Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

> 80th anniversary of the USSR conquering half of Europe

Is this a correct description of the end of WWII?






Yes?

You could mention something about "Losing 80% of their population of fighting-age men and nearly losing their capital city to German aggression before turning the tide" and something about the race against the other Allies, but that is what happened.

Victory Day is basically the largest holiday in Russia.


Sadly, in many ways, that’s true.

They entered the Second World War as allies of Nazi Germany. When Germany inevitably turned on them, it was we—the collective West, with my own country playing a significant and costly role—who helped drag them out of the mess they’d enabled.

And yet, not long after, they turned on us. They occupied Eastern Europe, ruled it with an iron grip, and spent the next 80 years constructing a narrative in which they were the heroes—and that they’d done it all on their own.


I have to agree, it's technically true. And tbh even more than technically.

Still, it's as correct to speak about the end of WWII in that terms as it is to describe love as four letter word.


Saying they turned on us is misleading. They were never on our side, but Hitler was the bigger threat.

The US nuked Japan post surrender (go look it up - the documents were declassified a decade ago) as a bluff to convince the Russians that they could not win a war where they attempted to take all of Europe.


"Post surrender" is misleading. https://blog.nuclearsecrecy.com/2022/05/06/did-the-japanese-... has good coverage of what's known here. There were definitely factions within Japan that wanted to surrender, but there doesn't appear to have been a formal attempt.

As is, there was an attempted coup to overthrow the government due to the first (conditional) surrender.




Join us for AI Startup School this June 16-17 in San Francisco!

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: