previous next


The Electoral College of Virginia.

--A meeting of the Electors of the State of Virginia was held in the Senate Chamber of the Capitol, on Wednesday, the 5th December, pursuant to the proclamation of the Governor. Present--Messrs. Francis T. Anderson, A. B. Caldwell, Thos.. Bruce, John J. Jackson, B. H. Shackleford, Lemuel J. Bowden, L. H. Chandler, Marmaduke Johnson and Joseph Christian.

At half-past 10 o'clock the College was called to order by Mr. John J. Jackson, on whose motion Francis T. Anderson, Esq., was elected Chairman.

Mr. Anderson accepted the position tendered him, and after returning thanks for the honor thus conferred, announced his readiness to proceed to business.

Mr. Jackson then nominated for Secretary, Col. J. L. Eubank, and the question being put, Col. E. was elected.

Mr. Jackson presented from the Secretary of the Commonwealth certain communications, which were handed to the Chairman, to be disposed of.

The Chairman announced the receipt of a letter from John R. Edmonds and others, which the Secretary read to the College as follows:


"Richmond, Dec. 5, 1860.
"Gentlemen:
"To the Electors now sitting in the Electoral College of Virginia:

"Gentlemen: The undersigned have received from the Governor of Virginia certificates that they have been elected Electors of President and Vice-President of the United States. We feel constrained, however, to say, that although by technical law we may be entitled to those certificates, and to cast our votes as Electors, we are satisfied that we were not elected in fact, and therefore we respectfully decline to take our seats in the Electoral College.

"Very respectfully, your ob't serv'ts,
"John R. Edmonds, "James Lyons, "R. A. Claybrook, "Wm. H. Anthony, "J. W. Massie."
The Secretary next read the following letter from Mr. Wm. Lamb, of Norfolk:

"Norfolk, Dec. 3, 1860.
"Gov. Letcher--Dear Sir:
Your letter, informing me of my election as one of the Electors for the State of Virginia, was received Saturday. My physician, who has been attending me during a severe illness, positively forbids my visiting Richmond tomorrow; indeed, he has not yet allowed me to leave the house.

"I regret, exceedingly, that I will not be able to attend the session of the College, to vote, in accordance with the wishes of those who elected me, for John C. Breckinridge, of Kentucky, for President, and Joseph Lane, of Oregon, for Vice-President. Please communicate the facts to the Electoral College.

Your friend,
"William Lamb."

A communication was read from the Secretary of the Commonwealth, announcing the election of the following persons as Electors: Thomas Bruce of Halifax, Marmaduke Johnson of Richmond city, Lemuel J. Bowden of Williamsburg, J. J. Jackson, Jr., of Wood, F. T. Anderson of Rockbridge, B. H. Shackleford of Fauquier, A. B. Caldwell of Ohio, L. H. Chandler of Norfolk city, Joseph Christian of Middlesex, William Lamb of Norfolk city, John R. Edmonds of Halifax, James Lyons of Richmond city, Richard Claybrook, of Northumberland, W. H. Anthony of Botetourt, J. W. Massie of Rockbridge.

On motion, the roll of Electors was called, and six of them being absent, a suggestion was made to fill the vacancies at once.

Mr. Marmaduke Johnson suggested that the better plan would be to have some private conference before proceeding further, and, on his motion, the College took a recess until half-past 1 o'clock P. M.


Afternoon session.

The College met pursuant to adjournment, F. T. Anderson, Esq., resuming the chair.

After the roll was called, and a quorum ascertained to be present, the Chairman announced as the first business in order the "filling of vacancies."

By motions severally made and seconded, Col. John E. Scruggs, of Fauquier, was nominated to fill the vacancy caused by the absence of Mr. Wm. Lamb, of Norfolk; Wyndham Robinson, Esq., of Richmond city, was nominated to fill the vacancy caused by the resignation of James Lyons, Esq; Mr. John D. Alexander, of Campbell county, was nominated to fill the place of Mr. R. A. Clay brook, of Northumberland; Waller R. Staples, Esq., was nominated to fill the place of Mr. W. H. Anthony, of Botetourt; Travis H. Epps, Esq., was nominated to fill the place of Mr. J. W. Massie; and James. F. Johnson, Esq., of Bedford, was nominated to fill the place of John R. Edmonds, Esq.

The vote was taken separately on the several nominations as made, and each of the nominees were unanimously elected.

The College being now full, as required by law, the Chairman requested gentlemen to prepare their ballots, to vote for President.

Mr. Johnson suggested that each Elector, as he deposited his ballot in the box, should declare the name of the person for whom he voted.

After the ballots were deposited, Messrs. Robertson and Johnson were appointed a committee to examine and count them. They performed the duty, and reported that the entire vote (fifteen) had been cast for John Bell of Tennessee, for President of the United States.

Ballots were next prepared for Vice President, and Messrs. Bruce and Christian, a committee appointed by the Chair, reported that the fifteen votes had been unanimously cast for Edward Everett, of Massachusetts, for Vice President.

The Chairman stated that he was happy to announce that the Electoral vote of Virginia had been unanimously cast for John Bell of Tennessee, as President, and Edward Everett as Vice President. Would to God, for the sake of our beloved country — for its future peace and prosperity — that vote could be effective.

The Secretary stated that the old book, which contained the proceedings of the Electoral Colleges of Virginia from the time of Jefferson's election to the present, had been mislaid in the State Library, but that the Secretary of the Commonwealth had promised to make a search for it. If it could not be found, he desired to know if a new book would be necessary in which to record the proceedings?

Mr. Jackson hoped a new book would be purchased. The old one had fallen into the hands of the Philistines and might not be recovered He wanted a clean sheet for the proceedings of this College.

Mr. Johnson preferred the old one. He was for Union, and did not like to see a severance commenced here. He wished the proceedings to be recorded with those of better days, so that the history might be continuous.

Mr. Jackson was for Union. No man admired the history of the Republicans of old more than himself. He had taken Madison as his guide, and wanted none better. If the old book could be found, he did not object to the continuance of the history, though he was no admirer of Pierce and Buchanan.

The Secretary was thereupon ordered to get a new book in which to record the proceedings, and to transcribe them in the old one, if that should be found.

Mr. B. H. Schackleford, of Fauquier, offered the following resolution, which was unanimously adopted:

‘ Resolved, That this Electoral College take pleasure in expressing their high appreciation of the conduct of the Breckinridge Electors, who, by informalities, were proclaimed by the Governor of Virginia as elected to this College, in resigning their positions as such Electors, and thus giving full effect to the popular vote of Virginia.

Mr. Johnson, of Bedford, nominated Jos. Christian, of Middlesex, as Messenger to deliver the vote of the College to the President of the United States Senate, and he was unanimously elected.

On motion, the College took a recess until half-past 5 o'clock, to give the Secretary time to prepare the necessary certificates, which the Electors were required by law to sign before adjourning.


Evening session.

The College reassembled at 6 o'clock, and proceeded to business, F. T. Anderson, Esq., resuming the chair.

On motion of Mr. Jackson, the three certificates, prepared by the Secretary, were read and compared, and then signed, in order, by the Electors.

Col. John E. Scruggs offered a resolution, which was adopted, allowing Col. John L Eubank $100 for services as Secretary of the Electoral College.

Mr. James F. Johnson, of Bedford, presented the following paper, which, on motion, was spread upon the records of the College:

The undersigned Electors of President and Vice President of the United States for the State of Virginia, relieved by the failure of six of the gentlemen (certified to have been elected by the Governor, on the official opinions of the Attorney General.) to attend the present meeting of the Electoral College, and by our consequent elections by our brother Electors as members of the College, from considering whether there was any mode or means of asserting, upon grounds denying the legality and validity of that certificate, our claim to sit in the Electoral College, or what measures we might or should adopt in reference thereto: yet unwilling in justice to ourselves and to that portion of the people of Virginia by whose legal votes we believe ourselves to have been elected, instead of some of those receiving such certificates, to seem by silence to accept the decision of the law officer of the State as correct, desire to declare, and do declare:

That we believe ourselves to have been duly chosen by the legal voters of the State of Virginia, as Electors of President and Vice President of the United States, and we respectfully ask that this, our protest and declarations, be spread upon the records of this body. James F. Johnson,

Waller R. Staples,

Travis H. Epes.

The certificates having been prepared, the members signed their names in order, as called upon by the Secretary.

The College then adjourned to meet again this morning at 10 o'clock.

Creative Commons License
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-ShareAlike 3.0 United States License.

An XML version of this text is available for download, with the additional restriction that you offer Perseus any modifications you make. Perseus provides credit for all accepted changes, storing new additions in a versioning system.

hide Dates (automatically extracted)
Sort dates alphabetically, as they appear on the page, by frequency
Click on a date to search for it in this document.
December 5th, 1860 AD (1)
December 3rd, 1860 AD (1)
May, 12 AD (1)
hide Display Preferences
Greek Display:
Arabic Display:
View by Default:
Browse Bar: