Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

The fear is from people who can extrapolate. Who can remember state of AI 20/10/5 years ago. And compare it to 2023.

Whether that extrapolation makes sense, nobody knows. But fear is understandable.




Everyone can extrapolate. One of the most irritating tendencies of public intellectuals is the assumption that only they understand the word exponential, and then insist on asserting that every trend they can lay their eyes on must be an exponential trend (or if it's clearly not, then it will be soon).

Progress comes in fits and spurts. Sometimes there's fast progress, and then the field matures and it slows down. It was ever thus. Measured in tech demos, AI progress has been impressive. Measured in social impact it has way underperformed, with the applications until November of last year being mostly optimizations to existing products that you wouldn't even notice unless paying close attention. That's what 10+ years of billion-dollar investments into neural nets got us: better Gmail autocomplete and alt tags on facebook images.

Now we have a new toy to play with at last, and AI finally feels like it's delivering on the hype. But if we extrapolate from past AI experience it's going to mostly be a long series of cool tech demos that yields some optimizations to existing workflows and otherwise doesn't change much. Let's hope not!


Not only that.

There's plenty of us with Twitter taglines such as "changing the world one line of code at the time," but I've been around a while that if tech has changed the world, it's not always for the better. It's not always to make the masses more powerful. Not all of us are working on sending rovers to Mars or curing Parkinson's.

Like everything else, AI will be used to control us, to advertise to us, to reduce variance between each other. To pay us less. To make plutocrats more rich, and everybody else poorer.

But at least you now have a personal assistant, smart recommendation engines and AI generated porn to keep you busy.


> The fear is from people who can extrapolate.

This isn't really true. There isn't consensus among people who have the history and background, but the "it's going to change everything" and especially "we're all screwed" make for better copy so they are getting a lot of media play right now.


From people who can extrapolate and appreciate that thanks to exponential curves, they're likely underestimating egregiously anyway.




Join us for AI Startup School this June 16-17 in San Francisco!

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: