Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

> $6T, which is too large for them to unwind.

Can I ask for a journal or study source/citation for this?




See the charts for yourself: https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/WALCL

In the aftermath of the 2008 financial crisis, the Fed managed to unload a mere $800B (balance sheet went from $4.5T to $3.7T) in the longest bull run in history. Now that it's an order of magnitude bigger, you can draw the logical conclusion yourself.


It'll take a while to unwind, no doubt about that.

The Fed currently holds ~$5.8 trillion, but it's long term holdings are about ~$1 trillion in current dollars, so it's holding an addition ~$4.8 trillion above what it normally has since the early 2000s.

In October of 2014, it held ~$3.7 trillion, or ~$2.7 trillion above what it normally holds, so the recent increase to $4.8 trillion above baseline isn't quite an order of (base 2) magnitude increase.

Having said all that, the net worth of households and non-profits in the US is about ~$118 trillion.

https://fred.stlouisfed.org/series/TNWBSHNO


Love it when people cite FRED. Top quality data source and one of the best litmus tests for the credibility of someone's claims on economic matters. This guy knows what he's talking bout. Good job!


Actually, I can't draw the logical conclusion myself. What is it?


The Fed won't be unloading those assets in your or anyone's lifetime.


Ok, thank you. I found a page as well on the "so what" of that. http://www.crfb.org/blogs/cbo-consequences-growing-national-... . It would be interesting to pontificate about how much USD the Fed can print before it does have these bad impacts. Currently it seems we're in a deflationary period bc the velocity of money has gone down so much and people are holding cash. Will be interesting to see how much inflation there is down the line after the $500B extra they're printing now.


History books? You could read about the Weimar Republic.


The Weimar Republic had debt obligations that it couldn't repay and so they printed money. Meanwhile the balance sheet of the Fed is just that. A balance sheet. The only way they can create inflation is by making the balance sheet bigger. As long as inflation is below the target they can just keep increasing the balance sheet. There is no obligation to decrease the balance sheet unless inflation is above the target.

Why are they even doing this in the first place? The Fed buys assets during deflation and sells assets during inflation. Buying a cheap asset (e.g. $50 for a share) with money created from thin air increases the money supply and over the long run increases inflation. Inflation causes the prices of cheap assets to rise above the original value to $100 for a share. The situation is out of control! What can the fed do? It can sell assets in exchange for $100. In other words. The fed never runs into a situation which it cannot undo.


The problem, you see, is that the money issued by the Fed is used all over the world through the magic of repo, while CPI is measured within the United States only. Ever heard of the shadow banking system? Eurodollars?


It can sell assets in exchange for $100.

To whom?


Would that tell me why US inflation fell to -1% when the Fed massively expanded its balance sheet in 2008?


No inflation. Amazing.

We must be living in a different place.

Childcare, Healthcare, Education and Housing have experienced huge inflation.

A home in the bay area was 700,000 in 2008. Today you can't find anything for less than 1.2 million.

When this inflation hits the economy what will a home cost? What will education cost?


You're saying the official figures are wrong in such a way to understate inflation after, but not before, 2008? What change in 2008 caused that?

Isn't it more likely that the price rises in Bay area property have been compensated for in other areas and sectors?


The velocity of money, not solely the supply of money, determines inflation.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: