CTI Courseware - EMPD - Cert - eBook.B PDF
CTI Courseware - EMPD - Cert - eBook.B PDF
by Barbara Wood
Table of Contents
Background information
Aim of the course . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 1 Learning outcomes and assessment criteria . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 2 Learning outcomes and assessment criteria . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 3
Individual units
Learning activities and the assessment toolbox. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 8
The use of icons Glossary Unit 1: Assessing your employability and professional development (epd) profile
1.1 Introduction. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 19 1.2 Assessment of personal behaviour and competence . . . . . . . 20
1.2.1 Activity: personality and learning styles . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 20
1.3 Assessing your learning and personality styles . . . . . . . . . . . 21 1.4 Expected attitudes and behaviour, current skills and competencies. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 23
1.4.1 Punctuality . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 1.4.2 Reliability . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 1.4.3 Trustworthiness .. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 24 24 24
ISBN : 13-978-0-9921989-5-4
1.4.4 Honesty . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 25 1.4.5 Politeness/courtesy . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 25 1.4.6 Respect . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 25 1.4.7 Self-discipline . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 26 1.4.8 Tidiness . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 26 1.4.9 Being organised and able to plan. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 1.4.10 Good time management . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 27 27
1.4.11 Commitment and tenacity. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 28 1.4.12 Being resourceful. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 28 1.4.13 Looking for continuous self-improvement . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 29 1.4.14 Ability to communicate clearly and appropriately. . . . . . . . . . . . . . 29
2.8 Completing a cv and forms needed in the work place and job interview . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 57
2.8.1 Activity: writing an up-to-date curriculum vitae . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 58
1.7 Conclusion . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 33
2.9 Maintaining transcripts and a cv . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 58 2.10 Portfolio building: developing and maintaining a personal portfolio . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 59 2.11 The job interview . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 59
2.11.1 Activity: the job interview role play. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 60
2.12 Conclusion . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 61
2.4 Evaluation of own development needs and the activities to meet them . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 42
2.4.1 Expectations by the employer. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 42 2.4.2 Activity: the most important employer expectations . . . . . . . . . . . . 43
3.3.3 Attitudinal barriers .. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 68 3.3.4 Ambiguity of words and phrases . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 68 3.3.5 Individual linguistic ability .. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 68 3.3.6 Physiological barriers. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 68 3.3.7 Communication noise. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 68
44
2.5.1 The actual employment contract. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 44 2.5.2 Regulation of working time. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 46 2.5.3 Leave (annual and sick leave). . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 47 2.5.4 Remuneration (salaries and wages). . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 48 2.5.5 Induction . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 49 2.5.6 Behaviour at work . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 49 2.5.7 Employment rights and responsibilities .. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 49
3.8 It as an effective communication medium . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 81 3.9 Interpersonal skills/communication in meetings . . . . . . . . . . 83 3.10 Personal effectiveness through communication . . . . . . . . . 3.11 Negotiating skills . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 84 84
3.13.9 Taking a break . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 94 3.13.10 Effective task scheduling . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 94 3.13.11 Time management leading to better productivity . . . . . . . . . . . . . 95 3.13.12 Improve your attitude . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 95 3.13.13 Integrate your information . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 95 3.13.14 Start to record your activities . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 96 3.13.15 Activity: the action plan . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 3.13.16 Making and keeping appointments . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 97 97
4.7.4 Excuses, excuses, excuses - and the blaming culture . . . . . . 141 4.7.5 Appearances. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 141 4.7.6 Going beyond the expected . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 142
4.8 Review of own development against original aims and objectives 143
4.8.1 Activity: revision of development plan . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 143 4.8.2 Activity: assessing areas that have been achieved . . . . . . . . . . . . . 143 4.8.3 Activity: assessing areas that need further corrective action, time lines.144
5.3 The process of and steps in problem solving . . . . . . . . . . . . 152 5.4 A seven-step problem solving cycle (University of South Australia) .. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 153
5.4.1 Identifying or recognising the problem. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 153 5.4.2 Defining the problem. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 154 5.4.3 Activity: online research . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 156 5.4.4 Examining the problem from all sides and in depth . . . . . . . . . . . . . 156 5.4.5 Forming a problem-solving strategy . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 160 5.4.6 Collecting and organising facts and information . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 161 5.4.7 Allocating resources . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 163 5.4.8 Implementing solutions . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 164 5.4.9 Monitoring progress. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 165 5.4.10 Evaluating the results. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 166
6.5 Gap in development and skills .. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 191 6.6 Problem analysis. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 192
6.6.1 Activity: problem-solving skills . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 192
6.7 Development plan, revision of aims and objectives, achievement dates, action plan, activities. . . . . . . . . . . . . 192
6.7.1 Activity: planning own performance enhancement. . . . . . . . . . . . . . 192
5.5 Other processes used to solve problems . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 167 5.6 Assessment of personal problem-solving skills . . . . . . . . . . 167
5.6.1 Activity: take the quiz - how good are you at solving problems? . . . . 168 5.6.2 Becoming proactive to avoid problems from occurring. . . . . . . . . . . 170
6.8 Monitoring performance development, review date achievements and shortcomings. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 193
6.8.1 Activity: monitoring personal performance. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 193
5.7 Review of own development against original aims and objectives . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 171
5.7.1 Activity: revision of development plan . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 172 5.7.2 Activity: assessing areas that have been achieved . . . . . . . . . . . . . 172 5.7.3 Activity: assessing areas that need further corrective action, time lines.173
6.10 Interpersonal and transferable skills and sustainability. . . . 194 6.11 Conclusion . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 194
Background information
Welcome to the course in employability and professional development. The world around us has changed dramatically. In the past, proof of successful tertiary education was good enough for a graduate to be offered attractive permanent employment - particularly if such qualification was obtained in the ict field. This is no longer the case. Over and above achieving an outstanding tertiary education pass mark, students now have to compete with job applicants from all over the world. These job competitors may have specific skills that make them more attractive to potential employers. Graduates are expected to show that they are job-ready, rounded personalities, socially well adjusted, capable and willing to find and keep a job. They are expected to be productive soon after appointment and to meet employers high standards. For this reason, we are offering this course, which will develop your skills and professionalism and your ability to conceptualise your own career planning. It will help to define your current personal employability and professional development profile. Thereafter, you will determine the goals you need to achieve. This course will teach you to take responsibility for your own future by setting your own performance objectives and by applying selfmotivation and self-discipline. The course employability and professional development will teach you to communicate in a clear and understandable manner with potential employers and co-workers. This ability must be enhanced further by efficient teamwork or as an individual, when so required. In this course you will be introduced to these enabling techniques to perform these activities.
7.4 Alternative options to employment .. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 205 7.5 The way ahead . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 206 7.6 Conclusion . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 206
time line management. The course will also lead them to understand why they need to monitor and control their progress in achieving the implemented goals associated with their employability and professional development plan.
2. Be able to demonstrate acquired interpersonal and transferable skills 3. Understand the dynamics of working for and with others
2.1 Communicate in a variety of styles and appropriate manner at various levels 2.2 Demonstrate effective time management strategies 3.1 Analyse team dynamics, discussing the roles people play in a team and how they can work together to achieve shared goals 3.2 Discuss alternative ways to complete tasks and achieve team goals
4. Be able to develop 4.1 Review tools and methods for developing strategies for problem solving solutions to problems 4.2 Develop an appropriate strategy for resolving a particular problem 4.3 Evaluate the potential impact on the business of implementing the problem-solving strategy
course content
1. Be able to take responsibility for own personal and professional development
Responsibilities: own responsibilities, e.G. Personal responsibility, direct and indirect relationships, decision-making processes and skills, ability to learn and develop within the work role, e.G. Employment legislation, ethics, employment rights and responsibilities Performance objectives: setting and monitoring performance objectives Individual appraisal systems: uses of performance appraisals, e.G. Salary levels and bonus payments, promotion, strengths and weaknesses, training needs; communication; appraisal criteria, e.G. Production data, personnel data, judgemental data; rating methods, e.G. Ranking, checklist, management by objectives; skills audit (personal profile using appropriate self-assessment tools); evaluating self-management; personal and interpersonal skills; leadership skills Motivation and performance: application and appraisal of motivational theories and techniques, rewards and incentives; managers role; selfmotivational factors. Development plan: current performance; future needs; opportunities and threats to career progression; aims and objectives; achievement dates; review dates; learning programme/activities; action plans; personal development plan. Portfolio building: developing and maintaining a personal portfolio Transcripts: maintaining and presenting transcripts including curriculum vitae
Glossary
We provide you with a glossary of subject terminology that is used in the coursebook. Please refer to the glossary (at the end of the coursebook) to familiarise yourself with the meaning of the concepts and terms used in this subject field, and become proficient with these terms.
Purpose
This coursebook will help you to master the expectations and demands made by employers and help you build a successful career. The coursebook contains readings, activities and application aids that will assist you in developing the knowledge and skills stipulated in the specific outcomes and assessment criteria. The coursebook has been designed to optimise study time and maximise learning. It is important for you to work through the coursebook attentively and follow all the instructions. In this way, you should be able to deepen your learning and enhance your chances of success. It is essential that the exercises and other learning activities in the coursebook are completed. The course assessments (examination, tests and assignments) are based on the assumption that these learning activities have been completed.
Individual units
The units in the coursebook are structured in the same way, and each unit contains the following features to enhance the learning process:
Unit title: Each unit title is based on the title and content of the specific outcome or the assessment criterion that is being discussed in the unit. The unit title is followed by an outline of the learning outcomes and assessment criteria, which guide the learning process. They show what you should be able to do once the unit has been studied. The learning outcomes represent the end product of what you should have learned in the unit. The learning outcomes are followed by an introduction that identifies the key concepts of the unit. The content of each unit contains the theoretical foundation of the course and is based on the work of experts in this field. The theory is illustrated by means of relevant examples. The concluding remarks at the end of each unit provide a brief summary of the unit and an indication of what you can expect in the following unit. The content is followed by a number of self-assessment questions to test your knowledge of the content of a particular unit. The self-assessment questions also give you an indication of questions that you may expect in the tests and in the final examination.
Additional reading
Learning outcomes:
Introduction: Content:
This icon is used to indicate how individual units in the Coursebook are aligned with a learning outcome and its assessment criteria.
This icon indicates that you are expected to do some additional reading i.e. you should obtain additional information by consulting relevant, external information sources.
Example
Notes
Concluding remarks:
Self-assessment:
This icon points to a section in the text where relevant examples for a particular topic (theme) or concept are provided.
Legislation
Useful website
Definitions
This icon appears when definitions of a particular term or concept are given in the text.
This icon appears at the end of each unit in the coursebook, indicating that you are required to answer self-assessment questions to test your knowledge of the content of the foregoing unit.
Glossary
To give up responsibility Adjourning is typically related to the end of a project team. It is also relevant when the purpose and structure of the team change substantially due to a sale, merger or restructuring process. Termination is when the project is permanently ended. Advocacy teams The teams who defend the proposed definition or action, i.e. are in favour of it, and those who believe it is not a good idea or not the correct reason and have to defend that view. Affiliative leaders They promote emotional bonds and organisational harmony around them. Allocating resources Assigning money and people to a project. Alternatives Other options, other ways of doing things. Ambiguity Sentences or words that sound the same but have different meanings for different people. Ambitious Wanting to achieve something better, sooner, before others. The Appreciative Examines what works well in the areas surrounding the Inquiry problems. Arbitration Settlement of a dispute by an independent person acting as an arbitrator. Assumptions Something taken for granted, taken as true or sure to happen before there is proof. Audio-visual Communication through TV, DVD, etc. - both via sight and communication sound. Autocratic, Demand immediate compliance, believe everything must authoritarian or be done their way. Do not tolerate other peoples opinions commanding leaders easily. Barriers to The intended communication does not take place, it is successful blocked. communication Basic Conditions of The laws that were put in place to protect workers. These Employment Act, labour laws were recently amended to remain relevant to 1997 (BCEA) the changes in South Africa. Belbin Team Roles The team personalities are described as Plant, Resource Investigator, Coordinator, Shaper, Monitor, Evaluator, Team worker Implementer, Completer Finisher, Specialist Biorhythms Any recurring cycles of physical, emotional and intellectual activity in peoples lives. Blaming culture Not accepting own responsibilities - always seeing the fault in others, and seeing others as the cause of problems. Body language Also called non-verbal communication. We communicate through gestures, postures, facial expressions. Boundaries Limits between what people can do. Your boundaries start where other peoples boundaries end, and vice versa. Braille Tactile communication used by people who cannot see. Abdicate Adjourn and terminate
10
11
A spontaneous discussion in search of new ideas. Encouraging others to look for other options, new solutions. Capabilities Skills people possess, things they are able to do. Capacity to perform in a certain area. Car/petrol Special amounts of money paid by an employer to allowances employees together with their salaries or wages. These are taxed. Cause-and-effect Looking at the interrelationships between what caused analysis which results. CCMA The Commission for Conciliation, Mediation and Arbitration. Workers can apply to this body if they feel they have been unfairly treated by their employer. CEO Chief Executive Officer in a company. Ranked below the Chairperson. May be a senior director of a company. Coaching leaders Develop people, establish relationships and trust with and among people. Their goal is to help people improve themselves. Coherent It is logical, has all concepts/points connected, is relevant communication to the main topic, and the tone and flow of the message is consistent. Commanding or Gets results (telling everybody exactly what to do, at that autocratic leadership moment). Remains in charge at all times. style Commissioner of A person (lawyer, police officer) before whom oaths may Oaths be sworn by people making affidavits or who certify true copies of transcripts. Commission Payment to a person for selling goods or services, often calculated in proportion to/as a percentage of the goods sold. Commitment Bind oneself with an obligation or pledge to do something. Communication There is interference with the decoding of messages sent noise over a channel by an encoder. The message cannot be received properly. Companys hierarchy The authority ranking in a company. Competence/ Skills or abilities. Can be generic or job-specific. competencies Complete Includes all relevant information, no information left out. communication Comprehensive Listing all objectives which will be measured on achieved performance performance. objectives Concise Sticks to the point and keeps it brief. No extra explanations. communication Concrete Gives the audience a clear picture of what you are telling communication them. Consequences Result produced by some action or lack of necessary action. Constructive Tests a proposed solution by subjecting it to the clash of controversy cycle ideas, showing it to be wrong, proving it, or disproving or improving it.
Brainstorm
Leaders adapt their style to suit a situation, they do not remain limited by one specific leadership style. Ongoing learning, honing of skills and abilities. Assumes some power being exercised over something or somebody. Direct influence over some action or measurement. Suitable and targeted to its audience. It is also free of grammatical or spelling errors. To fix previous errors or omissions. To take steps so that problems are resolved. Is polite, friendly and open. Evokes vivid images of what you are trying to say, breaks through the clutter often present in media environments. Message is straightforward, honest, to the point and truly believable. Stereotypical assumptions can cause misunderstandings, different cultures interpreting messages differently. A commonly used format for a document that provides personal, academic and work history information. Used in providing background when applying for work or membership of an association, or for assisting an employer in determining the skills and experiences of the applicant. To entrust a task or responsibility to somebody else for the duration of the task but to retain accountability. Gets everybodys input and opinion, reaches consensus before acting. A formal process followed by an employer following misbehaviour or poor performance by an employee, to bring on corrective behaviour that may result in dismissal. Altered or changed message, making it inaccurate. Matter in motion, also the interactions in a team. The activity of conveying the correct information through the exchange of thoughts, messages or information, via speech, visuals, signals, writing or behaviour. Good speaking skills, speaking clearly with correct pronunciation. Serious happening or situation needing prompt action. Does not have the title (e.g. CEO, manager or director) but has lots of influence with people. The ability to understand and manage ones emotions and control ones actions. Also the ability to understand and contextualise the emotions and reactions of others. The ability to cope with feelings of stress, tension, anxiety, fatigue. The ability to identify oneself mentally with a person or thing, and so to understand his or her feelings or its meaning.
Correct communication Corrective action Courteous communication Creative communication Credible communication Cultural noise Curriculum vitae (CV)
Distorted Dynamics Effective communication Efficient speaking Emergencies Emergent leader Emotional intelligence Emotional resilience Empathy and compassion
12
13
A person who works for a company in return for wages. The requirements of an employer of his/her employees in terms of performance and behaviour, the skills they must possess and the attitude they must show. Employability The job applicant has the character traits, competencies and skills to make the prospective employer keen to offer him/her the vacant job. Employment The official document between employer and employee contract stating the terms and conditions of employment. Engaging leaders Engage employees in understanding the existing conditions and how they can collectively assist in addressing them. Ethics Moral principles in all dealings. Etiquette The rules of correct behaviour in society or among the members of a profession. Evaluation Evaluating results - shows what works and does not work and why. Evaluation is an act or several acts of judgement by managers (or by yourself if it is a personal evaluation). Extraversion Driven by interaction with others, oriented to and motivated by the world outside oneself. Facial expression Conveys the message via the way the face moves: raised eyebrows, grimacing, smiling, sad expressions, angry frown, etc. Feedback The return of information about an action, product or service, response from others. Feeling style Information/situations are assessed subjectively, judgements based on worth/values. Flexible working Employees can start and finish work at varying hours, have hours to be present within core hours. Gaps Also called delta in behaviour or skills. Gap between current, actual and ideal level. Go or no-go decision Decision to be taken whether to proceed with action or whether to abandon action based on evaluation. Individual appraisal Assessing the individual employees performance according systems to predetermined parameters and a set time period. Induction manual Document that tells the new employee about the company history, its rules, behaviour codes, and who does what in the company. Infringing rights Breaking somebodys rights or boundaries. Interpersonal skills Interactive skills, teamwork, management and leadership skills. Intonation The way in which your voice rises and falls, the way it becomes louder or softer. Introversion Driven by solitary activities, oriented to and motivated by the world inside oneself. Intuition Abstract, symbolic, conceptual awareness. Knowing or understanding something without reasoning or being taught. Job competitors Others who have similar skills and experience who want the same job as you.
Judging style
Labour legislation
Managers
Plan ahead and/or follow the plan, live ones outer life with closure and structure, using the preferred judging process of either thinking or feeling. Laws designed to regulate the relationship between employer and employee. Usually there to protect the employee. The ability to lead others who follow willingly, motivating others by example. Various styles managers or leaders use naturally to be in charge of others, leading, commanding or motivating others. The way in which a person best receives information, processes it, and remembers and expresses it. Avoiding the use of industry-specific jargon or inappropriate words in communication. Ability to express a concept or idea clearly. May speak more than one language. Supervising employees. Are comfortable with tangible products and systems, anything they can control hands-on, with the present known environment, safer choices. They are often pragmatic, like to deal with matters which they can sort out and avoid risk. Managers are good at accepting and issuing orders, enforcing rules, making sure that everything works. Planning, organising, leading and controlling. The generic functions of a manager in any type of organisation. Polite social behaviour, a persons bearing or way of behaving towards others. Readily changing circumstances, place of work or residence. Impetus gained by movement, action causing further action. Ongoing monitoring involves regular feedback from people, systems, mechanisms, etc. Monitoring provides indicators of efficiency, effectiveness and impact; it collects and records ongoing information (benchmarking). Stimulating the interest of others, inspiring others to do something. Across several media types, e.g. on TV, online and in print. Self-centred style, concerned with their image, how employees perceive them, whether they are admired, copied, how much publicity they receive. Embarrassed by failures or being seen in the wrong outfit, with the wrong people. They need to feel important. Communication that does not use words. It includes sensory and expressive communication, body language, sign language, dress, etc. Something obstructs or hinders progress. Part of a SWOT analysis. Looks at possibilities and options for positive career progression and possible threats or hurdles to such career progression. Spoken communication.
14
15
Organisational noise
Poor communication in a company can prevent accurate interpretation, usually caused by poor systems or structures in a company. A graph showing all people in management and their position/role in the company. Set challenging and exciting standards and expect excellence. They believe that employees can do a lot better, faster than they do. The bar is raised on a regular basis they may be firm believers of Total Quality Management and continuous higher achievements. Chief importance, top ranking importance. Expressing the meaning of something in other words, rewording something. Keep options open to adapt, live ones outer life in a more emergent manner using the preferred perceiving process of sensing and intuition. Specific purpose or goals set for performance, usually agreed between employee and manager. Extras offered over and above wages or salary (e.g. medical aid, car allowance) Puts together personal skills development, the extension of ones abilities. It entails advancing ones current skills, abilities and knowledge. Different styles in which people act, react or function. Personality characteristics, the way a person tends to act or react. Limitations caused by tangible distances/obstacles, e.g. a different building, no cellphone signal reception possible. These barriers to effective communication may be the result of individuals ill health, poor eyesight or hearing difficulties. Developing a personal portfolio showing items/records of achievement or skills. Acting to avoid problems from happening. Precedence in importance, something to be done first. This cycle is portrayed in a logical, sequential manner. There are several models available that illustrate the problem-solving cycle. Postponing action, not getting things done when they should be done. Setting a proper career development plan, how to improve ones skills for better career advancement. Being given a better title at work or a better salary, or both. Usually only given if well-deserved through performance. Correct pronunciation means that your words will be correctly heard and understood. Close to others, e.g. desks close together, people sharing offices.
Psychological contract
Psychological noise Reflection Remuneration Resourceful Responsibilities Resum Role play Segmented Self-assessment Self-control Self-discipline Sensing Self-evaluation
Performance objectives Perks Personal development plan Personality styles Personality traits Physical boundaries Physiological barriers Portfolio building Preventative action Priorities Problem-solving cycle Procrastination Professional development plan Promotion Pronunciation Proximity to others
An informal exchange agreement between an employer and the employee, which specifies mutual expectations in terms of the way in which the employer treats the employee and the employees output and contribution to the organisation. Where prejudices and attitudes can make communication difficult. To think deeply, consider, remind oneself of past actions, events, behaviour. Salaries and wages paid for services rendered by the employee. To find solutions to problems, coming up with ideas and ways to do something. Legally or morally obliged to take care of something or to carry out a duty, liable to be blamed for loss or failure. More commonly used in the USA, a shortened version of a CV, similar to a summary of a CV. Acting out a specific scenario or concept to understand it better. Split into smaller parts, each part representing something. Taking stock of ones skills and abilities, looking at strengths and weaknesses. Being in control of ones emotions, ones responses and managing oneself. Taking control of your actions, reactions, emotions. Sticking to goals, tasks, commitments, promises. Tangible, experiential awareness. When it is left up to the individual to dig deep and find the reasons for great or poor performance, efficiencies that need to be addressed. Also so-called level 5 leader, who focuses strongly on giving staff the credit and working from behind the scenes. Specifications or attributes used as a basis for measurement. Communication which is Clear, Concise, Concrete, Correct, Coherent, Complete, Courteous. Involves eight stages: problem finding, fact finding, defining the problem, idea finding, selecting and evaluating, planning, selling the idea, and acting. These steps create a cycle of problem finding and solving that should continually be improved to enable the efficient functioning of the company concerned. Helps the business decision maker understand complex problems so that he/she can start the actual problemsolving process. Four stages help to uncover more details about what is creating the problem, and what actions will improve the situation or solve the problem. Levels of behaviour or performance set for quality assessment. Strengths, Weaknesses, Opportunities, Threats. Used to assess performance and the characteristics of an organisation.
16
17
Team dynamics
Team identity
Tempo of your speech Tenacity Thinking style Time management Toxic leader
Tone of voice
Mistakes in vocabulary and grammar. Making the message difficult to understand. A group of people with a full set of complementary skills required to complete a task, job or project. Work together to achieve the common goals. Team interaction and relationships. All team members bring their own unique talents, perspectives, values and experiences to the work of the team. The better all team members know each other as to their talents and expertise, the better they can utilise each relevant talent for better team performance. All teams have an identity of their own. This identity stems from the interrelationship with the larger organisational culture, the purpose of the team, the personalities of the various team members and what they each bring to the team. Each team has a specific role to play according to its short-term or long-term purpose. The speed of your speech. Could be too fast and no-one can catch what you are saying, or too slow and listeners get bored. Sticking firmly to ones goals, carrying on and not giving up. Information/situations assessed objectively or based on criteria or principles. Assessing how long something takes realistically, planning appropriately to be punctual and to do everything on time. Someone who abuses the leaderfollower relationship by leaving the group or organisation in a worse-off condition than when he/she joined it. They take out as much money as possible; they fire and hire the wrong people, make decisions that harm the company. They usually also quickly resign at one point, just before they would be fired or arrested, or just before the company goes into liquidation. Communicates to others what one truly wants to say. We can use a soft tone of voice or a hard/unfriendly tone of voice. Characteristics, something inherent to a person. Written records of achievements, documents proving experience and achievements. Activities that are linked to short-term actions needed actions that are needed immediately. Communicating with words (can be spoken = oral communication or written communication). Mobilise people toward a shared vision. They are seldom practical or hands-on. They are highly enthusiastic about new ideas and innovations. They expect others to become as enthusiastic about these ideas which they then are expected to implement.
1.1 Introduction
Whether at we are at university, home, work or among friends, we do not live in isolation. The way we behave is a reflection of the way we think of ourselves, of others, about circumstances and situations. We often act and react in a specific manner, not always conscious of the consequences of our behaviour. In order to become a valued member of society, a responsible adult, we are expected to take on responsibilities in our lives, to be aware of how we act and react in different environments; how our actions impact on direct and indirect relationships; our decision-making processes and skills; 19
18
and how to make ourselves marketable for both private and business environments. This necessitates an honest look at how you appear, act and manage yourself and your relationship with others. Do you know your strengths and weaknesses? Do you know how to communicate effectively via verbal and non-verbal means and consciously use body language? Are your interpersonal skills effective when working with others? How good is your time management? Are you trustworthy, reliable? Have you developed your emotional intelligence? How do you actually judge such strengths and weaknesses - do you rely on your own perceptions or are they based on feedback from others? Have these strengths and weaknesses changed since you left high school and started your tertiary studies? This unit will help you to assess yourself in an unbiased manner, taking stock of where you are now regarding your personal and professional development and where you should be - to become a highly sought-after individual within your chosen career field.
http://www.humanmetrics.comi/cgi-win/JTypes2.asp Self-Control Questionnaire, available from Cybernetics at http://www.e-trainme.com/questionnaire2.html Different learning styles, available at http://www.engr.ncsu.edu/learningstyles/ilsweb.html http://www.vark-learn.com/english/page.asp?p=questionnaire. All of these are cost-free. Some sites need you to log on and pay for information. According to Prof Richard M. Felder, there are active and reflective learners; sensing and intuitive learners; visual and verbal learners; sequential and global learners.
http://www4.ncsu.edu/unity/lockers/users/f/felder/public/ILSdir/ styles.htm
Depending on your personality type and learning style, you may find university or college a challenge, where there is too little visual stimulation, no chance to move around during class, or too sequential an approach for you to take all material in. Therefore, finding out what works best for you while learning as a student is important. Your personality style will also influence how you approach problems or challenges in life, and may even influence your final career choice and how you perform in such a career.
Read the table below and check again which personality styles you recognise as your own. We all sometimes show signs of more than one style, depending on the circumstances we find ourselves in, the stress we may be under, and the mood we wake up in. However, you will find that you more often think or act in a specific way. Check in this table which style describes you better by checking the part that describes how such person acts/thinks.
Colour code your notes; keep visual reminders/pictures. Write summaries in your own words; explain text to others. Take time to do things in a logical order; relate information to other topics. First skim through all text, then move to individual units/parts. Find more information on the Internet on how you can correct limitations in a specific learning style.
Style
Active Reflective Sensing Intuitive Visual Verbal Sequential Global
Acts/Thinks
Lets try and see if it works; lets work it out together in a group. Let me think about it; Ill work it out on my own. I look for facts and figures, proven methods, repetition; I am patient. I look for possibilities, innovation, fast solutions; I make a plan. I remember what I see/pictures. I remember what I read or hear. I understand things if they happen in linear steps; logical steps to get to solutions. I absorb information randomly; I can solve complex problems once I understand/get the big picture.
Every style has some inherent strengths but also some inherent challenges. Remember, there are solutions to challenges, steps to take to cope with negative impacts. So while a certain style may sound very positive, particularly if we are comfortable with such style, there are those challenges. For example, somebody who is patient and uses lots of facts and figures before making a decision may be far too slow for situations where instant decisions have to be taken and no facts and figures are available. Somebody who best learns via pictures/visuals may be faced at college or university (or work) with written text only, or worse, only spoken words by the lecturer/manager. How do such people then cope and learn? Every problem also has a solution available. You can hardly change your personality or learning style, yet there are strategies to manage the challenges that these present. How can you compensate for potential challenges occurring with each learning style? Look at the table below and see possible solutions.
Style
Active Reflective Sensing Intuitive
Possible solution
Try to think twice before you act to avoid potential trouble. Do not spend too much time reflecting; you also need to get things done. Set deadlines. Accept that facts and figures are not always available. Learn to improvise. Studying and work contain memorisation and routine as well; check for careless mistakes.
Employability also assumes that the prospective employer will see further positive potential for development and promotion/career enhancement in such potential employee. Besides the obvious and less obvious skills, employers will also be looking for employees who are willing to work (hard and smart), have the ability to do the job and fit into the company s culture, rules and regulations. They must also show their willingness to stay at this place of work for longer than just a few months. What are the interpersonal relationship demands and expectations required by potential employers? Work through each of these basic competencies which you should be able to demonstrate/achieve for optimum employability.
22
23
1.4.1 Punctuality
Whether it is a question of being punctual for university class, arriving at work or being on time for a family function, punctuality is a sign that you respect the other person and his/her time. Wasted time - through meetings starting late, topic items having to be repeated, or food becoming spoilt at home - costs the economy money, angers the aggrieved party, and shows him/her that you do not have respect or concern for others, that you only care for yourself. There can be valid and serious reasons for being late - once - but there are people who believe that it is their right to arrive whenever it suits them. The penalty? You will no longer be trusted or taken seriously, and you may miss out on important matters that get decided without you and could impact negatively on you. You will not be chosen for any task that demands punctuality or trustworthiness, and this could cost you future promotions where such trust and punctuality are essential.
1.4.4 Honesty
Lies need a good memory and continuous innovation of further lies - sooner or later, they will come out as lies. Honesty is essential in any professional environment, in every work place and in personal relationships. Why would you regard it as necessary to tell lies in the first place - would it not have been easier to be honest? What is going to happen when the truth comes out at a later stage? Are you proud of yourself that you got away with lies, with dishonesty? Do you believe that this is not serious, as it was not a real crime? Honesty obviously includes that you will never take anything that belongs to others - taking business items home is theft, no matter how small the monetary amount. You also do not illegally copy information, programs, data, music or other students work. If you get used to small lies or the odd act of dishonesty, you will get used to a dishonest mindset which can lead to proper criminal action in future.
1.4.2 Reliability
In line with punctuality, a lack of reliability can cost you future promotions and trust. If you have been asked to complete a task and you do not complete this in the specified manner and time, you will be labelled unreliable and therefore not suitable for important tasks or jobs. Ask yourself how you feel about other students, friends or family members if they let you down, or do not help you when they promised. This is exactly how others feel about you if you are unreliable. They no longer trust you. Can a team rely on you to be there for them when you have promised? Are you a team player or are your selfish interests more important? Are you sometimes reliable but not consistently so?
1.4.5 Politeness/courtesy
Politeness and courtesy are signs of good upbringing. It proves that you respect others, be they superiors at work, lecturers and staff at college/ university, older people, and people in positions of trust/respect/leadership. By practising polite behaviour towards everybody you deal with - even family members and close friends - you turn into a polite/courteous person. It also shows a good level of confidence and self-respect. You will also find that politeness is reciprocated.
1.4.6 Respect
Very closely linked to politeness, respect goes beyond your show of courtesy towards others. It implies that you recognise somebody elses achievements, position in society and his/her constitutional right to respect. As we already explained regarding rights and responsibilities, your boundaries stop where other peoples boundaries start, and you have to respect such boundaries. Over-stepping physical boundaries includes getting too close to somebody (without being asked to do so), touching without permission, or breaking emotional boundaries with bullying, harassing or threatening actions. It also includes creating excessive noise levels, smoking where it is not allowed, and infringing rights to privacy. If you want others to respect you and your rights, you have to start by showing others that you respect their rights. 25
1.4.3 Trustworthiness
Trust can be earned by being reliable and punctual. It can also be earned through your actions - beyond your words. If you are requested to keep confidential information to yourself, can you be trusted to keep this information to yourself? Or do you use this information to spread gossip and rumours, and actually damage the other person or the company/institution through your action? Would others typically describe you as trustworthy, maybe even in preference to others?
24
This means that respect goes back to basic human rights. It then also includes respect for achievements, for age and for positions. You will want to be respected once you achieve certain results in your studies and in your career. Show it to those who have already achieved these results.
1.4.7 Self-discipline
One of the basic character traits that can lead to success in life is selfdiscipline. It assumes that you know what is expected of you. If you set yourself goals (or accept goals set by others for you and make them your own), you make sure that you achieve those goals or what is expected of you, without having to be reminded to do so, without having to be told. You plan your time and your efforts, and do not leave tasks incomplete. Self-discipline also includes controlling your emotions, whether it is anger, frustration or disagreement with instructions by others, parents or managers. You have to know when and how you are allowed to speak, react and act, and when/how not. Self-discipline means that you take control of your actions, reactions and emotions, and go towards a clear outcome. It also means that you know how to keep private life and working life separate. You do not arrange your private life during class at college/ university or work, nor do you bring work home to the dinner table (except if asked to!). Private life has to stay at home and has no place at work. Are you self-disciplined enough to keep your cellphone in your bag/pack?
1.4.8 Tidiness
People often regard tidiness as something that is not necessary in their lives. They either delegate it to somebody else, or live and work in organised chaos. They claim that they know where everything is. However, while this may still be tolerated as a sign of rebellious youth while you are a student, it is regarded as a sign of an immature and unprofessional person once you are entering the working environment. Lack of tidiness can cause accidents, loss of important documents or items, and perils such as fire or spillages; it can be the cause of lost business opportunities. Many a laptop has been destroyed by spilled liquid; many sensitive documents have landed in a dustbin or worse have been handed out together with other paperwork. In a working environment, files need to be found instantly upon request. Tidiness even applies to electronic data has it been stored in an efficient manner so that it can be found instantly, if needed? 26
27
28
29
The more people get used to such casual communication levels, the less skilled they become in formal business communication. The general trend is that business writing skills are seriously lacking among new employees. New employees then come up against old generation expectations of perfect grammar and spelling by management and clients. They all expect knowledge of formal business writing as well as perfect manners/etiquette, dress sense and behaviour in business meetings and client meetings, and in the total business environment. There are rules to be followed. Some businesses allow casual wear, chewing of gum, casual address of superiors - others have strict rules against such practices. Every employee who wants to enjoy a successful career will have to make doubly sure that he/ she knows and adheres to all rules in the business that he/she has joined. Do you know how to write the perfect formal business letter or document, are you able to hold a professional business conversation on the telephone, and can you address clients and superiors in person in the proper manner, using appropriate verbal and non-verbal communication?
Competency
1.3.5 Polite/Courteous 1.3.6 Respectful 1.3.7 Self-disciplined 1.3.8 Tidy 1.3.9 Organised/able to plan 1.3.10 Good time management 1.3.11 Committed/tenacious 1.3.12 Resourceful 1.3.13 Looking for continuous self-improvement 1.3.14 Willing to learn all skills needed for your planned career 1.3.15 Able to communicate clearly and professionally in (business) writing, telephonically and in person
Competency
1.3.1 Punctual 1.3.2 Reliable 1.3.3 Trustworthy 1.3.4 Honest
30
31
1.7 Conclusion
In this unit we covered various methods to assess your own current state and performance, such as attitude and behaviour. We also looked at the gaps between where you are and where you should be. We concluded this unit with your self-assessment and action plans. After having worked through this unit, you should now have a clear picture of your current situation regarding personality traits, learning styles, employability and readiness for employment. You have also identified gaps between where you are and where you should ideally be.
Students should do the following self-assessment: In two sentences, please state and describe your personality and learning style. Please also state how you can compensate for any challenges in these styles (see and ). In two sentences, please state where you fall short on expected/demanded/ ideal behaviour and attitudes. In two sentences, now please state how you plan to correct this gap in behaviour or attitudes. What do you plan to do so that you improve your employability or professional behaviour? By when do you plan to have achieved this corrective action? And how will you measure this achievement
32
33
2.1 Introduction
In the previous unit, we covered various personality and learning style tests, which you completed online. We looked at personal character traits and competencies which have a strong influence on whether a person will be employed, will be allowed to stay employed, and will be considered for promotion and career advancement. We concluded the previous unit with assessments of your current competencies. You are now learning to look at yourself more critically, assessing how others could possibly see you, judge you and form opinions of you, either as a mature, responsible and professional person who is ready to be employed and who promises to have a great career ahead of him/her, or as somebody to avoid having in their team. If you are a student of this course, you must want to develop yourself. In this unit, we take the next step in your self-assessment, including professionalism. We will also look at methods to measure where you are now, how to design a development plan and how to measure your progress. As a CV and the job interview often form the gateway to your new employment, we will study some documents which will form part of your portfolio.
34
35
Self-assessment or self-reflection is no exception. The self-reflection that self-assessment requires can be more difficult than any other task because it needs total honesty. The person undertaking such assessment has to try to avoid bias. In the same way that a marketing executive has to regularly conduct a SWOT analysis (Strengths, Weaknesses, Opportunities, Threats) on his/ her brand, so you have to conduct a SWOT analysis on yourself - you are the brand! You have to be extremely honest with yourself, and keep in mind that the more honest you are at the assessment or reflection stage, the closer you will move toward your goal. If you pretend/lie to yourself, the outcomes will be distorted and you waste whatever effort you then put into the further programme. The same honesty has to be applied throughout, from assessment to the monitoring stages, to check whether you are progressing or not. The reward comes when you see that you are achieving successes - and ultimately when a potential employer finds you highly employable and professional, and hires you - you are then on your way to a successful career.
36
37
At the same time, remember that you have to be ready, truly employable and professional by the time you graduate and want to enter the job market - so the sooner you are on track with your desired results, the better. Develop an action plan. Take each one of the areas that need improvement and then write a list of what practical steps you will take to address those issues. This will show that you not only recognise your problems and have analysed them, but that you are capable of finding solutions to each of these challenges. Do not be overly ambitious; rather set realistic targets and achievable dates. Brainstorm with peers, class mates, friends and family if you need suggestions. Do this for every weak area where you lack a skill or competency. Set a time line for each of these. Some will be easier to fix and should thus take less time. Others may be more significant and may take up to a year to turn around. Very strongly entrenched habits can be changed within 21 days as long as you are committed to such change for every one of those 21 days. At the end of those three weeks, your habit should normally have changed - as long as you were consistent and adhered to the change plan. Once youve completed your assessment, stated your problem areas and set your short-term and medium-term goals, review the process and sleep on it. The next day, go through everything you wrote again with a fresh perspective, and make adjustments or changes where necessary. Then finalise your draft development programme. Use the grid provided below to help you draw up your own draft development programme. How to Write an Effective and Powerful Self-Evaluation for a Performance Review | eHow.com http://www.ehow.com/ how_2181299_effective-powerful-selfevaluationperformance-review.html#ixzz27tdCkLA9
Self-assessment table
Attribute/Trait Possess very strongly Possess somewhat Possess a little Lack a little Lack somewhat Lack very strongly
Punctual
Reliable
Trustworthy
Honest
Polite/courteous
Respectful
Self-disciplined
Tidy
Organised/able to plan
Resourceful
Looks for continuous self-improvement Looks to learn all skills for planned career Communicates clearly in business writing Communicates clearly telephonically Communicates clearly in person Ethical, top integrity
Professional
38
39
Attribute/Trait
Possess somewhat
Possess a little
Lack a little
Lack somewhat
so that you are understood the way you intend, you need to develop an action plan and set target dates for achieving this action plan.
Good manners
Emotionally mature
Good self-control
Self-disciplined
Driven to succeed
Confident/self-assured
40
41
most serious problems first, those that may take the longest to fix. Or you might rather want to progress from minor to more important changes/goals. So that it becomes clearer and easier to manage, break the list of problem areas into sections that go together, e.g. honesty, trustworthiness, reliability and integrity can go together. Then consider the main change goal for each. You may have identified some self-defeating, conflicting habits you want to change. See which aspects can form logical groups that you could see as a working unit, something you will tackle together as one. You then set up two main sections with related subheadings in each. Choose the best, most logical grouping that works for your purposes. You will measure your progress towards such goals over the next few months. To conclude, reflect on why reaching the goals you have listed is important to you.
learn and apply what they are shown and expected to do understand their responsibilities understand the limitations to their rights fit into the corporate culture understand and adhere to the companys dress code understand hygiene in the workplace show good manners (demonstrate correct behaviour at all times, do not shout, respect other peoples space and dignity, and treat them with respect) become capable team workers become efficient, self-motivated individuals. Characteristics of the ideal/model employee: arrives at work on time every day leaves a few minutes later than closing time (not a clock watcher) is prepared to handle extra tasks beyond the strict job description agrees to work overtime when needed without expecting extra pay all the time willingly helps others if asked to do so (also offers help without neglecting his/her own tasks) is pleasant and respectful in all dealings with superiors and equally so with colleagues, customers and suppliers gets through all tasks that are expected of him/her in the set time does not expect a promotion or an increase after having been with the company for only a few months.
2.4 Evaluation of own development needs and the activities to meet them
The previous section dealt with the necessary personal improvements with regard to bad habits, unacceptable personality traits and a lack of some essential behavioural competencies. In this section, we will focus on professional or business skills that need to be acquired to make you truly employable.
Ordinary hours of work and days of work Wage or the rate and method of calculating such wage Rate for overtime work Any other cash payments Any payment in kind and the value thereof Frequency of remuneration Any deductions Leave entitlement Period of notice or period of contract Description of any council or sectoral determination which covers the employers business Period of employment with a previous employer that counts towards the period of employment List of any other documents that form part of the contract, indicating a place where a copy of each may be obtained. Particulars must be revised if the terms of employment change. A statement of employees rights must be displayed at the workplace in the official languages used at the workplace. There is a tendency among many companies to hire staff on fixed term contracts (e.g. six months) instead of the previous norm of permanent employment. Permanent employment contracts usually had a three months trial period attached to them, during which time the employer and employee could both consider whether they were suitable for each other, and whether the new employee fitted in with the culture of the organisation. If not, the employment would be terminated after the three months. The fixed term contract is more complicated in that the contractee (the person being hired for the work) has to receive a new fixed term contract after every completed six-month period. This does not allow for a sense of true belonging, loyalty towards the company or a sense of security. It also gives the company freedom to change employees without lengthy and protracted dismissal procedures. It does give the employee the chance to remain mobile, finding new projects or companies to work for, but this is at the cost of continuity and job security. It is up to the incumbent employees to make sure that they read their employment contract in all its detail, and to get professional assistance 45
Section 83A of the Act defines who is an employee. An employee is a person who works for, or provides services to, another person if: his or her manner or hours of work are subject to control or direction he/she forms part of the employers organisation he/she has worked for the other person for at least 40 hours per month over the previous three months he/she is economically dependent on the other person he/she is provided with his or her tools or work equipment he/she only works for, or renders service to, one person. If one of these factors is present, the person is presumed to be an employee until the employer proves that he/she is not.
to check the contract before they sign and bind themselves to it. Rights and responsibilities will be spelled out in this contract but there may be additional documents such as job descriptions or duty sheets to explain the job content. New employees should make sure they receive a copy of the signed contract for their records and reference.
An employee who ordinarily works on a Sunday must be paid at times the normal wage. Paid time off in return for working on a Sunday may be agreed upon. Employees who work at night between 18:00 and 06:00 must be compensated by payment of an allowance or by a reduction of working hours. Employees who work regularly after 23:00 and before 06:00 the next day must be informed of (a) any health and safety hazards, and (b) the right to undergo a medical examination. Employees must be paid their ordinary pay for any public holiday that falls on a working day. Work on a public holiday is by agreement and paid at double the rate. A public holiday may be exchanged for another day by agreement.
Unpaid leave is usually granted at the discretion of the company after annual leave credit has been exhausted. Sick leave is calculated over a three-year period. According to the BCEA, an employee is entitled to six weeks paid sick leave in a period of 36 months. During the first six months, an employee is entitled to one days paid sick leave for every 26 days worked. An employer may require a medical certificate before paying an employee who is absent for more than two consecutive days or who is frequently absent. A pregnant employee is entitled to four consecutive months maternity leave.
2.5.5 Induction
Most established companies give new employees an induction manual and also offer an induction day/tour to introduce the new staff member to colleagues, explaining the way the business is run, where to find everything, and what the rules are that need to be adhered to. If no induction takes place, the new staff member would need to consult his/her supervisor and colleagues. Expectations from management will be that every employee will be aware of all rules and will adhere to them.
48
constructive, i.e. that the employee was unfairly forced to resign, or the actual dismissal was unfair or discriminatory. A contract of employment may be terminated on notice of not less than (a) one week, if the employee has been employed for six months or less; (b) two weeks, if the employee has been employed for more than six months but not more than one year; (c) four weeks, if the employee has been employed for one year or more. Notice must be given in writing. The notice on termination of employment by an employer in terms of the Act does not prevent the employee challenging the fairness or lawfulness of the dismissal in terms of the Labour Relations Act, 1995 or any other law. On termination of employment, an employee is entitled to a certificate of service. Apart from the formal contract between employer and employee, there is also an informal understanding between the two parties. The informal understanding, closely linked to mutual expectations, can be a source of disappointment or of security and job satisfaction.
A psychological contract can be defined as an informal exchange agreement between an employer and its employee, which specifies mutual expectations in terms of the way in which the employer treats the employer and the employees output and contribution to the organisation.
You are also expected to show an awareness and understanding of appropriate business etiquette/manners and behaviour in different circumstances and cultures. This requires the right attitude and sound judgement. Groups of professions, such as medical doctors, lawyers, auditors, researchers and engineers, subscribe to a professional code of conduct that guides their professional conduct. Employers expect their management and staff to be professional in all their dealings. Not only does professionalism aid in productivity, efficiency and a better working climate, it also enhances the companys image, particularly when clients and suppliers are dealt with in a professional manner. The challenge is that new employees - and often even those who have already worked for a company for quite some time - do not know or understand all the rules and what it means to be professional. Western customs and cultures are not the same as those in Eastern countries or those in Africa - etiquette is a learned behaviour that has to be appropriate to its environment. This starts with table manners, the way we talk to each other, greet each other and follow proper business etiquette/rules. However, integrity, ethical behaviour, courtesy and respect should be ingrained in everybody, especially in those who want to succeed in life and in their chosen career.
2.6.1 Activity: list all the attributes that you believe show professionalism
Discuss your list with your fellow students. Did you all include the same attributes? Are there any attributes which led to discussion/conflict/disagreement?
51
Competent business writing and email communication Appropriate dress/grooming Refer back to Activities and - did you include these attributes in your own list of what you regard as professional behaviour, and what you believe you have already mastered? Which attributes of the above list have you not included? Do you possess these skills? Remember, we do not live in isolation. The way we behave is a reflection of the way we think of ourselves and others, and how we judge circumstances and situations. Often, we become used to acting and reacting in a specific manner, not always conscious of the consequences of our behaviour. Being professional requires us to adapt our behaviour to develop our competencies continuously.
There will be a monthly review in class to compare progress made against the planned steps and commitments you had made. Some steps will be easy to measure (e.g. how often have you been late or punctual, and have you completed tasks on time?), while others will be difficult to assess by yourself - you need others to confirm whether you have improved, e.g. are more polite, do not shout, and act professionally at all times. Particular emphasis will be placed on those dates that you set at the outset, by when you wanted to have finally achieved the particular improvements. If you set these dates too far in the future, your challenge will be that the change may come too late to have any impact on your intended improved employability. You may already have had some job interviews - and not made a wonderful impression. Your gaps may have had a negative impact on your final years at college or university if you were not yet truly professional in your behaviour. So, set your personal goal dates reasonably soon, and be realistic yet ambitious. Then check on your progress so that you can see if you need to speed up your personal development or if you are ahead of your goal. Review dates will help you in this assessment.
2.7.4 Responsibilities
As a responsible adult, we are expected to: be responsible for all our actions be aware of how we act and react in different environments be aware of how our actions impact on direct and indirect relationships have learned our decision-making processes and skills know how to make ourselves marketable for both private and business environments. You are responsible for achieving your goals, and remaining committed to closing the gaps between current undesirable behaviour and improved employability and professionalism. The same applies to what you make of your studies, your career and your life. Your personal goals will obviously be influenced by what you decide you want to become - as long as you keep in mind what your potential employers will be looking for. Remember the tough economic environment and the fact that you are competing against global competitors for your potential job! It is your personal responsibility to make yourself as marketable as possible. Besides improving your personal and professional or business skills, you have to network with people who may help you to build these skills. Both direct and indirect relationships will influence your life, and they may test your personal and professional behaviours.
54
55
What are the skills needed in effective decision making? The following steps help to make effective decisions: List the options open to you. For each option, list the potential positive outcome if you were to select this option - the best that could happen. Then list the potential drawbacks or negative consequences of selecting this option - the worst that could happen. Now compare the positive outcomes of these options with each other - which sound more convincing? Which come closer to what you are really looking or hoping for? How realistic are these positive outcomes? Then compare the negative consequences of these options with each other - which of them will potentially cause more serious consequences? How realistic are these negative consequences? At this stage, you should be able to make your decision based on the results of your comparison and which of your options may have fewer potential negative consequences and more realistic positive consequences. Once you have made your decision, commit to it - do not leave a back door open! People who are undecided, who jump from one decision to another, or who do not see things through to their conclusion will never know whether the first decision would not have been the better one, after all. Indecisiveness is a negative reflection on a persons character as it implies that the person lacks decision-making skills.
2.8 Completing a cv and forms needed in the work place and job interview
An effective curriculum vitae (CV) accompanies you all your life and should be kept up-to-date. New achievements (e.g. Matric, drivers licence, degree/ diploma, extra courses, working experience, new skills) need to be added, as well as new contact details and new references. A CV is more comprehensive than a resum, which is more commonly used in the USA and is a shortened version of a CV. Please consult examples on websites, such as the site given below. A complete and up-to-date CV, together with a tailor-made cover letter written for the specific job and the specific company you want to work for, can open many doors. A CV that is full of spelling and grammatical errors, is incomplete, has not been updated, and does not contain contact details will not go beyond the first level screening process. The trend is also to have a CV no longer than three pages. Work experience and qualifications must therefore be given priority in your compiling of a CV. A curriculum vitae typically includes the following: Name Date of birth Nationality Identity number Home address Postal address Telephone number Cellphone number Fax number Email address Drivers licence Languages able to speak/read/write Work experience Qualifications Education Leadership positions References 57
56
Download three different CV templates from the Internet. Select the one that you feel is the most appropriate for your needs. Complete it to the best of your ability. Check all your facts. Now write a cover letter that accompanies your CV. You are applying for a job at Microsoft. Specify what job it is you are applying for at the company. State why you should be chosen for the vacancy. Spell check and grammar check your work. Discuss your drafts with your lecturer.
58
Have all the relevant documents (including your up-to-date CV, transcripts and portfolio) put together neatly in a folder which you leave behind after the interview (do not leave any originals behind) Arrive there early Be appropriately dressed for the job Be confident but not too assertive Listen to the person interviewing you and answer appropriately Be conscious of your own language and body language Apply what you have learned about employability and professionalism Ask questions about the company, the job, what it entails, working hours, the work place, who the team consists of and who it reports to Be careful that you do not come across as being only money-orientated, a clock watcher or argumentative Show energy and enthusiasm for the job and the company, and a career there.
2.12 Conclusion
In this unit, we covered various methods to assess and monitor own performance, such as attitude, behaviour, goal setting and achievements, communication skills, time management, and a number of other essential personal and professional skills. We also looked at completing a CV, your transcripts and your portfolio. We concluded this unit with the job interview.
Answer the following questions by giving full explanations: State what a potential employer will expect of you - give the 10 most important attributes. Define professionalism in business. Which professional attributes do you possess and which do you need to develop? What do you need to remember when going for a job interview? What must be included in your CV? What are transcripts? How must you keep them and what must you do with them? Define what a portfolio consists of. Do you have a portfolio? What does your portfolio include?
60
61
3.1 Introduction
In the previous unit, we covered how to assess yourself and compare that image with how others could possibly see you, judge you and form their opinions of you. This image could be that of a mature, responsible, professional person who is ready to be employed and promises to have a great career. Or it could be that of a person whom employers and other people around you would avoid having in their team. We covered professionalism, how it is defined and achieved, how to complete a CV, how to prepare for a job interview, and how to keep transcripts and a portfolio. In this unit, we will examine appropriate communication in detail, as well as good time management. We will conclude with a progress review of your personal and professional goals for improvement. Communication starts very soon after birth, when a baby cries to indicate hunger, discomfort or pain. Later on as children and adults, we communicate with others around us. Telephones, cellphones, letters and all electronic media allow us to communicate across the globe, sometimes in an instant. This ease of communication has its own challenges. This unit will show the student how to communicate more effectively in different circumstances, with various audiences and target groups. We will also analyse good time management, an important contributor to an all-round, professional image and better performance. Proven time management skills - and good communication - make a graduate more employable.
Communication requires a sender, a message and a recipient. The receiver need not be present or aware of the senders intent to communicate at the time of communication. Communication can occur across vast distances in time and space. The communication process is only complete once the receiver has received and understood the message of the sender. Communication is the flow or exchange of information among people or groups of people. Some communication has its own momentum, e.g. the 63
62
so-called grapevine where rumours, gossip, truth mixed with half-truths, facts or news that was supposed to be formally announced at a later stage has already spread throughout the company or among friends. It is part of informal communication. Besides communication through the use of words (verbal), non-verbal communication exists in the form of body language, eye contact, sign language, pictures, graphics, sound and writing. Tyler, Kossen & Ryan sum communication up as the process of information exchange by and among people (2005: 9). The South African Constitution also includes communication to/with people with disabilities (the display of text, Braille, tactile communication, large print, accessible multimedia, etc.).
(including various art forms) progressed to other surfaces, materials and structures, e.g. to primitive writing on papyrus, clay, wax and paper. Originally, tribes and other groups of people developed their own basic types of languages and alphabets or picture forms to communicate their messages, but the introduction of the Roman alphabet served as the foundation of most modern Western languages. Once the printing press was invented, it was easier and quicker to communicate with thousands of people at a time, instead of the handmade, hand-written and individually drawn/coloured copies of books. Centuries later, communication exploded, when the printed messages were first complemented by simpler electronic media, such as the radio, telex, fax, telephone and television in modern societies. These were later partially replaced by computers, laptops, tablets, cellphones, Skype, etc. Literally millions of people in South Africa do not write letters anymore; they use tools such as SMS, BBM, MMS and email. There is a risk of potential misunderstanding with any communication. The most carefully worded sentence, speech and presentation can be misinterpreted by somebody who has a different agenda, viewpoint, bias, cultural upbringing or language skills. While we assume that careful formulation of questions and answers, paraphrasing, examples and stories make communication clearer and easier, this is no guarantee that the message actually will be understood. To make sure that your written communication has been understood in the way you intended, you should follow it up with a phone call, especially if the written communication was very important. Even with electronic media, we cannot assume that the email was delivered/read, that it was understood in the way it was intended, and that it will elicit the desired effect/action as we are not present when it is received. This is problematic because we cannot explain ourselves, and add meaning with gestures, facial expressions or body language. There are various methods to make sure that both parties in a conversation understand each other, e.g. paraphrasing or asking the other person to repeat in their own words what was said.
65
Sender
Encoding
Message Media
Decoding
Receiver
NOISE
Feedback
Response
3.3.2 Structure
Communication problems can emerge in organisations (business, government or educational institutions) when the reporting structures are undefined, vague, duplicated or non-existent. Communication can, therefore, then also not follow any efficient path. Such problems can be overcome by setting up a proper organogram (a graph showing all people in management and their positions/roles in the company) that clearly outlines channels of communication.
66
67
Organisational noise, where poor communication can prevent accurate interpretation Cultural noise, where misunderstandings stereotypical assumptions can cause
Psychological noise, where prejudices and attitudes can also make communication difficult
69
70
First impressions last! Others base their opinion about you on your appearance, your body language, your demeanour, your mannerisms and how you are dressed. Every time you meet somebody new, or even when you see other acquaintances again, they check you out and form an impression of you. First impressions are lasting and very seldom change, making them extremely important. If the people you meet are important to your future success in business or in your private life, then work hard at creating a good first impression. In Unit 1, we discussed a whole range of attributes you should already possess, such as being punctual, polite and honest. Effective communication, which will lead to your being employable and professional, needs you to master all those skills. Which skills aid effective communication? What do you need to do to communicate well? Be on time or punctual to create a good impression. Be yourself, at ease. If you are feeling uncomfortable and on edge, it may also make the other person uncomfortable. To communicate a proper message, you need to come across as calm, confident and professional.
For business and social meetings, appropriate dress also varies between countries and cultures. A clean and tidy appearance is appropriate for all business and social occasions - a good haircut or shave, and no punk hairstyle except if you are applying for a DJ job. Clean and tidy clothes are essential. Neat and tidy make up too; nothing too heavy. Ladies must be aware that there are differences between evening make up and office style. Make sure your grooming is appropriate and helps to make you feel you can belong. Appropriate dressing and grooming make you feel more confident and relaxed, communicate a professional image and create a good first impression. You do not need to sacrifice your individuality but you should retain that for your private life. In any business setting, wear appropriate business attire, e.g. for a formal company evening social event, wear appropriate evening attire.
resort - but stay clear of discussions about politics, religion, racial issues or prejudices. Have a look around his/her office. Do you see any photos of him/her being involved in a hobby that you also have; do you have something in common with the person you are meeting? If so, this can be a great way to start the conversation and keep it flowing.
companys official templates, even when communicating with a close friend inside the company.
aids can communicate important information much quicker and easier than text.
Companys indicates possession. (Example: The companys trucks had not been maintained properly.) Companies is plural. (Example: The companies in this industry are suffering.) Learn more about commonly misused words, misused apostrophes and other grammatical errors. Many people rush through their documents, but this is how you miss mistakes. Be aware that the automatic spell checker may insert the wrong word, synonym or spelling. Proofread your headings and subheadings, and not just the text. Read the document out loud which forces you to go more slowly, so that you are more likely to notice mistakes. Proofread one sentence at a time, working your way from the end to the beginning. This helps you focus on errors, not on content. The more you write, the more effectively you will write! (http://www.MindTools.com)
77
Subtle and less subtle gestures, facial expressions and shifts in our whole bodies indicate what we really feel. The way we talk, walk, sit and stand all say something about us, the way we feel, and what we really mean and would like to express. However, when reading other peoples body language, do not over-react to some signals you believe are there - some body movements may be habit, or caused by physical problems/discomfort and may have nothing to do with the alternative signal. Being able to read body language and understanding what it means allows you to read people more easily. This puts you in a better position to communicate effectively with them. By increasing your understanding of others, you can also become more aware of the messages that you convey to them. Often we say one thing yet our body language reveals something different. This sends mixed messages to other people. What do we really mean to say? For example, if a person is communicating to you calmly, but the posture of his body and the position of his hands indicate that he is tense, you could reply in a calming way to try to put him at ease. When verbal and non-verbal communication is contradictory, the recipient of the message, i.e. the listener, is prone to believe the non-verbal message rather than the spoken words.
3.7.3 Defensiveness
Think of a time in a meeting when the other person was defensive and did not really listen. You ideally wanted him/her to be open and receptive to what you had to say. Some of the common signs that the person you are speaking with may be feeling defensive include: Hand/arm gestures are small and close to his or her body. Facial expressions are minimal. Body is physically turned away from you. Arms are crossed in front of his or her body. Eyes maintain little contact, or are downcast. By picking up these signs, you can change what you say or how you say it to help the other person become more at ease and more receptive to what you are saying. You can also monitor your own body language to ensure that your messages say that you are open and receptive to what is being discussed. Some signs and signals that people are not listening to you and are not really interested in your message include: Heads are down. Eyes are glazed or closing, or staring at something else. Hands may be picking at clothes, or fiddling with pens. People may be writing or doodling. (Note, however, that some researchers suggest that this can help people concentrate more effectively.) They may be sitting slumped in their chairs. Sitting at a computer/with a cellphone, not stopping yet attempting to listen. When someone appears not to be engaged in what is going on, you can ask them a direct question. Or perhaps arrange another more convenient time to talk to them, when they are ready to listen to you.
3.7.2 Confidence
You can identify some common signs and signals that give away whether others are feeling confident or not. Typical things to look for in confident people include: Posture standing tall with shoulders back. Eye contact solid with a smiling face. Gestures with hands and arms purposeful and deliberate. Speech slow and clear. Tone of voice moderate to low. You can use this knowledge to convey feelings that you are not actually experiencing but would like to project, e.g. you can use these confidence signs to project confidence.
3.7.4 Lying
Being able to tell whether a person is being untruthful will stand you in good stead in your future life. Some of the typical signs and signals that a person is not honest or not fully truthful include:
78
79
Eyes keep little or no eye contact, or there may be rapid eye movements, with pupils constricted. Note that down cast eyes in certain cultures are a sign of respect. Hand or fingers are in front of his or her mouth when speaking. His or her body is physically turned away from you, or there are unusual/ unnatural body gestures. His or her breathing rate increases. Complexion changes, such as red in the face or neck area. Perspiration increases. Voice changes, such as change in pitch, stammering or throat clearing. Vague and evasive answers to direct questions, or no answer. Over-explaining trivial issues with irrelevant details. Remember that everyones personal body language is slightly different. If you notice some of the typical non-verbal signs of lying, do not jump to conclusions as these signals can be confused with the signals of nervousness. Probe further, ask more questions and explore the area in more detail to determine whether they are being truthful or not.
and just notice how they act and react to each other. Try to guess what they are saying or get a sense of what is going on between them. In that way, you will be developing your observational skills and become a better communicator. Body language impacts a great deal on how we communicate and can reflect quite accurately what is going on inside us. It includes body movements and gestures (legs, arms, hands, head and torso), posture, muscle tension, eye contact, skin colouring (flushed red), and even peoples breathing rate and perspiration. Additionally, the tone of voice, the rate of speech and the pitch of the voice all add to the actual words that are being used, sometimes replacing the spoken word.
81
The impending skills shortages in the ICT sector are a major concern for many high level executives worldwide. The same concerns are being echoed in South Africa, and hopefully thousands of graduates will capitalise on this opportunity. There is a huge demand for software developers and a predicted growth in demand for especially Web developers. Employers also want to see that you can solve a business problem with your skills and that you use communication in the IT field in an appropriate manner. In the IT industry, often the emphasis is so much on one specific toolset over another, especially to minimise cross-training costs, that the real human potential is often ignored in favour of the current, hottest software toolset. When it comes to the candidates performance evaluation, accomplishments form the core of the performance profile. A survey titled: The Smart Workplace of the Future, contemplates a vision of 2030 in which organisations retain core business functions but look and behave like social networks, creating corporate communities that attract employees from a global talent pool. The study is based on insights from the third in a series of workshops that have brought together a diverse group of academics and workplace practitioners. The report predicts that Generation Y will trigger new innovative styles of working and management practices that incorporate social connectivity, increased technology use, automation and advanced software. This technological ingenuity will have a significant impact on job availability stock traders, for example, will be replaced by automated trading systems, thereby decreasing the need for human interaction. Employees will expect technologies to intuitively meet their needs and be seamlessly integrated into the remote work environment. The workplace of 2030 will be a sensory place continuously evolving and responding to experiences by constantly adapting the environment and its infrastructure to suit the individual. Agility will be a key priority for the providers of workplace services and infrastructure, and the smart workplace will take advantage of technological innovation to provide the enhanced communication and connectivity necessary to support these changes (http://www.gartner.com/ technology/ contact/contact.africa.jsp).
82
83
Effective negotiation helps you to resolve situations where your aims conflict with someone elses aims or wants. The aim of win-win negotiation is to find a solution that is acceptable to both parties, and leaves both parties feeling that they have won, in some way. Where you do not expect to deal with people ever again and you do not need their goodwill, then you can be tougher in your negotiations, seeking to win the negotiation round while the other person loses out. This excludes customers and other stakeholders whom you obviously want to retain. Similarly, where there is a great deal at stake in a negotiation, it may be appropriate to prepare in detail to gain advantage. Neither of these approaches is usually much good for resolving disputes with people with whom you have an ongoing relationship. Using tricks and manipulation during a negotiation can undermine trust and damage teamwork. While a manipulative person may not get caught out if negotiation seldom takes place, this is not the case when people work together routinely. Here, honesty and openness are always the best policies. For small disagreements, excessive preparation can be counter-productive because it takes time that is better used elsewhere. If you need to resolve a major disagreement, make sure you prepare thoroughly. Work through the following points before you start negotiating: What do you want to get out of the negotiation? Do you know what the other person wants? What do you and the other person have that you can trade? What are you each comfortable giving away? If you dont reach agreement with the other person, what alternatives do you have? How much does it matter if you do not reach agreement? Does failure to reach an agreement cut you out of future opportunities? And what alternatives might the other person have? What is the history of the relationship? Will there be any hidden issues that may influence the negotiation? How will you handle these? What outcome will people be expecting from this negotiation? What precedents have been set? What are the consequences for you if you win or lose this negotiation? What are the consequences for the other person?
85
Who has what power in the relationship? Who controls resources? Who stands to lose the most if agreement is not reached? What power does the other person have to deliver what you hope for? What possible compromises are there? Both parties should feel positive about the negotiations once they are over. This helps people to keep good working relationships afterwards. Be as detached as possible when discussing your own emotions; discuss them as if they belong to someone else. Focus on the issue at hand, not the person. The negotiation itself is a careful exploration of your position and the other persons position, with the goal of finding a mutually acceptable compromise that gives you both as much of what you want as possible. In an ideal situation, you will find that the other person wants what you are prepared to trade and that you are prepared to give what the other person wants. Both sides should feel comfortable with the final solution if the agreement is to be considered win-win. Fundamentally, good, open communications are needed to conclude win-win negotiations successfully (http://www. mindtools.com/CommSkll/NegotiationSkills.htm).
the basis of self-confidence. Assertiveness builds on self-confidence and provides many other benefits for improving your relationships at work and in other areas of your life as well. In general, assertive people: Get to win-win more easily they see the value in their opponent and in his/her position, and can quickly find common ground. Are better problem solvers they feel empowered to do whatever it takes to find the best solution. Are less stressed they know they have personal power and they dont feel threatened or victimised when things dont go as planned or expected. Are doers they get things done because they know they can. When you act assertively, you act fairly and with empathy. You are selfassured and do not intimidate, manipulate or bully. When you treat others with such fairness and respect, it is usually reciprocated. You are well liked, and people see you as a leader and someone they want to work with. If you are either more passive or aggressive, you need to work on the following skills to develop your assertiveness. Good verbal communications and the effective use of language are key skills in being successfully assertive.
Do not make the mistake of accepting responsibility for how people react to your assertive statements (e.g. anger, resentment). You can only control yourself. As long as you are not violating someone elses rights, then you have the right to say or do what you want. Express negative thoughts and feelings in a healthy and positive manner. Allow yourself to be angry, but always be respectful. Do say whats on your mind, but do it in a way that protects the other persons feelings. Control your emotions. Stand up for yourself and confront people who challenge you and/or your rights. Receive criticism and compliments positively. Accept compliments graciously. Allow yourself to make mistakes and ask for help. Accept feedback positively be prepared to say you dont agree but do not get defensive or angry. Learn to say no when you need to. Know your limits and what will cause you to feel taken advantage of. Know that you cant do everything or please everyone, and learn to be satisfied with that. Go with what is right for you. Suggest an alternative for a win-win solution.
Emotional intelligence (EI) is the ability to identify, assess and control own emotions, and those of other individuals and groups.
performance tests and has stronger relationships with traditional intelligence, whereas EI, also called EQ, is usually measured using selfreport questionnaires and has stronger relationships with personality. Learn to distinguish between appropriate actions and reactions towards outer stimuli. Learn to control your own emotions and be centred in yourself in the knowledge that you will be able to manage emotions.
http://www.mindtools.com & http://www.talentsmart.com You can read more about Goldmans research and writing on: http://www.eiconsortium.org/reports/what_is_emotional_intelligence. html You can do the EQ self-assessment tests on: http://www.queendom.com/tests
Daniel Goldman was the first author to popularise the use of the concept of emotional intelligence by publishing a book on the topic in 1995. Since then many researchers and authors have defined and described the topic, in the process assisting our understanding of the issue. Develop your emotional intelligence. Emotional intelligence (EI) is different from cognitive intelligence (IQ). IQ is usually measured using maximum 88
Another technique is scripting. It involves preparing your responses using a four-pronged approach that describes: The event: tell the other person exactly how you see the situation or problem. Your feelings: describe how you feel about expressing your emotions clearly. Your needs: tell the other person what you need so they dont have to guess. The consequences: describe the positive outcome if your needs are fulfilled. Once you are clear about what you want to say and express, it is much easier to actually do it. Being assertive means knowing where the fine line is between assertion and aggression, and balancing on it. It means having a strong sense of yourself and acknowledging that you deserve to get what you want. And it means standing up for yourself or your organisation, even in the most difficult situations. However, remember it is not at the expense of others, not to their detriment.
80% of results are achieved with only 20% of the effort. (Vilfredo Federico Damaso Pareto was an Italian engineer, sociologist, economist, political scientist and philosopher.) By applying better time management skills, you will achieve optimal results with the limited amount of time available to you. How well do you manage your time? Do you feel overloaded? Do you often have to work late to make deadlines? Maybe you feel that you go from one crisis to another, feeling stressed. We all would like to manage our time more effectively. However, we keep on making mistakes in our time management and often do not know how to improve on these. (Please refer to Unit 2 where we discussed our/your growth areas.) Efficient time management helps us to be more productive, reduces stress and improves performance. The most effective ways of achieving good time management are:
3.13.2 Prioritise
It can be difficult to know how to set priorities when you have a load of tasks ahead of you. However, you have to learn how to set priorities to be able to manage your time better. Firstly, distinguish between urgent and important activities. At the work place, your supervisor could guide you on deadlines. Sometimes you have to attend to urgent matters first (life or death decisions), other times you have to focus on important tasks before you can attend to urgent tasks. If you foresee that you will not be able to 91
meet the deadline, communicate that to the other party and find out if you can move the due date. To achieve good time management, you have to be clear about what is important and what is urgent.
Instead, focus on devoting a small amount of time to just getting started. Break projects down into smaller, manageable chunks. Check what needs to get done in the first few steps. Complete small chunks at a time so that it stops you from feeling that you could not possibly manage everything.
tasks when you multitask compared with completing the same list of tasks in sequence. The result is also that some of these tasks are not getting the attention they deserve and the results show the lack of concentration at the time. Focus on one task at a time (most men do this anyway!) and produce higher quality work.
fully productive, that allow you good time management. All others have to fall into the category of later attention. Check that you learn how to cut down on information overload. Keep all information that is essential to your studies and your work. Include information that is essential to your official life, e.g. documents, dates for renewal of licences and payment dates (in and out). What do you really need to know? How will you use this information to improve the way that you work? You may then decide that you can ignore some information, or quickly skim topics and headings of others. When you are more productive, it feels good to be in control of your time and know that you can produce the results that are expected of you. Get organised, have the right attitude and manage information effectively, and your time management will also improve.
Have you checked that both parties (you and the person/s with whom the appointment has been made) are available on the date and at that time? Could there be a clash of previous commitments? Have you confirmed how long the appointment will take? Does that cause problems? Will you be able to get to the place at the set time (have you calculated travelling time, finding the place, parking, traffic jams and late public transport)? Do you know exactly how long it will take you to get there? Have you entered the appointment in your physical or electronic calendar? Never assume that the other party has more time available than set aside for you. Never assume that meetings can just start without you and you can join when it suits you. Being late is seen as being impolite, not respecting the other party. It shows an attitude of I dont care or my time is more important to me than your time is to me. A fatal attitude to have in business or when applying for a job! Confirm your appointment date, time and venue in writing. Ask for a contact number in case you need to call en route. Appointments are commitments - to be honoured and kept at all costs. It is safer to phone ahead of the appointment to confirm that it is still taking place on the date, at the time and at the intended venue. The situation can change within a few days - check and be sure. If you are forced to change the appointment from your side, then let the other party know as soon as possible, render your apologies, give the reason for the cancellation/postponement, and ask to be given an alternative date, time or venue, if applicable.
When you have to complete tasks within a team, this becomes even more difficult as the team may include people who are slow, argumentative (spend more time on discussing the task than actually completing it), have two left hands (where a physical task is involved), may need on-the-job training and mentoring, or have language challenges (where they are not capable of speaking and reading your language, and you do not speak/read theirs). It will be very difficult under those circumstances to give an accurate time estimate of how long a task will need for completion. It may then be wise to overestimate the time you need if it is relatively small, or alternatively, use half a day at the start as an indicator and guideline to project the time you may need to complete the whole task. If you follow all the steps for better time management, you should soon be in better control of your tasks, your studies and your plans to a great career - and your life. Once learned, these skills will remain with you for the rest of your life.
98
Problem area
Score
Action
State why you have not yet achieved such positive change. What held you back? How are you going to move forward from now on? By doing what?
Score
Action
Date
Aimed score
for
3.15 Conclusion
Date Aimed score for
In this unit, we discussed the many dimensions of effective communication, including verbal and written. We looked at strategies you can employ to develop skills for effective communication. The importance of good time management was discussed, and tools to improve your time management skills were explored. You were given activities to complete, to develop improved skills and capacities in both those areas. The more you master these, the more likely you are to make a success of your studies and your working life. You can become a truly employable, professional individual. In the next unit, we will examine the role of teams and effective teamwork, and how to interact with others to ensure personal and organisational goals are met.
Improved aspects
Score Action
3.14.3 Activity: assessing areas that need further corrective action, time lines
Now list all those areas (including time management, communication, professionalism and behaviour) that you have not yet improved upon or not sufficiently improved upon. 100
Write an essay of 300 words about the most important aspects of effective communication. What negotiation skills do you need? Explain why you need them. 101
How do you develop assertiveness? Why is it necessary to be assertive? What do you need to watch out for when striving for effective written communication? How can you use non-verbal communication to help you in an important meeting? Describe the basic steps in effective time management.
102
103
Individual appraisal systems: Uses of performance appraisals, e.g. salary levels and bonus payments, promotion, strengths and weaknesses, training needs; communication; appraisal criteria, e.g. production data, personnel data, judgemental data; rating methods, e.g. ranking, checklist, management by objectives; skills audit; evaluating self-management; personal and interpersonal skills; leadership skills Own development against original aims and objectives set in the personal and professional development plan Acquired interpersonal and transferable skills.
4.2 Interpersonal skills: understand the dynamics of working for and with others
During the course of the past three units, we have already assessed your impact on others and the impact others have on you. Such impact is obvious during negotiations, when working in a team, when you go for a job interview and when meeting somebody for the first time. However, it is when you work in teams or formal work groups that the interaction with peers and superiors tests an employees ability to cooperate and be productive, while maintaining appropriate collegial relations. The word team stems from the Old English tam (as in team of draught animals), which in turn was based on the Germanic Zaum (bridle); also on teem and tow, from an Indo-European root shared by the Latin ducere (to lead) (Oxford Dictionary). Teams often refer to cross-functional members of an organisation who pursue a particular objective, possibly removed from the normal functions, e.g. researching a new performance management system or planning a new building for the organisation.
A team is a group of people with a full set of complementary skills required to complete a task, job or project.
4.1 Introduction
In Unit 3, you learned how to communicate effectively via verbal and faceto-face messages, and via non-verbal communication, body language, openness and responsiveness, and formal and informal feedback to and from colleagues. IT was discussed as an effective communication medium. We covered how to improve interpersonal effectiveness, negotiation skills, assertiveness skills and social skills. You also learned all the skills needed for good time management, such as prioritising workloads, using time effectively, making and keeping appointments, and achieving reliable estimates of task time. You then reviewed your current progress on your EPD plan and which corrective steps you still had to take. It is obviously essential for your own career path that you master all personal skills, such as conducting realistic and honest self-assessments, and developing traits that will assist you on a successful career path. These skills need to be reviewed on a regular basis, re-aligned with your personal goals and developed further. However, it is not enough to know what you are like and how you are progressing. As nobody lives in isolation and careers depend on our interpersonal relationships, we need to examine the dynamics of working with others and for others. We also examine the role of teams for your career, your interaction with others, your potential role within teams and the need for effective leadership skills. Do you know how to motivate others and how to bring out the best in others? This unit will teach you the fundamentals of this, and assist you to develop skills to achieve this.
There are many definitions of teams. The Oxford Dictionary defines a team as: two or more people working together a group of people working or playing together who come together as a team to achieve something a group of people with a full set of complementary skills required to complete a task, job or project The Business Directory refers to teams as: team members who (1) operate with a high degree of interdependence, (2) share authority and responsibility for self-management, (3) are accountable for the collective performance, and (4) work toward a common goal and shared reward(s). A team becomes more than just a collection of people when a strong sense of mutual commitment creates synergy, thus generating performance greater than the sum of the performance of its individual members. 105
104
Thinking (information/situations assessed objectively or based on criteria or principles) Feeling (information/situations assessed subjectively, judgements based on worth/values)
Teams and work groups differ significantly from each other. Work groups can be a conventional structure in an organisation where people of the same training and background work together, e.g. accountants or sales people. Work groups may also be set up for a limited time period on a particular project, e.g. to implement a new IT system and may be short term.
Judging (plan ahead and/or follow the plan, live ones outer life with closure and structure using the preferred judging process of either thinking or feeling) Perceiving (keep options open to adapt, live ones outer life in a more emergent manner using the preferred perceiving process of sensing or intuiting). Individuals who combine sensing and thinking pay attention to tangible realities based on current and past experiences. They focus on objective facts, criteria or principles. They only want the facts. Individuals who combine sensing and feeling pay attention also to tangible realities based on current and past experiences, but they focus on people and the values involved. They have a sensitive and caring approach. Individuals who combine intuiting and thinking pay attention to concepts, meanings, interrelationships and probable or possible future outcomes. They have an abstract, problem-solving approach and look at the principles and criteria involved. Individuals who combine intuiting and feeling also pay attention to concepts, meanings, interrelationships, and probable or possible futures, but they instead focus on the people and values involved. They have a growth-anddevelopment approach. If individuals in a company - and in a team - know their own personality styles, they can also understand the behaviour of others better. They can then either make allowances for them, or they could look for team members who will bring the correct style to the tasks at hand. For example, if you had a team consisting only of the sensing and feeling style, there would be a lot of harmony and care - ideal for a non-governmental organisation (NGO) or charity - but this would not necessarily lead to success if they had to drive sales. Sensing and thinking team members would be great in research, accounts and anything to do with facts and figures, but would not be so suited to a team trying to get a fun event organised for the company.
4.2.1 The roles people play in a team and how they can work together to achieve shared goals
In Unit 1 you looked at various personality types and learning styles. Go back to those websites and read about the different traits. Jung was the original creator of these classifications.
Why is it important to understand different personality types or learning styles when we discuss teams? In every team, many such personalities come together to achieve a common task or fulfil a common purpose. Different personalities bring their own strengths and challenges. Understanding these dynamics makes it easier to include suitable members in a team or to structure the team in an appropriate manner. If we examine the roles people play in a team, we first have to revisit these different personality traits (see Unit 1). Myers-Briggs referred to them as: Extraversion (driven by interaction with others, oriented to and motivated by the world outside oneself) Introversion (driven by solitary activities, oriented to and motivated by the world inside oneself) Sensing (tangible, experiential awareness) Intuition (abstract, symbolic, conceptual awareness) 106
107
What dynamics are involved between these different people? What are the roles people play in different settings, e.g. employer and employee supervisor and supervised person colleagues among each other team members employee and suppliers employee and customers/clients employee and other internal and external work contacts In all these relationships, there are hierarchies to observe, rules to follow and behavioural codes to adhere to. If you act in a professional manner at all times, you have little to be concerned about with regard to interpersonal relationships in the work place or within teams. Appropriate respect towards those higher up the ladder, be they employer, supervisor, more senior team member, clients/customers, suppliers, etc. has to be a given. You have to address them politely, accept instructions without argument or follow rules set by them - or you risk disciplinary action and possibly losing your job. This is a topic also closely related to leadership and management styles, your interpersonal skills and the personal development that this course is assisting you with.
Roles in teams may be formal or informal. Where a person is appointed as leader and another as secretary or treasurer, they occupy formal roles/positions. People also assume informal roles based on their own characteristics, strengths and weaknesses. We will discuss this in some more detail later in this unit. Every team member will have to be identified as to their specific role within the total task, e.g. researcher or report drafter. This must preferably be done at the commencement of the actual task. Individual members strongly influence the team dynamics. When the composition of the team changes, the team dynamics change. All team members bring their own unique talents, perspectives, values and experiences to the work of the team. The better all the team members know each other as to their talents and expertise, the better they can utilise each relevant talent for better team performance. This necessitates honesty, trust and excellent communication among the various team members. Different personalities have to fit into the team. There has to be a method of conflict resolution, i.e. a way to manage conflict if it occurs. Every team has to be clear about the common purpose, the time set aside for the task at hand, the resources and the expected outcome of the team work, and who is going to do what by when. At that stage, the different personality types and their preferred approaches to doing the work will have to be taken into consideration in order to achieve the optimal outcomes. Ideally, during the whole teamwork process, the successes/steps achieved will be monitored to ensure that no time is wasted on tasks that are not part of the original team purpose. During that process, individuals may either feel that they are contributing valuable inputs to the whole process, or that they are not allowed to contribute meaningfully. If all team members are properly involved and are able to bring their own best to the team, they will also be more productive and will be more willing to get involved in future teamwork. Informal team roles develop as the work of the team progresses. Some people are good at following up on issues and finishing a job properly. Others are good at provoking thought and coming up with creative ideas, but they are unable to finish a job effectively. Teams need both, the finishers/ implementers and innovators. 109
There are various roles team members play. Research has been conducted to establish which characteristics make a team successful or not. Belbin (1993) called them role labels after his research and identified the following Nine Belbin Team Roles:
Think of teams you have been part of. For the person with no or limited work experience, these are typically sports teams, teams organising events, study assignment teams, friends organising a group holiday, or friends arranging a farewell party for a friend, as discussed in the next section. How was that team experience? Have a look at the nine Belbin roles/styles. Which one describes you best? Are you like that every time you are part of a team? Did you feel that your efforts trying to make the team work were worth it? Would you want to be part of such a team again? What would you do differently now?
Team Role
Contribution
Creative, imaginative, freethinking. Generates ideas and solves difficult problems. Outgoing, enthusiastic, communicative. Explores opportunities and develops contacts. Mature, confident, identifies talent. Clarifies goals. Delegates effectively. Challenging, dynamic, thrives on pressure. Has the drive and courage to overcome obstacles.
Allowable Weaknesses
Ignores incidentals. Too preoccupied to communicate effectively. Overly optimistic. Loses interest once initial enthusiasm has passed. Can be seen as manipulative. Offloads own share of the work. Prone to provocation. Offends peoples feelings.
Plant
Resource Investigator
Coordinator
Shaper
Monitor Evaluator
Sober, strategic and discerning. Lacks drive and ability Sees all options to inspire others. Can be and judges accurately. overly critical. Co-operative, perceptive and diplomatic. Listens and averts friction. Indecisive in crunch situations. Avoids confrontation.
Teamworker
Implementer
Completer Finisher
Practical, reliable, efficient. Somewhat inflexible. Turns ideas into Slow to respond to new actions and organises work that possibilities. needs to be done. Painstaking, conscientious, anxious. Searches Inclined to worry unduly. out errors. Polishes and Reluctant to delegate. perfects. Single-minded, self-starting, dedicated. Provides knowledge and skills in rare supply. Contributes only on a narrow front. Dwells on technicalities.
Specialist
110
Then there has to be a willing helper, a person who gladly supports the leader, who needs to be wanted and needed. Usually, there are those who need to belong to anything that will allow them membership, where they qualify. They do not want to lead and they do not want too much work, but they love to be part of something. They like the label of being part of the team. Often, there are also the spectators who only want to watch, do not want to get too deeply involved, do not take part and avoid any responsibility. They are the ones on the side lines; they want to know what is happening but are not active. They may even criticise without contributing. If we refer back to the Belbin roles/social dimension of teams identified earlier, some fit into these roles while others remain undefined, e.g. the spectators and those who need to be needed. As a certain closeness/comfort zone develops among team members (bound by the same interests or goals), it is often difficult for new members to become accepted as part of the team. The intruder has to learn the rules and standards of the team, and learn to enter the team accepting the existing norms and its existing hierarchy. As a new member, it is better to avoid trying to make changes from the onset. These may be necessary but would be more acceptable to old members once you are an accepted member of the team.
What are the challenges of that role? Do others not accept the person in that role; do they want to take over? Do some students feel rejected? How does the leader achieve positive feelings and cohesion in the team? Is there conflict? How does the leader solve the conflict? If your current studies do not require assignments to be done in teams, identify an assignment or research project for which a team can be formed. Teamwork is an increasing reality in the work place and in advanced studies, such as in the MBA (Masters in Business Administration).
113
This also applies to top management in the company. Without them, there would not be a company and you would not have a job - so they form part of your ultimate team. In all cases, it is the success of working together as effective and efficient teams that make a company achieve its goals. That is why work teams are the preferred way to reach goals in certain organisations. Together with a team, an employee can achieve much more than on his/her own.
members all help one another as needed. Your productivity levels would probably increase exponentially. Delegation can occur voluntarily within teams, where you exchange your originally assigned task with somebody else while you take on some other task. It can also occur across members in the same department or even in different departments in a company. If delegating across departments, you would have to leave it to the manager of the relevant department to make the decision which person is the most suitable, and whether he/she can accept the task and handle it within his/ her resources and the time line. You will not be allowed to delegate across different departments. You may find that some departments are so competitive (i.e. have underlying conflicts) that they will not accept any delegated tasks - on principle. It will depend on your own level of seniority as to whether or not you have the authority to then insist on acceptance of the delegated task to such department. Where different skills are required, collaboration across departments may be required, e.g. a legal section may verify a sales contract drafted by sales teams, and the finance section then checks and agrees that the contract is according to budget. This is not, strictly speaking, delegation but there are similarities in the process, e.g. handing over part of a task to someone else to complete.
115
Show employers that you are self-motivated, and that you are committed to personal growth and continuous learning. If you are a part-time student, you will need to know how to fit in a whole range of demands: work, life and education. This will be similar in the work place, where you will be expected to arrive on time every day, irrespective of what you did the night or weekend before. You will be expected to leave private issues at home, concentrate on your work and interact in the best manner - even if you had an argument with a colleague during the previous day. As always, being professional in all your dealings should enable you to manage such challenges. One of the most important aspects of a successful business is a healthy working climate among its employees. Every employee has a role to play in this climate by remaining professional, adhering to the company rules and regulations, and contributing meaningfully and efficiently to the goals of the company.
116
117
exercises (including fun events away from the office). They encourage people from different divisions to meet/mix, to exchange ideas, and to find a common vision and goal. In such settings, dress is casual or, at worst, normal officewear, but always clean, neat and tidy. Some companies encourage family members to attend fun days, special occasions and celebration events to ensure that they are supportive of those working for the company (important when overtime work, extra shifts and stress/pressure at work take their toll). It also makes it easier for supervisors or managers to identify and understand the private life dynamics of staff members whose behaviour at work is cause for concern.
present, or senior people instructing exactly how everybody must act or behave. Team members will not open up or contribute freely under such circumstances. There are different skills needed to facilitate the best team building exercises. A facilitator has to encourage the quiet members to talk about their points of view. He/she has to make sure that the natural (or official through rank in the company) leader does not run the show, dominating all input and results. Ideally, the facilitator should use a team building exercise in the way a group moderator uses a group discussion: get as much input from everybody as possible, get reactions to everything that has been said, identify problems and find solutions. The facilitator must not offer his or her own solutions. Successful teams grow in maturity; they blend over time, changing dynamics from the early beginnings when every team member is still assessing his or her role and finding his or her own level of contribution, to the mature team where every member can totally rely on all other members. At the mature stage, the team has shared beliefs and visions, works like clockwork, and has achieved loyalties and trust in each other. Team members have learned to be adaptable and flexible when needed, and are fully committed to their common cause. This process of team development is often described as forming, storming, norming and performing. The following diagram shows the progression in team maturity.
119
Team Development
Performing
outcome of the task to which they all contributed. In addition to this, they should have grown positive relationships of trust, being able to rely on each other and to enjoy each others company and working together. The final stages in the life cycle of a team are adjourning and termination. Adjourning is typically related to the end of a project team. However, it is also relevant when the purpose and structure of the team changes substantially due to a sale, merger or restructuring process. This stage can be particularly stressful where the dissolution of the team is unplanned. This stage involves the disbandment of the team, termination of roles and the completion of tasks. This stage is also referred to as mourning, given the sense of loss experienced by some team members.
Norming
Tuckman Model
Storming
Forming Tuckmann, Bruce (1965) Development sequence in small groups Psychological Bulletin, 63, 384-399
The Challenge
The Questions
What will I do now? What will it be like now? Shall I stay (with the company) or shall I go?
Stage 2
STORMING Members resist control by group leaders and show hostility
NORMING Members work together developing close relationships and feelings of comraderie
In the ideal team, everybody learns something from everybody else, all members contribute something meaningfully, and all share a common goal. They share purpose and priorities, know their roles, and solve challenges and conflict. Their individual personalities are fully recognised and appreciated, skills are applied within the teams, standards are set and adhered to, and team members share setbacks and find alternative solutions - but they also share in the positive results and successes. They grow from all their experiences within the team. Members in the ideal team know what needs to be done, by when, by whom, with which resources and whom to delegate what tasks to. Team members adhere to set regular meetings, have set agendas and can prove results. The greatest satisfaction to team members will be the successful 120
Reference: Bruce W. Tuckman, Development Sequence in Small Groups, Psychological Bulletin. 1965. Tuckman, 1997 (in collaboration with Mary Ann Jensen), updated the model to include the fifth stage adjourning.
121
Storming
What is leadership - what defines an effective leader? It is not as simple as stating anybody in management, top politicians, union leaders, civic organisation leaders, etc. They may be leaders only according to their titles or having been elected. Leadership is more than being in a formal, appointed management position. One definition of leadership comes from Erhard et al who describe leadership as an exercise in language that results in the realisation of a future that wasnt going to happen anyway, which future fulfils (or contributes to fulfilling) the concerns of the relevant parties. This definition links leadership to the future and includes the concerns of the relevant parties (http://www.wernererhard.com and http://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/papers. cfm?abstract_id= 1392406). It differs from other definitions as it does not describe others as followers. It also looks at leadership as that of many people rather than that of an individual. It implies that fundamental concerns of the relevant parties are addressed which may not have been the idea of the leader. This is in direct conflict with the standard definition of leadership which is attributed to an individual possessing such qualities. Leaders are usually found in positions of responsibility in a companys hierarchy, and are expected to have the necessary expertise in adjudicating problems that may arise in the company. A true leader goes beyond the power and authority of the position held by an appointed head or chief. An emergent leader, i.e. one who does not have the title (e.g. CEO, manager or director) but has one element that some people in authority do not actually possess: he/she has informal power/influence over others. He/she has the ability to gain co-operation from others by means of persuasion. Ogbonnia (2007) defines an effective leader as an individual with the capacity to consistently succeed in a given condition and be viewed as meeting the expectations of an organisation or society. An individual who is appointed to a managerial position (e.g. CEO, manager or director) has the right to instruct, command and enforce obedience because of his/her authority in this position. However, besides such title and authority, a manager who is a leader would also possess the right attributes to match this authority and inspire staff to respect and follow 123
Performing
Norming
Dorming
Figure 4 Revised team development stages
4.3.1 Activity: alternative ways to complete tasks and achieve team goals
Well-functioning teams contribute to great productivity and provide efficient paths to success. However, there are times when the full team is not available or when team members leave (resignation, retirement, illness, etc.). Look at the roles and functions of the ideal team and what a team consists of. What could be the various ways for teams to complete tasks and result in satisfactory options to achieve team goals, even when you have a changing team? Justify your solution. Also consider the role of IT/electronic media can play towards such solutions. 122
him because of his/her ideas, standing, direction, dynamism/charisma, and the confidence he/she inspires. Should a manager not be capable of applying such authority in the correct manner, he/she may then be faced with an emergent leader challenging this role in the company, undermining his/her authority and credibility. However, only authority of position has the official backing of formal sanctions in the company. It follows that whoever wields personal influence and power can legitimise this only by gaining a formal position in the hierarchy, with commensurate authority. If there is conflict between the appointed authority (e.g. CEO, manager or director) and the emergent leader, staff loyalties could be challenged, and there may be a split in who listens to whom. Productivity can suffer as a consequence. This happens frequently between management and unions when a proper consultative approach is not followed. According to Pedler et al (2001), who write about managers development, group management competencies - based on research - are segmented into three sections: Foundation Specific skills and attributes Meta qualities They believe that management competencies have to include the following 11 skills: 1. Command of basic facts 2. Relevant professional knowledge 3. Continuing sensitivity to events 4. Analytical, problem-solving and decision-/judgement-making skills 5. Social skills and abilities 6. Emotional resilience 7. Proactive inclination to respond purposefully to events 8. Creativity 9. Mental agility 10. Balanced learning habits and skills 11. Self-knowledge. 124
Skills 3 to 7 are specific skills and attributes. Skills 9 to 11 are meta qualities that help the manager to develop other skills, and to deploy resources and other skills. They point out that many of the skills are interconnected in that possession of the onecontributes to the possession of the other. According to Pedler et al, skills 1 and 2 form the foundation level; they represent two kinds of basic knowledge and information that a manager may need to use in making decisions and taking action. Skills 3 to 7 directly affect behaviour and performance, while skill 3 (sensitivity) allows managers to acquire the basic knowledge and information involved in skills 1 and 2. The final skills 8 to 11 are those that allow a manager to develop and deploy skills and resources in skills 3, 4 and 5. Pedler et al refer to these qualities as meta qualities needed in particular circumstances. Every company or organisation needs leaders at every level. A company without an efficient leader is like a ship without a captain - rudderless and directionless. There is no vision and no driving force towards a specific goal in the company. The company may well have managers or directors - but if they cannot lead efficiently and effectively, the company is doomed to failure. How many times have these so-called leaders let their followers down, having failed to achieve the goals they promised they would achieve? How often have these same people only looked after their own interests and those of their closest family members, friends and allies, filling their own pockets, and exploiting power, position and influence? International news media have frequently described the failed leadership of banking and financial leaders in the last few years of the economic crisis. Where that occurs, there is no effective leadership. Instead it is exploitation and manipulation of others in order to achieve their own selfish gain. True leadership is a carefully developed skill for setting direction and setting standards, motivating others to be and do their best, being innovative when confronted with challenges, being responsive to problems, and trying to find solutions so that problems can be avoided. A true leader is an effective communicator, is reliable and consistent, shows the way, and gets others to follow willingly in his or her vision. A true leader also does not only have a vision but makes sure that this vision becomes a reality, working with and through others. Effective leadership: 125
Is focused on the destination rather than on the details of getting there Creates and communicates a vision for the company and often for individuals as well Enlists others to work with him/her towards such vision Has certain qualities, some of them natural (character trait) and others developed over time Tolerates and adjusts to circumstances as they unfold Has the ability to take charge Inspires others to follow the lead Has the resolve and determination to do whatever is needed to lead the company/organisation to success Inspires employees to see and relate to such leadership in deed and not only in word Facilitates management and employee understanding of the leaders vision and his/her stand on integrity, customer service and other important issues Makes sure that the values of top-level executives are aligned, and are filtered through the many layers of management and staff Works well with and through people Is well aware of changing markets, demands, competitor activity and trends (through carefully selected and well-appointed management/ staff), and steers the company either with or against those trends, whatever is best for the company or organisation.
the circumstances and the type of challenges we may be confronted with, we may well adopt some characteristics of one or more of the other styles for the specific circumstance or event - and later revert to the style which we are more comfortable with. The natural/born leader is one who already led others during childhood - with others following his/her ideas for games to play, things to plan or hobbies to participate in - without ever having to bully, bribe or entice other children. This ability would then have expanded during adolescence and early adulthood. Very often, natural leaders also volunteer for extra projects or leadership tasks (in youth groups, charitable organisations, etc.), or even start such organisations on their own. In adult life, such natural leadership talent then only needs to be groomed for business, i.e. adapted to the different environments and enhanced through business skills/job skills. Not all leaders are born leaders; many worked very hard to develop this skill to recognise and value the worth of other individuals, to learn to respect others for who they are and what they do, and to learn to show appreciation for their work and for their potential. People who are appointed to management are not automatically leaders for introverts, it may be more difficult to focus on others and their success, and the success of the company/organisation. The self-centred manager will steer the company so that all future success will reflect on him/her getting the credit and being the reason for the success. Failures will be attributed to others. We all know people like this - they are not leaders even if they call themselves that or they occupy positions of authority. True leaders create an innovative environment. They: are open to the ideas of others encourage and support experimentation eliminate unnecessary penalties for failure look for/tap into all talents of employees around them strive to incorporate a positive can do attitude into the whole organisational culture to set the tone of the companys culture.
127
Why would anyone want to become a leader? Is it not far simpler to remain below the radar screen of others, not getting bothered with responsibilities or accusations of non-performance, or having to motivate and drive others all the time? Yes, it would be much simpler to sit facing a computer, complete ones daily tasks, go home and face the same again the next day. No major responsibilities, no conflict, and not being responsible or accountable for the successes or failures of others. Some people accept such a mole-like existence all their lives. Others may initially regard this as a good option but eventually become dissatisfied with the work, the salary, their supervisors and life in general. Such lack of ambition means that one would then also have to forego promotions, salary increases, seniority and fringe benefits. They would not have the rewarding experience of being able to lead others, to manage and to grow as a person.
In other circumstances, a democratic approach (getting everybodys input and opinion, reaching consensus before acting) may be far more suitable. The style adopted by a leader (while personally tending more to one style that he/she is more comfortable with) should be the one that most effectively achieves the objectives of the company, the team, the situation and the goal to be achieved. Let us look at the various leadership styles from an emotional intelligence point of view, as described by Daniel Goleman et al: Visionary leaders mobilise people toward a shared vision. They are seldom practical or hands-on. They are highly enthusiastic about new ideas and innovations - others have to become as enthusiastic about these ideas as they are expected to implement the ideas. Coaching leaders develop people, establishing a relationship and trust with and among people. Their goal is to help people improve themselves. They are great believers in continuous training. Affiliative leaders promote emotional bonds and organisational harmony around them. They are more comfortable in an environment where people get on with each other, where problems get solved through discussions and agreement. Democratic or participative leaders build consensus through participation. This leadership style has the leader sharing the decisionmaking abilities with group members by promoting the interests of the group members and by practising social equality. Pacesetting leaders set challenging and exciting standards, and expect excellence. They believe that employees can do a lot better and faster than they do. The bar is raised on a regular basis - they are firm believers of Total Quality Management and continuous higher achievements. Autocratic, authoritarian or commanding leaders demand immediate compliance. Leaders in this style keep all decision-making powers centralised in the leader. This style is obvious in dictators but is also often present among patriarchal companies, the military and para-military, old-world educational institutions, etc. Autocratic or commanding leaders believe everything must be done their way, by the book, 100% according to the rules. They do not entertain any suggestions or initiatives from subordinates; they are not easily convinced that change is needed. If it has worked like that before for me, then it will work for you as well. Autocratic or commanding management is an easy tool for management. It allows easy and quick decision making, as only one
129
person decides for everybody and keeps each decision to himself until he feels it needs to be communicated to others. Engaging leaders engage employees in understanding the existing conditions and how they can collectively assist in addressing them. The engaging leader reaches out to employees during difficult times to better understand their concerns and interests. He/she openly and honestly explains the full impact of, for example, the economic downturn on them and the company. They also explain what can be done to keep as many employees employed as possible. Laissez-faire or free rein style leaders may be in a leadership position without providing actual leadership, leaving employees in the company to fend for themselves and make their own decisions as to when to act, and how. This type of leader is usually preoccupied with own activities and interests, far too busy to get involved in the day-to-day activities of the company/team that he/she is supposed to lead. These are different characteristics from those of the servant leader or so-called level 5 leader, who focuses strongly on giving staff the credit and working from behind the scenes. Narcissistic leaders show their self-centred style by being concerned with their image, how employees perceive them, whether they are admired or copied, how much publicity they receive, and whether articles are published about them. Embarrassment through failures, or through being seen in the wrong outfit or with the wrong people, are all the worst case scenarios for these leaders. They need to feel they are important. A toxic leader is someone who has responsibility over a group of people or an organisation, and who abuses the leaderfollower relationship by leaving the group or organisation in a worse-off condition than when he/she joined it. He/she milks the company for all it is worth, taking out as much money as possible; they fire and hire the wrong people, and they make decisions that harm the company. They usually also quickly resign at one point, just before they would be fired or arrested, or just before the company goes into liquidation. Contingent or situational leadership styles are those where leaders adapt their style to suit a situation. Leading a group of highly educated engineers may require a different style from leading a large group of manual labourers. This is a modern style that many leaders subscribe to and try to follow.
There are thus many leadership styles that can be identified; who is in charge in theory or who is really in charge. Learn to recognise the people around you for their leadership style. Leaders who demonstrate persistence and tenacity, and who have clear goals and apply efficient communication skills will bring out the best qualities in their subordinates and the best results for their companies.
4.5.2 Self-leadership
This process occurs within an individual. It is a combination of a number of decisions you make: you decide that you want to be in charge of your own life; be or become self-disciplined and self-motivated; turn from being led to leading - even if it starts only with everything in your own life. You make the decision and then act on this decision.
130
131
deadlines and to perfection but may lack good people skills. He/she may need to manage by fear, using the stick approach. Let us examine the most obvious differences between a leader and a manager as described by McShane and Travaglione (2007). What defines such differences?
and celebrates their successes. Leaders often need managers in their organisation, as they often tend to get bored with detail and are already on to their next vision or their next creative solution. They rely on efficient implementers. Many people admire the concept of being a director, a manager or a leader. Such aspiration is often linked to either the expected earnings attached to such a job/title, the big mansion, the luxury car, designer clothing, or international travel to exotic destinations - or, alternatively, to the perceived power. At the same time, most subordinates love to hate management - for setting up rules, for demanding too much in too little time, for not giving recognition when it is due, and for criticising in public and complimenting in private when nobody else hears or sees. Managers are often portrayed in movies as bullies and incapable back stabbers who are involved in fraud and corruption. Unfortunately also, there are thousands of bad managers around, confirming these prejudices. The same applies to many of todays so-called leaders. There are lots with wonderful charisma and very little ability to deliver on their promises. People recognise them the world over, especially when it is close to election time: politicians often make the wildest promises so that they get elected. Then comes delivery time - and little or nothing happens. Leadership, while satisfying and at times glamorous, is not for the fainthearted. You become very visible, with all your faults and strengths. You will be judged by everybody around you. Could you be a manager? Or could you be a true leader? Do you have what it takes? More importantly, do you want to be a manager or a leader? Changes in company law and auditing make life far more difficult for directors and senior managers. Company law now holds directors and senior managers accountable and liable for any damages, losses or negative impacts on others. This can even extend to their private assets, where they could lose everything they own if they are found to have been corrupt, fraudulent or negligent in their handling of company matters.
manager
Oversees the current process well Must achieve balance Thinks execution Comfortable with control Problems are just that, and needs resolution ASAP Procedure is King Instructs as to technique and process Impersonal, remote
leader
Wants to create the future Needs to make change Thinks ideas Welcomes risks Sees problems as opportunities, is patient Substance trumps the King Your best college Professor High Emotional Intellegence
Managers are far more comfortable with tangible products and systems anything they can control hands-on, within the parameters of the present known environment and safer choices. They are often pragmatic, like to deal with matters which they can sort out, and avoid risk. Managers are good at accepting and issuing orders, enforcing rules, and making sure that everything works and there is order. Managers accept senior leaders in their organisation - as long as they do not interfere in the day-to-day running of the business. Leaders are happier with ideas and concepts, are comfortable with and welcome change and the unknown future, and need time to dream, to be innovative and to create new visions. They are also risk takers, love challenges and are willing to break/bend rules. They are confident, have excellent verbal skills and use them to their advantage. The typical leader motivates, teaches and inspires through his/her vision. A leader is willing to accept blame for employee mistakes, gives credit to successful employees 132
133
Answer the following questions truthfully. There are no right or wrong answers. a.) Which are you more comfortable with: a) ideas, or b) products, or c) concepts, or d) systems? b.) Are you more present- or future-oriented? c.) Do you like to bend or break the rules to accomplish your mission? d.) Which do you deal with more successfully: change and innovation or maintaining the status quo? e.) Do you like being in authority, and if so, would you rather issue orders or work to inspire others? f.) Are you willing to take the risks that go along with increased responsibility? g.) Are you willing to invest the time and emotional energy required to lead others? Now compare the answers with the description of managers and leaders in . Once you have identified which of these options you lean towards (manager or leader - or neither?), explain in your own words what you understand your manager, leader or potential role to be.
What percentage increase would you expect? Do you think that all companies offer fringe benefits, e.g. medical aid, pension fund, car allowance and group life insurance? Would these perks be important to you? Smaller companies are usually not able to offer any fringe benefits in monetary terms, but they tend to offer more flexibility in terms of working hours, leave taken, working from home and a more familiar working environment. Could you see yourself working for a smaller company without top level perks? So what motivates you most: being paid well, receiving recognition, being able to work at your own pace, flexibility, or trying new tasks and innovating? Companies have to cost in the full package to employees. Everything that is offered by the company costs the company - be it paid in cash or via other methods. Employee retention is especially important when the economy is in recession because finding, interviewing, hiring and training replacements drain valuable time and other resources from a company. In order to promote employee job satisfaction and retention, organisations focus on making some perks available to employees, as long as the company can afford these.
many other jobs can be done at the home of the employee - at least part of the time, as long as he/she has a designated space where such work can be done in a professional manner, where confidentiality can be guaranteed, where there is an Internet and telephone connection, and the person does not need ongoing, direct supervision. Where others are continuously reliant on the employees work output (e.g. at a conveyor belt or in a laboratory) and where interpersonal actions are the basis of the work (e.g. surgeon and patient, dentist and patient), working from home is not an option. In the case of the dentist, he would have to set up his practice at home! In most other cases, the development in ICT has enabled people to work anywhere and anytime, particularly in sales, software development and consultancy. Even teachers can teach rural classes now via electronic media, and doctors can execute some operations in that way with local assistance and electronic access. Employees now enjoy greater mobility because of a change of mindset in organisations and the technological developments mentioned above. It is also a reaction to traffic congestion, a waste of productive time spent travelling and the rising price of fuel. Working from home promotes quality of life and work satisfaction. It allows employees to avoid the stress of traffic or missing appointments because they work so far from home. These perks are extremely valuable to employees and can assist the company in retaining highly skilled employees who could otherwise be lost to the company (e.g. maternity leave/small children at home, moving to a different suburb/city, difficult private life circumstances, etc.). The employee will also feel extra loyalty towards a company that makes his/her life easier. At the same time, employees do not arrive at the office already tired, in a bad mood (traffic jams, tickets or road rage) and can also find their optimal time of day when they are at their most productive, to complete all tasks. Naturally, it requires employees to be responsible, to work in a disciplined way, and to avoid conflict of interests between private matters and work responsibilities.
are likely to perform better and be absent less often, so this will benefit the company as well.
work toward promotions. However, formal education and training are expensive. It may be difficult for employees to pay for further education, especially for those who have already completed degree and certificate programmes. Tuition reimbursement and ongoing in-company or external, paid-for training opportunities are perks that can really help with employee retention. If an organisation is offering to pay for their education that could lead to an internal promotion, employees will be extremely keen to make use of the opportunity. They will then perform better for the company in the long term. Firms should use individual appraisal systems based on their job description, and then reward outstanding performance accordingly. Such a system must be transparent, well defined and documented to avoid accusations of favouritism.
These reviews are generally structured strictly according to those aspects stated in the job descriptions or performance contracts. Other companies set up complex performance review forms which look at actual task-by-task performance, as well as interpersonal relationships and team performances against set goals and time lines. They assess the strengths and weaknesses of the person, and his/her training needs, and include production data, personnel data, judgemental data and the employees own comments and explanations together with those of immediate supervisors rating their performance. An effective human resources department will then utilise these results to arrive at an overall corporate overview, one per department/division, one per team and one for each individual. These can then be benchmarked per category, with forecasts applied, remedial action taken where necessary, and/or promotions considered. It is common for organisations to pay bonuses or increases when they have achieved measurable profits, but where companies are in financial trouble it is not the obvious step to take. Remedial action will often be needed where employees have not adhered to behavioural codes or have underperformed. In such cases, it is very seldom only the actual job skill missing. The latter can easily be rectified through training. Attitudinal problems are more difficult to correct; the employee has to first realise that he/she actually has a problem. What are some of these potential problems that could hinder promotions or salary increases?
138
139
do something, you are definitely going to harm your career prospects. Naturally, if the supervisor is abusive or blatantly unfair, you should ascertain what company procedure there is to deal with such a situation, and then follow the correct procedure. Again, a professional approach to any such discussions, looking for solutions rather than trying to find excuses for the problems, will always be helpful. However, discussing these problems with other staff members or publishing negative comments online is a death knell to future promotions or an increase. Management may even consider cutting you out of any future development or training plans, and may look for ways to get you out of the company as they see you as being extremely disloyal. Anyway, why are you working for a company where you dislike everything and everybody?
4.7.5 Appearances
This important matter was mentioned earlier in this Coursebook. Some companies have a casual dress code which might suit you (as long as your clothes are clean, neat and tidy, and not torn or full of last nights dinner). If you do not come into contact with clients or other important external people, nor have meetings with management, you may be allowed to wear casual clothing. In all other cases, your dress code will be more formal, in line with company policy and suitable for the type of work you do. Technical staff would dress differently from those in marketing.
141
Not adhering to the companys dress code (embarrassing if a senior manager or a client complains about you!) may cause a disciplinary meeting to be called. Senior managers will also believe that you are not mature enough for a promotion to a more senior job if you rebel against the companys dress code. Another aspect to watch is how you behave when invited outside of work in a social setting with your manager or clients. Are your table manners up to scratch? Can you handle yourself when alcohol is served? Nobody wants to promote somebody who cannot be allowed to be close to clients, and who is an embarrassment in a restaurant or public place, even when attending a football match with colleagues. Appearance, good table manners and generally good manners are all essential to career advancement, as are social skills. You do need to be able to hold a conversation, as well as know how to make small talk and when not to make small talk. If you are not sure exactly what to do when and your family cannot teach you, go online and find the appropriate hints and tips, and practise, practise, practise!
Problem area
Score
Action
Date
142
143
Action
Date
4.9 Conclusion
In this unit, you learned about various aspects of teams and team formation, what constitutes good team work, and the roles people can play in teams. We discussed leadership, leadership styles and the basics of effective leadership, plus the difference between leadership and management. In the next unit, we will examine strategy formulation, problem definitions, problem-solving techniques and problem-solving strategies. Again, we will review what progress you have made on your own personal development.
4.8.3 Activity: assessing areas that need further corrective action, time lines
Now list all those areas (including time management, communication, professionalism and behaviour) that you have not yet improved upon or have not sufficiently improved upon.
Write an essay of 300 words about the most important aspects of team dynamics. What makes a team successful? What could cause serious problems in team work? State the various leadership styles, and give your opinion of the benefits and drawbacks of each style. State the difference between a good leader and a good manager. Give reasons for this. State five ways to motivate staff beyond their salary payments. How do you avoid losing out on a promotion? What do you need to do?
Score
Action
Date
State why you have not yet achieved such positive change, i.e. what held you back? How are you going to move forward from now on? By doing what?
144
145
5.1 Introduction
In the previous unit, you learned about various aspects of teams and team formation, what constitutes good team work, what constitutes effective leadership, and what differentiates a manager from a leader. In this unit, we will examine employability and professional development strategy formulation, problem definitions, problem-solving techniques and problem-solving strategies. We will again review your progress on your personal development. Why do you need problem-solving skills? Why do you need to develop a strategy for such skills? Because you will be confronted with many problematic situations in your personal life and your working life. The more your problem-solving skills have been developed and polished, the better you will be able to cope when faced with difficult situations. Ideally, however, you will learn how to: learn from previous problems and not make the same mistakes again (hindsight and learning) recognise current problems and find solutions for them (present problem solving) identify potential problems and take steps to mitigate or avoid them from happening in the first place (future-oriented problem solving) develop strategies to avoid, solve and cope with problems in various scenarios. For every successful career plan, problem solving is an exceptionally important skill. Being recognised as a competent and confident problem solver will create job opportunities for you, and will get you onto a successful road to career development. Superiors/managers like having problem solvers on their team as such skills enhance productivity in a company. Having acquired the appropriate skills, you can then approach every problem you encounter through a systematic process and be comfortable that the decisions you make are sound and reliable. You will know that by following a well-structured plan, you can resolve the problem to the best of your ability. Despite all these skills, you will never be able to avoid all problems from occurring, and you will also not solve all problems you come across. Many may be beyond your range of influence or competence. 147
146
For example: the world economy is going through tough times at the moment millions of people are losing their jobs changing South African legislation (e.g. B-BEEE, AA, scarce skills) will determine who will easily find a job and who will not climate change will impact on what we will be able to grow where, or if whole regions will become deserts or will be flooded alternative energy resources will have to be found water scarcity will become a severe problem ageing populations world-wide pose new challenges to economies. You will be unable to influence these factors affecting your life. However, having developed the appropriate problem-solving skills will make it much easier for you to cope with different changing and unknown circumstances. You will be able to adapt to such changing circumstances and reduce the influence of these external problems as far as possible. Consequently, you will then not feel that you are faced with insurmountable challenges in life. You will feel more powerful, more in control of your own destiny. You will be able to apply these skills during your studies, during your working life and even in your private life.
may have been spared such major impact on your life and only had to deal with problems emerging from your own actions or lack thereof (e.g. being blamed for somebody elses doings, not having completed homework in primary school or high school, etc.). With some problems, the only option open to you will be either to adapt to the consequences of these problems or to find new opportunities arising from them, e.g. in the case of a job loss, become an entrepreneur, start your own business and create jobs. With rising petrol prices, use public transport, get a bicycle or walk, and become extremely fit. In response to climate change and an energy crisis, reduce power usage, install solar panels, invent a new heating/cooling device, or recycle). What really are problems? Problems are when things do not go the way we expected them to go, the way we hoped matters would have developed; when we take things for granted and something totally different happens. Problems are when we are faced with an outcome that is different to what we wanted, expected, hoped for or had calculated. Some problems occur because of what we did, or incorrect choices we made, e.g. you drank too much at the party; you drove too fast and received a traffic fine; you studied the wrong material; you sent an email to the incorrect person. You can interpret these problems either way: you did the wrong thing or you can describe it as not having done the right thing. Sometimes problems arise because we lack certain experience, skills or insight. During your school years, did your teachers sometimes give you tests to write and you thought you knew the answers but failed the test as you got the answers wrong? The problem: you were not prepared well enough; you did not study enough. So, some problems occur not because of what we did but because of what we did not do. For example, if you want to pour yourself a cold drink and there is none in the house, this problem was caused because you did not buy one. If you blame the problem on somebody else (e.g. parents, roommates, etc.), you are trying to shift the problem to them. However, did you actually communicate to them that you wanted them to buy the cold drink? Did you check afterwards that it was actually bought? If not, then you abdicated the action or responsibility for it, and did not delegate it. Why did you not buy the cold drink in the first place if it was intended for you? So you really have yourself to blame - own the problem and learn from it. Next time, buy it yourself or ask somebody else in time to buy it on your behalf, and then check afterwards that they bought it. 149
The same applies to examinations. Do not shift the blame to the college or the professor or lecturer when you do not pass an examination with the mark you wanted, and accuse them that the material had not been covered or not covered well enough. Did you study everything enough in your own time? Did you attend all classes? Did you ask enough questions until you understood the material? Obviously, there are many problems that will be caused by others and you suffer the consequences without any fault of your own, e.g. the economic crises around the world, climate change, energy shortages or water shortages, etc. In those cases, it is still up to you to decide what you do about the consequences. You will still have to act in one way or another: you can either say that these problems are not your problems, the world must sort them out, or others have to find solutions. Or you state that you believe you have the power to contribute your own part towards a solution (such as using less energy or water; making sure you have low debt, if any; and that you learn good financial skills). Depending on how you act or react towards problems, you see yourself either as a person in control of your life, solving problems that already have or potentially have an impact on your life, or you see yourself as a victim, at the mercy of other people solving all problems (or not). There is also another method of approaching problems: the ostrich approach - putting your head in the sand, pretending the problems do not exist or will go away by themselves if you ignore them long enough, i.e. trying to ignore reality. Does this attitude solve problems? Does it put the person in charge of his or her life? No. The person suffers the consequences in the same manner that the victim suffers. Both styles usually live a selffulfilling prophecy - they see the negative results happening which they believed would happen anyway, so they give up on action, bemoan their fate and do not solve the problems impacting on them. Similar challenges will be posed to you at work. Often, you will be expected to know something that you had not been shown by others. Or you break an unwritten company rule and are now facing a reprimand from your managers. It would be easy to blame others for your problems. However, ask yourself: did you try and establish all the necessary information or did you just assume you knew everything? Your lack of preventative action caused your problems. If you now learn from your problems, you will also learn to ask lots of questions and make sure you know what is expected of you. Try and prevent those problems that you have no control over. 150
Concrete
Abstract
(Kolb, D.A., Rubin, I & McIntyre, J. (1979) http://www-personal.umich. edu/~cberger/psi76.html) The following is a seven-step problem-solving cycle model that has also been proposed:
1 Evaluate 7 Identify
We often land in a problematic or challenging situation without being aware how we actually got there. At work, a problem suddenly lands on your desk. At home or among friends, a problem arises from nowhere and we have to confront it. Sometimes, we do not even recognise a problem as such, or are not aware that it exists while we are already suffering the consequences. This is particularly true if the problem has been caused by something we did not do or forgot to do and maybe should have done, and where others acted instead of us, in turn causing our problem. This problem could be getting bigger and bigger, without us knowing that it even existed. Consider this example: One of your friends experiences a severe financial crisis. He needs to borrow money from the bank. The bank wants somebody to sign surety for him as your friend has no assets. You trust your friend, are willing to help him, and believe you know him well and that he will get himself out of his situation, so you sign. Months or years later, you have forgotten about your signature - until one day, you establish that your friend never paid back his loan. The bank decided that your friend has no money and no assets and they now hold you liable for the loan as you had signed the surety. Yes, you can sue your friend but it will cost you legal fees upfront. You now have a problem that developed without your knowledge. Or perhaps you suspected it but refused to face up to it 153
Explore
Implement 6
3 Set goals
Select
4 Look at alternatives
152
earlier. You will gain nothing by blaming your friend. Accept that you were equally at fault and now have a problem. What could or should you have done differently? Firstly, it is unwise to sign a surety unless you are willing and able to actually pay the debt. Secondly, you should have monitored what your friend was doing about payments. Finally, you should have made sure that you were released from your surety as soon as possible with written proof of such release received from the bank. While it seems like an obvious step, identifying or recognising the problem is not always as simple as it sounds. Foresight is better than hindsight. For that we need insight. In some cases, people mistakenly identify the wrong source or cause of a problem, which will make attempts to solve it inefficient, useless or even harmful. So, double check that you are sure what the real problem is - not just the symptoms of the problem but the problem itself. In the example we cited, the real problem is not that the friend was dishonest and disloyal. The problem was that you had signed a surety, had not followed up and were now liable for these payments.
personal problems - their causes and effects could be much wider than originally anticipated. For example, if your test marks are lower than you had planned or expected, you might think the problem is that it was too difficult or that questions did not cover what you had covered in class. However, the real problem is probably that you had not studied enough or had left parts of your textbook out, or that you had left studying too close to the examination, thus not giving yourself enough time to study. The correct problem identification in this example would mean that the real problem was that you did not study earlier and more intensely. Incorrect identification would lead to incorrect action, e.g. only cause the student to blame rather than to solve the problem. In the work environment, this can happen when a machine breaks down because it was not serviced - you blame the operator or the manufacturer, but the real problem was negligence with maintenance perhaps yours if it was part of your responsibilities. Could this be a problem you have had with your car? Now that you know how to reach an understanding of a problem, it needs to be defined clearly and completely. At this stage, it is appropriate to write a problem statement. Writing a clear problem definition forces you to focus on boundaries for the problem or those that define the problem.
155
You can only strategise towards proper problem solutions if you understand these details - what is really causing the problem. This is an extremely important step. You may need to revisit this step a couple of times. As you work towards solutions, form a strategy, and try to implement and monitor it, you may suddenly find that you made a mistake at the analysis and definition stage. Start again and re-visit the cause-and-effect analysis for the newly discovered theory. Continuously analyse any interrelationships between some of the causes or effects. They may highlight additional causes and additional effects and consequences. Take the example of lower examination marks. Extra causes could have been severe illness (why the student could not study) or family pressures (e.g. financial problems, having to take on extra part-time work to help pay for essentials or looking after a child or sick relative, etc.). There are many other possibilities; to establish them requires thorough analysis. Apart from additional causes/potential causes, there may also be a host of additional effects/impacts resulting from the problem that have not been considered. These could be failing the year-end examinations, or having to repeat the year. Such failure could, in turn, be the reason why the student then wants to change to a different field of study. He/she could drop out altogether and would have to find work without tertiary qualifications, earning less money and having a lower chance of promotion later in his/ her working life and remaining a lowly-paid employee. Problems that occur in the work place can often be analysed via timeand-motion studies, audits of financial records, a review of accountability structures, line-and-staff management structures, work flow charts, as well as interviews with the divisions and people involved. Some problems are merely the tip of the iceberg, particularly if these problems have not been addressed before, have been left unattended and have become part of the corporate culture, e.g. an old, inefficient IT system, slow delivery systems, absenteeism among staff or pilferage in stores. This is usually the case if quality is compromised (to save cost and time), if there is no monitoring of input or output, or if staff members are left to their own devices (see laissez-faire leadership in Unit 4). When the company is finally forced to face up to the problems, maybe because of financial stress, it is often too late to find solutions and the company may be forced to close. 157
Read up how you can work through the layers of a problem. State which of these three approaches you find most helpful. Give reasons why you find this the most helpful method.
156
Where problems have been identified as a whole series of interrelated problems, your most efficient way to get to the root cause of these problems is the drill down technique which allows you to examine each problem in depth, breaking the problems down into each aspect that will have to be addressed (http://www.mindtools.com/pages/article/newTMC_02.htm). The larger the risk involved in actions we have to take, the more people like to consult others before making a decision. Other people have different perspectives and views. Knowing their opinion helps us to become less subjective, and ensures that we consider other options and make decisions once we are better informed. It is always wise (safer) to also draw on other peoples experiences so that the solution we finally choose is the best under the circumstances. The term CAF is also used (i.e. consider all factors), e.g. by consulting other relevant persons who may know of influencing factors in other departments. When we discuss the various points of view with others, it may often result in a heated exchange of ideas. This is called constructive controversy. Its objective is to test a proposed solution by subjecting it to the clash of ideas, i.e. showing it to be wrong or proving it, disproving it or improving it. Some people refer to it as playing devils advocate. By having to defend or attack a specific idea, you clarify your own mind, your confidence in the proposed solution improves, or you now reject the idea as you reach a better understanding of all the factors involved. This problem-solving approach was introduced by David Johnson and Roger Johnson in 1979. It has been thoroughly researched and validated, and is acknowledged as an efficient method for developing robust and creative solutions to problems. It is based on these five assumptions: We adopt an initial perspective towards a problem based on our personal experiences and perceptions. The process of persuading others to agree with us strengthens our belief that we are right. When confronted with competing viewpoints, we begin to doubt our rationale. This doubt causes us to seek more information and build a better perspective, because we want to be confident with our choice. This search for a fuller perspective leads to better overall decision making.
Draw a Conclusion
Feel uncertain
(Johnson, D. & Johnson, R. 1979. http://www.mindtools.com) The more times you go through the cycle, the closer you come to the truth or the right solution. This process forces you to face your right or wrong assumptions. It stops you from drawing conclusions too quickly, and forces you to use clear reasoning to defend or argue against a proposed plan of action or for/against a specific definition of a problem. To apply this technique properly, you must follow a number of prescribed steps: Brainstorm possible definitions and reasons for the problem; then form advocacy teams (those who defend the proposed definition or action and are in favour of it, and those who believe it is not a good idea or not the correct reason). Each team is given a position to take, and then researches it and presents a best-case scenario supporting why that alternative should be chosen. Subsequently the two teams (or more if there are several alternatives) engage in constructive controversy. The teams present their case to the other groups. They have to try to persuade the others. This is followed by each team going through the same processes. The presenting team listens to the counter-arguments and tries to disprove them, and then defends its original position as best it can. Teams have to try and gain a better understanding of all options in order to make the best decision possible. They have to ask for solid data and to defend their conclusions.
158
159
After all teams have made their presentations, they then reverse their positions and argue for one of the options they originally tried to argue against. Peoples perspectives are now so dramatically changed that everybody gains a lot of understanding. Finally, the entire team has to make a decision. Their final proposal should now be better than the proposals made prior to this work session. While this is still being applied to the problem definition stage, the same process should be applied at the problem-solving strategy stage.
Discourage judgement at this stage or rank ordering of ideas. Get as much input as possible. Once this planning step has taken shape, only then select and evaluate the most obvious or best solution strategies. From the full list of approaches, first determine the criteria for a good solution, e.g. quality or cost, and then decide what elements are needed for a realistic, practical and appropriate solution, as well as the criteria you will use to choose between potential solutions. Once you have set the parameters, it will be much easier to select the best solution options.
160
161
Do you now have enough information to analyse the background to the current problem? Do you have enough information to be able to see which potential problems could occur? What do you not yet know? Have you conducted an impact analysis to establish if the problem solution will have major effects/impacts on many people, the environment or the companys financial situation? Do you know what resistance you can expect from civic society or special interest groups? Only once you can answer all these questions and have all the facts, can you make the final go or no-go decision, supported by the relevant facts and figures or studies. Many decision makers will not proceed if they cannot back up their decisions by significant and substantial data - it removes the sole risk from them, and they can revert to the data when challenged and base it on independent facts rather than a subjective decision. At this stage, you may also again apply the constructive controversy technique as it will force you to obtain additional information. We have already discussed the technique in detail. For it to be fully effective, remember to follow a number of rules: People must work together in a constructive, open and positive frame of mind. They must try to arrive at the best possible solution. Avoid competing with one another. Demonstrate mutual respect at all times. Criticise ideas, not people. Focus on good decision making, not winning. Listen actively and ask for clarification when necessary. Commit to understanding all sides of an issue. Be willing to change positions when the evidence suggests its necessary. Use rational arguments and draw conclusions based on facts, evidence and sound reasoning. If this task form is held in a conducive environment, does not bring any hidden agendas and participants have the necessary skills to manage this type of structured conflict, the results will significantly add to the successful problem-solving process (Johnson & Roger, 1979). 162
Once these potential failures have been identified, the potential consequences of each are rated according to: Severity how critical is the failure? Occurrence how likely is the failure to happen? Detection how easy will it be to detect the failure? They then identify the most serious threats and alter the design to eliminate or minimise the likelihood of the failure identified. So, let us assume that you have now established that you have a problem (you know what the problem is) and have derived a problem statement; have analysed what caused the problem and know what the effect will be if you do not find good solutions; have formulated a strategy of what you could do to solve the problem; have obtained all facts and figures, and all information needed to assess the extent and severity of the problem; have looked at alternative options; and have decided on a solution with full knowledge of what resources you have available for this task.
To implement any process successfully, you need buy-in from everybody involved. If you do not receive good support from management and those affected, the whole implementation process can collapse. This means that during the planning and researching stage, you must convince other stakeholders that your solution is the best one, and can and will work within the set parameters. You will soon find out who will support you and where you will meet with resistance. Get input, listen to what people say and make changes as necessary. Once you know what the final action plan will be, having made the necessary adjustments, and you have convinced your key stakeholders to support your proposed solution, you start the actual implementation stage. An immediate hands-on review will check that everything should happen according to the action plan and will precede major monitoring (that everything is going to have the desired results): Are the people now available who were allocated to the tasks (illness or holidays could prevent this)? Are the funds liquid/ready to be used? Are there any other complications that could interfere with the implementation? What alternatives could be applied? Did the first stage of the implementation go according to plan? If not, which immediate corrective action can be taken? What does such action involve? Is this all readily available? Are decision makers willing and able to allocate these resources?
164
As progress is being made, are the solutions still moving in the right direction? Are there setbacks? How severe are they? What are the consequences? Does the plan need any adjustments? Are these major or not? What will be involved in such adjustments? When are the first visible signs of success apparent? Does this success remain in place? Is the solution sustainable in the long term? What needs to be put in place to prevent the problem recurring? What can be done to prevent it? Will it need special financial or human resources?
166
167
a good idea to rush into a decision; it may be the wrong approach to the problem. There are various tools available to check how good you are at this stage in solving problems. Use this quiz to check if you are an effective problem solver, or what you still need to learn to become effective.
Do you systematically search for issues that may become problems in the future? When you decide on a solution, do you make it happen no matter what opposition you may face? Do you find that small problems often become much bigger in scope, and thus very difficult to solve? Do you ask yourself lots of different questions about the nature of the problem? After your solution is implemented, do you then relax and focus again on your regular duties? Do you focus on keeping current operations running smoothly and hope that problems dont appear? Do you evaluate potential solutions as you think of them? When you need to find a solution to a problem, do you usually have all of the information you need to solve it? When evaluating solutions, do you take time to think about how you should choose between options? Is making a decision the end of your problem-solving process? You will receive a score and the score interpretation. Write down your final score interpretation and discuss with your lecturer and fellow students how you fared, and why. How many students scored 16 to 36 points and thus view problems as negatives, instead of seeing them as opportunities to make exciting and necessary change? They may have had some poor problem-solving experiences in the past. With more practice, and by following a more structured approach, they will be able to develop this important skill and start solving problems more effectively right away. How many students scored 37 to 58 points? Their approach to problem solving could be a bit hit-and-miss. Sometimes the solutions work really well and other times they dont. Knowing what to do is not the same as actually doing the right thing. They need to work on being consistent and committed to the process to see significant improvements. How many students scored 59 to 80 points (without having cheated or pretended!)? They should really be the confident problem solvers. They tend to approach problems systematically, take time to understand the problem, understand how to arrive at a good decision, and generate good 169
5.6.1 Activity: take the quiz - how good are you at solving problems?
Go to http://www.mindtools.com/pages/article/newTMC_72.
Now take the test. Instructions: For each statement, click the button in the column that best describes you. Please answer questions honestly and not how you think you should answer. Do not worry if some questions seem to score in the wrong direction. When you are finished, please click the Calculate My Total button at the bottom of the test. The quiz will ask you to state how often (not at all, rarely, sometimes, often or very often) you take any of the stated actions/steps in confronting a problem. Once you choose a solution, do you develop an implementation plan with the sequence of events necessary for completion? After a solution has been implemented, do you immediately look for ways to improve the idea and avoid future problems? To avoid asking the wrong question, do you take care to define each problem carefully before trying to solve it? Do you strive to look at problems from different perspectives and generate multiple solutions? Do you try to address the political issues and other consequences of the change you are proposing so that others will understand and support your solution? Do you evaluate potential solutions carefully and thoroughly against a predefined standard? 168
solution options. Decisions are well thought out, well-planned and wellexecuted. This quiz is based on Min Basadurs Simplex problem-solving model referred to before. The process follows the circular pattern shown below, where current problems are solved and new problems are identified on an ongoing basis.
You need to look actively for problems as part of your daily life and your working life, and as part of any effective problem-solving process. Proactive, preventative problem-solving skills help to reduce the potential incidence of large problems. What can you do to become proactive in this process? How do you actually know what to look out for? Obviously, it is easier to work on historical data: if something went wrong in the past, causing problems, it is then also more likely that this could happen again, except if all the conditions for such recurrence have changed, have been eliminated or have been replaced by efficient systems (http://www.mindtools.com/pages/article/newTMC_07. htm,newTMC_82, newPPM_73.htm, newTED_01htm, newHTE_92htm) Consult the above website to learn more about potential problems in the business environment. There are a number of recognised techniques that can be used to assess potential flaws in the business environment which could cause problems. Some of these techniques are: The PEST Analysis, which looks at changes in trends, your environment, customer needs and market dynamics that you should pay attention to. The Risk Analysis, which identifies significant business risks. The Failure Modes and Effects Analysis, which identifies possible points of failure in your business process, allowing you to correct these before problems arise. The After Action Review, which allows you to scan recent performance to identify aspects and steps that can be improved in the future. The Prioritisation and Pareto Analysis, which helps you to prioritise what actions to take when, and which problems are the more important ones to read up on.
8. Action
1. Problem Finding
7. Sell Idea
2. Fact Finding
Simplex
6. Planning 3. Problem Definition
5. Selection
4. Idea Finding
Figure 9 Simplex problem-solving process (Basadur, M. Eight-step problem solving process, the Simplex Process, The Power of Innovation. The Simplex Process - Problem Solving Training http://www.Mindtools.com) The tools and strategies for each stage of the problem-solving process have been discussed in detail under section . Go back to this section to revise what you have learned so far about the problem-solving process.
170
Do you still need to improve them further? How are you going to do that?
Action
Date
5.7.3 Activity: assessing areas that need further corrective action, time lines
Now list all those areas that you have not yet improved upon or not sufficiently improved upon. State why you have not yet achieved such positive change. What held you back? How are you going to move forward from now on? By doing what?
Problem area
Score
Action
Date
Score
Action
Date
5.8 Conclusion
In this unit, we examined EPD strategy formulation, problem definitions, problem-solving techniques, and problem-solving strategies. We reviewed your personal development progress. We have now added the element of problem-solving skills so that you can turn your own personal problems into opportunities!
172
173
In the next unit, we will focus on monitoring and controlling. This will include measuring progress made, milestone setting, achievements, gap management and problem-solving progress.
Based on the discussion in this unit, prepare a document to focus on the following: Identify your problems (personal, interrelationships, study skills, work, etc.). Rank them in order of importance. Define the problems clearly as to their causes and effects. Describe a strategy for how you will solve each one of these problems. What facts and extra information can you supply for each problem area to enable a better solution? Give a structure and time line by when you will address every problem. What exactly will you do to solve each problem? Justify each process and action. Now set up a specific action plan. How will you monitor and assess each step and the success of your action? What do you hope to achieve with and through such action? What is your long-term goal?
6.1 Introduction
Over the past five units, we examined how to take responsibility for own personal and professional development. That encompasses assessing current personal skills levels and shortcomings, developing and maintaining 174 175
a personal portfolio, and compiling and presenting transcripts. It also includes how to develop professionalism and skills, such as effective communication, negotiation, assertiveness, time management, problem solving and social skills. We also covered decision-making processes and skills, ethics, employment rights and responsibilities, team dynamics, leadership and management styles, incentives and motivation at work, performance measurements and promotion. We will cover in more detail how to apply all the theoretical knowledge to your own personal and professional life. For this, you will have to revisit the following: how to reassess and monitor your own performance objectives; your current performance, future needs, and opportunities and threats to career progression; re-set a clear development plan with aims and objectives, achievement dates, review dates, a learning programme with activities, and set action plans; evaluate whether your problems were solved or not; measure the desired solutions against actual outcomes; demonstrate your acquired interpersonal and transferable skills, and prove that they are sustainable. If you can prove that you have mastered these skills, you will then also be truly employable - a professional person ready to climb the corporate ladder and on the path to a successful career. Part of good management and self-management is to know - at all times - that your tasks are on track against predetermined yardsticks. This ensures productivity, efficient allocation of resources and optimal outcomes. Management achieves such measurements through ongoing control, evaluation and monitoring of all steps involved. The same applies to self-management. If you want to know whether you are making progress, you have to control what you are doing, evaluate where you were and to what extent you have managed to progress towards your goals, and keep on monitoring your actions.
6.2 Control
6.2.1 Definitions of control
What do we understand by the term control? When talking about control as part of self- management, management authors such as Fayol and Weber describe controlling as an integral part of the managerial function because it helps to check for errors, and to take corrective action to minimise deviation from standards and ensure the stated goals of the organisation are achieved in a desired manner. Control in management terms means setting standards and objectives, measuring actual performance, giving feedback and taking corrective action. According to Henri Fayol, control consists of seeing that everything is being carried out in accordance with the plan which has been adopted, the orders which have been given, and the principles which have been laid down. Its object is to point out mistakes in order that they may be rectified and prevented from recurring. EFL Breach describes control as checking current performance against predetermined standards contained in the plans, with a view to ensuring adequate progress and satisfactory performance. Harold Koontz has a similar approach, describing control as the measurement and correction of performance in order to make sure that enterprise objectives and the plans devised to attain them are accomplished. Robert J. Mockler believes that control can be defined as a systematic effort by business management to compare performance to predetermined standards, plans or objectives in order to determine whether performance is in line with these standards, and presumably in order to take any remedial action required to see that human and other corporate resources are being used in the most effective and efficient way possible in achieving corporate objectives (Breach, Koontz, & Mockler, 2009). Management functions are known to be planning, organising, leading and controlling. All these definitions clearly presume that there should be prior clear objectives, standards for efficiency, plans and performance. Control then serves to adjust actions as needed to achieve the plan, or to contain variations of any objectives within allowable limits. If variations are observed 177
176
as a result of effective control, remedial action can be initiated before any serious damage or losses are incurred.
and measurements. This reality is not only applicable to the business environment, but also to our personal lives. For every effective method of control, there has to be efficient information. For example, the norms of acceptable behaviour become the standard against which sub-standard (or deviant) behaviour is measured. Therefore, the standard has to be set first, then communicated, and then actions and achievements measured. This again needs to be communicated. Without the correct information flow and communication, standards would not be known, nor met. Parents, for example, cannot expect their children to behave perfectly if they are not briefed and educated about suitable behaviour and standards of conduct. The rules of any game must be clear before the match starts. The most difficult type of control is monitoring the behaviour of individuals, comparing performance with some standard, and providing rewards or penalties. Sometimes, this control relates entirely to their output (such as sales). Other times, it relates nearly exclusively to behaviour (interaction with other people). Individuals levels of motivation and the measurement of their performance frequently become subjective judgements made by the supervisor or manager - especially where there are no clear and objective measurement criteria, such as timeous completion of accounts, meeting sales targets, making a good presentation, or winning a contract for a product or service. To perform such control, objective systems are set up that make judgements easier. These are: Setting performance standards Measuring actual performance Comparing actual performance with standards Analysing deviations/shortfalls Correcting deviations
179
No two people are alike, even if they both perform the same tasks or the same job. No two companies operate in exactly the same manner, with identical objectives, time lines, etc. There are even noticeable differences between government departments, between schools and between hospitals, all of which can be expected to operate with clear policies and objectives relating to their functions. Problems will always occur. The best way to control a company is to remain flexible, adjust to changing circumstances, and review goals, standards and measurements on a regular basis. Things change, circumstances change, people change. When personal attributes are set as standards, it becomes equally difficult to quantify whether a positive shift or change has been achieved or not. Subjective inputs have to be transformed into numerical data so that they can be measured instead of only looked at in a qualitative manner. However, there is the danger of there being an incorrect interpretation of the numerical meaning compared with the verbal meaning. Very often, ratings are too limiting or too complicated. They do not take into consideration that circumstances and situations vary, while daily events can influence perceptions, reactions and performance. For example, the behaviour of a young programmer is rated from 1 to 10, with 10 being the perfect behaviour. After determining the ranking for each situation where his behaviour was judged, adding these and dividing by the total number of such measured situations, the average ranking would indicate a particular programmers score on his behaviour. On the basis of this score, judgements might be made about his ability to perform appropriately. One programmer with a ranking of 5 might be considered to perform better than another who had a ranking of 5, and yet the two programmers may have performed correctly under different circumstances and conditions. External factors beyond their control may have influenced their performance, particularly bias and inaccuracies of the assessing manager. Measuring human performance, despite its extreme difficulty, subjectivity and imprecision compared with measuring quantitative factors such as items sold, is one of the most important control tools in large companies. The performance of individuals ultimately dictates the success or failure of every company. Job applicants and their potential to be future leaders and managers are often judged on a subjective basis. Although there may be some guidelines on current performance and behaviour informing such judgements, these are still biased/subjective and may even be unfair.
Control must also be timely. It is unfair to employees to receive information about their rating and suggested corrective action half way through to the next assessment/measurement. The employee then does not have enough time to correct his/her action or attitude to sufficiently influence the next rating.
6.2.5 Self-control
We looked at the meaning of control and how it is applied in different circumstances in an organisational context. However, can one also apply control to oneself? What is self-control? Self-control means being in control of your emotions, your responses and managing yourself. If you control your emotions, actions and responses, you are then also in charge of your own achievements. If you have no control over your emotions and responses, you are undisciplined and a victim of your own emotions and circumstances. Please also refer to the discussion on emotional intelligence (EQ). If you are in control of yourself, your reactions and responses, it means that you can also apply discipline to whatever you plan to do - your emotions will not control your actions. You will control anger or frustration that you may experience in the work place and in your private life. You remain controlled and professional. Self-control is learned appropriate behaviour, applied to changing circumstances and environments. People with good self-control can evaluate situations and adjust their own behaviour. Often described as keeping a cool head, such people can also evaluate their own performance and take corrective measures as and when required. 181
180
As there is a trend towards independent contract work, freelance work and people working from home, it becomes essential for people in these working situations to be able to apply not only self-discipline but also self-control. Only they know what they do each hour of the day, how productive or efficient they are and where they waste time, how they are going to increase output, and how they measure their own achievements or apply corrective action if and where needed. They also have to control their emotions and remain professional even in difficult circumstances (e.g. spouse and children demanding attention, electronic equipment not working, etc.). This is not an easy task. Without control by others, many people lack self-discipline, do not manage to set themselves good working routines (see time management in Unit 3) or settle for low-level, unchallenging outcomes. Comfort zones, distractions and emotional challenges interfere with the necessary self-control.
Control does not necessarily result in an improvement of performance - changes only happen when there are clear goals and achievement is accurately measured, plus corrective action is taken. You can, for example, control how long it takes you to finish a task - that in itself is no assurance of quality. Control should ideally be future-focused so that there is a future improvement, or at least a guarantee of maintained quality or efficient performance. Monitoring is a continuous process put in place to assess quality, ongoing improvement or maintained performance. Monitoring is useful when you test new systems, new production processes and new medication, test acceptance of certain procedures, assess technical performance (e.g. fuel efficiency in cars), assess workflows and efficiencies, and check expenditures against performance and achievements. Monitoring is the systematic collection and analysis of information as a project progresses. It is aimed at improving the efficiency and effectiveness of a project, an organisation, a business unit or an individual. It is based on set targets and activities planned during the planning phases of work. It helps to keep the work on track and serves as an early warning that things are going wrong.
6.3 Monitoring
6.3.1 Definition
What is monitoring and how does it differ from control? Control assumes some power is being exercised over something or somebody. When it is self-control, the power then rests with oneself. 182
Example 1: You monitor your diet. You can see if you gain weight and if you lose weight. Monitoring will give you the actual weight - nothing more. At that stage, you make assumptions why you gain or lose weight at certain times. Once you correlate what you ate/drank, and when and how much you exercised with your weight gains or losses, you will get a superficial reason. You then need to evaluate in depth what could be the cause of the weight gain or loss, e.g. by checking the calories consumed, the length and intensity of the exercises, your overall health, stress factors, illness, etc. Once you have established the cause, you can then take corrective action. 183
The same applies to monitoring performance in a company or in your private life when you have set specific goals that you want to achieve. Through monitoring, you try to observe and review progress, and identify the existence of problems. Once the monitored progress has been analysed and evaluated, corrective action can be taken to get closer to the goal. This process is repeated again and again, until a firm, positive pattern has set in. Example 2: Say you monitor the money in your savings account. If you regularly deposit money into the account and earn interest, then you should see a steadily increasing amount of money. Should the monthly amount of money you deposit not increase and if there are no changes to the interest rate, then your savings will increase at a steady pace, with compound interest. Monitoring such savings will be a relaxed exercise as there are no severe disturbances to the pattern. However, if you erratically withdraw differing amounts, and sometimes deposit money but not regularly or on fixed dates, then you have a more challenging task monitoring your savings levels. Forecasting how much money you will have saved in five years time will be near impossible. Goals or plans are essential both in your personal life and in business - but they are not necessarily permanent. If monitoring shows that the plans are not working or if circumstances change, then plans and goals need to change too. Monitoring helps to assess when plans are not working and when circumstances have changed. Monitoring identifies that something is going right or going wrong, and the direction it is moving in. It does not identify the cause or effect of change; it does not prescribe or even suggest what corrective action needs to take place. Evaluation or in-depth assessment can identify problems and their causes; it can find possible solutions to problems, and raise questions about assumptions, previous objectives, goals and plans, or strategy. Monitoring purely identifies direction and that a problem may exist. Evaluation normally only happens when monitoring has shown that there is a problem - or if success has been larger than anticipated and the reason for that must be understood so that it can be repeated. This then combines monitoring and evaluation. Together, they provide the individual or the company with very useful information for further action and possible corrective measures. 184
Monitoring starts with the plan and moves through various steps which include evaluation, learning, reflecting, monitoring, deciding and implementing. Some of these steps interlink. 1. Plan 2. Implement 3. Monitor 4. Reflect/learn 5. Implement 6. Monitor 7. Reflect/learn 8. Decide/adjust 9. Evaluate/learn
Which parts of your goals did you not achieve? Why did you not achieve those? What held you back? What went wrong? What are you going to do to achieve the remainder of your goals? How do you need to change your approach so that you will achieve the goal this time? By when do you want to achieve this? Do you now want to set new goals? Which ones? By when do you want to achieve those new goals?
It would be more difficult to provide proof that an individual has become more honest ... how do we know if he/she has not been telling lies? How do we know that the person is now more professional? The only proof would be to look at individual parameters that demonstrate being professional, and then assess the behaviour and the performance of the individual under a variety of circumstances, settings and challenges. You need to decide what your proof or indicators are to begin collecting the information through your monitoring activity. This assumes that you measured the starting point and know where you want to be once the goals have been reached.
Who is going to record it? Who will analyse the data at the various stages and at the end of the measuring period? Who will interpret the analysed data? How will the evaluation be handled to lead to corrective action? Who will handle this? How will it be communicated? Rating scales help you to record data where the individual is rating progress on attributes. This technique makes use of a continuum, along which students or employees are expected to place their own feelings, observations, etc. People are asked to say whether they agree strongly, agree, dont know, disagree, or disagree strongly with a statement. It is useful to measure attitudes, opinions and perceptions. You need to test the statements very carefully to make sure that there is no chance of misunderstanding. You can also have scales which rate a statement from 1 (extremely poor) to 10 (extremely good). Or you could use scales where the mid-point would represent neither, with two poles at either side. The use of a scale of 4 eliminates the tendency to select the neutral middle 3 on a traditional scale of 5. Sometimes, it is useful to have scales where agreement/disagreement with statements is measured.
Why do you need to evaluate data which you have monitored? What is the purpose of such evaluation? How can you record evaluated data? How can you record monitored data?
Recognise that change is exciting; it frees you from doing things that do not work.
Have others commented on any such changes? What were their comments?
190
191
6.7 Development plan, revision of aims and objectives, achievement dates, action plan, activities
6.7.1 Activity: planning own performance enhancement
So far, you have learned various skills to become more professional and employable. It is now time for you to write a formal development plan for yourself. Describe your aims and objectives. Remember that they have to be very precise as you will have to monitor them. State dates by which you undertake to have achieved these skills. Develop an action plan and the activities this will include so that you will gain the needed skills.
192
193
interacted in class. You have grown to some extent as a person and as a student. Your family may even notice a difference. Use the example of a monitoring and evaluating report, and write a full formal report on your own personal development process, from the original assessments across all skills taught in the six units. Use the format suggested. Pay particular attention to the conclusions which ask you to show what you have learned from all assessments, and the recommendations where you need to state in full detail what you plan for your future, what goals you are now setting, and how you will monitor progress, evaluate what you assess and correct your actions.
6.11 Conclusion
We covered the basic skills that you should master to become a professional, ready to be employed and to build a successful career. These skills will serve you well in business and in your personal life. They will empower you to be a confident and effective communicator, professional at all times in words and deeds and possessing good time management skills. You know now what is required to be an effective team player as well as a developing manager or leader. You will be able to distinguish between leaders and managers with the knowledge required to play a suitable role, choosing between the two and making the correct choices in life. You have learned how to solve problems, and how to strategise, plan, control, monitor and evaluate. You should be ready to go for your job interview, knowing how to present your CV, supported by a complete range of transcripts and a portfolio. You should also know your basic rights and duties at work.
At the end of this unit, you have almost completed the course. You have also studied other courses. You have completed assignments and you have 194 195
Part of good management and self-management is to know - at all times - that you are on track against predetermined yardsticks. This ensures productivity, efficient allocation of resources and optimal outcomes. Management achieves such measurements through ongoing control, evaluation and monitoring of all steps involved. This also applies to self-management. If you want to know whether you are making progress or not, you have to control what you are doing, evaluate where you are and to what extent you have managed to progress towards your goals, and keep on monitoring your actions. During tough economic times, not only will students find and keep work easier if they have acquired the extra employability and professional skills, it will also give them a sound basis for becoming entrepreneurs, should they select to start their own businesses.
7.1 Introduction
Over the past six units, we examined how to assess personal strengths and weaknesses, which skills have already been developed, and which still need to be gained regarding employability, professionalism and all factors included in these attributes. The ultimate aim of this course is to lead the student to the stage where he/she can take responsibility for continued personal and professional development. This includes decision-making processes and skills, ethics, leadership and management skills, problem-solving skills and employmentrelated behaviour codes. In Unit 6, we covered the establishment of a comprehensive personal development plan. This unit concludes the course and will focus on review, monitoring and evaluation. 196
Will this create greater benefits in your future? What proof will you need to see that your activities have caused the desired outcome? Did you ask for/get feedback from others? Did this feedback cause you to take any extra corrective action? What was that? What was the result?
Since completion of the previous unit, did you make any further progress towards achieving your set goals? What progress was there and how did you achieve this?
199
Your answer
Your answer
Your answer
200
201
Your answer
Your answer
Your answer
Your answer
Your answer
202
203
Your answer
Your answer
204
Summarise the main points taught in each of the six units and in this last unit. What was the major aspect you learned in each of these units? Unit 1 - Introduction to employability and professional development Unit 2 - Performance assessment, professionalism and development plan Unit 3 - Effective communication and time management Unit 4 - Understanding the dynamics of working with others Unit 5 - Strategy formulation and problem solving Unit 6 - Monitoring and controlling Unit 7 Summary and conclusions What did the whole course teach you about yourself?
7.6 Conclusion
We have re-analysed the basic skills that you have to master to become a professional individual, ready to be employed and to build a successful career. We also looked at how these skills can help you in case you decide to become an entrepreneur. You should be able to develop into a successful leader, manager, entrepreneur or problem solver who is able to strategise, plan, control, monitor and evaluate your own performance according to your goals and your personal development plan.
You have now completed the course. You have looked at various options, either employment or becoming an entrepreneur. You have grown as a person and as a student. You should now be ready for your final examination in this course.
206
207
Bibliography
Amended Basic Conditions of Employment Act. 1997 (BCEA). http://www.ils.co.za/act.pdf Armstrong, J.S. 1980.Bafflegab Pays. Psychology Today. Issue 12.http://qbox.wharton.upenn.edu/documents/mktg/research/ Bafflegab%20Pays.pdf Bailey, L. 2012. Education writer. Email: [email protected] Barnlund, D.C. 2008:47-57. A transactional model of communication. In C.D. Mortensen (Eds.), Communication theory. 2nd edition. New Brunswick, New Jersey: Transaction. Basadur, M. Eight-step problem solving process, the Simplex Process. The Power of Innovation. The Simplex Process - Problem Solving Training. http://www.mindtools.com/pages/article/newTMC_07.htm,newTMC_82, newPPM_73.htm, newTED_01htm, newHTE_92htm Berko, R.M., Wolvin, A.D. & Wolvin, D.R. 2010:912. Communicating. 11th edition. Boston, MA: Pearson Education, Inc. Breach, E.F.L., Koontz, H. & Mockler, R.J. 2009. The Control Function of Management. International Business Notes-MGU. Chandler, D. The Transmission Model of Communication.http://www. Aber.ac.uk/mediacommunication Convention on the Rights of Persons with Disabilities, 2008. http://www.searo.who.int/LinkFiles/Publications_SEA_ Disabilities_CRPD.pdfhttp://www.un.org/disabilities Article 2. Definition. World Health Organisation. Erhard, W, Jensen, M.C. & Granger, K.L. March 23 2011 Leadership. Harvard Business School: Social Science Electronic Publishing (SSEP), Inc. http://www.wernererhard.com and http://papers. ssrn.com/sol3/papers.cfm?abstract_id=1392406 Felder, Prof R.M. & Soloman, B.A., 2005. North Carolina State University.http://www4.ncsu.edu/unity/lockers/users/f/felder/public/ ILSdir/styles.htm 208
Goleman, D. 1995. Emotional Intelligence. Random House Publishing Group. http://www.eiconsortium.org/reports/what_is_emotional_ intelligence.html Goleman, D., Boyatzis, R.E. & McKee, A. 2002. Primal Leadership: Learning to Lead with Emotional Intelligence.http://www.eiconsortium. org/reports/what_is_emotional_intelligence.html Hariman, R. 2004. Graduate programs: Rhetoric and Public culture. Communication studies. Department of Communication studies, Northwestern University. Email: [email protected]. Hariman, R. & Salazar, L.F. 2004. Also developed models for understanding leadership.http://www.communication.northwestern.edu/ faculty/ast.php jar.sagepub.com/content/23/1/6.refsSimilar Heyman, R. 1994. Why Didnt You Say That in the First Place? How to Be Understood at Work. 1st edition. San Francesco, CA: Jossey-Bass Inc. How to Start a Self-Assessment Paper. eHow.com. http:// www.ehow.com/how_6453248_start-self-assessment-paper. html#ixzz27tZ0e5JD How to Write an Effective and Powerful Self-Evaluation for a Performance Review. eHow.com. http://www.ehow.com/ how_2181299_effective-powerful-selfevaluation-performance-review. html#ixzz27tdCkLA9 http://www.eiconsortium.org/members/goleman.htmhttp://www.gartner. com/technology/contact/contact_africa.jsphttp://www.gdnet.ucla.edu/ asis/agep/advcv.pdf On writing an up-to-date Curriculum Vitaehttp://www. humanmetrics.com/Personality types http://www.queendom.com/tests On EQ self-assessment testshttp://www.learnmanagement2.com On the communication process http://www.mindtools.com http:// www.mindtools.com/CommSkll/NegotiationSkills.htm On win-win negotiations http://www.mindtools.com/pages/article/ worksheets/PrioritizedToDolistDownload.htm On task schedulinghttp://www.mnn.com/money/sustainablebusiness-practices/stories/employers-should-offer-perks-outside209
the-paycheck http://www.talentsmart.com Johnson, D. & Johnson, R. 1979. http://www.mindtools.com On constructive controversy Kolb, D.A., Rubin, I. & McIntyre, J. 1979. http://www-personal.umich.edu/~cberger/psi76.html McShane, S. & Travaglione, T. 2007. Organisational behaviour on the Pacific Rim. 2nd edition. NSW, Australia : McGraw-Hill Irwin. Montana, P. J. & Charon, B. H. 2008:333. Management. 4th edition. New York: Barrons Educational Series, Inc. Non-verbal communication. http://www.businessdictionary.com/ definition/non-verbal-communication Pedler, M., Burgoyne, J. & Boydell, T. 2001. A Managers guide to self-development. 4th edition. London: McGraw-Hill. Ratcliffe, J., Chairman of The Futures Academy at the Dublin Institute of Technology. A 3D model of the life of a smart worker in 2030. http://www.ideaprojects.co.uk/files/7066_smart_workplace_ elements.zi Schramm, W. 1954:3-26. How communication works. In W. Schramm (Ed.). The process and effects of communication. Urbana, Illinois: University of Illinois Press. Seven-step problem solving cycle, University of South Australia. http://www.w3.unisa.edu.au Shannon, C.E. & Weaver, W. 1949. The mathematical theory of communication. Urbana, Illinois: University of Illinois Press Team definition http://www.businessdictionary.com/definition/team. html#ixzz29m1J58RU Tuckman, B.W. Development Sequence in Small Groups. Psychological Bulletin. 1965. Tuckman in collaboration with Jensen M.A. 1977. Updated model to include the fifth stage. Tyler, S., Kossen, C. & Ryan, C. 2005:9. Communication - A foundation course. 2nd edition. Australia: Pearson Prentice Hall.
Author Biography
Barbara Wood studied psychology and market research. She holds a Masters degree in Business Leadership. She has started and managed her own companies since 1975. They are in market research, media, advertising and consultancy. She is active in SACOB and the Johannesburg and Sandton Chambers of Commerce. She lectures part-time and is CEO of Woodlands Media. Ms Wood is active in promoting the involvement of women in business.
210