Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

You keep throwing examples of weapons of mass destruction, meant to evoke emotions.

For better or worse, nuclear weapons have been democratized. Some developing countries still don't have access, but the fact that multiple world powers have nuclear weapons is why we still haven't experienced WW3. We've enjoyed probably the longest period of peace and prosperity, and it's all due to nuclear weapons. Speaking of, Cold War era communists weren't “pursuing profits at all costs” either, which didn't stop them from conducting some of the largest democides in history.

The announcement from OpenAI should give you pause because it's being run by board members that are completely unfit to lead OpenAI. You rarely see this level of incompetence.

PS: I'm not against regulations, as I'm a European. But you're talking about concentrating power in the hands of a few big (US) companies, harming the population and the economy, while China is perfectly capable of developing their own AI, and having engaged successfully in industrial espionage. China is, for this topic, a bogeyman used for restricting the free market.




Nuclear weapons have absolutely not been democratised, and still stand as a technology that has largely been restricted and not proliferated. Only 9 countries in the 190 or so out there currently nuclear weapons, and 3 countries (South Africa, Ukraine, and Kazakhstan) decided that maintaining stockpiles was more trouble than it was worth.

Huge effort has been made to keep nuclear weapons out of the hands of non-state actors over the decades, especially after the fall of the USSR.


To be fair many countries dont want or need them or rely on other allied countries that do have them so they dont have to feild the expense. Other have them but dont officially admit to it. Some cant afford them. But a basic gun type nuclear bomb design like little boy is not technically difficult and could be made by a highschool ap physics class given access to the fissionable material.


That countries don’t want to handle the expense is one of the signs that they haven’t been commoditised.

The number I provided also includes both declared and undeclared nuclear powers.

It’s not just about the ability to make a bomb, it’s about being able to maintain a credible arsenal along with delivery platforms.


>You keep throwing examples of weapons of mass destruction, meant to evoke emotions.

I actually think global catastrophes evoke much less emotion than they should. "A single death is a tragedy; a million deaths is a statistic"

>For better or worse, nuclear weapons have been democratized.

Not to the point where you could order one on Amazon.

>The announcement from OpenAI should give you pause because it's being run by board members that are completely unfit to lead OpenAI. You rarely see this level of incompetence.

That depends on whether the board members are telling the truth about Sam. And on whether the objective of OpenAI is profit or responsible AI development.




Join us for AI Startup School this June 16-17 in San Francisco!

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: