Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

> TL;DR Linkbait/Apple is evil because they removed old software. The article and some of his comments show a very narrow mindset. Thinking on how evil is every corporation, just for being a corporation.

What is the value in giving a synopsis like this which is completely wrong? The author discusses his feelings a couple of times in the article, impugns Apple's motives not once, doesn't discuss corporatism, and uses the word "bad" precisely once to describe his experience here. He's not hyperbolic enough to use the word "evil," that was you.

Users who depend on both X11 and Apple's RSS support (all ten of them) are going to find this upgrade a bit of a pain. That's not reflective of a narrow mindset, it's reflective of an unusual use case.




The thing is, nobody is forcing them to upgrade. Except for the RSS thing that was a dubious way to handle it (maybe being more clear on ways to get out a OPML file).

Apple did inform, maybe in a way too opaque. But they did inform it.

On the topic of corporations. I may not interpret it as americans have the "corporations" rhetoric. But the feeling I have as a whole, from the author (Anthony and comments) was very paranoid.

Even calling the backend of OSX has "The Terminal" was very narrow on his scope to explain the problem of this trend and what we loose.

From where I see it, let XQuartz (partially supported/founded by Apple), Google (as seen on iOS6 Youtube.app removal), do it outside the OSX/iOS release schedule, even Apple did it for the iBooks apps and Podcast app.

Having old software stalling progress is just bad for all.




Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: