Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

But not like the UK and US social housing / projects. They need to be in master planned, well thought out and connected communities.



> But not like the UK

The UK's social housing scheme was/is a stonking success, right up until about 1980. it completely reset the minimum standard of housing from slums to actually decent. It wasn't all a success, skelmersdale and thamesmede sucked balls.

The problem with the uk's social housing came as follows:

1) the change from needing a job to have a council house to being a dumping ground for troubled families without support 2) removing the ability of councils to fund new housing 3) overly complex centralised funding of repairs and upkeep 4) selling off housing and then taking the money away that was needed to replace them

Thats very different to the "projects"


I don't know the UK situation in much depth but one of the things I read was how they were disconnected from the rest of the community (socially, services, transport, etc).


indeed, some of it was/is. However in london it was (mostly) slammed in on bombsites/ex industrial places: https://www.insidehousing.co.uk/news/council-releases-map-of...

southwark has the most council estates. the further out boroughs did try and put their estates far out. Places like thamesmede (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Thamesmead) failed because there was literally nothing else around (thats improved significantly, 50 years later)


I cannot upvote this enough. We ruined today through decades of car centric planning, we have to give the future something better.


This whole chain is a series of ideas that will never happen.


The issue might get forced if energy prices hit a threshold, debt bomb explodes, etc.


These are not the vibes I am looking for. If you don’t have hope, what are you even doing?


Apologies, I hope our next generation of leaders are master planners.


https://www.theguardian.com/us-news/2024/mar/13/biden-infras... ("Biden pledges billions to rebuild cities ‘torn apart’ by highways decades ago")


Mixed use. And also mixing all types of social, free-market rental and owner occupied. Quality for later two could be better, but it should still be next to each other using same services.




Join us for AI Startup School this June 16-17 in San Francisco!

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: