1 CONCEPT PAPER: EDUCATION AND GENDER EQUALITY

Photo: Nicaragua, Christina Guldbrandsen

EDUCATION AND
CONCEPT PAPER

GENDER EQUALITY
Oxfam is guided by “Universal and Equitable access to Quality Education” and also the fact
that “lack of access and poor quality of education have serious consequences for especially
girls and women” (Oxfam Strategic Plan 2013-2019)..

In November 2016, in Copenhagen, in a meeting convened by Oxfam IBIS, Oxfam constituted

an “Education Community of Practice and Influence” agreeing that “Strengthening transforma-
tive public education for all to fight inequality” is the overall goal of our future education work.
Achieving this goal will:
1. Have a straight redistributive impact – putting ‘virtual income’ into the pocket of poor and
marginalized people – particularly in relation to girls and women.
2. Enhance social mobility.
3. Strengthen political mobilization - a transformative, quality education leads to knowing
your rights and responsibilities, having a voice, being able to participate and organize,
and building active citizenship for children, youth and adults.

This series of Oxfam IBIS concept papers define the Oxfam IBIS’ understanding and approach
in key areas.

Each paper contains the following sections:

A) Justification for Oxfam IBIS’ work on the issue
B) Brief overview of relevant theories and definitions
C) Presentation of Oxfam IBIS’ approach and lessons learned
D) References to further documentation
2 CONCEPT PAPER: EDUCATION AND GENDER EQUALITY

JUSTIFICATION
Gender inequality is a serious and pervasive form of discrimination affecting especially women
and girls. Discrimination against women and girls is a major obstacle to obtaining their rights
as citizens as well as to the development of societies. Non-discrimination and equality be-
tween women and men are central principles of human rights law. The Universal Declaration
of Human Rights adopted in 1948 proclaimed the equal entitlements of women and men to
the rights contained in it, without distinction of any kind, such as sex. The obligation of states
to eliminate discrimination based on sex is also underlined in the International Covenant on
Political and Civil Rights from 1966. The recently adopted Sustainable Development Goals
(SDGs) to be reached by 2030 also promotes gender equality and women’s empowerment.
Goal number 5 pursues to “Achieve gender equality and empower all women and girls,” and
is an opportunity to address structural obstacles and shift social norms. This would potentially
enable permanent pathways out of poverty and inequality achieving the gender equality tar-
gets of the 2030 agenda. Gender equality is a right in itself, but it is also an important means
to achieving other sustainable development goals.

Education has the potential to play a crucial role in attaining gender equality, as documented
for example by UNESCO in Education transforms lives (2013). When a girl receives a quality
education, she is less likely to get pregnant young, be married early, be a victim of violence,
get a job or contribute as active citizen to the development of society. Educating both girls and
boys has a huge positive impact in terms of preventing gender inequality and gender based
violence. Evidence shows, that the more literate the women in a country are, the lower female
mortality rate and the better health and political integration of women.

Since the launch of the Education for All (EFA) movement in 2000, gender equality in edu-
cation has been considered necessary for social justice on a global scale. And yet, gender
inequality is also pervasive in education. Though significant progress has been made over the
last decades in narrowing down gender disparities at primary and secondary level, in most
parts of the world, girls and women are still disadvantaged in the education systems. Accord-
ing to the Global Education Monitoring (GEM) report 2015, about 43 % of the world’s out-of-
school children will never go to school: 48% of girls compared with 37 % of boys are likely
never to enter a classroom. Moreover, 500 million women above the age of 15 are illiterate,
compared to 281 million men, meaning that 64% of the adult illiterate population are women.
Fewer girls than boys get a secondary education, and even fewer get a higher education.

It should be noted though, that in some countries, boys are now at a disadvantage, for exam-
ple in some Latin American countries, girls are more likely to enrol in and complete their edu-
cation than boys. Since 2000 there has been a growing concern over boys ‘underachievement
in learning outcomes. According to the GEM 2015 research from Brazil, Rwanda and other
countries showed that men with less education were more likely to be violent in the home and
express discriminatory gender views. However, only a few countries have put in place policies
to address this concern. An education that promotes gender equality needs to be of good qual-
ity, explicitly aimed at addressing gender inequalities and transforming negative or rigid gender
norms and stereotypes. The quality and transformative character of education is crucial to en-
sure that gender inequality is not reproduced in the formal education system and in non-formal
education activities and later in life.

Achieving gender justice is one of the goals in Oxfam’s Strategic Plan 2013 – 2019. While
the reasons behind inequality between women and men are about more than money there is
 CONCEPT PAPER: EDUCATION AND GENDER EQUALITY 3

no doubt that economic inequality compounds gender inequality. In the case of children who
have ever been to school, there is gender parity for middle income countries, but disparity at
the expense of girls in low income countries where 93 girls for every 100 boys have ever been
to school. Oxfam works to encourage women’s participation and transformative leadership; to
eliminate violence against women and girls and to improve women’s economic empowerment.
Oxfam believes in transforming gender - and related power relations - as well as the struc-
tures, norms and values that underpin them - by using education. This transformation is critical
to ending poverty and to empowering women to enable them to be global active citizens with
rights equal to men.

THEORIES AND DEFINITIONS

GENDER
Gender refers to the socially constructed identities, attributes and roles between women and
men, girls and boys, as well as the relations between women and those between men. These
attributes, roles and relationships are context- and time-specific and changeable. Gender influ-
ences determines what is expected by, allowed for and valued in a women or a man in a given
context. In all societies there are differences and inequalities between women and men in re-
sponsibilities assigned, activities undertaken, access to and control over resources, power and
rights and decision-making opportunities. In most of the world’s societies these socially con-
structed differences and relations often results in a specific focus on girls and women because
they are mostly adversely affected by existing gender inequalities and roles.

Gender equality
Gender equality refers to the equal rights, responsibilities and opportunities for women and
men and girls and boys to access and control social, economic and political resources, includ-
ing protection under the law. Equality does not mean that women and men will become the
same, but that there is equality of opportunity, i.e. that girls/women’s and boys/men’s rights,
responsibilities and opportunities will not depend on whether they are born male or female.
Gender equality is not a women’s issue but should concern and fully engage men as well as
women.

Gender justice
Oxfam IBIS understands gender justice as the full equality and equity between women and
men in all spheres of life, resulting in women jointly, and on an equal basis with men, defin-
ing and shaping the policies, structures and decisions that affect their lives and society as a
whole. This means that there is need both to continue improving legislation and policy, but also
to transform societies through sustained, widespread changes in attitudes and beliefs about
gender power relations. Oxfam IBIS envisions a safe and just world, where women and girls
gain power over every aspect of their lives, including not to be exposed to violence. When
women and girls are able to make their own choices and exercise their collective voice, and
when institutions address their needs and interests, gender justice will be achieved.

Gender mainstreaming
Oxfam IBIS is involved in an ongoing process to ensure that all our work across development,
humanitarian and campaigns programming incorporates the promotion of gender equality
and women’s rights. This process, known as Gender Mainstreaming (or integration), involves
gender justice considerations being built into all stages of policy making and programming.
4 CONCEPT PAPER: EDUCATION AND GENDER EQUALITY

This includes using gender and power analysis, set focus on girls and women’s rights’ objec-
tives and specific actions explicit addressing structural gender discrimination - and not just its
symptoms. As an organisation, we are committed to building the capacity of staff and partners
to focus on gender justice and girls and women’s rights and ensuring that gender is main-
streamed in all our policies, structures, practices and beliefs.

Gender equality in education

Gender equality in education involves achieving gender parity – (equal numbers of boys/girls,
women/men) in accessing formal and non-formal quality education. Furthermore, it includes
equal access to education at all levels, as well as equal opportunities within the education sys-
tem for advancing, gaining competences and developing as an individual.

FACTORS FACTORS OUTSIDE EFFECT ON FACTORS IN SCHOOL EFFECT ON

SCHOOL EDUCATION EDUCATION
Gender Women are expected Low value placed Negative or inflexible Lack of female teach-
stereo- to become mothers on girls’ educa- gender stereotypes ers means a lack of
types and wives and men tion as they are not may be reinforced at female role models
to bread-winners and perceived as bread school for girls
contribute economi- winners. Early mar- Gender biased cur-
cally to the family as riages and early riculum reinforces
heads of households pregnancies can lead existing gender roles
to school drop out Gender biased teach-
ers’ may reinforce
existing gender
stereotypes and lead
to discrimination
Violence Women and girls are Girls are less safe School related gen- Long distance to
and safety more often than boys than boys on the way der based violence school increases
and men the victims to school as well as (SRGBV) makes unsafety for girls
of gender based in school it less safe for girls Lack of separate
violence and harass- than boys to go to toilets increases
ment and sometimes be in unsafety for girls
In fragile countries schools SRGBV is a higher
and conflict contexts risk for girls
this disadvantage is
reinforced
Economic Poor families can- If families have to The cost of schooling The higher the cost
factors not afford the cost choose for financial may include school of schooling the
of sending all their reasons they tend to fees, additional cost higher risk to girls’
children to school prioritise boys’ edu- and opportunity costs education
Poor families depend cation over girls (value of children’s’ Privatisation of edu-
on children to work Girls have to do work work lost by family) cation, particularly
inside or outside the in the household with commercially driven
home less time for school for-profit schools,
Boys have to carry increases inequal-
out work for the fam- ity and exaggerates
ily with less time for girls’ already disad-
school vantaged position
in accessing and
completing quality
education
 CONCEPT PAPER: EDUCATION AND GENDER EQUALITY 5

Barriers to gender equality in education: There are a number of factors that hinder gender
equality in education. They are related to equal access to education and equal competition
but also to chances of success. Some of these barriers are linked to the school/education, but
others are linked to the social and cultural perceptions of gender roles and responsibilities in
society, and to poverty, inequality and power relations. The table below developed by Oxfam
IBIS summarises some of the barriers related to gender inequality with a focus on girls and
adolescents girls in formal education.

OXFAM IBIS’ APPROACH

Oxfam IBIS and partners work with a range of approaches in order to address the barriers to
gender inequality in education. These include working at the community and school levels, as
well as influencing work towards decision makers to bring about systemic change.

CHANGING GENDER STEREOTYPES

Working with communities
Gender equality can not be achieved without involving the communities and challenging them
to discuss and reflect on existing gender roles and perceptions. Gender perceptions have
deep roots in culture and tradition and transforming these is a long process. It needs a long
term engagement and commitment. In order to create awareness and facilitating a learning
process, Oxfam IBIS and civil society partners use platforms to communicate and discuss
issues such as: gender roles and norms, the right to gender equality, gender-based violence,
and the importance of education to both women/girls and men/boys. These activities are in
some cases linked to literacy training for adults. Gender discussions also take place within
the framework of support to school management committees (SMCs), where we encourage
and support gender equality among the parents participating in SMCs, and seek to put gender
equality on the SMCs agenda.

Working with schools and teachers

To achieve gender equality quality educators, who are aware of gender issues, are crucial.
Oxfam IBIS stresses the importance of ensuring gender sensitive pedagogic training for all
teachers. It is important to capacitate the educators with methods, materials and tools that will
ensure gender equality in the classroom and enable them to teach in a transformative way that
will change discriminatory perceptions and attitudes of the roles and responsibilities of girls
and boys in society. Gender-based violence in school settings is widespread, especially sexual
violence. Applying an inclusive, gender-sensitive pedagogy that acknowledge diversity and a
norm-critical approach has the potential to change this by creating a safe space for students,
girls as well as boys, including those who may not identify with the conceptions and attributes,
associated with the body and gender that they are born with.

Oxfam IBIS works to ensure not only equal enrolment of girls and boys but also an equal
number of male and female teachers. Many girls lack female role models, feel unrepresented
at their school and need female teachers to talk to – shortcomings which in some cases keep
girls from coming to school or make them drop out. Strategies we use to encourage female
teachers include providing secure transport between home and school, giving them economic
incentives and providing them with further training to ensure the quality of their teaching. Simi-
lar to ensuring possible role models for girls, it is also relevant to introduce learners to a differ-
ent approach to gender than the binary understanding.
6 CONCEPT PAPER: EDUCATION AND GENDER EQUALITY

Oxfam IBIS also support schools to work with the children themselves on gender equality, chil-
dren’s rights, etc. This work includes supporting girls’ school clubs, children’s parliaments and
adolescent girls’ summer camps, allowing them to talk about sensitive issues within a secure
and conducive environment. Quality educators can challenge the perception of what is under-
stood as ‘masculine’ and ‘feminine’, including which related possible actions are available and
acceptable.

Influencing decision makers

Oxfam IBIS supports civil society organisations and networks in holding governments ac-
countable in fulfilling their responsibility of for providing free public education services of good
quality for all, which is one of the ways to ensure gender equality in education. Depending on
the context, this includes advocating for more well-supported female teachers, teacher train-
ing on gender equality, gender scrutiny of the curriculum etc. It also includes influencing work
related to policies and laws that may discriminate girls, such as violation or denial of the rights
of girls to continue studies during or after an early pregnancy. Oxfam IBIS and partners (civil
society organisations and local education authorities) also work with innovative models, e.g.
junior secondary boarding schools for girls in the most deprived areas, and advocate the state
to up-scale and integrate these in the public education system.

ELIMINATING VIOLENCE AND ENSURING SAFETY

Working with communities
Addressing School Related Gender Based Violence (SRGBV) is an important aspect in Oxfam
IBIS’s work with gender. SRGBV is a serious rights violation which also obstructs the educa-
tion for especially the girl child and adolescent girl. SRGBV is a reflection of the gender based
violence more broadly in societies and communities, and it is linked to the low status of wom-
en and girls as well as to the prevailing unequal power relations. In order to address gender
based violence, it is important that girls, boys, women and men are aware of their rights and
know when an act is a violation against those rights. Oxfam IBIS and partners apply a commu-
nity based approach in working with SRGBV, an approach that often results in developing and
approving gender rights by-laws. Platforms, groups, councils and other local spaces are used
to discuss and be aware of rights, gender-based violence and to create awareness and action
if these rights are violated.

Working with schools and teachers

To ensure gender equality in education, it is fundamental that the girls and boys feel safe in
their learning environment. Making sure that the distance from home to school is reduced also
reduces the risk of violence on the way to school. Separate toilet facilities for girls and female
teachers are an important element in ensuring that girls’ and women teachers’ safety and
needs are fulfilled at the school. Another important element is to establish Code of Conducts
for teachers and other education personnel, a set of legally binding rules and guidelines on
how teachers and other staff members are supposed to relate to the students. These should
clearly spell out that any form of violence, abuse and harassment is forbidden. The school
community must be informed of the code of conduct. In this way they know what is right and
wrong for a teacher to do. In addition, both communities and children must have access to re-
porting cases of violence or abuse to responsive authorities, as well as to proper treatment of
abuse victims. The protection and empowerment of girls and women is especially important in
fragile situations, as they are often even more at risk of sexual harassment and exploitation. At
the same time schools can also be a safe place, where girls and boys are safe from violence
bringing normalcy in fragile contexts and refugee camps.
 CONCEPT PAPER: EDUCATION AND GENDER EQUALITY 7

Influencing decision makers

School safety and the elimination of SRGBV is ultimately the responsibility of the state. Oxfam
IBIS and partners therefore advocates for governments to ensure the safety of both girls and
boys at school through proper sanitation facilities, training of teachers, adoption of Code of
Conducts for teachers and other education personnel as well and ensuring adequate systems
for reporting, prosecution of perpetrators and proper treatment of victims of abuse.

ADDRESSING ECONOMIC BARRIERS

Working with communities
Within the community-based approach Oxfam IBIS seeks to sensitise parents to recognize
that girls have an equal right to education with boys – even if the economic means of the fami-
lies are limited. Oxfam IBIS also supports poor families and communities in terms of linking up
to economic empowerment programs and access to micro credit. In very poor and fragile con-
texts, school-meal programmes are supported as a counter measure to the opportunity cost of
parents when sending children, especially girls to school.

Working with schools and teachers

Over the last decades more and more countries have started offering free public education,
and school fees have been abolished, especially at primary level. This has had a tremendous
effect on school enrolment in general, and an even more remarkable effect on girls’ education.
However, many schools have additional costs in terms of school uniforms, books and station-
ary, and in some cases also so-called ‘hidden costs’ where schools and/or teachers ask par-
ents to contribute, and as such pay unauthorised fees. Oxfam IBIS works against hidden costs
by building the capacity of SMCs to address and put an end to this.

Influencing decision makers

Any kind of cost on education limits access – and thereby the right to education for all. This is
particularly the case, when it comes to girls’ education. Access to free, public, quality educa-
tion is one of the major advocacy priorities of Oxfam IBIS, and we are engaged in these both
at country level, but also in all regional and international forums, where education financing is
raised. Ensuring free access to quality education is the responsibility of governments. In coun-
tries with limited means, donors should support education systems. Furthermore countries
should seek to expand their gender sensitive budgets and spending through better taxation of
companies and extractive industries, and they should make sure, that no hidden, unauthorised
fees are required by schools or teachers. Finally, governments should also put an end to the
recent trend of commercially driven low-cost private schools.
8 CONCEPT PAPER: EDUCATION AND GENDER EQUALITY

FURTHER DOCUMENTATION AND REFERENCES

• Oxfam Strategic Plan, 2013 – 2018: The Power of People against Poverty, Oxfam 2016
• Even it up: Time to end extreme inequality, Oxfam 2014
• Education for Change Strategy (2012-2017), IBIS
• Education for All 2000-2015: Achievements and challenges, GEM report 6, UNESCO 2015
• Gender Review: Creating Sustainable Future for All, GEM report. UNESCO, 2015
• Education for People and planet: Creating sustainable futures for all, UNESCO 2016 GEM
report, Education transforms lives, UNESCO, 2013
• United Nations Girls’ Education Initiative (UNGEI): http://www.ungei.org/
• UN Women: http://www.unwomen.org/en
• Sustainable Knowledge Platform:
https://sustainabledevelopment.un.org/post2015/transformingourworld

ABOUT IBIS EDUCATION FOR CHANGE CONCEPT PAPERS

Oxfam IBIS Concept Paper: Education and Gender, version 1, March 1st, 2017
This series of concept papers was introduced June 1st, 2014 with the target audience being
Oxfam IBIS staff and management as well as partners and stakeholders. The papers have been
developed through a participatory process and are living documents to be revised whenever
needed. At this point the series includes the following concept papers:

1. Quality Education
2. Transformative Education
3. Educator Professional Development
4. Youth Education and Training
5. Mother Tongue - Bilingual Education
6. Education in Fragile Situations
7. Education and Gender Equality

All Oxfam IBIS concept papers can be found at www.oxfamibis.org

[email protected], VESTERBROGADE 2B, 1620 COPENHAGEN V, DENMARK