Amazon seem to be working on bringing Amplify up to the same standard as Firebase, and it's certainly getting there, so in the near-future there may be quite a few alternatives.
I wrote a master thesis where I compared several realtime database products. I promise you amplify is no where "getting there". It is a crippled version of firebase and there is no fix in sight. For example you cannot even do sort-queries with datastore or Amplify is not working with angular because they have broken typings since 9 months with no fix. And the list goes on..
Neither of those issues surprise me, from what I've seen of the project.
I'm not familiar with the project historically, as I've only been using it for about 2 months, but it seems to me like there's been an increase in activity since the start of the year - like the package modularization, new UI components, and new docs (which are still pretty bad to be honest). I totally agree it's sub-par to Firebase, and if you stray anywhere off the beaten path you're completely on your own (i.e. not using React, seemingly (!!)), but I do think it has the potential to become a viable alternative.
My primary issue with the platform is the choice of a NoSQL database, which, in my view, just doesn't match the majority of application requirements - if you want to do any sort of text search, you have to spin up a whole sodding Elasticsearch ___domain, which are expensive as hell for a new product and take literally 20-30 minutes every time they're updated with an `amplify push` command. I also waited over a week for one to be deleted not too long ago. That's why my plan is to replace the API with a Lambda function running Postgraphile with some JWK logic to use Cognito for authN, while keeping the idM and file storage stuff.
I find the overall Amplify offering to be a mess. The hosting and authentication works pretty well but the rest of it just feels like they put duct tape in front of a bunch of existing AWS services.
I’ve found Hasura+Cognito+S3 as the closest equivalent to Firebase. It’s not as neatly wrapped up into a single product but it’s pretty close.
Yes I completely agree actually, I've been using Amplify to prototype UI quite well but my plan is to switch to using Postgraphile (or maybe Hasura, I haven't decided yet) + Cognito to replace the backend - primarily so I can use a relational database that isn't Aurora Serverless. I do feel like they've made good progress on the project in recent months, but it really needs another good year of work on it before I'd consider it cohesive enough to stick with.
