CHAPTER-II Grand Theory
CHAPTER-II Grand Theory
Setiyadi states that language teaching is influenced by ideas on the nature of language
(language theories). Differences in language theories may affect the selection of the
teaching materials and differences in learning theories may affect the teaching
methods. A method that is used on the assumption that we learns his native language
(LI) will differ from one based on the assumption that learning a foreign is not the
same as learning mother tongue. It may be argued that the actual teaching of English
in Indonesia may differ from the English teaching in Malaysia or teaching English in
United State of America, where people should learn English in the condition where
10
11
Talking about English as a foreign language in our country, the government has
decided that English should be thought the students from elementary school up to
university level.16 It is expected that the students are able to have the ability or
knowledge of English, which can be used for communication. The general aim for
language teaching is to equip to students with the knowledge and skill required for
international language has an influence on the human life, in whole world. Though
this language, we can communicate and interact with people from different countries,
and can follow different technology development. Based on the statement above the
researcher assumes that the teaching English as a foreign language meaning that the
teacher should create a way to teach English in order the students can face the
globalization era and communicate with people from different countries confidently.
communicative syllable that teacher should play role as facilitator, motivator, and
16 Ibid, p.9
12
B. Concept of Speaking
Speaking is one important part in learning. Sanggam states that: the spoken
information to a listener or a group listener. 17 Speaking is one of the four basic skills
in learning foreign language besides listening, reading, and writing. It has been taught
since the students enter a junior high school however it is not easy for students to
communicate in English. They have to think more often when speaking English.
Pollard states that speaking is one of the most difficult aspects for students to
master.18 This is hardly surprising when one considers everything that is involved
when speaking: ideas, what to say, language, how to use grammar and vocabulary,
communicating with any learner of a foreign language can confirm how difficult
speaking is. It means that learning to speak a foreign language in this case English is
difficult.
take it granted. Natural and integral is speaking that we forget how we once struggled
to achieve this ability until, this is we have to learn how to do it all over again in a
17 Sanggam Siahaan. The English Paragraph, (Yogyakarta: Graha Ilmu, 2008) p.2.
18 Lucy Pollard, Op.Cit, p.33
19 Scott Thornbury. How to Teach Speaking, (England: Longman Pearson Education Limited,
2005), p.1.
13
their general purpose, the kind of participant they involve and the degree of
way to express ideas and opinions directly what we have in our minds.
Based on the previous definitions above, it can be synthesized that speaking is the
process of using the urge of speech to pronounce vocal symbols in order to share the
information, knowledge, idea, and opinion to the other person. Moreover, speaking
cannot be dissociated from listening aspect, because speaking involves speaker and
listener.
Speaking is a way to share the information and knowledge, also to express ideas and
opinions directly what we have in our minds person to the other person. Meanwhile,
tasks in a job.21 Also, Siagian stated in Suratno, ability is a blend of theory and
practical experience gained in the field.22 From the definition above, we can conclude
that speaking ability is the capacity of someone to share and express the information,
20 Ibid, p.14
21 Suratno, Konsep Kemampuan Sumber Daya Manusia, available
sulut.kemenag.go.id/file/file/kepegawaian/aunw1341283316.pdf retrieved on May, 12th 2015 23:55
pm. P.1
22 Ibid, p.1
14
Rychen states that the ability to communicate effectively is a competency that may
towards those with whom he or she is communicating.23 Moreover, Richard states that
the ability to speak a second or foreign language well is very complex task if we try
to understand the nature of what appears to be involved. 24 From the statements above,
Moreover, learning speaking has a purpose that is to make the students can speak
important part of the curriculum in language teaching, and this makes them an
important object of assessment as well. 25 It means that speaking skill is a difficult one
Students should learn to speak the second language by interacting to others. For this
case, students should master several speaking components, such as: comprehension,
23 D.C. Rychen, The Definition and Selection of Key Competencies Executive Summary, (Key
DeSeCo publications), p.4, available http://www.oecd.org/pisa/35070367.pdf retrieved on May, 11th
2015.
24 Jack C. Richard and Willy A. Renandya. Methodology in Language Teaching: An
Anthopology of Current Practice. (New York: Cambridge University Press, 2002), p. 201
25 Sari Luoma, Assesing Speaking, Cambridge University Press, New York, 2004, p.1
26 H. Douglas Brown, Language Assessment: Principle and Classroom Practice,
(California: Longman, 2003), p.157
15
improve the students speaking skill, give attention to the speaking components’, and
formal or informal. Besides, it is also important to know that the language, in this
case English can be standard or non standard so that they are able to communicate
to express their ideas, opinions, feelings, and experiences, using English with good
In order to assess students’ speaking ability, Brown clarified five indicators of scoring
1. Grammar
by his/her interlocutor.
2. Vocabulary
The speaker needs to use an appropriate vocabulary in order that the speaking is
3. Comprehension
16
4. Fluency
5. Pronunciation
This category is related to accent whether the speaker speaks like native or not.27
In this research, researcher assesses students’ speaking ability by using the scoring
rubric which is clarified by Hughes. They are accent, fluency, vocabulary, accuracy
and comprehension.
Table 2.1
The Category Level of Speaking Ability
NOTE:
a) Accent
6 = Native pronunciation, with no trace of “foreign accent”
5 = No conspicuous mispronunciations, but would not be taken for a native
speaker
b) Grammar
6 = No more than two errors during the interview
5 = Few errors, with no patterns of failure
4 = Occasional errors showing imperfect control of some patterns but no
weakness that causes misunderstanding
3 = Frequent errors showing some major patterns uncontrolled and causing
occasional irritation and misunderstanding
2 = Constant errors showing control of very few major patterns and frequently
preventing communication
1 = Grammar almost entirely inaccurate except in stock phrases
c) Vocabulary
6 = Vocabulary apparently as accurate and extensive as that of an educated
native speaker
5 = Professional vocabulary broad and precise, general vocabulary adequate to
cope with complex practical problems and varied social situations
4 = Professional vocabulary adequate to discuss special interest, general
vocabulary permits discussion of any non-technical subject with some
circumlocutions
3 = Choice of words sometimes inaccurate, limitations of vocabulary prevent
discussion of some common professional and social topics
2 = Vocabulary limited to basic personal and survival areas (time, food,
transportation, family, etc)
1 = Vocabulary in adequate for even the simplest conversation
d) Fluency
6 = Speech on all professional and general topics as effortless and smooth as a
native speaker
5 = Speech is effortless and smooth, but perceptively non-native in speed and
evenness
4 = Speech is occasionally hesitant, with some unevenness caused by rephrasing
and groping for words
18
e) Comprehension
6 = Understands everything in both formal and colloquial speech to be expected
of an educated native speaker
5 = Understands everything in normal educated conversation except for very
colloquial or low-frequency items, or exceptionally rapid or slurred speech
4 = Understands quite well normal educated speech when engaged in a dialogue,
but requires occasional repetition or rephrasing
3 = Understands careful, somewhat simplified speech when engaged in a
dialogue, but may require considerable repetition and rephrasing
2 = Understands only slow, very simple speech on common social and touristic
topics; requires constants repetition and rephrasing
1 = Understands to little for the simplest type of conversation.28
Because English in Indonesia is as a foreign language, the score levels given to the
Table 2.2
The Classification of Speaking Ability
28 Arthur Hughes, Testing for Language Teachers, (Cambridge: Cambridge University Press,
2003), p.111-113
29 Suharsimi Arikunto, Dasar-dasar Evaluasi Pendidikan: Edisi Revisi, (Jakarta: Bumi Aksara,
2009), p. 245
19
to be learned. It has relation with the technique used in the classroom. Harmer states
that there are three main reasons for getting students to speak in the classroom, those
are:
3. Finally, the more students have opportunities to activate the various elements of
language they have stored in their brains, the more automatic their use of these
elements become. As result, students gradually become autonomous language
users. This means that they will be able to use words and phrases fluently
without very much conscious thought.30
Good speaking activities can catch by using an interesting technique and teaching
skill from teacher. Thornbury suggests that the teaching of speaking depends on there
being a classroom culture of speaking, and that classroom need to become ‘talking
classroom’.31 From the Thornbury states above, students will be much more confident
speakers and their speaking ability will improve if the teacher and students establish
Teaching speaking activities in the classroom are accordingly divide into three main
30 Jeremy Harmer, How to Teach English (Longman: Pearson Education Limited, 2007), p.123.
31 Ibid, p.123
20
activities.32 Pre-speaking which are planning and organizing, begins before students
outside of the classroom have an impact upon what students will say and how they
will say it. Pre-speaking activities involve thought and reflection, and provide
While-speaking are called going public. It means that students who have been
informal and formal speaking experiences are more likely to have the confidence
needed to “go public” with student ideas and information. In order to communicate
and interact with others, students need to engage in a variety of formal and informal
reflect upon their performance because students who have opportunities to reflect
students reflect upon their performance, they begin to recognize what they have done
According into three main categories of speaking activities above, we can conclude
32 Saskatchewan Education, The Speaking Process available on https://www.edonline.sk.ca/
bbcswebdav/library/Curriculum%20Website/English%20Language
%20Arts/Resources/Core/speaking.pdf accessed by 00:35 am on April 19th, 2015. p.1
21
that to reach the goal of speaking ability, we should know the steps of speaking
activities. In the pre-activities, teacher are planning and organizing the material or the
topic that will be taught to the students. For while-speaking, the students are given the
opportunities to speak their ideas based on the topic. The students interact with others
depend on the speaking situations that conducted by the teacher. Furthermore, in the
post-activities, the teacher gives the students a reflection. It used to know whether the
One of the parts in teaching speaking is giving task to the students to find out the
ability of them. Brown argued that there were five types of similar categories apply to
the kinds of oral production that students were expected to carry out in the classroom.
All of the categories of speaking performance will help teacher to give task to the
students. It can measure the ability of students in speaking skill. The teacher can
choose the design speaking performance based on the lesson being learned at the
time.
Teaching speaking is much more complex than teaching any other language skill or
components because it involves a command of certain skill and several different types
From the explanation above, the researcher assumes that in teaching speaking, teacher
should stimulate the students in teaching and learning process. The teacher can use
technique to interest the students. Therefore, they can speak their ideas experience or
feeling without being ashamed or afraid of communicating with other. Harmer states
that speaking activity divided into three types, there are decision-making (choosing
F. Concept of Game
There are many good ideas about English teaching. One of them is using games in
the English class as a technique which is most easily accepted by students and
exciting. The use of games in a learning environment will not only change the
dynamic of the class, but also rejuvenate students and help the brain to learn more
effectively. And she also says that game allow the students to work cooperatively,
compete with each other, strategize, think in different way, compare and share
knowledge, learn from other, learn from mistakes, work in a less stressful and more
Based on Wright, Betteridge and Buckby that games help and encourage many
learners to sustain their interest and work. Games also help the teacher to create
contexts in which the language is useful and meaningful. The learners want to take
part and in order to do so must understand what others are saying or have written, and
they must speak or write in order to express their own point of view or give
information.36
Hadfield also said that a game is an activity with rules, a goal and element of fun.
There are two kinds of game: comparative game, in which player of teams race to be
the first to reach the goal, and co-operative games, in which player of teams work
together towards a common goal.37 It means that the teacher can make the different
kinds of game activity in the classroom. The teacher can use the game which make
the player of teams compete to be the first to reach the goal, or the teacher use the
game which make the player of teams work together to reach the goal.
Game can be used at many levels, from beginner until advanced based on the player’s
age, cleverness and background. Everybody likes game because it is challenging and
usually there is a reward besides it. Such as score or point, it make a situation on the
game lively and the player does not feel bored and try to be the best on the game or
35 Redjeki Agoestyowati, 102 English Games (Jakarta: PT. Gramedia Pustaka Utama, 2009),
p.xiii
36 Andrew Wright David Betteridge and Michael Buckby, Game for Language Learning
(Britain: Cambridge University Press, 1994), p.1
37 Jill Hadfield, Intermediate Communication Game, (England: Longman Ltd, 1996), p.v
24
on their team.
Caillois defines a game as an activity that must have the following characteristics:
E. Governed by rules : the activity has rules that are different from everyday life.38
difficult to persuade the students to say anything in foreign language. Game motivate
them to speak, to work co-operatively, compete with each other, strategize, think in
different way, compare and share knowledge, learn from other, learn from mistakes,
work in a less stressful and more productive environment and allow students to have
From all of the statements above, we can conclude that game is activity with rules, a
goal and element of fun. Game is structural activity that can be used in teaching
learning activity and in the game it is not only to get fun but there is a goal and
structure.
38 Roger Caillois, The Definition of Play and the Classification of Games, (London: The MIT
Press, 2006), p.128.
25
According to Holmes, pass the ball game is a game the students pass the ball when
they asked a question to the other. 39 Also, according to Copland in Teaching English
Young Learners Activity Book, throwing a ball game has similarity with pass the ball
game.40 Moreover, in throwing a ball game, students passed the ball when they
introduce their selves or ask the questions. From Holmes and Copland statement
above, the students should be answering the question from the other when they
According to Rohlf, Pass The Ball game is played in small groups. One student asks a
question and tosses a paper ball to someone in the group, who tries to answer it. Then,
in turn this person asks a question, and so on. No repetition of questions is permitted.
When the teacher calls time, students recapitulate what they remember. 41 Based on
Rohlf’s statement, this activity fosters paying attention and especially good for
kinesthetic learners. Also, this game invites the audiences or the students to think and
speak fastest.
Pass The Ball Game has similarity with Toss a-name game by Adam Fletcher and
Kari Kunst.42 Fletcher and Kunst are using ball and timer to make the students speak
fast. Because in the real activities, when the students faced with foreign people and
39 Ibid, p.14
40 Fiona Copland, Teaching English Young Learners Activity Book (London: British Council,
2012), p.84
41 Judith Rohlf, Let’s Begin Talking (Canada: Speaq, 2011), p.50.
42 Adam Fletcher and Kari Kunst, Guide to Cooperative Games for Social Change (Common
Action, 2006), p.7-8
26
made the conversation, they have to think fast in order to give a question or answer
From all of the statements above, the researcher concludes that Pass The Ball game is
a game activity that using a ball as media when the students give the questions to the
others. The students who got the ball should answer the question. Moreover, the
students have to think and speak quickly when they pass or get the ball. Also, Pass
The Ball game can be played in a small group or one team compete with the other
teams.
Holmes states in his variation of game, there are some procedures of using pass the
person can bounce the ball off the floor across to another students.
b. The first student holds the ball and asks a question like “How old is your
boyfriend?” As the first girl is asking the question, she bounces the ball on the
floor over to a friend who in turn must answer the question before touching
c. If the friend hesitates for too long, or is too slow and hasn’t finished
answering before she touches/catches the ball, then she is disqualified and
Also, according to Copland, there are some procedures of pass the ball game as
follows:
b. The teacher starts the game by saying, ‘Hello, I’m Maryam’ and throws the
ball to a child. The child who catches the ball introduces him/herself in the
c. If a child can’t continue to speak, the child is ‘out’ and the game continues
From explanation above, it seems that in pass the ball game the students are trying to
solve their speaking problem. Pass the ball game as a technique in teaching and
learning process, especially in teaching and learning speaking, it will improve their
confident to speak to the other and think fast to produce many words that used in
In this research the researcher uses pass the ball game in teaching and learning
1) The teacher tells the students to make a group which consist 4-5 students.
2) The teacher tells the students to seat at seating order according to different
team. It means when one student from group 1 sit beside one student from
group 2, and beside student from group 2 is student from group 3, etc.
3) The teacher gives the students a topic, and told them to make a question.
5) Students who be the beginner can decide the time between 20 second until 1
minutes. Time was used by teacher to limit the students when they speak in
the game.
6) The first student who holding the ball can give a question to anyone that
7) When the student gives his/her friend a question, don’t forget to pass the
8) During the time, anyone can ask anything related with the topic from
teacher. When the time is up, the student who holding the ball or is
eliminated. Also, when the students can’t answer the question, they must be
9) The teams which still have their member and to be the last person who has
eliminated all of the other member team, his/her team will be the winner.
10) The teacher can give a reward to the winner team and give the loser teams a
penalty.
The advantages of using pass the ball game are students express their ideas and
feeling as free as they can, the students more comfortable and confidence in teaching
English in the classroom, the number of questions asked by students increase, provide
motivation to boost the students to develop their language learning, students get the
researcher assumes this game can solve students’ problem in speaking. By using pass
the ball game, the students should to think fast to make a question related with the
topic from the teacher and speak it out. It can be played for the whole class. The
teachers also can divide their students and uses pass the ball game in two sections.
Besides, when we can find many kinds of the strength this game, also this game have
some weakness, they are: students getting overexcited, students who can’t answer the
questions getting frustrated or holding the game up, students doing nothing while
waiting (maybe a long time) for the ball, students often asked the same questions, the
situation is crowded, the teacher should to handle and control the class when this
45 Journal of Wulandari, Teaching Speaking Using ‘’Pass The Ball Game’’ Technique at
Fourth Grade Students of SDN Mekarasih Kabupaten Bandung (STKIP Siliwangi Bandung, 2012), p.2
30
game is running, sometimes the students not ready yet when they get the
punishment.46
K. Relevance Study
The studies that have relevant with this study are: first this study which has relevance
with this research was conducted by Mairiza Devina (2014) on her thesis The Effect
Of Using Describe And Identify Game Toward Speaking Ability Of The Second Grade
The problem of her study, those were: Is there any significant effect of using describe
and identify game toward students’ speaking ability of the second grade students at
SMPN 6 Pekanbaru. The research used in her study was experimental class. The
researcher use quasi experimental design: pre-test, treatment, post-test. The similarity
of this research is the researcher using cluster random sampling to choose control
Second is Sriningsih (2014) on her thesis The Effect of Using Twenty Questions
Game Technique toward Speaking Ability of The Second Grade Students at SMPS Sei
The problem of her study, those were: Is there any significant effect of using Twenty
Questions Game Technique toward speaking ability of the second grade students at
The research used in her study was experimental research. The research design of this
research was One- Group Pretest – Posttest Design. Furthermore, the similarity of this
research is the researcher same discuss about using game towards speaking ability.
L. Frame of Thinking
Speaking is a way to share the information and knowledge, also to express ideas and
opinions directly what we have in our minds person to the other person. In teaching
speaking, and that classroom need to become ‘talking classroom’. However, the
researcher found that most of students in grade tenth at SMAN 12 Bandar Lampung
still have difficulties in speaking. It caused by some factors. Those are; first, most of
the students are too shy and afraid to take a part in the conversation. In the other
words, the students are having problem with their confidence. Second, the students
are still clumsy in speaking, they just speak when the teacher ask them. Third, the
students are not enthusiastic and not brave enough to involve in the speaking learning
English
(Pekanbaru: UIN Suska Riau, 2014)
32
Based on the frame of theories, the researcher assumes that students’ speaking ability
is still low. To solve this problem, in learning speaking, the teachers need to
implement a technique that can help the students to reach the English material easily.
Besides, the teacher also needs to use media in teaching and learning activity more
attractive and more interesting both for students and for the teacher themselves.
When the teacher uses pass the ball game, students can learn and practice their
speaking ability. Also, the students will learn English exciting, because pass the ball
game is interesting and motivate the students to speak English well. The students also
increase their knowledge to think fast and produce many words that used in
conversation in enjoyable atmosphere. Teacher should control the class and help the
students when they found the difficulties of learning English using this technique in
the class.
SPEAKING
Moreover, the researcher assumes that using pass the ball game, the students are not
only increase their speaking skill but also gaining their confident in spoken English.
Also, pass the ball game gives the students motivation to learn English more. They
get the opportunities to increase their confident to speak English and think fast to
produce many words that used in conversation. In this case, when this technique
success, it means students can speak English confidently with some components as
M. Hypothesis
Based on the theoretical assumption above, the researcher formulates the hypotheses
as follows:
Ho : There is no influence of using pass the ball game towards students’ speaking
ability.
Ha : There is an influence of using pass the ball game towards students’ speaking
ability.