Controversy PDF
Controversy PDF
Controversy
Lesson code: 112R-H17F-2KV3 PRE-INTERMEDIATE
1 Warm-up
Is it a good idea to give money to beggars?
2 Key words
Match the underlined words to the correct definitions:
3 Reading
You are going to read an article about a proposal to ban begging in Norway. Decide if the following
statements are true (T) or false (F) and then read the text to check your answers.
1. Under the proposed law, people who offer money or food to beggars can go to prison for up to 2 years.
2. The government proposed the new law because there are too many beggars on the streets.
3. Norway's parliament started debating the ban on begging five years ago.
4. At the moment, begging is legal everywhere in Norway.
5. The new law is controversial.
6. Norway is Europe's richest country.
1 Norway has proposed a controversial new law. If the new law becomes a reality, it will be illegal to
help beggars on the streets. If this happens, people who offer money or food to beggars can go to
prison for between six months to a year, and organized begging will become a crime.
2 City authorities in Oslo are angry about the proposal, but Norway's justice minister Anders Anundsen
said the law was needed to stop people who run begging networks as an "organized business".
3 Norway's parliament started debating the ban on begging last year, because of the high number of
beggars on the streets. Individual councils are already able to ban begging, but now the government
wants a nationwide ban.
4 Inger Husby, from Oslo, often invites homeless people into her house. She is afraid that her `kindness'
will become illegal if the proposal becomes a law.
5 "They have stayed here several times," she said. "I give them a packed lunch, and I fill their cups with
cocoa. I wash their clothes when they need it and they come for dinner from time to time."
6 Karin Andersen, a member of parliament for the Socialist Left Party, tweeted her anger at the proposal
and accused the government of criminalizing poor people.
7 "Europe's richest country criminalizes Europe's poorest people," she said.
Adapted from The Independent, by Roisin O'connor Wednesday, February 4th, 2015
1. propose a. a law
2. go b. a reality
3. become c. for dinner
4. come d. money or food
5. offer e. to prison
Now make your own sentences using the above phrases.
1. If the new law becomes a reality, it illegal to help beggars on the streets.
2. If this , people who offer money or food to beggars to prison for
between six months to a year.
3. She is afraid that her `kindness' illegal if the proposal a law.
The above structure is called the first conditional. We use the first conditional to say what will happen in a
certain situation in the future. A first conditional sentence contains two halves:
7 Practice 1
Complete these first conditional sentences with the present simple or `will'. Only use contractions for
negatives - e.g. won't/don't.
8 Practice 2
Look at the possible future situations below. Form a sentence with `if' for each one like in the example.
9 Talking point
Discuss any of the questions below: