Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

I had the exact same problem. It is now permanently in my closet. This is what I wrote in my Amazon review:

In everyday use, there's a pretty major issue: it won't stay closed. When you fold it and hold it upright like you would any umbrella when you get indoors, it just falls open, getting your pants went and making you (and others) trip on it.

You can try to hold it shut, but the sticks are all different lengths, you need to individually grab each one, and you won't have any spare hands to open the door or get your keys. You can try to wrap it up, using not one, but TWO straps, which will get your hands all wet. And it's annoying as hell to have to do all the time.

It also won't stay closed when you prop it up against a wall, it will just fall all over the floor and make everything wet.

As if that weren't enough, the shape is odd: it makes it hard to cover yourself completely. I've tried. It is always too narrow in one direction. It also makes you look like a dork.

To be fair, it is solidly built and can hold its own in strong wind. The handle smells slightly but is comfortable to hold. Watch out though, because it's made of two parts that join as you open the umbrella, and it's quite easy to pinch yourself.

To sum up: bad design. Looks good on paper, terrible in actual use.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: