Hacker News new | past | comments | ask | show | jobs | submit login

The nobility were involved in military campaigns. The wealthy always being completely insulated from danger in war is a modern thing. When we talk about our historical sources being limited, it's because they focused on things like battles and military strategy, precisely because it is interesting to the wealthy people who support historians.

The things we don't know about are irrelevancies (to wealthy people), like almost any normal aspect of a common persons normal life. Really the only way you can find out how normal people lived and spoke is through records of trials.

edit: I mean, when to start firing is not a decision that the archers are going to get to make on their own. It's not folk wisdom.






> edit: I mean, when to start firing is not a decision that the archers are going to get to make on their own.

Why not?


> The wealthy always being completely insulated from danger in war is a modern thing

even in modern wars it is far from true (if your country is getting overrun by enemy being rich is not enough to completely insulate you)


> The wealthy always being completely insulated from danger in war is a modern thing.

It’s not even true for all (or probably even most) of modern times. For instance the upper classes of Britain in WWI suffered much higher casualties than the lower classes.


I don't think WWI can be firmly called "modern times" with regards to warfare. It was a notable event in the transition to modern, but the cavalry charges against machine guns and such are reason enough to exclude it.

The modern period of history is widely considered to have begun in or around the 15th century. A common epochal event is the fall of Constantinople to the Ottoman Turks in 1453.

Any definition which lumps drones and airplanes together with swords and muskets is not useful, in my opinion. The last ~100 years are totally different from what came before.



Join us for AI Startup School this June 16-17 in San Francisco!

Guidelines | FAQ | Lists | API | Security | Legal | Apply to YC | Contact

Search: