Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

Do you not keep your books according to GAAP either?

If you make up your own accounting rules and it seems to work for you, well, more power to you.

I like to have a clear understanding of where my business is going and the GAAP rules are pretty reasonable and align with other companies and what they do.




We do. We also have professional accountants who manage all this for us.

It’s interesting that HN is more concerned about the rules changes than the person filing our company’s taxes (or our CFO). This is a topic that is basically glossed over as a non-event between us and those professionals.

(Unlike the wayfair ruling which sent everyone, including our accountants, up in arms about sales tax and how to decide nexus)

Maybe I have a bad accountant and CFO? Or HN is extrapolating this to mean more than it does.


> It’s interesting that HN is more concerned about the rules changes than the person filing our company’s taxes (or our CFO). This is a topic that is basically glossed over as a non-event between us and those professionals.

You are the one who originally asked why engineers can't be considered a cost center. There is a reason; the R&D tax credit.

> Maybe I have a bad accountant and CFO? Or HN is extrapolating this to mean more than it does.

I am guessing you just do not qualify for the R&D tax credit or it just not worth the paperwork at your scale. For larger companies (and profitable, fast-growing startups that do a lot of the 'develop' part of R&D, which are rare these days, I guess) there is a benefit.

https://taxfoundation.org/research/all/federal/research-and-...

Considering even the tax foundation claims would bring in less than 20k jobs, maybe Congress made the right decision to bring in amortization even if I disagree with what it funds. I do not have numbers for how much it brings it to the federal government but the credit was already known for being difficult for small businesses to use.




Consider applying for YC's Summer 2025 batch! Applications are open till May 13

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: