I got into 'The League' — the Tinder for elites — here's what it was like

First, I had my friend send me a link to join The League.

Tech Insider/Molly Mulshine

The link took me to the App Store, where I downloaded the app.

The League

This was my first look at the exclusive app.

The League

The next screen made a lot of promises. I'm not really sure how the threat of voyeurs plays into online dating, but okay.

The League

The League links to Facebook, so I had to give it permission to access my info.

The League

The app also goes through LinkedIn. It's cool that they prevent people from your current company from seeing you. Nobody wants to run into a coworker on a dating site.

The League

Now for the fun part: filling out the profile.

The League

Followed by the REALLY fun part: Dictating exactly what I want in a match. The height-obsessed users of Tinder would love this.

The League

Now for the moment of truth ... am I good enough for The League?

The League

Nope, not quite. Or at least not yet. I was going to have to wait. But at least my friend's VIP status on the app meant I was bumped to the top of the list.

The League

While waiting to get in, I was able to play around with my profile. I wish I could take "Tinder Booster" off since I only follow that account for work, but I can't.

The League

Thankfully, I CAN take away the photo of me and my ex that auto-populated the app, though. I know from an interview with an online-dating expert that ex photos can be a deal breaker.

The League

Click here to read more about why you shouldn't post photos with your ex on dating sites.

A few hours after joining the waitlist, I got in!

The League

They like me, they really like me! Reading the rules, I find it interesting that I only get to pick from a few guys per day. I guess that makes each match more special, but it doesn't sound as fun as Tinder.

The League

A cute but fake "concierge" sent me the ground rules.

The League

There are a lot of ground rules. Also, I'm pretty wary of anyone who uses the word "classy" unironically.

The League

Okay, can I see some guys already? It took a few minutes to load.

The League

When they finally appeared, I didn't end up liking that many of them. It felt cold and clinical to analyze people based on stats like their alma mater, height, and occupation. Tinder feels like a cocktail party where you're constantly flirting with people you like. The League feels like sorting through potential hires' résumés.

The League

And once I did "like" someone, if he hadn't liked me back, he stayed on the screen instead of disappearing as unfulfilled matches do on Tinder. This gave me some light feelings of rejection that I never experience while using Tinder.

The League

Once you do match with someone, you have 21 days to message each other. My matches look good on paper — they're mostly Ivy League grads who work in finance. But no one is messaging me! Is it because I went to state school or what?

The League

You can sort your matches by a few options including "Least Flaky," which seems weird to me. Doesn't "Least Flaky" just mean these are the guys who are talking to and taking out the most girls? That's not exactly a selling point for me.

The League

After trying it out, I don't think my future soul mate is on The League. Analyzing potential boyfriends based on their résumés really doesn't do it for me. And anyone who takes himself seriously enough to join a dating app for "elites" probably isn't my type anyway.

The League

Plus, I've always wondered: If everyone on The League is so great, why are they still single? If you're Ivy-educated, good-looking, and successful and none of the other million dating sites have worked for you yet, I don't see why this one would.