. 1989. appear in SLS 20:2. Brend, R. and K. Pike, eds. 1977. The Summer Institute of Linguistics. The Hague: Mouton. Bresnan, J., ed. 1982. The mental representation of grammatical relations. Cambridge, MA: MIT Press. Bresnan, J. and S. A. Mchombo. 1987. Topic, pronoun, and agreement in Chichewa. Language 63:741-782. & Clements: African linguistics its 35 contributions to linguistic theory Bresnan, J. and J. M. Kanerva. 1989. Locative inversion in Chichewa: a case study of factorization in grannmar. Linguistic Inquiiy 20:1 .1-50. Byarushengo, E. R., L. M. Hyman and S. Tenenbaum. 1976. Tone, accent, and assertion in Haya. SCOPIL 6. Los Angeles: University of Southern California. Chomsky, N. 1981. Lectures on government and binding. Dordrecht: Foris Publications. N. and M. Halle. 1968. The sound pattern of English. New York: Harper & Row. Clark, 1^. C. 1988. The tonal system of Igbo. ms., University of New Hampshire, to be published by Foris Publications, Dordrecht (in press). Clements, G. N. 1975. The logophoric pronoun in Ewe: its role in discourse. Chomsky, Journal of West African Languages 10:2.141-177. Clements, G. N. 1978. Tone and syntax in Ewe. Elements of Tone, Stress, and Intonation, ed. by D. J. Napoli. Washington, D.C.: Georgetown University Press. Clements, G. N. 1983. The hierarchical representation of tone features. Current Approaches to African Linguistics, vol. 1, ed. by I. R. Dihoff, 14576. Dordrecht: Foris Publications. 1985. Akan vowel harmony: a nonlinear analysis, in Goyvaerts, 55-98. Clements, G. N. 1986. Compensatory lengthening and consonant gemination in Luganda. Studies in Compensatory Lengthening, ed. by L. Wetzels & E. Sezer, 37-77. Dordrecht: Foris Publications. Clements, G. N. and J. Goldsmith, eds. 1984. Autosegmental studies in Bantu tone. Dordrecht: Foris Publications. Cole, D. T. 1971. The history of African linguistics to 1945, in Sebeok, 1-29. Demuth, K. 1989. Maturation and the acquisition of the Sesotho passive. Clements, G. N. Language Duignan, P. 65:1. 1967. Handbook of American resources for African studies. Stanford: Hoover Institute. Giv6n, T. 1971. On the verbal origin of the Bantu verb suffixes. Studies in African Linguistics 2:145-164. Givon, T. 1972. Linguistics, Studies in African in Chibemba and Bantu grammar. Supplement 3. Los Angeles: Department of Linguistics. Studies UCLA. Giv6n, T. 1976. Topic, pronoun, Topic, ed. by C. N. Li, 149-188. and grammatical agreement. New York: Academic Press. Subject and Givon, T. 1984. Syntax: a functional-typological introduction. Amsterdam: Benjamins. Autosegmental phonology. MIT Ph.D. dissertation, 1976. Goldsmith, J. published 1979 by Garland Publishing, Inc., N.Y. Goldsmith, J. 1981. English as a tone language. Linguistics in the 1980s, ed. by D. L. Goyvaerts. Ghent: Story-Scientia. Goldsmith, J. 1989a. Autosegmental and metrical phonology. Cambridge: Basil Blackwell. . 36 Studies in the Linguistic Sciences 19:2 (Fall 1989) J. 1989b. Phonological theory and African language phonology. Paper read to the 20th ACAL. University of Illinois, Urbana, April 20-22, 1989. To appear in SLS 20:2. Goyvaerts, D. L., ed. 1985. African linguistics: essays in honor of W. M. K. Semikenke. Amsterdam: John Benjamins. Greenberg, J. H. 1948. The tonal system of Proto-Bantu. Word 4:196-201. Greenberg, J. H. 1962. History and present status of African linguistic studies. Proceedings of the First International Congress of Africanists, Accra, 1962, 85-96. London: Longmans, Green & Co. Reprinted in Anwar S. Dil, ed., Language, culture, and communication: essays by Joseph H. Greenberg, Goldsmith, Stanford University Press, Stanford, 1971. Greenberg, J. H. 1963. revised edition 1966. Greenberg, J. H. 1965. The languages of Africa. UAL 29.1 (Part The Hague: Mouton & Co. The African world: a survey Linguistics. research, ed. by Robert A. Lystad, 416-441. [expansion of Greenberg 1962]. Greenberg, J. H. 1972. II). 2nd of social Part 5, 'African linguistics' Linguistic evidence regarding Bantu origins. Journal of African History 13:2.189-216. J. H. 1978. How does a language acquire gender markers? Universals of Human Language, vol. 3, ed. by J. H. Greenberg, 47-82. Stanford University Press. Gregersen, E. 1977. Language in Africa. New York: Gordon and Breach. Hagege, C. 1974. Les pronoms logophoriques. BSLP 69:287-310. Hall, R.B. 1947. Area studies with special reference to their application for research in the social sciences. New York: Social Science Research Council. Halle, M. 1983. On distinctive features and their articulatory implementation. Journal of Natural Language and Linguistic Theory 1:91-105. Halle, M. and J.-R. Vergnaud. 1980. Three dimensional phonology. Journal of Linguistic Research 1:91-105. Harris, Z. and W. E. Welmers. 1942. The phonemes of Fante. JAOS 62:318- Greenberg, 333. Hayes, B. 1988. Precompiled phrasal phonology, ms., UCLA, to CSLI Workshop on the Syntax/Phonology Connection, ed. by and D. Zee, CSLI, Stanford. CA. Hodge, C. 1947. Hausa grammar. Language Dissertation No. 41. appear in S. Inkelas Linguistic Society of America. J. 1985. On the autosegmental and metrical nature of tone terracing, Goyvaerts, 209-238. An overview of 1982. Hulst, H. G. van der and N. S. H. Smith, eds. autosegmental and metrical phonology. The Structure of Phonological Representations, Part 1 ed. by H. G. van der Hulst and N. S. H. Smith. 1- Huang, C. in . 45. Hyman, Dordrecht: Foris Publications. L 1975. Phonology: theory and analysis. Winston, New York: Holt, Rinehart, & Clements: African linguistics Hyman, 1985. L. A theory & its 37 contributions to linguistic theory of phonological weight. Dordrecht: Foris Publications. Hyman, L. and A. Duranti. 1982. On the object relation in Bantu. Studies in (Syntax and Semantics 15), ed. by P. Hopper and S. Thompson, 217-239. New York: Academic Press. Hyman, L. and J. R. Watters. 1984. Auxiliary focus. Studies in African Linguistics 15:3.233-274 Hyman, L. and E. R. Byarushengo. 1984. A model of Haya tonology, in Transitivity Clements and Goldsmith, 53-103. Johnson, D. E. et al. 1976. A survey of materials for the study of the uncommonly taught languages: languages of Sub-Saharan Africa. Washington, D.C.: Center for Applied Linguistics. Kenstowicz, M. 1982. Gemination and spirantization in Tigrinya. Studies in the Linguistic Sciences 12:103-122. Kenstowicz, M. and C. W. Kisseberth. 1979. Generative phonology: description and theory. New York: Academic Press. Kimenyi, A. 1980. A relational grammar of Kinyanwanda. University of California Publications in Linguistics 91. Berkeley. Kisseberth, C. W. and M. Abasheikh. 1977. The object relationship in ChiMwi:ni, a Bantu language. Syntax and Semantics, vol. 8: Grammatical Relations, ed. by P. Cole and J. Sadock, 179-218. New York: Academic Press. Kisseberth, C. Koopman, H. W. 1984. Digo tonology, in Clements & Goldsmith, 105-182. 1983. The syntax of verbs: from verb movement rules in the Kru Foris Publications. languages to universal grammar. Dordrecht H. 1986. The genesis of Haitian: implications of a comparison of some features of the syntax of Haitian, French, and West African Languages. Substrata versus universals in Creole genesis: papers from the Amsterdam Creole workshop, April, 1985, ed. by P. Muysken & N. Smith, 231-258. Amsterdam: Benjamins. Kraft, Charles. 1963. A study of Hausa syntax (3 vols.), Hartford studies in linguistics nos. 8-10. Hartford: Hartford Seminary Foundation. Ladefoged, P. 1964. The phonetics of West African languages. Cambridge: : Koopman, Cambridge University Press. 2nd edition 1968. Lambert, R. D. 1984. Beyond growth: the next stage in language and area studies. Washington, D.C.: Association of American Universities. Suprasegmental phonology. MIT Ph.D. dissertation, 1973. Leben, W. Cambridge, MA. Published by Garland Publishing, New York. Leben, W. 1976. The tones in English intonation. Linguistic Analysis 2:69-107. Leben, W. and S. Inkelas. 1987. Where phonology and phonetics intersect: the case of Hausa intonation. Papers in Laboratory Phonology I, ed. by J. Kingston & M. Beckman. Cambridge University Press (in press). 1979. Etymological dictionary of Gurage (Ethiopia), 3 vols. Leslau, Wolf. Wiesbaden: O. Harrassowitz. 1979. The feature expanded. Journal Lindau, M. of Phonetics 7:163-176. 38 Studies in the Linguistic Sciences 19:2 (Fall 1989) Lindau, M. 1986. 80:757-64. Loogman, Testing a model of intonation 1965. Alfons. Swahili grammar and in a tone language. syntax. Pittsburgh: JASA Duquesne University Press. McCarthy, A 1981. J. prosodic theory of nonconcatenative morphology. Linguistic Inquiry 12:373-418. McCarthy, J. 1989. Guttural phonology. University of Massachusetts at Amherst, ms. McDonnell, L.M. 1983. Federal support for training foreign language and area specialists. Prepared for the U.S. Department of Education. Santa Monica: Rand Corporation. Maddieson, 1987. The Margi vowel system and labiocoronals. Studies in I. African Linguistics 18:3.327-56 Maddieson, I. and P. feature hierachy. Ladefoged. 1988. Paper presented Multiply articulated at the segments and the annual meeting of the LSA, New Orleans, December, 1988. Marantz, A. 1984. On the nature of grammatical relations. Cambridge, MA: MIT Press. Mahler, K.E. 1983. National security and language competence. M.A. thesis, U.S. Army Command and General Staff College, Ft. Leavenworth, Kansas. Newman, P. 1972. Syllable weight as a phonological variable. Studies in African Linguistics 3:301-23. Newmeyer, F. J. 1986. The politics of linguistics. Chicago: University of Chicago Press. Nurse, D. and T. Spear. 1985. The Swahili: reconstructing the history and language of an African society, 800-1500. Philadelphia: University of Pennsylvania Press. D. 1987. Kimatuumbi phrasal phonology. Odden, Phonology Yearbook 4:13- 36. Odden, D. 1988. Kimatuumbi phonology and morphology. Ohio State University, ms. Perlmutter, D., ed. of 1983. Studies in relational grammar 1 . Chicago: University Chicago Press. J. 1980. The phonology and phonetics of English intonation. Unpublished Ph.D. dissertation, MIT, Cambridge, MA. Pike, K. and C. Fries. 1985. Introduction, in A.C. Wares, vol. 2. Pulleyblank, D. 1986. Tone in lexical phonology. Dordrecht: Reidel. Rana, H. M. and J. A. Distefano. 1987. Directory of African and Afro-American studies in the United States. Los Angeles: African Studies Association, Pierrehumbert, UCLA. 1986. The representation of features and relations in nonlinear E. phonology. Unpublished Ph.D. dissertation, MIT, Cambridge, MA. Schachter, P. 1971. African linguistics since 1945, in Sebeok, ed. Schuh, R. G. 1988. African language teaching and research in Europe and North America. Keynote address to the 19th Annual Conference on African Linguistics, Boston, Mass. Sagey, Clements: African linguistics Sebeok, 1971. T. A., ed. Africa. & its contributions to linguistic theory Current Trends in Linguistics, vol. 7: 39 Sub-saharan The Hague: Mouton. Selkirk, E. O. On 1986. derived domains in sentence phonology. Phonology Yearbook 3:371-405. 1987. Aspects of logophoricity. Linguistic Inquiry 18:3. V. 1988. The homogeneity of the substrate as a factor in pidgin/creole genesis. Language 64:1.27-51. Stucky, S. 1981. Order in Makua syntax. Ph.D. dissertation. University of Illinois, Urbana. To be published by Garland Publishing, N.Y. Turner, L D. 1949. Africanisms in the Gullah dialect. Chicago: University of Chicago Press. Sells, P. Singler, J. Wade-Lewis, M. 1989. Lorenzo Dow Turner: the First African-American Linguist. Department of African American Studies, Temple University, Philaelphia, Pa. To appear in SLS 20:1. Wares, A. C. 1979/85. Bibliography of the Summer Institute of Linguistics, Vol. 1 (1935-75), vol. 2 (1976-1982). Dallas: Summer Institute of Linguistics. Watkins, M. H. 1937. A grammar of Chichewa, a Bantu language of British Central Africa. Language Dissertation No. 24. Philadelphia, Pa.: Linguistic Society of America. Watkins, M. H. 1972. Yoruba phonemics. Studies in linguistics in honor of George L. Trager, ed. by M. E. Smith, 380-394. The Hague: Mouton. Watkins, M. H. 1978. Setswana phonemics: Sefokeng dialect. Linguistic and literary studies in honor of Archibald A. Hill, vol. 2: descriptive linguistics, ed. by M.A. Jazayeri et al., 353-358. The Hague: Mouton. Welmers, William E. 1959. Tonemics, morphotonemics, and tonal morphemes. General Linguistics 4:1-9. Welmers, William E. 1973. African language structures. Berkeley: University of California Press. Williams, E. 484 1976. [written Underiying tone and in Margi and Igbo. Linguistic Inquiry 7:463- circulated in 1971]. 1965. A grammar of the Kolokuma dialect of Ijo. West African Language Monographs 2. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. Zawawi, S. M. 1971. Kiswahili kwa kitendo: an introductory course. New York: Harper and Row. Zawawi, S. M. 1979. Loan words and their effect on the classification of Williamson, K. Swahili nominals. Leiden: E. J. Brill. 4 n & 5t--'^t lum. Tss: ^h-j Wh&s -^s- s ^i Studies in Volume 19, the Linguistic Number TUKI GAPS: Sciences 1989 2, Fall NULL RESUMPTIVE PRONOUNS OR VARIABLES? Edmond Biloa University of Southern California - Los Angeles It is argued in this paper that gaps in Tuki WH-constructions are non-overt resumptive pronouns rather than wh-traces. The fact that the language violates Subjacency corroborates this claim. The analysis of weak crossover phenomena, coordination, parasitic gap constructions and anaphoric binding in Tuki provides evidence that gaps in this language are null resumptive pronouns which are syntactically bound. shows that gaps in Tuki WH-constructions should be analyzed resumptive pronouns which do not involve movement on analogy with the resumptive pronoun strategy, rather than variables left by 'Move Alpha'. In Tuki, a Bantu language of Central Cameroon (West Africa), the head of the WHphrase can be associated with a gap or a resumptive pronoun. Generative grammar analyzes the gapped examples as instances of 'Move Alpha', a general rule that prohibits movement from island environments. The fact that the resumptive pronoun strategy in Tuki violates Bounding Theory is expected under current assumptions in the field. Such a violation is unexpected under a movement analysis of the gapped constructions in the language. However, Tuki consistently appears to violate island constraints such as the CNPC, the Moreover, WH-island, the CED, and the Sentential Subject Constraint. coordination of a clause containing a full resumptive pronoun and a clause containing a gap is possible. Furthermore, while resumptive pronouns fail to exhibit weak crossover effects, gapped sentences also fail to exhibit weak crossover effects, suggesting once more that these gaps are pronominals and not variables. Other facts such as parasitic gap constructions corroborate this claim. In the next section, we introduce the reader to resumptive pronouns in Tuki. Section 2 establishes the parallelism between gaps and resumptive pronouns in Tuki WH-constructions. In Section 3, we provide evidence that that the behavior of the gapped sentences is similar to the behavior of the resumptive-pronoun-sentences with respect to island constraints. In Section 4, This paper as null 44 Studies in the Linguistic Sciences 19:2 (Fall 1989) we examine Section 5 coordination and conclude that Tuki does not violate the CSC. that full resumptive pronouns as well as gaps do not exhibit shows weak crossover effects exhibits weak crossover (at S-structure), while in Section 6 we show effects at LF, providing further support that that Tuki gaps in Tuki WH-constructions are non-overt resumptive pronouns. It is claimed in Section 7 that resumptive pronouns license parasitic gaps in the language. The analysis of anaphoric binding in Section 8 strengthens the idea that resumptive pronouns are syntactically bound in the language. 1 . Resumptive Pronouns Following Sells (1984a, 1984b, 1987), we will assume that resumptive pronouns are pronouns which appear in unbounded dependency or WHmovement constructions, and which are directly bound by the operator in such constructions, as (a) (1) in the following Tuki sentences: mutu odzuj ngu muj dingam him love man who 'the man who (b) okutu I I love him' odzuj ngu woman who 'the woman who (c) mu pi I I danced bina dance na with her with her* nosi waaj mangadzu odzuj a who mother his SM 'the child who his mother loves Puta' child aj dingam love Puta Puta pronouns are morphologically Identical to object There are eight object pronouns in the language which can refer only to NPs bearing the feature [+ human], as shown in (2) below. In other words, there are no object resumptive pronouns for [- human] NPs. There are also no overt subject pronouns or overt subject resumptive pronouns in the In Tuki, resumptive pronouns. language. (2) Tuki Object Pronouns Singular Biloa: andzuj (a) (3) [ imgbeme who 45 xj ] SM 'who does the who unam y lion kills lion kill?' andzuj [imgbeme (b) TukiGaps SM 'who does the nam muj i lion lion kill him ] kill him?' WH-word andzu 'who' which is + human] can be associated either gap or a resumptive. In contrast, the WH-word ate 'what' which Is human] can only be associated with a gap below: In (3) the [ with a [ - (4) nambam Mbaraa atei [okutu a what woman of Mbara SM xj] cooks 'what does Mbara's wife cook?' The contrast in behavior between andzu 'who' and ate 'what' with respect to the generation of resumptive pronouns will become crucial when we look at island phenomena in Tuki In a subsequent section. 3. Island Environments In this section, we consider the island environments in Tuki. Chomsky (1977) has subsumed Ross's (1967) island constraints under the Subjacency Condition. Subjacency prohibits movement from island configurations. Tuki, however, consistently violates island constraints. clauses (5) seem (a) to violate the mutu [CP odzuj man (b) [IP who ee[IP Putaam that Puta 'the SM p 1 Mbara a m udza [NP Mbara SM pi tell una xj ]]]]] that [IP the story that Puta which Mbara a Mbara SM Puta a m(u) tevere [CP odzu [IP [CP ee PutaSM 'the table that mam ama [CP story this kill man whom Mbara told table For instance, Tuki relative CNPC: p1 Mbara ofa m killed' udza [NP p1 tell x maru ama story this ]]]]] throw told the story that Puta threw away' CNPC is violated irrespective of whether the position relativized can be associated with a resumptive pronoun or a gap. In (5b) for instance, since tevere 'table' is [- human], the position it has vacated cannot be filled with a resumptive pronoun. Nevertheless, the position is disrespectful of the CNPC without any ungrammaticality resulting. The 46 Studies in the Linguistic Sciences 19:2 (Fall 1989) Consider the following sentences: [karate odzu] (a) (6) book 'this (b) iya xj send book, I know my man who send Nga idzima [CP the ti my nu nambam anenga cook In (6a), position inside my mother* [IP xj a SM what ]]] this know what (she) will cook this evening' NP In (6b), mu PutajjIPi Puta it 'Puta, good it is Mbara 'Mbara, is good [IP xj a nu banam f1 marry SM that Mbara]] Mbara that (she) will marry Mbara' mu it it wusi [CP ee is Mbarai,[IPi (b) In (7a), don't to ate a sentential subject: (a) (7) SM karate odzu 'this book' is associated with a variable inside the topic NP iya ame 'my mother' is extracted over the ate 'what'. And in (7a & b) below, a topic is associated with a the topic relative clause. WH-element aye evening I know neg I 'my mother, a a [IP who arne]]]] mother f1 odzu mother ame]i, [IP [iya man know I ma tomena p2 idzimam [NP mutu [CP [IP Ngi i, this wusi good [CP ee good is that [IP Puta Puta a nu muj/O banam PutaSMfl him that ]]] marry marry him/0' will the subject Puta has been topicalized. Bear in mind that there are no overt subject resumptive pronouns. In the following sentence, extraction has taken place over an adverbial clause: [manya amajj, avan (8) food 'this (8) violates this food, before to dze that you touch o timbita you touch , xj, suwa amboo roo wash hands your wash your hands' Domains (Huang 1982) which prohibits ungoverned environments, and the data presented so far the Condition on Extraction extraction from appear before indicate that Tuki allows island violations. extraction from relative clauses, embedded questions and Since Tuki allows adjuncts, it seems appropriate to suggest that gaps in Tuki should not be analyzed as variables by 'Move Alpha', but rather as null resumptive pronouns. left Biloa: Tuki 4. Gaps 47 Coordination Further evidence for a parallelism between gaps and full resumptive pronouns is provided by the fact that it is possible to conjoin a clause containing a full resumptive pronoun and a clause containing a gap: [IP (9) Mbara a sesam [CP andzuj Mbara SM asks who [IP Tsimi a Tsimi SM mui him [IP Puta a Puta benam]]]] SM dingam ka xj then loves hates 'Mbara asks who Puta loves and Tsimi hates him' However, Tuki does not 1967); it is violate the Coordinate Structure Constraint (Ross impossible to extract one constituent of a conjoined stoicture in Tuki: idzimam [NP mutu [CP odzui (10) *ngi [IP Puta a dingam xj who Puta SM loves [IP Mbara benam Dima ]]]] a Mbara SM hates Dima know the man whom Puta loves and Mbara hates Dima' know I man ka then 'I Across-the-board extraction allows extraction from both conjuncts, provided that the affected elements in each conjunct be 'identical' in syntactic category (see Williams (1 978, 36, (31 ) ). Consider in this respect (lib): (11) (a) idzimam [NP mutu [CP odzui [IP Puta a dingam xj ka Mbara a benam xj ]]]] know the man whom Puta loves and Dima hates' ngi idzimam [NP mutu [CP odzuj [IP Puta a muj/O dingam ka ngi [IP 'I (b) Mbara a muj /O benam ]]]] know the man whom Puta loves him/0 and Mbara hates 'I [IP him/0' grammatical because the same extraction rule has applied in both Notice that in (lib), the two conjuncts are the two VPs and that in each case the trace left by the extracted element can be replaced by a resumptive pronoun. Assuming Williams's requirement that the WH-movement rule must apply across-the-board to an identical item in both conjuncts, then we have to assume that WH-movement has affected both conjuncts in (1 1 ), and that the trace that is left behind is optionally spelled out as a resumptive pronoun. Given that the phonological realization of the trace cannot change its syntactic category in compliance with Williams's condition, both gaps and resumptive pronouns must be of the same syntactic category. That is that they are both (11a) is conjuncts. bound by the WH-word at S-structure. 48 Studies in the Linguistic Sciences 19:2 (Fall 1989) We conclude that Tuki does not violate the CSC, although it seems to Georgopoulos (1985) observes the same behavior in Palauan and concludes that the CSC is a constraint different kind from other constraints subsuming Subjacency. in Scandinavian languages too observe the CSC while many island constraints are violated (Engdahl and Ejerhed 1982). violate consistently other island constraints. 5. Weak Crossover Full (12) at S-structure resumptive pronouns do not exhibit weak crossover effects (a) andzuj waaj ] [a mother his SM 'who does his mother love?' andzuj [okutu [odzuj xj a [nosi who (b) who 'who Likewise, sentences containing gaps also (a) andzuj andzuj 'who On analogy [okutu (14) ] his to exhibit xj a ]] Tuki: ] benam muj him SM hates him' weak crossover [a dingam SM loves xj effects, variables: ]] love' [odzuj xj a dingam ]]] woman whom SM loves does the woman whom he loves hate' with their English counterparts, the sentences ruled out by the Bijection Principle Condition fail waaj mother 'who does his mother who dingam gaps are pronominals, not [nosi who (b) dingam loves woman whom SM loves does the woman whom he hates love providing further evidence that these (13) mu him in In (Koopman & Sportiche 1982) a benam SM hates (13) should be or the Leftness (Chomsky 1976, Higginbotham 1980): The (a) Bijection Principle Weak half: A quantifier can bind only one variable. (Violation results in semigrammaticality) (b) Strong half: A in must bind a variable. (Violation results ungrammaticality) quantifier The Leftness Condition states that a pronoun cannot be coindexed with a variable to its right. The fact that the constructions in (13) are licit seems to imply that the gaps are non-overt pronouns which may be phonetically realized when is [+ human]. Sentences such as (13) have important consequences for Safir's (1984, 1986) Parallelism Constraint on Operator Binding (PCOB): the position they are associated with TukiGaps Biloa: on Operator Binding (PCOB) (15) Parallelism Constraint If one O local A'-bindee of bindees of O 49 must be [& is [& lexical] lexical] and [b pronominal], then all or [b pronominal]. Safir's constraint rules out as illicit constructions in which a single operator binds two variables, one of which is a trace and the other a pronominal. Since we have argued that gaps in the above weak crossover configurations are nonovert resumptive pronouns, it is possible to suggest that all the local A'-bindees of the operator andzu 'who' are [+ pronominal ]. If this argumentation proves to be accurate, both types of Juki bindee would bear the feature [+ pronominal ]. 6. Weak Crossover LF at Tuki allows WH-in-situ phrases. The latter consistently trigger weak crossover effects as evidenced by the ungrammaticality of the following sentences: (16) (a) *isa father waaj a his SM 'his father (b) 'karate ate dingam andzuj loves who loves who' udzam ee book what says 'which book says nosi a dingam waaj mother his SM loves that his mother loves which [mwana child that ate]i what child' The illicitness of the above two constructions infers that coindexing is not possible between pronouns and unmoved wh-words to their rights. Assuming that WH-in-situ items raise at LF, consider for instance the LF representation of (16b): (17) [karate ate] j [mwana ate]j [xj udzam ee nosi waaj a dingam xj ]] In (17) above, the variable x is to the right of \Naa 'his' and the construction is disqualified by the Leftness Condition (Chomsky 1976, Higginbotham 1980). As opposed to the previous cases where the weak crossover effects were nonexistent, in (17) wh-movement has taken place weak crossover effects at LF. Consider next the interpretation (18) (a) *ee a [e]i SM that 'that (b) he *iyere is Tuki thus exhibits of quantifiers in the following mu yedza is mad mad annoys waaj a at LF. i SM sentences: saseyam [mutu ongima]i annoys man every everyone' dingam [mangadzu child teacher his SM loves 'his teacher loves every student' a of sukunj school ongima]i every 50 Studies in the Linguistic Sciences 19:2 (Fall 1989) both sentences above, the anaphoric relation between the pronoun and the phrase is impossible. The LF representations for both sentences are provided below: In quantifier (19) (a) (b) [mutu ongima]i [ee man every that a [e]i he SM [mangadzu a sukum ongima]i every of school child mu yedza] is mad saseyam i SM xj annoys waaj a dingam teacher his SM loves [iyere xj ] the above structures, pronouns are coindexed with variables to their right; the Leftness Condition disqualifies them consequently. This again provides prima In facie evidence that weak crossover effects show up in Tuki at LF. Notice that there seems to be a correlation between the presence of resumptive pronouns and the occurrence of weak crossover effects. The unavailability of resumptive pronouns at LF, after the raising of quantified NPs and the movement of WH-insitu items, inevitably triggers 7. Parasitic weak crossover effects. Gaps Chomsky (1982) indicates that resumptive pronouns cannot license that resumptive pronouns are indexed at LF whereas parasitic gaps are licensed at S-structure. So, only WH-traces which receive their index at S-structure through Move Alpha can license parasitic gaps. Consider the sentences given in (21) where the four logical possibilities in (20) parasitic gaps. He argues are explored: (20) trace... gap pronoun resumptive pronoun. ..gap resumptive pronoun... resumptive pronoun trace.. .resumptive (21) (a) [okutu ate]i o woman what you '[which (b) [okutu woman] ateji (c) (d) dinga love did you love o woman what you '[which mu pi woman] mu dinga pi love did you love tj avan adze before that t tj o before marrying avan adze o before that you t mu you pi [okutu ate]j mu muj bana p1 her marry before marrying her' '[which woman] bana mu pi ei marry muj dinga avan adze o mu muj before that you pi her her love did you love her before marrying her' o woman what you ei marry e' muj dinga avan adze o mu [okutu o ate]i woman what you p1 her love before that you pi '[which woman] did you love her before marrying e' mu bana bana marry Biloa: TukiGaps 51 (21a) above, a parasitic gap is not c-commanded by its licensing WH-trace, bound by the same operator which binds the WH-trace. In (21b) the parasitic gap is realized as a resumptive pronoun. In (21c), the resumptive pronoun apparently does license a parasitic gap. In (21 d), both the wh-trace and the parasitic gap are realized as resumptive pronouns. We would expect (21c) to be ungrammatical. However, turns out that is grammatical. The test usually applied to identify parasitic gaps is to replace the 'real' gap with a lexical NP, and see if the parasitic gap is then disallowed. The test is performed on (21c) and the result is seen in (22) below: In and Is it o (22) *[okutu ate]j mu dingaPutaj avan it adze o mu bana woman what you '[which (22) is woman] love Puta before that you pi p1 did you love Puta before marrying e' ungrammatical because Puta occupies the position ej marry of the variable. Given the licitness of (21c), it seems to be the case that resumptive pronouns can indeed license parasitic gaps. This poses a bone of contention between the Tuki facts and Chomsky's claim that resumptive pronouns receiving their index at LP cannot license parasitic gaps at S-structure. Thus in (21), the relevant gaps and resumptive pronouns do indeed license parasitic gaps, contradicting the situation which obtains in languages such as English where resumptive pronouns do not license parasitic gaps (Chomsky 1982). We argue that resumptive pronouns license parasitic gaps in Tuki because resumptive pronouns in this language, whether null or overt, are coindexed with the relevant antecedents at S-stnjcture, and parasitic gaps are licensed at that level of representation. Tuki, then, unlike English, pattterns with Swedish, Irish, Hebrew and Palauan in that resumptive pronouns (null or overt) function as bound variables at S-structure (Borer 1979; McCloskey 1979; Zaenen et al. 1981; Engdahl and Ejerdhed 1982; Sells 1984b; Georgopoulos 1985). This one more evidence for the view that gaps in Tuki WH-constructions are null resumptive pronouns. constitutes 8. Anaphoric Binding The claim that resumptive pronouns are syntactically bound in further supported by the analysis of anaphoric binding in the language. a lexical anaphor cannot precede and c-command the NP Tuki is In Tuki, with which it is coindexed, as illustrated by the ungrammaticality of this sentence: woman 'his udzam ee ta [e]i /Isomoj a that he /Isomo SM neg says own wife says that he/lsomo does not love her/0' (23) *[okutu waamatej her self ]j muj /O her/0 dinga love 52 Studies in the Linguistic Sciences 19:2 (Fall 1989) In (23) the clause containing the antecedent [e] /Isomo is embedded within the clause containing the lexical anaphor waamate 'herself. Irrespective of whether the antecedent is an NP or an empty pronominal, the sentence is illicit. (24) *vatu va men SM ee kutu dzara prog, talk he mu a [e]j that SM maru m(a) Isomoj (Okutu waamatej of Isomo woman her self . of husband 'People were talking about Isomo's problem. he is udzam says ombee waonumutu bad is ]j story His own wife says that a bad husband' In (24) a possible antecedent in the immediately preceding discourse cannot bind a reflexive in the immediately following discourse. However, WH-fronted constituents can contain lexical anaphors bound by a following antecedent, as evidenced by the following construction: (25) [CP okutu waamatej ate ]j her self what woman [IP bunganam [CP ee o you think [IP Isomoj a ta dzu Isomo that Slwl neg still muj /O dinga? her /O love 'which of his It is own commonly assumed binding in wife you think that Isomo no longer loves her /O' within the standard transformational tradition that (25) takes place before WH-movement. Now we question the waamate in (23), we obtain if subject of the clause containing the lexical anaphor a grammatical sentence: (26) [okutu woman Isomoj a muj /O dinga ta ate]j udzam ee what says that Isomo SM neg her /O love own wife says that Isomo no longer loves her/0?' waamatej her self 'which of his worth comparing the ungrammatical (23) to the grammatical (26). In (26) mu or the gap is bound by an anaphor in an A' position, which is not the case for (23). Notice that (25) and (26) enjoy the same status of grammaticality, showing that both the resumptive pronoun and the gap can be bound by an item in a non-theta position, and suggesting that the binding relationship between the wh-phrase and the resumptive pronoun/gap has taken place in the syntax. Thus in Tuki, since resumptive pronouns and gaps are It is the resumptive pronoun lexical anaphor located in a fronted WH-phrase, one can reach the conclusion that Tuki resumptive pronouns are syntactically bound at coindexed with a S-structure. Biloa: Tuki 9. Gaps 53 Conclusion paper, we have shown that in Tuki. topic NP or the head of the clause can be associated either with a resumptive pronoun or a gap. Since Tuki allows violations of island constraints, we have claimed that gaps in Tuki should be analyzed as null resumptive pronouns which do not involve movement, on analogy with the full resumptive pronoun strategy available in the language. Further evidence for a parallelism between gaps and full resumptive pronouns was provided by the fact that it is possible to conjoin a clause containing a gap and a clause containing a resumptive pronoun. Full resumptive pronouns as well as gaps do not exhibit weak crossover effects in Tuki; this constitutes more evidence that these gaps are pronominals. Moreover, in Tuki. relevant gaps license parasitic gaps, contradicting the situation which obtains in English and Spanish where resumptive pronouns do not license parasitic gaps (cf. Chomsky 1982)). We argue that this is possible in Tuki because resumptive pronouns in this language, whether null or overt, are coindexed with the relevant antecedents at S-structure. and parasitic gaps are In this relative licensed at that level of representation. Acknowledgements We are much indebted to Joseph Aoun. Carol Georgopoulos. Hajime Hoji. Osvaldo Jaeggli. Kenneth Safir, Peter Sells, and SLS reviewers for providing helpful comments on an earlier version of this study. Thanks also go to Maria Luisa Zubizarreta with whom we have discussed in class material included here. Thanks to the participants at the 20th Conference on African Linguistics at the University of Illinois and to Joan Bresnan for her encouragement. The usual disclaimers apply. Glosses We have made use in the glosses of the following symbols: f1= future tense one marker Neg= negation marker 0M= object marker p1= past tense one marker p2 = past tense two marker SM= subject marker 54 Studies in the Linguistic Sciences 19:2 (Fall 1989) REFERENCES BORER, 1980. Restrictive relatives in Modern Hebrew. NLLT 2.21 9-260. 1976. Conditions on rules of grammar. Essays on form and interpretation. New York: North-Holland. 1977. On wh-movement. Formal syntax, ed. by P. Culicover, T. Wasow, & A. Akmajian. New York: Academic Press. H. CHOMSKY, Noam. Some concepts and consequences of the theory of government Monograph 6. Cambridge, MA: MIT Press. ENGDAHL, E., & Eva Ejerhed. 1982. Readings on unbounded dependencies in Scandinavian languages. Stockholm: Umea. GEORGOPOULOS, Carol. 1983. Resumptive pronouns, syntactic binding, and levels of representation in Belau. Proceedings of North Eastern Linguistic Society 14, ed. by C. Jones & P. Sells, 81-97. Amherst: Graduate Linguistic Student Association. 1985. Variables in Palauan Syntax. NLLT 3:59-94. HIGGINBOTHAM, J. 1980. Pronouns and bound variables. Linguistic Inquiry 1982. and binding. Linguistic Inquiry 11:4. HUANG, James. 1982. grammar. MIT KOOPMAN, The H., & Linguistic McCLOSKEY, J. Logical relations in Chinese and the theory of dissertation. D. Sportiche. 1982. Variables and the bijection principle. Review 2:135-170. 1979. Transformational syntax and model theoretic semantics. Dordrecht: Reidel. ROSS, John R.. 1967. Constraints on variables in syntax. Ph.D. dissertation, MIT. SAFIR, Ken. 1984. Multiple variable binding. LI1 5:603-638. 1986. Relative clauses in a theory of binding and levels. LI1 7:663-690. Resumptive pronouns and weak crossover. SELLS, Peter. 1984a. Proceedings of West Coast Conference on Formal Linguistics 3, ed. by M. Cobler, S. MacKaye. and M. Westcoat, 252-262. Stanford. 1984b. Syntax and semantics of resumptive pronouns. Ph.D. dissertation, University of Massachusetts. 1987. 298. Binding resumptive pronouns. Linguistics & philosophy 10:3.261- E.S. 1978. Across-the-board application of rules. LI 8:419-423. 1981. Resumptive Annie, Elisabeth Engdahl, and Joan Maling. pronouns can be syntactically bound. LI 12:679-682. WILLIAMS, ZAENEN, Studies in Volume 19, the Linguistic Number Sciences 1989 2, Fall WHERE DO IDEOPHONES COME FROM?* G. Tucker Childs Temple University This paper begins with an analysis of ideophones in Kisi (West This examination leads to consideration of the diachrony of ideophones, but because of the lack of data with any real time depth, we are limited to finding clues in the synchronic data. This study looks first at verbs, the class of words which Kisi ideophones resemble most closely. Such is also the case in other African languages, where ideophones can often be analyzed as verbs, as has been done for several Southern Bantu languages. then demonstrate how Kisi ideophones can be derived from verbs, illustrating several possible scenarios for such a process. then look at possible derivational relationships with other word categories, finding that with other word categories the direction of derivation is the opposite. For example, nouns are derived from ideophones but no vice versa. This generalization holds across other African languages as well and may be true for expressive language in general. Atlantic, Guinea). I I 1 . Introduction This paper presents an answer to paper by examining the links between The title actually poses two questions, answering in any but a general or the question posed by the title of this ideophones and other word classes. the first of which we are incapable of highly speculative manner, that is, determining the ultimate origin of ideophones. The more tractable second question asks, where do new ideophones come from once ideophones already exist in a language? The reply to this question is that ideophones come from verbs, as is shown by data drawn from More Kisi (Atlantic Group, Niger-Congo) and other African languages. importantly, the process of deriving ideophones from verbs via reduplication 56 Studies in the Linguistic Sciences 19:2 (Fall 1989) accords well with universals of reduplication. suggestions as to the ultimate origin of ideophones. I conclude by presenting The earliest discussions of the emergence of new ideophones often consist of anecdotal accounts detailing no specific process. While ideophones many languages comprise an open and productive class, e.g., Ewe (Ansre 1961:49), they do not do so in every language, e.g., Swahili. Whether or not they form such a class is an empirical question and must be answered for every in language individually. One sort of claim for complete productivity is that ideophones can be created spontaneously. For example, Noss speaks of an elderly story-telling hunter 'creating a series of ideophones' (1975:149). Innes similarly states, 'New ideophones are sometimes coined by a story teller' (1964:18), which statement Samarin strongly questions, 'It is not enough to rely on the statements of a few informants who professed not to have known the ideophones (as Innes, in a personal communication, explains)' (1967:40). Where processes of ideophone creation have been detailed, one ideophones arise from within their own word class, as novel assemblages of ideophone partials. Maduka makes this claim for Igbo (198384) and Nembe (1988b); Awoyale states that for Yoruba ideophones consist of small, even non-concatenative, sound-symbolic morphemes ('phonesthemes* in the terminology of Bolinger, e.g., 1949), which combine to form new ideophones (Awoyale 1988). claim is explicit that Ideophones have also been analyzed as being derived from other word The two classes have always been seen as closely related, especially in Benue-Congo, e.g., Voeltz 1971. Although the directionality of the derivation is sometimes ambiguous, e.g., Noss 1985, in the majority of cases ideophones arise from verbs, in one case even from verbs with extensions (Nurse 1974). This process has been particularly well documented in Southern Bantu, e.g., von Staden 1977, and is common elsewhere in Bantu, e.g., Alexandre 1966. In the comments that follow, discuss how just such a process can be identified in Kisi, despite their being no active synchronic processes in the language. classes, most notably, from verbs. I 2. Ideophones and expressiveness unhelpful) answer to the question of where ideophones Ideophones arise out of the universal need for human beings to express themselves, to signal their individuality and their unique perception of events. That this need is universal can be seen in the presence of comparable classes in other (non-African) languages of the world, including The short (and come from is that Childs: pidgins and Creoles. seen below. (1) Where do ideophones come from? A sampling of languages In which such words appear 57 is Iroquoian languages (Mithun 1982); Jamaican English (DeCamp 1974); Japanese (Frei 1970); Korean (Martin 1962); Lahu, TibetoBurman, Laos (Matisoff 1986); Malay (Carr 1966); Mayan languages (Durbin 1973); Middle English (Smithers 1954); Russian (Andersen 1988 p.c); White Hmong, Miao, Thailand. (Ratliff 1986). The universality of this need can be seen further in the fact that in languages where there are no ideophones, speakers employ other means to achieve the same ends, for example, through intonation and gesture (see Samahn 1973 for a full discussion of these issues). An expansion to the short answer given above must state why there is a human need for expressiveness, a statement that is far beyond the concerns of this paper. Nonetheless, that the need for expressiveness is universal is is the ways in which ideophones fulfill this established; what remains to be seen need. 3. Ideophones and other word categories In KisI present the relationships between In the following discussion, ideophones and other word classes, demonstrate the directionality of these relationships, and assess their productivity. Although the point of this section will be that ideophones are most closely related to verbs, ideophones also show links with other word classes. Ideophones are somewhat related to adjectives and nouns, and totally unrelated to syntactically important words, such as particles, prepositions, and pronouns. I 3.1 Ideophones and nouns Only a few cases of nouns and ideophones exhibit what could be construed as a derivational relationship. Ideophone-like nouns are usually derived from ideophone-like verbs by a regular process of nominalization. In the exceptional cases discussed below, nouns exhibit a more direct relationship with ideophones. The examples below illustrate cases where the directionality is uncertain. Nouns related to ideophones follow the phonotactic (including tonotactic) That the phonology of constraints of the language (unlike ideophones). ideophone-related nouns is 'tamer* can be seen in the second and third sets of words (2b and 2c), where the raised register of the ideophone (indicated by the framing '+'s'), is not associated with the noun. 58 Studies in the Linguistic Sciences 19:2 (Fall 1989) Ideophone -> Noun ? (2) (a) H dong H H / H dong-dong H id. 'quietly, silently' H dongdongndo nam. 'Febmary (quiet month)' + HH + (b) mui id. +HH 'hard, sharp, bitingly, pinchingly' HH+ mui-mui id. 'finely LL H muiyo n. ground' 'mosquito' Noun -^ Ideophone ? (3) +H H H H+ kpele-kpele id. 'straight (up), steeply, to the top' +H H+ kpeleng id. 'loudly, clearly, at a high volume' HH HH kpeelaa The first direction, very straight palm tree with a smooth trunk and sometimes no fronds' n. 'a tall, two sets of examples (2a and 2b) and the last (3) suggests the opposite. hint at the time of the year dongdongndo an ideophone-to-noun set, the name of the informants were sure as to represented, yet they were all familiar with month probably comes from the ideophone. Not In the first all Their unsurety suggests that the name of the month is newer, perhaps even a product of Western calendar-making. In the second set (2b) the same direction is likely because many animal names are onomatopoeic in the ideophone. origin and use reduplication (see below). One piece of evidence for a noun-to-ideophone derivation, as in the final is fomial. The assonance of the ideophone is predictable; Kisi ideophones generally have the same vowel throughout. If the derivation is from ideophone to noun, there is no way to predict which vowel will appear in the set of examples, noun. More importantly, however, one informant stated kpele-kpele and kpeleng come from the noun. In that the ideophones the examples appearing below, the directionality of the derivational is straightforward: nouns are derived from cognate ideophones. relationship Childs: The Where do ideophones come from? 59 based on the semantics of the new nouns. Both new concepts for the Kisi people, arising only recently from contact with Western culture. Assuming that the ideophones were part of the lexicon before trousers were part of the Kisi wardrobe and candy a part of a child's intake, we can hypothesize that the Kisi words representing 'trousers' and 'candy' date back only to the introduction of justification for this 'trousers' {4a) these items claim and 'candy' is (4b) are relatively into Kisi culture. F (4) (a) H id. 'flaccid, H lOndOngndo n. 'trousers' H floppy' L HL F (b) H F lOndO/HOndO) bOng bOOng / H L id. H bOmbOngndo 'sucking or drawing HL H bOngbOOngndo^ in' R / n. 'candy' 3.2 Ideophones and adjectives As and ideophones. Kisi and a productive process deriving adjectives from verbs. Kisi adjectives can be identified by their morphosyntax, as in the sequence illustrated below (NCP = noun class pronoun; NCM = noun class marker). Adjectives follow nouns they modify and show agreement by affixing the noun class marker (suffix) of the noun they modify. The noun class marker of the noun is replaced with its respective pronoun, except in the case of o-class nouns, where noun stems appear without a pronoun, as in 'pineapple' below. has a with nouns, no statable processes link adjectives relatively large number of underived adjectives Stem+NCP Adj+NCM (5) [[Noun]N [AdjJAjNP -> (a) wangmgbang id. H H H wangmgbang+lang window+NCP open+NCM 'wide H H H 'widely, far' LH H wundEI-fIa +H (b) H H-t- musuku L L bEIE-fO open windows' id. 'broken into small pieces' H H HL H musukuu-fO Stem+NCP Adj+NCM 'a pulverized pineapple' 60 In Studies in the Linguistic Sciences 19:2 (Fall 1989) the second example (5b) the ideophone used as an adjective has the tonal pattern associated with derived adjectives (HL). this last example, that the adjective It seems likely, then, at least in derived from the ideophone, and one can generally in this direction. Adjectives, similarly to assume that derivation is nouns, seem an unlikely source for is new ideophones. Thus far have demonstrated the non-productive relationships that exist between ideophones and nouns, and between ideophones and adjectives. Where relationships exist, the directionality has been uncertain, and there have been no suggestions of productivity. now consider ideophones and verbs, the latter being the class to which ideophones are most closely related. I I 3.3 ideophones and verbs that The first fact that emerges in a consideration of ideophones and verbs is many more verbs than nouns or adjectives show affinities with ideophones. furthermore apparent that the relationship between verbs and ideophones, is direct. Ideophones also share morphosyntactic features with verbs. The similarities between verbs and ideophones, however, are not extensive enough to support the claim that Kisi ideophones are actually a sub-category of verbs, as has been claimed for other African languages, especially those in southern Africa (Fortune 1962, Kunene 1965). The features shared by Kisi verbs and ideophones are given below. It is both formal and semantic, (6) 1 . Reciprocal co-occurrence restrictions 2. Syntactic proximity 3. Appearance after co and iva^ (auxiliary / copula) Reciprocal co-occurrence restrictions signify that ideophones co-occur few verbs and that verbs often co-occur with only a few ideophones. These tendencies culminate in a situation where a verb takes only one ideophone, and that ideophone appears only with the one verb. The tightness of such cooccurrence restrictions is illustrated below. The first ideophone (7a) occurs with only one verb, the second (7b) with two, and the third (7c) with three. with (7) Childs: Where do ideophones come from? H (c) cing 'keenly' 61 LLH nuaa 'to stare L LH tofaa 'to look 'to see' at' at' LH cOO A second morphosyntactic Ideophones syntactic proximity. feature ideophones share with verbs is appear clause-finally after a verb (first typically three examples, 8a, 8b, 8c) or adjective LH L (8) (a) ma pel Pro fikiki Id fill 'It L L L ma CO huno Pro Aux come-out LHL (c) (d) example, 8d). -i-HHH-i- filled (it) all the way.' HH H H L (b) (last fEIE-fElE Id 'It's dribbling out.' HHLLL LLR CO hiilOngndo yikpE-yikpE Id 'The grass grass Aux shake billo L o Pro L CO is shaking a lot.' H H+ LLL LH +H H L luEiyaa nyEIE-nyElE Cop NCP sharp 'The knife Id is razor sharp.' Note how the ideophone comes after the non-finite form of the verb in the second and third examples (8b and 8c) rather than after the auxiliary co, which is marked for tense, aspect, and polarity. This stands in contrast to the syntax of non-subject arguments. These elements appear before the verb (and after the auxiliary) in compound-verb constructions, as is represented schematically below. (9) Simple NP Compound NP Aux Verb (NP) (NP) Id (NP) (NP) Verb Id Although ideophones appear peripheral to the structure do seem attached in some way to the verb itself. of the sentence, they Ideophones have in common with verbs that they appear after co and wa, words that double as copulas and auxiliaries. When verbs appear in co constructions, they have either a progressive or future meaning, as represented in the examples below. 62 Studies in the Linguistic Sciences 19:2 (Fall 1989) (10) Prog HHLLHLLHFH L num bEE a co ya malaa capo you indeed you are me help a-lot 'You indeed are greatly helping me.' it L LL CO hau Aux today 'It will L o Fut L R start be started today.' ideophones can appear L H R kandOng in H H exactly these constructions. Qiilds: (13) (a) Where do ideophones come from? HH HH wee -wee LL H 63 id. 'cut into small pieces' v. throw (something), esp. small LL H wliyo/weiyo 'to rocks' LL LL H welweiyo v (pi), "to (at throw small rocks something)' HL HL (b) kili-kili id. 'describing quick footsteps of small animals kiolu In the night, pitter-patter" LL LLL / kelu to V. cut' LL LL V kilikili The ideophone (pi), 'to cut into small pieces' representative pairs exhibit relationships where the almost an exact copy of the verb. following is (14) id. V. 'curvaceous' 'pervade, go around, spread throughout' id. 'plentiful V. 'to peeling, copious scraping' peel or scrape' id. 'smooth and slippery' V. to smooth out or over' Often ideophones are used with their cognate verbs, as shown below. (15) H HHL L LL LH L o buu boo yOmndo buuu he peel bark tree Id 'He really peeled the bark off the tree." 64 Studies in the Linguistic Sciences 19:2 (Fall 1989) it 'It HHL LL R buunung L o buuu peel-Mid Id peeled everywhere.' LLHHL H FHLH tElEka lEngndeng tElEkElE he smooth ground Id 'He smoothed the ground thoroughly." These facts can be rearranged A into what can be presumed reduplicated for emphasis to represent a the morphological reduplication used to convey plurality). For greater emphasis the second part may be formally altered, either prosodically, with extra-high tones, or diachronic process. verb is (cf. segmentally, e.g., by changing a vowel. This step is not absolutely necessary as shown by the ideophones that are segmentally identical to the verbs from which they arise. This item is then reanalyzed as a separate element. A schematic representation of the different possibilities, all attested in Kisi, appears below. In all cases there are formal and semantic similarities between the forms at each stage. The stages are arranged in the order in which they may have occurred. Stage one thus represents the earliest stage and the fifth stage a possible final stage. An actual example from Kisi follows. Redup. vb vgrt? (16) 1 2 3 4 5 + + + - + + + - - Ideophope + + + (Reanalysis) LL (17) 'to ye la taste good' LL LL 1) reduplication of verb for 2) erosion / emphasis partial reduplication yela-yela * LL L yela-ye LL H 3) reanalysis as separate morpheme, yela ye tone raising LL H H 4) ideophone reduplicated yela ye-ye 5) ideophone used with other verbs * Where do ideophones come from? Childs: Although many traces remain, in Kisi the process is no longer 65 active. A final step is to consider ideophones that are related to each other, the incestuous relationship which may eventually lead to sound symbolism. 3.4 Ideophones related to each other Sets of ideophones appear related forms. In many in what can be interpreted as derivationally African languages these relationships are common among the ideophonic part of the lexicon, more so than in other parts of the language, occasionally displaying a great deal of systematicity. Shared partials in many ideophones can be isolated as possessing identifiable meaning. These partials can be recombined to form new ideophones. Bolinger (1940) has labelled the diachronic process 'accretion', and Samarin (1989) refers to the resultant phenomenon as 'clustering'. In another paper (Childs 1988) call it 'neutralization', focusing on the fact that segments which contrast elsewhere do not contrast among some sets of ideophones. In Kisi no systematicity appears, yet there is enough phonetic similarity among semantically related ideophones to hint that such systematicity is possible, as illustrated below. I (18) (a) H H H H dOnggu-dOnggu 'going H L H L donggo-donggo lasting a long time or happening on for a long time' repeatedly' (b) H H yeng-yeng 'alert, clear, H H H H yengge-yengge 'delicately H H H H yenggeng-yenggeng HH H H yElEng / (ears) wide open' balanced, about to topple' 'balanced, alert, listening carefully' HH yElEng-yEIEng 'slowly, gently, delicately' we assume that each set of examples represents one ideophone, we can see how contrasts elsewhere in the language are suspended in the ideophonic subsection. Back vowels are in free variation in (18a), and in (18b) we see even sequences differing even in syllable structure can mean the same thing. A If potentially d...ngg..., meaning-bearing as in (18a). unit, for example, would be the non-concatenative 66 3.5 Studies in the Linguistic Sciences 19:2 (Fall 1989) Summary From this discussion of ideophones and other word classes, we see that ideophones and verbs form a closer bond than do ideophones and any other word category. That ideophones show more affinities with verbs than with other word classes is registered quantitatively and in the close formal and semantic similarities. Besides the clustering that is a harbinger of sound symbolism, we see clearly how ideophones are derived from verbs. The process can be seen as consisting of two steps. more 1. Reduplication. 2. Reanalysis. This stage changes. (19) A verb is repeated for emphasis. The repeated verb is analyzed as a separate word. may be accompanied by segmental and tonal now consider ideophone derivation in other African languages, many of which possess fully productive processes for deriving new ideophones from verbs. The process we have identified in Kisi is just one of several types. I 4. New Ideophones in other African languages Language-specific processes can be separated from universal ones. In all processes are particular to a language, but some are shared with many languages and may be universal. The display below presents an overview of the processes under consideration. actual fact, (20) Universal 4.1 Language-specific Onomatopoeia Sound symbolism Accretion Borrowing Reanalysis Productive derivational processes Sound symbolism Language universal processes Although the extent to which forms said to be onomatopoeic truly imitate sounds of nature is problematic, most onomatopoeic forms draw their substance from speakers mimicking sounds in nature. In some sense onomatopoeic forms are significantly different from ideophones. Only a relatively small proportion of ideophones are usually based on sound, e.g., Samarin 1965. Nonetheless, ; Childs: there is Where do ideophones come from? 67 a process by which onomatopoeic forms become ideophones and even verbs, as has been noticed by others, e.g., Alexandre (1966:24). Some examples of onomatopoeic ideophones and cognate forms are given below. (21 Gbaya 68 Studies in the Linguistic Sciences 19:2 (Fall 1989) (23) H L L Childs: Where do ideophones come from? 69 the same way ideophones do. Pidgins used by African speakers notoriously borrow ideophones (Noss 1975:146). in Bulu. Below appear some examples of borrowings converted to ideophones (The particle ne often marks the following word as an ideophone.) (26) L H L ne fonos L LH 'repulsive' in < English 'punish' LH ne didon-didon 'flirtatiously' < French 'dis-donc' (Alexandre 1966) It is universal processes such as onomatopoeia, (universal) sound symbolism, and borrowing that serve to supplement the expressive resources of a language in general, and of ideophones in particular. No one process, however, contributes in any major way to the augmentation of the word class of ideophones. now turn to several language specific processes. I 4.2 Language specific processes A number of language-particular processes also provide for the creation of new ideophones. A necessary preliminary step for the existence of a productive system of phonesthemes or (local) sound symbolism depends on a process of accretion (Bolinger 1940). Accretion is the process by which language-particular non-arbitrary sound-meaning correspondences are built up, namely, the building of sound- symbolic associations. The original associations, of course, are completely arbitrary, as are the first similar sound-meaning correspondences, but then both sound and meaning changes provide a set of correspondences. Structure can arise in a self-organizing way (Lindblom 1986). Sound symbolism is present when these associations reach some undefined critical mass. Sound symbolism a relatively pervasive association of a sound pattern As shown above, there are universal associations of this type; there are also local, language-specific associations. In an intermediate stage, patterns of association exist which have arisen from changes of the sort described in languages with documented time depth. is with a specific meaning. (27) ham hEm hal hEI pal pEI (Samarin 1989) The sound-meaning correspondence could have begun with one ideophone and gradually attracted other ideophones, which subsequently changed their form, their meaning, or both. Productive sound symbolism is illustrated below. 70 Studies in the Linguistic Sciences 19:2 (Fall 1989) A third process is reanalysis. Reanalysis requires that speakers Interpret a sequence as containing an ideophone and subsequently treating the item as an ideophone. This process is important for ideophones being derived from the second half of a reduplicated verb in Kisi, as indicated above. The reverse process is well attested, a situation where a verb and an ideophone are interpreted as a verb, e.g., Kanuri (Hutchison 1981). In addition to reanalysis, there may be derivational processes specific to a A common observation is that ideophones are closely related to e.g., Marivate 1985). Because of this close relationship, it is not surprising that verbs provide the major source for new ideophones, as has been shown for Kisi, where it is mediated by reduplication. Although discuss this process as language-specific or internal process, suggest below that it is universal in that it involves the use of reduplication for expressiveness, a language. verbs (cf., I I process in and of itself universal. Alexandre demonstrates the importance of reduplication for deriving ideophones from verbs. Bulu ideophones are derived from verbs by various forms of reduplication. (28) L -bom HH L -^ (ne) L L L L bpmp-bomo-bpmp HH HH -jae -> (ne)Jae-Jae LL kaaft (Alexandre 1966:22) 'fill' Ekere has similarly found that ideophones a process of reduplication. (29) 'strike' in Ibibio are related to verbs by LL LL LL kaaAkaafikaaft 'limp' 'clumsily LL niyak 'limp with L L L L niyak-niyak 'limpingly' a sore between the thighs' (Ekere 1988a, 1988b) Note how the process illustrated here is different from that identified for Kisi. Here, as in Southern Bantu, ideophones are simply reduplicated verbs. In Kisi, as demonstrated above, ideophones likely arose from the second part of a reduplicated verb. Because Kisi uses verbal reduplication for pluralization and because the process is 'newer' (Childs 1987), this resource is no longer available to speakers of the language and may explain why the process of ideophone derivation is no longer productive. Childs: Where do ideophones come from? 71 A second type of productive derivational process, discussed above, features recurrent partials that recombine productively, as exemplified below: (30) Nembe phonesthemes (Maduka mi kpi -^ [+S0FT1 ^ [+WELL-MARKED] [+WELL-MARKED] gb-j -^ LL L L 1988b:107) LH kpokorokpokoro LARGE(R) ansl ROUND and WELL-MARKED H L HH gbodoroo LARGE(R) and ROUND and WELL-MARKED LL L L LL SOFT and SMALL and THIN m^ftlam^gala LH L L L L SOFT and LARGE and ROUND mugurumuguru (31) 'psychomorphs' in Igbo km (medial [k] or (Maduka 1988a) 'back and [g]) forth" regerege 'swinging side to side' kwakakwaka 'shaking side to side' (32) Non-concatenative phonesthemes of Yoruba (Awoyale 1988) i 'hard, solid' u 'sealed r-g-d 'largeness' p-l-b 'flatness' gbirigidi 'of solid rigid! 'round, solid, massive' ragada 'very wide' These examples illustrate matter rolling with much off' impact' a highly productive system of language-specific sound symbolism. Thus far have sketched out a number of processes for the creation of new ideophones. Cross-linguistically and within Kisi derivation from verbs stands out as the most common. It can even take several forms, in some languages being an entirely productive process. I 5. Implications and conclusion It identify has been shown that with sufficient ingenuity and imagination, we can a process of ideophone derivation in Kisi that was probably once more 72 Studies in the Linguistic Sciences 19:2 (FaU 1989) many other African languages. We should not be surprised that verbal reduplication serves as the primary source for new ideophones. Their close relationship to verbs recommends this analysis and may raise something of a chicken-egg question, were it not for the derivational directionality we have been able to establish. active in the language, replicating a process found in That the process used is reduplication is also not surprising. Reduplication is a universal process; other facts about ideophones fall into line with consideration of universal features of reduplication. (33) 1. Reduplicated structure entails the meaning of its nonreduplicated part (implying that reduplication is semantically additive) 2. Conveys 3. Can Ideophones and amount of intensity change (Moravcsik 1978) quantity of referents also convey word class add an extra dimension of meaning, as in Moravcsik's convey intensity, typically in the action itself. Verbs represent the strongest candidate for the ___location of such information, as was exemplified in Kisi verb pluralization. There has also been a word class first point. change, as They in clearly certainly her third point, i.e., from verb to ideophone. On the basis of the facts of Kisi and other languages coupled with universals of reduplication, we can make a strong prediction about the between reduplication and ideophone derivation. The prediction is is a process of ideophone derivation, it will involve reduplication, and probably reduplication of verbs. The process need not be synchronically active and may even be overridden by language-specific considerations. In Kisi we observe a situation where the formal resources of the universal process have been usurped by verb pluralization. Nonetheless, traces of ideophone relationship that if there derivation by reduplication exist. recommend we view the issue of ideophone derivation in a concern with universals. Cross-linguistic comparisons show that ideophone-like words are found in many, if not all, languages. Furthermore, have shown how ideophones exploit a universal morphological process in augmenting their number, even suggesting that the production of ideophones in such ways is also a universal. To find out what is truly universal and basic, even creative about human language, one needs to examine expressive language, especially when it manifests itself so prominently in a language as do ideophones in African languages. In terms conclusion, I of I half of the question posed by the title clue as to the ultimate origin of ideophones. If ideophones were not originally ideophones, then they were probably verbs. The only problem now is to identify where the verbs come from. To of my return to the paper, unanswered second we may have some Childs: Where do ideophones come from? 73 NOTES Unusual conventions used '+' The '+' in this (plus sign) before with the next '+' paper one or more tones representing a raised register representing the end of that raised register. Reduplicated parts of an ideophone are separated with a '-' (hyphen). Tvpocraphical conventions ng ny c L H the velar nasal the palatal nasal the voiceless alveo-palatal affricate low tone high tone * Much of the data for this paper Research Grant. would also comments and criticism. like to I was acquired with the aid of a Fulbright thank William J. Samarin for his helpful The word for 'candy' may represent a borrowing from French, as has been suggested by several commentators, but such a derivation is unlikely. The reduplicated form is usually the newer of reduplicated and nonreduplicated forms. Furthermore, French-Kisi bilinguals showed no awareness of such an etymology (as they did in other cases). Tonal evidence also argues against borrowing: on the basis of other borrowings, tones on the putatively borrowed form would be different than the tones actually found. 1 2 for Co, roughly speaking, one form is the present form and is wa the past. What is true true for the other. REFERENCES ALEXANDRE, Pierre. 1966. Preliminaire k une pr6sentation des ideophones bulu. Neue Afrikanistische Studien, ed. by Johannes Lukas (Hamburger Beitrage zur Afrika-Kunde, Afrika-Forschung. 5), 9-28. Hamburg: Deutsches Institut fur 74 Studies in the Linguistic Sciences 19:2 (Fall 1989) ANSRE, Gilbert. Linguistics, 1). 1961. The Hartford, tonal structure of Ewe (Hartford Studies in CT: Hartford Seminary. Yiwola. 1988. On the non-concatenative morphology of Yoruba ideophones. Paper given at the 19th African Linguistics Conference, Boston University (14-16 April 1988). BOLINGER, Dwight L. 1940. Word affinities. American Speech 15:62-73. Reprinted in Forms of English (1965) 192-202. Cambridge, MA: Harvard AWOYALE, University Press. BOLINGER, Dwight L. 1949. The sign is not arbitrary. Boletin del Institute Caro y Cuervo 5:52-62. Also in Forms of English (1965), 231-40. Cambridge, MA: Harvard University Press. Carr, Denzel. 1966. Homorganicity m Malay/Indonesian expressives and quasi expressives. Language 42:2.370-377. Childs, G. Tucker. 1987. Verb extension renewal in Kisi. Current approaches Dordrecht, to African linguistics 4, ed. by David Odden, 73-91. Holland/Cinnaminson, NJ: Foris Publications. Childs, G. Tucker. 1988. The phonology of Kisi ideophones. Journal of African languages and linguistics 10:165-190. DECAMP, David. 1974. Neutralizations, iteratives, and ideophones: the locus of language in Jamaica. Pidgins and Creoles: current trends and prospects, ed. by David DeCamp & Ian F. Hancock, 46-60. Washington, DC: Georgetown University Press. DURBIN, Marshall. 1973. Sound symbolism in the Mayan language family. Meaning in Mayan languages: Ethnolinguistic studies, ed. by Munro S. Edmonson, 23-49. The Hague: Mouton. EKERE, Michael Edoabasi. 1988a. Ideophones in serial verb constructions: a case study of Ibibio. Department of Languages ms.. The Polytechnic, Calabar, Cross River State, Nigeria. Ekere, Michael Edoabasi. 1988b. Nominal Ideophones in Ibibio. Department of Languages ms., The Polytechnic, Calabar, Cross River State, Nigeria. FORTUNE, George. 1962. Ideophones in Shona. London: Oxford University Press. Frei, Henri. HILL, 1970. Cinquante onomatop6es japonaises. M6langes Marcel Cohen, ed. by David Cohen (Janua Linguarum, Series Maior, 27). The Hague: Mouton. Archibald A. 1972. Sound-symbolism in lexicon and literature. Studies in The Hague/Paris: linguistics in honor of George L. Trager, 142-147. Mouton. 1981. Kanuri word formation and the structure of the P. Nilo-Saharan proceedings, ed. by M. Lionel Bender & Thilo C. Schadeberg, 217-237. Cinnaminson, NJ: Foris. INNES, Gordon. 1964. Some features of theme and style in Mende folktales. Sierra Leone language review, 3:6-19. Jakobson, Roman & Linda R. Waugh. 1987. The sound shape of language (2nd ed.). Berlin/New Yori</Amsterdam: Mouton de Gruyter. Hutchison, John lexicon. Childs: Where do ideophones come from? 75 KUNENE, Daniel P. 1965. The ideophone in Southern Sotho. Journal of African Languages 4:19-39. LiNDBLOM, Bjorn. 1986. On the origin and purpose of discreteness and Invariance in sound patterns. Invariance and variability in speech processes, ed. by Perkell & Klatt, 493-523. Hillsdale, NJ: Lawrence Eribaum. Maduka, Omen N. 1983-84. Igbo Ideophones and the lexicon. Journal of the Linguistic Association of Nigeria, No. 2:23-29. Omen N. 1988a. The Km critical psychomorph in Igbo. Paper presented at the Ninth Annual Conference of the Linguistic Association of Nigeria (Obafemi Awolowo University, lle-lfe, Nigeria, 31 July-4 August f^ADUKA, 1988). f^/lADUKA, Omen N. 1988b. Size and shape ideophones in Nembe. Studies in African Linguistics 19:2.93-113. fy/lARiVATE, C. T. D. 1985. The ideophone as a Southern Bantu languages. Studies in syntactic category in the African linguistics, supplement 9:210-214. MARTIN, Samuel E. 1962. Phonetic symbolism in Altaic linguistics, ed. by N. Poppe in (Uralic Korean. and In American studies Altaic Series 13), 177-89.. Bloomington, IN: Indiana University Press. 1986. Tone, intonation, and sound symbolism in Lahu: stretching the syllable canon. Paper delivered at the Sound Symbolism Conference, University of California, Beri<eley, January 16-18, 1986. MiTHUN, Marianne. 1982. The synchronic and diachronic behavior of plops, squeaks, croaks, sighs, and moans. International Journal of American Linguistics 48:49-58. MORAVCSIK, Edith A. 1978. Reduplicative constructions. Universals of Human Language 3: Word Structure, ed. by J. H. Greenberg, C. Ferguson, & E. A. Moravcsik, 297-334. Stanford, CA: Stanford University Press. Nemer, Julie F. 1987. Phonological stereotypes and names in Temne. Language in Society 16:341-352. NOSS, Philip A. 1975. The ideophone: a linguistic and literary device in Gbaya and Sango with reference to Zande. Directions in Sudanese linguistics and folklore, ed. by S.H. Hurreiz & H. Bell, 142-152. Khartoum: Khartoum Matisoff, James A. University Press. Philip A. 1985. The ideophone in Gbaya syntax. Current approaches to African linguistics 3, ed. by G. J. Dimmendaal, 241-255. Dordrecht/Cinnaminson, NJ: Foris Publications. Nurse, G. T. 1974. Verb species relationships of some Nyanja ideophones. African Studies 33:4.227-242. Ohala, John J. 1984. An ethological perspective on common cross-language utilization of Fq of voice. Phonetica 41:1-1 6. Ratliff, Martha. 1986. A test for tonal iconicity in White Hmong expressives. Paper delivered at the Sound Symbolism Conference, University of California, Berkeley, 16-18 January 1986. NOSS, 76 Studies in the Linguistic Sciences 19:2 (Fall 1989) Samarin, William J. 1965. Perspective on African ideophones. African Studies 24:117-121. Samarin, William of West Samarin, William in J. 1967. Determining the meanings of ideophones. Journal African Linguistics 4:2.35-41. J. 1973. Linguistic adaptation to anthopology, ed. by William speech function. McCormack (Proceedings Language of the IXth Congress of Anthropological Sciences, Chicago, 1973). The Hague: Mouton and Co. Samarin, William J. 1989. Intersubjective and intradialectal variation in Gbeya ideophones. Paper presented at the 20th Annual Conference on African Linguistics, April 19-22, University of Illinois, Urbana-Champaign. Smithers, C. V. 1954. Some English ideophones. Archivum Linguisticum International 6:73-111. VOELTZ, Erhard Friedrich K. 1971 Toward the syntax of the ideophone in Zulu. Papers in African linguistics, ed. by Chin-Wu Kim and Herbert Stahike, 141-52. Edmonton/Champaign: Linguistic Research, Inc. VON Staden, Paul M. S. 1977. Some remarks on ideophones in Zulu. African . Studies 36:2.195-224. WESCOTT, Roger W. 1973. Tonal 4:197-205. icons in Bini. Studies in African Linguistics Studies in the Linguistic Sciences Volunne 19, Number 2, Fall 1989 CURRENT RESEARCH ON SHINZWANI IDEOPHONES & Heather Primrose Kansas State University Harriet Ottenheimer This paper explores the use of ideophones in ShiNzwani Islands) narratives. A Collection of tape-recorded narratives provides the basic data for a survey of ideophones. Methods of identification (listening to tapes, reading through transcripts, developing computerized concordances) are discussed and evaluated. Variant versions of selected narratives are compared for relative frequency of ideophone use and for differences attributable to gender, age, story-type and locale. Transcriptions of tape-recorded examples are provided. (Comoro Spoken on the Comoro archipelago, ShiNzwani Hinnebusch and Nurse place it within the Sabaki family with elements of both northern and southern KiSwahili dialects (see Hinnebusch 1985, Hinnebusch and Nurse 1984, Nurse 1983, Nurse and Spear 1985). KiSwahili is said to have few ideophones (see Deed 1939; Doke 1954; Snoxhall 1938; Samarin 1971:134), and ShiNzwani, too, does not appear to have many. This paper is a summary of cun-ent research in ideophones and ideophone use in ShiNzwani. is island of Anjouan in the related to, but separate from, KiSwahili. The data from which we are working was collected during several field sessions ranging from 1967 to 1982. The collection includes folktales, narratives, riddles, recipes, interviews and oral histories. Most of the texts were taped in 1967-68 by Comorian student assistants (ShiNzwani speakers). A few were taped by Harriet Ottenheimer or by her husband, Martin Ottenheimer, the leader of the 1967-68 research team. A few of the contexts were natural, most were not. Most have been transcribed, sometimes by the student who had collected the texts, sometimes by others. All of the texts have been broadly translated and some have been analyzed in detail. In addition to preparing the texts for publication we have also been using them to construct the ShiNzwaniEnglish Dictionary. 78 Studies in the Linguistic Sciences 19:2 (Fall 1989) Our search native-speakers for ideophones was greatly simplified by the fact that the transcribed the texts included ideophones in the transcriptions. We put a few transcriptions through KWIC-MAGIC, a concordance program designed for bilingual texts, but the output proved more cumbersome to use than the transcripts themselves. Most useful, in the end, was reading through the transcripts and listening to the tapes first separately and then together. Primrose read through the transcripts and marked likely ideophones; Ottenheimer listened to the tapes and noted likely ideophones. When we compared notes we found a high level of agreement. A final thorough examination of both tape and transcript was required for those examples on which we differed to be certain of our interpretations. We then used LEXWARE, a set of computer programs designed for bilingual dictionaries, to sort and resort the list; sorting by gloss, for example, made potential cases of soundsymbolism easier to identify. who — We found it useful to distinguish between ideophones, emphatics and ShiNzwani intensives are principally ordinary words which are altered in some way most often doubled or stretched in order to intensify their meanings. They may be verbs {aende 'he went' becomes aeeeeende 'he went and went), adverbs {mbio 'quickly' becomes mbio mbio 'very quickly'), demonstratives {hule 'over there' becomes huleeee 'waaaay over there') or adjectives {masera 'crazy' becomes maseraaaa 'very crazy'). We did not count intensives but there appear to be a lot of them. Ideophones, on the other hand, are not ordinary words and are therefore nearly impossible to translate. Although some of them appear to be stretched (krrrrrr) they do not have any 'unstretched' forms to refer back to. Although they are sometimes doubled, tripled, quadrupled, or further multiplied (gara gara gara gara) they do not appear to have any specific meaning or even to exist as single words. Emphatics are emotive expressions {AH, Fa!, Oheeee!, Unhun!) while ideophones provide sensory descriptions {ba, dududududu, vwiiii). intensives. — — — — Syntactically, ideophones generally follow verbs (the cattle came, dadadadada; they fell, bwa bwa bwa, he pounced, ba), emphatics follow mba, a word best glossed as 'he said' or 'that' or 'quote' (He said, quote, 'Ail'; She cried out, quote, 'Oheeee! ') or they begin sentences ('Hai! What is this here?), and intensives function in the same way as their unintensified base forms do. Laughter was a particularly difficult example to deal with. Although seemed like an ideophone at first, behaved structurally like an emphatic and so, in the ' it it end, we classified it as such. Ideophones in ShiNzwani are probably adverbials. There are no surface manifestations of an auxiliary verb phrase such as Marivate suggests for southern Bantu (1985:210-214). 'He pounced,' bwa, may indeed imply an auxiliary 'in this way' in ShiNzwani but it is impossible to be certain from the texts. Additionally, although they do not appear to be inflected, it is likely that some derivation takes place, particularly with respect to verbs. The relationship Ottenheimer between kwala for example, is & Primrose: Current Research on Shinzwani Ideophones 'a clinking, clattering noise' and hukwala 'to bump 79 into, to kick," possibly derivational. All of the ideophones we found were in folktales and riddles. There were none in conversations, interviews, histories, recipes, or other narratives. Nor were there particularly large numbers of ideophones in the folktales and riddles. This surprised us as we had been expecting to find high levels of ideophone use, particularly in these two latter forms (Whiteley 1966:154; Johnson 1976:241). Instead, we found relatively few ideophones in our texts. In twentythree folktales and one set of riddles (112 pages in all) we found fewer than fifty distinct ideophones. There was some repetition within texts but not much. Generally an ideophone was used once, in a very specific context, and not repeated unless the context (or scene) was repeated. This low incidence of ideophones in folktexts probably parallels the infrequent use of such words in the language in general. While all narrators used many expressive devices such as emphatics and intensives, expressiveness itself did not appear to be a significant indicator of ideophone use. Less animated narrators were as likely Some very expressive to use ideophones as more lively narrators were. narrators used very few, if any, ideophones. Others used as many as 2 per page (typed, double-spaced). Some of these findings are summarized in the following table: GENDER AGE female 60-70 SETTING TEXTS PAGES IDEOPH. REPET. male (numbers are totals, not averages) The ShiNzwani data indicates that men use ideophones more frequently than women. In fact, most women used no ideophones at all. Of seven narrations by women, only two (28%) contained any ideophones. Of seventeen narrations by men only two did not contain any ideophones (i.e., 88% contained ideophones). Furthermore men used ideophones twice as much as women; men's ideophone use ranged from .3 to 2.3 occurrences per typed page while women's ideophone use only ranged between .14 and 1 per typed page. Context is probably most important here, as this is predominantly an All of the recordings of women were made in the 1960s with running the tape recorder. This was not the most natural setting, as women more often told stories to children or other women. Occasionally a woman's husband and/or brother was also present during the tale-telling session, and this might have created a more comfortable story-telling setting for Islamic society. men 80 Studies in the Linguistic Sciences 19:2 (Fall 1989) these women. There when narrating to culturally work a chance that women who used few, if any ideophones might have behaved differently with a different (more appropriate) audience. It will take some focused field research to is men this out. Urbanization Not among men. may correlate with some differences many folktales were collected in rural in ideophone use settings, but every one of them used ideophones. More folktales were collected in the town Domoni, but only about 85% of the urban collection included ideophones. One specific story collected in a rural setting had four times as many ideophones as its urban counterpart. Nonetheless, both rural and urban men who did use ideophones did so with about the same frequency (averaging one per page). Age did not appear to be a factor in the data that was collected in 1967-68. Some of the more recent data suggest, however, that aging may influence ideophone use. Two of the tales that were collected in 1982 were renarrated by the same individual. In each case this individual used fewer ideophones in the newer versions than in the earlier ones. Context may account for these differences, also, as the earlier versions were narrated to a WaNzwani audience, while the 1982 ones were not (and may have been intended to be reminders or summaries). Again, further fieldwork could resolve single of some of these questions. The level of ideophone use in ShiNzwani seems better correlated with Narrators who used ideophones individual narrators than with specific stories. in one story were likely to use them in others. Different people telling the same way they used ideophones. Ideophone use is also textspecific to some degree. Certain actions or scenes are more likely to provide openings for ideophones than others (whether these openings are taken advantage of or not is a more individual matter). However, when sacks of glass are opened and spilled out on the beach, for example, or when someone is rushing away on horseback, the discourse is almost ripe for the insertion of ideophones. Yet not every individual uses every one of these opportunities. stories varied in the A scene that is repeated one or more times in a text may contain an ideophone each time, or it may not. The ideophone used in each occurrence of the scene may be the same one, it may be a variant, or it may be a different ideophone. One narrator used three slightly different ideophones in one story to describe climbing a chain (gagara gagara gagara, garara garara garara, and gara gara gara). He used one of the three ideophones (gara gara gara) in a different story to represent pulling a bucket up from a well. (If one considers the hand-over-hand action common to both situations these might be variants of the same ideophone). Kicking or opening or dumping out sacks of glass provides another appropriate setting for ideophone use. Most often this is something like kwalalalala, but there are other possibilities such as krrrror shwaa XhaX are used and for some narrators the scene is not marked by an ideophone at all. . . Ottenheimer & Primrose: Current Research on Shinzwani Ideophones 81 There are several examples of the same ideophone representing different Kwalalalala, for example represents the clinking of broken glass but it is also used for the lowering of a chain. Shwa represents kicking a sack of glass Rrrrrr with one's foot and turning one's horse quickly or galloping away. represents the unwinding of a chain and the growling of a monster. It is possible that there is a common semantic range that we are unaware of in these ideophones but would take more work with native speakers to be certain. ideas. it be a very slight tendency toward sound symbolism, for example, appears to be associated with rapid, continuous motion (a horse running, a ring spinning, a chain unwinding, [k] and [1] seem to associate with clinking sounds, [g] seems to be associated with foot and hand motions (pulling up, climbing up, knocking on the door). There also appears consonants, at least for to [r], sum, although there are relatively few ShiNzwani ideophones, they do be a separate class. They are probably adverbials, following specific syntactic and text-sensitive mles. Gender and locale (and possibly age) also seem to have some predictive value. Finally, although there seems to be a tendency towards sound-symbolism, there is also quite a bit of room for individual improvisation. Ideophones are particularly difficult items to work with, especially for non-native speakers. The fact that one of us has good fluency in KiSwahili and the other in ShiNzwani, helped immeasurably in preparing this paper. Yet we feel that this paper has raised many more questions than it has answered. We anticipate that further fieldwork, focused at least in part on ideophones, will be necessary. In appear to EXAMPLES (1) Vushuka watsunga wakuzhonosa zi nyombe. Mmmm. A herdsman came down to water his cattle. Mmmm. Akia zi nyombe hale zizhao dadadadadada N/lmmm. [Banawasi] heard the how the cattle were coming dadadadadada . Arongoa mba, He said, . . . . . Mmmm. 82 Studies in the Linguistic Sciences 19:2 (Fall 1989) (2) 'I mali izha irengwa The wealth was taken, wahimondro tsomoa hule, and when they dumped it out, ta mabai ya falasika de ya shukao, bwa bwa bwa was pieces of bottles which fell out, bwa bwa bwa . it . Tsiremwa mahava tsitolewa." was slapped and was sent away.' I I 'Kwaaa kwa kwa kwa kwa kwa, tsihu kubalia na mfuko wa dhahabu, 'Haaa ha ha ha ha ha, will give you a sack of gold, I be endra ta meso but wait vo.' tomorrow.' until (3) Bahe azhosika gagara gagara gagara gaqara Her father grabbed and gagara gagara gagara gagara it ahea zhu hule. he climbed up to the top. (4) Arongoa 'Ai masikini u He 'Ai! My poor said, mwana wangu daughter is afu. dead. Mwana wangu jini lizha limuli.' My daughter, a djinn has come and eaten her.' Bako tsio areme ishundri ne asiki isilisili, The old man cried a tear but he grabbed the garara gara ra garara garara oarara. oarara garara oarara o arara aarara. ta ahea until hule. he climbed to the top. chain, ' Ottenheimer & Prinuose: Current Research on Shinzwani Ideophones 83 (5) Mwana vo akia mba ule de bahe, When the child heard [the djinn] sounding like her father, andra vambua upetro vie, jm, ta udmbu u montsi she unwound the chain, rrrr, until it reached the ground. Bako jini ausiki, gara qara gara gara gara qara The old djinn grabbed [and climbed up], gara gara gara gara gara gara . it ata until mwezimgu amtria nia alawa, ahizhohima mlangozhu. God gave her the notion to leave, while he was climbing . . to the door. (6) Ashishi hule hutsaha ya mazhi. He lowered it down to get some Banda ashisha, dia, As soon as he had lowered it, water. dra . vwa daria hule nyoha ile ingia kamwe. nyoha ingia vale. the snake climbed inside of it. The snake climbed in. ta I i Ta ahendro tsudza zhau vwa vudzitro. And when he was lifting the bucket was it very heavy. Ahedza, gara gara gara gara gara gara gara He raised it, gara gara gara gara gara gara cara. . ta ahendro hedza akuona nyoha. while he was raising it he saw the snake. until (7) Bako ule avutsu umundru vuvuni ya kwaka. The old man thrust a foot underneath where [the sacks] were. Akia kwala Arongoa 'Ail Vani una mpesa halini? He heard kwala He said, 'Ai! You have money like this? ' ' ' .' Hail Unu Hail This akentsi hashizaya vani. guy .' . lives in poverty here. . . . . . 84 Studies in the Linguistic Sciences 19:2 (Fall 1989) (8) Ule areme She Mba li bahe lahe ntrini. the [sacks he said his father had given him]. hit asikia kwalalalaiala And she heard . kwalalalaiala Alawa amwambia bahe. Then she went to tell her . father. (9) Guni The la handra libulwa tswaa sack was opened tswaa .' ' first .' ' Mabai yafalasika. litsomolewa, kwalalala was dumped out, kwalalala .' Pieces of bottles. .' ' it ' Vuvurwa la vili, krrrrrrrrr Mabai ya falasika. The second was dug into, krn'rrrrr Pieces of .' ' .' bottles. Vuvurwa la raru. Mabai ya falasika. The third was dug into. Pieces of bottles. Bako ule tsio azhahasira: The old man became angry: 'Ail 'Ai! Mkantre roho yahe.' He is a person who would cut your heart out.' (10) Bweni avutsu mundru, akia kwalalala put her foot [there], and heard kwalalala . The woman Ahentsi mba, 'Zile mpesa.' She thought, 'That's money.' (11) Na ule asusisa i sllisili ile And she would lower kwalalalaiala the chain kwalalalaiala idaria montsi. until it reached the ground. . Ottenheimer & Primrose: Current Research on Shinzwani Ideophones 85 (12) Tsimono ule avutsu u mundru, shwa vuvuni. saw him kick with his foot, shwa underneath. . 'I it Ufanya shwaa It went, shwaa . ! ! Anambia mba na wantru dagoni hoho wana hamu ta. He told me that the people at his home were very sad Indeed. Ule, mwana wa mfalume, tsio. "Kwaaa kwa kwa kwa kwa kwa kwa" There she was, the king's daughter. "Kwaaa kwa kwa kwa kwa kwa kwa" atsehe karnwe.' laughing already.' (13) Mwana wa The waziri ule son took vizier's arenge ifarasi yahe, his horse, mbio, mbio ta ahimovira zhezhe wale wamsheudza, 'Hee, hee.' quickly, quickly, until Ne tsishuguli yahe, aviri vale, But it fwiii [the fatiha] they hailed him, 'Hey, hey. . wasn't any of his concern and he passed by, Mwana wa The i fwiii . azha ta ahipara Zhomani awadzisa wale mba son continued until he arrived at Zhomani and asked waziri vizier's 'Vale, 'Is when he passed by hazi ile ikomo?" the work finished there?' Wale wamsiki wampulia ngamani, wamfinikia. They grabbed him and pushed him into the pit, and covered him Mwanamtsa ule tsio Then the youth left. Alawa vasa vo na He left i alawa vasa. Wakati The time farasi . ruru ruru . hendra hule adzisa. he arrived. until fatiha yavira. was yahe, mbio mbio, with his horse, quickly, quickly, ruru ruru ta i of the fatiha finished. up. 86 Mba Studies in the Linguistic Sciences 19:2 (Fall 1989) hazi 'I [He asked,] Mba ikomo?' 'Is the work finished?' 'Ikomo.' [They said,] Abuzudza He turned mba ile i 'It's finished.' farasi shwa shwa ta andre hule amwambia mfalume. shwa and he went and told the king, horse shwa his 'Tsende hule. saying, 'I went Waziri wakati When I there. hazi ile ikomo.' The work is finished.' amona mwanamtsa ule azhua mba mwana wahe afu. saw that youth, he knew that his [own] son was dead. the vizier NOTES A version of this paper was presented African Linguistics, University of Illinois at 20th Annual Conference on Urbana-Champaign, April 19-22, at the 1989 REFERENCES 1987. The phonology of Kisi Ideophones. Paper presented to the Phonology Lab, UCB. MS. DEED, F.I. 1939. Ideophones and onomatopoetics in Swahili. Inter-territorial Language Committee, Bulletin 13. DOKE, Clement. 1954. The Southern Bantu languages. London and New York: Oxford University Press. DURBIN, Marshall. 1973. Sound symbolism in the Mayan language family. Meaning in Mayan languages: ethnolinguistic studies, ed. by Munro S. Edmonson, 23-49. The Hague: Mouton. FINNEGAN, Ruth. 1970. Oral literature in Africa. Oxford: Oxford University CHILDS, G. Tucker. Press. HINNEBUSCH, Thomas. appraisal. 1985. HINNEBUSCH, Thomas & Derek affiliations. JOHNSON, Sabaki and lexicostatistics: African Studies Association Meetings ms.. Nurse. 1984. a critical New Comorian: Orleans. external linguistic African Studies Association Meetings ms., Los Angeles. Marion R. 1976. Toward a definition of the ideophone Ohio State University Working Papers in Linguistics 21 :240-253. in Bantu. Ottenheimer & Primrose: Current Research on Shinzwani Ideophones 87 MARIVATE, C.T.D. 1985. The ideophone as a syntactic category in the Southern Bantu languages. Studies in African Linguistics, Supplement 9:210-214. MITHUN, Marianne. 1982. The synchronic and diachronic behavior of plops, squeaks, croaks, sighs, and moans. International Journal of American Linguistics 48:49-58. NURSE, Derek. 1983. Is Comorian Swahili? Being an examination of the diachronic relationship between Comorian and Coastal Swahili. Round Table on the Limits of Swahili ms., Paris. NURSE, Derek and Thomas Spear. 1985. The Swahili. Philadelphia: University of Pennsylvania Press. OTTENHEIMER, Harriet. 1984. A Shinzwani dictionary for the Comoro Islands. Papers of the Annual Meeting of the African Studies Association, 84:82. Los Angeles: Crossroads Press. OTTENHEIMER, Harriet and Martin Ottenheimer. the languages of the Comoro Islands. 1977. The classification of Anthropological Linguistics December:408-415. SAMARIN, . W.J. 1965. Perspective on African ideophones. African Studies 24:2.117-121. 1967. Determining the meanings of ideophones. Journal of West African Linguistics 4:2.35-41. . . 1970. 169. 1971. Inventory and choice in expressive language. Word 26:2.153- Survey of Bantu ideophones. African Language Studies 12:1 30- 168. SNOXHALL, R.A. 1938. The ideophone in Swahili. Inter-territorial Language Committee Bulletin 12. WHITELEY, W. H. 1966. A study of Yao sentences. Oxford: Clarendon Press. Ill & Phonology Laura Tone J. Tonology downing in Jita questions Larry M. hyman Accent in Bantu: An appraisal Claude Timmons & Christian Dunn La selection morphophonologique des classes en kpokolo Studies in Volume 19, the Linguistic Sciences Number 2, Fall 1989 THE INTERACTION OF TONE AND INTONATION IN JITA YES/NO QUESTIONS^ Laura J. Downing University of Illinois In Jita, an E. Bantu language spoken in Tanzania, yes-no questions are realized at a higher pitch than declaratives. If the declarative contains one word with a high tone, the overall tone pattern of the corresponding question does not change. But if the declarative has all low tones, then the corresponding question is realized at a raised pitch except that the final syllable is low-toned. In this paper will show that these tone patterns may be accounted for by a rule spreading an intonation register high tone from the first syllable of a yes/no question rightwards to the metrically prominent syllable of the utterance, raising high tones to super-high and low tones to high. Finally, the tone pattern of questions is shown to provide evidence that phrase-final extratonality rather than phrasefinal low tone insertion blocks the spread of high tones to phraseI final syllables. 1 . Introduction Jita Is discussed speaker a Lacustrine Bantu language spoken in Tanzania. The data paper come from my field work with F. T. Magayane, a native In this paper will present an Jita from the island of Ukerewe. in this of analysis of the tone pattern of yes/no questions I in Jita. As shown in the data in and (2), if there is at least one high tone in a declarative sentence, as in (la), the corresponding yes/no question (lb) is realized with the same basic tone pattern, except that the tones of all syllables up to and including the one bearing (1) the rightmost high tone are raised: ) 92 Studies in the Linguistic Sciences 19:2 (Fall 1989) (1 Yes/No Question with (a) Ba: ku - - fuli - at least one High Tone^ ye they-you-wash for -tense They have washed (something) (b) Ba: ku - - fGli - for you. ye? they-you-wash for-TENSE Have they washed (something) for you? If there are no high tones in the declarative, as in (2a), then the corresponding yes/no question has raised low tones on all syllables through the penult, as illustrated in (2b): (2) Yes/No Question Ba: with no High Tones (a) ye they-wash for-TENSE They have washed (something) for (someone) (b) Ba: - full - ye? they-wash for-TENSE - fuli - Have they washed (something) for (someone)? In this paper will first argue that the tone pattem of both (lb) and (2b) may be straightforwardly accounted for by a rule spreading an intonational high tone from the first syllable of a yes/no question rightwards to the metrically prominent syllable of the utterance. Then will show that the tone patterns of yes/no questions provide evidence that helps decide between two competing analyses proposed in Downing (1988) to limit the ___domain of high tone shift in Jita. I I 2. Tone Patterns of Yes/No Questions As can be seen by comparing (1a) with (lb) and (2a) with (2b), above, Jita yes/no questions have the same words in the same order as the corresponding declarative sentences. Only intonation distinguishes the two, namely, the overall pitch of yes/no questions is raised. If the declarative has one or more high tones, as in (la), then in the corresponding yes/no question all tones up to and including the rightmost high tone are raised, as shown In (lb). This same pattern is found no matter where in the sentence the rightmost high tone may occur or how many high tones it contains, as shown in the data in (3), (4) and (5): (3) More Yes/No Questions (a) mw you You - pi. a:ma -TENSE (pi.) with at least one High Tone^ - m^l(a) o:ku-t6:ka - finish INF- cook finished cooking (yesterday). Downing: The (b) mw - Interaction of Tone a:ma - and Intonation in Jita 93 mSl(a) 6:ku-tS:ka? you pl.-TEN6E -finish INF- cook Did you (pi.) finish cooking (yesterday)? (4) (a) (b) w - a:ma - suk(a) e:mi - ke:ka you-TENSE - weave CI.4 - mat You wove the mats (yesterday), w - a:ma - s(jk(a) e:mi - ke:ka? you-TENSE - weave CI.4 - mat Did you weave the mats (yesterday)? (5) (a) Ba aBa-fwimf - kal - ire i:-nama they-dry-TENSE Cl.9-meat The hunters have dried the meat, CI. (b) 2-hunter aBa-fwimT Ba- kal -ire i:-fiama? 2-hunter they-dry-TENSE Cl.9-meat Have the hunters dried the meat? CI. In we see second of Comparing (4a) with and (5a) with (5b) shows that the pitch is raised only up to the rightmost tone, even when one or more low-toned words follow. (3b) that the pitch of the yes/no question the two high tones (4b) high is raised up to the the corresponding declarative (3a). in If there are no high tones in the declarative, as in (2a), above, then the corresponding yes/no question has raised low tones on all syllables through the penult, as shown in (2b). This same tone pattern is found no matter how long the sentence may be. The data in (6a), (7a) and (8a) illustrate low-toned sentences of various lengths and structures. Note that the corresponding yes/no questions in (6b), (7b) and (8b) all have a raised low tone through the penult: (6) More Yes/No Questions (a) (b) with no High Tones nguBo ye they-wash for-TENSE Cl.lO-clothes They have washed clothes for (someone). Ba: - full - B^: - fiilf - ji y6 jf - nguBo? they-wash for-TENSE Cl.10-clothes Have they washed clothes for (someone)? (7) (a) Ba: - seiek - er(e) omu - jinga mu cannon They have hidden the cannon in the they- hide - tense CI. 3- - ci - Bira in-CI.7-forest forest. 94 Studies in the Linguistic Sciences 19:2 (Fall 1989) (b) Ba: - seiek - 6:mu- jinga 6r(e) TENSE mu ci - - Bi'ra? cannon in-CI.7-forest Have they hidden the cannon in the forest? they- hide (8) (a) omu - - soni CI.3- a: - o:mu maiisy(e) - limu -seamstress s/he-tinished CI.3 - job The seamstress has finished the job. CI. (b) 1 omu - soni A: - malisy(e) 6:mu - limu? -seamstress s/he-finished CI.3 - job Has the seamstress finished the job? CI. 1 Yes/no questions in then, have basically the Jita, pattern as declaratives, except that the pitch is same relative raised up to a certain point tone in the not a surprising state of affairs. Cruttenden (1986) notes that both Bolinger's (1978) and Ultan's (1978) cross-linguistic surveys report that yes-no questions are characterized by a pitch rise or generally higher pitch in many languages. Further, Lieberman (1967: 130-133), in his cross-linguistic survey of yes/no question intonation, concludes that languages (like Jita) which do not form yes/no questions either by an Interrogative particle, phrase or word or with a change in word order are the ones most likely to have a pitch rise to indicate yes/no questions. Referring to research by Chang (1958) and especially Egerod (1956) on Chinese yes/no question intonation, Lieberman (1967: 130) suggests that 'in tone languages the sentence intonation is ... superimposed on the individual tones.' question. This is This indeed seems to be the case In Jita. Yes/no questions have the same basic tone pattern as the corresponding declaratives, with an intonational high tone 'superimposed' on the basic pattern up to a certain point in the question. As a result, the simple high vs. low tone contrast found on the surface in declaratives becomes a three-way contrast in yes/no questions. This is shown by comparing (1a) with (lb) again (repeated below for convenience): (1) (a) Ba: - ku - full - ye they-you-wash for-TENSE They have washed (something) (b) Bd: - ku - fGli - for you. ye? they-you-wash for-TENSE Have they washed (something) for you? In (la), the declarative, we find only high and low tones (high-toned syllables are marked with an acute accent; low-toned syllables are unmarked). But in (lb), the corresponding yes/no question, we find three tone levels: a raised high tone, indicated by a double acute accent; a raised low tone, indicated by a single acute accent; and a low tone, again unmarked. ) Downing: The Interaction of Tone and Intonation in Jita 95 Adopting and adapting Clements' (1983) proposal that tone in three (or more) level systems - especially those derived by intonational register shifts be represented by a hierarchical feature system, the four tone levels of Jita yes/no questions and declaratives may be represented as in (9): (9) (a) " Raised high tone (indicated by ) (yes/no questions) H raised register I H basic tone I a (b) syllable (= tone-bearing unit) Raised low tone (indicated by ' (yes/no questions) H raised register I L basic tone I a (c) syllable (= tone-bearing unit) Unraised low tone (unmarked) (yes/no questions and declaratives) L basic tone I a (d) syllable (= tone-bearing unit) Unraised high tone (indicated by *) (declaratives only) H basic tone I a syllable (= tone-bearing unit) level high tone in (9a) and (9b) represents the intonational high tone which derives the raised register of yes/no questions. The bottom level high and low tones are the 'basic' tones associated with each syllable after the The upper application of the post-lexical rules, including insertion of default low tones. derive the raised register of yes/no questions, an intonational high tone associated to the tone of the initial syllable of the utterance, as shown in To is first (10): ) 96 Studies in the Linguistic Sciences 19:2 (Fall 1989) (10) Intonational High Tone Assignment H I I I T T I I X$ $ a (X stands for any number of tone-bearing units; $ indicates a phrase boundary; T stands for a high or low tone) The intonational high tone then spreads rightward either to the rightmost high tone of the utterance (as shown in (11a)); or, if there are no high tones, to the penult syllable (as (1 1 (a) shown in (lib)): Intonational Spread to Rightmost High Tone H f-vT T I I $a H I L I Y$ a (X is any number of tone-bearing units; Y is any number of low-toned syllables.) (b) X Intonational Spread to Penult H [•V T L I $a (Y is L I I Y o L I a$ any number The application of these rules (12), and of (2b), given in (13): of low-toned syllables.) is illustrated by the derivation of (lb), given in Downing: The Interaction of Tone and Intonation (12) Derivation of (1b) Ba:kufQliye? 'Have they washed (something) for you?' in Jita 97 98 Studies in the Linguistic Sciences 19:2 (Fall 1989) In (12), after the intonational high tone links to the first spreads to the high tone; while no high tones. in (13) It tone of the utterance, it spreads to the penult, since there are Although the rules in (10) and (11) derive the correct intonational pitch a disadvantage of the rules in (11) defining the ___domain of intonational tone spread so far is, precisely, that there are two rules. One rule, (11a), applies to questions with at least one high tone, while another, (lib), applies to questions with no high tones. It would be preferable to have the same rule or rules apply to derive the tone pattern of all yes/no questions. In order to replace (11a) and (lib) with a single rule, however, it is necessary to show that the rightmost high tone and the penult of questions with no high tones have something in common which attracts the intonational high tone. What propose is that either the rightmost high tone or, if there are no high tones, the penult syllable is designated as the metrically prominent position in a yes/no question by the grid-building rules in (14). (The formulation of these rules is adapted from Selkirk (1984)): patterns, I (14) Grid Building Rules for Yes/No Questions (a) Demi Beat Alignment: Align a first level grid position (b) a sentence. High Tone Beat Addition: Assign a second level (basic) beat (c) Right (demi beat) with all the syllables of End Rule: Add a third level beat to all high-toned syllables. to the final basic beat of the sentence. Rules (11a) and (lib) may now be replaced with a single rule of Attraction to Accent, formulated in (11"), below: 1 ( 1 ') Accent a yes/no question, the intonational high tone spreads rightward up to the syllable bearing the third level beat (or Attraction to In accent (*)).^ Using metrical rules to assign an accent which defines the ___domain of high tone spread rules like (11') has been proposed by Goldsmith, Peterson and Drogo (1986) in their analysis of tone and accent in Xhosa, and by Peterson (to appear) in her analysis of tone in Zulu and Ndebele. Using metrical rules to determine which syllable of a word or phrase attracts a lexical high tone has also been proposed in the analysis of lexical and phrasal tone patterns in other languages, such as ChiChewa (Peterson 1987), and ChiZigula (Kenstowicz and Kisseberth, to appear). And a number of authors (Liberman 1975, Pierrehumbert 1980 and Selkirk 1984) have proposed that intonational pitchaccent tones in English associate with the accented syllable in their ___domain. Downing: The What I propose is that a metrical accent intonational high tones, as The and Interaction of Tone in Jita may and Intonation also define the ___domain of spread of yes/no questions. application of the yes/no question intonation rules formulated in (IT) one high tone is illustrated by the new (14) to questions with at least derivation of (lb) given in (15): (15) 99 in Jita Derivation of (lb) Ba:kufGliye? 'Have they washed (something) for you?' > 100 Studies in the Linguistic Sciences 19:2 (Fall 1989) the grid-building rules apply first, assigning prominence to the rightmost Then the intonational high tone is associated with the first tone of the utterance and spreads to the prominent syllable, deriving the correct tone In (15), high tone. pattern. we try to apply the grid-building rules to questions with no high tones, however, we do not yet derive the correct results. First, since it is the penult and not the final syllable which is assigned prominence in Jita if there are no high tones, the phrase-final syllable must be extrametrical. i.e., invisible to the rules assigning metrical structure (Hayes 1982). The following extrametricality rule must then apply before the metrical rules in (14): If like (2b), Yes/No Questions is marked extrametrical for the construction of the metrical grid which determines the ___domain of spread of the yes/no question intonational high tone. (Following Halle and Vergnaud (1987), extrametrical syllables are indicated by placing them in angled brackets.) (16) Extrametricality in A phrase-final syllable Secondly, since utterances with no high tones do not have a second level beat assigned to them by High Tone Beat Addition (14b), it is not clear how the Right End Rule would assign a third level beat to them either, since it accents the rightmost second level beat. To resolve this problem, assume, following Halle and Vergnaud (1987), that the Right End Rule may be interpreted according to the convention given in (17). (A schematic representation of the effects of the convention on hypothetical grids is also given in (17)): I (17) End Rule (Adapted from Halle & Vergnaud (1987: 71, Interpretive Convention, Right (a) Add a third level fig. (43)) beat to the rightmost basic beat: X X X -> XXX (b) In XX XXX cases where there are no basic beats, a third level placed over the rightmost beat of the next lower beat is the line (i.e., rightmost de mi beat): X — XXX XXX 7b) creates a gap in the column of beats over the penult after the applies, so Halle and Vergnaud (1987) propose another convention, which we might call a Well-Formedness Condition for grids, which Convention Right (1 End Rule Downing: The fills the gap in Interaction of Tone and Intonation 101 in Jita the column of beats above the penult automatically, as shown in (18): (18) Well-Formedness Condition for Grids (WFC) (Adapted from Halle & Vergnaud (1987: 71, figs. (44) and (45)) X X --> X XXX XXX Halle and Vergnaud (1987) propose these two conventions to account for the stress system of languages like Aguacatec Mayan in which the rightmost long syllable is stressed, but in words with no long syllables, the final syllable is stressed. questions, The Since this I assume is prominence pattern and conventions may apply. entirely parallel to the the same rules application of the intonation rules yes/no question with no high tones given in (19): (19) and the new Derivation of (2b) Ba:fulfye? L Output, I post-lex Ba: rules they- Rule (16) L L L III fu li ye washed for for yes/no interpretive conventions to is illustrated in Have they washed (something) for Jita (someone)? a derivation of (2b), 102 Studies in the Linguistic Sciences 19:2 (Fall 1989) Downing: The (20) (a) Interaction of Tone and Intonation 103 in Jita Rightward Spread (RS) H f--. o a (b) Leftward Delink H The in application of tone shift (20a, b) illustrated is by the derivation of (1a), given (21): (21) Derivation of (la) 'they Baikufuliye have washed (something) UR Ba: ku they you fu wash li for you' ye for (Pres. Perfect) Post-lexical rules H f--. RS Ba: ku fu li ye li ye L L H =^\ Delink Default Ba: ku fu L L H II III Lows Ba: SR Ba:kufuliye ku fu li ye Although RS is a very general rule, it fails to apply when the target of spread is a phrase-final syllable. For example, the infinitives in (22a) and (22b), below, have a high tone underlyingly on the stem-initial (or penult) syllable (oku- is the infinitive prefix). This penult high tone does not shift to the final syllable when the words are in phrase-final position. It does shift to the word- 104 Studies in the Linguistic Sciences 19:2 (Fall 1989) final syllable, shown in (22) however, when the infinitive is in phrase-medial position, as (23a) and (23b), below: No (a) (b) from penult to phrase-final syllable Oku f:ga 'to look for' Oku B6na 'to see; get' shift (23) Shift from penult phrase-medially (a) oku i:ga 'to look for' okui:ga ji:nd6Bo (b) oku Bona okuBona 'to ji: 'to see; get' i:noni i: 'to n doBo 'buckets' look for buckets' noni see/get a 'bird' bird' There are two proposals found in the literature to block high tones from spreading to final syllables. As Myers (1987) has argued, one way of accounting for lack of high tone spread beyond penult syllables is for phrasefinal syllables to be extratonal and so unavailable as a target of tone spread. (Extratonal syllables are indicated by placing them in parentheses in the derivations which follow.) However, it has also been argued (Sietsema 1989) that final segments or syllables may only be invisible to metrical njles, not tonal rules like tone spread, so that extratonality may not be appealed to in order to block spread of a high tone to a final syllable. Instead, Sietsema (1989) proposes that low tones inserted phrase-finally by a rule like (24), below, link to the final syllables: (24) Phrase-Final 0— > L Low / Insertion phrase This phrase-final low tone blocks the spread of a high tone from the penult to the final syllable (this account assumes that tone spread may generally only target a tonally unassociated vowel): ' ^ I (25) RS blocked by a phrase-final low "H L H L I--I 'phrase If the final syllable is derives a falling contour on that syllable: (26) Contour Creation H 'phrase underlyingly linked to a high tone, the phrase-final low tone L I'phreee Downing: The As Interaction of illustrated in the derivations of (23a) Tone and given in (27a) and (27b), both of these solutions correctly allow spread from the penult to a word-final syllable word 105 Intonation in Jita when a phrase-medial position, but block spread from the penult to the syllable when a word is in phrase-final position: is in (27) (a) Extratonality analysis, derivation of (23a) okui:ga ji:nd6Bo UR Oku INF i:ga to look for 'to look for buckets' final 106 Studies in the Linguistic Sciences 19:2 (Fall 1989) H Delink Default ok u i: L L I L I I ga H I Lows ok u SR okul:ga ji:nd6Bo i: M H ga ji:n L I ji:n L do Bo H L II do Bo In (27a), the high tone of okui:ga may spread since that word is in phrasemedial position, but the high tone of jindoBo may not spread to the extratonal phrase-final syllable. In (27b), too, only the high tone of okui:ga may spread since that word is in phrase-medial position, but the high tone of jindoBo may not spread, because it is blocked by the phrase-final low tone. Besides blocking high tone spread, the rule of Phrase-Final Low Insertion also necessary in Jita to account for the fact that phrase-final high tones are realized as falling contours in declarative sentences. That is, alternations like those in (28): (24) is (28) Nouns (a) with a High Tone on the Final Syllable Downing: The Interaction of Tone and Intonation in Jita 107 One question we might ask, then, is whether Phrase-Final Low Insertion in yes/no questions or only in declaratives. If Phrase-Final Low Insertion only applies in declaratives, then phrase-final high tones should be realized with a level high tone in yes/no questions, instead of with a falling contour. This is indeed the case in Jita, as shown by comparing the data in (29a, c and e) with those in (29b, d and f): also applies (29) Yes/no Questions: Phrase-final high tone (a) ci - - li u:mula we-FUT-rest We (b) will rest. ci- lf-u:muia? we-FUT-rest we Will (c) Ba: rest? ma gwa - - a:nsT down down (yesterday). Ba: - ma - gwS a:nsT? they-TENSE-fall down Did they fall down (yesterday)? they-TENSE-fall They (d) (e) a: - fell (a)ndik - ire i: - naruBa s/he-write-TENSE Cl.9-letter S/he has written a (f) a: - (a)ndik - (re letter. i: - fiaruBS? s/he-write-TENSE Cl.9-letter Has s/he written a letter? conclude from the lack of a falling contour on phrase-final high tones in the yes/no questions in (29b, d and f) that Phrase-Final Low Insertion (24) does not apply in yes/no questions but only in declaratives. I The next question we might ask is whether high tones on the penult will yes/no questions. Recall from derivation (27b) that one explanation for the lack of high tone spread from the phrasepenult syllable in declaratives was a phrase-final low tone blocked high tone spread. Since no low tones are inserted phrase-finally in yes/no questions, this analysis predicts that high tones underlyingly linked to the penult will spread to the phrase-final syllable. But, in fact, high tones underlyingly associated with the penult do not spread to a phrase-final syllable in yes/no questions, as spread to phrase-final syllables in shown by the data in (30): 108 Studies in the Linguistic Sciences 19:2 (Fall 1989) (30) Yes/No Questions: Phrase Penult High Tones (a) Ba: seiek - they- hide er(e) 9:Bi - tense - They have hidden the (b) Ba: s6lek - er(e) - - tense Have they hidden a: ma - - donge pills. e:Bi'-d8nge? they-hide (c) - Cl.7-pill Cl.7-pill the pills? gwa s/he-TENSE-fell He (d) a: tell (yesterday). m§ - - gwa? s/he-TENSE-tell Did s/he (e) we (f) fall? a:ma TENSE - c(i) - Bala ji - ngbko We count Cl.10-chicken counted the chickens (yesterday)? c(i) - - a:ma - - BSl^ ji - ng8ko? we - TENSE - count Cl.lO-chicken Did we count the chickens (yesterday)? In both the declaratives in (30a, c and e) and the corresponding yes/no questions in (30b, d and f) the phrase-penult high tone fails to spread to the final syllable. The phrase-final low tone account is not available to block spread from the penult to the phrase-final syllable in yes/no questions, since PhraseFinal Low Insertion (24) does not apply to them. Instead, the phrase-final syllable must be extratonal when RS applies in order to block spread from the penult. Since RS fails to apply in both yes/no questions and in declaratives when the target of spread is a phrase-final syllable, the extratonality analysis provides the most general way of accounting for the lack of spread. Since the only effect of Phrase-Final Low Insertion (24) and Contour Creation (26) is to derive a falling contour on phrase-final high tones in declarative sentences, conclude that they are not post-lexical rules applying to all utterances, but intonational rules applying only in declarative sentences. To capture the fact that RS, Delink and Default Low Insertion apply no matter what the intonation of the sentence may be, propose that they form a separate ___domain of post-lexical rules ordered before the intonational rules which apply either to declaratives or to yes/no questions. The rules discussed so far and the domains in which they apply are summarized in (31): I I Downing: The (31) Summary I. Interaction of Tone of Post-lexical Post-lexical and and Intonation 109 in Jita Intonational Rules Domain Extratonality of Phrase-Final Syllable Rightward Spread of High Tones (20a) Delink (20b) Insertion of Default II. Intonational Low Tones Domain Yes/No Questions A. Extrametricality of Phrase-Final Syllable (16) Grid-Building Rules (14a-c) Conventions (17), (18) Intonational High Attraction to Tone Association Accent (10) (11') Declaratives Phrase-Final Low Insertion (24) Contour Creation (26) B. One last problem remains to be discussed. Rule (16) marks phrase-final syllables extrametrical for the grid-building rules (14a-c), yet phrase-final high tones are realized with a raised high tone, as the data in (29) show. In order for phrase-final highs to be the prominent (accented) position in yes/no questions, Adopting phrase-final high-toned syllables may not be extrametrical. Goldsmith, Peterson and Drogo's (1986) suggestion that in tone systems, highpropose to revise rule toned syllables may be considered metrically heavy, (16) so that only light, i.e., low-toned, phrase-final syllables are marked extrametrical, as in (16'): I (16') in Yes/No Questions, Revised methcally light (i.e., low-toned) phrase-final syllable is marked extrametrical for the grid-building rules which determine the ___domain of spread of the yes/no question Extrametricality A intonational high tone. The tone now be below: pattern of yes/no questions with a phrase-final high tone correctly derived, as shown in the derivation of (29d), given in may (32), Studies in the Linguistic Sciences 19:2 (Fall 1989) 110 (32) Derivation of: (29d) Baimagwgi a:nsi? 'Did they fall down (yesterday)?' H H I UR Ba: magwa they-TENSE-fall Post-lexical rules H ! a:nsi down Downing: The SR In Interaction of Tone BamagwS and Intonation 111 in Jita a:nsT? does not apply to mark the phrase-final syllable extrametrical The grid-building rules assign a third level beat the phrase-final syllable, and the intonational high tone spreads to (32) rule (16') since it bears a high tone. (accent) to that syllable, deriving the correct tone pattern. 4. CONCLUSION In conclusion, have argued that Jita has a level of intonational rules which follows the post-lexical level. The intonational rules which apply to yes/no questions are, first, grid-building njles which assign prominence to either the rightmost high tone or, if there are no high tones, the penult syllable of the utterance. An intonational high tone is then linked to the first tone of the utterance and spreads to the prominent position. Further research is necessary to determine whether the ___domain of the yes/no question grid-building rules is the utterance or an intonational phrase. have also argued that phrase-final low insertion is an intonational rule which applies only to declaratives, since the only effect of the rule is to derive a falling contour on phrase-final high tones in I I declarative sentences. If one only examined the tone pattern of declarative sentences, one could argue that phrase-final low insertion was a post-lexical rule and that the inserted low tones were what blocked the spread of a penult high tone to the phrase-final syllable. However, phrase-penult high tones do not spread to the final syllable of yes/no questions, either, even though phrase-final low insertion does not apply in questions. The tone pattern of questions thus provides is the evidence that phrase-final low insertion is an intonational rule, and that extratonality of the phrase-final syllable which prevents high tones on the penult from spreading to the final syllable in both yes/no questions and declaratives in it Jita. NOTES take this opportunity to thank F. T. Magayane for his patient, me with the data which appears in this paper. would also like to thank M. Ourso and R. Chung for their assistance in verifying the tone patterns of yes/no questions, and L. Bickmore, C. Bundrick, R. Cervin, A. Dunn, D. Evans, C. Kisseberth, T. Williams and two anonymous SLS Any errors of data or reviewers for helpful comments on the paper. ^1 would like to friendly cooperation in providing I my own. Finally, would like to acknowledge the assistance of the University of Illinois African Studies Center who have interpretation are, of course, I 1 12 Studies in the Linguistic Sciences 19:2 (Fall 1989) supported my dissertation research by granting research grant for the 1988-89 academic year. me a FLAS Fellowship and a ' ^Transcription conventions adopted in this paper are as follows: a raised low tone in questions, but a declaratives; low tones are unmarked in both; 'B' is a bilabial " indicates indicates a raised high tone; high tone in fricative. ^Vowels parentheses have coalesced with the adjacent vowel, leading vowels are indicated by a colon. A detailed analysis of vowel coalescence in Jita may be found in Downing (in progress). in to lengthening; long ^For the sake of compactness in the derivations which follow, shall replace the grid by placing an asterisk (*) over the syllable assigned a third level beat after the Right End Rule applies. I ^The long vowels in the initial discussed in detail in Downing (in two words in this phrase are compensatory lengthening processes syllables of the actually not underlying but derived by progress). REFERENCES D. L. 1978. Intonation Across Languages. Universals of Human Language, Volume 2: Phonology, ed. by J. P. Greenberg, C. A. Ferguson and E. A. Moravscik. Stanford: Stanford University Press. CHANG, N. T. 1958. Tones and Intonation in the Chengtu Dialect (Szechuan, BOLINGER, Phonetica 2:59-85. G. N. 1983. The Hierarchical Representation of Tone Features. Current Approaches to African Linguistics (vol. 1), ed. by R. Dihoff, 1451 76. Dordrecht: Foris Publications. CRUTTENDEN, A. 1986. Intonation. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press. DOWNING, L. J. 1988. Tonology of Noun-Modifier Phrases in Jita. Studies in China). CLEMENTS, I. — the Linguistic Sciences 18:1.25-60. -. In Problems in Jita Tonology. Ph.D. Urbana-Champaign. progress. Illinois at dissertation. University of S. 1956. The Lungtu Dialect: A Description and Historical Study of a South China Idiom. Copenhagen: Ejnar Munksgaard Ltd. GOLDSMITH, J. 1987. Tone and Accent and Getting the Two Together. BLS EGEROD, 13. 1986. Tone and Accent in the J., K. Peterson and J. Drogo. Xhosa Verbal System. University of Chicago MS. HALLE, M. and J. R. Vergnaud. 1987. An Essay on Stress. Cambridge, Mass.: The M.I.T. Press. GOLDSMITH, Downing: The HAYES, B. 1982. 13:227-276. Interaction of Tone Extrametricality and Intonation in Jita and English Stress. 113 Linguistic Inquiry KENSTOWICZ, M. and C. Kisseberth. to appear. Chizigula Tonology - The Word and Beyond. Proceedings of the Stanford Conference on the Syntax-Phonology LIBERMAN, M. 1975. Interface, ed. The by D. Zee and S. Inkelas. System of English. Ph.D. dissertation, Intonation M.I.T. LIEBERMAN, Research Intonation, Perception and Language. Cambridge, Mass.: The M.I.T. Press. MYERS, S. 1987. Tone and the Structure of Words in Shona. Ph.D. dissertation. University of Massachusetts-Amherst. PETERSON, K. 1987. Accent in the Chichewa Verb. CLS 23:2: Parasession on Autosegmental and Metrical Phonology, 210-222. -. To appear. A Comparative Look at Nguni Verbal Tone. Current Approaches to African Linguistics, vol. 6, ed. by I. Haik and L. Tuller. P. Monograph 1967. no. 38. — Dordrecht: Foris Publications. PIERREHUMBERT, 1980. The Phonology and Phonetics of English J. Ph.D. dissertation, Massachusetts Institute of Technology. SELKIRK, E. 1984. Phonology and Syntax: The Relation Between Sound and Structure. Cambridge, Mass.: The M.I.T. Press. SIETSEMA, B. 1989. Metrical Dependencies in Tone Assignment. Ph.D. dissertation. Massachusetts Institute of Technology. ULTAN, R. 1978. Some General Characteristics of Interrogative Systems. Universals of Human Language, ed. by J. P. Greenberg, C. A. Ferguson and E. A. Moravscik. Volume 4: Syntax. Stanford: Stanford University Intonation. Press. the Linguistic Sciences studies in Vol. 19, Number 2, Fall 1989 ACCENT IN BANTU: Larry M. AN APPRAISAL Hyman University of California, Berkeley or so there has been considerable Bantu phonology from an accentual perspective. Pointing out that within verbs only the first root vowel can exhibit a seven-way opposition, Bennett (1978) argues that rootinitial stress can be reconstructed for Proto-Bantu (cf. stem-initial accent in Western Bantu). On the other hand, penultimate accent occurs in Eastern and Southern Bantu. In this paper provide an appraisal of what has been said about accent in Bantu, recently and becomes clear that By synthesizing this work in earlier studies. Bantu is marked by accents of different kinds, e.g. those used to predict segmental properties, tonal properties, juncture, rhythmic or intonational effects, etc. The conclusion to be drawn is that if all of these things are (metrical) accent, then Bantu languages must allow for multiple (and usually conflicting) metrical representations, as is now coming to be recognized in a number of language families. Over the past ten years interest in approaching I it would like to consider some of the recent concepts and have arisen in the study of prosodic phenomena in The issue that will focus on is that of accent, which has been of Bantu.'' interest to us for at least two reasons: First, as Bantuists, we are concerned with understanding the synchronic and diachronic bases of prosody in our Second, as phonologists, we are concerned with how these languages. prosodic properties fit in typologically with other languages and language families and, ultimately, with what these prosodic systems have to say about the In this paper I analytic difficulties that I nature of phonology, universally. Needless to say, I and share with you where, heading. not be able to cover will arise in the study of accent in I Bantu. think, Instead, we I all of the important issues that hope are, and, if to cover a few basic points where we might be possible, 116 Studies in the Linguistic Sciences 19:2 (Fall 1989) will not expend a great amount of energy developing definitions of what is a tone or what is an accent, etc. Instead, will simply assert what think is one standard view of tone and accent in (1). I I (1) a. tone = cf. I pitch features present lexically (e.g. at Welmers (1959): "a tone language is word level) a language in which both pitch phonemes and segmental phonemes enter into the composition of at least some morphemes'. b. accent = (headed) word level)2 metrical structure present lexically (e.g. at By defining accent (or, if one wishes, stress) as metrical structure, choose to remain neutral as to how this structure is marked, e.g., by trees, grids or even diacritic heads such as the asterisk notation introduced by Goldsmith (1976). Since languages can have both tone and accent, it doesn't make sense to ask whether a given language is "tonal' vs. 'accentual.' Instead, the discussion can turn around questions such as in (2): (2) a. b. I are there lexical (word level) tone features? is there lexical (word level) metrical structure? Bantu, these questions are particularly interesting, since, as summarized in the same tonal facts from the same language have been cited by different researchers, who have reached quite different conclusions. In (3), KINYARWANDA/ (3) UNDERLYING KiKUYU TONGA KIRUNDI + + accent As an example, consider the Tonga sentence in (4). LUGANDA KiMATUUMBI + + + + + Hyman: Accent (4) Tonga [ ta-ba-ba-lang-i ] in Bantu: 'they An Appraisal do not look at 117 them" NEG-they-thsm-look a. ta-ba-ba-lang-i b. ta-ba-ba-lang-i c. ta- d. ta- baH^ ba- (Meeussen 1963, based on Carter 1962) (Goldsmith 1984) lang- i (Pulieyblank 1986) 118 Studies in the Linguistic Sciences 19:2 (Fall 1989) (6) a. ku-lagaz-a ku-guluk-a ku-songelez-a 'to run' 'to aggravate' ku-lombez-a 'to request' ku-hamil-a 'to bump' ku-hangalasanya 'to carry 'to drop' many things at once' Kenstowicz and Kisseberth argue that underlyingly verb bases may either be in (7a) or have an unlinked H tone, as in (7b), which as seen also toneless, as in (8b), regularly links to the (7) a. [ lagaz ] penultimate vowel. 'drop' ) Hyman: Accent in Bantu: An Appraisal 1 19 H tone. Now, if the stem has only one syllable, the undergoes the rule and not its prefix. The conclusion he draws is that metrical structure must be introduced lexically, but only the LAST accent of a phrase will have this tone-raising effect. raises a STEM-penultimate stem — syllable The same conclusion is drawn from (9c). Zulu and the other Nguni languages have penultimate stress marked by vowel length, as seen in the nontone marked example in (10a), from Doke (1967). (10) a. 6a-6^:n-e 'may they seel' (subjunctive) b. 6a-6?^n-e: 'they saw' (< Ba-B^n-yl-e As seen in (10b) there is an exceptional final stress caused by the contraction of the -He ending with the verb root. Doke's analysis is to assign stress before contraction, as indicated by the double underlining in the parentheses. It is interesting to note that if -He constitutes a bisyllabic foot, when contraction takes place, stress is automatically shifted to the ultima, as Halle and Vergnaud (1987) have argued. Before moving on to consider stem-initial accent, let us pause. As convincing as these arguments are for penultimate accent, there are problems. Although Zulu and Xhosa have penultimate stress conditioning vowel do lengthening, they also have H tone attraction to antepenultimate position. not know if an analysis would work in which the stress-foot is extrametrical for the purposes of H tone spreading. If not, the metrically strong position required for vowel length does not coincide with the methcally strong position required for tone. There are other cases like this. Selkirk (1986) has argued that there is a Latin-like metrical foot required in Chimwiini, which determines the realization She bases her analysis on Kisseberth and of accentual vowel length. Abasheikh (1974), who make clear that stress and vowel length do not I necessarily coincide. Here too we would need two different metrical stnjctures: time one for vowel length and one for stress. As a third example, consider the Kinande form in (1 1 ). this (11) This /e-ri-so-a/ -^ Kinande infinitive form is e-ri:-s6a underlyingly toneless. ^ Two [6rl:swa] things happen 'to grind' phrase-finally. acquires length on its penultimate syllable. What is clear is that the it acquires a H tone on its penultimate vowel. modifications being conditioned by phrase-final position are targeting units: the penultimate syllable for length, but the penultimate vowel First, like all other words, it Even we propose a sequence would face problems. if of boundary tones, as in Hyman (in Second, prosodic different for tone. press), we still The inescapable conclusion is that the same language may require more than one metrical structure. At present, it looks as though we have one metrical 120 Studies in the Linguistic Sciences 19:2 (Fall 1989) Structure per prosodic feature (e.g., stress vs. length vs. tone). In this regard we note the similar claims made for Slavic (Wilson 1987) and Tiberian Hebrew (Rappaport, cited by Halle and Vergnaud 1987; cf. also Hammond 1989). To this observation, cannot help citing Hyman, Katamba and Walusimbi (1987), who showed that different (non-metrical) prosodic domains are required for tone vs. vowel length in Luganda and also Dobrovolsky (1988), who argues for non-isomorphic domains of vowel harmony and stress in Turkish. complete I Thus, while there is considerable agreement going back several generations of Bantuists for a penultimate accent, we note that this accent may be feature-dependent and/or that it may contrast with a second metrical structure in the same language. Turning now West and accent, this has been particularly the work my mind, that the stem-initial accent in this Teke language has striking phonological and phonetic effects on the tone, on the consonants and on the vowels. The same claim has inexplicably been made for one Eastern Bantu language, Luganda (Ashton et al 1954; Tucker 1962), and this observation is often repeated, usually citing the stem -yagala 'want' (van Buick 1952, Doke 1967 etc.). have, however, never to the to stem-initial successfully claimed for a number of languages. of Paulian (1974), who shows, conclusively to I will cite I seen any evidence for a stem-initial accent in this language or any mention of how exactly it is supposed to be manifested.^ If we can dismiss the Luganda claim, then stem-initial accent becomes a Western areal feature and penultimate accent remains an Eastern areal feature within Bantu. In fact, the arguments for stem-initial accent extend well into non-Bantu Benue-Congo and maybe so-called Kwa, since some of Paulian's arguments hold in languages such as Gokana, l]o, Tiv, and so forth. What are these arguments? Let me mention one, which will pinpoint the many, if not most or all West African languages where the generalization can be tested, there are severe restrictions on the distribution of consonants and vowels within a stem. Typically, a full range of consonants appears in stem-initial position, with a more restricted class of consonants appearing in other positions. Paulian shows that a stem in Kukuya can have one of the following shapes in (12a): problem. In (12) a. b. c. CV. CVV, CVCV, CVVCV, CVCVCV C = any of 30+ consonants second and third C = /P, T, K, m, n, 1/ only first Similarly, there are at in (13a) can be (13) a. b. filled, most two consonant positions of the Gokana stem shapes and (13c) (Hyman 1985): respectively, as in (13b) CV, CVV, CVC, CVCV, CVVCV first C = /p. t, ky, kp, b, d, g^. gb, f, s, v. z, I, B/ (plus nasality) Hyman: Accent second c. C= /B, D, G/ in Bantu: An Appraisal 121 (plus nasality) Should we therefore conclude that there is a stem-initial accent that the fuller distribution of consonants in stem-initial position? is licensing Returning to Bantu, Bennett (1978) reconstructs positions of stress Proto-Bantu on the basis of vowel distributions such as in (14): stem-initial vowel: i, e, b. prefixes, verb extensions: i, e, o, c. verb-final suffix: i, e, d. deverbal u, d (14) a. final suffix (?): e, e, u, o, d, in a a a (o?) Bennett notes that the full range of 7 historical vowels is found only on the first vowel of the root, as in (14a), while prefixal vowels and non-final suffixal vowels (e.g., verb extensions) can only be one of the four given in (14b). He gives the four verb-final suffixes in (14c), to which we can add the derivational final vowels in (14d) which derive deverbal adjectives and nouns, respectively, suggesting that a final vowel morpheme could be any of six or perhaps all seven proto vowels. Now it turns out that noun prefixes and verb extensions (14b) show an absence of tonal opposition. As Bennett puts it: 'A single hypothesis which would account for the loss of height contrasts, of the i-u contrast, and of tonal contrast in certain positions, is postulation of a stressaccent, placed on the first syllable of each nominal or verbal stem, with secondary prominence on certain suffixes, which may originally have been enclitics' (pp. 6-7). The argumentation is a familiar one: one should find fuller distributions of consonants, vowels and tones under accent, and reduced distributions of the same under lack of accent. Although Bennett is reconstructing stress-accent at the Proto-Bantu level, his observations hold for many of the present-day languages, for example, in Luganda, where we could therefore also propose However, this would metrically strong stem-initial and final-vowel positions. raise a problem, since there are at least five arguments that the second stem mora is accented: 1) in (15a) and the noun form in (15b), a suffixal second mora of the stem, if the first stem mora is Stevick 1969; Hyman, Katamba and Walusimbi 1987): As seen (floating) toneless (15) H tone (cf. in the verb form links to the a. a-a- b. ki-[ [ -^ gul-il-il-a kyange -> sumuluzo a- ki- [ [ gul-fl-il-a sumuluzo kyange ® The floating H is attracted to accent 'he on the second mora.'* who bribes* 'my key' 1 22 Studies in the Linguistic Sciences 1 9:2 (Fall 1 989) 2) Fusion or imbrication of the -He ending takes place with a preceding [I] as in (16a,b): the preceding [I] is deleted and through regular sound change *ViC develops into a surface geminate, here [dd]. In (16c), on the other hand, the preceding [I] does not delete, because it occurs within the accented second mora: (16) a. a-ko^I-il-e b. a-linv]l-il-e -> a-koo-il-e -> a-lim-i-il-e -> ^-ko-dde -> a-lim-T-dde c. a-kol-ll-e -^ a-kol-i-e -> a-koz-e Instead, the 3) In lengthened (1 of -He drops in (16c) and there is 'he a change of the for' preceding [I] again by regular mle. into [z], -a in [I] has uprooted' has cultivated 'he has worked' 'he stem-stem verb reduplications, the final vowel of the stem is it is in second mora position, as in (17a). Compare the short final if 7b,c). (17) a. Here, the accent ku- [ lim-a is causing lengthening. -* ku- [ lim-aa-lim-a 'to cultivate' -> ku- [ lijm-a-liim-a 'to spy' -> ku- [ lim-jl-a-lim-il-a 'to cultivate for' 4) As seen in (18a), the final [I] of a verb labiodentalizes to [v], as do other consonants, before the -u adjectivizing final vowel. As seen in (18b), this process is blocked if the [u] is the second stem vowel, i.e., if it is accented. (18) a. Hyman: Accent in Bantu: An Appraisal 123 Luganda shows the same distributions as Bennett points out and if am correct about the second mora accent, then this Luganda has an accent on the first, second, AND final stem moras... However, if for Proto-Bantu, means that which makes Be Western this for as I a it lot of accents. may, I think it is important to point out the disparity between which shows these distributional effects vs. Eastern penultimate accent which does not. That is, if all of this is accent, we have to ask why the penultimate accent does not license a fuller range of consonants and vowels, as its Western counterpart does.^ The inevitable question is whether these two accents are really comparable or, to put things slightly differently, whether a (Bantu) language could not have both such accents, i.e., stem-initial accent to get the Paulian effects, but penultimate accent to get e.g., vowel lengthening or tonal modifications and so forth? Returning to Chizigula, Kenstowicz (1986) and Kisseberth (1989) argue for a primary penultimate accent and a second stem-initial accent, though all the evidence presented is stem-initial accent, tonal. We thus have seen different kinds of accent: penultimate accent, which can be realized as stress, vowel-length and/or tone vs. positions within a stem which can have effects on phonological distributions or rules, as tried to show from Luganda. Of course, one might wonder whether stem positions need be identified via metrical structure, i.e., as accented. One interesting case for the metrical approach comes from Kikuria, described by Odden (1987). As seen in (20), perfective verb forms place a H tone on the fourth vowel of the stem:^ I (20) a. 124 A H Studies in the Linguistic Sciences 19:2 (Fall 1989) tone could be placed as in (21a) on a single vowel located with respect to edge of a ___domain. Or In (21b), one could place a H on the last odd- or even-numbered V counting either from the left or the right. Alternatively, in (21c), one could find a H on every odd- or even numbered V, counting from the left or the right. Since the maximal, bounded metrical constituent ever proposed is the ternary one mentioned in (21 d), one could count assign a H to the first, last, or every third vowel, counting either from the left or the right. In Kikuria, the 4th vowel position is still not a possible outcome, since in a stem that has at least 7 vowels, the 4th position would represent the head of the middle ternary constitute. While Odden (1987) demonstrates that a separate H tone may be assigned to the stem-initial vowel, giving a pattern of first and fourth vowel H tone in some verb forms, his examples make it clear that the 7th vowel is not ever targeted by this tone assignment process. Thus, even we conceive of the first three vowels that are skipped over in (20) to put a H on the 4th vowel as an invisible initial ternary consitituent, we must explain why the 7th vowel does not acquire a H, when there is a 7th vowel. its relation to the left or right if At least two rather complicated metrical accounts are possible, as in (22), using Halle and Vergnaud's (1987) system.^ schematized (22) a. b. Hyman: Accent in Bantu: An 125 Appraisal evaluating the metrical approach, it should be noted that the analyses awkwardly handle the final rising tone that is obtained when the verb stem contains fewer than four vowels. An example involving a stem with Odden only three vowels, n-tuuri 'I have picked', was seen in (20a). (1987:324) also gives the infinitive form ko-bari 'to count', with a two-vowel stem, where the 4th vowel tone pattern again surfaces as a rising contour on the In in (22) only The (22a) leads potentially to the right result for a twocontra current practice, that the entire single foot is extrametrical. The word tree would thus not be contructable, and an assigned suffixal H would not be able to link. (22a) would, on other hand, incorrectly place a H on the final vowel of three-vowel stems. The analysis in (22b) can be made to work if we assume that the obligatory cola must not be shorter than four vowels. This would then result in 'ghost' vowels occurring to the right of two- final vowel. 8 vowel stem, if solution in we assume, of two V slots floating after ko-bara is not no evidence for the cola in verb tenses not tone (and in other forms classes). and three-vowel stems. The spectre appealing —especially exhibiting a if fourth vowel there H is metrical phonologist to explore exactly what one were to accept either foot extrametricality, as in (22a) or the cola, as in (22b) and, where possible, constrain the apparatus. What metrical theory should not be allowed to do is target an arbitrary integer, such as 4th vowel from the edge, as is suggested by Kikuria. One wonders also how or whether the metrical framework might deal with Cheng and Kisseberth's (1979) account of Makua. As seen in (23), In short, it behooves the patterns are logically possible (23) a. b. if u-l6kotanih-a 'to pick up' u-tetemelel-a 'to tremble at' u-l6kotanihac-a 'to pick up pi.* 'to use u-kakam^liher-a (*u-l6kotanih|c-a; c. u-kakam^liherac-a (*-a) (*-a) sth. to strength sth.' *u-kakamaliher-a) 'to use sth. to strength sth. pi.' u-l6kotaniherac-a 'to pick up pi. for/with' (*u-kakamalih|rac-a; *u-l6kot^nih|rac-a) This Bantu language places a H tone on the 1st and 3rd vowels of the stem, but not on the Sth (or 7th etc.)^. Here we must find a way to get a binary foot construction process to stop arbitrarily after it has constructed n number of ^o in this case, after it has constructed two binary left-headed constituents. feet and cola As in (22b), we can group each pair of binary feet into a (headed?) then construct an unbounded left-headed word constituent out of these colas. The first cola alone would be the locus of H tone assignment. In this case, each — head-of-foot receives a H tone, perhaps because each H is assigned by a separate rule (Odden 1988). The Makua data thus raise the question of whether alternating H tones of this sort, as has been claimed by Pulleyblank ) 126 Studies in the Linguistic Sciences 19:2 (Fall 1989) (1983) for Kimatuumbi and Goldsmith and Sabimana (1984) for Kirundi, are necessarily the reflex of an alternating accent system. We thus arrive at the last kind of accent claimed for Bantu: RHYTHMIC accent, said to occur when H tones are assigned to alternating vowels. Consider the infinitive paradigm of Kirundi in (24). ku-sab-a (24) a. 'to ask for* ku-baz-a 'to ask (question)' b. ku-bi-sab-a ku-bf-baz-a c. ku-bi-mu-sab-a ku-bi-mu-baz-a d. ku-bi-mu-ku-sab-ir-a ku-bi-mu-ku-bar-iz-a ku-ha-bi-mu-ku-sab-ir-a ku-ha-bi-mu-ku-bar-iz-a (24e = 'to ask him for them for you there' e. -bi- 'them' (cl. -mu- 'him/her' -ku- 'you sg.' 8) (cl. 1) -ha- 'there' (cl. 16) These and other materials collected with the late Pierre-Claver Ndayisenga confirm the findings of Goldsmith and Sabimana (1984) for Kirundi, and similar findings for nearly identical Kinyarwanda by Kimenyi (1988) and Rialland (1988), who all see motivation for accents of some sort. The forms in (24a) show the infinitive without any object prefix. In the left hand column there is no surface H tone, while there is one on the verb root -baz- in the right hand column.'' We appropriately conclude that the root -sabis underlyingly toneless, while -baz- has an underlying H tone. In (24b), the object prefix -bi- has been added. Since there is no H tone with the verlj root ^ -sab-, we conclude that the object prefix is also toneless. In the form to the right, has come to be realized on the object prefix. Kimenyi (1976, 1988) accounts for this by a rule of tonal anticipation in Kinyarwanda, while Goldsmith and Sabimana (1984) introduce a H pullback rule. Moving on to (24c), where there are two object prefixes, both forms now have two H tones: one on the first object prefix -bi-, one on the verb root -sab- or -baz-. Two conclusions must be drawn. First, as in neighboring languages such as Luganda and Haya, a second object prefix necessarily comes in with its own H tone; and second, the H tones distribute themselves so as to alternate, as shown. This is confirmed in (24d) and (24e), where a third and a fourth object prefix are introduced, and where the H's continue to appear on every other the H tone of -baz- vowel. The approach taken in the literature has been to introduce accents and moving H tones around to produce the alternating pattern. Goldsmith and Sabimana (1984) construct binary strong-weak feet and a system of mles to guarantee that H will wind up in the appropriate strong positions. In closely rules related Kinyarwanda, Kimenyi (1988) constructs weak-strong feet, while Rialland (1988) argues that metrical feet are superfluous, and opts instead for a diacritic accent analysis. With all of the discussion of tone vs. accent in Bantu, Hyman: Accent in Bantu: An 127 Appraisal one would not be surprised to see an autoseg mental analysis in purely tonal The fact that needs to be captured is that H tones alternate on the surface in Kirundi, and at a non-surface level in Kinyarwanda, which obscures the pattern by spreading each alternating H one vowel to the left (thereby creating even numbered sequences of H tones on the surface). One could either introduce binary feet to motivate the alternating H tones, or one could simply let the tonology of the language produce the surface output, since we have alluded to a different approach to the alternating H tones in Makua. The problem is not unlike the one we face in Luganda. in that language, where a word can have at most one pitch drop, have argued that this is a surface output resulting from the tonology and not the expression of an accent (Hyman 1982). terms. I What might a purely tonal analysis of Kirundi look like? possible approach which (25) a. can present only I Identification of underlying in Let me propose a outline form in (25). stem H tones: nouns: prelinked or floating i. verbs: floating only in the underlying representation (UR) level, one there is a rule applies within the macro-stemi2 subject to two conditions, ii. b. ® If as follows: V2 RULE: Assign H to the second vowel following each left stem bracket (left-to-right), Condition 1 No two H tones on successive vowels (=OCP ii. effect or telescoped result of Meeussen's Rule), Condition 2: No H on V2 of innermost stem if there is a iii. preceding H anywhere in the macrostem. i. : @ in the stem does not get shifted around is crucial is that an underlying and copied into positions, but rather, serves only as a TRIGGER for the V2 oile— and then fails to surface (cf. Hyman 1989 for a similar claim made for Haya). What Consider the underlying representation (26) (26a). © a. b. in [ ku- [ ku [ - [ bibi - [ [ mu- mu- [ [ sabsab- I 1 H H a a ] ] ] ] ] ] ] (=UR) 1o ask him ] (=LR) for them' In this form we have underlyingly a toneless verb root and at least one of the two object markers is also toneless, as was concluded from (24b). Now, as was observed in (24c), when there are two object markers, a H tone is realized on both the first object marker and the verb root. The question is: where did the H tone come from? Does it belong to bi- because it is followed by another OM, as Or in Haya? Or to mu- because it is preceded by another OM, as in Luganda? maybe the presence of two OM's assigns a special H tone to the verb root or to 128 Studies in the Linguistic Sciences 19:2 (Fall 1989) Massamba (1984) argues for Cirurl? This does not appear to be an answerable question, but in any case misses the generalization underlying the data in (24): as long as there is at least one tone anywhere in the macro-stem, we will get the expected alternating pattern. An analysis such as in (25b) thus streamlines the analysis and avoids hair-splitting issues like: which morpheme does the belong to? The surface output in (26b) is obtained by applying the \/2 rule left to right, subject to condition 1.13 Let us now justify the assumption that the underlying ®'s do not themselves actually the last vowel, as ® ® surface. us note that there are verb forms with no surface H tones at all, in (27), for which a feature combination such as [+MC, +Fut, +Aff] itself serves as a distinct trigger for the toneless (all L) First, let e.g., the main clause future affirmatives pattern. (27) tu-zoo-sab-a tu-zoo-baz-a 'we will tu-zoo-bi-sab-a tu-zoo-bi-baz-a tu-zoo-bi-mu-sab-a tu-zoo-bi-mu-baz-a ask for/ask' ( -bi- 'them') ( -mu- 'him') etc. Second, there are verb forms that show only a single surface H on the macrostem coming from a suffixal ©, for example, the main clause negative present habitual tense in (28). 'we do not ask (28) nti-tu- [ sab-ai4 nti-tu- [ baz-^ nti-tu- [ bi-sab-a nti-tu- [ bi-b^z-a nti-tu- [ bi-mii-sab-a nti-tu- [ bi-mu-baz-a nti-tu- [ bi-mu-ku-sab-ir-a nti-tu- [ bi-mu-bar-iz-a nti-tu- [ ha-bi-mu-ku-sab-ir-a nti-tu- [ ha-bi-mu-bar-iz-a cases where there for/ask' ® ® tone, the will trigger a single suffixal cases where there is a stem ®, we can assume either that the stem tone(s) are removed, as in the main clause triggers a new application of the V2 mle future affirmative or that the suffixal that wipes out the earlier application. In either interpretation, the way a single V2 H tone is obtained is by having the suffixal tone assigned at a stage where the inner stem brackets are no longer visible, as in (29). In application of the V2 is no stem rule (see below). — In ® ® (29) a. b. ha nti-tu- [ nti-tu- [ha - bi - - bi mu - - ku mu - - sab ku - - ir - sab a (=UR) ] - ir - a ] (=LR) I H This contrasts with the alternating pattern, which results from the same process operating at a stage where internal left stem brackets ARE visible. Recent work may be an enclitic or on Haya (Hyman 1989) suggests that the suffixal ® Hyman: Accent in Bantu: An Appraisal separate phonological word. suffixal @ in have (29) will If to this have 129 sketch of Kirundi has any substance to this same it, the property. — There is much more to be said about Kirundi and Kinyarwanda in fact, monographs can and have been written on the subject. want only to say two things. First, we have seen that the metrical approach deals clumsily with Kikuria and Makua, and in fact, with most of what Odden (1988) calls I be It is easy to imagine how metrical theory could elaborated to count up to the 5th position (initial syllable extrametrical + construction of cola), or, in mirror-image fashion, the 5th position from the end. Other equally odd calculations are possible from the overly powerful metrical model. The second point is that the accents that are built for alternating H tone systems have no other purpose: like the penultimate accent, these accents ^there is nothing segmental that exist for the sole purpose of placing H tones corresponds to a strong vowel position vs. a weak one. For example, a similar stem and prestem environment is involved in the dissimilatory process known 'predictable tone' in Bantu. — as Dahl's Law, schematized (30) a. c. [ [ kV [ in (30a). kV b. [kV[kV[kV[kV i i i i i i g k g g g k kV [ kV [ kV [ kV 4- ^ 4' 4* g k g k However, in their survey and Nurse (1982) found of Dahl's Law in a number of Kenyan languages, Davy such as in (30b) and no evidence multiple applications any. ..convergence on an obligatory rule giving only alternating 174) as in (28c). In other words, there have been no segmental correlates to the alternating H tones reported in Bantu. ''^ While this is not a requirement, the crucial absence of a supporting segmental evidence of the sort produced by Paulian for Kukuya, for instance, leads me to think that direct assignment of H tone is just as good as systems with metrical heads. [quote] outputs' 'of (p. The we are left with is one with a proliferation of accents and a metrical structures that do not coincide within the same thus appears that if (metrical) accent is the proper conception of situation proliferation language. It of phenomena have surveyed in this paper, these accents in Bantu are very different from one another, may be totally independent from each other in the same language, and are usually set up for the purpose of a single rule or generalization. This raises the question of whether we are dealing with a single phenomenon or, as believe, with a number of different, but potentially related the kinds of I I ones. 130 Studies in the Linguistic Sciences 19:2 (Fall 1989) NOTES paper attempt both to synthesize some of the major contributions area as well as present some of my own findings, particularly from Luganda, which have been able to research with Dr. Francis Katamba, thanks to a National Science Foundation grant #BNS89-96111. would like to thank Patrick Bennett and Douglas Pulleyblank for helpful comments, agreements and disagreements on this paper. ^In this I in this I I 2| have added 'headed' in parentheses, since metrical structure may be used not only for accent, but for also for the purpose of nonconcatenative morphology (McCarthy and Prince 1986, 1987). While Hammond (1989) shows that so-called parsing feet may be required for stress purposes as well, there is no stress without a stress foot, which is headed, as required by (lb). 3The last three syllables of the following Luganda verb forms are in every respect homophonous, despite the fact that they have a different stem structure: i) ii) a-kusika a-ku-sika 'he respects' 'he pulls you' (stem = [kusika]; preceding a- is subject prefix) (stem = [sika]; preceding -ku- is object prefix) is to identify the first mora of the stem as invisible as proposed for Tonga by Pulleyblank (1986). As seen in (15b), however, this would require us to say that it is still invisible at the point where the possessive pronoun is added (as an enclitic) to the noun and in fact that the noun class prefix ki- is not available for linking the free H tone. Even if one were to overcome this difficulty, the other arguments for a second mora stem accent would still need to be addressed. '*An alternative ('extraprosodic') — ^Another prediction of final accent would be that there should also be a range of CONSONANTS in the last mora of the stem. As far as know, this is Instead, restrictions on Bantu consonants follow a different not borne out. have determined both from synchronic Luganda and pattern. For example, from Guthrie's and Meussen's reconstructions, that the two consonants of CVC and CVVC verb roots show interesting restrictions involving nasality. Virtually missing from the reconstmctions are the following patterns: 1) *bVm, *bVVm, *dVn, *dVVn (and mirror-image); 2) *mVn, *mVVn (and mirror image); and 3) *NVNC. The one exception to the first restriction (CI voiced stops do not cooccur with a homorganic C2 nasal) is *bumu 'belly', which has a restricted has anything to do with It is doubtful that any of this distribution in Bantu. accent, but rather is reminiscent of various OCP effects on roots (McCarthy fuller I I 1986). Hyman: Accent in Bantu: An Appraisal 131 ^These tone patterns may be modified by later rules; see Odden (1987). Note the final rising tone on trimoraic stems such as n- [ tuuri] in {20a). This presumably is the result of inserting an additional V to be the fourth mora (creating a LH rising tone on the surface). ^More analyses are possible, if one admits ternary feet. Thus, one could have left-headed ternary feet, which are gathered up into a left-headed word. If the first ternary foot is extrametrical, the fourth vowel will be the head of the word tree and hence receive the one H tone of the construction. ^Presumably there will not be any single vowel stems, since a Bantu verb has at least one vowel to which a final vowel morpheme (usually -a or -e) is added. root 9|t rule. in should be noted that each Hence these stems actually H tone doubles onto the next vowel by a later have H on their 1st, 2nd, 3rd AND 4th vowels most cases. ^OThe alternative positing of a single TERNARY foot constructed at the beginning of the stem, whose edges are marked with H tone is not terribly attractive, nor is it desirable to identify the second vowel as the head of a binary constituent with L tone assigned to it. 1^ Though irrelevant for our discussion, the verb base -baz- actually consists of the root -bar- followed by the causative suffix -/-. ^2The macro-stem consists of the verb stem plus all preceding object markers in Kirundi. Its relevance to tonology has been noted by a number of Bantuists, most recently by Mutaka (in preparation), who argues for a macrostem cycle on the basis of both the tonal and non-tonal phonology of Kinande. ^Of course, given what we have said about a second mora accent in Luganda, we may wish to see the V2 position as a position of accent. Note, however, that nothing depends on this except for the alternating H pattern. In addition, if we started with diacritic accents (i.e. asterisks) instead of ®'s, we would have to decide where to place the asterisk in the input string in (25a), an issue which was suggested to be unresolvable. i^This final H is not realized prepausally. "^At the conference David alternating property not line in Odden up with tone assignment in Law may have this any case, the alternating pattern does indicated that Dahl's Kikuria, but that in any way. 132 Studies in the Linguistic Sciences 19:2 (Fall 1989) REFERENCES ASHTON, E. O. et al. 1954. A Luganda grammar. London: Longmans. BENNETT, Patrick R. 1978. The role of stress and intonation in early ProtoBantu. University of Wisconsin, MS. (Paper presented at 9th Annual Conference on African Linguistics, Michigan State University.) Byarushengo, Ernest Rugwa, Larry M. Hyman and Sarah Tenenbaum. 1976. Tone, accent and assertion in Haya. Studies in Bantu Tonology, ed. by Larry M. Hyman, 183-205. SCOPIL 3. University of Southern California. CARTER, Hazel. 1962. Notes on the tonal system of Northern Rhodesian Plateau Tonga. Colonial Research Study No. 35. London: Her Majesty's Stationery Office. Cheng, C.C. and Charles W. 1). Davy, Studies J. I.M. in Kisseberth. 1979. Ikorovere the Linguistic Sciences 9.1, 31-63. and Derek Nurse. 1982. Makua Tonology (part Synchronic versions of Dahl's law: the Journal of multiple applications of a phonological dissimilation rule. African Languages and Linguistics 4.157-195. DOBROVOLOSKY, Michael. 1986. Stress and vowel harmony in Turkish. Berkeley Linguistic Society 12.61-71. DOKE, Clement. 1967. The Southern Bantu languages, international African Institute. London: Dawsons of Pall Mall. Goldsmith, John. 1976. Autosegmental phonology. Ph.D. Dissertation, M.I.T. (available from I.U.L.C. and Garland Publishers). Goldsmith, John. 1984. Tone and accent in Tonga. Autosegmental studies in Bantu tone, ed. by G. N. Clements and J. Goldsmith, 19-51. Dordrecht: Foris. Goldsmith, John, Karen Peterson and Joseph Drogo. In press. Tone and accent in the Xhosa verbal system. Current approaches to African linguistics 5, ed. by Paul Newman and Robert Botne. Dordrecht: Foris. Goldsmith, John and Firmard Sabimana. 1984. The Kirundi Verb. Ms. HALLE, Morris and Jean-Roger Vergnaud. 1987. An essay on stress. Cambridge, Mass.: M.I.T. Press. Hammond, Michael. 1987. Hungarian cola. Phonology Yearbook 4.267-269. Hammond, Michael. 1989. On the interaction of stress feet and parsing feet in complex metrical systems. University of Arizona, MS. Hyman, Larry M. 1985. A theory of phonological weight. Dordrecht: Foris Publications. Hyman, Larry M. 1989. The consequences of rule ordering in Haya tonology. To appear in Proceedings of Arizona Phonology Conference 2. Hyman, Larry M. In press. Boundary tonology and prosodic ___domain theory. To appear in Proceedings of Workshop on the Syntax-Phonology Connection, Stanford University. Larry M. and Francis X. Katamba. To appear. Final vowel shortening Luganda. Studies in African Linguistics 20. HYMAN, in « Tuki Gaps Biloa: Hyman, 133 Katamba and Livingstone Walusimbi. 1987. Luganda Phonology Yearbook 4.87-108. KENSTOWICZ, Michael. 1986. Accent and tone in Kizigua-a Bantu language. To appear in Certamen Phonologicum ed. by P.M. Bertinetto and M. Larry M., Francis and the strict layer hypothesis. I, Lopocaro. KISSEBERTH, Charles W. University of Illinois, 1989. Metrical structure in Chizula tonology. MS. Khumalo, James S. M. 1987. An autosegmental account of Zulu phonology. Unpublished Ph.D. Dissertation, University of the Witwatersrand. KiMENYi, Alexandre. 1988. A tonal grammar of Kinyarwanda: autosegmental and metrical account. Ms. Abasheikh. 1974. Vowel length in KISSEBERTH, Charles W. and Mohamed ChiMwi:ni-a case study of the role of grammar in phonology. Papers from the parasession on Natural Phonology, ed. by A. Bruck et al., 193209. Chicago Linguistic Society. Massamba, David P. B.. 1984. Tone in Ci-Ruri. Autosegmental studies in Bantu tone, ed. by G.N. Clements and J. Goldsmith, 235-254. Dordrecht: \. Foris. McCarthy, John J. 1986. OCP gemination and antigemination. effects: Linguistic Inquiry 17.207-263. McCarthy, John J. and Alan Prince. 1986. Prosodic morphology. University of Massachusetts and Brandeis University, MS. McCarthy, John J. and Alan Prince. In press. Foot and word in prosodic morphology: the Arabic broken plural. Natural Language and Linguistic Theory. McHUGH, Brian. 1989. Unpublished Ph.D. Dissertation, U.C.L.A. MEEUSSEN, A. E. 1963. Morphotonology of the Tonga verb. Journal Languages 2.72-92. MUTAKA, Ngessimo. In preparation. The lexical of African tonology of Kinande. Ph.D. Dissertation, University of Southern California. 1985. An accentual approach to tone in Kimatuumbi. African by Didier L. Goyvaerts, 345-419. SSLS 6. Amsterdam: Benjamins. Odden, David. 1987. Predicting tone in Kikuria. Current approaches to African linguistics 7, ed. by David Odden, 31 1-326. Dordrecht: Foris. Odden, David. 1988. Predictable tone systems in Bantu. Autosegmental studies on pitch accent, ed. by Harry van der Hulst and Nerval Smith, Odden, David. linguistics, ed. 225-251. Dordrecht: Foris. Odden, David. 1989. Kimatuumbi phonology and morphology. MS. PAULIAN, Christiane. 1974. Le kukuya: langue teke du Congo. S.E.LA.F. PULLEYBLANK, Douglas. 1983. Accent in Kimatuumbi. African linguistics 2, ed. by Jonathan Kaye Paris: Current approaches to 195-215. Dordrecht: et al., Foris. PULLEYBLANK, Douglas. 1986. Tone in lexical phonology. Dordrecht: Reidel. 1 34 Studies in the Linguistic Sciences 19:2 (Fall 1989) RiALLAND, Annie. 1988. Systemes prosodiques africains. Thdse du Doctorat d'Etat. Selkirk, Elisabeth O. 1986. On derived domains Phonology Yearbook 3.371-405. in sentence phonology. Stevick, E. W. 1969. Pitch and duration in Ganda. Journal of African Languages 8.1-28. TUCKER, A. N. 1962. The syllable in Luganda: a prosodic approach. Journal of African Languages 1.122-166. WELMERS, William E. 1959. Tonemics, morphotonemics, and tonal morphemes. General Linguistics 4.1-9. Wilson, Stephen A. 1987. Metrical structure and diachronic change. Papers from the Parasession on Autosegmental and Metrical Phonology, ed. by Anna Bosch et al., 418-430. Chicago Linguistic Society 23. Studies in Volume 19, the Linguistic Sciences Number 2, Fail 1989 LA SELECTION MORPHOPHONOLOGIQUE DES CLASSES EN KPOKOLO* Claude Timmons & Christian Dunn In Kpokolo, as in other Kru languages (and the majority of languages from the Niger-Congo family), nominals are grouped into classes. The aim of this article is to show that, except for the semantic class of humans, all other nominal classes are defined The according to a set of nonarbitrary phonological criteria. hypothesis argued for in this article, namely that nominal classes are determined by phonological criteria, is illustrated by three morphosyntactic processes: 1) pronominalization; 2) adjective/noun agreement; 3) possessive pronoun/noun agreement. Our analysis is presented in the framework of Kaye, Lowenstamm & Vergnaud 1985, where the facts of Kpokolo find a natural and straightforward explanation. 0. Introduction Dans cet article, nous pr6sentons une analyse de la s6lection des classes en kpokolo (une langue kru parl6e dans le canton de Kpokolo en Cote-d'lvoire). Plus sp6cifiquement, nous montrons que cette langue poss§de un systdme de classement des nominaux qui, bien que bas6 en partie sur des criteres semantiques du type 'humainV'non humain', est avant tout conditionn§ par des facteurs phonologiques.'' Dans la section 1 nous L'article est organist de la fagon suivante. presentons les donn6es et les diff6rents tests qui permettent de regrouper celles-ci en quatre classes. Dans la section 2, le probl6me de la selection des classes en kpokolo est pos6 et discute de mani§re informelle. Dans la section 3, nous presentons le cadre th6orique adopte, c'est-a-dire, celui developpe dans Kaye, Lowenstamm & Vergnaud (1985). Enfin, dans la section 4, nous proposons une analyse de la selection des classes en kpokolo basee sur les notions presentees dans la section pr6c6dente. , 136 1 Studies in the Linguistic Sciences 19:2 (Fall 1989) Les donndes . 1.1 Systdme vocalique du kpokolo Le kpokolo possdde un systeme vocalique de surface qui comprend 13 - ATR :7 voyelles r6tract6es ( )2 et 6 voyelles avanc6es ( [ + ATR ). En outre, la presence de voyelles centrales est k signaler. s'agit, en effet, d'un fait assez peu courant dans les langues kru, et qui presente un certain interet dans I'analyse de la selection des classes que nous suggerons dans la section 4. Pour situer le lecteur, la voyelle transcrite par le signe I ] represente une voyelle haute retract6e d'arri6re non arrondie. La voyelle correspondante + ATR est representee par le [ 4 ]. La voyelle represent6e par le chiffre 3 est un schwa [ - ATR ]. La version [ + ATR ] de cette voyelle est transcrite par [ § ]. Par convention, nous representons les voyelles [ - ATR ] par des capitales et les voyelles + ATR par des minuscules. Par exemple, le [ I ] represente le iota, c'est-a-dire, le [ relach6. Le [ E repr6sente le £ ], c'est-^-dire le son que Ton retrouve par exemple dans le mot frangais p[e]re, etc. En (1 ), nous presentons voyelles [ ] ] II [ [ ] [ ] i le ] ] [ systeme vocalique du kpokolo. (1) Systeme vocalique de surface du kpokolo Timmons & Dunn: sepuye Selection morphophonologique des classes en kpokolo 1 37 138 Studies in the Linguistic Sciences 19:2 (Fall 1989) Selection des formes pronominales (3) Pronom (a) classe O toi yu o kUkwEi....O i cifi O i classe kOtaj aj sikpeie i....a dagbele vaka i..a i / a E i j j il/le' sOi 'enfant il/le' b'oi 'coq il/le' lUi 'chef il/le' kotuj / a kokoti elle/la' 'chapeau il/le' j j3IIi 'bouc il/le' trEj U / il/le' 'pied il/le' 'chanson 'chemise E E E E i / 'bras classe gelej / E elle/la' elle/la' / 'pore il/le' 'singe il/le' labac il/le' 'serpent il/le' Examples d'emploi yu i j * wOlU 'laver' du p6re de I'enfant etc.) du rat du cafard etc.) lave un enfant' (en parlant du bouc de la tortue etc.) du singe etc.) lave un enfant' (en parlant du serpent lave un enfant' (en parlant lave un enfant' (en parlant 'il j suJet 'il 'il j Pronom 'il (ii) wOlU O wOiU U wOlU a wOlU E U U U U / 'chaussure..el!e/la' wOlU yu wOlU yu wOlU yu yr3bl yrSbl yrSbl yrSbl classe 'p6re (i) i objet direct / 'main (b) U / \ a; O wOlU O sujet j, j, j, j, j, j, j, yr3bl s (nom propre) 'Rabat 'Rabet 'Rabet 'Rabet •• wOlU (en parlant du chien le/la lave* (en parlant le/la lave' pronom objet de I'enfant etc.) de la chemise du petit pot etc.) (en parlant du boucj, du chapeau du poisson (en parlant de I'automobile le/la lave' le/la lave' •> j, j, j. j, j, etc.) j, j, j, etc.) un autre processus morphosyntaxique celui de On voit qu'un adjectif qui modifie un nom appartenant ci la classe / O / prend comme derni6re voyelle un [ O ]; de meme, le modifieur d'un nom appartenant k la classe / U / prend comme derni6re voyelle un U ], etc. Nous pr6sentons en I'accordS entre [ le nom (4) et I'adjectif. , Timmons (4) & Dunn: Accord classe / adjectif / Sdlection morphophonologique des classes en kpokolo / nom 139 140 Studies in the Linguistic Sciences 19:2 (Fall 1989) marqueur de genre dont la forme au singulier est [ a ], alors que les appartenant au genre masculin prennent le marqueur [ o ]. (6) Accord en genre en a. b. italien Questa ragazza 6 'Cette fille noms alta est grande' Questa ragazzQ e altQ 'Ce gargon est grand' c. Questa automobile d bella 'Cette automobile est belle' d. Questfl ristorante e famosa 'Ce restaurant est repute' dans on rend compte des diff^rentes formes le ph6nom6ne d'accord en genre. Le marqueur de genre n'apparait pas toujours sur le nom, bien qu'un genre lui soit tout de meme assign^ (of. c. automobile = genre f6minin / d. En effet, le genre est une propriete ristorante = genre masculin). morphologique inherente au nom. Un nom qui ne serait pas marqu6 pour un genre en italien serait rejete parce qu'il ne repondrait pas k cette propriety universelle de la classification nominale. Ainsi, les phrases de (6), prises par les determinants et les adjectifs par La question maintenant est de deteminer les facteurs qui permettent nom k une classe donn6e en kpokolo; de d6finir,en quelque sorte, les criteres linguistiques retenus dans le classement des nominaux dans d'assigner chaque cette langue. On notera sans peine que les noms appartenant k la classe / O / se regroupent sur la base d'une propri6t6 semantique commune. En effet, la pluparl des noms qui entrent dans cette classe refdrent aux etres humains. Ainsi, a partir du sens du nom, on peut pr6dire le marqueur de classe qui lui sera associ6. Notons cependant que certains noms denotant des animes etroitement associ6s k I'activitd de I'homme entrent 6galement dans cette classe. Ainsi, les animaux familiers comme le chat sepuye ou le chien gweye de meme que les animaux rituels comme le coq kUkwE\on\ partie de la classe humain. Pour ce qui est des autres classes, est impossible de relever un crit6re s6mantique qui puisse relier les nominaux entre eux. En effet, quel trait pourrait relierdes noms comme larmes, poll, terre, chanson, sauce, chemise, rat, etc., qui appartiennent tous a la classe / U / ? De meme, pour la classe / a /, on ne crapaud, ragout, voit pas tres bien quel trait pourrait relier des noms comme il : : Timmons genou, classe tortue, / E & Dunn: riz, Selection morphophonologique des classes en kpokolo La calegon, main, etc. meme impossibilite s'observe pour 141 la /. La seule considdration qui puisse etre retenue dans la selection de ces classes est celle de la 'ressemblance phonologique' qui existe entre les dernieres voyelles des noms appartenant a une meme classe. Notre premiere tache sera done de definir de fagon plus explicite ce que nous entendons par 'ressemblance phonologique", de fagon a rendre compte des differentes restrictions qu'on observe en finale de nominaux dans la distribution des voyelles en kpokolo. En effet, on remarque que les noms appartenant a la classe / U / ne presentent comme voyelle finale que des voyelles arrondies, alors que les noms appartenant k la classe / E / n'ont en finale que des voyelles d'avant. Les noms de la classe / a / ne prennent en finale qu'un a ou sa forme harmonisee [ e ].^ [ Enfin, les noms appartenant k la classe / O / ] acceptent n'importe quelle a noter qu'aucun nom en kpokolo ne se termine par une voyelle centrale. Etant donn6 que Ton veut prefer ici a la voyelle finale du nom une fonction morphologique de classement, serait interessant de faire decouler ces contraintes de notre definition formelle des classes phonologiques et de leur mode de selection. Le tableau (7) recapitule les facteurs semantique et phonologique qui priment dans le classement des nominaux en kpokolo. voyelle peripherique en finale. il (7) Tableau recapitulatif Par ailleurs, il est 142 3. Studies in the Linguistic Sciences 19:2 (Fall 1989) Cadre th^orique Pour definir la notion de 'ressemblance phonologique', nous utilisons la des representations phonologiques d6velopp§e dans Kaye, Lowenstamm & Vergnaud (1985)7 En particulier, nous montrons que la notion de 'tete d'expression' joue un role determinant dans le systeme de classe en theorie kpokolo. Dans Kaye, Lowenstamm & Vergnaud (1985; desormais KLV), on fait I'hypothese que tous les systemes vocaliques peuvent etre d§riv6s de trois elements I, U et A. Les elements eux-memes sont indivisibles, lis sont d6finis en fonction d'une theorie de la marque comme I'ensemble des matrices de traits ne comportant qu'une seule valeur marquee. : Elements vocaliques de base (8) I = - arrondi + arrondi - - arriere + arriere + arriere + haut U = + haut A = - arrondi haut - ATR -ATR ATR - bas - bas bas Pour chacune de ces matrices, le trait dont la valeur est marqu6e est KLV designent ce trait comme 6tant le trait "chaud" de r6lement. Chaque element est represents sur une ligne etiquette du trait chaud qui le souligne. caracterise. Ainsi, U est represents sur la ligne Arrondie, I, sur la ligne ArriSre, L'ensemble de lignes horizontales est entrecoupS par des lignes verticales L'intersection reliant les elements k une ou plusieurs positions du squelette. etc. d'une ligne verticale et horizontale, sur laquelle n'apparait aucun element, est remplie par la voyelle froide: c'est-ci-dire, une matrice n'ayant aucun trait chaud. (9) Voyelle froide^ - arrondi + arriere Y Dans = + haut - ATR - bas certains systSmes, les lignes peuvent etre fusionnSes. C'est le cas Entre autres les lignes Arrondie et ArriSre sont fusionnSes. en kpokolo ou Timmons & Dunn: Selection morphophonologique des classes en kpokolo 143 le parametre de la fusion des lignes pr6dit qu'aucune voyelle arrondie d'avant ne pourra apparaitro dans ce systeme. choses, Suivant ce qui vient d'etre dit, le systeme vocalique du kpokolo est represente comme en (10a), ou de fagon 6quivalente comme en (10b), suivant ia notation parenthetique. (10) Representation phonologique du kpokolo (a) Structure interne des segments vocaliques element ATR I I I j I j — u-I— U— y— v— Y— Y— A-A -A — — A— — Y— A— A — Y— A- Arrlere/An-ondi— I— U— Y — I— u— Y— Y— Y Y Haut X [I] (b) I xxxx xxxxxxxx [Ul[a][E][0] [I] [3][i][u][e][o] [i] [e] Notation parenthetique ( V = = = = = = = = = = = = = [U] [O] [I] [E] [a] [i] [3] [*1 [u] [0] [i] [e] [6] En (10a et b). r6l6ment soulign6 agit comme tete de I'expression phonologique. 9 La notion de tete d'une expression est utilisee dans le calcul matriciel et permet de d6river la forme phon6tique des expressions phonologiques. Une expression consiste en une tete et un operateur. Par convention, la tete est soulign6e et plac6e ^ la droite de I'op^rateurJO Le calcul d'une expression consiste a assigner la valeur du trait chaud de I'op^rateur au meme trait de la tete, ainsi, I'expression ( A • ) dont la tete est U se calcule U 144 Studies in the Linguistic Sciences 19:2 (Fall 1989) comme en (1 1) ou la valeur du trait chaud de rop6rateur se substitue k celle de la tete. (11) Calcul matriciel 4. arrondi + arrondi arriere + arriere + arriere haut + haut - ATR - ATR ATR bas - bas bas U O + arrondi haut Analyse Nous sommes maintenant en mesure de definir formellement la 'ressemblance phonologique' qui determine I'appartenance k une classe, de meme que les classes elles-memes en kpokolo. Sur la base de ce que Ton vient de presenter, on peut affirmer qu'il existe trois classes phonologiques qui correspondent aux primitifs de la th6orie des 6lements de KLV, c'est-^-dire, I, U, A. Un nom se terminant par une voyelle dont la tete est un de ces trois elements appartiendra a la classe correspondante. Ainsi, la selection de la classe en kpokolo est fonction de I'identitd de la tete de la derni6re voyelle du nom avec celle du marqueur de classe (de la classe elle-meme) (cf. 12 & la page suivante). Le marqueur d'accord peut §tre different du marqueur de classe. Ceci marque d'accord peut int^grer d'autres informations morphemiques que la seule appartenance k une classe donn^e. Ainsi, les nominaux appartenant k la classe / 1 / ont pour marqueur d'accord singulier la voyelle / E /, mais comme marqueur d'accord pluriel la voyelle I ]. D'ailleurs, s'explique par le fait que la [ de fagon g^n^raie, le pluriel s'exprime par la substitution de la dernidre voyelle de I'adjectif, du pronom, du possessif, et meme du nom pour certaines classes par la voyelle I ]. y a done en ce qui a trait a la formation du pluriel une neutralisation phonologique de la repartition des classes. Nous avons pour les marqueurs d' accord / O / et / E /, une distribution analogue, ainsi que pour les marqueurs d'accord / U / et / 1 /. Par consequent la repartition des marqueurs d'accord que on observe pour le singulier n'op^re pas identiquement pour le pluriel. Nous pr6sentons, en (13), la fagon dont le kpokolo forme le pluriel reguiier des noms. On notera que la classe s6mantique / humain / et la classe phonologique / 1 / forme leur pluriel par I'ajout du suffixe / -a / au radical du nom. [ I' II Timmons & Dunn: (12) Selection Selection morphophonologique des classes en kpokolo des classes phonologiques en kpokoloi^ Norn 145 146 Studies in the Linguistic Sciences 19:2 (Fall 1989) Le glide s'interposant entre le suffixe et le radical est conditionnd par la tete de voyelle finale du radical et a pour fonction d'eviter une sequence de deux voyelles contigu§s. la (13) Formation classe / pluriel regulier des noms humain /=Vnom...v + a Singulier to du Pluriel classe / U /=Vnom...(v->0) + Singulier Pluriel I Timmons (14) & Dunn: Accord classe yuwej pluriel adjectif / humain / Selection morphophonologique des classes en kpokolo nom classe / k3dl 'grands enfants' 'grands' d3dl, 'enfants' kUkwI k3dl b'l i i 'grands coqs' i sepuyewe k3dl j 'grands chats' i / U / kSdl 'grands harpes' 'grands' j 'harpes' 'grands' 'coqs' 147 'pieds' kSdl 'grands pieds' 'grands' f3fl kSdl j i i 'grands i poils' 'chats' 'grands' 'polls' 'grands' cifi kSdl ketl kSdl 'grandes chemises' 'grandes' i classe kOtI 'grands chefs' i / A classe / kSdl i 'mains' i 'grandes mains' kokotlyg 'grands' kSdl 'gr. chaussures* 'chaussures' 'grandes' sikpeli \ i dagbeli kSdl i j i 'chemises' 'grands' 'chefs' i 'gr. 'chapeaux' 'grands' vSklj kSdl 'boucs' 'grands' i I / kSdl j i 'grands pores' 'pores' 'grands' gleye kSdlj j lOwEya 'grands singes' 'grands' 'singes' chapeaux' / kSdl j 'elephants' j 'grands elephants' 'grands' kSdl 'gr. chlmpanzes' 'chlmpanzes' 'grands' gwEyai 'grands boucs' i Nous pouvons par le fait meme expliquer pourquol une voyelle non s'agit de poser, pour les p6rlpherique ne peut apparaitre en finale de mot. nominaux en kpokolo, un syst6me de classe fond6 sur les considerations phonologiques exprimees cl-dessus, de meme qu'une condition generate de classement faisant appel k la notion de tete.''^ De plus, une condition sp6clfique de classement dolt etre pos6e pour rendre compte de la classe II 'humain'i3 (1 (cf. 15 a-b). 5) Conditions sur le (a) classement des nominaux en kpokolo classement g6n6ral: Vnom...tetedeV crit6re finale = phonologique {I, U,A} Studies in the Linguistic Sciences 19:2 (Fall 1989) 148 (b) classement specifique: nom 5. critere = s6mantique 'humain' Conclusion Nous avons vu que le kpokolo imposait aux membres de la cat6gorie + N ] un critere g6n6ral de classement faisant appel k la notion de 'tete d'une expression' telle que developpee dans Kaye, Lowenstamm & Vergnaud (1985). Nous avons pu constater egalement que les facteurs phonologiques retenus pour le classement n'6taient pas arbitraires, mais correspondaient plutot a ce qui definit, dans une theorie particulaire, la base de tous les systemes vocaliques, c'est-^-dire les 6l§ments I, U, A Ceci nous a permis de rendre compte d'une contralnte sur la distribution des voyeiles centrales dans [ . les noms. NOTES *Cette recherche a et6 rendue possible grace aux subventions du CRSH #411-85-0012 du Canada et du FCAR # 87-EQ-2681 du Qu6bec. De plus Christian Dunn a benefici6 d'une bourse doctorale du CRSH # 452-88-1683 du Canada. Toutes les informations presentees sur le kpokolo sont bas6es sur des seances que nous avons menees avec informateur durant I'hiver 1989 au Groupe de Recherche en Linguistique Africaniste de UQAM. Nous tenons a remercier notre informateur Gustave Rabet Dagbo pour son aide pr§cieuse, I' ainsi qu'lsabelle HaTk pour avoir revu et corrige cet article. Nous remercions deux r6viseurs anonymes de la revue Studies Sciences, pour leurs critiques et commentaires judicieux. egalement les in the Linguistic ^La repartition des classes dans les langues du groupe Kru varie legerement d'une langue a I'autre. Voir Dawson (1975) pour le tepo, Marchese (1979) pour le proto-kru, Kaye (1981) et Vogler (1987) pour le vata. 'Advanced Tongue Root '; projection de la racine d© la permet de distinguer, entre autres, les voyeiles [ e ]. o ] de [ 6 ], respectivement. Voir Kaye, Lowenstamm & Vergnaud (1985) pour les ] [ 3 details de leurs propositions concernant le statut special de I'^lement ATR. 2 ATR, en anglais langue. Ce trait : [ 3 Dans ce qui suit, nous ne transcrivons pas les tons puisqu'ils ne sont aucunement pertinents au probleme aborde. Par ailleurs, I'apostrophe indique rimplosion lorsqu'elle suit I'occlusive labiale voisee [ b ]. Les groupes [ ng ] et [ nj ] representent respectivement les occlusives nasales v6laires et palatales. Timmons & Dunn: Selection morphophonologique des classes en kpokolo 149 Les groupes voisees / gb ] et [ kp ] transcrivent des occlusives velaires labialisees [ non-voisees. Enfin, [ j ] est une occlusive palatale. faut remarquer que la presence du nom antecedent dans la phrase pas requise. Comme Kaye (1981) a note, le choix de la forme pronominale est d'ordre phonologique en vata (comme c'est le cas en kpokolo), mais les contextes dans lesquels ce pronom apparait ne le sont pas. La pronominalisation est un processus morphosyntaxique en kpokolo tout comme en frangais. Pour une etude detaillee de la pronominalisation en vata (langue kru), voir Kaye (1981). ^ II n'est I' 5 Voir Neil I'accord, de Elliot (1981) pour une caracterisation du meme que Dunn & Timmons phenomene de (en preparation). ^En kpokolo, comme dans la plupart des dialectes bete, le mot existe phonologique est soumis a une harmonie lexicale + ATR ]. En outre, en kpokolo une harmonie d'arrondissement declenchee par les voyelles hautes arrondies (i.e. u ] et [ U ]). Concernant les contraintes de cooccurrence entre VI et V2, les lecteurs sont convies a consulter, une fois de plus, Kaye, il [ [ Lowenstamm & Vergnaud (1985). ^Nous verrons que la notion de 'segment', telle qu'elle etait consideree en phonologie generative classique (cf. Chomsky & Halle (1968)), c'est-a-dire comme le resultat d'un faisceau de traits realises simultanement, est fort dans les theories particulaires (cf. entre autres, Anderson & Jones Schane (1984), Kaye, Lowenstamm & Vergnaud (1985), Goldsmith Ewen & van der Hulst (1985)). differente (1974), (1985), ^Cette caracterisation de la voyelle froide est d'une importance cruciale en En effet, aucun nominal ne se termine par une voyelle centrale (i.e. [ \ 4 et 3 ]). Toutes ces voyelles ont comme tete d'expression la voyelle froide, on dira done que I'expression est constituee d'une tete 'vide'. En d'autres termes, kpokolo. , tous les nominaux en kpokolo doivent se terminer par une voyelle dont la 'tete est pleine" (cf. 10 a et b). Cette specification en soi n'a rien d'etonnant, si Ton considere, en morphologie, que la tete d'un 'mot' doit etre egalement 'pleine' Nous verrons a la section (cf. Williams (1981) et Di Sciullo & Williams (1987)). 4 que nous predisons effectivement avec notre analyse la non-occurrence en finale des trois voyelles centrales [1,4,3]. 9Une expression constitute de deux voyelles froides (v) est ac6phale, puisque la voyelle froide a un statut d'el6ment d' identity au sens mathematique du terme—dans le calcul matriciel. L'6lement ATR, en sa qualite — d'op§rateur externe, ne peut jamais agir comme tete d'expression. . 150 Studies in the Linguistic Sciences 19:2 (Fall 1989) lOLe calcul matriciel de Kaye, Lowenstamm & Vergnaud (1985) est quelque peu similaire a celui presente dans Bach & Wheeler (1980) pour les Grammaires de Montague. 11 faut distinguer la voyelle [ § ] derivee par le processus d'harmonie ATR des autres voyelles centrales. En effet, la selection des classes nominales doit s'effectuer avant le renversement du rapport tete/operateur provoque par ['assignation de I'element ATR harmonique tel que stipule par la theorie du charme. (Concernant la theorie du charme et le mecanisme d'inversion du rapport tete/operateur, voir Kaye, Lowenstamm & Vergnaud 1985.) II 1211 va sans dire une reference ^ une 'tete plelne* (i.e. [ I, U ou A ]). i^Sauvageot (1965) a remarqud ^galement qu'il existait des langues ou une double repartition du lexique des nominaux pouvait §tre relev^e: 'I'une etant fondee sur des crit6res formels, I'autre sur des criteres s6mantiques'. Entre autres, a note qu'en wolof, comme dans la plupart des langues de la famille Niger-Congo, une redistribution du stock nominal, basee non plus sur la forme du classificateur, mais sur un critere s6mantique du type 'humainV'non humain' s'operait au niveau du systeme pronominal. Sauvageot reserve le terme de 'classe' aux faits reposant sur le crit6re formel et le terme de 'genre' k ceux fondes sur le critere s6mantique. La m§me distinction terminologique pourrait etre employee pour le cas du kpokolo. il BIBLIOGRAPHIE Anderson, 1974. Three Theses Concerning Phonological J. M. & C. Jones. Representations. Journal of Linguistics 10. 1-26. Bach, E. & D. Wheeler. 1980. Montague phonology. University of Massachusetts, MA. MS Chomsky, Noam, & Morris Halle. 1968. The sound pattern of English. New York: Harper & Row. DAWSON, K. 1975. L'accord vocalique en t6po. S6rie H. 8. Di SciULLO, A. M. & E. Williams. Annales de I'Universitd d'Abidjan. 1987. On the definition of word. S.J. Keyser Cambridge. MA: The MIT Press. Dunn, C. & C. Timmons. (en pr6paration). Euphonic agreement. UQAM. Elliot, W. Neil. 1981. Grammatical Number. Th6se de Ph. D. The City University of New York. NY. EWEN, C. & H. van der Hulst. 1985. Single-valued features and nonlinear analysis of vowel harmony. Linguistics in the Netherlands 1985. H. Bennis & F. Beukema (eds.), 39-48. Dordrecht: Foris. (ed.). Timmons & Dunn: Selection morphophonologique des classes en kpokolo 151 J. 1985. Vowel harmony in Khalkha Mongolian, Yaka, Finnish and Hungarian. Phonology Yearbook 2. C.J. Ewen & J. M. Anderson (eds.), 253-275. Cambridge, MA: Cambridge University Press. KAYE, J. D. 1981. La selection des formes pronominales en vata. Revue quebecoise de linguistique. 11.117-134. KAYE, J. D., Lowenstamm J., & J.-R Vergnaud. 1985. The internal structure of Phonology phonological elements: a theory of charm and government Yearbook 2. C. Ewen & J. Anderson (eds), 305-328. Cambridge, MA: Goldsmith, . Cambridge University Press. 1967. La classification nominale dans les langues negroG. africaines. Centre National de la Recherche Scientifique. Paris. Marchese, L 1979. Atlas linguistique kru. Institut de linguistique appliquee Manessy, LXXIII. R.C.I. Description synchronique d'un dialecte wolof: University d'Abidjan. SAUVAGEOT.S. 1965. du Dyolof. Memoire le parler F.A.N 73. Dakar. Schane, S.A. 1984. The fundamentals of particle phonology. Phonology Yearbook 1. C.J. Ewen & J. M. Anderson (eds.), 129-155. Cambridge, MA: Cambridge VOGLER, P. 1987. Strasbourg 3. Strasbourg. Williams, E. 1981. I. University Press. Le parler vata. Strasbourg: On Travaux de I'lnstitut the notions 'lexically related' Linguistic inquiry 12.245-274. d'Ethnologie de Universite des sciences humaines de and 'head of a word'. IV Lexicography & Historical Linguistics Mohammed Trends in Oromo lexicon Ali and lexicography Robert botne Reconstruction of a grammaticalized auxiliary in Bantu Cynthia Robb Clamons Modification of the gender system in the Wollegan dialect of Oromo studies in Volume 19, the Linguistic Sciences Number 1989 2, Fall TRENDS IN OROMO LEXICON AND LEXICOGRAPHY Mohammed University of AN Warsaw This paper presents an overview of trends in Oromo lexicon and lexicography and to suggest an alternative approach to this subject. The study focuses attention first on the assessment of past lexical works and review of recent developments. Second, proposals developing for Oromo lexicography, particularly the creation of new presented at some length. Future areas of lexical work, as a passing comment, are discussed, and illustrations are provided to support the analysis. lexical items, are 1 Past Lexical Works The earliest lexical works on Oromo are those of Father Ludwig Krapf's Vocabulary of the Galla Language in 1842 and of Karl Tutschek's Lexikon der Galla- Sprache in 1844. Then we have Viterbo's Grammatica e dizionaho delta lingua oromonica in 1892. m 1913 provides interesting Grammatical information especially part of sentences are not supplied. The major short- Foot's Galla-English, English-Galla Dictionary collections of basic vocabulary. speech coming is given. Illustrative of Foot's dictionary is its inadequate transcription system. Anonymous, Vocabulaire Frangais, Oromo, Abyssin, in 1928 contains good collections of basic vocabulary. Transcription of consonants is generally adequate except that there is no differentiation between voiced stop d and implosive stop dh, and between voiceless labial stop p and ejective labial stop Gemination is fairly well marked, but vowel length is not. There is a small grammatical note given in the introduction including numeral and possessive and personal pronouns. ph. Da Thiene's Dizionario della lingua galla works on Oromo lexicography. It is a result of is one over of the fifty most important years of work (1881- 156 Studies in the Linguistic Sciences 19:2 (Fall 1989) among the Eastern Oromo as a missionary. As such, this dictionary an Eastern Oromo dialect. The dictionary is divided into two parts; Oromo-ltalian and Italian-Oromo. Elaborate grammatical notes are provided. Transcription of consonants and gemination is fairly adequate while that of vowel length is comparatively poor. Along with the entries grammatical information, particularly part of speech, and illustrative sentences are provided. Inflectional information is given but not in a systematic manner. Da Thiene's dictionary is a large storehouse of Oromo lexicon. 1938) reflects Arenzano's Grammatica delta lingua galla (1940) gives very interesting collections of basic vocabulary of Italian-Oromo and Oromo-ltalian. The consonants and marking of gemination is satisfactory. Whereas vowel length is inadequate. Grammatical information, along with the transcription of that of entries, is practically absent. 1.1 Recent Developments To begin with, we have Father Venturino's Dizionario Borana-ltalian, published in 1973. In the introduction a very brief phonological and grammatical explanation is given. The transcription of consonants and notation of gemination is good while that of vowel length is inadequate. Grammatical information such as part of speech and illustrative sentences are sporadic. Father Venturino also published in 1976 Dizionario Italiano-Borana, using the same system of transcription as the one above. Gragg's Oromo Dictionary (Oromo-English) appeared in 1982. This is a result of systematic, accurate and scholarly work. It is based on the Western Oromo dialect. It contains about 3000 main entries, and along with sub-entries the number exceeds well over 6000. This is quite a formidable supply of lexicon for an inflectional language like Oromo. This dictionary gives found the a very informative introduction. Regarding lexical organization, citation of verbs based on the first person singular present to be more practical than the one based on third person singular present. The difference between the two approaches is slight: verbs end in -addh for first person and -ta for third person. In any case, found the former approach most helpful in identifying the root. Along with the entries, elaborate grammatical information is provided in three areas: part of speech, inflectional information and syntactical information. The systematic index, among other functions, helps one to get easy access to lexical items for a given subject matter, e.g., ___location, size-quantity, movement, body parts, shape-color. As such, it has a very important practical use. Gragg's dictionary is a milestone in the development of Oromo lexicography. dictionary I I Father Jaammoo's Kuussaa Sagalee Oromoo (1987) is the first Oromodictionary on record. The author Is a native speaker of Western Oromo Oromo hence script. this dictionary reflects his dialect. Entries are listed The dictionary is written in Ethiopic according to the order of Ethiopic syllabary. Ali: Trends Grammatical information, in Oromo Lexicon and Lexicography 157 speech, is absent. Inflectional sentences are provided in a sporadic manner. Synonyms are rarely given. In spite of these weaknesses, however, Jaammoo's work constitutes a great contribution to the development of Oromo information particularly part of inadequate. is Illustrative lexicography. Heine's Monnuyo, an Oromo dialect (1980) contains a small vocabulary of English-Oromo. Transcription system is accurate so also is the system of lexical organization. Grammatical information is limited to part of speech. Heine's The Waata dialect of Oromo (1981) contains a small vocabulary of English-Oromo. The presentation of the vocabulary is based on the same pattern as the one above. Owens (1985) in A Grammar his of Harar Oromo gives a small but interesting collections of basic vocabulary in Oromo-English. The system of accurate, as is the method of lexical organization. Adequate grammatical Information, especially part of speech and inflectional data, is transcription is provided. Stroomer's Comparative Study of tt)e Ttiree Southerri Oromo Dialects of (1987) gives very elaborate vocabulary of Barana, Orma and Waata The transcription dialects. The vocabulary is prepared in Oromo-English. system and lexical organization is accurate. Grammatical information on parts of speech, inflectional information and limited illustrative sentences are Kenya provided. Stroomer's book is a significant lexical work on Oromo. Maanifestoo Paartii Kommonistii {Manifesto of ttie Communist Party) translated by Kuwwee Kumsaa in 1976 contains a very small vocabulary regarding technical terms in social sciences. There is still a considerable number of new words in the text which are not covered by the glossary. The text It is a very interesting attempt to resolve the is written in the Ethiopic script. problems of neologisms. Oromtittii, a publication of the Union of Oromo Women in Europe in its 1986 issue, provides a very small collection of vocabulary in Oromo-EnglishArabic of technical terms in the text. There still remains a substantial number of new words in the text which are not included in the glossary. Regardless of the represents a very good beginning. small size of the vocabulary, it Gamta'a Oromo-English Dictionary lexicography. 1.2 Overall Gamta is (in press) will further enrich a native Oromo speaker and a professional Oromo linguist. assessment The objectives regarding the works on Oromo lexicon varies from one scholar to another. To start with, Krapf(1842), and Foot (1913) published their 158 Studies iA the Linguistic Sciences 19:2 (Fall 1989) dictionaries witli a view to facilitate communication with the indigenous Oromo people. The second group, such as Viterbo (1892), Anonymous (1928), Da Thiene Arenzano (1940), Venturino (1973 and 1976), was basically motivated by the desire to extend the effort of Evangelization to the Oromo people. The third group, consisting of the owrks of Heine (1980 and 1981), Owens (1985), Stroomer (1987), was driven by the need to explain concepts and basic vocabulary used in their respective studies of Oromo grammatical structure of given dialects. The fourth group, comprising mainly Kumsaa (1976) and Oromtlttii (1986), aimed at providing their readers with the meanings of new words used in their texts. In contrast, the last group, consisting of Tutschek (1844), Gragg (1982). Jaamoo (1987), Gamta (forthcoming), aimed at producing purely scholarly work on Oromo lexicography. (1939), On the whole, the works of the above mentioned scholars, despite the in scholarly objectives and the level of descriptive adequacy, helped a great deal to develop Oromo lexicography. Nevertheless, there was no deliberate effort made to extend the use of various systems of word formation with a view to develop Oromo lexicon for technical and scientific purposes. This differences paper aims 2. to fill this gap. Proposals for developing Oromo lexicography In view of the foregoing, an attempt will be made to show the existence in the language of various ways of developing Oromo lexicon. An attempt is also made here to create an awareness of the existence of productive forms for developing Oromo lexicon by providing illustrative sentences. The methods used for analysis include derivation, composition and borrowing. 2.1 Derivation The forms given here section is to exist in the make these forms Oromo familiar and language. The purpose in this show the wide range of their to application. 2.1.1 Passive adjectives Passive adjectives are formed by suffixing -aa, -tuu, which give the These forms are very productive (Owens 1987, equivalent of English -able. Gragg 1982). Thus, we have: arrarfam- banambeekamdabram- be be be be reconciled araarfamaa- reconcilable opened known banamtuubeekamtuudabramtuu- openable knowable passable passed Ali: harkifamjaalatame.g. Trends in Oromo Lexicon and Lexicography harkifamaajaalatamaa- be stretched be liked 159 stretchable likable Shuraabni diimaan kan at! naaf bitte harkifamaa. red sweater which you bought me is stretchable." The ganda keennyatti hedduu jaalatamaa. Inni our village, he 'In Compound 2.1.2 is very likable." adjectives There are certain variations regarding the affixes for compound adjective formations between Harar and Wellegga Oromo. In the latter case, we have -qabeessa 'having', -laafeessa 'weak -dhabeessa 'lacking in', -guddeessa 'abounding in', and many others (Gragg 1976:182). Compound in', adjectives are well developed use Wellegga Oromo. These forms are in current We note a lot of these forms in the days of Onesimus Nesib. his Gall Spelling-Book (1894). at least since particularly in In 'lacking contrast, in' in Oromo we -qabduu 'having' and -dhabduu -qabduu and -dhabduu are equivalent respectively (Ali 1987:9). In fact, the forms -qabduu Harar or 'not having'. to English -/u/and -less, The have: suffixes and -dhabduu are not very familiar in Harar Oromo except in certain technical usages. But, the most common forms and those in current use are the related forms such as -qabeennya and -dhabeennya which are equivalent to English fulness and -lessness respectively. At any rate, the purpose here familiar for developing technical to is and make the forms -qabduu and -dhabduu words. These forms are very scientific Hence, we have: productive. abdii hope bifa color abdiiqabduu bifaqabduu colorful dhandhama taste dhandhamaqabduu tasteful horii money horiidhabduu humna power humnadhabduu moneyless powerless qaanyii shame qaanyiidhabduu shameless e.g. hopeful Hawwiituun shamiza bifaqabduu bitte. 'Hawwiituu bought a colorful shirt.' Inni bara shan hojii hinqabu kanaaf horiidhabduu tahe. five years that is why he became moneyless. 'He has [had] no job for 160 2.1.3 Studies in the Linguistic Sciences 19:2 (Fall 1989) hin- + passive adjectives we have forms which are not commonly found in technical and usage but exist in the language and are in current use. So, the purpose here is to create awareness of the existence of these forms in the language and popularize them for technical and scientific use. These forms are quite productive and give interesting terms for technical and scientific Here, scientific application. The morpheme hin- is a negation marker which is prefixed to verbs and Passive adjectives with hin- correspond to English in-, im-, and unplus adjectives (cf. All 1987:3). Thus, we have: adjectives. invariable hinjijjiramne hinobsamne intolerable hindabramne impassable hinqoodamne impartible hinbeekamne unknown hinfuramne unsolvable Karaan Qarsaa e.g. The Rakkoon This 2.1.4 fi Girawaa jidduu jiru road from Qarsaa to Girawaa is tuni is ganatti karaa hindabramne. impassable in the rainy season.' waan hinfuramne. an unsolvable problem.' noun + -bailees This form of derivation is in current use in the language. But, does not commonly occur in technical and scientific literature. Therefore, the aim here is to make this productive form familiar and show its interesting applications. it The -bailees suffix 'make wrong'; -bailees 'wrongly' 1987: (cf. Ali 6), is is as a causative verb form which means 'make bad', equivalent to English mis- meaning 'badly' or illustrated below: bifa color bifaballeesa miscolor gorsa advice gorsaballeesa misadvise maqaa name maqaaballeesa misname ulfina esteem ulfinaballeesa misesteem e.g. Makiinaa tee diimaa hindibin, bifaballeesita. 'Do not paint your care red, you shall miscolor Inni Ibsaa, Tulluu miti. "He is Nama Ibsaa and not Tulluu. it.' maqaaballeesita. You misname people.' Ali: 2.1.5 Trends in Oromo Lexicon and Lexicography 161 verb + -tuu This form is in current use in Oromo language. The idea here is to show the possibility of extension of this form for obtaining a wide range of terms for technical and scientific application. Here, we can observe that very interesting series of terms can be constructed by suffixing -tuu (agentive suffix) to verbs: dib- 162 Studies in the Linguistic Sciences 19:2 (Fall 1989) Nama biraa ulfeesuun ifulfeesu. 'Respecting other people is respecting oneself.' 2.2.1.2 lf(i) + postposition Ali: irra Trends in Oromo Lexicon and Lexicography 163 164 Studies in the Linguistic Sciences 19:2 (Fall 1989) 2.2.3.3 Gargar + verb Gargar means baha 'apart' or 'separately'. Thus, we have: Ali: dubbii Trends affairs yeroo time dhiheesa supply heera regulation e.g. in Oromo Lexicon and Lexicography dubbil-alaa external affairs yeroogubbaa dhihessajala overtime under supply heerakeessaa internal regulation 165 Ibsaan yeroogubbaa hojjata kanaaf saaqa hedduu argata. is why he gets a lot of money." 'Ibsaa works overtime that Bara kana dhihessajalaa kan bunaa qabna. This year we have under supply of coffee.' 2.2.4.2 Noun noun -i- We use certain base forms which give us various compound words. They 'father', haala 'conditions', karaa 'way' or 'road', and sirna 'system', as in the following examples: include: abbaa seera law qilleensa air bishaan sagalee e.g. water sound abbaaseeraa lawyer haalaqilleensaa karaabishaani sirnasagalee climate waterway sound system abbaaseeraa tahuu fedha. wants to be a lawyer.' Bilisaan 'Bilisaa Haaliqilleensaa kan biyya keennyaa fayyaaf gaarii. 'The climate of our country 2.3 is good for health.' Borrowing It is observed that, out of a selected sample of 300 loanwords in Oromo, nouns constitute about 95% and the rest are verbs. The sample contains loanwords from Arabic and English. In Oromo, as in other languages, words such as video, computer, plastic, satellite are borrowed directly. This is a common process that is observed in many other natural languages. In addition such terms, there are loan translations. Interesting loan translations can be obtained from German. Thus, to beekinsa afaani 166 Studies in the Linguistic Sciences 19:2 (Fall 1989) e.g. Argaayaan beekinsa ufaani barate. 'Aragaayaa studied Mikiinaa isaaf 'He bought a 3 linguistics.* qabaneesaa haaraya new bite. radiator for his car." Concluding remarks the preceding survey, we attempted to present a general picture of the Oromo lexicography. We have shown that there is a reasonably large number of studies in Oromo lexicon, but most of them lack depth. These works, however, do provide a solid basis upon which future studies can build. It is along these lines that we have suggested certain ways to create new lexical items so as to extend the dimensions of the Oromo lexicon. From the above analysis, we note that the system of derivation gives very productive word formations. Next comes the system of composition, i.e., the construction of In trends in compound words. words for scientific Loan translation plays a and technical uses. significant role in creating new a large quantity of Oromo lexicon scattered in various books and It is necessary to assemble them separately for each dialect. This enables the maximum use of the existing stock of lexical resources. A standard transcription system should be adopted to facilitate the wide use of lexical works, primarily as reference material for meanings of words and for correct spelling. Grammatical information, to the extent possible, must be expanded. Given the fact that Oromo is an inflectional language, expanded description of this aspect of the language would help enlarge the range of its There is literary materials. lexicon. Illustrative sentences, aside from the syntactical information they carry, should be designed to give examples on various contextual aspects of a given lexical item. Since inflectional processes phenomena, it is in Oromo morphophonemic morphophonemic notes in the be emphasized here that future often involve essential to provide sufficient introductory parts of lexical works. It is to research effort to publish a Standard English-Oromo dictionary as well as technical dictionaries of social and natural sciences would fill a serious gap in Oromo lexicography. REFERENCES ABDII,T. A. 1984. Makmmaaksa. AGRICOLA, C, and Agricola E. deutschen Sprache. Berlin, MS. 1987. Worter und Gegenworter: Leipzig. Antonyme der Ali: Trends in Oromo Lexicon and Lexicography 167 1987. Antonyms and some related problems In Oromo. Conference paper. 5th International Hamito-Semitic Congress. Vienna, Sept. 27-Oct. ALI, M. 2. 1988. Morphological features of two Oromo dialects: Harar and Wellegga. Conference Paper. 10th International conference of Ethiopian Studies. Paris, Aug. 22-26. ALI, M.. 1988. Review of G. Gragg's Oromo dictionary. Ethiopian Studies, . University of Anonymous. Anonymous. ARENSANO, Warsaw. 1928. Vocabulaire frangais oromo abyssin. Dire Daoua. 1973. HIrmaata dubbil afaan Oromoo. I. D. 1940. Grammatica della lingua galla, con esercizi traduzione, nonmenclatura, converaazione e vocabolario. BAXTER, 1987. P. Ethiopia's dl Harar. unacknowledged problem: the Oromo. African Affairs (July:283-296). BENDER, and M. Eteffa. Galla. Languages in Ethiopia, ed. by M. L. London. CERULLI, E. 1922. The folk-literature of the Galla of southern Abyssinia. Harvard African Studies 3. DINNEN, F. P. 1967. An introduction to general linguistics. New York: Holt Rinehart and Winston. M. Bender. GASPARINI, GRAGG, L., A. G. B. 1979. 1976. A grammar. Awasa. The Non-Semitic Languages practical outline of Gujjl Oromo Ethiopia, ed. by M. L of Wellegga. Bender, African Studies Center. of Michigan State University. GRAGG, Gene B. 1982. Oromo dictionary, with the help of Terfa Kumsa and other Oromos. Monograph No. 12, African Studies Center. Michigan State University, in cooperation with Oriental Institute. University of Chicago. East Lansing: xx + 462. HABERLAND, E. 1963. Galla sud-ethiopiens. Stuttgart. B. Munyo, an Oromo dialect. The Non-Bantu Languages of Kenya, ed. by Berd Heine and Wilhelm J. G. Molhig. Berlin. 1981. The Waata dialect of Oromo, grammatical sketch and vocabulary. The Non-Bantu Languages of Kenya, ed. by Berd Heine and Wilhelm J. G. Molhig. Berlin. HOCKETT, C. F. 1958. A course in modern linguistics. New York: Macmillan. HODSON, A. W. and C. H. Walker. An elementary and practical grammer of the Galla or Oromo language. London. HULTIN, J. 1982. The Oromo expansion reconsidered. Journal of Research on North East Africa 1:3 (Autumn). JAAMMOO, D. 1987. Kuussaa sagalee Oromoo (first Oromo-Oromo Dictionary). Wellegga. JAROSSEAU, A. 1922. Notions grammaticales sur la langue Galla (ou HEINE, . Oromo). Imprimerie Saint-Lazare. Dire Dawa. KORRAM, A. M. 1969. Oromo proverbs I. Journal of Ethiopian Studies 8:1 .65- 80. . 1972. Oromo proverbs II. Journal of Ethiopian Studies 11:105-126. 168 Studies in the Linguistic Sciences 19:2 (Fall 1989) KRAPF, L J. 1842. Vocabulary of the Galla language. KUMSAA, Kuwwee (trans.). Maanlfestoo Paartii Kommlstii. Addis Ababa. LAUNHARDT, J. 1973. A guide to learning the Oromo language. Addis Ababa. LEWIS, S. H. 1962. Historical problems in Ethiopia and the Horn of Africa. Reprinted from Annals of the New York Academy of Sciences. LYONS, J. 1978. Semantics. Cambridge University Press. MORENO, M. M. 1935. Favole e rime Galla. 1939. Grammatica teoreticao-pratica della lingua Galla con esercizi. Milano. NESIBO. 1893. Kaku Haaraa (The New Testament). Moncuilo. 1894. The Galla spelling-book. Moncuilo. NORDFELDT, M. 1947. A Galla grammer. Lemonde Oriental. Uppsala. OWENS, J. 1985. The Oromo causative: lexical grammar without lexical rules. Bloomington, Indiana. . . 1985. . STROOMER, H. A grammar of Harar Oromo. Hamburg. 1987. A comparative study of three southern Oromo dialects of Kenya. Leiden. THIENE, G. TRUDNO, D. A. 1939. Dizionario della lingua Galla. Harar. 1984. Oromo documentation, bibliography and maps. Oriental Studies, Department of African Institute of Languages and Cultures, Warsaw University. TUTSCHEK, K. 1844. Lexikon der Galla-Sprache. Munchen. EUROPE. 1986. Oromtittii. Bologna: Dizionario Borana-ltalaino. Oromo Women IN VENTURINO, B. 1973. UNION OF Editrice Missionario Italiana. 1976. Dizionario Italiano-Borana. Cathelic Mission Marsabit (Kenya) E. 1892. Grammatica e dizionario della lingua oromonica. Roma. ZABORSKI, A. 1975. Material for a comparative dictionary of Cushitic languages: Somali-Galla comparisons. Hamito-Semitica, ed. by J. & Th. Bynon. The Hague-Paris: 321-330. 1975. The Verb in Cushitic. Studies in Hamito-Semitic. Krakow: Universytet Jagiellonski. 1 984. Review of Gene Gragg's Oromo dictionary Africa and Ubersee . VITERBO, . . LXVII. . Studies in Volume 19, the Linguistic Sciences Number 2, Fall 1989 RECONSTRUCTION OF A GRAMMATICALIZED AUXILIARY IN BANTU Robert Botne Indiana University Bantu verbal formatives have frequently developed from grammaticalized auxiliary verbs, as exemplified in the future formative-fafrom -taka 'want' study the author suggests that a a sense of 'desire/ want', is the source of future formatives in various other Bantu languages. In particular, he argues that the future formatives -ond>, -ndisya-, -zidza-, and -lembe- found in four widely separated languages - Kimbundu (H21), Kikonzo (J41), Chichewa (N31b) and Kimabiha (P25) - are reflexes of such an auxiliary verb. The processes of grammaticalization, not always regular in these languages, have served to obscure this common origin. If correct, the study points to a wide-spread use of a 'desire/ want' + infinitive structure in Bantu, but one that may employ a different form of the verb 'want' in different languages. in Kiswahili. In this different auxiliary verb, also having The Bantu languages, as even a cursory glance of the different languages tense formatives. Many, and perhaps most, of these formatives have arisen from periphrastic constructions involving an auxiliary verb followed by an infinitive. In fact, Givdn (1971 :146) claims that (all?) Bantu modality prefixes arose from main verbs dominating sentential complements, most of them independently after dispersal of the Proto-Bantu speech community. The potential for this development was already present, he indicates, display a rich variety of verbal suggests (Giv6n 1969:198), 'in the reduced infinitival complement structure of modal verbs, ...such as "want".' However, the common origins of many of the formatives presently extant in the Bantu languages have been obscured as a result of extensive phonological and/or morphological processes. This has led some to state, as does Giv6n (1971 :156), that '...most of the modality prefixes cannot be reconstructed back to Proto-Bantu.' Nevertheless, it is still possible to reconstruct some earlier auxiliary roots and to indicate probable paths of grammaticalization. This paper represents an initial phase of exploration in 170 Studies in the Linguistic Sciences 19:2 (Fall 1989) reconstructing some of these auxiliaries, in effect trying to linl< together some of the diverse forms that occur. One ___domain of tense morphology that involves future formatives. one language (1) to another, especially rich in diversity to vary considerably from is These formatives seem as the forms tu-lembe-ku-tenda in (1 )-(4) attest. 'we will make (remote)' Kimabiha (P25) 'we will make (near)' Kimbundu (H21) 'we will (habitually) 'we will 1P-FUT-INF-make (2) tu-ond>banga 1 (3) ti-zi(dza)-panga 1 (4) P-FUT-make tru-ka-nd!sya-ko:la 1 make' Chichewa (N31b) P-FUTHAB-make make Kikonzo (J41) (remote)' P-T-FUT-make These languages - Kimabiha (P25), Kimbundu (H21), Chichewa (N31b), and Kikonzo (J41) (classified according to the Tervuren modification of Guthrie's system; see map in appendix) - will constitute the core of the analysis. In considering the future formatives in these four widely separated languages, will argue that the source of the formatives can be found in two verbs both having a sense of 'desire'. I 1 . Reanalyzing a root in Kimabiha (P25) The source of the remote future formative in Kimabiha because neither the full periphrastic form (5b) nor the verb lost (Harries (5) is readily apparent itself (6) has been 1940). (a) tu-lembe-ku-tenda (b) tu-lembela ku-tenda 'we ku-lembela (6) 'to will make (remote)' want' examples is the underlying morphology of answer is that the common Bantu suffixes -el- and -a are attached to a root -lemb-. However, evidence from other Bantu languages suggests that such an analysis is incorrect. What is not so apparent from these the verb stem. The seemingly self-evident 1 Botne: Reconstruction of a Grammaticalized Auxiliary in Bantu One 1 7 important piece of evidence comes from languages that exinibit a a verb in opposition to a transitive form, as in reflexive (and intransitive) form of (7) and (8). Kipende (K52) (7) -di-felela (a) -felela (b) 'wait in hope; hope' 'hope; wait' Kinande (J42) (8) -yi-tsutsa (a) -tsura (b) 'be covetous 'envy, covet (intr)' (tr)' Other languages have a reflexive form, but seem to have lost the non-reflexive counterpart (9-10). In some cases the reflexivized form has assumed the meaning and transitivity of the non-reflexive form. Chiyao (P25) (9) -li-jila 'await outcome with confidence (intr)' Shitembo (J57) (10) -ci-fisha 'desire, have need of (tr?)' we find the reflexivized form in one language, but the a close neighbor, as illustrated below in the case of two southern Zimbabwean languages and Setswana/Sesotho. In some areal clusters non-reflexive (11) in (a) -di-elezha 'covet' (b) -le-elezya 'desire strongly' Ha (M63) Chitonga (f^64) 'want' Setswana (S31) -eletsa (12) of these various data points strongly to a reflexivized form in it is not While the reflexive marker is listed by Harries (1940) as unknown for Bantu languages to have (or have had) more than one form of this prefix or for the vowel of the prefix to have become lowered. Holoholo (D28b, Coupez 1955), for example, utilizes both -If- and -/- (note that the symbol I is used here to represent a high close front vowel in a seven-vowel system, in place of Guthrie's cedilla). And in the Chitonga example above (11b), we find the reflexive with [e] rather than the more common [i]. Thus, rather than a root of the form -lemb- for Kimabiha, the root of the verb 'want' would be -mbel-, with a fossilized prefix le-. The composition of the stem, then, would be as in (13). Comparison Kimabiha. (13) -//' , -le - mbel - a 'want' 172 Studies in the Linguistic Sciences 19:2 (Fall 1989) Evidence supporting a root of this form can be found in several languages. While the Initial NC cluster may seem odd for a root, such intrusive nasals are not uncommon in Bantu. For example, we find in Chinsenga (N41; Ranger 1928) -nkala 'be, sit, dwell', which in other languages has the root form -kala. With respect to the general shape of this root, a similar future formative -be- is found in Omyene (B11) as illustrated in (14). (14) zwe-be-jena 1 P-FUT-see 'we will see' Though the original periphrastic construction appears not to exist, this formative derives from the verb -beta 'desire', which has undergone final syllable deletion as did -lembela in Kimabiha. Several other languages also have a cognate form of this verb 'desire', though it has not become grammaticalized as in Omyene and Kimabiha. most likely (15) -bil-am-a 'desire' Chitonga (M64) (16) -bind-am-a 'desire' Kikongo (HI 6) (17) -li-vel-a 'covet' Umbundu 'desire ardently' Sesotho (S33) (18) -bel-a+bel-a (R11) Further evidence supporting a reflexivized stem in Kimabiha comes from languages closer to the Kimabiha area. In Kimakua (P31) we find a cognate form, though with a slight shift in meaning. (19) In -li-pel-a 'expect, hope; await' Chigogo (Gil), we also find the *mb>p Kimakua (P31) cognate verb 'want, covet', but without the reflexive prefix. (20) -hil-a What these data suggest is represents second degree aperture reflexive/ intransitivizing prefix -//- p>h Chigogo (G11) 'want, covet' an earlier root of the form -bil- (where [i] a seven vowel system). In Kimabiha, the was added, with subsequent lowering of the in vowel in the prefix (either specifically for this verb or through some process of vowel harmony). The prefixless-verb seems to have been lost in Kimabiha, rendering the current morphology opaque. Botne: Reconstruction of a Grammaticalized Auxiliary in Bantu 2. Reconstructing a root in 1 73 Kimbundu (H21) As in the case with Kimabiha, the source of the future formative is fairly transparent. Chatelain (1964:33) indicates that variant forms of the future construction occur (occurred?) in different dialect areas. These forms (21) represent a continuum of grammaticalization from a periphrastic construction to a completely incorporated formative that has undergone significant phonological changes. The process reflected here resembles the process of clitic reduction discussed by Hock (1986:87) in which consonants and/or vowels of the cliticized element may become weakened and lost. (21) (b) tu-anda ku-banga tu-anda u-banga (c) tu-ando-banga (d) tu-ondo-banga (a) 'we will make' The form -anda-, as Chatelain suggests, is the grammatically shortened form of the verb -andala 'want, desire'. Final syllable deletion of auxiliary verbs is quite common in Bantu, being found not only in Kimabiha, but in languages across the Bantu-speaking area, as the examples in (22) illustrate. (22) (a) (b) (c) (d) Omyene(B11) -be- < -beta 'desire' -bondo- < -bondela 'want; ask for' Likuba (C27) 'want, desire; ask < -taka Kiswahili (G42) -ta'want' < -saka Ciluba (L31) -sa- for" Final -a of the root and initial u- of the infinitive coalesce to form [d], with subsequent and idiosyncratic (i.e., peculiar to this construction) vowel harmony serving to round and raise the first vowel of the auxiliary. Having established -andala 'want, desire' as the source of the Kimbundu we can turn to a consideration of the historical form of the root. In nearby Nyaneka (R13) we find two dialectal variants of the verb 'desire' -handa and -vandya. These are clearly cognates of Kimbundu -andala, and indicate a root of the form -Cand. The [h-] and [v-] suggest an initial bilabial consonant. Further support is found in Ngangela (K19) -yavala 'want (int)'. This verb appears to have the structure -yi-a-val-a, where -yi- is the reflexive prefix. Compare this form with a similar form recorded for Kikongo (HI 6; Maia 1961). future formative, (23) (a) di-a-vuna -funa (b) 'covet' Kikongo (HI 6) 'want' Chichewa (N31b) 174 Studies in the Linguistic Sciences 19:2 (Fall 1989) Substantiating this evidence from closely related languages is Guthrie's (1968-1972) comparative/historical work in which he posits a sound change *b > for Kimbundu. Hence, we can tentatively reconstruct an earlier root *-band-. The suffix -a/- appears to be an intransitivizer having a function similar to the reflexive prefix noted earlier; compare it with the verb 'hide' in Sena (N44) and 'spill' in Lwena (Luvale K14) illustrated below. (24) Lwena (K14) (a) -mwang-a (b) (25) 'spill (tr.)' -mwang-al-a 'spill (int.)' Sena (N44) (a) -bis-a 'hide (b) -bis-al-a 'hide oneself The reconstructed (tr.)' (int.)' in Kimbundu bears a strong resemblance discussed previously for Kimabiha. It appears both probable and plausible that a single root can be reconstructed for these two forms, the Kimbundu form having changed in vowel quality. Comparison of forms in Kikongo (HI 6b), Chitonga (M64) and Umbundu (R11) that appear to be cognate with Kimbundu -andala suggests an original mid, front vowel in the root, eventually lowered to [a] in Kimbundu. root *-band- to the auxiliary root *-bil- (26) (a) -bind-am-a 'desire' Kikongo (HI 6b) (b) -bil-am-a 'desire' Chitonga (M64) (c) -li-vel-a 'covet' Umbundu While a change of [i] or [e] to [a] might seem be a regular phenomenon in Kimbundu, as example, Guthrie (1967) reconstructs a root neighboring language of Kikongo (HI 6) as (R11) unmotivated here, it does appear other examples can be found. *-ced- 'sift', -sela. In which is to For realized in the Kimbundo, however, the root is -sala. We can conclude from this that the original root was of the form *-bil-, the If this in some languages most likely a later intrusive element. reconstruction is correct, then the future formatives in Kimbundu and Kimabiha would seem to derive from the same periphrastic construction incorporating [n] found reflexes of this auxiliary verb 3. Resurrecting a root *-bil-. in Chichewa (N31b) Reconstruction of a verbal root is much more difficult for Chichewa than for Kimabiha or Kimbundu. Direct evidence of an original periphrastic either Botne: Reconstruction of a Grammaticalized Auxiliary in Bantu construction does not exist, nor 175 there any trace of a verb comparable in form However, there exists extensive circumstantial evidence which, taken together, suggests an earlier periphrastic construction formed from a verb meaning 'desire'. is to the future habitual formative. in his grammar habitual formative in a preceding vowel in (27) Chichewa, Watkins (1939) indicates that the future variety of Chichewa produces lengthening in the verbal construction, as illustrated in (27a). of the Kasungu (a) ni:ziremba 1S-FUT-write (b) nizidzarcmba Though Watkins lists . } will 'I only the -:zi- write (habitually)' form, other varieties of Chichewa and -zidza- (27b). Final syllable deletion, as noted in the preceding discussions of Kimabiha and Kimbundu, is a common Bantu phenomenon in periphrastic constructions that have become grammaticalized. Given these two phenomena, we can hypothesize an earlier stage exhibit in an alternation between which the formative was -zi- of the form -Vzidza-. The form -Vzidza- can be further decomposed into four constituent morphemes: -Vz-idz-a < -Vl-il-i-a. Supporting evidence for this analysis can be found in neighboring eastern and southern languages. -inlela (28) (a) -inl-el-a/ 'want, covet' Kimakua(P31) Kimakonde (P23) Chinsenga (N41) /-li-il-il-a/ 'covet' (c) -li-(i)lizya /-li-il-il-T-a/ 'want a (d) -di-elezha /-di-el-el-i-a/ 'covet' lla 'want' Setswana (S31) -eletsa (e) We I -li-(i)lila (b) see in these I five -el-el-I-a/ languages a some sense lot' common (M63) root -i(n)l- /-el- closely some instances (b to d) the reflexive/intransitivizing prefix -//- /-di- appears, generally adding the sense of 'very much' as well as rendering the verb intransitive (i.e., wanting for oneself). In the more southerly languages an -/-suffix has been introduced, which produces spirantization in the preceding consonant [I]. The eastern zone P languages did not Insert this suffix, and consequently, the original [I] is still apparent. associated with of 'want'. In The close similarity in form between the future habitual formative -VzidzaChichewa and, for example, -eletsa in Setswana, suggests an original auxiliary verb 'want' for Chichewa similar to, and perhaps cognate with, the Setswana -eletsa. However, there is one apparent problem with such an in 176 Studies in the Linguistic Sciences 19:2 (Fall 1989) according to Guthrie's hypothesized sound changes for Chichewa but we see from the examples in (28) that the original *d occurs analysis: _ *d > z / before [-il-], The appears I , not [-TI-]. resolution to this problem can be found in a rather odd rule that have affected certain roots. In the very closely related dialect of to Marjanja (N31c), and in Chichewa (example 30 only), environment for spirantization of alveolar stops. (29) *-yit- (30) *-ged- 'name' > -csa 'measure' > -eza we find a peculiar This spirantization of the alveolar stops [t] and [d] occurs only when the initial consonant has been deleted, i.e., when the root has become vowel initial. Compare the cases above with instances in which the initial consonant remains (31-32) and, itself, undergoes weakening. (31) *-bid- 'boil' > -Rira (32) *-ket- 'cut' > -tset-eka We have already established that the root of the future habitual formative one stage, -Vz-. Given the nature of the rule outlined above, we can surmise that the V of the root was a mid, front vowel. But we can go further and posit an initial consonant as well. Guthrie has proposed a sound change for Marjanja (N31c), Nyungwe (N43) and Sena (N44) that deletes an initial *g in an environment immediately preceding [i] (but [g] remains before other non-close vowels). Most other languages in the region have lost initial *g in all environments. Hence, we can posit with some assurance an initial [g]. was vowel-initial at From these we can now reconstruct an a meaning 'want/desire'. While Chichewa itself any trace of this verb, a verb of this form and general circumstantial bits of evidence, original root *-gid- having appears to have lost meaning does occur in Kikerebe (33) -ligira /-li-gir-a/ (J24). 'covet, desire' Recall that the sense of 'covet' derives from the presence of the intransitivizing/ //Thus, we have clear evidence of a root *-gid- meaning 'want/ desire'. In Chichewa, various phonological processes have conspired to reflexivizing prefix reduce the . original verbal calization process is element to -z/-. summarized below. The general path of this grammati- Botne: Reconstruction of a Grammaticalized Auxiliary in Bantu (34) * 1 77 -gid-id-T-a V id id T a initial *g deletion V idz iz a [d] spirantization V :z z idz vowel coalescence/loss a final syllable deletion (optional) i [-zi-] apparently Because the simple indicative remote future formative -dza has the same form as the deleted final a grammaticalization of -dza 'come' syllable of the future habitual formative, the future habitual may have become reinterpreted in some instances as habitual marker -zi- plus future marker -dza-. — In resurrecting a verbal root *-gid- as the source for the habitual, we have seen that a sequence to obliterate the root itself, leaving only Chichewa future have combined form. From both of phonological rules a trace of the original and external evidence we have been able to reconstruct a plausible scenario of grammaticalization that finds support in processes observed both in Chichewa itself and in other Bantu languages. Let us turn now to a consideration of Kikonzo (J41), where the evidence is even less straightforward internal than 4. in the case of Chichewa. Recreating a stem We saw in Kikonzo (J41) the remote future formative in Kikonzo is in shape to the Chichewa future habitual. However, the situation in Kikonzo is more complex and ambiguous than it is in Chichewa. In order to appreciate the complexity of Kikonzo non-past forinitially in (4) that -ndisya-, a formative very similar 178 Studies in the Linguistic Sciences 19:2 (Fall 1989) matives, it These are of is to examine present and near future constructions. together with the remote future construction in (34-36) for ease necessary listed comparison. 1 (36) 'we are making' tru-ka-ko:la (35) P-T-make (a) tru-ka-ndi-ko:la (b) tru-ke-ndi-ko:la (37) (a) tru-ka-ndisya-ko:la (b) tru-ke-ndisya-ko:la 'we will make (near)' 'we will make (remote)' While the data are open to various analytical interpretations, will suggest from the outset that -ndisya-, regardless of how speakers might currently interpret it, derives from a single verbal unit, not two independent morphemes. The primary reason for this position is that such an analysis places Kikonzo in what appears to be a widespread group of languages that incorporated a verb 'want' in a periphrastic future construction. As we will see, the evidence supports such I a claim. Note that when the formative -ka- occurs with either -ndi- alone or with is variable, realized either as [a] or [e]. Without one of the future formatives, it is invariably [a]. This variation can also be observed in the negative counterparts of the above constructions which do not incorporate the -ka- formative, but rather an -a-. -ndisya- the vowel quality 'we are not making' si-tru-li-ko:la (38) NEG-1 P-T-make (39) (a) si-trw-a-ndi-ko:la (b) si-trw-e-ndi-ko:la (a) si-trw-a-ndisya-ko:la » (b) si-trw-e-ndisya-ko:la * \ (40) > 'we will not make (near)' 'we will not make (remote)' There are three plausible explanations for this variation: 1) partial vowel harmony in which the [a] is raised because of the following [i] (note that Kikonzo has a seven vowel system in which [I] is the highest front vowel); 2) vowel coalescence involving the [a] and an initial front vowel on -ndisya-; or 3) an original formative -endisya- which has come to be reanalyzed as -a-/-e- plus ^ Botae: Reconstruction of a Grammaticalized Auxiliary in Bantu 179 -ndisya- by analogy with the -ka- plus -ndisya- affirmative paradigm. It is the possibility that appears to provide the most satisfactory explanation. First, the formative -a- may appear in another negative construction, as illustrated in (41), where it does not harmonize with the following high vowel. That is, there is no variation in the vowel quality as noted for the future construction. second (41) si-trw-a-swTrTa 'we did not hit (long ago)' NEG-IP-T-hit Second, there exists a formative [e], as in (42). (42) (a) which coalesces with -/- -a- and is realized as 'we have not worked' si-trw-e-tra-ko:la /si+tru+a+i+tra+kola/ (b) si-i-tra-ko:la 'I have not worked' One might suggest that the future constructions also incorporate this -/This, however, does not appear to be the case, since the future constnjctions (39-40) manifest the [e] vowel in both the negative and affirmative constructions, whereas the -/- formative illustrated in (42) appears only in the negative forms of other constructions. Since this -/'- is linked with negation, it formative. seems tions. that is highly unlikely that it also would appear in affirmative future construcFurthermore, the future constructions exhibit a vowel alternation (-a- /-e-) not found with this -/- formative. Since it appears that the observed vowel alternation in the future constructions depends on the presence of -ndi(sya)-, and given the nature of the phonological change observed in (42), we can conclude that the form of the future formative must have been -indisya-, the initial vowel coalescing with a preceding [a] to form [e]. As the grammaticalization process has continued, the presence of the initial vowel has become opaque; analogy with the simple present construction (35) is producing a [ka] in all constructions. Noting the number of similarities with Chichewa, we might suspect that there was at one time an initial [g]. However, according to Guthrie's hypothesized sound changes, proto-Bantu *g became [y] in Kikonzo, not [0]. But consider the reconstructed and current forms (43-44) of some nouns and verbs in Kinande (J42), a closely related (43) (a) (b) (44) variety. > > eky-iyo omw-ibi 'molar' *-gibI *-gid-/-gId- > -yiraZ-ylra 'act' *-gego 'thief 180 Studies in the Linguistic Sciences 19:2 (Fall 1989) What these data suggest is that Kikonzo incorporated a change that involved loss (and glide formation?) of *g just in that environment where [g] preceded [i], i.e., *g i. > But recall that we have encountered this rule before in the / discussion of Chichewa, where we saw that MaQanja (N31c), Nyungwe (N43) and Sena (N44) all exhibited the same change. Given this motivated sound Kikonzo was, at some earlier Note that this is the same form that we previously reconstructed for the Chichewa future habitual, and which appeared in Kikerebe (J24) as -li-gir-a 'covet, desire'. We can surmise that the Kikonzo root is cognate. change, I propose that the future formative in stage, -gindisya-, deriving from a root *-gi(n)d-. As we did in Chichewa, we can decompose the future formative into constituent elements, and motivate the analysis both through internal and The form -gindisya-, propose, originates in the structure + T + a/. The change of [I + I] to voiceless [c] (written as sy) is attested elsewhere in the language. For example, the class 10 nominal prefix is esyon-, which developed historically as illustrated in (45). external evidence. /-gind + I il (45) < esyon- e-zl-on- < i-li-on- Given the viability of the change in Kikonzo, we may consider the source of the formative -/'-. One possibility is that it was an extension of the radical, similar to the case of 'want, desire' (46) -loonzaa MashI in [-loond-i-a] possibility is that it was the other central northern languages. Another in (J53), (47) (a) io-kosol-i (b) tu-IUmbuk-I (c) tw-a-kinduk-i (48) rhw-aa-gend-i-sunik-a 1P T go an intensifier perhaps. 'want, desire; seek' final suffix of the verbal unit, as exemplified 'we will save' 'we are speaking' 'we will cross (one day)' Bobangi (C32) 'we are going to push' Mashi (J53) Mituku (D13) Nyanga (D43) push One apparent problem with such an analysis is the occurrence of the final -a- in Kikonzo. If the original periphrastic construction was like that found in Mashi (48), the occurrence of the final -a- must be explained. This turns out not to be a problem because several languages in this area, Runyankore (J11) and Kikaragwe (J21) formative in for example, exhibit what appears to be an intrusive -a- the remote future construction, as comparison of different 1 Botne: Reconstruction of a Grammaticalized Auxiliary in Bantu constructions from neighboring Runyankore (49) (49b-d) in all but the affirmative indicative (49a). (49) (a) tu-rya-ta:ya:ya (b) si-tu-ri-ta:ya:ya 'we 'we (c) o-ri-ta:ya:ya 'he (d) o-ta-ri-ta:ya:ya 'he illustrate. who who not 8 -ri- Runyankore (J11) will visit' will Note the simple 1 visit' will visit...' will not visit...' Whatever the case, whether radical extension or final tense suffix, the -/formative appears to be a common suffix in the languages of this area, and hence it is not surprising to find it in Kikonzo. Thus, a periphrastic construction incorporating an auxiliary root *-gid- 'desire', presents a plausible analysis-and one that reflects developments in other Bantu languages-of the origins of the Kikonzo future formatives. The interesting thing about Kikonzo is that the common process of final syllable deletion of the grammaticalized auxiliary has a completely new construction, the near future, and not just in a reduced form of the simple future. resulted 5. in Reconsidering the meanings of the reconstructed roots It seems apparent that the futures in all four languages being considered here developed from similar periphrastic constructions incorporating auxiliaries meaning 'desire, want'. It is not clear, however, that both of these auxiliary roots had this meaning in proto-Bantu. We reconstructed for the two coastal languages. Kimabiha and Kimbundu, an original root of the form *-bid-, which evolved into -mbel- and -and-, respectively. In most instances this root seems to be associated with a meaning of 'want, desire, covet', but in Kimakua (P31) we find -lipela 'hope, expect; await'. A similar situation exists for the two interior languages, Kikonzo and Chichewa, for which we resurrected a root *-gid-. Although these two languages no longer include a verb derived from this root, in Kikerebe (J24) we occurrence of the verb with this general meaning. However, we also find the cognate form -lijila in Chiyao (P21) (*g > I / i.e). But the meaning here is 'await outcome with confidence'. The most probable direction of change is from 'await (expect?)' to 'desire, want'. Thus, we might conclude that the roots *-bid- and *-gid- underwent a shift in meaning in most languages to 'desire', subsequently becoming an auxiliary in some languages and undergoing grammaticalization. find -liglra 'covet, desire', substantiating the 182 Studies in the Linguistic Sciences 19:2 (Fall 1989) Some 6. implications and conclusions This initial exploration of future formatives has interesting innplications for Bantu historical work. We have seen that future formatives in four widely separated languages each developed out of a 'desire + infinitive' periphrastic construction. Coupled with our knowledge of languages such as Kiswahili that also employ a 'desire' derived future formative {-ta- from -taka), we can hypothesize a quite widespread use of this type of periphrastic construction for future meaning. However, this reflects widespread occurrence of a syntactic type which has incorporated different forms of a verb 'desire'. Thus, we can suppose that the 'desire + infinitive' construction, as a future, was not part of proto-Bantu, but appeared at a much later date, thereby supporting Givon's (1971) claim that modal prefixes arose at a relatively late date from main- verb/sentential-complement constructions. We have seen, in addition, that reflexive/ intransitivizing prefix much the initial the root of the verb 'desire' can take the which renders the meaning 'desire very the non-prefixed form is then lost, the underlying structure particularly if phonological changes also affect either consonant or vowel of the prefix. (for oneself)'. tends to -//-, If become opaque, Through extensive comparison and access to, or reconstruction of, are able to reconstruct roots that have become nearly obliterated, such as those in Chichewa and Kikonzo. However, in some languages the grammaticalization process has proceeded so far that there is no internal evidence remaining to support reconstruction. Still, comparison with languages like Chichewa and Kikonzo provide us with plausible, albeit circumstantial, support for proposing similar analyses. Two examples will illustrate this point. In Chigogo (Gil) we find the remote future formative oband a near future formative ->. Although there appears to be absolutely no evidence in the language suggesting the origin of these formatives, the analysis presented here suggests a viable one. Chigogo has a verb 'want' of the form we idiosyncratic changes, -hila (from -pila *p > harmony that we final syllable deletion, evolved as Assuming processes of vowel coalescence and vowel Kimbundu, and creation of a new construction from we can posit an original -hila + infinitive construction that h). noted in (50). (50) -hila ku-root As we saw in > -hllD-root > -Disroot (remote); -D-root (near) Kimbundu, final -a of the auxiliary and coalesces with u- of Bantu change) to produce the mid vowel [6\. Subsequent loss of initial [h] and vowel harmony result in the observed earlier in the infinitive (a common Botne: Reconstruction of a Grammaticalized Auxiliary in Bantu formative. we observed in Kikonzo (section produce a near future formative. Similar to what final syllable to 1 83 4) is the loss of the In Kiyombe (H12b) a similar problem arises with the remote future -ela. Here, however, we can note that the language underwent a sound change *g > (except after N). Thus, we can posit an original -gila + infinitive construction; lowering of the vowel occurred in the shift from a seven to a five vowel system. While other explanations of the origins of the future formatives in these languages are certainly possible, the scenario have presented here provides a coherent overall picture of the development of future formatives in Bantu lanI guages that captures both similarities and differences in their realizations. NOTES thank Charles Bird as well as two anonymous reviewers criticisms on the problems raised in this paper. Their remarks have contributed to making this a better paper. Responsibility for content and any errors naturally lies with me. ' I for SLS would like to for their comments and 1 use these items from Kinande because the same are not available for Kikonzo and because these two languages are extremely close, sharing extensive vocabulary and many grammatical elements. I 184 Studies in the Linguistic Sciences 19:2 (Fall 1989) APPENDIX Botne: Reconstruction of a Grammaticalized Auxiliary in Bantu 1 85 REFERENCES G. 1897. An introductory grammar of the Sena language. London: Society for Promoting Christian Knowledge. BaiAo, Domingos Vieira. 1939. Dicionario Gangueia-Portugues. Lisboa: Centre de Estudos Filologicos. Chatelain, Heli. 1888-1889. Grammatica elementar do Kimbundu. Geneva. (Republished in 1964 by The Gregg Press.) CORDELL, O. T. 1941. A Gogo grammar. Mpwapwa, Tanzania: self-published. COUPEZ, A. 1955. Esquisse de la langue Holoholo. Tervuren: Musee Royal du Congo Beige, Annales - Sciences de I'Homme, No. 12. COURTOIS, Victor Jose. 1899. Elementos de grammatica Tetense (lingua Chinyungue). Coimbra: Imprensa da Universidade. DE Clercq, L n.d. Grammaire du kiyombe. Bruxelles: Goemaere. Eddie, Jas. B. 1887. A vocabulary of Kilolo. London: The East London ANDERSON, W. Institute. Pauline. 1961. A Nande-English and English-Nande dictionary. Washington, D.C.: Laubach Literacy Fund, Inc. GiLLis, A. 1981. Dictionnaire frangais-kiluba. Gent: Heni Dunantlaan. Giv6n, Talmy. 1971 On the verbal origin of the Bantu verb suffixes. Studies in Fraas, . African Linguistics 2:2.145-163. 1969. Studies in Chibemba and Bantu Grammar. Doctoral Thesis, UCLA. Griffin, A. W. S. 1915. Chitonga vocabulary of the Zambesi Valley. London: Oxford University Press. Guerreiro, M. Viegas. 1963. Rudimentos de lingua fvlaconde. Lourengo Marques: Institute de Investigagao Cientffica de Mogambique. Gusimana, Barthelemy. 1972. Dictionnaire pende-frangais. Bandundu, R6p. du Zaire: CEEBA. Guthrie, Malcolm. 1967-1971. Comparative Bantu. London: Gregg Press Ltd. Harries, Lyndon. 1940. An Outline of Mawiha Grammar. Bantu Studies 14, 91-146. HOCK, Hans Henrich. 1986. Principles of historical linguistics. Berlin: Mouton de Gruyter. HORTON, A. E. 1949. A grammar of Luvale. Johannesburg: Witwatersrand University Press. La langue kikerewe. Mitteilungen des Seminars fur HUREL, Eug'ene. 1909. Orientalische Sprachen 12:1-113. Tokyo: Institute for the Study of 1985. Lexique Tembo KAJl, Shigeki. Languages and Cultures of Asia and Africa. LE GUENNEC, Gregoire and Jos6 F. Valente. 1972. Dicionario PortuguesUmbundu. Luanda: Institute de Investigagao Cientffica de Angola. I. 186 Studies in the Linguistic Sciences 19:2 (Fall 1989) LiBRARlUS (publ.). 1986. Learner's English-Tswana dictionary. Johannesburg. Maia, Antonio da Silva. 1961. Dicionario Complementar Portugues-KimbunduKikongo. Luanda, Angola: Edigao e propriedade do autor. MATEENE, Kahombo. 1980. Essai de grammaire generative et transformationelle de la langue nyanga. Kinshasa: Presses Universitaires du Zaire. Matos, Alexandre Valente de. 1974. Dicionario Portugues-Macua. Lisboa: Junta de Investigagoes Cientificas do Ultramar. POLACK-Bynon, Louise. 1975. A Shi grammar. Tervuren: Mus6e Royal de I'Afrique Centrale, Annales - Sciences Humaines, No. 86. 1978. Lexique shi-frangais suivi d'un index frangais-shi. Tervuren: Musee Royal de I'Afrique Centrale, Annales - Sciences Humaines, No. 94. RANGER, A. Sidney B. 1928. Chinsenga handbook. London: The Sheldon Press. Meredith. 1954. A dictionary of the Yao language. Zomba, Nyasaland: The Government Printer. SCOTT, David and Alexander Hetherwick. 1957. Dictionary of the Nyanja language, being the encyclopedic dictionary of the Mang'anja language. London: Lutterworth Press. Silva, Antonio Joaquim da. 1966. Dicionario Portugues-Nhaneca. Lisboa: SANDERSON, G. Institute de Investigagao Cientifica de Angola. Smith, Edwin W. 1907. A handbook of the Ha language. Oxford. (Republished in 1964 by The Gregg Press.) Stappers, Leo. 1973. Esquisse de la langue Mituku. Tervuren: Musee Royal de I'Afrique Centrale, Annales - Sciences Humaines, No. 80. Taylor, Charles. 1985. Nkore-Kiga. London: Croom Helm. 1959. A simplified Runyankore-Rukiga-English and English-Runyankore- Rukiga dictionary. Kampala: The Eagle Press. 1957. Methode pratique pour apprendre I'Omyene (2^"^® U. Edition revue et augmentee par Mile. V. Dubois). Paris: Soci6t6 des Missions Evangelique de Paris. Tobias, G. W. R. 1954. English-Kwanyama dictionary. Johannesburg: Witwatersrand University Press. TORREND, J. 1931. An English-Vernacular dictionary of the Bantu-Botatwe dialects of northern Rhodesia. Marianhill, Natal, S. A. (Republished in 1967 by The Gregg Press.) TUCKER, A. N. 1960. Notes on Konzo. African Language Studies 1:16-41. Watkins, Mark Hanna. 1937. A grammar of Chichewa. Supplement to Language, No 24. Whitehead, John. 1899. Grammar and dictionary of the Bobangi language. London. (Republished in 1964 by The Gregg Press.) Teisseres, studies in Volume 19, the Lingijistic Sciences Number 2, Fall 1989 MODIFICATION OF THE GENDER SYSTEM IN THE WOLLEGAN DIALECT OF OROMO Cynthia Robb Clamons University of Minnesota Gender markings Oromo language the eastern and southern dialects of the both a natural and a grammatical In the western (Wollegan) dialect, gender in reflect scheme. marked classification distinctions are not markings do appear, they in some constructions. Where gender perceived natural gender of the referent only. In the analysis proposed in this paper, the reconstructed paradigms are most similar to those found in presentday dialects of the east and south and the western dialect is taken to have an historically simplified gender system. This analysis is consistent with classification of Oromo as a T/K substratum language and the recent history of the various dialect groups. 1. reflect the Introduction This study compares gender markings in a number of dialects of the language. will argue that in some areas of the grammar of the dialect of Wollega, for example, on demonstratives and possessive pronouns, the feminine form has vanished and the masculine form has been generalized. Further, will also argue that in other areas of the grammar where the feminine form has been retained, for example on the third person singular form of the verb and some adjectives, the basis for assigning gender has changed.^ Oromo I I Fleming and Bender (1976) classify Oromo on the Lowland branch of the Cushitic group of the Afroasiatic family, a close relative of Bararetta and the Konso languages, also related to the Somali and the Afar and Saho languages. One of the characteristics of the Cushitic languages that they mention in arguing the distinctness of the Omotic languages from the Cushitic group is the T/K (feminine and masculine) gender marking of the Cushitic languages that is not found in the Omotic languages.^ 6 188 Studies in the Linguistic Sciences 1 9:2 (Fall 1 989) her study of T/K languages, Bryan (1959) considers some languages as well as Cushitic languages. She concludes that all languages showing these distinctive gender markings share at least one common ancestor, the T/K substratum. She further distinguishes two underlying t forms within the Cushitic group, one from this T/K substratum, *t, and another which she characterizes as Hamito-Semitic, HS t. In her In that are not in the Cushitic subfamily analysis, the Oromo shows the distinctive opposition between *t (feminine) and k (masculine) in the demonstratives, possessive pronouns and so forth. She argues that the third person feminine verbal inflection (among others) is directly from the HS t. She suggests further, that the HS t has merged with *t in the feminine particularlzer and that the *t has been changed to c in the masculine particularizer.3 2. Evidence from Wollegan Oromo In the introduction to his folk literature collection, Cerulli (1922:11) points Maccaa dialects show no difference between the masculine and feminine possessive forms. This can be seen in (1) and (2) below. The data in (1 a) and (2 a) are from my teacher, Abraham Oluma, of Wollega, in Maccaa, in western Ethiopia.'* In his dialect the possessive form is keeti when modifying haadha 'mother' and abba 'father.' The data in (1 b) and (2 b) are from my teacher, Stephanos Madda, an Arussi from southeastern Ethiopia.^ The second person possessive pronoun is tee when modifying the feminine haadha 'mother', but kee when modifying the masculine abba 'father.' This reflects the T/K alternation referred to In the descriptions of the Cushitic and T/K substratum languages. out that the Wollega (1) a. kun haadha this mother 'this is (2) a. father 'this is b. your your mother?' kun abba this arussi keeti? keeti? your your father?' tun this 'this b. haadha tee? mother your is your mother?' kun abba this father 'this is kee? your your father?' The other eastern and southern dialects that have been reported in the show the same alternations as those found in the Arussi data. The chart in (3) provides the possessive pronoun paradigm from a number of literature dialects. Qamons: Modification of the Gender System (3) WEST CENTRAL EAST WOLLEGA ARUSSI HARAR SOUTH KENYA KENYA BOORAN MUNYO WAATA koo masc: koo tiyya tiyya tiyya tan-ti tf kiyya xiyya kiyya kan-ki kfinki kee masc: kee tee te (t^n)te tan-te tente kee xe(k^n) k6 kan-ke kee ishia -sha 'my' fern: 'thy' Wollegan Dialect of Oromo in the tern: 189 'her': shee/see isi ISII 'his': saa is^ isa^sa^ isa isa keenya teenna tennya teenna xennya keenna tan-teen (ten)teena keennd kan-keen (ken)keena teess^n teesani t^n-teesan (ten)teesani 'our* fem: masc: keenya your* fem: keesani masc: keesani 'their': saani ISII te^sani keessan xeesani keesani isaani warra isaani -sa kan-keeesan (ken)keesani -saani isaani Also notice that the demonstrative 'this' in (1) and (2) shows no alternation does in the Arussi. The absence of this alternation in the Wollegan data can also be seen in other areas of the Wollegan grammar, e.g., 'the other* in (4) and (5), 'which' in (6) and (7) and the relative form in (8) and in the Wollegan, but (9): WOLLEGA (4) a. muri bread cut 'cut (5) a. ARUSSI daabboo kaan other IMP muka kaan kamtu which 'exactly kamtu which 'exactly b. FAM haadha kee? mother your which is your mother?' abba kee? your your father?' father which is hapii taan muri other cut IMP the other bread!* bread 'cut muri other cut IMP 'cut the other tree!* (7) a. FAM the other bread!" tree (6) a. b. FAM muka kaan muri other cut IMP *cutthe other tree!' tree tamtu FAM haadha tee? mother your which is your mother?' which 'exactly kamtu which abba kee? 'exactly which father your is your father?' 190 Studies in the Linguistic Sciences 19:2 (Fall 1989) ija koo kamtu na dhukkuba eye my REL me hurts 'it is my eye that hurts' (8) a. (9) a. fuhfiaan koo kamtu na 'it's In all dhukkuba REL me my nose my nose b. my REL me hurts my eye that hurts' is funnaan kiyya kamtu na dhukkuba my nose REL me hurts 'it's my nose that hurts' b. hurts the instances considered thus tiyya tamtu eye 'It that hurts' has been generalized as na dhukkuba ija far, contend that the T/K alternation in (10): k<*t/k (10) those areas of the grammar where gender distinctions are feminine form, and the k masculine form, derived in Bryan's analysis from the T/K substratum, that gender distinctions have been obliterated and the masculine k form generalized in the grammar of Wollega. Again, is in it marked by the *t However, there are other areas of the grammar in which the feminine form marked with an alveolar stop in the Wollegan, as well as the other dialects. These are derived from the HS t forms in Bryan's reconstruction. The verb is marked for agreement with the feminine subject in (11) whereas in (12) there is is no overt marker. Wollega (11) a. Arussi obboleettiin koo dhufte obboleettiin tiyya dhufte sister my came F sister my came F 'my sister came' 'my sister came' (12) a. obboleessi koo dhufe obboleessi kiyya my brother 'my brother came' brother my came 'my brother came' dhufe came This pattern of overt stop on the feminine marker and absence of a stop on is also found in some adjective forms, as in (12) and (13), where dheer- 'tall' is marked -tuu and -aa respectively.'' the masculine marker , Wollega (13) a. Arussi dheertuu dha PART NOM tall F COP dubartittiin woman 'the woman (14) a. namiccii b. 'the dheeraa dha tall M COP dheertuu b. namiccii person dha PART F NOM tall woman is tall' person is tall' person PART M NOM Ihe man is tall' namtittiin dheeraa F COP dha PART M NOM tall M COP 'the man is tall' 1 Qamons: Modification of the Gender System in the Wollegan Dialect of Oromo 1 9 Notice that there is also an alternation between the forms of the as can also be seen in (13) and (14). It is not, however, marked by an alternation between the alveolar stop and the velar stop, as in (1)-(9), but by an alternation between the alveolar stop and a palatal affricate. Notice that both the patterns, that with an overt stop marking the feminine form alternating with no overt marker on the masculine form and that with an overt stop marking the feminine form alternating with the alveopalatal affricate marker on the masculine form, are found in the Wollegan dialect, as well as in the other These are the forms derived from HS t in Bryan's reconstruction. dialects. particularizer, The assignment of nouns to the feminine class in the Arussi is not necessarily based on the perceived sex of the referent. In (4 b) and (5 b), for example, hapii 'bread* and muka 'tree' are modified by feminine and masculine In the eastern and demonstratives taan and kaan 'the other*, respectively. southern dialects, the basis for distinguishing gender is not only perceived sex of the referent but also phonological shape of the noun or arbitrary lexical classification. Owens (1985:244 ff) discusses the factors involved in gender assignment in the Harar dialect. This situation is extensible to the other dialects considered in this study, except the Wollegan. would like to suggest that in the eastern and southern dialects, there are two rules of the two kinds proposed in Hutchinson (1985) for specification of the anaphoric pronoun in Temne. To choose the correct gender marker: I (1 In belief. 5) you believe this refers to a female use the feminine form, to a a. If b. male, the masculine form, If you believe this refers to an inanimate object, use the form appropriate for its lexical class or phonological form. if (15 a) a grammatical form is chosen on the basis of nongrammatical (15 b) wholly grammatical information is also invoked. In Gragg (1976) point out that the gender in the based on a natural system; referents that are female are Nordfeldt (1947:20ff) and Wollegan dialect is referred to by feminine forms, those that are male, by masculine forms. But also marked as feminine are names and adjectives that refer to objects that are small, insignificant or that belong to certain semantic classes, e. g., names of The difference between assignment in this flowers or astronomical objects. dialect, as opposed to the other dialects can be seen in (16 a) and (16 b), the Wollegan data does not show feminine agreement marked on the verb, but the Arussi data does. 192 Studies in the Linguistic Sciences 19:2 (Fall 1989) WOLLEGA (16) a. ARUSSI koo na dhukkuba chikilee elbow my me hurts 'my elbow hurts' Wollega, the form In in meaning 'my elbow b. na dhukkubdi elbow my me hurts F 'my elbow hurts' chikilee tiyya (16 a) would be the only form for the straightforward The form in (16 b) may also be used in Wollega, but only in talking of an Insignificant hurt. Similarly, in the Arussi dialect, the feminine form may be used illiterally to signify such meaning. The form in (13 b) may be used sarcastically, for instance, in referring to a man thought to be worthless. In the Wollega dialect, the form in (13 b) has this literal pejorative meaning hurts.' only. In addition to the neutralization of the distinctions between the feminine and masculine forms as in (10), would like to suggest that the gender system in the Wollegan dialect has been simplified in another way. The Wollegan dialect has but one rule similar to (15 a), but extended to (17). The rule in (15 b) has been eliminated in this dialect. I (17) If you believe this refers to a female, or small, insignificant or worthless referent use the feminine form, if to a male, the masculine form. It appears from the data examined that it is nonlinguistic belief alone that in determining gender, not purely grammatical information. is invoked 3. Conclusion The have described here is consistent with linguists' Lewis (1966) reconstructs the history of the Oromo over the past several centuries. In his reconstmction, the Maccaa tribes moved into the areas they presently occupy in southwestern Ethiopia from the Oromo cradleland in the northern areas of present day Boraan. This means that these tribes moved into a contact situation with speakers of Omotic languages, which do not have Recall the characteristic T/K gender system found in the Cushitic languages. that it is in these cases that the masculine gender has been generalized in the dialect of Wollega. As in many other areas of Ethiopia, the Oromo of Wollega are also in an intimate contact situation with the Amhara, whose language is Semitic. Although the data in Cooper and Carpenter (1976) and Cooper et al. (1976) only begin a sketch of the sociolinguistic situation in Wollega, it is clear that Oromo is an important second language for the now small group of speakers of the Omotic language as mother tongue and also for the native Amharic speakers, while Amharic is an important second language for the native Oromo speakers. situation that expectations. I Qamons: Modification of the Gender System in the Wollegan Dialect of Oromo 1 93 Weinreich (1953:42-43) discusses a number of contact situations in wiiich gramnnatical accommodation results in the disappearance of grammatical categories and observes further that the assignment of gender tends to be simplified to a semantic basis. Gumperz and Wilson (1971) report on a contact situation in India. They describe modifications in the gender systems of Marathi and Urdu as they are spoken in a village in which Kannada, Marathi and Urdu have all been spoken for centuries. The loce; varieties of the Marathi and Urdu show modifications with respect to the standard varieties that reflect changes similar to those that have described in the Oromo of Wollega. I In standard Marathi most, but not all nouns denoting females (or males) are feminine (or masculine), and while nouns denoting inanimate objects are most often neuter, they may be masculine or feminine as well. In the variety of Marathi that is discussed in the study, nouns denoting males are masculine, nouns denoting females feminine and nouns denoting inanimate objects are neuter. This forms an isomorphism with the Kannada gender system. In summary, have concluded that there have been two modifications in First, in all areas of the grammar the gender system in the Wollegan dialect. where Bryan's reconstruction assumes an historically underlying *t/k, k is generalized in the Wollegan dialect, as in (10). Secondly, where Bryan's reconstruction assumes the underlying HS t, gender distinctions are still I marked in the Wollegan dialect, but the choice is based on a semantic (17) and not on a grammatical rule as in (15 b). rule as in NOTES U would like to thank Stephanos Madda and Abraham Oluma for their generous and patient assistance in establishing the data for this study, and also Larry Hutchinson and Rocky Miranda for their valuable suggestions and encouragement. 2There is a noun stem alternation in Kefa where o and e alternate, an earlier T/K alternation. Lionel Bender (personal communication) has been involved more recently in reconstructions that suggest that these two groups are in fact derived at a greater depth from common stock. indicating 194 Studies in the Linguistic Sciences 19:2 (Fall 1989) 3The kind of analogical change that Bryan's analysis suggests appears to be reflected at a later stage in the Harar dialect reported in Owens (1985:98) where the negative particle exhibits an alternation between the x and h in: tun harree-miti innii donkey not 'this is not a donkey' There is no alternation found angafa xiyyaa-mihi he this 'he in this ^These data are consistent my my elder elder is not negative form with data in not brother' in the other dialects. Gragg (1976,1980). sjhese data are consistent with those reported in Andrzejewski (1972). 6The Harar data are from Owens (1985), the Boraan data from Andrzejewski (1962) and Owens (1980 and 1982) and the Kenyan data from Heine (1980 and 1981). ^Gene Gragg has pointed emergence of end with this Miranda (1975) discusses the out that there are other forms that phonological form that are not feminine. such anomalous forms. REFERENCES ANDRZEJEWSKI, B. W. 1962. Ideas about warfare African fables. Language Studies in Borana Galla stories and 111:116-136. in Galla hymns in praise of Sheikh Hussein of Language Studies 13:1-31. Bender, Marvin Lionel, ed. 1976. The non-Semitic languages of Ethiopia. 1972. . Bale. Allusive diction African East Lansing, Michigan: African Studies Center, Michigan State University. R. L. Cooper and C. A. Ferguson, eds. 1976. Language in London: Oxford University Press. Bryan, Margaret. A. 1959. The T/K languages: A new substratum. Africa (London) XXIX:1-21. CERULLi, Enrico. 1922. The folk literature of the Galla of southern Abyssinia. Harvard African Studies 111:9-228. Cooper, Richard L, and Susan Carpenter. 1976. Language in the market. The non-Semitic languages of Ethiopia, ed. by M. L Bender, 244-255. African Studies Center, Michigan State East Lansing, Michigan: , J. D. Bowen, Ethiopia. University. B. N. Singh and Abraha Ghermazion. 1976. Mother tongue and other tongue in Kefa and Arusi. Language in Ethiopia. Language in Ethiopia, ed. by M. L Bender, J. D. Bowen, R. L. Cooper and C. A. Ferguson, 213245. London: Oxford University Press. , Qamons: Modification of the Gender System in the Wollegan Dialect of Oromo 1 95 FLEMING, Harold C. and Marvin L. Bender. 1976. Non-Semitic languages. Language in Ethiopia, ed. by M. L. Bender, J. D. Bowen, R. L. Cooper and London: Oxford University Press. 1976. Oromo of vVellega. The non-Semitic languages of Ethiopia, ed. by M. L. Bender, 167-195. East Lansing, Michigan: African Studies Center, Michigan State University 1982. Oromo dictionary. East Lansing, Michigan: African Studies Center, Michigan State University. C. A. Ferguson, 34-58. Gragg, Gene B. . J. and Robert Wilson. 1971. Convergence and creolization: A case from the Indo-Aryan/Dravidian border in India. Pidginization and University creolization of languages, ed. by Dell Hymes. Cambridge: GUMPERZ, John Press. Heine, Bemd. Kenya Vol . 1980. Munyo, an Oromo dialect. Language and Dialect Atlas of II, 141-171. Berlin: Reimer Verlag. The Waata 1981. Kenya Vol IV:7-71. Oromo. Language and Dialect Atlas Reimer Verlag. dialect of Berlin: Hutchinson, Larry G. 1985. Nonlinguistic belief in linguistics. Pragmatics 9:109-136. LEWIS, Herbert S. 1966. The origins of the Galla and Somali. of Journal of Journal of African History 7:1.27-46. Indo-European gender: A study in semantic and of Indo-European Studies. 3:199-215. NORDFELDT, Martin. 1947. A Galla grammar. Le Monde Oriental. XXXI l-XXXV. OWENS, Jonathon. 1980. Observations on tone in the Booran dialect of Oromo MIRANDA, Rocky. 1975. syntactic change. The Journal I (Galla). . African 1982. Case Language Studies 17:141-196. in the Booran Dialect of Oromo. LXV -43-75. 1985. A grammar Afrika und Obersee of Harar Oromo (Northeastern Ethiopia). Hamburg: Helmut Buske Verlag. Weinreich, Uriel. 1953. Languages in Contact. New York: Linguistic Circle of . New York. V Appendices to the Proceedings APPENDIX A History of the Annual Conference on African Linguistics APPENDIX B Research and Publications in African Linguistics by Students, Alumni, and Faculty of the University of Illinois, 1980-1990 Studies in Volume 19, the Linguistic Number Sciences 1989 2, Fall Appendix A HISTORY OF THE ANNUAL CONFERENCE ON AFRICAN LINGUISTICS Compiled by M. Lionel Bender, SlUC Ronald Schaeffer, SIUE Russell Schuh, UCLA » 200 Studies in the Linguistic Sciences 19:2 (Fall 1989) Date Apr. 6-8 Host Institution Queens College & 1973 Graduate Center Program/Proceedings Program in SAL 4.2 / Organizers Amy Meyers No Proceedings of CUNY. NYC. NY 5 Mar. 29-31 1 974 Stanford University Stanford (Palo (is<) Alto), William Leben Program CA in SAL William Leben, 5.1 /Ed. SAL Suppl. 5, 1974 6 7 Apr. 11-13 Ohio State University 1975 Columbus, 1976 University of Florida PNP/Ed.: Robert Robert K. Herbert OH Herbert. Haig Der-Houssikian Paul A. Kotey & K. 1975. PNP/Eds.: Paul Kotey & Haig Der-Houssikian. 1 976. Proceedings of the Seventh Conference on African Linguistics (Language and Problems Hornbeam Press. Columbia, SC. Apr. 1-3 Linguistic in Africa). APPENfDDCA: History of AC AL # 201 ( the Linguistic Sciences Studies in Volume 19, Number 2, Fall 1989 Appendix B RESEARCH AND PUBLICATIONS IN AFRICAN LINGUISTICS BY STUDENTS, ALUMNI, AND FACULTY OF THE UNIVERSITY OF ILLINOIS, 1980-1990 Compiled by Issam M. Abu-Salim, University of Jordan Laura J. Downing, University of Illinois Since the creation of the African Language and Linguistics Program in the of Linguistics in 1969, there has been a rigorous and on-going research effort in all aspects of the study of African languages. The publications and research of the Africanist students, alumni, and faculty listed below confirm this effort and constitute a follow-up to the first listing (1970-1979) published in Department SLS 1 9:2 (Fall 1979). STUDENT RESEARCH ON AFRICANIST TOPICS Diop, Abdul Aziz African Linguistics, Phonology, Sociolinguistics a) Specialization: b) Africanist publications/conference presentations: 1989. Language planning across political boundaries: A case study of Fula. Paper presented at the 20th Annual Conference in African Linguistics, University of Illinois, Urbana, April 1989. Downing, Laura J. a) Specialization: Phonology and Tonology (Eastern and Southern African Bantu Languages b) Dissertation Problems title: in Jita Tonology (^990) of this dissertation are, first, to present a detailed analysis of the tone systenn of an Eastern Bantu language spoken in Tanzania and second, to motivate a theory of the interaction of tone and accent in Bantu. As a background to a discussion fo the tone system, The goals Jita, a romraic analysis of syllable structure is presented (the syllable is the tone-bearing unit of 204 Studies in the Linguistic Sciences 19:2 (Fall 1989) with special attention to the processes of compensatory lengthening. Next, the tone patterns of verbs, nouns, and noun-modifier phrases are analyzed, and it is shown that much of the Jita tone system may b e accounted for by non-metrical rules, i.e., rules which refer to the tonal properties only of immediately adjacent syllables. However, some tone patterns in Jita are derived from long-distance tone-spread and (re)association rules. argue that these long-distance tone processes provide evidence for the interaction of tone and metrical Jita), I prominence (accent) in Jita, since metrical stmcture is the only phonological device which allows long distance operations to be formulated so as to respect the Locality Principle. Further, the interaction of tone and accent in Jita is shown to provide evidence against the Ordering Hypothesis (Goldsmith 1982, Sietsema 1989) since non-metrical tone rules must precede the assignment of accent in some constructions. c) Africanist publications/conference presentations: 1988a. Tone in Jita noun-modifier phrases. Studies in the Linguistic Sciences 18:1.25-60. (Revised version of a paper presented at the 19th Annual Conference on African Linguistics, Boston University, April 1988.) 1988b. Local and metrical tone shift in Zulu and Xhosa. Paper presented at the 1988 Annual Meeting of the Linguistic Society of America, New Orleans, December 1988. 1989. Tone and intonation in Jita yes/no questions. Paper presented at the 20th Annual African Linguistics Conference, University of Illinois, Urbana, April 1989. 1990. Compensatory lenghthening and the representation of nasal-consonant (NC) clusters. Paper presented at the 21st Annual African Linguistics Conference, University of Georgia, Athens, April 1990. Dunn, Andrea S. a) Specialization: b) Dissertation African Linguistics, Pragmatics. Discourse, Swahili title: Discourse Markers in Swahili (1990) The thesis explores the role of discourse markers in creating coherence in Swahili discourse. Core meanings will be given for three mar)<ers in terms of hearer inferences about speaker plans based on the context in which the particle occurs. Current research besides c) my dissertation topic concerns the pragmatics of demonstratives. Africanist publications/conference presentations: 1985. 1989. Swahili language policy implementation in Tanzania: Council. Studies in the Linguistic Sciences 15:1. More on Swahili demonstratives. Paper presented at The role of the National Swahili the 20th Annual Conference on African Linguistics, Urbana, April 1989. 1990. The pragmatics of the Swahili discourse marker BASI. Paper presented at the 21st Annual African Linguistics Conference, University of Georgia, Athens, April 1990. Evans, Dorothy Eaton a) Specialization: Computational Linguistics, Phonology, and Kiswahlli Appendix b) B: Research Proposed & Publications in African Linguistics dissertation title: / 205 University of Illinois A Phonological Rule Tester Comparing Two Hierarchical Phonological Theories The research envisaged here involves the development of an autosegmental phonological mle tester on the Macintosh computer. The study will compare E. Sagey's (1986) feature hierarchy and D. Archangeli & D. Pulleyblank's (1986) theory and hierarchy using data from Swahili. c) Publications/conference presentations: 1989. Vowel alternations with the applied verbal extension in Swahili. Paper presented at the 20th Annual conference on African Linguistics, University of Illinois, Urbana, April 1989. 1990a. Underspecification, default and complement rules of Kiswahili tested in HyperCard. Paper presented at the 21st Annual African Linguistics Conference, University of Georgia, Athens, April 1990. 1990b. The contribution of African Linguistics to linguistic theory: 19:2 & 20:1. Associate Editor. Proceedings of the 20th ACAL SLS Kamwangamalu, Nkonko African Linguistics, Code-mixing, Bantu syntax a) Specialization: b) Dissertation c) Africanist publications/conference presentations: title: 1985a. Passivization in Theory and Method of Code-Mixing: A Cross-Linguistic Study (^989) Bantu: Implications for Relational Grammar. Paper presented at the Linguistics, Yale University, March 1985. 1 6th Annual Conference on African 1985b. Relativization in Bantu: A Relational Approach. Paper presented America Linguistics Conference, Kansas State University, April 1985. 1985c. Passivization in Bantu languages: Linguistic Implications for Relational 1985 Mid- at the Grammar. Studies in the Sciences 15:1.109-133. 1986a. (with E. G. Bokamba.) The significance of code-mixing to linguistic theory: Evidence from Bantu languages. Paper presented at the 17th Annual Conference on African Linguistics, Indiana University, Bloomington, April 1986. 1986b. (with H. Obeidat.) Relativization in Bantu: A relational approach. Mid-America Linguistics Conference, 120-132. In Papers from the 1985 1987a. The pragmatics of code-mixing with English: The case of African languages. presented at the Conference on Pragmatics and Language Learning, University of Urbana, April 1987. Paper Illinois, 1987b. French/vernacular code-mixing in Zaire: Implications for syntactic constraints. Papers 166-180. from the 23rd Annual Regional Meeting of the Chicago Linguistic Society, Part I, 206 Studies in the Linguistic Sciences 19:2 (Fall 1989) 1987c. (with E. G. Bokamba.) The significance of code-mixing to linguistic theory: Evidence from Bantu languages. Studies in the Linguistic Sciences 17:2.21-43. 1987d. Code-mixing and modernization across cultures. In: ERIC Educational Document (A Clearinghouse on Language and Linguistics), ED No. 284 441. 1988a. Phonology-syntax interface: Evidence from Ciluba. Paper presented at the 19th Annual Conference on African Linguistics, Boston University, April 1988. Linguistic Repertoire and Language 'Mixing' in Africa. Paper presented at the 6th PanAfrican Conference, Indiana State University, Terre Haute, April 1988. 1988b. C-command' and the Phonology-Syntax 1988c. interface in Ciluba. Studies in the Linguistic Sciences 18:2.87-109. The pragmatics of code-mixing vi/ith English: The case of African languages revisited. Paper presented at the Conference on Pragmatics and Language Learning, University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign, April 1989. 1989a. Some 1989b. morphosyntactic aspects of French/English-Bantu code-mixing: evidence for universal constraints. Paper presented at the 25th Annual Regional Meeting of the Chicago Linguistic Society, April 1989. 1989c. On constraints on grammars in contact: A Bantu perspective. Paper presented at the 20th Annual Conference in African Linguistics, University of Illinois, Urbana, April 1989. 1990. The problem of constraints on language 'mixing': An alternate approach. Paper presented at the 21st Annual African Linguistics Conference, University of Georgia, Athens, April 1990. Kapanga, Mwamba T. African Linguistics, Sociolinguistics, Swahili a) Specialization: b) Dissertation c) Africanist publications/conference presentations: 1988. title: Language Variation and Change: Shaba Swahili (1990) A Case Study from Non-native varieties and second language acquisition theory: A case study from Shaba Paper presented at the 19th Annual Conference in African Linguistics, Boston University, April 1988. Swahili. 1989a. Shaba Swahili: Any evidence Annual Conference of pidginization/creolization? of African Linguistics, University of Illinois, Paper presented at the 20th Urbana, April 1989. (with M. Ngame.) Convergence and divergence in African-based pidgins and Creoles: Kikongo and Swahili. Paper presented at the 20th Annual Conference of African 1989b. Linguistics, University of Illinois, Urbana, April 1989. Mmusi, Sheila Onkaetse a) Specialization: African Linguistics, Phonology and Tonology APPENDIX B: Research b) Dissertation title: & Publications in African Linguistics An Autosegmental Analysis / University of Illinois of Verbal Tone in 207 Setswana The thesis will provide an autosegmental analysis of the various tonal patterns verbs assume in this language under different environments determined by grammatical aspects such as tense, negation and so on. am I also currently involved with research on some aspects of verbal tone in Lozi, a language in Southern Africa, in the attempt to provide an autosegmental analysis of tone in this spoken language. c) Publications/conference presentations: 1989. (with C. Kisseberth.) The object marker and verbal tone in Setswana. Paper presented at the 20th Annual Conference of African Linguistics, University of Illinois, Urbana, April 1989. Grammatical high tone spread in Setswana - Implications for the syntactic-phonological Paper presented at the 21st Annual African Linguistics Conference, University 1990. interface. of Georgia, Athens, April 1990. Ourso, Meterwa A. a) Specialization: b) Dissertation title: African Linguistics, Phonology/morphology Lama Phonology and Morphology (1989) This thesis will be an exploration in the segmental and the tonal alternations verb morphology. Main focus on the interaction between: the root final segment and suffix initial segment; u) the tone of the root and tone of the suffix. Hi) the aspectual suffix and the other components of the VP. in noun and i) I am also currently working on a Lama-French-English word list with the aim of writing a trilingual dictionary. c) Africanist publications/conference presentations: 1987a. Constraints on borrowing and nativization. Paper presented at the 18th Annual Conference on African Linguistics, Universit6 du Qu6bec ^ Montr6al, April 1987. 1987b. (with E. Yu.) Noun class system in Lama. Paper presented at the 18th Annual Conference on African Linguistics, Universit6 du Qu6bec ci Montr6al, April 1987. 1988a. (with M. Kenstowicz.) Tone in Lama. Paper presented African Linguistics, Boston University, April 1988. at the 19th Annual Conference on 1988b. Tonal polarity in two Gur languages. (In collaboration with M. Kenstowicz and E. Nikiema.) Studies in the Linguistic Sciences 18:1.77-104. 1988c. Root control, underspecification and ATR harmony. Studies in the Linguistic Sciences 18:2. 1989a. (with E. Yu.) The semantics of noun classes. Paper presented at the 20th Annual Conference on African Linguistics, University of Illinois, Urbana, April 1989. 208 Studies in the Linguistic Sciences 19:2 (Fall 1989) 1989b. (with C. Ulrich.) Sonorant-Hardening in Lama. Paper presented at the 20th Annual Conference on African Linguistics, University of Illinois, Urbana, April 1989. (forthcoming.) Phonological processes in the noun class system of en Lama. Journal of Lama. Studies in African Linguistics. (forthcoming.) Crit6res de distribution des affixes West African Languages. Treece, Rick. a) Specialization: b) Dissertation title: Morphology, Kiswahili Deverbal Nominals in Kiswahili: Morphology and the Lexicon (1990) Underspecification Apart from the regular prefixed infinitive, Kiswahili exhibits a number of processes for deriving nominals from verbs by affixation. The dissertation will provide a formal morphological description of the most common of these processes (suffixation in -o, -/, -aji, -e, -a, etc.) as well as show how such nominals specification, including c) fit into the larger Kiswahili noun system. Various issues of morpheme/meaning correspondence, will also be addressed. lexical Africanist publications/conference presentations: 1976. Exercises for Book I. In Diop & Britten, eds. Dossiers P6dagogiques Documentaires. Dakar: Centre de Recherche, Ecole Normale Sup6rieure, 29-47. Peace Corps/Senegal Teacher's Manual 1977. for Volunteers Using the CLAD Method. Dakar: PC/S. A new description. Paper presented at the 1 7th Annual Conference on African Linguistics, Indiana University, Btoomington, April 1986. (to appear in Current Approaches to African Linguistics, vol. Dordrecht: Foris.) 1986a. Kiswahili agreement for kinship terms: . 1986b. What 1987. is a Bantu noun class? Studies in the Linguistic Sciences 16:1.149-166. Swahili deverbal nominals and the spurious causative. Paper presented at the 18th Annual Conference on African Linguistics, Universit6 du Qu6bec k Montr6al, April 1987. The underlying representation in Kiswahili. Paper presented at the 20th Annual Conference on African Linguistics, University of Urbana, April 1989. Illinois, 1989. of the class 1 substantive prefix 1990a. Underspecification and Kiswahili Phonemes. Paper presented at the 21st Annual African Linguistics Conference, University of Georgia, Athens, April 1990. 1990b. The contribution of African Linguistics to linguistic theory: 19:2 & 20:1. Associate Editor. Proceedings ACAL SLS Yu, Ella Ozier a) Specialization: Morphology (Lama, Gur language family). Syntax of the 20th APPENDIX b) B: Research Dissertation title: & Publications in African Linguistics Theoretical Aspects of / University of Illinois Noun Classes in Lama (1 209 990) The thesis presents a descriptive analysis of the noun class structure in Lama. Special emphasis is placed on the semantics of class entities and morphology of the class suffixes. an analysis of the treatment of how borrowings are incorporated into the class system and possible analyses of agreement in left-dislocated coordinate stmctures are presented. Also, c) Africanist publications/conference presentations: 1987. The noun class system of Lama. Paper presented at the 18lh Annual Conference on African Linguistics, Universit6 du Qu6bec k N/1ontr6al, April 1987. Reconstoiction evidence for noun class splitting in Lama. Paper presented Annual Conference on African Linguistics, Boston University, April 1988. 1988a. at the 19th 1988b. Agreement in left dislocation of coordinate structures. Papers from the 24th Annual Regional Meeting of the Chicago Linguistic Society. Part 2: Parasession on Agreement in Grammatical Theory, 322-336. 1989. 2 (with M. Ourso.) The semantics of noun classes. Paper presented at the 20th Annual Conference on African Linguistics, University of Illinois, Urbana, April 1989. DOCTORATES at the IN AFRICAN LINGUISTICS University of Illinois at Urbana/Champaign (1980-1989) AND ALUMNI RESEARCH ON AFRICANIST TOPICS Abasheikh, Mohammad I. Ph. D. 1978 Dept. of European Languages King AtKJulaziz University P.O. Box 9032 Jeddah 21413, SAUDI ARABIA Africanist publications (1980Forthcoming, (with In C A Kisseberth.) Progress, (with M. Abasheikh.) ): Chimwiini dictionary. A Grammar of Chimwiini. Abdul-Karim, Kamal W. 6435 Bothwell Road, P.O. Box 47 Reseda, CA 91335 a) Dissertation title: Aspects of the Phonology of Lebanese Arabic (1 980). b) Africanist publications: 1980. (with t^. Kenstowicz.) Cyclic stress 10:2.55-76. in Levantine Arabic. Studies in the Linguistic Sciences 210 Studies in the Linguistic Sciences 19:2 (Fall 1989) Abu-Salim, Issam M. Associate Professor Department of English Yarnnouk University JORDAN Irbid, a) Areas of research interest and synopsis of current researcfr. Current approaches to phonological theory: metrical, lexical, autosegmentai, etc.; Arabic phonology; Semitic phonology and morphology; Teaching English as a Foreign Language. I b) am currently compiling Dissertation a syllable-based dictionary of Standard Arabic. A title: Reanalysis of Metrical c) Some Aspects Approach (1 of Arabic Phonology: A 982). Africanist publications: 1980. 1982. Epenthesis and geminate consonants Sciences 10:2.1-11. and Syllable structure in Studies Palestinian Arabic. Studies syllabification in Palestinian Arabic. in the Linguistic in the Linguistic Sciences 12:1.1-28. 1986. Vowel shortening 1987a. Vowel harmony Palestinian Arabic: in in Palestinian Arabic: A A metrical perspective. Lingua 68:223-240. metrical perspective. Joumal of Linguistics 23:1- 14. 1987b. Some aspects of the inflectional morphology of the verb Jordan) 14:7.37-58. 1987d. The syllable structure of Arabic, 11:33:45-63. (in 1988a. Consonant assimilation An autosegmentai In Arabic: Arabic) Joumal Syllable patterns in Standard Arabic: for the Humanities, A of Arabic perspective. Lingua 74:45-66. In Arabic. Dirasat 15:3. quantitative study. in Arabic. To appear On the phionological status of /?/ in Classical Arabic. University of Beimt. Forthcoming. (with H. Academy To appear in Arab Kuwait University. Forthcoming. Consonant assimilation processes 1987. Dirasat (University of Journal of the Jordan 1988b. Syllable structure constraints and the sonority hierarchy Forthcoming. in Tigrinya. Abd-ed-Jawad.) Slips of the tongue in in Forum Linguisticum. To appear in Abhath, American Arabic and their theoretical implications. Language Sciences 9:2.145-171. 1988. (with H. Abd-el-Jawad.) Sciences 18:2.1-22. Syllable patterns in Levantine Arabic. Studies In the Linguistic 1 Appendix B: Research & Publications in African Linguistics / University of Illinois 21 Forthcoming, (with G. Haddad, translators.) Translation of Generative Phonology by M. Kenstowicz and C. Kisseberth, Academic Press, 1980. To be published by Khartoum International Institute for the Arabic Language. Alghazo, Mohammad H. P.O. Box 11 Alwahadneh JORDAN Ajioun, Dissertation Syncope and Epenthesis Approach (1987). title: Bader, Yousef in Levantine Arabic: A Nonlinear F. Assistant Professor Department of English Yarmouk IrtDid, a) University JORDAN Areas of research interest and synopsis of current research: Berber phonology and morphology; teaching of English to non-native speakers; English and grammar and phonology; application of current phonological findings (e.g., OCP, etc.) to Berber data, contrastive analysis between English and Arabic. Arabic b) Dissertation title: Kabyle Berber Phonology and Morphology: Outstanding /ssues (1984). The study is a descriptive account of the most important phonological and morphological processes operating in Kabyle Berber. It is conducted within the framework of modern generative phonology with special emphasis on recent theories of syllable structure, Specifically, the autosegmental phonology, and lexical phonology and morphology. problems of schwa, free and construct states, sandhi phenomena, and the nx)rphology of the verb system are discussed. c) Africanist publications: 1983. Vowel sandhi and syllable structure 13:1.1-17. 1985a. 1988. Schwa Is in BertDer: there case Forthcoming. devices. in A in Kabyle Berber. Studies in the Linguistic Sciences non-linear analysis. Lingua 67:225-49. Bertser? Arab Journal for the Humanities (Kuwait University) 8:435-449. Contrastive analysis and students' pertormance: English and Arabic connective To appear in The Journal of the Faculty of Arts. King Saud University, Riyadh, Saudi Arabia. 1985. (with Michael Kenstowicz and Rachid Benkeddache.) The phonology of state in Kabyle Berber. African Linguistics: Essays in Memory of M. W. K. Semikenke, ed. by D. Goyvaerts, 319-334. Amsterdam: John Benjamins. 212 Studies in the Linguistic Sciences 19:2 (Fall 1989) 1987. (with Michael Kenstowicz.) Syllables and case in Kabyle Berber. Lingua 73:279-299. Cassimjee, Farida. African Studies Center University of Illinois, Urbana, IL 61801 a) Dissertation title: An Autosegmental Analysis of Vends Tonology (1987). b) Africanist publications: 1989. (with C. W. Kisseberth.) Shingazidja nominal accent. SLS 19:1.33-62. Chishimba, Maurice M. University of School of Zambia Education, Department of Education P.O. Box 32379 Lusaka, ZAMBIA Dissertation title: African Varieties of English: Text in Context (1 984). Dalgish, Gerard M. Ph. D. 1976 Dept. of Foreign Languages and Linguistics Dar-es-Salaam Dar-es-Salaam, TANZANIA University of Africanist publications: 1982. 1987. A Dictionary of Africanisms. Westport, Conn.: /-a/ reduction phenomena: Greenwood Press. and computer generalizations. Current Approaches by D. Odden, 137-149. Dordrecht: Foris Publications. Linguistic to African Linguistics, vol. 4, ed. Dram6, Mallaf^. English Department, College of Education King Saud University - Abha Branch P.O. Box 157 Abha, SAUDI ARABIA Aspects of Mandingo Grammar (^9B^). a) Dissertation b) Africanist publications: title: 1979. Aspects of complementation in Mandingo. Studies in the Linguistics Sciences 9:2. 3 Appendix B: Research & Publications in African Linguistics / University of Illinois 21 1978. (with E. G. Bokamba.) Where do relative clauses come from in Mandingo? Papers from the Fourteenth Regional Conference of the Chicago Linguistic Society, ed. by D. Farkas, W. M. Jacobsen, & K. W. Todrys, 28-43. Garber, Anne. B.P. 40 Orodara, BURKINA PASO Dissertation title: A Tonal Analysis of Senufo: Sucite Dialect {^9Q7). Haddad, Ghassan a) Dissertation F. Problems and Issues title: Arabic b) {^ in the Phonology of Lebanese 984). Africanist publications: 1980. {with M. Kenstowicz.) A note on the parallels between the definite article and the relative clause marker in Arabic. Studies in the Linguistte Sciences 10:2.141-148. Forthcoming, (with I. Abu-Salim, translators.) Translation of Generative Phonology by M. Kenstowicz and C. Kisseberth, Academic Press, 1980. To be published by Khartoum International Institute for the Arabic Language. Hamid, Abdel Halim. Department of Arabic Language Faculty of Arts Omdunnan Islamic University P.O. Box 382 Omdurman, SUDAN Dissertation A title: Descriptive Analysis of Sudanese Colloquial Arabic Phonology (^9&A). Ka, Omar. Assistant Professor of Linguistics and French Department of Modern Languages and University of Maryland Wilkins Linguistics Baltimore County Avenue Catonsville, a) - MD 21228 Areas of research interest and synopsis of current research: Phonology; language planning; structure of Wolof; non-linear phonology with respect to Atlantic languages; language planning in francophone Africa. West . 214 b) Studies in the Linguistic Sciences 19:2 (Fall 1989) Dissertation Wolof Phonology and Morphology: Approach (1988). title: A Non-Linear This dissertation provides a general analysis the phonology and morphology of Wolof, a Atlantic language spoken in Senegambia, West Africa. The study examines and treats various and salient phonological and morphological phenomena, including syllable stmcture, vowel length, gemination and degemination, prenasalization, vowel harmony, vowel coalescence, reduplication, prefixation, suffixation, and stress assignment, the latter within a West metrical framewort<. c) Africanist publications: 1981 La Derivation et no. 77, 102 pp. 1982. (with A. Diak), A. A. Diaw, M. Gufeye.) Terminologie grammaticale Wotof. Dakar: Centerfor Applied Linguistics (C.L.A.D.), no. W. 19, 46 pp. 1985a. (with E. G. la composition en Wolof. Dakar: Center for Applied Linguistics (C.L.A.D.), Bokamba & M. Sarr.) Aywaci Wolof. Champaign-Urbana: University of Illinois, Center for African Studies. 1985b. Syllable stmcture and suffixation 90. 1987. in Wok>f. Studies in the Linguistk; Sciences 15:1.61- (with A. Dialo, A. A. Diaw, & M. Gudye.) Pour un enseignement 6l6mentaire en Wolof: Progressions. Dakar: Center for Applied Linguistk:s (C.L.A.D.), no. W. 29, 102 pp. In progress. Wolof Phonology and Morphology: In progress. In progress, (with C. Language Planning W. in Francophone Kisseberth.) Prosodk; A Non-Linear Approach. Africa: domains Problems and Perspectives. in Wok}f vowel harmony. Khalil, Aziz M. Assistant Professor Bethlehem Universrty P. O. Box 666 Bethlehem, The West Bank a) Areas of research (via Israel) interest and synopsis of current research: Interlanguage studies; contrastive linguistics. am currently comparing native and non-native teachers' consistency in evaluating Arab am also EFL students' writing using both "holistic" and "analytic" evaluation methods. studying problems encountered by Arab EFL students when they translate English passive sentences and on Arab linguists' evaluatons of the translated sentences. I I b) Dissertation title: Communicative Error Evaluation: A Study of American Native Speakers' Evaluations and Interpretations of Deviant Utterances Written by Arab EFL Learners (1984). This study deals with the question of intelligibility in communication with particular reference Using data from written compositions by Arab EFL learners, the dissertation to English. . APPENDIX B: Research & Publications in African Linguistics / University of Illinois 215 focuses on two aspects of this question; (1) an investigation of the differences between judged intelligibility and naturalness, and (2) an analysis of the extent to which error type (grammatical or semantic) and immediate linguistic context affect the intelligibility, naturalness, and interpretability of deviant utterances. The discussion of these questions leads to the articulation of a validation measure for judgments of intelligibility. c) Africanist publications/conference presentations: 1985a. Communicative error evaluation: native speakers' evaluation and interpretation of written errors of Arab EFL learners. TESOL Quarterly 19,2: 335-351 (An earlier version of this paper was presented at the Fourth Annual Linguistics Conference, University of Jordan, . April 1-3, 1985.) 1985b. Interlingual and intralingual errors in Arab freshman English compositions. Bethlehem University Journal 4: 8-31 1987. (with Dr. Shukri Sanber.) A study of the relationship between attitudes and orientations of Arab freshman students and their proficiency in English. Bethlehem University Journal 6: 74-99. (An earlier version of this paper was presented at the First Symposium on ELT at the West Bank and Gaza Universities, Bethlehem University, March 13, 1987.) To appear. A study cohesion and coherence in Arab EFL college students* writing. System (An earlier version of this paper was presented at the Fifth Annual Linguistics Conference, Yarmouk University, Jordan, April 1-3, 1986.) of (March 1989.) in English and Classical Arabic: formation, type and Bethlehem University Journal 7 (August 1989). To appear. The passive voice function. Kidda, Mairo. Department of Languages and Linguistics University of Maiduguri P.M.B. 1069 Maiduguri, NIGERIA Tangale Phonology: a) Dissertation b) Africanist publications: title: A Deschptive Analysis {^ 985). 1987. (with M. Kenstowicz.) The Obligatory Contour Principle and Tangale phonology. Current Approaches to African Linguistics, vol. 4, ed. by D. Odden, 223-238. Dordrecht: Foris Publications. Livnat, Michal A. 2600 Netherlands Avenue, #201 Riverdale, NY 10463 Dissertation title: Focus Constructions in Somali (1984). 216 Studies in the Linguistic Sciences 19:2 (Fall 1989) Magura, Benjamin. 106 Twickenham Drive, Northwood P.O. Mount Pleasant Harare, ZIMBABWE Dissertation title: Style and Meaning in African English: A Sociolinguistic Analysis of South African and Zimbabwean English (1984). Marshad, Hassan A. Taif College of Education Ummal-guraa SAUDI ARABIA Taif, Dissertation title: An Approach to Code Elaboration and its Application to Swahili (^9QA). Mochiwa, Zacharia S.M. Idara ya Kiswahili S.L.P. 35040 Dar-es-Salaam, Dissertation TANZANIA title: Depletion as Both a Syntactic The Case of Swahili (1988). and Semantic Phenomenon: Odden, David A. Assistant Professor Department of Linguistics The Ohio State University 204 Cunz Hall of Languages Columbus, OH 43210-1229 a) Areas of research interest and synopsis of current research: Phonological theory and Bantu languages, especially tone. am on the interaction between syntactic structure and phonology, as well am working on a t)00k on the phonology tonology and prosodic structure. and morphology of Kimatuumlji, and am working on comparative Bantu tonology. I currently working as problems b) in Dissertation I title: Problems in Tone Assignment in Shona (1981). i This study presents basic tonal data from the Karanga dialect of Shona, and analyzes tone in an autosegmental framework. Complex stem tone alternations are analyzed in terms of a series of floating tone melodies which are assigned to verbs according to alternations morphosyntactic construction. 7 . APPENDIX c) B: Research & Publications in African Linguistics University of Illinois / 21 Africanist publications: What's 1976. really going on Nupe? in Washington Working Papers University of in Linguistics 2:86-89. 1979. (with Janice Jake.) Raising 1980a. (with C. Linguistic in Kipsigis. W. Kisseberlh.) Aspects Sciences 10:1.125-140. 1980b. Associative tone in Shona. Journal 1981a. Assigned mle features in Shona. of Studies Historical evidence 12:2.219-223. A 1981d. the Linguistic Sciences 9:2.131-157. tone assignment of Linguistic NELS XI, ed. 1981b. Evidence for the Elsewhere Condition 11:1.145-162. 1981c. in in Kimatuumbi. in Research 1 Studies J. the in Pustejovsky, 235-248. the Linguistic Sciences Studies for abstract phonological analyses. in :2.37-51 by V. Burke & Shona. Studies in African Linguistics nonlinear approach to vowel length in Kimatuumbi. Pr6cis from the 12th Conference Linguistics. Studies in African Linguistics, Supplement 8:99-103. on African Separating tone and accent: The case of Kimatuumbi. Proceedings of the First West Coast Conference on Formal Linguistics, ed. by D. Flickinger, M. Macken, & N. Wiegand, 219-230. 1982a. 1982b. Tonal phenomena in Kishambaa. Studies in Afrtean Linguistics 13:2.177-208. 1983a. Aspects of Didinga phonology and morphotogy. Nito-Saharan Language Studies, ed. by M. L. Bender, 148-176. East Lansing, Ml: Michigan State University African Studies Center. 1983b. Book notice reviewing 732. 1984a. N. T. Toweett, A Study of Kalenjin Linguistics. Stem tone assignment in Shona. Autosegmental Studies Clements & J. Goldsmith, 255-280. Dordrecht: Foris. 1984b. Formal correlates of focusing 299. in Kimatuumbi. Studies in in Language 58:731- Bantu Tonology, ed. by G. African Linguistrcs 15:3.275- 1985a. An accentual approach to tone in Kimatuumbi. African Linguisttes: Studies in Memory M. W. K. Semikenke, ed. by D. Goyvaerts. 345-419. Amsterdam: John Benjamins. Three dialects of Kipare. Current approaches Dimmendaal, 257-280. Dordrecht: Foris. 1985b. 1985c. to African Linguistics, vol. 3, ed. of by G. Problems in the metrical representation of tone. Pr6cis from the 15lh Conference on African Linguistics. Studies in African Linguistics, Supplement 9:254-257. 1985d. (with M. Odden.) Ordered reduplication 1986a. On the 383. role of the obligatory 1986b. Review of L. in Kihehe. Linguistic Inquiry 16:497-503. contour principle Hyman, A Theory of in phonotogical theory. Language 62:353- Phonotogical Weight. Language 62:669-673. 218 Studies in the Linguistic Sciences 19:2 (Fall 1989) 1987a. Predicting tone in Kikuria. Odden, 311-326. Dordrecht: 1987b. (editor). Current Approaches to African Linguistics, vol. 4, ed. by D. Foris. Current Approaches to African Linguistics, vol. 4. Dordrecht: Foris Publications. 1987c. Kimatuumbi phrasal phonology. Phonology Yearbook 4:13-36. 1988a. Floating tones and contour tones 1988b. Review of D. Pulleyblank, Tone In press. in in Kenyang. Studies in African Linguistics 19:1-34. Lexical Phonology. Journal of Linguistics 218-224. Predictable tone systems in Bantu. Autosegmental Studies van der Hulst & N. Smith. Dordrecht: Foris. in Pitch Accent Systems, ed. by H. In Syntax, lexical rules and postlexical mles in Kimatuumbi. Proceedings of the Stanford Conference on the Syntax-Phonology Connection, ed. by S. Inkelas and D. Zee. press. Rugege, Geoffrey. ESL Program Community College 709 Ashbrook Road Director, Fayettevllle Technical Fayettevllle, a) NC 28314 Areas of research interest arid synopsis of current research: Contrastive analysis/Error analysis in teaching ESL. Developing modules that could be turned into computer software for searching errors in student writing. b) Dissertation title: Kinyarwanda Sentential Complementation (^984). The study examines the semantics of complementizers in Kinyarwanda sentential complements. The fact that complementizers have semantic content dictates a particular analysis of Kinyanwanda complementation. Stucky, Susan U. Assistant Director Institute for Research on Learning 2500 Hanover Street Palo Alto, CA 94304 and Affiliate Researcher CSLI, Dept. of Linguistics Stanford University Stanford, a) CA 94305-4115 Areas of research interest and synopsis of current research: Situated cognition, discourse stmcture and interface with syntax and semantics. both thought and language are highly indexical (as has been argued and demonstrated at how do they relate? My hypothesis (the null hypothesis) is that they relate maximally efficiently, i.e., that the resulting mental structure from processing a sentence (if If length), then APPENDIX B: Research & Publications in African Linguistics / University of Illinois 219 successfully processed) is no more or less Indexical than the incoming sentence. Exploring the consequences of this hypothesis for language use and learning is the primary focus of my research these days. b) Dissertation title: \Nord Order Variation Grammar Analysis (1 Mal<ua: in 981 A Phrase Structure ). This study provides the first formal description of aspects of the syntax of Makua using the Generalized Phrase Structure Grammar framework. The work treats a number of central aspects of Makua syntax, among them relative clauses and verb agreement, with special reference to the order of constituents within the clause. The main theoretical issues addressed include the relation of basic order to its formal embodiment in the theory as well as a discussion of grammatical relations as defined by the interaction of the syntax and the semantics. c) Africanist publications: 1976. Locatives as objects 1978. in Tshiluba. Studies in Locative phrases and alternative concord 9:1.107-119. 1978b. How a noun class system Sciences 8:1.216-233. may be lost: the Linguistic Sciences 6:2.174-202. in Tshiluba. Studies in African Linguistics Evidence from Kituba. Studies Focus of contrast aspects in Makua: Syntactic and semantic evidence. the Fifth Annual Meeting of the Berkeley Linguistics Society, 362-372. 1979a. 1979b. The interaction of tone and focus 1:2.189-98. in Makua. Journal of African in the Linguistic Proceedings of Languages and Linguistics 1979c. (with Kathryn Speed Hodges.) On the inadequacy of a grammatical relation referring passive rule in Bantu. Studies in the Linguistic Sciences 9:2.91-99. 1980. Free word order languages, free constituent order languages, and the gray area between. Proceedings of the North East Linguistic Society XI, 364-376. 1982. Linearization ailes and typology. Proceedings of the First Annual on Forma! in West Coast Conference Linguistics. 1983. Verb phrase constituency and linear order in Makua. Order, Concord and Constituency, ed. by G. Gazdar, E. H. Klein, & G. K. Pullum. Dordrecht: Foris. 1985. Order in Makua Thayer, Linda Dissertation title: Syntax. New York: Garland Press. Inc. J. History of the Chari Languages Comparative Bongo-Bagirmi-Sara Segmental Phonology with Evidence from Arabic Loan Words (1974). A Reconstructed 220 Studies in the Linguistic Sciences 19:2 (Fall 1989) Wahba, Waafa A. B. 17, Saada street El-Haam, Cairo EGYPT Wh-constructions a) Dissertation b) Africanist publications: 1980. title: in Egyptian Arabic. (1984). I (with M. Kenstowicz.) Clitics and the double object construction Studies in the Linguistic Sciences 10:2.149-164. in Egyptian Arabic. j 1983. (with M. Kenstowicz.) Wh-in-situ constmctions in Egyptian Arabic. Current Approaches to African Linguistics, ed. by J. Kaye, et al., 261-282. Dordrecht: Foris. Yokwe, Eluzai. University of I Juba P.O. Box 82 Juba, SUDAN | a) Dissertation b) Africanist publications: 1978. (with B. 3. title: L. Hall.) Tlie Bari Tonal Gramniar of Ban {\^Q1). \ Vowel Harmony. CUNY Forum Papers In Linguistics 5-6:285-294. FACULTY RESEARCH ON AFRICANIST TOPICS Bokamba, Eyamba G. i Associate Professor Department of Linguistics 707 S. f^^athews Avenue University of Urbana, IL , Illinois 61801 j a) Areas of research interest and synopsis of current researcti: Bantu syntax; sociolinguistics (especially, multilingualism, language planning, code-switching, language and literacy). and revision of a am currently involved in two major projects. The first concerns the writing Bantu syntax book manuscript initially written in 1981. The second project involves an empirical investigation of the socio-psychology of the phenomena of code-switching and code-mixing, using an introspectively based questionnaire as an instrument. I ' A ^ APPENDIX B Research : b) & Publications in African Linguistics / University of Illinois 221 Africanist publications: 1980a. Verbal agreement as a non-cyclic rule in Bantu. Papers from the Sixteenth Regional Meeting of the Chicago Linguistic Society, ed. by J. Kreiman & A. E. Ojeda, 10-29. Revised and expanded version in African Linguistics: Essays in Memory of M. W. K. Semikenke, ed. by Didier Goyvaerts, 9-54. Amsterdam: John Benjamins Pub. (1985). 1980b. Language and national development: Black English in America. Language and Development: An International Perspective 1:6-9. Also in (ed.), Black English and the Proceedings of the National Invitational Education of Black Children and Youth: Symposium of the King School, ed. by G. Smitherman, 278-288. Detroit, Ml: Arlo Press (1981). 1981a. Language policies and national development in Sub-Saharan Africa: Issues for the 80s. Proceedings of the 9th Absolute Values and the Search for Peace of Mankind: International Conference on the Unity of the Sciences. 421-450. New York: International Cultural Foundation. 1981b. Language and national development in the Linguistic Sciences 11:1.1-26. 1981c. Ekolongonelo ya Lingala: An in Sub-Saharan Africa: Introductory Textbook Urbana: Center for African Studies, University of A progress report. Studies and Grammar. Mimeographed. Illinois. 1982. The Africanization of English. The Other Tongue: English Across Cultures, ed. by Braj B. Kachru, 77-98. Champaign, IL: University of Illinois Press. 1984a. Language and literacy in West Africa. Annual Review of Applied Linguistics 1983, ed. by R. B. Kaplan, 40-75. Rowley, MA: Newbury House Publishers. 1984b. Review of R. L. Cooper, ed., Language Spread: Studies 1982. English World-Wide 5:2.275-96. 1984c. Language in African Culture and Society. Sciences 14:2. Editor. 1984d. French colonial polcy 14:2.1-36. 1986. in Africa Education and development in and its Zaire. Diffusion and Social Change, Special issue of Studies legacies (part The in I.) Studies Crisis in Zaire: in in the Linguistic the Linguistic Sciences Myths and Realities, ed. by Nzongola-Ntalaja, 191-218. Trenton, N.J.: Africa World Press, pp. 1987. Are there syntactic constraints on code-switching? Variation in Language: NWAV-15 at Stanford, ed. by K. M. Denning, S. Inkelas, F. C. McNair-Knox and John R. Rtekford, 34-41. Revised version in World Englishes 8:3.277-292 (1989). 1988. Code-mixing, language variation and linguistic theory: Lingua: International Review of Linguistics 76:21-62. Evidence from Bantu languages. of (the sociolinguistics of) English in West Africa. English Around the World: Sociolinguistic Perspectives, ed. by J. Cheshire. London: Cambridge University Press. To appear. Overview African English. The Oxford Companion to the English Language, ed. by .McArthur. London: Oxford University Press. To appear. T 1978. (with Mallaf6 Dram6.) Where do relative clauses come from in Mandingo? Papers from the Fourteenth Regional Conference of the Chicago Linguistic Society, ed. by D. Farkas. W. M. Jacobsen, & K. W. Todrys, 28-43. 222 Studies in the Linguistic Sciences 19:2 (Fall 1989) 1979. 1980. (with Salikoko S. Mufwene.) Are there modal-auxiliaries in Lingala? Papers from the Fifteenth Regional Meeting of the Chicago Linguistic Society, ed. by P. R. Clyne, W. F. Hanks, & C. L. Hobauer, 244-255. The consequences of the language policies of African States vis-eiLanguage and Linguistic Problems in Africa, ed. by P. A. Kotey & Ha. DerHoussikian, 35-53. Columbia, SC: Hornbeam Press. Reprinted in Reconsideration of African Linguistic Policies, ed. by Kahombo Mateene & John Kalema, 43-66. Kampala, Uganda: The OAU Inter-African Bureau of Languages. (with Josiah S. Tlou.) vis education. 1986a. (with course Omar Ka and Momodou Sarr.) AywaCiWolof. Wolof (24 lessons) LatxDratory, University of Illinois, UC. for introductory in [A microcomputer-based, multi-media diskettes and typeset]. Language Learning 1986b. (with Mwamba Kapanga and Zacharia Mochiwa.) Tujifunze Kiswahili. [A microcomputerbased, multi-media course for introductory Swahili (25 lessons) in diskettes and typeset]. Language Learning Laboratory, University of Illinois, UC. 1987. (with Nkonko M. Kamwangamalu.) The significance of code-mixing to linguistic theory: Evidence from Bantu languages. Studies in the Linguistic Sciences 17:2.21-43. Cheng, C. C. Professor, Department of Linguistics Language Learning Laboratory Foreign Languages Building Director, G70 S. Mathews Avenue University of Illinois 707 Urbana, a) IL 61801 Areas of research interest Chinese b) Linguistics, Computational Linguistics, Computer-Assisted Instruction Africanist publications: 1980. (with Charles Kisseberth.) Sciences 10:1.15-44. Ikorovere Makua tonotogy 1981. (with Charles Kisseberth.) Sciences 11:1.181-202. Ikorovere Makua 1982a. (with Charles Kisseberth.) Sciences 12:1.123-139. (part 2). tonology (pari Tone-bearing nasals in 3). Makua. Studies in the Linguistic Studies in the Linguistic in the Linguistic Studies 1982b. (with Charles Kisseberth.) High tone doubling in two Makua dialects. Proceedings from the Twelfth Conference on African Linguistics, ed. by W. R. Leben. Studies in African Linguistics, Supplement 8:5-8. . APPENDIX B: Research & Publications in African Linguistics / 223 University of Illinois Kenstowicz, Michael Professor, Department of Linguistics 707 Mathews Avenue S. University of Urbana, a) Illinois 61801 IL Areas of research interest. Phonology, Syntax; African, Semitic, Slavic languages b) Africanist publications/conference presentations: 1980. Notes on Cairene Arabic syncope. Studies A 1981a. & note on cyclic stress H. Borer. in in in Semitic Linguistics, ed. by J. Aoun Linguistics 3:21-31. in Palestinian Arabic: Gemination and spirantization 1982. the Linguistic Sciences 10:2.39-54. Levantine Arabic. Studies MIT Working Papers 1981b. Vowel harmony 465. in a suprasegmental analysis. Studies in Tigrinya. in Linguistics 19:449- the Linguistic Sciences 12:1.106- 123. three Arabic dialects. Proceedings of the 1983. Parametric variation and accent assignment Chicago Linguistics Society 19:205-213. 1984. The null-subject parameter in Modern Arabic dialects. Proceedings of the North East Linguistics Society 14:207-219. (Revised version to appear in The Pro-Drop Parameter, ed. by O. Jaeggli and K, Safir. Reidel, 1988.) in 1986a. The phonology and syntax of wh-expressions in Tangale. Linguistic Studies in Memory of Theodore M. Lightner (Studies in the Linguistic Sciences 15,2.), ed. by M. Kenstowicz, 79-92. (Revised version in Phonology Yearbook 4 (1987):229-241 1986b. Notes on syllable stmcture Linguistique in three modern Arabic dialects. Revue Qu6becoise de 16:1.101-128. 1987. Tone and accent in Kizigua - a Bantu language. Certamen Phonologicum I, Proceedings of the Cortona Phonology Conference, April 1987, ed. by P. M. Bertinetto & M. Loporcaro. 1980. (with Kama! Abdul-Karim.) Cyclic stress in Levantine Arabic. Studies in the Linguistic Sciences 10:2.55-76. 1980. (with Ghassan Haddad.) A note on the parallels between the definite article and the relative clause marker in Arabic. Studies in the Linguistic Sciences 10:2.141-148. 1980. (with Wafaa Wahba.) Clitics and the double object construction in the Linguistic Sciences 10:2.149-164. 1983 1984. in Egyptian Arabic. Studies Current Approaches to (with Wafaa Wahba.) Wh-in-situ constmctions in Egyptian Arabic. AfricanLinguistics,ed by J. Kayeetal, 261-282. Dordrecht: Foris. (with Omar Linguistic Irshied.) Some phonological mles of Bani-Hassan Arabic. Sciences 14:2.109-148. Studies in the 224 Studies in the Linguistic Sciences 19:2 (Fall 1989) 1985. Yousef Bader and Rachid Benkeddache.) The phonology of state in Kabyle Berber. Essays in memory of M. W. K. Semikenke, ed. by D. Goyvaerts, 319334. Amsterdam: John Benjamins (with African linguistics: . 1986. (with Emmanuel Nikiema.) Tonology Qu6bec Montreal, i Universite du 1987. (with Mairo Kidda.) Approaches 1988. (with of Moore. The Obligatory Contour to African Linguistics, vol. 4, ed. Principle and Tangale phonology. Current by D. Odden, 223-238. Dordrecht: Foris. Emmanuel Nikiema and Metenwa Studies in Internal report, Linguistique Africaniste, ci Ourso.) the Linguistic Sciences 18:2.77-104. Tonal polarity in two Gur languages. To appear, (with Charles Kisseberth.) Chizigula tonology: the word and beyond. The SyntaxPhonology Connection, ed. by Sharon Inkelas and Draga Zee. CSLI, Stanford. Kim, Chin W. Professor, Department of Linguistics 707 S. Mathews Avenue University of Illinois Urbana,IL 61801 a) Areas of research and synopsis interest of current research: Phonetics, phonology, morphology, Korean and African linguistics, stylistics. am currently doing research in the phonology-syntax interface, the interrelation between tone and intonation and the interrelation between language, literature and music. I b) Africanist publications: 1971. Papers (ed. with Herbert Stahlke.) Research, in African Linguistics. Edmonton, Canada: Linguistic Inc. 1973. Opposition and complement in Swahili phonology. Issues Kachru et al, 409-417. Urtana, IL: University of Illinois Press. 1974. A note on tonal conjunction in Efik. Studies in in Linguistics, ed. by Braj B. the Linguistic Sciences 4:2.112-22. Kisseberth, Charles W. Professor, Department of Linguistics 707 S. Mathews Avenue University of Illinois Urbana,IL 61801 a) Areas of research interest and synopsis of current research: Research on the tonal structure of Chizigula (Tanzania), Sesotho-Setswana-Northern Sotho Africa), Tsonga (South Africa); research on the phonology/syntax interface (Chizigula, Chimwiini, Bari, Kimatuumbi, Tsonga); documentation of inadequately described languages (dictionaries, texts and grammars of Chimwiini, Makua, Kimatuumbi, Chizigula). (South & Publications in African Linguistics Appendix B: Research b) / University of Illinois 225 Africanist publications/conference presentations: 1981. Tone displacement Digo Tonoiogy. 1984a. in Digo (Part 2). Studies Autosegmental Studies in the Linguistic Sciences 11:1. 73-120. in Bantu Tone, ed. by G. N. Clements & J. Goldsmith, 105-182. Dordrecht: Foris Publications. To appear. Tone and accent in Chizigula. Festshrift for E. O. J. Westphal, ed. by D. Gowlett & S. Satyo. University of Capetown. In progress. In Progress. The Tonal Grammar of Chizigula. Makua Phonology and Morphology. Ikorovere (Makua) tonoiogy (Part 1980a. (with C.-C. Cheng.) Sciences 10:1.15-44. (with D. Odden.) Aspects Sciences 10:1.125-140. 1980b. tone assignment of 1980c. (with W. Wood.) Tone displacement 10:1.141-177. 1981. in 1). Studies Ikorovere (Makua) tonoiogy (Part (with C.-C. Cheng.) Sciences 11:1.181-202. in Studies Kimatuumbi. Studies in Digo (Part 1982a. (with C.-C. Cheng.) Tone-bearing nasals 12:1.123-139. 2). 3). Makua. Studies in in the Linguistic the Linguistic the Linguistic Sciences Studies in in in the Linguistic the Linguistic Sciences 1982b. (with C.-C. Cheng.) High tone doubling in two Makua dialects. Proceedings from the Twelfth Conference on African Linguistics, ed. by W. R. Leben. Studies in African Linguistics, 1984. (with 1985. F. Supplement 8:5-8. Cassimjee.) Downstep (with F. Cassimjee.) in Venda. Studies Three cases of downstep in in the Linguistic Sciences 14:1.1-29. Venda. Studies in African Linguistics, Supplement 9:45-48. 1989. (with M. Kenstowicz.) Chizigula tonoiogy: the word and beyond. The Syntax-Phonology Connection, ed. by Sharon Inkelas and Draga Zee. CSLI, Stanford. Forthcoming, (with E. Yokwe.) Bari tonoiogy. Forthcoming, (with C.-C. Cheng and Forthcoming, (with M. Abasheikh.) F. A Cassimjee.) A Makua Dictionary. Chimwiini dictionary. A Reference Grammar of Kimatuumbi. In progress, (with D. Odden.) In Progress, (with M. Abasheikh.) A Grammar of Chimwiini. 1 Vol. 4:1 Vol. UNIVERSITY OF ILLINOIS-URBANA 3 0112 038150972

Log In

Convergence and Syntactic Reanalysis: The case of 'so' in Dakkhini

Sign up for access to the world's latest research

Abstract

Related papers