Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

How are they supposed to know what you’re torrenting?



The protocol is more or less all plaintext. The "best" peer to peer cipher available is rc4; almost no one uses it. The tracker announces can run over HTTPS, but often run over plain HTTP.


The "best" peer to peer cipher available is rc4; almost no one uses it.

...which is unfortunate because even something like the anonymous DH that is specified, or more standard, TLS with random/self-signed certificates, would force monitors to need to MITM all connections in order to find out what they contain.

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/BitTorrent_protocol_encryption


Oh god... you're not under the impression that bittorrent is a secure or anonymous protocol, are you?


No but all they see is parts identified by hashes. How are they supposed to know whether is a Linux distro or a movie?


Because, quite frankly, parts identified by hashes is not all they see.

If you're monitoring and logging the traffic then it's trivial to not only determine the filename of a bittorrent download, but also everything you need to connect to the torrent yourself and download it to verify that it's what the filename says, if that's what you wish to do.

And, personally, I'd expect someone to at least check the filename before accusing me of committing a crime. :(


The torrent file is downloaded over a secure connection that you can’t monitor. Can you please tell me which messages in the BitTorrent protocol contain the filenames?


Can't you just look up the hash on DHT? Since hash is the only mandatory field in a Magnet URI.


Of course but connecting to a peer to peer network and looking it up doesn’t sound ‘trivial’ to me.


Clients can obfuscate traffic though?


How much can they obfuscate it if other clients need to be able to download it?


The obfuscation is just to disguise the traffic so providers can’t easily implement blanket bans on all BitTorrent traffic


I suppose they could have known by using a tool such as the one linked in this post.




Consider applying for YC's Summer 2025 batch! Applications are open till May 13

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: