Directed by Sara Clark: Discussion Guide
Directed by Sara Clark: Discussion Guide
PRESENTS:
Discussion Guide
Cincinnati Shakespeare Company
For more than a decade, Shakespeare produced a steady stream of works, both tragedies and comedies,
which were performed at the Globe, the royal court, and other London theaters. However, shortly after
the Globe was destroyed by fire in 1613, he retired and returned to Stratford. He died in Stratford in
1616.
Cincinnati Shakespeare Company
Olivia’s uncle, Sir Toby Belch, her servant Maria, and Sir Toby’s friend, Sir Andrew Aguecheek, who is
also hoping to woo Olivia and is being led on by Sir Toby, who is trying to fleece him of his money, all
plot to expose the self-love of Malvolio. By means of a false letter they trick him into thinking
his mistress Olivia loves him. Malvolio appears in yellow stockings and cross-garters, smiling as they
have told him to in the letter. Unaware of the trick the Countess is horrified and has Malvolio shut up in
the dark as a madman.
Meanwhile Viola’s twin brother, Sebastian, who has also survived the shipwreck, comes to Illyria. His
sea-captain friend, Antonio, is a wanted man for piracy against Orsino. The resemblance between
Cesario and Sebastian leads the jealous Sir Andrew to challenge Cesario to a duel. Antonio intervenes to
defend Cesario whom he thinks is his friend Sebastian, and is arrested. Olivia has in the meantime met
and become betrothed to Sebastian,
believing him to be Cesario.
The play ends as Orsino welcomes Olivia and Sebastian and, realizing his own attraction to
Cesario/Viola, he promises that once she is dressed as a woman again they, too, will be married.
Cincinnati Shakespeare Company
She does her best to blend into her new world, but her love for Orisno, the clowns
around her, and misplaced love from Olivia, won't let her do that. She's not flashy
but she's smart. She has the ability to take in her surroundings and keep herself safe.
She's not loud, but she's true to herself, even under the guise of Cesario. She's not
outgoing, but she feels for those around her. Even in the midst of Olivia's pursuits,
which could ruin her relationship with Orsino, both as a master and a possible lover, she feels empathy for
Olivia's unrequited love. She's a dear, dear character to be playing. She's real, she's lovely, and she's honest, even
in the midst of, you know, being a man.”
In Twelfth Night, Antonio refers to an inn called “The Elephant” in Illyria; in Shakespeare’s day, “The
Elephant” was a pub close to the Globe Theatre in London, where many of his plays were performed.
When Twelfth Night was first performed in 1602, female characters were usually played by boys or young
men. So the character of Viola would have been played by a boy playing a girl pretending to be a boy!
Shakespeare created a whole series of domestic fools for [Armin the actor]. [His] greatest roles,
Touchstone in "As You Like It,"(1599), Feste in "Twelfth Night,"(1600), and (the) fool in "King
Lear,"(1605); helped Shakespeare resolve the tension between thematic material and the traditional
entertainment role of the fool. Armin became a counter-point to the themes of the play and the power
relationships between the theatre and the role of the fool--he manipulates the extra dimension between
play and reality to interact with the audience all the while using the themes of the play as his source
material. Shakespeare began to write well-developed sub-plots expressly for Armin's talents. A balance
between the order of the play and the carnevalized inversion factor of festive energy was achieved.
Armin was a major intellectual influence on Shakespeare's fools. He was attuned to the intellectual
tradition of the Renaissance fool yet intellectual enough to understand the power of the medieval
tradition. Armin's fool is a stage presence rather than a solo artist. His major skills were mime and
mimicry; even his improvisational material had to be reworked and rehearsed. His greatest asset was as
a foil to the other stage actors. Armin offered the audience an idiosyncratic response to the
idiosyncrasies of each spectator.
It is defined by the Shorter Oxford English Dictionary as “the evening of the fifth of January, preceding
Twelfth Day, the eve of the Epiphany, formerly the last day of the Christmas festivities and observed as
a time of merrymaking”. There is some confusion these days, however, as to which night is Twelfth
Night: modern practice is often to regard the night of Epiphany itself (sixth of January) to be Twelfth
Night. The older tradition of Twelfth Night being the 5th of January stems from the medieval practice of
the day beginning at sunset, rather than at midnight as it does now. Thus Twelfth Night falls on the 5th of
January, ahead of Twelfth Day on the 6th.
A recent belief in some English-speaking countries holds that it is unlucky to leave Christmas
decorations hanging after Twelfth Night, a belief originally attached to the festival of Candlemas which
celebrates the Presentation of Jesus at the Temple (February 2).
In medieval and Tudor England, the Twelfth Night marked the end of a winter festival that started on
All Hallows Eve — now more commonly known as Halloween. The Lord of Misrule symbolizes the
world turning upside down. On this day the King would become the peasants and vice versa. At the
beginning of the Twelfth Night festival, a cake that contained a bean was eaten. The person who found
the bean would rule the feast. Midnight signaled the end of his rule and the world would return to
normal. The common theme was that the normal order of things was reversed. This Lord of Misrule
tradition dates back to pre-Christian European festivals such as the Celtic festival of Samhain and the
Ancient Roman festival of Saturnalia.
Cincinnati Shakespeare Company
In colonial America, a Christmas wreath was always left up on the front door of each home, and when
taken down at the end of the Twelve Days of Christmas, any edible portions would be consumed with
the other foods of the feast. The same held true in the 19th-20th centuries with fruits adorning Christmas
trees. Fresh fruits were hard to come by, and were therefore considered fine and proper gifts and
decorations for the tree, wreaths, and home. Again, the tree would be taken down on Twelfth Night, and
such fruits, along with nuts and other local produce used, would then be consumed.
In the eastern Alps, a tradition called Perchtenlaufen exists. Two to three hundred masked young men
rush about the streets with whips and bells driving out evil spirits. In Nuremberg until 1616, children
frightened spirits away by running through the streets and knocking loudly at doors. In some countries,
and in the Catholic religion worldwide, the Twelfth Night and Epiphany marks the start of the Carnival
season, which lasts through Mardi Gras Day. Modern American Carnival traditions shine most brightly
in New Orleans, where friends gather for weekly King Cake parties. Whoever gets the slice with the
"king", usually in the form of a miniature baby doll (symbolic of the Christ Child, "Christ the King"),
hosts next week's party.
In parts of Kent, there is a tradition that an edible decoration would be the last part of Christmas to be
removed in the Twelfth Night and shared amongst the family.
Cincinnati Shakespeare Company
Gender: Gender is a big topic in Twelfth Night, and the play brilliantly demonstrates how gender, a
socially constructed identity, can be “performed” and impersonated with the use of voice, costume, and
mannerisms. The theme is largely explored in relation to Shakespeare's profession as an actor and writer
because in Elizabethan times, all-male acting companies performed the roles of women. The
relationship between gender and performance is particularly complex in Twelfth Night because the part
of Viola is played by a boy actor, who is cross-dressed as a female character, who disguises herself as a
young man.
Rules and Order: Twelfth Night takes its name from the Carnival-like festivities surrounding the
Christian feast of the Epiphany. Like the Mardi Gras festival, Twelfth Night is a religious holiday and
an opportunity to invert social order while indulging in unruly and riotous behavior. The play is also
chock-full of drinking, carousing, eating, over-indulging, and other spirited activity. Yet, the rebellious
spirit of Twelfth Night is not limited to overt “partying.” Gender-bending, misguided pursuits of love,
clowning, and the humiliation of the play's resident “Puritan” figure Malvolio, also embody the spirit of
festival in the play.
Cincinnati Shakespeare Company
Elizabethan Manners:
Except below taken from Fabritio Caroso's "Nobilita di Dame" (1600) in his Dialog
Between a Disciple and His Master, on the Conduct Required of Gentlemen and Ladies
at a Ball and Elsewhere for some pointers on how to behave in court.
For Gentlemen
Here is Caroso’s description for a gentleman's comportment with a king:
Elsewhere, Caroso offers advice on sword wearing, another essential social skill of a
gentleman:
"When a gentleman wears a sword while dancing these lively dances, he should hold it with his left
hand, so that it will not wave around wildly; also if he find himself dancing in a very samll space, he
should hold it [still] with his left hand, turning it a bit by that hand so that the point will hang forward in
order to avoid offsense to those seated behind him. If you have space, however, allow it to move as
usual. Be careful not to push down on yoru sword hilt to such an extent that the tip points skyward, for if
you do so, you will resemble a Spanish Captain playing his part in the Commedia, and you will be
mocked at and ridiculed, rather than appreciated by any onlookers. After you have taken leave of your
lady and as you return to your seat, pay due respect to thoseenear where you will be sitting with a small
salutation; and with your hat in your right hand, and your left hand turning your sword toward the
front."
For a Lady
Here is Caroso’s description for a lady's comportment with a king or other nobility:
It is interesting to note that it is assumed that public business will be conducted by men, and that women
engage in purely social behavior with other women. There aren't directions about how a woman should
behave in a court situation with a prince. The contexts in which men and women interact are actually
quite limited, dancing being one of the major ones, and one reason why deportment is so important a
part of dance instruction. Caroso's guidance on how a lady should invite a gentleman to dance provide
interesting insight into behavior between the genders:
[Sometimes] during a dance, some new brides and other ladies cast their eyes so low that the gentlemen
cannot tell which one of them has been invited [to dance], so that one rises to his feet rather than the
other. Or sometimes, in their great eagerness to dance, they [all] give her their hands, with the result
that she does not know which one to take. It would be better, then, for a lady to keep her eyes level, and
when she chooses to invite some gentleman, to look at him [directly], so that those sitting near to or
behind him will not need to rise, thus avoiding any ensuing scandal. Now as he rises, the gentleman
whom she has invited should remove his right glove (if he is wearing it) at the same time as she makes a
Reverence to him, and she should pretend to adjust her dress, making it sway, strutting slightly, and
turning a bit sideways toward the one she has just invited. On occasion a gentleman may wear his
gloves so tightly that removing his right glove takes longer than saying an 'Ave Maria', as I have said
above. It is not proper, however, for the lady to remain directly facing [the gentleman], for it would look
as if they were making love; therefore gentlemen should wear their gloves a little loose rather than tight.
This is interesting because it describes the polite way for women to interact with men -- not too direct,
but not so modest as to cause social confusion. The bit about not facing the gentleman for too long a
time is worth noting. Before the late 20th century, the phrase 'making love' referred to romantic
conversation. Being truly lady-like by the standards of the time is a difficult task!
Cincinnati Shakespeare Company
Discussion Questions
1. Orsino spends a whole lot of time and energy professing his "love" for Olivia. Is he really as smitten
with her as he says he is? Why or why not?
2. Olivia falls head over heels for "Cesario." What is it about "Cesario" that Olivia finds so attractive?
What textual evidence would you use to back up your claim? Does the play ever reconcile Olivia's
desire for "Cesario"? If so, how? If not, why not?
3. At the play's end, Viola reveals her true identity, which frees her up to marry Duke Orsino. But, Viola
remains in her "Cesario" disguise because the sea captain is keeping her "maiden weeds" for her. What
is Orsino's response to this? How does the situation influence our interpretation of their relationship?
4. Why does Viola disguise herself as a boy? How does Viola's gender-bending "Cesario" disguise
create comedic situations in the play? What is Viola's response to the way other characters treat and
respond to "Cesario"?
5. We know that Shakespeare wrote for an all-male stage, which means that Viola's role was played by a
boy actor who had to convince the audience that he was a woman who disguised herself as a man. How
does this complicate or challenge our notions about "masculinity" and "femininity"? Is it possible for a
person to have both characteristics? Why or why not?
6. What does Duke Orsino say about women's capacity to love? Is there evidence in the play to support
or disprove Orsino's opinion?
7. Why does Sir Toby Belch convince Sir Andrew Aguecheek to challenge "Cesario" to a duel? What
does this suggest about Toby's ideas about what it means to be a man?
8. Why do Maria, Toby, Fabian, and Feste decide to play such a cruel prank on Malvolio?
9. Is Malvolio really in love with Olivia? If not, why does he fantasize about marrying her?
10. Why does Orsino say that Sebastian's blood is "right noble"? Why should it matter?
11. Is the title of Twelfth Night, or What You Will an appropriate name for the play? Why or, why not?
12. How does Sir Toby Belch spend his time in the play? Why do other characters object to his
behavior?
13. Aside from the obvious depictions of drinking, eating, and over-indulging, what other kinds of social
unruliness does Twelfth Night portray?
14. We know that Twelfth Night refers to the Christian feast of the Epiphany. ("Epiphany" literally
means "appearance" or "manifestation.") Does the concept of revelation ever appear in the play? If so,
what is it that is revealed?
Cincinnati Shakespeare Company
Classroom Activity:
Part of teaching middle school and high school students is dealing with lovelorn, love obsessed, and
lovesick teenagers. While reading Twelfth Night, students will discover that the characters in the play
have as much trouble with love (and often times, more) as they do. This lesson allows students to toy
with the theme of love and explore the different characters' opinions about love before they begin the
play. Students will have a chance to play with language, engage in performance, and grow excited about
the play before it begins.
What To Do
2. Each member of the group should receive a copy of the following speeches: Orsino, 1.1.1-15; Viola
2.2.18-26 and 33-41; and Olivia, 3.1.152-164.
3. Ask students to read each speech several times, circling any words or phrases that they find confusing.
4. Lead a class discussion with the students. Ask them to consider possible meanings for any words that
seem confusing.
5. Explain to students that, in their groups, they will break up the lines into sets (which can be anywhere
from 1–4 lines) that seem to convey a single idea or seem to want to stand on their own. Then, after the
group has broken all of the speeches up into pieces, the students must find a creative way to merge all
three speeches into a performance. This can be done in countless ways. For example, pick students to
play each character and read that character's lines, and then have the other students act out the scenes
silently. The only requirements are that all 5 members be involved in the presentation and that the lines
from the three speeches be intertwined in some way, so that the parallels between the speeches are clear.
6. After each group has performed, ask students to write a response addressing the following questions:
Describe each of the following characters in 2–3 sentences based on the speeches you read: Orsino,
Viola, Olivia. How do you think these characters are connected to each other in the play? Which of the
presentations did you find most effective? Why? What questions remain in your mind after today's
activity?
7. Extension activity: Have students revisit their written response as they read the play, adding in
insights and opinions of the characters.
Cincinnati Shakespeare Company
Sources:
http://www.nosweatshakespeare.com/play-summary/twelfth-night/
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Twelfth_Night_(holiday)
www.schmoop.com/twelfth-night
http://www.latourdulac.com/manners/Elizabethan.html
http://pages.simonandschuster.com/images/ckfinder/26/pdfs/Folger%20Curriculum%20Guides/Guides-
Apr2012/Folger_TwelfthNight.pdf
http://www.folger.edu/eduLesPlanDtl.cfm?lpid=632
Fabritio Caroso, Courtly Dance of the Renaissance, a New Translation and Edition of the Nobilta di
Dame (1600), trans. Julia Sutton, Dover Publications, NY.
Baldassarre Castiglione, The Book of the Courtier, trans. George Bull, Penguin, 1976.
Natalie Zemon Davis, The Gift in Sixteenth-Century France, University of Wisconsin Press, 2000.
Frederick J. Furnivall, editor, The Babees Book, The Bokes of Nurture of Hugh Rhodes and John
Russell, Wynkyn de Worde's Boke of Kervynge, The Booke of Demeanor, The Boke of Courtasye,
Seager's School of Vertue, & c. &c. with some French & Latin Poems on like Subjects and some
Forewords on Education in Early England, London, 1868.
Michel de Montaigne, The Complete Works of Montaigne, Donald Frame, translator and editor,
Stanford University Press, 1971.
Kristen B. Neuschel, Word of Honor, Interpreting Noble Culture in Sixteenth Century France, Cornell
University Press, 1989.
Sara Paston-Williams, The Art of Dining, A History of Cooking and Eating, The National Trust, Great
Britian, 1999.
William Leon Wiley, The Gentleman of Renaissance France, Harvard University Press, 1954.