> And how's that working out for Sweden? 20x death rate to date compared to neighboring Finland which has a lockdown in place, and an ever accelerating rate of infected. Cool, cool.
Think about it: if you allow it to spread, then yes, you will see people die. The same is true of the flu, which has so far killed more people in the same period of time than COVID has according to the CDC -- in every age category [5].
I bet flu deaths are plummeting in Finland, too. I bet you anything that Sweden has 20X the death rate from the flu as compared to Finland and Denmark. Because nothing spreads when you're locked in. But it would be absurd to lock everyone inside because of the flu right? It's a question of risk management not risk elimination. [1]
And they're quite right, that they will be safe from a second wave as no other country will.
So, to answer you question, it's working out well.
> Also China today is nothing like China pre-covid. Mandatory mask wearing everywhere, temperature checks every few blocks, in every shop, mobile codes to scan certifying your virus free status before being allowed to buy anything. They're not exactly planning their next Disneyland trips over there.
1. They wore masks anyways due to the pollution ([2] this photo is from 2013 not 2020).
2. They had police/army stops anyways due to the PRC government being totalitarian. [3]
3. They have actually re-opened Shanghai Disneyland, as of March 9th. [4]
I don't have a good sense on the other points but I would point out the points about China are not quite right.
1. This is untrue. Masks were worn intermittently only on "bad pollution" days in cities like Beijing and Shanghai. Inland cities like Chengdu there is not widespread mask usage.
2. There is a difference between Xinjiang and the rest of China. You definitively do not see this type of security checkpoints in "regular" pre-covid China.
China is not back to "normal", there is fits and starts in the restarts to life, and there is also a psychological drag on consumer demand even though some shopping is reopened.
1. I think it's fair to say every day is a bad pollution day in Beijing haha. I've seen the PM counts. With that in mind, of course, I've no reason to doubt you.
2. Sure, it varies.
I didn't mean to imply it was back to 100%, just that it was pointed in the right direction again.
Think about it: if you allow it to spread, then yes, you will see people die. The same is true of the flu, which has so far killed more people in the same period of time than COVID has according to the CDC -- in every age category [5].
I bet flu deaths are plummeting in Finland, too. I bet you anything that Sweden has 20X the death rate from the flu as compared to Finland and Denmark. Because nothing spreads when you're locked in. But it would be absurd to lock everyone inside because of the flu right? It's a question of risk management not risk elimination. [1]
And they're quite right, that they will be safe from a second wave as no other country will.
So, to answer you question, it's working out well.
> Also China today is nothing like China pre-covid. Mandatory mask wearing everywhere, temperature checks every few blocks, in every shop, mobile codes to scan certifying your virus free status before being allowed to buy anything. They're not exactly planning their next Disneyland trips over there.
1. They wore masks anyways due to the pollution ([2] this photo is from 2013 not 2020).
2. They had police/army stops anyways due to the PRC government being totalitarian. [3]
3. They have actually re-opened Shanghai Disneyland, as of March 9th. [4]
Sounds pretty similar to me.
[1] https://www.schneier.com/essays/archives/2013/08/our_decreas...
[2] https://www.chinadaily.com.cn/photo/2013-01/25/content_16174...
[3] https://www.wsj.com/articles/twelve-days-in-xinjiang-how-chi...
[4] https://www.usatoday.com/story/travel/destinations/2020/03/0...
[5] https://www.cdc.gov/nchs/nvss/vsrr/COVID19/index.htm