Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

> but what about all the workers who have nothing to do with his politics?

This is a preposterous argument, I'm sorry. Should I feel sorry for people who enable Musk's antics? Why? They get paid very well to work for him I'm sure.

I disagree with Musk's antics and as such I'm not going to give him money. What's so difficult to understand about this?

I don't care that in 20 years time he'll be forgotten. We are here and now, and the best way to send him a message that what he is doing is not OK is by hurting his wallet.




You're sending a message to Elon about as much as sending a message to Mars Inc by not buying a Snickers bar.

Sending "real" messages is more than not buying things from companies or people you don't like and then virtue signaling about it online from the comfort of your armchair.

I think it's highfalutin.


So you are saying I should instead happily give him my money even though I deeply disagree with what he's doing? Let's take your argument ad absurdum: you'd happily give money to a mass murder as long as he was making a product you like?


I'm not saying you should do anything, but many people will buy Tesla because they don't see Tesla and Elon as the same thing.


Yes and many people don't. What is your point? Many people are upset with what Elon is doing, that's what is being discussed. Like it or not, Tesla and Elon are the same thing. It's his choice. He wants to be the public face of a company, he can't then selectively choose to shield said company from his antics when they backfire.

Nothing stopped Elon from divesting himself of his commercial holdings and announce that he wants to enter politics. Then I, and many others, would have no qualms about buying Tesla cars.

Obviously, doing so would've required a degree of personal integrity and humility, which he seems to be lacking.


How's does that 10% share price collapse, off the back of slumping European sales, fit into your world of messages?


Why do you care what other people do with their money?


There's a difference in caring about something and pointing something out as meaningless and contrived.


Is there? You clearly care enough to argue with strangers about it.




Consider applying for YC's Summer 2025 batch! Applications are open till May 13

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: