Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

Is this still centralized? Or can you self-host without needing a separate client instance for each host?



https://github.com/revoltchat/self-hosted

As for clients I don't know.


8 GB RAM minimum for a non-graphical server software?! This thing must have more components and services than my desktop OS while having a few website open in Firefox and Chromium each


Synapse, after a reboot and the cache is cold, uses less than that. I don't think our synapse server even has 8GB allocated to it.

But that's for private chat, we can't join large rooms because I deployed our server as a test, alongside Mattermost and rocket.chat. I haven't felt compelled to switch to dendrite or whatever, nor split the synapse microservices out, nor install postgres on a dedicated VM, and so on. All of which would make someone else's matrix experience better but my life ^ that much worse.


9 services, 5 theirs, 4 other OSS


The compose file specified a service for the web app


edit- shit, it was rocket.chat, i'm so sorry.

Ignore the below, it is for a different "FOSS" discord replacement.

i did self-host it for a week to test it out - and honestly i was put off immediately.

What happens when you set it up according to the docs, is that it automatically "registers" for a license - the free license being limited to 5 users, even if you self host. Ridiculous, and just right out the gate shows me that whoever makes this does not have the user's best interest in mind.

the UI is also full of stuff that requires an expensive license, and i did not see an easy way to remove that stuff when self hosting.


License? Isn't revolt open-source, so you could have as many users as your server can handle? https://github.com/revoltchat/backend uses the AGPL, I assume whatever other things a revolt server requires have similar licenses.


sorry, i mixed it up with rocket.chat, another "foss" discord replacement.


Rocket wasn't that way when we used it, but it turned into a snap or flatpak or something, and as me, I won't maintain opaque software.

Matrix does everything we need, to where the group on matrix and the people I talk to on discord are a two separate circle Venn diagram.

Matrix also lets you inline files, do threads (y tho), voice chat, video chat. I don't know if it does conference calls or screen sharing as we don't use that.

I had to sign everyone up in my family. Because "change the server to 'matrix.whatever.com'" is impossible for nearly everyone.

Discord? Click a link you're in.

I don't like discord that much - I don't have it installed on my cellphone with a SIM.


I read the FAQ, searched google and the documentation and could not find a single ting about any license.


sorry, i mixed it up with rocket.chat, another "foss" discord replacement.


What are you talking about. Revolt is a donation funded FOSS project


A benevolent assumption would be that GP tries out a lot of stuff (according to their other comments) and therefore mixed something up, unwittingly spreading FUD about Revolt


sorry, i mixed it up with rocket.chat, another "foss" discord replacement.


maybe you're talking about mattermost?


sorry, i mixed it up with rocket.chat, another "foss" discord replacement.




Join us for AI Startup School this June 16-17 in San Francisco!

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: