Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

I have little sympathy for people that are "forced" to sell their homes for a large capital gain. They can move to where it's cheap and live large. Maybe my perspective as an immigrant is unusual, but I'm a big fan of the freedom to migrate. That includes the freedom to buy housing at market price.



Most of the people being forced out are renters.


Then it's even easier to move. If the polity doesn't want to zone for more housing, they've chosen to expel people who can't pay more than $X for rent. They'll feel the pain when there's no one around to make their coffee anymore.

There's no such thing as unlimited demand for luxury housing. Build enough and the rent will fall for the existing housing stock.


> Then it's even easier to move.

Moving requires finding a home somewhere that they can afford. The fact that they’ve been subjected to rising rents rather than a financial windfall like nearby homeowners… makes that far more difficult for them


They could have bought. Instead they took advantage of the optionality afforded to a renter that can up stakes and move at will, without being tied to a mortgage.

If they couldn’t afford to buy then they got to take advantage of a locale they desired at a lower price, another benefit of renting.

(While it would be nice if anyone could live — and own — anywhere they like without worrying about price or competing demand from the billions of other humans around, that’s so far away from reality it’s not worth discussing.)


I’m starting to feel we may be nearing a local maximum on housing, as more and more arguments seem to take for granted that it can never go down …




Consider applying for YC's Summer 2025 batch! Applications are open till May 13

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: