I feel like LLMs are going to be a skill to have similar to the ability to google or type since it can get good answers pretty well but bad answers when you don't know the subject manner.
Agreed, and that's where teams like the OP come in
OpenAI does great at training for general tasks, and we should not be disappointed when specialized tasks fail. Interestingly, openai advertises increasingly many subjects they are special casing like math, code, & law, and so holding them to standards is fair there IMO.
For specialized contexts openai doesn't eval on, these merit hiring consultants / product to add the last-mile LLM data & tuning for the specific task. And at least in my experience, people paying money for AI experts & tech expect expert-level performance to be met, and ultimately, exceeded..