Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

Since the initial reveal, I have been utterly underwhelmed by this product. I fail to see a viable market or a satisfactory use case for such an oddly designed and artificially limited gaming device, and am confident that it will be yet another failure in a long line of Nintendo failures.

No touch screen? Not a single camera for AR content and/or social communication? The controllers look miniscule in the actor's tiny hands. The dock HAD to cover the screen of the device? I foresee the controller sliding and locking mechanism wearing down over time, leading to sloppy interconnection between the controllers and the device.

I could go on with the horrible design choices, but I cannot think of a single redeeming quality. It looks like the market is 6-12 year olds.




Just an FYI, it is a touch screen, according to the presentation at the 41m50s mark - https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=uuC4YLLkqME&feature=youtu.be...


"I could go on with the horrible design choices"

You can create hundreds of speculatively horrible design choices, but not one of them would mean a thing until you try the product and check if they apply right?


It's easy to analyze in a frictionless vacuum.


It has a touch screen and there is a camera in the joycon


> I fail to see a viable market or a satisfactory use case for such an oddly designed and artificially limited gaming device, and am confident that it will be yet another failure in a long line of Nintendo failures.

It is a portable console that I can take on business trips. That's a use-case :)


> The dock HAD to cover the screen of the device

Why shouldn't it? You're not able to use the Switch when it's docked, and the screen is disabled, so why show the screen?




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: