Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

I didn’t even mention the bible, which I have read btw. The assertion was that Christianity offers a “beautiful and empowering message” and I said that it’s also imaginary.

The message is imaginary because it’s based on an imaginary idea: god




That's just as dogmatic as saying there is a god. Both positions are unfalsifiable and similar.


That is not rational. You can’t just make up an idea and then claim it’s true because no one can prove it isn’t. If you want to claim something that is outside our ordinary perceptions (and tests!) of how reality works is true then the onus is on you to prove it.


I did not argue God exists because no one can prove he doesn't.

I claimed that your claim is just as unprovable as the claim that God does exist.


> I did not argue God exists because no one can prove he doesn't.

You are saying that by claiming that my claim is dogma. If I say the sky appears blue that isn't dogma, it's a statement of human perception of reality. I see it, you see it, everyone sees it. We know because it's what we perceive. We know how it works down to the quantum level. We can describe it with words and with math. We can test it.

Claiming there is a god is not that and the fact that it's unfalsifiable doesn't lend it a shred of legitimacy. It's an idea, nothing more.




Consider applying for YC's Summer 2025 batch! Applications are open till May 13

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: