The Aesthethics of Metaphors Copy 2
The Aesthethics of Metaphors Copy 2
Rose Galea
Metaphor is not just pretty poetry, it is not good or bad logic, however, it is in
fact the logic upon which the biological world has been built; the main
characteristics and organising glue of the world of mental processes (Bateson,
2005).
In their seminal book ‘Metaphor we live By (1980), Lackoff and Johson describe
that the ___domain which maps onto the basic spatial concepts inherits a sort of
reasoning, of how concepts connect and flow, which are originally in the structure
of our bodily manipulation of space (facing the future, upright person, head of an
organisation, top of things
According to Stern (1985), the most functional and basic parts of a human
being need to be learned and understood by the infant in a primarily nonverbal
way. To survive in the world the infant has to learn to navigate the world. The
babies accumulate representations of objects, are able to anticipate, recall,
have memories of events and repeat them. Interactional patterns such as the
duration of the eye-contact, quality of touch, distance between people and
others are being laid down without the use of language
Language thus becomes a modality of the human body (Gallagher, 2005: 107),
which is born out of movement. Gallagher refers to Merleau-Ponty who claims
that the body converts certain motor essence into vocal form, and that body
knowledge is the foundation on which language rests.
According to Lakoff and Johnson (2003, 1999), metaphors are shaped by
the sense of us as embodied beings, and this is the basis for
understanding all sorts of concepts. Gibbs et al. (2004: 2) agree that “the
poetic value and the communicative expressiveness of metaphoric
language partly arises from its roots in people’s ordinary, felt sensations of
their bodies in action.” They defend a direct link between recurring patterns
of embodied experience, metaphor, conventional, and poetic language
He postulates that “the mind is embodied, in the full sense of the term, not
just embrained” (Damasio 1994: 93). Purely verbal psychotherapeutic
perspective need to move towards an inclusion of the embodied experience
Perception
Barsalou’s (1999) perceptual symbol system theory would support this view: It
shows clearly that cognition is inherently perceptual, and integrates the
positive contributions of the different existing approaches to knowledge,
namely, according to him includes representation, processing, and
embodiment.
Recent neurobiological findings claim that a neural foundation for intersubjectivity has been
discovered, which are the “mirror neurones”. Mirror neurons are the foundation of our pre-logic
and pre language understanding and interpretation of actions and emotions in others. These
neurones provide the neurological mechanisms for understanding the ability for core
intersubjectivity (Gallese, 2001). which can “overcome all linguistic and cultural
barriers” (Rizzolatti and Sinigaglia, 2008).
“We experience the other as if we were executing the same action or feeling the same emotion.
This “participation” in another’s mental life creates a sense of sharing with and understanding the
other, and in particular their intentions and feelings.”
Stern, p.81
The human nervous systems are designed for empathic response and intersubjective resonance,
which generates neural pathways which direct growth and development of the individual (Siegal,
2010)
Embodied Simulation
Embodied Simulation also characterises brain areas involved in the processing of emotion
and perception as well as cognitive tasks such as language comprehension or mental
imagery. This claim holds true even for the comprehension of bodily metaphors, namely
metaphors based on our bodily experiences (e.g., Boulenger. Hank, and Pulvermüller 2009;
Boulenger, Shtyrov, and Pulvermüller 2012; Desai et al. 2011; Desai et al. 2013).
Thus, the processing of a metaphorical expression such as “John grasps the idea” will
determine the activation of hand-related areas of the motor cortex too. It has been
suggested that, in this example, we comprehend the abstract concept of
“understanding” (the target ___domain of the metaphor) resorting to the physical action of
“grasping” (the source ___domain of the metaphor).
Bodily attitudes and sensations contribute to the implementation of cognitive tasks such as
language comprehension and social cognition. Neuroscientific data shows that during
simulation areas of the brain that process bodily sensations are not just confined to the
motor areas but involve also areas related to the experience of bodily sensations. (Cuckoo,
Steen, 2019, p 187).
Embodied Simulation and metaphor
Attention has a key role in deliberate metaphors processing. In fact, it is the attention we
pay to the source ___domain of a metaphor that makes a metaphor a deliberately processed
metaphor.
In fact, in this view, it is the attention we pay to the source ___domain of bodily-related
(grasped) metaphors that might determine a significant difference in the activation of
the mechanism of simulation compared to the processing of non-deliberate bodily
metaphors (Cuccio & Steen, 2019 p. 186).
In a face to face conversation, by virtue of the activation of this mechanism, both hearer
and speaker should, then, physically experience in their own bodies the bodily components
of the metaphors and they should share this experience, thus, living similar bodily
sensations. Both these conditions might determine a greater communicative effectiveness
of deliberate bodily metaphors compared to non deliberate one.
Metaphors in psychotherapy
Simply put, a metaphor is a figure of speech containing an implied comparison. ...
Here's a metaphor example: "The curtain of night fell upon us." In this metaphor,
the evening did not develop into a velvet curtain. Rather, simple words are being
used to paint a colourful picture.
Where verbal language seems limited, the use of movement and metaphor offers
new possibilities.
Exersize
The curtain of night fell upon us
What meaning would you give to this metaphor?
Can you come up with different metaphors that
capture your current experience?
Source ___domain - is the bodily experience, or known knowledge
Target ___domain - abstract
How is this act of perceiving in your mind’s eye similar to your actually looking
at your loved one’s face?
All our experiences and phenomenal world are built and maintained through
the inter-workings of approximation, association and image formation (Geary,
2012; Miller, 1996; Shahar, 2010). Daniel Siegel (2007) expresses his
understanding of this when he discusses the position and the power of images
in relation to brain and long-term neural growth. He states
Studies of mental imagery have now clearly revealed that the act of
perceptual imagining not only activates those regions of the brain involved in
the carrying out of the imagined action, but also produces long-term structural
growth in those very areas. (p. 201)
Embodied Imagery
Images, are not “mental” pictures seen in the “head” but rather, image-based felt
experiences found in the body/mind space and are referred to as Embodied
Images (Faranda,).
This embodied way of working with images is based on the understanding of the
mind as playful and figurative.
Image and metaphor are the basic currencies of emotional and linguistic
experience. Nestled within the “neural fibers” of metaphor and image are the proto
systems of self-formation and self-maintenance.
It is not the mere existence of an “image” that contributes to the therapeutic value,
but rather it is our experiential involvement with an image that brings forth the
increased therapeutic importance.
This is the kind of image that is less metal picture and more felt-experience. This is
an image that is neuronally connected to the systems of emotion, motor, and self.
The Brain on Images
Another layer in understanding the relationship of the image-making brain to our sense of
self is found in the realm of emotion. Panksepp (1998, 2003) contends that the foundations
of self are to be found in the “basic emotional circuits” (p. 199) of the brain. And according to
Damasio (2010, 2012), our feeling states are, in essence, images of emotion “made special
by their unique relation to the body” (p. 80).
The general capacity of the brain to simulate a state that isn’t actually occurring (as we do
during a therapy intervention), as in the “as if body loop” and the mirror neuron system, we
have an area of the brain that has all the equipment to generate, maintain, and I would
suggest further, repair the very fabric of self. Accessing this system then, in a therapeutic
context, is availing oneself of the functional and architectural capacity to re-establish, re-
integrate, and re-mobilize dissociated, fragmented, and frozen parts of the self.
Group work - dyads
Mental Image
1.Go to the place you would visit first after the isolation/
distancing is over
2.While discussing with another, try to bring up the image
that your client is trying to convey
3.Discuss with her/him the image you got from her
description and the embodiment that you experienced -
sensations etc
Symbols
Grainger (1990) writes about the intrapsychic qualities of symbol, namely that
which is in between; a bridge between inner and outer events. Metaphor and
symbol can therefore be described in psychological terms as the bridge
between the unconscious and the conscious and also between what is me and
not-me.
Tuby (1996), a Jungian analyst, describes the symbol as the third presence
that reconciles the conflicts between the unconscious and the conscious.
When we carry Tuby’s idea of a reconciling third presence out of the inner
world of the psyche and into the therapeutic space, we can begin to perceive
symbol as something that connects two people, a bridge of understanding.
The presence of a symbol can bridge between the conscious and unconscious
of the client and therapy and the middle ground approach or as in gestalt the in
between at the contact boundary
Gestures
Another area where we see the relationship of metaphor to affect and body is in gesture.
David McNeill (1992, 2007) has brought together tremendous research and theory on the
nature and meaning of gesture. He has effected unification between language and
gesture which provides support for our grounding of metaphor in the body.
Contrary to the once held idea that gesture was perhaps an early form of communication
predating verbal language, McNeill has convincingly shown that gesture appears to have
had a parallel ontological development. Metaphoric gesture is the body’s expression of a
felt bodily experience and, as such, is governed by very distinct brain regions from
voluntary gesture (Merleau-Ponty, 1962; McNeill, 2007).
Poetry is a tool that may be used in therapy to aid in emotional healing and
personal growth. It brings about insight, clarifies foggy issues, and bring a
smile to faces of people experiencing, anger , depression and anxiety. It can
be used to help clients overcome a number of emotional struggles, such as
traumatic experiences (Anderson, 1999)
The aesthetic value is the beauty contained within poems, the images they
crate and the psychological effect that this beauty has on the reader. The
aesthetic value of poetry has long been recognised and its healing effects on
our lives , where it transports us and help us engage in the deeper meaning
of our lives.
The rhythm in poetry helps us to know that we are inextricably
connected to nature and to the universe. Additionally the rhythm and
pattern of a poem whether it rhymes or not, has the soothing emotional
effect - like rocking a baby.
Rainer Maria Rilke claimed that only through a poetic language can a
“higher truth” be expressed. (I am so afraid of the word of man) he
comments on the inadequacy of language for expressing basic human
perceptions Rilke claims that human-kind kills the nature of things and
that only the lyrical, poetic can still perceive the “singing of the things”
Poetic iconicity
Although Reuven Tsur’s (1992, 2003) work in cognitive poetics never explicitly refers
to the notion of iconicity, his approach incorporates the relation of feeling and form
that is considered a necessary element in poetic iconicity. He argues that the effect of
poetry is to slow down or disrupt the conceptual processes that lead to constancy and
coherence (cognitive stability) and efficient coding of information (cognitive economy),
those elements of the mind that enable us to function “normally” in the world.
Under this view, what poetry is doing, like all the arts, is to bring us, for at least a little
while, into a certain relation with the world. This relation is variously described in the
arts, in different philosophies and religions, as expressing the inexpressible, ‘stopping
to smell the roses’, becoming one with the universe, to capture, in Merleau-Ponty’s
terms, the primordial experience of the invisible.
Poetic iconicity creates in language sensations, emotions, and images that enable the
mind to encounter them as phenomenally real. As Merleau-Ponty (1962: 404) notes,
moments of great danger and great love can trigger this response. It is what it means
to live wholly in the present moment, to grasp the phenomenally real.
The phenomenally real - the unseen world “from which the soul receives
its most rarefied nourishment. Everything existing in the visible world is
the imperfect mirror of this hidden reality” (Wheeler 2006: 23). This
“hidden reality” is the flip side of our everyday experience and may be
accessed at any moment.
Dyads - While one talks about anything that she wants the other while being attentive
and listening, tries to come up with a metaphor, or image, gesture, symbol or poetry
related to what she has been listening to
Alternate
Protocols for Working With Client Metaphors
Seven-Step
Interview Protocol a Six Step model
1. Notice metaphors. 1. Hearing a metaphor
2. What does the metaphor 2. Validating the metaphor
look like?
3. Explore metaphor(s) as 3. Expanding the metaphor
sensory image(s).
4. What is it like to be, what is 4. Playing with the possibilities (
your experience of, and what could include others in the client’s life)
are you feeling as you [the
metaphoric image]?
5. If you could change the 5. Marking and selecting
image in any way, how would
you change it?
6. What connections (parallels) 6. Connecting with the future
do you see between [the
metaphoric image] and the
original situation?
7. How might the way you
changed the image apply to
the current situation?
Kopp and Craw (1998). bSims (2003); Sims and Whynot (1997).
Art object
When practicing aesthetic experience a wordless silence can emerge. In addition, when we
explain the relational aspect of gestalt therapy, it is considered as a unique experience
which contributes to the ‘real experience’ which emerges between the therapist and the
client, and takes place ‘between’ (Spagnuolo Lobb,2013).
It is within this space that real contact is experienced between the two, in the here-and-now
space that is co-created. Francesetti, Gecele & Roubal, (2013) claim that using the aesthetic
concept for evaluation at the contact boundary, involves the felt experience, which is implicit
knowledge, that is pre-verbal and pre-cognitive (Francesetti, Gecele & Roubal, 2013).
Adding on to this, in his book “On the Occassion of the Other’ Robine (2011) describes the
situational activity and gives examples of Merleau-Ponty’s view of the body as being the
expressive space.
It becomes in between
When working in therapy; maintaining the connections to body, emotion, and image, as well as
maintaining, in myself (the therapist), a deeply felt experience of connection to the client, her
feelings, and her images. My willingness to be present, to get my hands dirty, if you will, becomes
what we might call a shared embodied experience. Such an experience is facilitating to the
healing potential of image work through fostering mutuality and engendering a safe enough space
for letting go.
Surrendering is not something one can access voluntarily. It happens in the moment at the
contact boundary, where there is less self, as we become engaged and enter into the world of
embodied images, our own conceptualisations of self fade from view.