Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

  > winding parables and directed self-learning are incredibly impactful.
For those of us with a spouse for whom direct advice is useless, please go on.



Ha. I have a very conversational thought process. Often times, giving my wife direct advice would give her anxiety or make her feel like I was giving her directions, rather than direction. "Maybe you should..." would be heard as "I want you to..."

I've found that providing access to unopinionated information ("Here's a study related to that thing you are worried about"), bringing attention/space to the problem (without creating stress), or encouraging her to speak with friends who have had similar issues who I know will give her good advice will help her come to her own conclusions, at which point she will come to me and discuss her findings and the direction she wants to go in.


No offence to your wife, but I find it incredibly exhausting to speak to people like this.

I agree that unsolicited advice is not good. But one should make exceptions for advice from spouses, who's vowed to be by your side, and who has your general best interests at heart - no matter how direct the advice is.

This seems more like a "it's not what you say, it's how you say it" kind of scenario, which is pointless sugarcoating (especially when you have a problem to solve, so you should be willing to listen to advice or take direct instructions if you yourself don't know how to solve it).


If you want I can give you her contact info and you can spend your next 25 years trying to change her. I've capitulated.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: