Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

> The China that tries to have trade both ways by forcing Hollywood to portray China positively just to get 50% of what they should at the Chinese box office?

What's this one about?




Super layman's take:

- China has a "ministry of culture" which decides what foreign media can enter the domestic market, especially to play on the big screen

- Chinese domestic films enjoy what effectively is media protectionism

- Hollywood obviously wants a piece of that giant market

- What movies get approved/denied and for what reasons can get very arbitrary. So it comes down to a matter of trying to win favors of people deciding the approval process.

- Often this means shooting big scenes in locations in China, or portraying China in a positive light, or starring Chinese characters, etc. This effectively translates to "you can help us look good globally and we allow you to make money in our market".

I have no idea where the "get 50% what they should" came from, and I'm too lazy to look. But dealing with the Chinese government regulations is really just a quagmire of conflicts of interest.

*Edit: formatting


The Chinese government controls access to their lucrative movie market. There is no freedom of speech; people who displease them are punished with loss of access.

Hollywood complies by making films that please the Chinese government censors. A quick search will find a NY Times article about the head of Disney going to China to apologize about a film about Tibet, and promising that such a thing would never happen again. IIRC, there are stories that Hollywood gives Chinese government censors prior review of films before they are finalized, and edits them as instructed/requested.

When was the last time you saw a film critical of China? Showing China doing something bad? Complementary of the Dalai Lama?


For example, the remake of Red Dawn a few years ago was supposed to feature China invading the US. They changed in to North Korea under pressure.

http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-2237717/Red-Dawn-rem...




that probably refers to the large amount of capital from China instilled into Hollywood over recent years.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: