Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

[flagged]



I would argue that it can. The question is if an individual finds it unethical or not, not if it's being stolen. Legally speaking at least.


The argument is that for something to be "stolen" it has to be missing afterwards. An unauthorized copy is copyright infringement, legally speaking, not theft.

Words mean something and there is a reason why right holders tried to coin this (pillaging, murdering) piracy to give it a bad connotation. Then the various "pirate parties" said if you want to call large swaths of the population pirates, then we will be taking that word from you (somewhat similar to pride movements).


No contest. You've convinced me.

For the record, I have little to no issue with "unauthorized copies", for the most part. I just disagreed with some of the phrasing.


Interesting argument.

Secrets can be stolen, but they're not missing after.

Spies steal secrets, not copyright infringement them :)


> Secrets can be stolen, but they're not missing after.

You technically lose the secret in this case, since it's not a secret anymore.


Espionage is also not theft in a legal sense


> The argument is that for something to be "stolen" it has to be missing afterwards.

...assuming the word has only one usage -- which it does not. The word can also be correctly used to describe an act of appropriation.

"Stolen" is not necessarily a synonym of "theft"


> ...assuming the word has only one usage -- which it does not.

To me it sounds like propaganda against information sharing, by coining negative words, like "piracy":

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Copyright_infringement#%22Pira...


Digital information cannot be stolen.

The courts ruled on this last century. At least as far back as the 80's when people were stealing HBO from satellites with TVRO dishes in their backyard.

It's time to stop beating that horse.


The courts ruled it a crime, they did not rule it to be theft. Presenting it as such is a politically motivated distortion of the the facts.




Consider applying for YC's Summer 2025 batch! Applications are open till May 13

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: