Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

What about gifts? Does it follow that gifts are a form of corruption, that exchanges need to be equivalent? Or how would you, for both practical law application as well as moral purposes, distinguish an inheritance, from a gift before death, from a gift in life, from providing shelter in youth and from giving a the gift of life through a part of oneself?



This isnt abstract, modulo reasonable thresholds Gifts are taxed as income by value in most countries. Inheritance (in the US) _is_ the weird wealth transfer exception.


Interesting.

Just checked and in argentina there is no federal tax gift, and in some provinces it's just much lower. We also have a wealth tax so that may address the gen wealth issue in another manner.

Tax is like that different in every country and hard to compare apples to apples.


Entirely fair point, and it always makes internet discussions more complicated without innumerable caveats.


A gift is one person giving something to another. An inheritance is ultimately someone else's kids giving your kid something.


I could only see this statement being accurate in a world where each generation of kids was synchronized into a discrete quanta. The continuous and arbitrary nature of birth and death in the real world makes this viewpoint somewhat incoherent to me.




Consider applying for YC's Summer 2025 batch! Applications are open till May 13

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: